#but for the entire premise of a book?
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
This is probably also why so many booktok/bookstagram-famous books are (imo as an avid „actual“ reader) shitty? As in ‚books written by 13 year olds on Wattpad make more sense and are written better‘-shitty.
I‘m not going bash people for liking to read or fantasise about toxic relationships, you do you. I don‘t like it, so I don‘t read it.
But I have no idea how people could stick around for an entire book of objectively bad & inconsistent writing and like it, without doing this parapgraph skipping/ only reading dialogue thing (aka not actually reading).
Do they know that reading is not mandatory? Nobody is forcing them to read?
#The horrifying alternative would be that people unironically love reading sentences like „we laughed at our son‘s big balls“#and being perfectly fine with an inconsistent ‚chonic illnes‘ (that the author also has) only popping up when it makes the mc interesting#but not when it would actually negatively affect her#Suspension of disbelif is one thing.#but for the entire premise of a book?#It also feels like most of the MCs in these books are flatter than week-old soda & have to be Very Special Princesses not by their own right#but because She‘s The Universe‘s Favourite Princess. Usually there is boting special about her skillset or ambition.#she‘s just born bettter than everyone else.#(eg getting 2 fated dragon instead of 1 like a normie‚ being turned into a fae even if that doesn‘t make sense)#And while I‘m usually against gatekeeping/ calling people ‚poser‘#this seems like a good time to gatekeep and call people poser.#especially when they‘re treating bookishness like an aestetic.
40K notes
·
View notes
Text
not to ramble about iwtv but i think a lot of people who balk at the unsavory parts of gothic fiction are people who have either 1) never truly had to face an onslaught of the macabre in their own life 2) have not actually sat with the discomfort of the darker parts of existence or simply not learned or had to learn how to process truly twisted emotions within themselves. and i bring this up in relation to iwtv because i see a lot of people pointing out 'problematic' parts of the book or bemoaning which ships are more or less toxic. and it's like it's a cow farm there's gonna be cows on the cow farm.
yeah anne rice wrote some weird shit and some of it is definitely unnecessary, most of those elements were corrected in the show. but a lot of it is just gothic fiction. you don't get to have sexy vampires, romanticism and tortured yearning without the inappropriate attachments, the true face of grief and the blurred lines between violence and eroticism which has evoked great interest in humans for centuries.
#iwtv#interview with the vampire#lestat de lioncourt#louis de pointe du lac#claudia de pointe du lac#claudia de lioncourt#i saw a lot of people on tiktok complaining about how claudia is described in the books#and when i started reading i expected something way worse#and it was like...nothing#it's uncomfortable at points but that is...the enTIRE PREMISE#she's not supposed to exist like that#they trapped an eternal soul in an unfinished body and it's wrong and inappropriate#but alSO i think some ppl just have lost understanding for descriptive language in gothic text#bc modern publishing often pushes for more basic sentence structures and less flowery prose#so when ppl read shit that does have the more classic style and is VERY descriptive w strong words they're like whAt#and it's like bro it's poetic u gotta be less literal
175 notes
·
View notes
Text
can frostpaw redeem a clan that has fallen from the holy path and followed a wicked non-believer?? can she show them the light of god starclan again?? find out in the least christian arc so far of warriors
#asc spoilers#wind spoilers#im sorry. im sooo annoyed#it's bad enough the entire book's conflict premise sucks shit. but this is the path we're going? okay.
