#how dare you eat
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
ALRIGHT HIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII >__</
ok so, this is a PART 1 ÂĄYES! HI BATZ IM GONNA KILL YOU FOR BEING SO GOOD AT WRITING
:3c
MY BRAIN IS JUST FULL OF THE SCENES OF THE FANFICS I READ
when I read, everything in my brain is just so visual for some reason and then my next move is to make a fucking comic or something, AND YES IM DOING MORE.
Also, yeah this is what I told you about doing something for chapter 5 last time, also remember that fic that was what if varian was the one on the amber instead of his father and then something something happens with the moonstone and then moon stone lives inside of varian?
well...
ehhehehehehehehhehehe
ALSO, OH SHIT!
THE NEXT PART IS GOING TO BE ONLY ON DISCORD OR MAYBE ILL MADE A NEW ACC BC THAT SHIT IS GOING TO BE A LITTLE BIT SPICY AJHKGFAKJGHG
BTW GO AND GIVE SOME LOVE TO @aziraphalesbookkeeper
THIS IS THE LINK OF THE FIC WAAAAAAAAAAA
and I'm going to read the fic again so brb :b
#vat7k#alchemy boyfriends#hugo rottewange#hugo vat7k#varian#tts varian#tts#hugo the human#varian and the seven kingdoms#varigo#ao3 fanfic#ao3 fanart#fanfic#also batz im going to read all your fics for mha bc how dare you have bkdk fics??? IM GONNA EAT THEM ALL#vat7k hugo#vat7k varian#vat7k au#varian vat7k#varian and the 7 kingdoms#what summer meant to you fic#my art <3#im killing everyone
255 notes
¡
View notes
Text
When you're one of the most selfish mc who only saves people because it's part of a job you never wanted and did not get to chose or you would've died, who took your co-workers' morals and ideals because you didn't have any and desperately wanted to fit in somewhere, be it with the heroes or the villains, who's activelly haunted by one the most tragic past to have been created and suffer from a psychosis so bad (dare I say schizophrenia) that even your enemies acknowledged that you are mentally ill and objectively flawed in your judgement, never hesitated to try to kill anyone and has the most egoistic reason to be a good person but the fandom still thinks you're just a kind crybaby "I don't know what a gun is" homosexual twink.
#him being refered as an angel by Shibuzawa is FUCKING IRONIC !!#ASAGIRI IS ALWAYS IRONIC WHEN IT COMES TO LIGHT NOVELS CENTERED AROUND ATSUSHI#Ex : The plot of 55min being parallele to the Decay of Angels arc#He's also called the Man-eating tiger and yes I do think that Dazai lied to him when he said he never ate anyone to preserve his psyche#and was also called âthe man who can see the futureâ and has time travelled with Akutagawa like why aren't we talking about that#his relationship with Mori is also actually good#Mori is one if not the only character who saved and helped Atsushi during their first meeting and kept good contacts with him#because yes Atsushi has seen Mori knowing that he was the pm boss off-screen and they had a normal exchange#I also think that Shibuzawa Atsushi and Fyodor are connected to a form of Holy Trinity#Believer/God/Angel or Messenger#Joseph/Jesus/Mary#or Fyodor and Atsushi as Jesus and Judas#but the instance of trinity in bsd are dare I say extreme#Oda/Ango/Dazai#Sigma/Fyodor/Nikolai#Atsushi/Akutagawa/Kyoka#and so on#and the whole situation around his ability which is unlike any other#It turns him into Byakko (her own being) (similar to Natsume) and nullify his wounds no matter how lethal (similar to Dazai and Yosano)#and enhance him even with his ability off making him constantly stronger than other characters and dare I say equal to the hunting dogs#yk the MODIFIED humans#and the plot of both 55mins and Dead Apple being around abilities and giving us Atsushi lore make me think that Atsushi and Byakko are 1/2#probably a sort of higher being since some abilities are very religious centered (how Fyodor sees abilities and Shibuzawa) 2/2#but I think it would lend toward a âsinnerâ position which would be crazy because that Atsushi would then probably be the reason why Fyodor#hates abilities so much if Atsushi and Byakko are somehow be connected to the âsinâ of abilities#and so you guys know Atsushi's orphanage was a church so yes he's related to christianity#and the Decay of Angels is LITTERALY full of religious people to different degrees#and it would be ironic (once again) if the antagonists were the âAngelsâ and the protagonist a demon#I just realized that I did a lot of typos sorry I got too excited#but yeah keep calling bsd bad written (we're on barely chap.115 no good manga was finished by chap.115 guys just wait for the rest to drop)
