#hypothetical amy spinoff

[rubywolf0201]

White Lily is pretty much Amy’s evil counterpart.

Instead of wanting to spread love, Lily spreads chaos and discourse to the businesses she took over and won’t hesitate to drop them like flies if they serve no interest to her any longer.

Amy has a temperamental side to her but has enough emotional maturity to recognize her mistakes and would put her personal feelings aside to ensure her friends are happy, Lily is a spoiled bratty womanchild who is utterly incapable of putting her feelings aside and would throw temper tantrums when things aren’t going her way. Made worse is that Lily is actually 19 years old compared to Amy’s 12! 💀

Amy is a go-getter and determined girl who doesn’t know when to give up on her goals once she sets her mind to it, Lily is of the same but hers is much more twisted in nature in that it’s related to capitalism and plagiarism.

Amy feels compassion and empathy for others, Lily is lacks those things and would dismiss those feelings as ‘weak’ in her own eyes.

Amy gets jealous of other girls whenever they’re close to Sonic but she would ultimately befriend them once the misunderstanding is cleared up or because they need help (Elise being a big example), Lily couldn’t even put aside her jealously for one second when it comes to her business rivals so she would do anything within her power to get rid of them, whether it’s by spreading false rumors via PR or humiliating them.

Amy uses a hammer, Lily uses a sword whip.

Amy’s main outfit is a red dress and boots, Lily’s is a dark red business suit and wears stilettos.

Amy is a cheerful and kindhearted girl who sees the good in everyone and is positive from the get go, Lily is a rude, selfish, pessimistic and egotistical young woman who has a negative outlook and is overall never satisfied with what she has despite the amount of dirty money she makes.

Amy has friends in Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, Big, Cream and Elise. Lily only has a secretary named Camelia who she treats like complete utter shit and not to mention pretty bossy to her. Lily also views her business partners and underlings working for her as pests and wouldn’t hesitate to fire and blacklist them should they annoy her.

Amy is unambiguously a good girl, Lily may look kind on the surface but she hides her nasty attitude from her competitors and won’t hesitate to backstab them at any chance.

[rubywolf0201]

Oh that’s a really neat idea! I love this!

I hope you don’t mind my idea of my Amy-centric spinoff but one of my ideas of it is that Amy would venture out to Soleanna to see a fashion show and from there she would reconnect with Princess Elise. But just as they’re about to watch the show, an antagonist who is named White Lily (an evil counterpart of Amy) would come and terrorize not just the fashion show but also the brand as well.

Amy, Elise and another human companion would have to work together to save the fashion show and brand from the hands of White Lily. (Basically a take that to capitalism lol)

Alright, this may be wishful thinking but…

Someday. Someday, I hope Amy Rose will either have her own game, or be the second protagonist alongside Sonic. Both would definitely be a service to her.

I would dare say, that this should’ve existed a long time ago at this point. Amy has been here for a very long time. SEGA, she deserved better.

[sonicboomseason3]

Amy + Shadow + Eggman.

🧭💅🌕

(idk, i'm just trying to make it as random as i can)

ask game: send me AT LEAST 3 emojis (the more random the better) and AT LEAST 2 characters from sonic boom and i’ll come up with a little drabble in response!

"It's a beautiful night tonight," Amy remarks as she briefly looks up and out her window. "There's even a full moon out. Should we go out stargazing after this?"

"What? You promised we'd play Fuzzy Puppies!" Eggman's voice comes out in a borderline whine. "I didn't cancel my plans to attack the village tonight just to look at some stupid stars, you know."

"They're not stupid," Amy protests. "And we can do both! We can just set the game up outside."

"Okay, fair. As long as the wind doesn't blow the pieces away, I'm game."

Amy nods and resumes what she was doing before: painting Eggman's nails red and yellow, alternating colors between each finger. The two of them scheduled this hangout a few days ago to celebrate the release of the new Fuzzy Puppies figurine, Chunky Chihuahua. Despite how highly coveted it was and still is, Amy somehow got her hands on it on the first day through means that Eggman is desperate to uncover when they play later. That's really the only reason he agreed to be here tonight. That, along with his belief in the importance of nail care.