59 notes
·
View notes
Text
Comic panels that are referenced in (or just remind me of) the movie
#in vaguely chronological order#for the movie that is#nimona#I bing read the book after watching the movie and they’re both good but they’re so different#it caught me off guard when there was exact dialogue because the general premise is almost entirely inverted#but I love the movie and am 1000% down with all the creative liberties#but I’m not an og so idk#good stuff tho
382 notes
·
View notes
Text
should i start Never Let Me Go the series or should i not go through that rabbit hole yet
#never let me go the series#tagging it like this cause ive also read and watched nlmg the book/movie and it's something else entirely#would recomend it tho#but yeah im so obsessed with pondphuwins acting#like their chemistry??? top tier#and the premise of nlmg the series sounds so good#but We Are the series isn't done yet#and im not done obsessing over it#i wanna watch smth new tho#AHKSHSKA#anyway#what do you guys think#pondphuwin#pond naravit#phuwin#We Are the series#We Are#phuwin tangsakyuen
21 notes
·
View notes
Text
Looking at my old bendy posts is so sad. I used to post dissections of the story and fun things in it, I'd still like to do that but Mike sucks out so much of my energy but I also constantly feel the need to post about whatever dumb shit he says so I can explain to people why it's bad and shouldn't be supportive. On his youtube post a ton of people are being so kind to him and I'm just baffled. This rude asshole who has been nothing but bigoted towards his fans who want to see more diversity gets to be seen as some massive victim because HE said some dumb shit and people didn't like it? What about the young queers who were devastated to find out they'd never be represented in Bendy? What about the people of color who had to witness the graphic novel be filled with almost nothing but white people, with the only canonical person of color now being a book-exclusive [aka Non-Canon] character? Why do they matter so little to so many people? Why do the feelings of Mike, who has literally earned every bit of hate he's ever gotten, matter more than those of the people he's hurt? Why do I have to be the one who constantly updates tumblr on the new stupid shit he's saying no matter how tired and upset it makes me to have to constantly talk about the awful things he constantly says and then gets away with.
I miss being able to talk positively about Bendy, when most of my posts were just talking about cool things I thought about from the franchise. But being honest, I don't think I can ever go back to that time either. With stuff like the bendy books being no longer canon when they contain the best writing in the entire franchise and the way Mike shits himself at any critique he gets... I just can't speak positively of Bendy without some sort of "But..." Anymore, this franchise just fucking sucks currently.
I could make the posts I wanted to about stuff like how much I love Norman but I don't like Game Norman cause he lacks the interesting bits the books added and Book Norman has an awful design now thanks to these assholes! I could make all the posts I had wanted to about BATDR and its story, but I don't like to speak positively of the games anymore cause I don't want people to support them! I could make more posts on the books but then I'll be reminded that all this great writing Kress did, the bendy devs are completely ungrateful for! I literally can't speak purely nice of this franchise anymore cause at every turn I'm faced now with just how much it's been ruined and how much of that happened recently. I miss being able to make a causal nice post about Bendy but now I feel I can't do so without it being misleading or not the full story, Mike has tainted this fucking franchise with his presence and the fact Meatly lets him speak for both of them without stopping him or challenging him makes me assume he thinks the same way Mike does. Ughhhhhhhhhh
#ramblez#sorry there's not really a point to this post its just me rambling and being angry n sad lmao#Im not this heartbroken over not being able to make posts like I used to I have other things I should focus on more anyways#but it still sucks looking back at that norman n henry post I made n knowing it kinda falls apart bc literally the best and most interestin#part of it was dissecting how norman spoke of henry in the books and now theyre not canon anymore#I literally couldnt make that post as wholesome as it used to be now bc doing so would be misleading#thats how far gone this franchise is lmao#anyways thats it for now Ill prolly contunie to make nothing but bendy sucks and heres why posts until the end of time now sorry but its#mikes fault far as Im concerned#just you guys wait for me to talk about why the cage is gonna be bad cause Im gonna rip that entire games premise a new one n explain why#it literally has to be underwhelming or doesnt make sense yippeeee
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
rewatched flatland 2007 last night. what was i talking about that this movie was a 1:1 adaptation of the book. the movie took so many creative liberties. but i guess they were good creative liberties that suited the main themes and ideas. but they were still so many creative liberties lmfao
#basically the entire second half is its own original plot only based on the premise of flatland#anyway i was just recommended the 1965 short animated film of flatland and this one is ACTUALLY far more accurate to the book#the book is only like 100 pgs like its so short and so yknow an 11 minute short film suits it far more#than a 90 minute feature length film#so yknow. of course the 2007 flatland had to fill in so much screentime#and by god they filled it in. lol. i still love it so much#brot posts
9 notes
·
View notes
Note
i would love to hear about the scarlet welly boots and/or lesbian art heist
Scarlet Welly Boots was inspired by The Amazing Devil's "Welly Boots," with the premise being an epistolary of "letters" from Cosette to a deceased Jean Valjean keeping him appraised of things in her life and asking him the questions she never got the chance to ask. The story would follow her through the pitfalls of adulthood without a parent figure there to guide and her trials and struggles as she figures out who she is and makes peace with everything that happened.
