#and never respected authority
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
After rewatching the Legend of Korra, specifically the pro bending episodes, I feel like it would've made much more sense for Toph to have invented pro bending instead of becoming a cop/chief of police. I can understand why her developing a school to teach metal bending would be an aspect of her future, but a cop? Not so much. Considering her past as the Blind Bandit, creating pro bending makes much more sense for her character.
#toph is literally the most un-cop person ever#she was literally committing crimes in the original series#and never respected authority#like i know she was 12 but people's childhoods' heavily influence who they become in the future#but i guess beating the fire lord and saving the world may have inspired her to be a cop?#if it was in that context then i could maybe accept it#lok#the legend of korra#avatar the last airbender#toph beifong#atla toph#atla
23 notes
·
View notes
Text
News spreads fast.
[First] Prev <–-> Next
#poorly drawn mdzs#mdzs#jin guangyao#wei wuxian#jiang cheng#I absolutely love the contrast between JGY and JGS in this scene.#While JGS is acting as an instagator and trying to fan the flames of discontent (pulling his devious (g) strings)#JGY tries to keep a fairly neutral stance. If anything he reads like someone who's attempting to chair an unruly group project.#Honestly I think this scene does so much to show us why JGY manages to become the respectable leader he does in the future.#He's actully good at leading discussions and doesn't rise to bait. He's trying to start a productive discussion with *real facts*.#There is genuine honour in his approach and he never jumps into the emotional bandwagon.#The issue at the moment is that he doesn't have same level of authority as the contrastively *worst* sect leader does.#Jin Guangshan has a very specific agenda - to gain power by throwing anyone he deems expendable into the gutter.#The story even explicitly calls him out on not being so different from Wen Rohan multiple times.#The insidious part is that he's surrounded by people who think this is all justified.#It's all about using the 'victim' narrative to leverage justification. Which I'll get into more in upcoming comics.#(cut off text in panel one is supposed to be 'dead girls walking' but I ran out of room to make that clear. whoops!)
3K notes
·
View notes
Text
#anti booktok#booktok critical#anti sjm#these kinds of comments also just show a blatant ignorance of the fantasy genre as well bcus there are Plenty of male authors#writing pulpy and popular and sexy fantasy. which has rightly never been considered a masterpiece#i rly need people to understand you can enjoy something and it doesn't have to be a masterpiece#i love many things that range from just ok to great but not a masterpiece#and i feel that it undermines respecting women's reading to insist that these standard fantasies are masterpieces bcus#they can't stand being accused of reading and enjoying a book that's just Fine#hope that makes sense it's like 8am on a sunday which is not a peak coherence hour for me
660 notes
·
View notes
Text
we know EA interfered a lot with veilguard, i definitely do attribute the "sanitization" of the setting directly to EA's meddling, i even think to some extent taash's quest and the corporate representation feel of it all was influenced heavily by EA and not just weekes. and i think a lot of the companions being so shallow and their quests feeling half-baked is also mostly due to time constraints and rewrites/cut content-- the writers genuinely did do the best they could with what they had, and i feel for them and their frustrations. but. there are also just a lot of really bad decisions made elsewhere, too. like i said the racism has always been present in these games and it's always been a problem, it's literally baked into the worldbuilding, though i can definitely agree that some of it was potentially made worse specifically in veilguard due to constant rewrites and the loss of context and cohesion, but like... it was always there to begin with... and it's not "unfair" for players to point this out.
both things can be true-- EA absolutely fucked these people over, and we shouldn't be speculating conspiracy theory-type shit about the writers hating fans or whatever when we know. we know EA interfered, we know there were creative differences, we know they ruthlessly laid off a lot of the people that poured their blood, sweat, and tears into this game! EA is both stupid and actively malicious, they get no sympathy from me. veilguard absolutely is a casualty of the current state of the gaming industry. and i also think there were a lot of poor writing decisions made independently of that as well, that are fair to criticize and question. a lot of these problems are the same problems we've seen in every single DA game, and this consistency makes it clear this is not just an issue with corporate overreach.