He wasn't really aware that Shadow would also be here until he ran into him in front of Amy's door earlier, though he certainly isn't complaining about the additional company.

He turns his head to acknowledge the third person in the room. "What about you, Shadow? Do you wanna be Fuzzy Puppy buddies with us?"

Shadow is lying on his back on Amy's other couch, his hands folded across his chest in relaxation. Between his facial mask and the two slices of cucumbers on top of his eyes, his expression is even more difficult to read than usual. Thankfully, for what his countenance lacks in clarity, his words more than make up for it. "I'd rather be mauled by real dogs."

"Oh come on, it's real fun. Don't let the name fool you, it's a legitimate game that centers around strategy, cunning, and aggression—"

"I know what the game entails, you buffoon. Dave keeps talking about it and trying to get me to join him. My answer to you is the same one as the one I always give him. Unless they start selling a spinoff featuring cats and not dogs, I have zero interest." He peels a cucumber slice off of one of his eyes so he can shoot Eggman a warning look. "Now stop with this absurd offer of yours before I forcibly oust you from this house."

His glare may have been a bit more effective if he didn't look the way he currently does, but Eggman nevertheless figures that it may be best if he doesn't ruin one of the few times he isn't actively on Shadow's bad side. "Alright, yeesh. If this hypothetical cat spinoff ever comes out, don't expect me to play with you when you show up at my door."

Shadow scoffs but says nothing, instead opting to toss the cucumber slice in his mouth rather than putting it back on his eye. Once he swallows it, he grabs a chocolate chip cookie from the platter on the coffee table. He and Amy scheduled this hangout a few days ago to eat some of the treats she baked. Despite his aversion to the idea of friendship, Shadow ultimately decided that indulging his sweet tooth would be worth the various sacrifices he would have to make to his established character. That's really the only reason he agreed to be here tonight. That, along with his belief in the importance of exfoliation.

He wasn't really aware that Eggman would also be here until he ran into him in front of Amy's door earlier, and he certainly is complaining about the additional company. In his head.

"You know, speaking of the full moon being out, I have this recurring dream where I destroy half of it with a giant laser," Eggman supplies as a change in topic. "Not sure why."

Amy stops in the middle of putting the second coat of nail polish on his right middle finger to look up at him, a mixture of horror, confusion, and anger on her face. Shadow also looks a little taken aback as he devours his cookie and reaches for the next one, even if he seems to be doing his utter best to completely ignore him.

"What? I'm not saying I'd actually do it!" Eggman cries. "Do you know how many negative effects that would have on the planet? That's not my brand of villainy!"

Amy exhales in relief. "Good." She'd much rather not have to send Knuckles up to space again. Her contentment transforms into irritation when she hears an especially loud crunch coming from Shadow. She turns to glare at him. "Shadow, will you stop eating while you're lying on my couch?! You're going to get crumbs everywhere!" She pauses as she looks down at the cookie platter. Assessing its contents, she adds with even more annoyance, "And don't eat all the chocolate chip! Save some for Eggman!"

Shadow doesn't verbally respond to any of her demands. He simply turns his head to stare at her with his single open eye as he takes an additional two chocolate chip cookies from the platter. He stacks them underneath the cookie he already started eating, then chomps down on all three with his fangs, making sure the ensuing CRUNCH echoes throughout the entire house. He continues to stare at her.

"Ugh." Amy is the one to break eye contact first, because of course she is. She can't even say she's surprised at the lack of respect in the face of all her hospitality.

She scheduled separate hangouts with Eggman and Shadow a few days ago as part of her efforts to be the bigger person. She even tempted them with sweets, board games, and cosmetology!

And then they showed up at her front door together, one looking far more enthused than the other, and it was then that Amy knew that she accidentally double-booked. Maybe she can't complain, since she knows for a fact that things could be going a lot worse than they actually are.