69 notes
¡
View notes
Text
I need the people who look at posts talking about Wyll's treatment in both the actual game and especially the fandom and respond with "but i don't like him and I think he's boring" to know that shutting the fuck up is 100% the better option 100% of the time. Him being the only origin character to not have at last 10 hours of content and the existence of mods that literally whitewash him and his dad - among everything else wrong with how Wyll is treated - are not suddenly okay because you, personally, as an individual, don't find him interesting, and your personal individual feelings about him are irrelevant to the issues surrounding his treatment in the bg3 community at large, so like. Stop barging in with your unwanted, unhelpful opinion
#not 3h#wyll ravengard#being daring today and using a non FE main tag because holy shit is this one of the most annoying things fucking ever#had to rant about this because it happens ALL THE TIME in the bg3 fandom i swear to god#person (usually a black person or someone otherwise nonwhite): I think Wyll should have been given more content individual to him#some fuckwit: but he's boring!#person: I think Wyll should have been given more autonomy as a character and not have everything about his arc be up to the player#fuckwit: but he's BORING!!#person: I think it's strange how antagonistic we the player HAVE to be towards Wyll many times especially compared to the other companions#fuckwit: BUT HE'S BORING!!!#person: I think it's problematic that Wyll is constantly connected to his abuser in promo material when no one else is connected to theirs#fuckwit: WYLL IS BORING THO!!!!#person: I think it's unfair to people who like Wyll that bugs that have been around for multiple patches are only now getting patched#(while characters like Asta/rion get even more content on top of already having a shit ton)#fuckwit: BOOOOOOORRRRRRRRRIIIIIIIIING!!!!!#person: I think the fandom treatment of black Wyll fans who want more Wyll content is racist#fuckwit: HE'S SO BORING!!!!!!#person: People making mods that turn Wyll white/have you beat up *only* Wyll/give Wyll's content to white characters is racist#fuckwit: BUT HE'S SOOOOOOOOO BORING!!!!!!!#like holy SHIT shut the fuck up. that is SO not the damn point.#Fandom Be Normal About Characters of Color Challenge (IMPOSSIBLE) (FAILED) (I ENDED UP BEING RACIST???)#go back to eating Asta/rion's toe jam or whatever the hell his fans do jesus fuck
62 notes
¡
View notes
Note
If you want to be bothered. Maybe this for dick and Bruce???
i ALWAYS want to be bothered these are always the highlight of my day tbh you're a delight for letting me just yap <3
Dick. For the canon isn't real square I am Specifically talking about the Tom Taylor Nightwing run. Usually I ignore bad runs but given this one is ongoing (though about to end THANK GOD and get replaced by Dan Watters who i have high hopes for since i adored his Sword of Azrael (2022) run but i digress) so I counted it. Especially since it's so debated if that run is bad or not, for some reason. I'm a 90s Nightwing truther. I love Dick so dearly and tbh recently I've been more enamored with him the more I read his Discowing era, I didn't used to be as big of a Dick stan as I am these days.
Bruce. Honestly where do you even start with Bruce. I want to fist fight him and also patch him up. He got me into comics and superheroes as a whole but I roll my eyes whenever he shows up in a story. He's a bastard and usually not a good father but also complex and should be dissected under a magnifying glass. I love him dearly. He's also just the worst. I think that's why I love him. I'm always a fan of unabashedly Complicated Asshole Bruce who's generally not always the best person, particularly not to the Batfamily and that being the driving force of his relationships with them, especially in shipping.
And for bonus points, Tim. Because know above all else, I'm a Tim Drake kinnie /deg. He's been my number one for a decade and I've yet to uproot him from my brain. He's literally the Worst half the time and I love him for it. And the canon isn't real refers to Tim Drake: Robin because... that sure was a comic. And that's about all I can say about it. Pre-Flashpoint Tim I miss you so dearly. I think it's fun that I want to put him in a blender and drink the juice but also want Nothing Ever to happen to him.