Dear Dad,
I had my driving exam today. I passed! I’m so excited, but it’s weird, because it doesn’t seem like a big deal to anyone else.
You’re dead now, so it feels petty and annoying to blame my current failings on you, but apparently most students in the US start receiving instruction from their parents from 16, if not before. I know we took public transit and walked when we could, but we had a car — we had my car, even. It never occurred to you to talk me through the things you were doing?
It's a premise I really wanna revisit and make work, but at the time I was deeply unhappy with how it was panning out and decided I would need to read more and grow as a writer before I was ready to handle it the way I wanted.
---
Lesbian Art Heist had its first draft around 80% finished before I noticed a MASSIVE plothole that would require a total rewrite to correct for. I'd been writing it for a fic exchange (despite wanting to write the base premise since I first encountered it), and with the deadline looming I ended up abandoning it and drafting up Favour instead.
The Metropolitan Museum of Art is a fucking nightmare to smuggle things into for the same reason it’s a nightmare to steal things out of: the place is a glorified vault. When her father had organized the team to steal Degas’s Little Dancer of Fourteen Years, ninety percent of the plan had been causing enough confusion that Montparnasse and Claquesous could move the damned thing out to the main gallery and get it through a sky window without drawing too much attention. In the chaos, Éponine had managed to get Gueulemer to unwittingly help her steal a New Kingdom Egyptian collar from storage that, with any luck, won’t be missed for several more months, and, much more regrettably and almost as an afterthought, one of the Benin Artifacts from where archivists had already packed it up.
Her ears still ring from the phantom pain of Cosette’s anguish that Éponine hadn’t known that the Benin Kingdom was not located in the modern day country of Benin. Look, if six weeks of standing around in the Exhibition Room with them hadn’t told her this, maybe it’s the fault of the exhibit.
Her one saving grace in all of this, Éponine thinks as she takes the now-familiar route up the stairs to where an exhibit on 20th century American jewelry has now replaced the Benin Artifacts, is that they don’t seem to realize yet that they’re missing one of their artifacts. It had, of course, been the logic in the last-second swipe: already weighed, measured, and repackaged, no one would know to miss it until the artifacts were already on the next leg of their global tour, at which point museums would be pointing fingers at the movers rather than assuming it had never been there to start.
‘Germany only finally returned them four years ago!’ Damn, maybe not-Benin shouldn’t have been loaning them out so soon then.
‘You have to return it.’ Éponine thinks the fuck not.
(The plothole had to do with underground tunnels, I'm still Big Mad about it.)
#could I have disregarded real life and gone ahead doing whatever I damned well pleased?#literally No#this was important#answers and shitposts#cxndles#shitposting sometimes writes#thank you for the asks!#I have read uhhhhhh almost one hundred books in 2024#so I might finally be ready to reattempt Welly Boots?#but now I'm out of practice with actually writing stuff and that'll be prosey as FUCK#the words MATTER SO MUCH for a premise like that#I'll need to ... brood first#(oh but also Éponine and Cosette aren't even dating yet in the second one)#(they met at the exhibit and this was Éponine's cringefail way of flirting)#(I had to plot out the entire pre-fic before I could write the main fic)#(FUCKING PLOTHOLES)#the benin kingdom was in modern Nigeria btw
6 notes
·
View notes
Text
:v my friend really wanted me to read this gay cultivation book and like.... it's fine.
but i also CANNOT stand the blatant and petty sexism. it's unreal. it's so much so that it's detracting from my enjoyment.