"He can have all the chocolate chip he wants, it's an overrated flavor anyway. A snickerdoodle though? That's where it's—hey. Hey!" In the middle of his sentence, Eggman finally looks down at Amy's handiwork and becomes indignant. "Don't paint Orbot and Cubot's faces on my nails! What makes you think I want those two buckets of bolts anywhere on my body?!"

"You wanted red and yellow!"

"Yes, to go with my coat, not my robots!"

"Well then, sorry!" Amy snaps as she uses her finger to rub Orbot and Cubot's faces away. What a shame; she thinks she did a pretty good job with them. "What do you actually want to put on your nails? Because they feel too plain with just the colors."

"Hm..." Eggman purses his lips and rubs his chin with the hand Amy isn't in the middle of fixing, taking extra care to not accidentally rub any still wet nail polish against his skin. "Hmmm... Hmmmmmmmm..."

"Get on with it," Shadow, staring up at the ceiling, grunts as he munches on a snickerdoodle, having already gone through all of the chocolate chip. Amy's fairly certain his choice to go through the snickerdoodles next is solely to spite Eggman.

Eggman throws his hand up in the air in a well-what-can-you-do fashion. "Draw a compass pointing north on my pointer finger."

Amy levels him with a very puzzled look.

"What," Shadow mutters incredibly judgmentally.

"Hey, come on, don't either of you get it? Compass pointing north on my pointer finger? I point at things a lot?" When neither of them have a visible epiphany, he rolls his eyes and sighs at what he perceives to be their slowness. "It symbolizes that I have a sense of direction! When I point at you and your team and yell, 'ROBOTS, ATTAAAAAACK!' it shows that I lead my creations!"

"Okay, but... a compass of all things?" Amy questions. If There are so many other things that can carry the same message. For example, there is the classic arrow, which would definitely look a lot better on a fingernail than a freaking compass.

"You have no so-called 'sense of direction.' If you did, you would have already conquered this pathetic village long ago. In addition, you wouldn't be sitting around the house of one of your enemies getting a beauty treatment."

Amy wisely chooses to ignore Shadow and his blatant hypocrisy in favor of trying to understand Eggman's muse. "And why do you want it to point north anyway?"

"Oh, easy. To represent my eventual rise in power once I build my theme park," Eggman explains casually. "It's important to have aspirations. Reaching for the heavens, you know."

"Eggman..."

"Did this fool just imply that he thinks that north is the same thing as up? As in the direction of the sky? Or 'the heavens,' as he calls it?"

"What's wrong with..." Eggman pauses as it dawns on him. "Oh. Well, it's the direction closest to being up! It's not any less up than east is!"

"Hey, it's okay, you don't have to justify this," Amy cuts in quickly before he can get too into defending his logic. Mainly because she knows that once he truly starts, there's no shutting him up. "I'll paint you your compass if that's what you really want."

"Sure. And when one of the villagers asks him which way is north, he can use that finger to point upwards," Shadow says snidely, as he grabs the very last cookie off the platter. Raising it to his lips, he adds, "Given the average intelligence level of these people, they'll believe him, too."

Eyeing the cleaned plate warily, Amy makes a silent note to bake a bigger batch of cookies next time. That, or prohibit Shadow from gaining any access to them and miraculously getting him to comply with that.

"It doesn't hurt to be a little less mean, Shadow," Eggman chides as Amy resumes her work on his nails. "What would Maria think if she saw you with this attitude of yours?"

"Who's Maria?" a clearly uncaring Shadow asks through a giant mouthful of oatmeal raisin.

"My cousin. And I think you asking that just set off everyone reading this, so we should wrap this up now."

Shadow only hums noncommittally, peeling the cucumber slice from his other eye and popping it into his mouth.