but i really feel for everyone involved with making this game, this shit was clearly a very long and tiring fight, i can't even imagine the kind of constant corporate shitstorm they had to deal with for ten fucking years, and personally there is no NDA in the world that would keep me from talking shit. so these guys are stronger than me lol
#sorry i know these are just silly posts on tumblr dot edu but its important to me that people know im mostly being flippant#in some of my negative comments#like i dont think the writers are evil or whatever theyre just humans with biases that are very apparent in some of the things they write#and i also understand they got shafted big time and no one deserves the treatment they got#i could never be a narrative designer or writer in the gaming industry i would be so sickkkkkkkkkk#i follow this one author. the guy who wrote warm bodies. and he sent out a newsletter recently about how he was working on#a huge gaming project for a UK based company#and then the game got scrapped and they sealed all of his writing in a vault to just Never be released#oh i would be on the NEWS!!!!!! i couldn't do it. these people may be insufferable at times but they have my respect#for dealing with this shit. i could never#da posting
373 notes
·
View notes
Text
thinking about all the wenclair fics where wednesday sees enid covered in blood and thinks she’s beautiful and how now it’s cannon.
Wednesday saw enid— finally after having been looking for her and she was covered in a mess and couldn’t help but immediately think how strong enid was. How beautiful enid was. And then SHE FALLS INTO HER SAFE PLACE TO LAND ?!?!
Oh— OH KILL ME NOW STARS THE WORLD IS SPINNING SO VERY FAST

#wenclair#wednesday addams and enid sinclair#wednesday addams x enid sinclair#back on my never ending b*llshit#wenclair fics#like I’m pretty sure even I’ve written that scene#Wednesday admiring enid ???#ENID COVERED IN BLOOD#oh absolutely#author was a wenclair I respect that
113 notes
·
View notes
Text
Something something Jason feeling like he doesn't quite fit as "Greek" or "Roman" as a metaphor for bisexuality, particularly the semi-canonical bi-coding in his half of experiences during the Cupid scene and how Favonius and Cupid speak to him in parallel to the scenes confirming Nico is gay.
Something something the camps as metaphors for traditionally acceptable forms of relationships and Nico living as a rogue outside of them, rejecting expectation (ergo in himself representing a metaphor of queer identity and living outside of boxes and defined/usually hetero-allonormative/binary ideas of what love/relationships should look like) versus Jason struggling with the expectation to conform to a label and even discussing with Nico both of them remaining at CHB together.
Something something the inverse of Jason shifting away from the camps after he breaks up with Piper, feeling lost and unable to find a place between the camps as he begins to explore his queer identity properly for the first time versus Nico only remaining at CHB because he has entered a relationship. In this essay I will-
#pjo#riordanverse#jason grace#nico di angelo#analysis#i know ive semi-rambled about this before here#but i was thinking about it on the discord the other day#for those in the discord forgive it being mostly copy/pasted from my rambling lol#i say ''semi-canonical bi-coding'' re: the Cupid Scene because. well. it's in the text! it's pretty overt!#which means it's pretty canon but nobody ever really discusses it and Rick has never acknowledged it#but also he never acknowledged Reyna's aspec-coding until a rare instance of him responding to q's on twitter#(that chain was also specifically sparked by me in that instance - due to him replying to my open letter about aspec coding in the series#- which i still find amusing cause it is SO obvious he didnt read it)#and he only like once acknowledged his mostly unintentional aspec-coding of the Hunt on goodreads#and very frequently goes ''death of the author - whatever i say outside the books is irrelevant and doesnt matter. read it how you want.''#''if you can get it out of the text then there's your canon.'' which i respect. reject ''word of god'' canon embrace analysis
