#cynical critics
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Made another one
#muse arg#don't feed the muse#dftm#anthony williams#mark mayhew#cynical critics#the cynical critics#scott pilgrim edit#scott pilgrim artstyle#scott pilgrim comic#ramona bynes#screenshot edit#Kinda like this more than the other one#the changes in the text are kinda odd tho-
30 notes
·
View notes
Text
Metaphor: reFantazio really stares you dead in the eye and says 'democracy is not some magical system that ensures moral good. Even if you could take away all the barriers and practical difficulties, even if you could guarantee beyond a shadow of a doubt that the entire nation voted, and the vote could not be tampered with, and that it was a genuine expression of their true belief of who was most fit to rule with no other concerns taken into consideration- that still would not keep people from elevating strongmen and demagogues and tyrants. Their is no promise that the 'will of the people' will always be the most moral, the most practical, or the most wise choice. People are short sighted and easily swayed and ruled by their biases and instincts, and more then that they often lack the time energy and understanding to make the most wise choice.'
And then as you are staring into the black void of hopelessness it keeps going and says 'And that's okay. People have lived beneath unjust, imperfect systems since the dawn of civilization. All these things, from Republics, to Theocracies, to Monarchies, to Dictatorships- they are all human creations and so reflect human flaws. It's okay. It doesn't mean you stop living, stop helping other people, stop trying to do the best for those you care for. It doesn't absolve you of your duties and responsibilities to others. Dream of a better world, and do what you can for the people you can and you might just make the world a better place, the same way everyone throughout history has- one day a time, and one choice after another.'
#m:rf#m:rf meta#metaphor: refantazio#metaphor refantazio#I am having A Lot Of Feelings About This Game#Beating it post election was deeply deeply cathadric and also weirdly freeing#it hit at the exact time I needed it most#it's a scathing criticism of the idea of democracy#without being cynical or hopeless about it#and that helped me work through my feelings hopelessness and cynicism#real life stuff#us politics
246 notes
·
View notes
Text
i think it is very silly to react to dropout's response like "why were people mad, you know the cast and crew are pro palestine" yeah exactly and if they weren't i don't think attempting to push a petition/boycott to them about this would do anything. the result of them acknowledging this was a net good. twenty thousand dollars
#dropout#this happened with critical role also#where people pushed the company from silence (apart from a few cast members liking ceasefire posts)#to making a 50k donation from the cr foundation#like yes online activism isn't everything but you can't deny the material good that you can achieve#by holding companies that pride themselves as being progressive to their standard that they set#do i think there were people in that crowd who were being overly cynical abt dropout's views. sure#like idt they deleted their discord so it would be harder to get feedback to them for one.#idt the time they took to make the statement was out of maliciousness#but having concerns abt people being on their shows who have expressed harmful views b4#is like. a perfectly valid thing to be concerned about.#dropout is a COMPANY it is not your FRIEND if you want to praise them for being progressive then hold them to that#because you are the audience it is catering to!
123 notes
·
View notes
Text
singapore was CRAZY bc wdym carlando held off a two-pronged mercedes war machine on brand new mediums, hungry for blood, hunting them down, nipping at their heels, with nothing but 42-lap-old hards and the good old power of friendship??!
this is cinema. that is main character behavior.
#maybe the pastel ponies were right#friendship really is magic#also you better never let cynical haters criticize your favorite media for using the power of love in climactic moments again#‘unrealistic’ ‘convenient’ ‘plot device’ if two real-life racecar drivers can pull it off so can your fictional fave#checkmate#formula 1#singapore gp 2023#carlando#lando norris#carlos sainz
737 notes
·
View notes
Text
I really hope Rick and Morty as a series will finally move on from portraying Rick's love for Morty / his family as this special, redemptive trait that Morty just needs to open his eyes to. Or portraying it as something Rick just needs to be emotionally honest about, finally admit in a grand gesture, and then everything will be healthy and resolved.
Two things can be equally true: Rick can sincerely care about Morty, deeply enough to be tender with him, showing gestures of affection, being protective of him, being truly proud of him... and can also constantly let Morty down, put him in mortal danger, make Morty feel responsible for his emotional health, treat him awfully and in manipulative controlling ways, and not be there for him when it matters most. His love is real, but is also a fickle thing that Morty cannot always rely on. That uneven dolling out of affection is exactly what entrenches the abuse and damages Morty further. Even now that Rick is slowly improving as a person, his simultaneous love and unreliability persists in milder ways, and the long pattern of abuse leaves deep scars on his grandson.
In my opinion, it makes perfect sense for Morty to see Rick's care for him as this unreliable, dangerous, and potentially non-existent thing, but also to paradoxically crave it nonetheless. Every time he lets his guard down and starts to trust Rick too much, he's been kicked in the nuts for it to varying extents-- even recently. I don't think he actually believes Rick cares nothing for him, but he's been trapped in this cycle of good and bad for so long that his self-worth is eroded and wholly defined by his grandpa's conditional affection, and he's scared of and dependent on it simultaneously. Even if Rick became truly healthy and openly caring from now on, that won't change how he's screwed up Morty with his behavior.