[loveletterworm]

My prediction regarding the live action Sonic movies is that I do really think that if the movies continue after the third one then they will finally stop being able to resist the marketability of Girl Character In Children's Movie, and they WILL put Amy in there, but she's not going to get a whole fourth theatrical film to introduce her. She's just going to show up in a random spinoff-of-a-spinoff, like she's going to be in a DVD exclusive short that nobody will watch or maybe they'll inexplicably make another streaming miniseries if they're feeling crazy, and then in the hypothetical fourth movie she'll just be there as if everyone just knows her already. This is not a "hope", this is a vision I'm having in extreme clarity. I'm doing everything in my power to understand their mindset and I am sure their mindset contains the phrase "Eventually we're going to have to start selling some sort of pink girl animal". I'm confident in this. They can't keep denying themselves pink girl animal money.

[wereh0gz]

I have a Sonic spinoff game idea

Ok so. It's a turn-based rpg inspired by dnd, bc I have an itch to play rpgs and also I'm still mad abt them not doing anything with the dnd stuff the official social media posted abt months ago

The story is essentially a battles and badniks (dnd in sonic's world) campaign run by Orbot. Sonic and co. hear abt it somehow (possibly through an invitation?) and decide to check it out thinking it might be one of Eggman's schemes, but nah. It's just a straight game Orbot is running for funsies. Not exactly sure what the story of the campaign would be, but I know it involves Sonic being a villain bc he deserves to let loose. Also Eggman and Sage would be minor antagonists, basically like rivals to the party that they meet and fight at certain points. The main party could consist of Amy, Tails, Knuckles, and Shadow, with Amy possibly being the de-facto main character and with more characters joining the party later on

The game is divided into two types of gameplay- in-game segments that look like your typical high fantasy rpg, which take up most of your playtime, and out-of-game segments in a similar style to a visual novel, which are a lot shorter

The rpg segments play like a mixture of your typical turn-based game and ttrpg. The party is on a quest of some sort, exploring the world of their game, meeting people, visiting various villages and doing small side-quests along the way. The party can encounter enemies in areas between villages, which they battle in a similar manner to most games of the genre, by selecting the actions each character takes. BUT they have to roll their dice to determine how well they perform the selected action, which is the main gimmick of the game. They can also perform checks to lessen the effects of certain actions taken against the characters in battle or to determine how well certain actions are performed out of battle, which in some cases could affect how the story progresses so each playthrough is kind of unique. There's also an exp system, in which exp is gained by defeating enemies and performing side-quests

The out-of-game segments serve to give a bit of extra exposition to the player (like setting up the actual campaign and showing why each character is playing the role they are playing in it, stuff like that). There would be some moments in the rpg segments where the campaing is interrupted by these segments, mostly used for gags at first until later into the game where some interpersonal drama happens

Both segments would have different art styles, too. The rpg segments would have a 2.5d pixelart style while the visual novel segments would have a style similar to tmosth. Since this is a hypothetical game, I'd throw in voice acting too, but if it were real I wouldn't expect there to be any

Each characters' class would be the same as seen in this post, and they'd have different names and slightly different appearances to the "real-world" characters playing them. Of course their outfits are different to fit the roles they are playing, but their actual physical appearance and age could be different too, all depending on how they were made by the characters playing them. Amy's character specifically would essentially just be Paladin Amy from Sonic Dash and Speed Battle. Not really sure abt the others tho

The endgame would be to redeem Sonic's character, who as I said earlier is the main villain, and also figure out why Sonic would choose to play the villain in the first place (spoiler alert: he's stressed as fuck and wants to not be seen as a hero for once). They also gotta stop Eggman and Sage from causing trouble. Fun hijinks, dnd-based jokes, (possibly) some high fantasy horror, and plenty of character drama ensues

[rubywolf0201]

Oh! That’s a BRILLAINT idea! Or have the antagonist be the opposite of Amy and for the pink hedgehog to only beat them but in the end, help said villain and make them have a change of heart as well.

Amy Rose centred game where not only is she the main heroine in her own game, but she goes through a personal adventure where meets and befriends people, do sidequests since it’s in her character to help people and believe in them (which contrasts with Sonic's ‘I believe in you’ theme), have gameplay stages revolve around Amy's hammer and have it harken back to the first Advance gameplay she has. The art and story would be done by Tyson Hesse since he is the one person who understood who Amy truly is.