364 notes
·
View notes
Text
FANFIC TIIIME
I've only read a few sentences yet and I'm already hyped!! Rambling in the tags below (part 1)
#💬 rory rambles#puppeteer au#YES we WERE in dire need of Pomni-centric content thank you dear author#the ribbons being endless and everywheeere. based#PASSENGER IN YOUR OWN BODY MENTIONED#girl I love the determination (though we all know how this will end)#THE REFERENCING THE DAY ONE COMIC AAAAAAHHHHH#I AM FREAKING OUT RN#and the allusions to The Incident hehehehehehheh#ohh Kinger... never change#the hinting that maybe Gangle stayed away from Jax because she feared getting injured. because she wasn't powerful enough yet#hmmm oh yes yes I am considering it#MY SECOND ONESHOT'S EVENTS fuckkk I really don't like that one anymore. really don't like it#but I respect your choice to include it#I didn't give you guys much “canon” lore to go off of after all#about certain events#...because I didn't HAVE very certain events in mind. just a vague direction for things to go tbh. I was just fuck it we balling it#STRUNG UP LIKE AN ABSTRACT ART INSTALLATION#exactly exactlyyy#HAHAHAHAH OHH WOW THAT IS HORRIFYING#HER SPEAKING THROUGH ZOOBLE#I LOVE THAT#yeah Pomni is a nervous laugher I getcha girl#fun fact (just remembered this from Jax showing up brandishing scissors) I have thought of a sort of “bossfight”#between Gangle possessing Ragatha vs Jax and Pomni. for funsies. whenever I listen to a specific Spider Dance remix I imagine it#GANGLE HAVING A MONSTER FORM???? YES PLEASE#“She'd never thought that Jax could scream like that. She never thought he was capable of begging like that.”#I am grinning like a sick sadistic freak rn#THEM BOTH SPEAKING AT ONCE ohh haunting. I enjoy it#I'll wrap it up on this post bc there's a tag limit BUT I'M STILL GOING
18 notes
·
View notes
Text
just saw someone call dunmeshi "a show about sapphic women" i think maybe you don't actually know what dungeon meshi is about
#farcille is both a big part of the story and not because it's not canon! it has never been and will never be canon. their friendship is!#there are no canon romantic relationships outside of very minor pre-established ones#if you cannot respect dungeon meshi for what it's actually about and instead must water it down to your favorite ship dynamic#i think perhaps you've missed the point and shouldn't be speaking on it with any amount of authority#explicitly sapphic work is out there but this isn't one of those#it's subtle/implied at best. and certainly not what the series is “about”#tox.txt
141 notes
·
View notes
Note
Hi Kit! Hope your doing well! I just wanted your thoughts on something: what do you think about the difference in tone when come to top!Obi-Wan and top!Anakin? Top Anakin always has more dubcon/noncon, and even in fests, prompts always lean one way or the other. Like top!wan is always so much more wholesome, while the other ship is very…not lmao (love both btw)
oh this is an interesting ask and I’ve gone back and forth on an answer!! I can definitely see what you’re talking about but I also feel like there’s at least a bit of confirmation bias as well as actual truth to the observation (at least for me)
but my guess is that maybe it has something to do with either the characters themselves or the ways people like to write the characters together?
Anakin has moments of being sweet and out of control but ultimately well meaning in canon but he also has moments of being, well, evil. so different authors can lean into different interpretations of his character for their fic and have it still ring true to him.
and Obi-wan can be seen as being very in control and cool and collected in the face of anakin’s out of control (but Obi-wan’s canon self doesn’t have that flavor of darkness or evil, except in sith aus which are very au from the get go), and different authors can lean into that sense of control as meaning that he would be a (soft) healthy and wholesome dom to anakin’s needing submission.
and other authors can want to explore what an Obi-wan who has lost his control to a forceful anakin would look like, which may lend itself more to dub/non con fics?