The series isn't going to make any meaningful progress if the writers keeps cycling around the superficial "does Rick care? does Morty know how deeply Rick cares?" question that they've asked since Season 1, instead of progressing to more meaningful, realistic questions about what Rick's love even means after all the past seasons of codependent abuse, and how much it should be worth to Morty in the end. (Ideally, much, much less than it's worth now.)
Yes, Rick cares. Yes, he loves his family deeply. But as with many forms of abuse, that's part of the problem.
#rick and morty#rick sanchez#morty smith#character analysis#slightly rnm critical ig because my cynicism towards the recent seasons' writing lol#they could take this a good direction though if they decided to be consistent and honest about the main duo's dynamic#as well as Rick's direct culpability in perpetuating it that has yet to be seriously confronted#bit of a longshot though#at least the season 7 finale fed me crumbs of it being a possibility#this series likes teasing heavier topics but being mediocre at the follow-up. so we'll see
373 notes
·
View notes
Note
You're the only person i follow who posts about thomas sanders
And i only watch him for sanders sides, i'm not really in the fsndom online, so i guess you are the best person to ask this
Why does thomas take so long to upload new sander sides?
ten questions scientists still can't answer, anon
#to expand beyond the cynicism#idk when you joined the fandom but i was there in like The Era. 2017. virgil's name reveal. i was 14 & Unwell#wrote a lot of fic (and i mean a Lot of fic) & was in the Wattpad Scene of it all#(not to do all the fandom hierarchy popularity bullshit but if anyone's wondering why i have 1500 followers on wattpad that's why)#anyways. 5 or so years go by. fans get older. content (or at least good canon content) is few & far between#i move on. move to ao3. move to tumblr & other fandoms#idk how i found the crit tag but it's a good place as an 'ex-fander' so to speak to vent frustrations#you'll find a lot of stuff in the tag on your question anon#basically my take is thomas wants all the money from the series & merch & patreon without actually putting in the work#as he's lost passion for the series but has hyped it up way way too long to back out now#idk he's kind of a shit person from what i've seen though again there's more elequent posts on it than this tag dump#i'll leave the appropriate tags below#ts crit#ts critical#ts criticism#asks
59 notes
·
View notes
Text
d
DON’T FEED THE MUSE ART WITH THE CYNICAL CRITICS,,,!!!!!!!
[art under the cut because it has bright colors/eyestrain]
Hey wait a minute are those lyrics from a Lemon Demon Song called Spiral of A—FUCKING DIES
#don't worry ya'll everything is FINE#Mark is just having a crisis :3#don't feed the muse#dftm#don’t feed the muse#the cynical critic#happy meat farms#muse arg#mark mayhew#antonio geist#the cynical critics#cynical critics#cynical critic
64 notes
·
View notes
Text
Bro.. Bro it’s SATIRE it’s SATIRE BRO
#dont feed the muse#dftm fanart#dftm jared#dftm#happy meat farms#hmf jared#hmf#jared warrenheim#Jared Warrenheim fanart#The muse arg#muse arg#this place is not happy#alex bale#Cynical Critic
86 notes
·
View notes
Text
seeing the typical jelloapocalypse defenders "oh my god you guys are being so sensitive it's just satire" and like
first of all, you keep using that word. it doesn't mean what you think it means
second, no it fucking isn't - satire is funny. he's not. satire is poking fun and stretching the truth for laughs, any fucking discussion he's had about any of the stupid videos he's made makes it very clear he believes every fucking stupid remark he's making and unsubtly hiding behind Schrodinger's Douchebag using that stupid fucking voice he does (which is also the only joke he knows how to make and it was funnier in Battleblock Theater, the game he stole it from). on top of that, he's going beyond 'satire' by making parasocial attacks on the creatives involved because he's a bitter shithead who's jealous that other people are successful when he isn't because his overinflated ego has convinced him he's the smartest, most talented and specialest creative on the planet and everyone else is doing it wrong, an attitude that got him blacklisted from two studios this year and is likely the reason he's gone back to a series he'd previously made a big stink about not wanting to do anymore because no one cares about any of the other garbage he's made
#there's no 'good faith' when you're randomly making character attacks on people you don't know with zero backing#hbomb does the exact same shit - in his rwb/y review he relentlessly dogs on Miles and Kerry for no other reason than to make them look bad#it's beyond just criticism of creators for how they handle the works they make - it's spurious value judgments on people they do not know#because of some parasocial obsession they have with needing to prove they're better than them#and both of them also make similarly spurious value judgments on the audiences of the media they hate on#it's all cynical bitter and mean-spirited bad faith whining and i'm sick of that getting a free pass
30 notes
·
View notes
Text
I feel like the narrative wants Neve to be this cold ruthless pragmatist who is just here to do a job but is completely hamstrung at every turn by its own refusal to allow her to be even slightly mean. Well I think she should kill someone
#Datv critical#<- I guess?#Dav chatter#I like her as a character but my god does she need more teeth both for the sake of her own character and for the narrative as a whole#Let! Her! Be! Mean! Let! Her! Be! Ruthless!#Heart of gold under a cynical exterior would work better if her cynical exterior were more... Well... Cynical#Knowing she was supposed to be calpernia I can see all the edges they smoothed over#Well unsmooth them! Make her meaner!