Not only that, but I want the Amy-centered game to prove her antis wrong and that she is not some mindless fangirl.

Yes this! Have her villain be the antithesis or at least a parody of what the hatedumb thinks Amy is.

[kyliafanfiction-archive]

A Wesley/Illyria spinoff would be amazing! Also, tell us more about the Faith/Faimy spinoff please! :) Where would it take place? Would it be Slayer and Witch fighting the forces of darkness together? Would it start with them bumping into each other a bit like Cangel in City Of? Would it be slow burn or they would hook up right away?

I talked some thoughts Faith the Series as I would write it here, but here’s some more thoughts in line with your questions.

It would probably be a road trip style show, I think. That, or set in like, New York. Let’s go with New York for now. The premise would be that Faith doesn’t want to/can’t share a Hellmouth (Cleveland) with Buffy. They aren’t, after all, supposed to exist together.

Faith isn’t planning to stick around in New York, she’s just passing through - most of the baby slayers are being trained in Cleveland or England, so she’s doing a pass through of major US cities and spending a month or two just blazing through the local Vamp/Demon community (I imagine she like, finds the most dangerous demon/vamp bars, the ones only the really evil and violent ones go to, and just walks in with shotgun, stake and knife and just.... you know, butchers).

Anyway, so Amy gets introduced in the first ep. Like, the ep gets started with Faith blasting through a gang of vamps, then she goes to a nightclub for some drinks and anonymous sex. She picks up Amy, not knowing who she is. Cut to Faith’s hotel room (she uses a Council Credit Card to splurge, much to the annoyance of Giles [I’d have a one-sided phone call about this at some point early on - like, imply Giles is on the other end, but don’t necessarily hire ASH to speak the role]), where they wake up the next morning, Amy getting dressed quickly - and that’s when they (or specifically) Amy gets attacked by the Seasonal big bads... this part, still kinda fuzzy on. Some kind of bad guys want to kill Amy, and they end up, by Episode end, to be bad enough guys that Faith decides she needs to stick around in NYC long enough to take them out. At the end of that ep is when Ghost!Wesley would show up. 

Anyway, as for Faith and Amy, while they end up working together to fight the baddie, and of course, bond over the things they have in common and the like, and become friends over the course of the first half the season, they wouldn’t actually repeat the one-night stand (because Faith doesn’t usually do that). But by the end of Season 1, Amy would have fallen for Faith, and we’d at least have hints that Faith has feelings for Amy (but neither would know about the other). Their relationship then, would be slow-ish burn, but I imagine they would probably finally have their kiss in mid-Season 2 (by this point Faith is sticking around in NYC because it’s starting to feel like a place to stay in, kinda thing, you know?), though they sort of feel their way to an actual relationship in Fits and starts - I figure they become ‘officially’ dating near the end of ‘Season 2′, in this hypothetical series. 

[rubywolf0201]

I hope Sega makes a spinoff (even a series of shorts) showing Amy travelling the world on her own with no man and having the Flicky bird as her companion. She could even go hiking in the wilderness and even occasionally getting lost due to being impulsive (she got overly excited due to being on an adventure)

Yeah. I mean an Amy spinoff doesn’t have to be confined to a game. It can be in the form of a comic miniseries or even webisodes!

[rubywolf0201]

I don’t know why but whenever I think about an Amy-centric game, I think her game would something similar to Princess Peach Showtime but instead of a theater, Amy is saving a famous fashion boutique from closing down and propose doing a fashion show to save it from an evil tycoon into buying it (this antagonist in particular would serve as Amy’s foil much like Grape is to Amy, let’s call her Poison for now)

I wish to expand it more but these are all I have.

(P.S. Elise would be there too 😉 and Amy would gain a tol human companion)

[rubywolf0201]

For how Elise would play in Amy’s Fashion Runaway, I imagine there would be mini segments in between the stages where Elise with the help of my OC Marshall, would don disguises to gather intel on the latest trends and also any dirt on White Lily.