character analysis is definitely not my thing tho and this is all really just vibes (and sounds much more binary than I like tbh) but I do feel like it boils down to, at least in canon fics, what obi-wan’s character is likely to do, and while anakin’s character runs the whole spectrum of emotions in the movies, Obi-wan’s thing is being in the light. so I can see it being more common for fics where he tops to be topping while in the light lmao whereas that’s not necessarily true for top anakin fics
#asks#obikin#I’m using the some authors and different authors phrases#because it’s absolutely not like#this for everyone and im hedging my bets while being respectful#I think there are a ton of wholesome top anakin fics to be clear#and I’ve definitely seen top Obi-wan fics that are dub or non con#so in general I try never to use the word always but also this ask reads in good faith#and I’m always willing to discuss in good faith
23 notes
·
View notes
Text
MDZS Disco Elysium AU part 2 - Psyche Skills
Part 1 - Part 3
#poorly drawn mdzs#mdzs#disco elysium#MDZS disco elysium au#jiang cheng#jiang yanli#yu ziyuan#While it's more in vogue to draw a character's skill roster tailored to them -#One of the more subtle details I love in DE is how some of the skill portraits parallel character portraits of people hbd associates with.#Theres somethine rather poetic to be said about how other people shape out thoughts and sometimes act as a 'voice' in our head.#How we are in part a collection of impressions other people left behind on us.#I am a huge Skillhead (Those are my friends! My party members! They love me! They have their own agendas and alliances!)#so of course a healthy portion of this AU is dedicated to them <3#the Int skills go basically unchanged from DE. Psy as well (with changes to a few quirks in voice).#Fys skills though...well...wwx is in a different body! Those voices belong to Someone Else.#Esp electrochem (MXY in this AU also partied to near death. WWX is withdrawing and craving substances he's never even heard of before)#While I personally don't fully subscribe to Volition Jean I *do* see Volition Jiang Cheng. The voice of your Not Brother keeping you afloat#All three of these parallels make me unbelievably sad. They are also both purple. Art is like that sometimes.#Empathy Jiang Yanli...oh man do I have a lot of thoughts about her. Disco fans Who Know....you can probably see what I'm cooking.#Authority is a really interesting skill in DE because *yes* its about power and intimidation - but it's also about finesse and respect#Titus Hardie and YZY both abuse *and* finesse how they establish their authority - in a way that leaves quite an impression.#2 more mdzs disco posts that I *need* to create and then I'm off to working on raffles <3
749 notes
·
View notes
Text
Here's a v quick vague rushed half assed TWSB propaganda post
TWSB is a romance novel isekai subversion story. You know, the escapist genre that there r 2353533535 kr webtoons/novels for... i got reincarnated in my fav romance novel as the villainess yadayada THAT genre. but a twist on it!!!
TWSB is for fujoshi/fudanshi/fujin who would rather ship the 2 male love interests in a romance than have a love triangle with the female lead... TWSB is also for poly/throuple/trio enjoyers (whether platonic or not ur choice). And old women yuri enjoyers. And people who enjoy novel isekai subversions like orv and surviving romance (and SVSS? i havent read but ive heard comparisons)... /ppl who think novel isekai premises Could be interesting but find so many of them boring cliche or wasted potential... and people who like fun worldbuilding... or ppl who r interested in the premise "typical shoujo romance novel plot gets derailed and ends up accidentally becoming a non-romance action fantasy which is also highkey extremely gay"..... *dangling a chocolate croissant in front of u* ooooh u want to read twsb so bad wooooo is it worki
(EDIT: oh to be clear im recommending the novel btw!! webtoon is cute but the novel is where u get the full experience 🛐 idc which one u start w but pls read the novel... hehe)
#i made an entire twsb rec post without even mentioning yeseo at all sknfjsdj#or cedric or christelle#twsb#btw dont get mad at me for this post (for reasons idk) im being /LH here#*spongebob get hit w a piano and live pose* IM /LH!!!!#anyway back to drawing twsb fanart and brainrotting and hopefully drawing ppl in organically#when the third wheel strikes back#서브 남주가 파업하면 생기는 일#talk tag#sidenote ive still only read up to ch 92 as of this post fkfbd#oh also forgot to ment#TWSB stands for When the Third Wheel Strikes Back (서브 남주가 파업하면 생기는 일 lit: what happens when the 2nd male lead goes on strike in kr)...#even the title sounds unserious as hell😭😭 youd never expect it to actually be Deep...#twsb rly is the def of taking like a funny gag concept#and really goes ALL the way w it#so so so much love and respect to the author... sookym-nim...🛐#recommendation#rec post#webtoon recommendation#novel recommendation#edit: to be clear im recommending the NOVEL tho!!! webtoon is cute but novel gives u the full twsb experience
