#gay treasure island

[ahb-writes]

Book Review: 'Clash of Steel: A Treasure Island Remix'

Clash of Steel: A Treasure Island Remix by C.B. Lee

adventure

Asian fantasy

LGBTQIA

lesbian characters

mythology

pirates

queer books

romance

swashbuckling

ya fiction

My Review: 5 of 5 stars

At the farthest edge of what the westerners have historically branded "the opening of China," two young women discover the unmapped intersection of youth's uncultivated curiosity and the desperate proclivities of a dawdling adulthood. A CLASH OF STEEL begins painfully slow, but once all of the rightful pieces are in place, the novel's momentum churns forward with such unrelenting power that no amount of dramatic irony can outrun the book's satisfying conclusion.

Xiang's wistful gaze, from the rough mountains beyond her tiny river village, spy a curtain of distant ports and a mixed and matched fleet of merchant vessels. She lives in modest comfort, yes; and she has wont of little beyond the approval of her regularly absent mother, certainly; but what Xiang desires most is more. That is to say, the girl desires to stride the deck of a sea-worthy vessel, to taste and smell the vastness of a mercantile city a thousand times the size of her home tea shop, hear the myriad languages spoken by the myriad folks who sail the world's distant oceans. Xiang is an avid reader, but she wants to do more than read about adventure, she wants to experience it for herself (Xiang: "[W]ould I be satisfied merely listening to travelers' stories now that I've had a taste of the world?" page 273).

A chance trip to Canton, to visit her mother's center of business, enlightens Xiang to the possibility that she was born for more than being scolded by her tutor on lazy afternoons. Bandits running through alleys. Pirates and smugglers skulking the bay. Corrupt government officials absorbing bribes day-in and day-out. Trade for salt, fish, and more, are heavily tracked and regulated, but between the seams, the people of Canton, ephemeral, drift from one glimmering opportunity to the next, danger be damned.

The novel's opening act pivots grudgingly around the main character's misgivings for her simple, rural life, whereas the quickened pace of the book's later events makes for an effective contrast: life around narrow rivers and rice terraces versus life in the smoke-filled streets of a loud port city; life at a rural tea house with few visitors versus life among the raucous fools scratching for coin aboard patchwork ships. One has sympathy for readers who never made it past the first 80 pages.

A CLASH OF STEEL doesn't hit its pace until Xiang wields such opportunity by tagging along with her first new friend in ages, a pirate girl named Anh. Warm, brown skin. Wild hair. Talkative. Fearless.

Xiang's connection with Anh flares bright and hot, almost immediately, and the young woman is both enthralled and fearful of what that means. A CLASH OF STEEL nurtures and frames and scolds and builds back up Xiang and Anh's fledgling relationship, revealing, to those not previously aware, the author's skill in crafting queer characters worth believing in is nothing to worry about.

The lure of riches notwithstanding, boarding the Huyền Vũ and making for an island chain and a hidden hoard are the least of Xiang's troubles. After all, seeking to mend a fractured mother-daughter relationship by running away from home and pursuing a decades-old folktale thanks to an ancient, family relic? If that's not adventure, then what is?

A CLASH OF STEEL is a fun read for several reasons. Some such reasons pair well with the novel's reflection upon a long-eroded Age of Exploration. Others more to do with the book's structural arrangement and clever narrative positioning. What is the relationship between humanity and nature? What is humanity's relationship to itself when assimilation is believed inevitable? Why is the bond between government and the individual so heavily strained (stained) by greed? Relatedly, if there is no room for good people to conduct legitimate business, then does that mean freedom is only guaranteed through means of illegitimate business? (Xiang: "Who is more the thief: the government that preys on its people, or those who must become thieves in order to survive?" page 241)

Xiang stumbles into these questions and more while slowly transitioning from pampered countryside waif into a scraggly but sprightly shipmate with salt in her hair and a few splinters in her heels. The girl soon learns that an adventurous life is equally sought and earned.

Xiang's greatest education comes not from her trusted tutor, Master Feng Zhanli, who loves her like a daughter and protects her from the wrath of the girl's absent mother. Instead, Xiang learns kindness from the garrulous Captain Hoa Ngọc Hạnh; she learns steadfastness from shipmate Maheer, gentle and devout but indiscriminating; and she learns feminine ferocity from Ling Shan, a former courtier in the Forbidden City, who is now a skilled swordfighter whose tongue is a pit of vipers.