The gameplay would be somewhat similar to how Princess Peach would stealthily and secretly gather info on the X-nauts in Paper Mario TTYD with the help of TEC and also a mix of how Phantom Thief and Detective Peach plays in Princess Peach Showtime!

First, a disguised Elise and Marshall would go around town to enquire on the latest fashion trends by pretending to read newspaper all the while listening in to the gossips on the latest trend. From there, there would be a minigame where Elise would have to recall the small whispers she heard from the passerbys to Marshall where he would take note of. There would be three tries in total and if Elise fails to recall all three, it would be game over. So players have to be really observant on the whispers and murmurs of the passerbys and have Elise recall them correctly.

For gameplay relating to gathering intel on White Lily’s plan, it would be the same as above but this time there would be a stealth mini game so as to tail on White Lily’s goons and see what they’re up to. Like the passerby mini game, there would be three tries in total. If Elise and Marshall gets spotted way too many times, it would be a game over.

There is however an accessory that Elise can equip if players wants to be casual and have extra lives on Elise but it would probably cost around 500 rings so players have to be resourceful on how they should spend their money.

[rubywolf0201]

One of the reasons I made Elise to be a co-star in Amy’s Fashion Runaway is not only because I adore the friendship between Amy and Elise (short and brief it may’ve been) and the potential it could bring. But I also did it to cheese off that crowd who wants Amy to beat up Elise for ‘stealing’ Sonic from her.

[rubywolf0201]

While I was thinking of a role that Elise could play in Amy’s Fashion Runaway, I decided that her gameplay would probably revolve around stealth and gathering info from the people of Soleanna regarding fashion trends and White Lily’s terrible deeds.

Her gameplay would be something similar to how Peach is played in Paper Mario TTYD in certain stages. An example would be that while Amy is away beating up goons that were sent by White Lily, Elise has to don a disguise and sneak out to the streets of Soleanna where she would gain intel about the latest fashion trend that is running along with what Lily is doing.

And just like how Peach would frequently email Mario about what is happening regarding the X-nauts and the Crystal Stars, Elise would do the same by informing Amy and my OC Marshall but with fashion trends and White Lily’s plan.

She would get captured but unlike what happened in 06, she freed herself using the wits she learned from past stages and the resources within her captured grounds and save the day along with Amy!

[rubywolf0201]

Your idea of having an Amy spinoff where Amy squares off against an evil businesswoman and becomes gal-pals with Elise is brilliant!

I hope Sega does something similar. I mean if princes peach can get two whole ass spinoffs I don't see why Amy can't get one!

Hehe thanks.

I think Amy fighting a supervillain that is basically her evil counterpart is just a fun idea I played around with. I’m glad that you liked it!

[rubywolf0201]

@kittydoremi @dragondelsus @hypersonicjd

I should also add this but the antagonist White Lily despite being named after the Lily flower, her flower motif is actually the Red Spider Lily!

Outfit-wise, I imagine it to be a polar opposite of what Amy wears: a sleek business suit complete with stilettos to them though they do share the same color albeit of a different shade and both ladies wear gold bangles. (Lily however also wears a ring on one of her hands)

[rubywolf0201]

Yess I love the idea having a nemesis that is a corrupted cold-hearted businesswoman. Makes a great foil to Amy's kind heart and willingness to help people (and animals) for free.😍

Bonus points if she treats her employees like shit and works them half to death 😈

Yeah I was thinking that too for White Lily. But I kind of decided that she will not only fire her employees but also blacklist them should they not meet her standards.

[rubywolf0201]

In regards to a hypothetical Amy spinoff, I know this sounds a bit meta, but what if the main villainess used her influence to spread nasty rumors about Amy to smear her reputation? Like spread rumors that she is a clingy psycho yandere that forces herself on and stalks random hedgehog males.

You know that gives me a good idea about White Lily. She would be the type of person who would misuse her influence to spread nasty rumors about her competitors just to give herself an edge well stroking her ego.