#necrotic answerings#batcest#bruce wayne#dick grayson#tim drake#fandom tag#anyway the fandom is i guess mean to all of them#but like it's deserving.#everytime i meet a tim anti i'm like you're SO right. he's the worst. pls hate his ass more.#same with bruce. like never met a bruce anti who didn't have endless receipts for hating his ass.#(except for those using the shallow 'he's a billionaire beating up the mentally ill' argument which. i ignore)#(bc why are you. consuming superhero content if you just don't like or understand the genre. it's lazy pseudointellectual nonsense.)#and i don't think ppl are truly mean to dick. i think they just don't understand him.#which extends to the entire batfamily bc well. the state of the fandom and all.#like âeveryone else is wrong about themâ isn't in a âno one gets them but meâ way#(except about tim truly no one gets him but me /j)#it's in a âoh y'all just want to fit them into neat boxes don't youâ way#one more person call dick grayson âeldest daughter coreâ and i'm going to your house and eating the stuffing out all of your pillows.#first of all can we stop calling male characters âfemale codedâ in any way please#women exist in comics too.#second of all it's just not true? and it's not the complex he has with bruce nor his âsiblingsâ if you wish to call them that#and then bruce. where do you even start.#you dare say you think it's in character for bruce to hit his kids and *SOCIETY. society goes wild.*#like ofc it has to be in specific contexts. he's not just swinging.#and sometimes it *is* written very OOC bc bruce is written as a machismo self insert i give you that#but yeah a soldier who views his children as soldiers and has zero healthy emotional regulation or communication skills#is gonna sometimes swing in his worst moments. it is just how the superhero genre works everyone is gonna fist fight to solve problems.#why are you reading comics about ppl who hit other ppl for a living if you don't like it when they hit ppl.#also random hot take about dick's characterization#the young justice tv show did incredible damage to ppl's perception of him and i dislike the take it's the best adaptation of him
59 notes
¡
View notes
Note
"Suave sugar big bad daddy Alastor" is the reason I ignore most of charlastor and radioapple content, it's laughable how absolutely the same a lot of works are and even funnier that a lot of people from both groups dislike the other ship lol
my GOD, you're right 𤣠for two ship groups that don't like each other, they sure do use a lot of the same tropes.
i'm sorry i just can't see Alastor being a big bad suave sugar daddy. 𼲠Where's his whimsy? Where's his goofy silliness? Cannibalism can be sexy, but you know what else is sexy? Being a clowning little freak.
#how DARE they strip of him of tomfoolery#why does he always act like some suave little gentleman#as is this guy wouldn't eat a cornchip off the floor#as if he wouldn't drop a rotting piece of liver and say â5 second rule!â and then pop it in his mouth#yes he can look sexy and put together#but let the clown honk every once in a while#you can't push down the buffoonery it's not healthy for him#asks#anon#anonymous#radiobelle#charlastor#radioapple#appleradio#alastor#hazbin hotel#the radio demon
87 notes
¡
View notes
Note
BY THE END OF THIS MONTH THEY'D BETTER BE ENGAGED.
sure why not. Get Engaged Beam Now!!!
#korn asks#mega man#mega man classic#megaman classic#megaman#freezeice shit#freezeice#freeze man#freezeman#ice man#iceman#ANON you sent the second ask to my main blog!!! how dare you /j /lh#i was gonna try to get this done earlier but hooo boy kinda been already been busy since getting back to work#but everyone wants freezeice wedding huh?#anyways happy pride and i hope you eat well random anon
72 notes
¡
View notes
Text
Respectfully, but a character can be and SHOULD BE allowed to be more than one thing without it being considered "contradictory", "retconning," or "negative character development."