33 notes
·
View notes
Text
GDHDJSGDJDHSH FINALLY HE HAS SUCCUMBED TO YOUR GORGEOUS ART STYLE AAAHHGH🤩🤩🤩💕💕💕💕
guess who
#HE'S SO AHHH#I LOVE HIM SO MUCH💕💕#HE'S BEAUTIFUL😍#beautiful art :3#muse arg#dont feed the muse#muse arg fanart#happy meat farms#don't feed the muse#spongebob theory arg#alex bale#anthony williams#cynical critics#cynical critic#the cynical critic#the cynical critics
11 notes
·
View notes
Text
If the unlisted Cynical Critics videos where Anthony is in them where actual watchable videos it would have been cool and interesting as fuck . But sadly Alex was allergic to put any Anthony related ...sigh...😔
#muse arg#don't feed the muse#dftm#alex bale#anthony williams#the cynical critics#cynical critics#the cynical critic#Alex prob forgot who Anthony was#UUughhghg it woukd have been so cool to see how Anthony and Mark interacted and how the Cynical Critic videos were before the muse AGHH#Anthony was such a wasted character that it almost makes me mad and every time I think sbout his missed potential I tear up#Anthony my beloved you deserve justice
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
I think the spoilers I saw for Veilguard has solidified my decision to never play the game. What a slap to the face. Does Bioware even like or respect fans? I was willing to play it in a couple of years after the hype and outrage has died down and after my own feelings about their lack of respect for and dare I say, laziness about player choices in previous games (they were able to handle this well ten years ago but now it’s too hard for them according to defenders) But seeing what they did to previous regions in the previous games and effectively what it did to beloved characters in those regions (ineffective, incompetent, or now irrelevant) is too much for me. Forget it. I’ll look for a different series to love and content myself with three Dragon Age games.
#anti bioware#anti veilguard#bioware critical#veilguard critical#sorry it sucks that effectively nothing you did mattered the characters you loved are irrelevant and they only want new fans now#what a cynical end to a beloved series
30 notes
·
View notes
Text
me when the boy savior the boy saved everyone: 🤯🤯🤯
#me when the boy savior loops time over and over and over to keep the girl he hates and loves and grieves and forgives from killing herself#me when the boy savior risks everything and pushes time beyond its limit as the entire city sits paralyzed around him so he can save them#me when the boy savior who serves as an atlas figure and monolith for all that has happened in zaun + to jinx and has harbored so much#jaded anger as he’s yearned and grieved for all that could have been while pushing himself to fight for better things finally gets to fix#part of what went wrong (saving jinx and choosing to see her as someone who can change Again <- feeling that is part of what Made him so#cynical in the first place bc his friend was Gone and how is a kid supposed to grapple w that while still trying to be a beacon of hope??)#and solidify himself as the last and only hope in the end (which is what he always was and always was going to be) <333#my arcane s2 criticisms are glaring but i still have ekko goggles on#ah shit i just remembered the firelights were snubbed in favor of the half baked jinx revolutionaries. damn.#like don’t we remember why he was the boy savior in the first place. ah fuck. damn.#nvm i can’t think about it i’m going to get mad 😭#anyways.txt#arcane spoilers
22 notes
·
View notes
Text
i keep complaining and vagueing, but man i see so much stupid bad faith shit here recently & i have to let it out somewhere or it will eat my insides otherwise.
i honestly wonder why some of you saying how you don't have enough faith that writers put those things in there on purpose are even playing those games to begin with? If you consider creators of those things stupid and incapable... why even waste your time engaging with them?
like. you are literally holding yourself back from engaging with the story with your own preconceived notion that the people working on it can't do their jobs.
i don't say it's perfect and there is no room to critique writing... there always is. like all the things ever it was created by people and people are flawed so the things they create often reflect those flaws. but. some of you are clearly not even giving them or their creation a chance...
#like. please try exercise some better faith. it really helps to see the good things...#this cynicism will fucking kill you guys.#and if not you then sure your ability to enjoy things.#blah blah text post#fandom critical#lady whines#i feel like i need a cigarette and i don't even smoke
27 notes
·
View notes
Text
Six of Crows- Chapter 26 (Leigh Bardugo)
I should make it a series- It's fascinating how I have yet to encounter enraged fans demanding Kaz to be held responsible for his reckless and selfish disregard of the people relying on him.
#Grishaverse#SoC Chapter 26#Kaz Brekker#Dirtyhands#grishanalyticritical#Six of Crows#Six of Crows duology#V#books#quotes#Leigh Bardugo#more optimistic guess:#Is it because revenge is so relatable?#cynical one:#Highly readable story of cool young criminals on a heist doesn't exactly invite critical approach to the text#and nothing bad happens in the end#so all's forgiven even if anyone notices.#Unlike in case of a prejudiced view on desperate erring revolutionary#responsible for hundreds of never introduced outcasts.#Merely pointing out the double standards.
21 notes
·
View notes