100 notes
·
View notes
Text
#“well i guess people change don't they?” is killing me because he attempted to kill crowley in mrs. tran's body like four episodes ago#anyway fascinating conversation that i think leads right into 8.09#“every relationship i have ever had has gone to crap at some point but the one thing i can say about benny: he has never let me down.”#in a 'why wasn't i Enough to Change For' kind of way for sam on two occasions—s4 and 7.03/7.07#like it genuinely does speak to the lack of respect dean holds for sam and sam as a person detached from himself in the sense that#because in the same way season four sam asks dean to trust him on a level that ensures sam's ability to make his own decisions about himsel#and his relationships he asks dean to not trust amy but to trust him... and does dean Does Not. just as he didnt trust or respect sam in s4#but somehow benny is both an exception beyond the things dean verbally berated into sam's values in exchange for his inclusion back into#their dynamic in 7.07 as well as an example of the higher standard that exists for sam in the sense that. sam is expected to automatically#trust benny as an extension of dean. but dean was unable to do that for sam and sam flips that back around onto dean#but the thing is that dean has the authority to have the final say about amy's life or sam's autonomy#trusting sam isn't enough because just that alone doesn't meet dean's standard of his decision making#but trusting dean should be enough for sam to trust benny. like “and you believe him?” just. its suchhh a line#because dean has never believed sam. not when he was monstrous and (arguably just as ethically) drinking blood#not in season five (in fact he says it outright!) not in season seven with his own autonomy and by extension amy#but dean expects sam to believe him after holding sam in their relationship to a higher standard than he does for himself#(expecting sam to be open about ruby amy and amelia... but not doing the same with benny until its unavoidable)#and the thing is that. this was sam's point all along! so much of his relationship with ruby vs dean revovled around the idea that he shoul#be able to have that relationship w/o opening it up to dean. but dean redefines that boundary for sam's inclusion into their relationship#and then expects different standards for himself ie. that he should be able to do so while sam does not have that privileged#speaks very much to the patriarchal structure at play here and how these characters as Third to the samndean dynamic#and their own genders play into how they disrupt the dynamic. it's just as fascinating to me#that sam eventually lets dean have his lower standard wrt his not knowing that dean goes no contact w benny after 8.10#like sam watches benny get stuck in purgatory again with the idea that their relationship had continued#8.06#adflatus
14 notes
·
View notes
Note
the book was a lot better, wasn’t it? I feel like the movie got a lot of the spirit, and was well done, but the book was definitely better.
it absolutely was better, yeah.
i agree that the movie got the spirit, but the book just intensifies everything. the struggle, the humour, the desperation but also the brilliance of everyone and everything.
like. take the scene where the hab depressurised and Watney was cannon-balled out with the airlock. in the movie his suit breached with a crack in his faceshield, which was gut clenching but ultimately easily fixed with some duct tape. in the book his faceshield was shattered and the airlock breached. and it took him like four tries to find and repair the breach, at the end of which he was still IN the airlock, could not EXIT the airlock without dying bc his suit was fucked, but no longer going to suffocate. there was then another whole problem solving scene of getting out of the airlock.
i think it's just. the ingenuity in the book that doesn't come through as well in the movie. like, you find out WHAT went wrong, HOW it went wrong, WHY it went wrong, the CONSEQUENCES of that and THEN what all has to be done to fix it. it looks all cool and flashy on the big screen but it's so much harder to ask and answer those questions for the audience.
That is a part of what makes Weir's choice to write the book as an epistolary so god damn brilliant, which was replicated to a degree in the movie, but that's a whole 'nother rant and this is getting long...