#this is specifically about the people reacting to downfall going WOW WHAT IS TAL DOING WITH MELORA SHE WAS SO SWEET AND KIND#and WOW PELOR USED TO BE SO SWEET??#like no people contain multitudes#and it's common in EVERY FANDOM so I'm not tagging it as a specific fandom#because it feels like characters get sanded down to one or two core traits#and anything not related to that either gets ignored or considered a retcon or the writers/players/actors not knowing the character#like going back to CR i saw some people reacting to Tal's VERY COMPLEX view of ashton's contradictory views on his feelings for fearne#as tal not understanding his own character and i'm like omfg have you never been a self-hating person who wants something they're scared#that they can't have??#are you all seriously just One Thing all the time#LET CHARACTERS HAVE THEIR NUANCE#STOP CLAIMING IT'S OOC OR RETCONNING OR BAD WRITING WHEN A CHARACTER IS COMPLEX#I AM GOING TO EAT A ROCK#this isn't even getting into this with my other fandoms#like oh this character did something shitty one time they are now completely defined by that shitty act#and any further kindness is just trying to cover up the shitty thing they did#how dare they#JUST HHNNGSDHSJKJ I AM SO ANNOYED BY THIS#STOP IT#WHY IS THIS HAPPENING
59 notes
¡
View notes
Text
i posted something for nagumo on ao3 if anyoneâs interested :3
#đˇď¸.ficânagumo#nagumo yoichi x reader#unfortunately my laptop yet again went off the railsâŚ.!?!#and i donât have the patience to post a 3k word fic using my phone on this godforsaken app :)#too glitchy and a lot of workâŚ.sometimes the app eat the wordsâŚ.. iykyk#hahahahahaa 2025 how dare you#nagumo x reader#nagumo yoichi fanfic#nagumo yoichi x you#nagumo x you#nagumo yoichi#nagumo#queued post
26 notes
¡
View notes
Text
Heâs mine now, @phoebepheebsphibs, youâve lost your rights
#double mutated mikey#phoebepheebsphibs#rottmnt fandom#Belle yells#Iâm not caught up but I saw your last post and sneak peek after a friend messaged me#and uhhhh hey how dare you /lh /nm#yoinks your kid. heâs my kid now weâre gonna go play Wii party and eat pizza#(also I am so so sorry I havenât replied to our thing in so long and havenât left reviews recently)#(plz know I still think about you and love dm Mikey dearly)
51 notes
¡
View notes
Text
WWEonFOX: Roman Reigns laughed at the idea of Solo Sikoa becoming Tribal Chief đ
#wrestling#wwe#solo sikoa#roman reigns#jey uso#jimmy uso#the usos#the bloodline#and then roman would name him 'tribal heir' anyway because he no longer had control of jey#and the usos were right there planting and encouraging the idea to solo#as were alllll you mfs cheering him on!!! (not even the first time dont think i forgot or will let you who boo now <3)#so: actions have consequences#also shoutout to the 'solo ate my sign' sign with a bite mark making the video crop lmao#solo is innocent of all crimes#whatever he did maybe its your fault actually#including eating your signs#solo just took the ball and ran yall kicked it towards him ok#how dare yall criticize a man for being proactive???#roman wasnt around and was slipping anyway so someone had to?????#solo is a good boy any say otherwise is slander
63 notes
¡
View notes
Text
The Number You Have Called Cannot Be Reached 6
Part 1|Part 2|Part 3|Part 4|Part 5
Ship: Dead on Main (Danny/Jason) Warnings: angst/depression and canon typical violence
Bruce sighed, absently feeling the air on his hands folded in front of his face. He stared unseeingly ahead. His frowned deeply, at a loss of what to do. Worry picked at his self control.
Something was up with Jason. Ever since the other night, something had happened between the thief and Jason. It had left him unsettled and off balance, that much was obvious. Theyâd all been able to see it.
Now, today, Jason had lost control. Heâd been agitated of course, but Bruce hadnât expected the outburst. Jason was usually good at managing his anger these days, at least in the family. He didnât get physical with them anymore in anger. Except today Jason had suddenly pulled him up by the shirt, and Bruce had honestly expected him to punch him. Jason had shaken it off, but then heâd fled.
The urge to move, to do something, itched at him. He wanted to get answers, but confronting Jason was out of the question. Their truce was fragile, and it seemed every time he spoke to Jason he said the wrong thing. He didnât know what to do except control the urge to go after his son. He couldnât fight his demons for him. He could only try not to make it worse.
And so he sat there, staring, unseeing.
Dickâs footsteps, came down the stairs, easily recognizable: light and almost dancing to a rhythm only he could hear, skipping a step every now and then.
âHey B, thought you were going golfing with the mayor, keeping up the old appearances and all thatâ he greeted brightly, as ever immune to Bruceâs mood. Or maybe Alfred sent him down to deal with him, that was also an option.
âOh I love these,â Dick reached forward over Bruceâs shoulder to grab a protein bar from the backpack. He opened it and started to eat it without hesitation.
âDick,â Bruce sighed, âthis is evidence.â
Dick snorted and leaned on the console so he could look at Bruce. âYouâre serious.â
Bruce raised an eyebrow.
Dick snorted again, of course Bruce was serious, then he pulled the backpack over and started rooting through it. Much to Bruceâs exasperation he opened another protein bar.
âDick, they could be drugged.â
âAs if youâd have let me take the first one if that was the case,â Dick mumbled around the mouthful of granola. Bruce mentally conceded the point.
âAnyways,â Dick swallowed and continued, reading the name tag on the inside of the backpack, âDanny Fenton, whoâs that?â
Bruce sighed.