#like ik the entire premise of this particular book is to shit on the author (long story)#and it's also parodying the entire genre itself. but still. BUT STILL.#uhg
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
my favorite character in the nancy drew files series is (still) nancy's tingle
#if you even care but the tingle DOES come back in the passport to romance trilogy#because the entire premise of those books is 'it's okay to cheat on your boyfriend if you're mad at him/in europe'#these books are hilarious but not on purpose
3 notes
·
View notes
Text
Do you ever read a post online where someone complains about how "IDW never talks about this [idea/character/plot/theme]" and you just think to yourself... this person hasn't read anything besides MTMTE have they?
Really sad when you see people complaining "the story never talked about this!" and act angry about it as if it's some oppressive flaw that the writer (JRO) was evil for never talking about but it's like. Bud if you just read exRID/OP or maybe Windblade/TAAO you would have read plenty about that.
The two worst ones I can think of off the top of my head are "Optimus is always treated like a saint, I hate how he gets away with everything just because he's a Prime" (wrong, read literally anything Barber writes) and "the Decepticons never get a sympathetic perspective, they're always just villains and the narrative is totally just treating them as if being revolutionaries makes them evil" (wrong, read several side stories that Barber wrote). Like literally the moral of the story is just "read something besides MTMTE."
And I'm not complaining about people who are just curious or don't know. I'm talking specifically about people who complain, or say MTMTE is bad, or generally act as if JRO's writing/MTMTE/LL represents the entirety of IDW1 and basically act like, if JRO didn't write it it doesn't exist and clearly since he didn't write it that means no one else did. Like please I'm begging you to read the other less popular but still good series in IDW1 and you'll find multiple stories/ideas that they tell that MTMTE/LL doesn't.
#also it's just funny to me that mtmte/ll readers will complain about there being no decepticons#my brother in christ you are reading the story about autobots in an autobot ship going on an autobot adventure#like. the entire premise is that it's a ship full of autobots and a few other random people they pick up#why are you reading the autobot story and getting mad it's mostly about autobots. this is the TF idw equivalent of 'read another book'#also don't complain about how the story never talked about xyz thing when you've only read one single series#squiggposting#granted i don't think JRO and his work are without flaw but like#idk i think there's just something about how like. just bc JRO didn't write it doesn't mean you can't find it elsewhere in idw#that and people seem too inclined to think that the comic writers all conspired to write/not write certain things for an agenda#when in reality they were just a bunch of independent writers trying to make things kinda coherent but mainly doing their own things#anyways. i would recommend reading the phase 2 dinobot trilogy by barber and the autocracy trilogy by metzen#barber's stuff in general is worth reading. i don't like a lot of his choices but he DID choose to write about them#i think it's worth reading his stuff if only as food for thought and more ideas even if his execution was middling in many parts#i also think mscott's stuff isn't talked about much and is underrated for how much exciting stuff is in it
19 notes
·
View notes
Text
sometimes i forget what fandoms i've been in until they smash me in the head like a steel beam in the most incomprehensible combination of letters like "QSMP but in VLD" and then it just makes perfect sense in my head and i spend 2 hours of my life sketching rough designs like
etoiles doesn't know how he got caught up in all this, but he most definitely did. etoiles is not related to the garrison, but he's visiting his friend baghera where she's got a job there as a communications specialist.
it's not his fault at all that there's a very suspicious "meteor crash" while he's there. it's not his fault at all that baghera goes investigating. it's not his fault at all that he follows her (okay, maybe it kind of is, but it feels like something he has to do okay?) it's not his fault at all that former junior officer forever is snooping around too. it's not his fault at all that the "meteor crash" was actually just a star pilot cellbit in an alien spacecraft - star pilot cellbit who notoriously piloted a mission to the outskirts of the solar system with junior officer felps and lead scientists pac and mike, star pilot cellbit who crashed the ship onto the moon kerberos. anyway...