#The Martian#andy weir#i have another rant about Mark Watney's characterisation (and minor beef with fic authors)#bc like. i feel they don't capture the never-say-die attitude that was so critical to his character and his survival#look imma be real i have a *lot* of rants rn about the martian. i could get started on literally anything if you want me to#god it's just. an amazing amazing amazing book#from a literary/story perspective but also a technical perspective#there's like. 3 different styles he uses. epistolary. 3rd person limited pov. and 3rd person omnicient#Watney. NASA staff (Mindy. Kapoor. etc). and When Things Are About To Go Wrong And Why respectively#aikovneo;aihf;oeai dfvlaksjd okay i'm shutting up now thank.#someone rec me a new book to listen to before i lose my mind
15 notes
·
View notes
Text
I love how when any men celebrity does something bad, you can always find the comments "x would never do such a thing" "y is disappointed/would be disappointed"
#neil gaiman#i mean its just “wow this man is trash but you know there is this other ine that isn't”#by the way Pratchett was amazing but he was not the one being talked about now#is he?#so no need to bring his name?#i remember ages ago when other authors were doing shitty things and everyone was like “well at least Gaiman would never”#they are people that we don't know everything about#keep the respect#keep the love for the work#but know that you don't know this people#and every case is a case#you don't need to look for a idol “that is great” just to prove to yourself that your taste is immaculate
32 notes
·
View notes
Text
Again the sickness speaking but here's something that has been going through my mind since forever:
I feel like a good way to mitigate a lot of discontent with the doa arc ending and in general the whole Dazai-being-flawless issue bsd has going on is by comparing bsd to Sherlock Holmes by Arthur Conan Doyle. Please bear with me for two minutes.
When Sherlock Holmes was being published, people were intrigued and enamoured by Holmes' brilliant and charming, crimes-solving figure. People read the stories for the pure joy of being left gaping at his superhuman wits again and again; they didn't want to see him fail, they wanted to be shocked and amazed by his genius. When Holmes died and then came back, nobody lamented it being unrealistic, because realism was not what people were reading the books for! They were reading to be impressed, to cheer for the hero and then take satisfaction in seeing him turn out victorious. That's the author-reader deal that was made there: to impress and to enjoy being impressed.
As of recently I feel like we've been asking from bsd something it never promised us in the first place. Maybe it's just not that kind of series! Maybe it's more about surprising the reader with how the hero is going to make it and less about highlighting his flaws and insecurities. And like, that's okay! That's why Dazai getting away with it isn't it him getting away with it “again”, it's just how bsd is; in a way, it's what makes bsd bsd.
I think it really clicked with me like it never did before when I watched the last episode of season 5; because the arc ending felt so shocking and unpredictable, very deus-ex-machina trope, a little underwhelming in its lowering the stakes that were there the whole time, and yet so extremely on brand with bsd, I didn't even have it in me to be disappointed. It was so similar to the Guild's arc ending and even more to the Cannibalism arc ending, and maybe it really is just a pattern, maybe it really is what bsd aspires to be, and that's okay too.
Also, I can't stretch this enough: if it's not your cup of tea, that's fine. I can't say it's mine either. But I feel like criticizing bsd now for how it's always been falls quite short, because it really feels like demanding from it what it never promised to deliver in the first place. That's just as far as my current perception of the series goes, though, so feel free to disagree with me on this.
#Btw this is not me comparing Holmes character with Dazai character.#Holmes character is something Dazai character will never be (respectful of women)#The also real difference between Holmes and Dazai is that one author loathes the character with everything that's in them–#and the other author loves the character with everything that's in them#I've also briefly mentioned before that Atsushi is a very Watson-like figure in the way it uses as someone deeply human‚#sympathetic to the reader and that the reader can see themselves in‚#plot device so that Holmes has someone he can explain his deduction to and with his awe further underlines and uplifts Holmes' genius#Also sassy#osamu dazai#bsd#bungou stray dogs#bsd s5#Wow and here's me putting my season 5 thoughts down after three months. Took a raging fever for me to do so#To be fair when the episode dropped everyone was a bit crazy over the ending for one reason or the other#So back then I felt like waiting things to chill out first#mine#I often find superfluous to end posts with “feel free to disagree with me on this” because it's so obvious and expected it goes unsaid#But I suppose sometimes it bears repeating...
155 notes
·
View notes
Note
Fair warning: I don't think this is going to be a question, just a few post-latest chapter thoughts haphazardly stacked together under a trenchcoat.
Thank you for this chapter. It made my day to read something almost fluffy (I don't think anything in LH can be called purely fluff, and that's a good thing because fluff is best when it is padding for the plot, and that's what this chapter was).