âThe thief.â
âThe Ghost!?â Dick looked up in excitement, âso we have a name now?â
âPresumably, it may not originally have been his backpack.â
âTrue, doesnât help much either does it? Danny is very common and Fenton may not be Johnson, but itâs not exactly unique.â
âI havenât looked it up yet.â
Dick narrowed his eyes.
âThis has anything to do with why youâre brooding?â
Silence stretched between them, but Dick could be surprisingly patient when he wanted to. There was no point in dragging things out, it wasnât a secret, Dick could easily find out through the surveillance if he wanted, Bruce would rather he didnât.
âJason was the one who delivered the backpack.â
âAh.â There was the worried frown Bruce would have liked to avoid. He leaned down a bit to better face Bruce.
âYou had a fight?â The question was posed carefully, softly, not betraying any inkling what he thought of that, in a way to gently pry the answer from Bruce, but Bruce knew his eldest son well enough to know he was already mentally running damage control options. That was Dick, always trying to keep their family together tooth and nail. There was a soft pang of appreciation in his chest he couldnât articulate, instead he focused on the problem at hand.
âHeâs convinced the thief needs help, I donât actually disagree.â
Dick sat back in realization, his eyes flickered to the backpack and its sorry spoils.
âBut he could still be working for someone,â Dick recited with a sigh, it was an old lesson. One he knew Jason wouldnât have appreciated, not if he felt Bruce was dismissing his concerns. âB.â
âI know.â
Do you? Dickâs eyebrows asked, but he had the grace not to actually say it. He clapped Bruce on the shoulder instead, squeezing slightly.
âHeâll warm back up.â
âYou think so?â He asked unable to look up at Dick.
âHey,â Dick said brightly in a way that naturally drew attention to him, âweâve come back from worse.â And there was that bright smile and that pang of appreciation was back, along with another warm feeling in his chest: hope.
âWell, I gotta get going, Iâve got work tomorrow. Just gotta grab a few more of these.â
And the feeling was gone.
âDick.â
âWe shouldnât waste perfectly good food, B, also theyâre W-Mark exclusives, they donât have them in BlĂźdhaven.â He grinned, pockets stuffed with contraband. Invariably reminding Bruce of a younger version with pockets full of candy heâd been denied. Brat already knew he had won. Bruce waved him off with a sigh.
Dick practically skipped towards the stairs. Then he paused.
âOh and B, if I was you, Iâd check the phone at the bottom of the bag. Itâs not a brand I recognize.â
With that he was off.
Bruce stared after him. Pride warred with annoyance. Heâd been so absorbed in his thoughts he hadnât even noticed Dick checking out the bag more thoroughly than the cursory look he himself had done when Jason had handed it to him.
He grabbed the bag and rooted around a bit, and just as Dick had said, there was a phone.
He pulled it out, and turned it over in his hands. It was made from dark blue plastic. The logo on the back, a stylized V in front of a globe, wasnât one he recognized. It looked old and scuffed, had actual buttons and a jarringly small screen when you were used to modern smartphones.
It was also out of power.
With how old it looked, it was unlikely cordless charging was an option. He looked at the bottom edge where there was an actual mini headphone jack, along with what he assumed was the charging port - it wasnât a type he recognized.
He frowned and got up. He wouldnât be too late for his meeting with the mayor if he left now, not something he couldnât brush off as eccentric forgetfulness at least.
He could drop the phone off at Timâs on the way. Tim would get the phone working one way or another.
Oo o oO
Danny stayed underneath the pavement long after the not-ghost had left. The feeling of almost giving in was a crawling like ants underneath his skin. The threat of almost capture was like a noose around his neck - if they captured him, if they managed to contain him, he would never get home.
Eventually the bone deep tiredness of using his powers too much hit him, and he dragged himself back to his haunt, invisibly and intangibly, because heâd had much too much excitement today. He was raw and empty inside when he dropped onto his blanket pile and rolled up. He would get food some other day. Never mind that he was completely out. It wouldnât end his existence, just weaken him. Ghosts at the core ran on willpower, and Danny wanted to go home.
A small squeak and rustle, had him opening his eyes a crack and turning his head to look to the far side of the room. There the rat was going his trash, the packaging probably still smelled like food.
He huffed and closed his eyes again. If he got truly desperate he could always eat the rat - It wouldnât be the worst thing heâd eaten.
next
Masterpost for subscription
Sorry, it's not the longest part this time, but we got to appreciate a few other characters, yay! Hope you enjoyed, cause Danny sure isn't enjoying himself.
