#file:peaches | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

janmisali · 8 months ago

Text

Super Mario Bracket: HONORABLE MENTIONS

so then! now that round one is wrapped up and the first batch of round two's polls have been posted, (note: tumblr glitched and posted this too early so that's not in fact true yet as of when this is being posted) now's a good time to go through some of the characters from the preliminary nomination process that didn't make the cut!

the ones that barely didn't make it

while every character with at least six nominations made it into the bracket (with the exception of four ineligible "characters"), only the "first" few characters with five nominations (with the tie-breaking order decided by who had their first nominations earliest) made it in. so, here are all the characters that got five nominations that aren't in the bracket, in order of when they were first nominated (there's quite a few!):

Talking Flower, from Super Mario Bros. Wonder

Antasma, from Dream Team

Big Daddy of Blooper-surfing, from Super Mario Sunshine

Thwomp, from Super Mario Bros. 3

Koopa Troopa, from Super Mario Bros.

Big Top, from Mario Party 8 (I don't know why the Super Mario Wiki has MC Ballyhoo and Big Top as two separate articles. Big Top is MC Ballyhoo's hat)

Thwimp, from Super Mario World

Joan of Arc, from Mario's Time Machine

Bouldergeist, from Super Mario Galaxy

Shakespeare, from Mario's Time Machine

Bob-omb, from Doki Doki Panic / Super Mario USA

Reznor, from Super Mario World

Julius Caesar, from Mario's Time Machine

Diddy Kong, from Donkey Kong Country

Baby Luma, from Super Mario Galaxy

Eggman Nega, from Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Winter Games

Cosmic Mario, from Super Mario Galaxy

Goombette, from Super Mario Odyssey

Lakitu (Mario Kart referee), from Super Mario Kart

Lumalee, from Super Mario Galaxy

Watt, from Paper Mario

Pyoro, from Mega Microgame$!

Johnny, from Super Mario RPG

Inspector Gadget, from Super Show!

Lakitu, from Super Mario Bros.

Yamamura, from Super Mario Maker

Princess Shroob, from Partners in Time

Larry Koopa, from Super Mario Bros. 3

Mad Piano, from Super Mario 64

Bowsette

a lot of people wanted to nominate Bowsette, but since she doesn't have a Super Mario Wiki article she is not eligible, and in fact the nomination form mechanically prevented people from submitting a nomination without providing a Super Mario Wiki link. however, if I had counted nominations based on what conceptual character people were trying to nominate instead of just looking at the provided Super Mario Wiki article, Bowsette would have made it into the top 128, and I would have had to exclude her manually.

the nominations that mentioned Bowsette by name consisted of:

one nomination for Bowser

three nominations for Peachette

one nomination for Undodog, inexplicably

three nominations for Bowletta

three nominations for List of references on the Internet, the actual Super Mario Wiki article that covers Bowsette (among other topics)

one nomination for the Super Crown

one nomination for File:Peach Bowser Concept TAoSMO.jpg

technicalities

as you might have noticed from the 128 characters that did make it into the bracket, a lot of nominations were for subjects that, under some technicality, qualify as a "Mario character". disappointingly, the technicalities that didn't make it into the bracket were, generally speaking, really boring. the main types of not-really-Mario-characters people nominated were:

crossover characters, Sonic characters especially

real-ass people. I'm pretty sure every single person in the Super Mario Wiki's Category:People was nominated at least once. after making a poll about it, I decided that real people are only eligible if they appear in some piece of official Mario media as a fictional version of themself, so real people with entirely nonfictional relevance to Mario are disqualified

non-characters. none of the specific nominations of this type that didn't make it into the bracket are really worth highlighting; it's just random stuff that happens to have a Super Mario Wiki article

typographic characters, which were disappointingly uncommon. Letter (Super Mario Odyssey) only got one nomination!

the Super Mario Wiki's Mario Awards polls (concurrent)

at the time of writing, votes are open for the Super Mario Wiki's 2023 Mario Awards. here's how many nominations each character in their "favorite character" polls got for this bracket!

Favorite Major Character

Luigi: 104

Rosalina: 101

Waluigi: 90

Princess Daisy: 81

Yoshi: 71

Mario: 56

Wario: 45

Bowser: 45

Toadette: 31

Princess Peach: 27

Toad: 21