it's still definitely not etoiles' fault that they commit some form of crime/felony/something- he's not even sure what they just committed but now they have half the garrison on their tails and an unconscious should-be-dead star pilot, so they run. forever apparently knows how to hotwire a car and baghera apparently knows how to disable all the tracking devices and they're apparently good friends too, and etoiles is just standing there with someone's unconscious body in his hands and he's already this implicated, definitely an accomplice, and he's doomed anyway so he follows.
star pilot cellbit wakes up and apparently he and former junior officer forever are even better friends, and it's just etoiles who's. here. for some reason. apparently, etoiles is also the only person here with a shred of rationality, because star pilot cellbit starts talking about aliens, former junior officer forever talks about telepathic conversations, and even baghera starts talking about government level conspiracy cover-ups. and, again, etoiles is just. etoiles. baghera's friend that somehow got caught up in all of this.
former junior officer forever tries to show them the traces of alien civilisation and traces of telepathy but etoiles wanders off (something calls at him, traces his steps out for him), and lo and behold, he stumbles upon the alien spaceship that has been sending out telepathic brainwaves or something to former junior officer forever for the past 2 years that star pilot cellbit has been declared missing
the alien spaceship is a giant yellow lion and there's a giant yellow forcefield (????) around it that doesn't lower itself no matter how much the others try, until etoiles walks up and says hi to it. it's another thing, with the controls not reacting to, you know, star pilot cellbit, former junior officer who was a pilot forever, or even just communications specialist baghera who at least has an idea of what all these controls are.
etoiles, who is still just etoiles and has no clue what all these stuff is, accidentally touches a control, which lights up under his hand, which sends the alien spaceship careening into the sky and out of the atmosphere, out to the fringes of the solar system, and there's a giant alien spaceship out there and he fights it somehow, and apparently that's the giant alien spaceship that star pilot cellbit escaped from. somehow, he opens up a wormhole and the yellow alien lion spaceship zooms through it and now they're half the known universe away from home.
they exit the spaceship - star pilot shiro first with the most confidence, then everyone else when they see that they're not going to die of suffocation due to lack of oxygen or improper atmospheric pressure or something. there's a giant castle, which the alien lion spaceship roars at and it opens up???? and then they walk in and baghera pokes around something and two cryopods rise up from the ground and open up.
cue the alteans. altean prince roier mourns the loss of everything he's ever known as he wakes up 10000 decaphoebs into the future with nothing but the castleship and one other person. this one other person is his closest friend jaiden, who was made royal advisor just 5 vargas before the destruction of their world. both cling to the castleship because it's all they have left and all that truly belongs to them.
obviously, since these new people have arrived in the yellow lion, the alteans decide that this must be about reforming voltron, and now must be the time to strike back against the galran empire. there's uh, only one issue.
there's four people and five lions. they do not have enough people to form voltron.
there's another issue, actually, where they don't even know who matches up with which lion. there's only really one person who they can match a lion to, and that's the yellow lion with etoiles - who, is still the only person here to not actually be caught up in any of this space business. he's still here somehow. he does actually have some sort of fighting experience, though? he was in the fencing club when he was in university! altean prince roier probably should actually know how to match them, but he was never really that interested in that aspect of his studies.
because they only have the yellow lion and the black lion, they also need to collect the other three. and because they don't know which lion matches up with which person, they can't just send one person in to pilot the lion out, they have to send the yellow lion in to physically pick up the other lions. thank the stars that the yellow lion is one of the more sturdy lions.
these issues are only apparent to the alteans because, well, the humans have no clue what's going on. there's 5 spaceships to be piloted? well, there's 6 people here, that's not a problem to them. just get one of the alteans to pilot the last spaceship.
the alteans do not want to pilot the last lion, too attached to the castleship to abandon it.
it's a fundamental difference in their point of views.
it gets worse from here.