#Sorry Danny this is what you get for being my favorite character#all misery#Jason doesn't appear in this part#He'll be there next time angsting over how Danny keeps running away from him#Jason is catnip to Danny#Danny however doesn't do recreational drugs#sorry Jay#your ghost is on another rooftop#what is this#spoilers for the next part in the tags#Moku how dare you#dp x dc#dead on main#Missed Connections#angst#cw depression#Dick Grayson is a good detective#can we please appreciate him#let's try to ignore that he was eating Danny's stolen food#in Dick's defense the stolen food was already stolen#don't waste food#Bruce is trying to be a good dad
875 notes
¡
View notes
Note
no sour cream? -50 aura points
i was just taking orders and itâs funny bc the plates donât even come with sour cream to begin with đ
46 notes
¡
View notes
Text
Today I'm more than usually annoyed with a pop science article, so I'm going to talk about reading these sorts of articles, why you should always be skeptical of claims in them, and some of the ways you can tell the article's author didn't understand what they were reading and told you the wrong thing.
I clicked on an article in Eating Well about low bone density and dementia, because my mother has both. There's not a lot we can do for her now, but I am a curious person. I know Eating Well isn't great at science interpretation and communication, so I'm anticipating that I'm going to need to read the original study already, going in. (How do I know Eating Well isn't a great source usually? Well, I have read it before, and it has some really clear biases if you read a few articles that aren't science communication, and so you get to know a source over time like that. Regardless of how, I'm already suspicious they're not going to do a great job.)
The article is talking about research that shows low bone density may be predictive of dementia risk. It is written by a journalist and reviewed by a dietician. Now, I don't know what review the dietician did, but she did a bad job, and also, so did the journalist, because THE FIRST red flag that goes up is pretty quick: the math is very, very clearly wrong.
This says there are 3651 participants, and that over 11 years, 688 of them developed dementia. This is 18.8% and the article calls it 19%. That's fair! Not a red flag so far, just rounding. Then it says that of the 1211 people with lowest bone density at the start, 90 people (7.4%) developed dementia, and of the 1211 with highest bone density, only 57 (4.7%) did.
This IS a red flag. It's a GIANT red flag. This red flag can be seen from SPACE by anyone who knows how percentages work.
Here's how: You have 3651 people. 1211 of them are in the low bone density group, 1211 of them are in the high bone density group, leaving 1249 people. You have 688 total dementia cases, but your high and low groups account for only 147 of them, leaving 541 cases for that middle group. That's a LOT of cases. That middle tertile, just eyeballing it, has to have about 40% of its people with dementia -- that makes low bone density look like it predicts LOWER dementia risk relative to the middle group.
I can write out the equations for you two ways:
3651 - 1211 - 1211 = 1249 688 - 90 - 57 = 541 541/1249 = 0.433 0.433(100) = 43.3%
Because I am someone who does a fair amount of stats for a living, though, what I noticed was pretty much this equation:
0.074(1211) + x(1249) + 0.047(1211) = 0.19(3651) and I knew immediately that x had to be MUCH bigger than it should, which indeed the math bears out: x(1249) = 0.19(3651) - 0.074(1211) - 0.047(1211) x(1249) = 694 - 90 - 57 x = 547/1249 = 0.438 0.438(100) = 43.8%
That 694 is because the authors rounded 18.8 to 19 earlier, not because I can't math. So, due to rounding, you get slightly different answers -- but BOTH of them point to something SERIOUSLY WRONG with the reporting. What is actually going on in that middle tertile? Where do these numbers come from? Well, lucky us, they mention the name of an author, a journal, and a date. Always be wary of pop sci articles that don't give you a way to track down the original, but giving you that way to track things down doesn't mean they aren't still doing a crummy job with their reporting, as we see here.
The original paper is Association of Bone Mineral Density and Dementia: The Rotterdam Study, published March 2023 in Neurology. This is a pretty technical article with a fair amount of math and things in parens etc. etc. and tables and lots of measurements. The table captions are often not the greatest, which makes it a bit harder to read and interpret. For example, in Table 1, items are listed as number(number) and this can be any of:
count (percent) -- this one's usually labeled in the table itself
mean (standard deviation)
median (interquartile range) -- these last two are NOT labeled in the table, so we don't know which set of numbers is which.