LH Book 5 has been the beginning of payoff for the Dramione slow burn, and while that is immensely satisfying, it also means there are less milestones to look forward to. I don't know if this was an intentional decision, but I love how you started seeding in another slow burn that has kept us equally invested: the Black family drama.
I love reading anything that does the dysfunctional family dynamic well, and seeing Draco getting old enough to identify it clearly, have questions, testing his boundaries, fighting back against what he's been told to accept, has all been immensely satisfying as someone who has gone through this myself. Your depiction of the Black family dynamics has been /chef's kiss/. * spoiler for chapter 70 * when Draco witnesses his cousins casually throwing information his way, what I wanted was for one of the adults to see how much he needed that information, that connection, and give it to him. My god ❤️ You have written a lonely boy craving family so well.
Back to the Dramione of it all (and this might be a question), I love how Harry chose to approach the contained chaos waiting to unravel around him and just bluntly told Draco what he did. Question: do you think this is something Canon Harry would have done in this instance? Was there a choice to change anything in your characterisation of Harry (with respect to Canon) that resulted in this wonderful, blunt, more-mature-than-many-adults-who-can't-even-identify-their-needs version of Harry?
If not, what canon Harry actions/traits do you think would point to him acting this way?
Thank you! This is a beautiful and very kind trench coat, and I am luxuriating in it.
I will answer your question while continuing to luxuriate: I don't think canon Harry would ever confront his friends about an emotional problem, mostly because because he never does. Hermione and Ron, the two people he's most comfortable with in the world, are feuding for most of HBP, and while he does have a few "can't you guys just get along?" type-outbursts, he doesn't really sit down and ask "hey, what's going on with you? How can I help?" because canon!Harry is, as you might expect for a 15-year-old boy, better at ignoring his problems than solving them. (I also think there's an ingredient of conflict-avoidance in there from his upbringing with the Dursleys, but I'll be the first to admit that's mostly headcanon.)
My Harry is a bit softer — in part because that's just how I prefer my Harry, my favorite scenes with him are those where he's showing tenderness for things other people have neglected. This is the best of him, and this is the core of him, in my opinion. Canon Harry has this marvelous capacity for empathy, and when he chooses to use it, it's kind of astonishing how capable he is of resisting prejudice and caring for people. He's fiercely loyal in defending Hagrid, always. He makes a point of freeing Dobby, who's just spent a book trying to maim him. He refuses to let Sirius kill Pettigrew, even knowing that Pettigrew betrayed his parents ("My dad wouldn't want you to" — sweet boy, you mean you don't want them to, and you understand on some level that's the only thing you can say that will stop them.) He saves Gabrielle Delacour, because even if she would have been safe in the end, he's not leaving a little girl at the bottom of a fucking lake. He reads the Half-Blood Prince's handwriting — Snape's handwriting — and thinks: "I bet he's someone like me." On the basis of handwriting, he empathizes with this person! Harry is constantly trying to save people, and he doesn't ever really tell us why. And we'll never know why canon!Harry does that, consciously or subconsciously, but I have to imagine that every time Harry looks at someone in pain, he sees a lonely kid stuck under a staircase, and he thinks not fucking today.
#the emotional maturity — such as it is — I attribute to having more of mrs weasley's influence#in that lionheart takes him away from the dursleys and basically never sends him back#i don't think lionheart!molly would let it happen and lionheart!sirius certainly wouldn't#this is not criticism of the original — I've said many times that the early HP books are weird because they're children's books#so stuff like. child neglect. for instance. isn't treated That Seriously#because why on earth would it be it's a children's book!#and we ignore things like that in children's books because we don't take any of it#THAT seriously. except then you have to retroactively frame#harry's past as a realistic adult figure in the later books#and then it all sort of fractures. tonally speaking.#so the only thing I would claim lionheart has in that respect is the benefit of foresight#in knowing that there are going to be 7 books and they are going to explore#these characters as adults. that's all!#which is my ultimate justification of: i think this is what harry would have been#if the author had known that the books were going to follow him into adulthood#and had wanted to set up the man that harry purports to be in Book 7 a little earlier. that's all!#lionheart spoilers#lionheart#greenteacup asks
37 notes
·
View notes