#qsmp x vld au#ramblings#sun qsmp posting#sun writing#qsmp au#AAAAAAND thats VOLTRON! Coming in with the steel jaw!!#anyway that was 2 hours on the designs of just jaiden and roier#and now another 1.5 hours writing this entire premise#its over 1000 words what the hell#thats more than what i need done for my essay (that is due tomorrow and i havent even started because my brain got carried away with this)#lets uuhhhh also not talk about how i did the designs in the wrong book. this is not my sketchbook. oh no
11 notes
·
View notes
Text
finished private rites. haven't reached the final page of a book and said "wait thats it????" aloud in a while
#gene.txt#man it had such a compelling premise and the first 100 or so pages were rly promising and then it just. fell apart#i was right abt it being like our wives where the last 50 (in this case like 10) pages change how i feel abt the entire book#but it was in such a distinctly disappointing way. like of all the places u could have taken it u go with That??#and worse than the story going off the rails was the prose starting to rly grate on me#i think our wives worked bc it was short and sharp and armfield's tendency toward pontificating gave the briefness depth#meanwhile private rites is 300 pages and it began to feel bogged down (lol) in the prose#which sucks bc im all about the prose!! im a prose > plot guy!!! but u still need to have a clear point to pull off a vibes-heavy book#and while i could see what she was trying to say it just got swept away (lol x2) by the profundity hammered into every sentence#also the multiple povs didnt help. it actually would have hit harder solely from isla or irene's pov imo#tl;dr julia armfield water lesbians 2: electric boogaloo could have made a good novella. regrettably it is Not that#ANYWAY onto carys davis's clear!! im v excited for this one
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
I feel old bc I didn't like the amazing digital circus.
#like not to be a hater but like.#....i feel so underwhelmed#its so odd how half of the show feels like a lab grown “sure to do numbers on tumblr” by the book experience and then the other half is lik#the weirdest most well animated love letter to late 90s early 2000s computer media.#and how none of those 2 halfs manage to congeal well to me at all and creates something that feels so fanficky in its creation i cant help#but feel disinterested in literally anything it has to say because i know they werent thinking that hard about it.#like i told my friend that you could replace the setting with a haunted house or a deep sea cult and fundamentally you would have the same#plot and charactertization.#nothing felt fundamental to its premise beyond its comedy and “nonspecific glitch monster” and created something that i feel relies purely#on style with zero substance. it feels like keto diet the animation.#and like it sucks bc im struggling to figure out whether or not it was a personal taste issue or if it genuinely didnt work from a writing#level.#and like ig thats a good thing im thinking so hard about it but ngl i probably wont go back to watch any new content they make for it.#ngl from the little ive seen of murder drones its the same thing? so maybe just stylistically glitch's projects arent a thing for me.#thats entirely a possibility.
8 notes
·
View notes
Text
y'know as shitty and horrible as warrior cats is, 'my blood is on fire!' goes hard as fuck
#don't read warrior cats it'll only make you miserable#my honest recommendation: if you want to get into warrior cats do it through the things the fandom creates#it's significantly better than the actual books#i'll give you a few places to start too-#bonefall has a really good rewrite where they're also developing their own conlang#barrenclan is almost over but that entire story is incredible through and through#and clangen is really good for giving you a basic rundown of the premise#not to mention all the other cool stuff you can find through it#anyway. rip honeyfern
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
I read To Kill a Mockingbird and Go Set a Watchman back to back within 3 days and my god, Harper Lee's original work is such a masterpiece of literature and the sequel released 55 years later is one of the worst books I've read all year.
#literature#american literature#harper lee#to kill a mockingbird#go set a watchman#the entire premise of the second book is just trying to academically justify the#“hmm so much for the tolerant left” argument#and it's bad
16 notes
·
View notes