Great. Thanks guys. Assuming what's called a "normal distribution" mean (SD) and median (IQR) numbers will be similar, but they're not the same and I'm irritated they're conflated but OK. Soldiering on!
The original study looked at several different measures of bone density, and found only ONE of them to show predictive ability for dementia: the density of the femoral neck. This means that for their article, Eating Well should have looked at the results for femoral neck bone density, which we find in Table 2:
You have the actual numbers for 5 years, 10 years, and study end, as well as the hazard risk (HR) for each bone density tertile, with the highest tertile set as the standard. Numbers in the HR column have 1 as a reference point -- lower than 1 is lower risk than the highest tertile, and higher than 1 is higher risk.
The first thing I noticed is that neither 57 nor 90 occur in the femoral neck section at ALL. Those numbers from the Eating Well article are just not there. I also notice that the other numbers don't align even one little bit -- the number of total cases of dementia is different, for example. I do notice that the column with the 10 year followup has numbers in it close to 57 and 90 (49, 67, 86, totaled to 202) and that the overall numbers for the total study are much higher -- 201, 236, 229. Interesting.
At this point, I just straight-up search the paper for "90", and I find it in Table 2....in the total bone density section, which the paper's authors have said is NOT the section that showed possible predictive results. I search for "57", and also find that in total bone density, and also....wow the EW author straight up failed to read. This is actually worse than I thought.
Read across, these are the 5 year followup numbers (first 2 columns - count and HR), 10 year (middle 2 columns), and total followup numbers (last 2 columns).
We see our friends 57 and 90 in the 10 year columns. 90 is, as described in the EW article, in the lowest bone density tertile, but 57 is NOT in the highest bone density tertile. It's in the middle tertile. The actual number for the highest tertile is 68. Additionally, the total cases for 10 years is nowhere near that 688 number -- it's 215. We only get total case numbers close to 688 when we look at the study end numbers: it's 686, in this particular group. If we look at the study end case numbers for highest, middle, and lowest tertiles, we see WHY this particular measure can't be used to predict anything: they are 227 (highest), 227 (middle), and 232 (lowest) -- not significantly different from each other.
We can also see here that this group of people -- people who had total bone density measurements -- is not 3651, but 3633, which is listed across the bottom row. The overall STUDY had 3651, but not all of them had total bone density recorded.
Now we know that the author of the EW article did all of the following:
read the wrong part of Table 2
mixed up middle and high tertile results
reported 10 year results mixed with total followup results (this resulted in the weird math that alerted me something was very very wrong in the first place).
and the person who was supposed to review the article didn't have even the basic math skills to catch the problem -- which she absolutely should have, as a registered dietician. For giggles, I looked up program requirements for a BS in Dietetics. Programs require things like statistics and precalc -- not math heavy, but the math that alerted me to this problem is VERY basic statistical knowledge, like the kind they teach in 6th grade level statistics, which I know because it was literally in my 6th grader's curriculum this past school year. So a registered dietician DEFINITELY had enough math to catch this problem, and should have, and Eating Well should be ashamed of itself.
SO. What can we learn from this?
Well, science communication is a skill set. Some people have worked very hard to develop that skill set and are excellent at it -- but lots of people do not have it, and even those who do can make mistakes. Many, many pop sci articles are not written by trained science communicators, or people with any education in how to read scientific articles, or people with good reading comprehension, even. It's very common for pop sci articles to have these sorts of errors in them. Therefore:
Always read pop sci articles with a skeptical eye. Ask yourself:
Do these numbers line up? Usually the math in pop sci articles is not very complex -- you can often do some basic arithmetic to make sure it even makes sense, as was the case here.
Does one part of the article seem to contradict another part of the article?
Do I feel confused about what exactly I'm being told? What's not clear about it?
Am I being told about HOW something works or WHY it works or both? Are those two things being conflated somehow?
Is there a link or way to find the original research? If not, my advice is to throw the whole article away. If yes, you can go check it out -- often just looking at the abstract or results section will be enough, and abstracts usually aren't paywalled even if the rest of the article is. You would be surprised how many times the abstract says "we found X" and the pop sci article says "the researchers found Y".
Could I explain this article to someone and have it make sense? If not, why not?
Is the article confusing correlation (these things happen together) with causation (one of these things causes the other)?