The book builds its tale of the modern imaginary on this foundation of furtive exploration. Readers of fairytales and folklore will recognize the author's exquisite use of a call to purpose, a lure from the quotidian, the foreshadowing of disappointment, the shifting standard for filial piety, and the introduction and subsequent destruction of a source of intrepid enlightenment. Tales of legendary pirate commanders? Stories about playful and distant relatives who only tease their benevolence? A CLASH OF STEEL is about leaving home on a treasure hunt, but it is also about unburying friendship and camaraderie from the embers of a discomfited life nobody truly asked for (Xiang: "I'm tired of others deciding my story for me," page 352).

❯ ❯ Book Reviews || ahb writes on Good Reads

[batwynn]

Because we’re good.

(A patron request)

[elliottswaterlilies]

𝐈'𝐌 𝐆𝐑𝐄𝐀𝐓𝐄𝐑 𝐓𝐇𝐀𝐍 𝐘𝐎𝐔'𝐋𝐋 𝐄𝐕𝐄𝐑 𝐁𝐄.

[kloppenheimer]

technically black sails is just treasure island fan fiction and clearly it was written by a gay 17 year old girl

[queeringclassiclit]

John Silver & Captain Flint

from Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stevenson (1883)

[tragonn]

nate stetson, treasure island media

[funtimespringscare101]

@chaosverse-mainblog @misterah13 I Headcanon that Jake and Henry are those two with the vibes of “Are they gay?” (Probably not) and everyone else senses it. They are just close friends. But I thought that it would be funny.

Also, I officially have made the Oswald Corruptus in GL2, which was so much fun to figure out! The size difference may not be finalized yet but I see the Oswald Corruptus to be a little bit taller than the average toon!

I also got the idea of the potential Henry x Jake ship from @de4thcr0wey666 (whose art fucking rocks btw), inclined to say, I think they hooked me.

[fisheito]

Lol angst ? about nukani , my super unserious gayporngacha game? Can't be that bad

(10k words later into a fic) Ooohh.ohhh it was a mistake. I should not have read this hahahahahahahgyrk *choking sounds*

[scythevampire]

Got Treasure Island brainrot rn so here’s a drawing of George Merry and Fionn :)

[boatmediatourney]

i know the pirate fandom is a little raw right now but i got the idea in the shower to start a new tournament for the best boat media

my ideas so far (and feel free to suggest more!) are as follows:

1899

Black Sails

Hornblower 

Master and Commander

Muppet Treasure Island

Our Flag Means Death

Pirates of the Caribbean 

The North Water

The Terror

Titanic 

Treasure Planet

[tautechart]

Dr. Livesy, from the Soviet Treasure Island movie.

Originally posted on Twitter on September 4th 2022

[aravinus]

OUR FLAG MEANS TREASURE ISLAND

I made my first peice of fanart ever !!!! I haven’t ever really done digital art so the learning curve was INSANE. But here is my boy Izzy and my boy Long John Silver (Tim Curry) from Treasure Island!

It’s for my upcoming fic that I will soon write a little intro about !!!

[artisticallyaroacecrickett]

I started rereading Treasure Island this week and I was not expecting to decide that Doctor Livesey and Squire Trelawney are boyfriends but that's 100% what happened and I'm here for it

[dis-harmony]

Treasure Island sexuality headcanons!

Jim Hawkins is trans and gay

Dr. Livesey is pansexual or bisexual

Captain Smollett is gay

Squire Trelawney is asexual

Long John Silver is trans

Blind Pew is non-binary

Black Dog is heterosexual

[slutty-sweater-vest]

It's rare that I'm checking out a current, active fandom on Tumblr, so I don't usually see fandom doing the fandom thing. But right now, I'm overwhelmed at OPLA fandom going gaga, yet again, for the Skinny White Twink. You have a Broody Sword Man, and y'all are going gaga for the clown? Why am I not surprised. 30-damn-years in fandom, and the fans are ALWAYS going to go for the skinny white twink.