Pop sci articles, like other journalistic articles, are extremely subject to bias issues from the publication they're in. A lot of people tend to read pop sci articles as neutral, factual reporting, but they aren't! I mentioned EW's biases earlier -- the one I think is most relevant to how their article is written is a pervasive belief that if you just eat the right things in the right amounts you will be thin and healthy and stave off all kinds of problems. They close their article by mentioning that, although the study's authors are clear that this connection is unlikely to be causative, and that risk factors for low bone density and dementia have substantial overlap, readers should act like it might be causitive with diet and exercise choices that promote bone health. They were so excited to get to their point about fixing your diet that they didn't pay attention to the actual science they were reporting on. (Sidenote: actual scientific journal articles are supposed to be neutral, factual reporting. They also aren't actually that, but there are some measures in place around this to try to prevent the worst effects of bias.)
It's worth brushing up some basic math skills. You don't need to know a lot! Very basic information will help you better understand a lot of articles -- both ones that are accurate and well-written, and ones that are shoddy and should not have been published. I really like Larry Gonick's The Cartoon Guide to Statistics but if your grasp of percentages is shaky, it will be too advanced. A good option might be something like The I Hate Mathematics! Book, which is pretty old but really accessible, but there's probably some newer great ones out there that I just don't know about.
#science#pop sci#reading comprehension#how dare you say we piss on the poor#math#statistics#eating well#bad science communication#neurology#dementia#bone density
55 notes
¡
View notes
Text
Anyway, I just thought of something for my Housewife Vox AU.
One day, the 1950s internalized misogyny and homophobia gets to Vox, and he has a crisis about wearing dresses AND bottoming for a man and how those two things are related. Like, "Of COURSE I'm the one who takes it, I'm wearing a fucking dress! Why did I ever think that was a question!"
Just. Suddenly thinking that Alastor must think less of him for both of those things, and that everyone (ie Alastor and Rosie) who knows him are laughing behind his back about it, for whatever reason.
It just all gets to him at once one day, and he has an entire breakdown about it.
Alastor does his best to comfort him and tell him that wearing a dress and preferred sexual position aren't related at all, and that he would eviscerate anyone who ever dared to think of mocking him about either. "My dear, our delightful Rosie wears dresses, and none would say she is weak for it, and neither are you, darling!" Etc etc.
It barely works, but at least Vox stops crying.
What DOES work is that the next time Vox wants to be intimate, Alastor makes Vox wear a suit regardless of whatever he was wearing before. Vox is confused, but just goes with it.
And then Alastor puts on a dress and fucks Vox until he's crying for a whole 'nother reason, and afterwords asks Vox if he still believes that whatever he chooses to wear is demeaning or says anything about his sexual preferences.
(Thus, the swarmy manipulative businessman version of Vox is eventually born, just with less internalized shit from when he was alive).
(Alastor still generally doesn't wear dresses or skirts, but he will if Vox picks out an outfit and wants him to. But now Vox knows it's more of a personal preference with his clothing and nothing judgemental against him wanting to wear them).
#housewife vox au#anyway this happened bc the idea of Alastor in a dress is hot#and him being in a dress and fucking Vox is also hot#and then i was like#how does this man from the 1950s feel about wearing dresses and being the 'submissive ' partner and he flipped out#while Alastor is just there like darling neither of those things are related and i will eat anyone who dares to think or insult you
35 notes
¡
View notes
Text
Do you feel any kind of remorse for what you do..
#HOW DARE YOU#I SWEAR#Iâm crazy ignore me#IM GONNA EAT MY DRYWALL TF#WELL YOU DIDNT HEAR IT FROM ME#helluvaboss stolas#helluva boss blitzo#helluva boss season two#helluva boss season 2#helluva boss trailer
71 notes
¡
View notes
Text
I know it's le most tired trope ever, but, "Oh no, Person A cooked all this food for Person B, but Person B is already on their way out / not coming home until late / eating out with his hoe / whatever / so they let it all go to waste!" always gets to me. How DARE you let Person A's cooking go to waste!! She spent all this time on top of the stove for you!!! EAT HER FOOD >(
#It is definitely a result of being raised by my mom#she spent most of her younger years handling food insecurity#so she HATES to think of me going hungry#and she was very set on family meals#our food tastes also run quite different. so often in my childhood I'd say I wasn't hungry when I didn't like the food.#and she would ALWAYS insist: 'Are you not hungry or do you not want this? I'll make you something else.'#so now as an adult I'm always like.#'THEY MADE YOU FOOD. EAT THE FOOD. HOW DARE YOU!!'#'IT WAS MADE WITH LOVE'
53 notes
¡
View notes