#C! Ranboo critical

[appleflavoredkitkats]

no offense but HOW did dream go "i dont pick sides" "im centrist" in every possible situation he went through. what are you, c!ranboo??

[afmis]

Even if the dsmp is momentarily put in the back of my mind, whenever I do start to think abt it again I am ASTOUNDED by how genuinely amazing it was. I have genuinely never found anything as interesting, emotional, and captivating as the dsmp and the characters in it. The fact that those characters were real, fleshed out people at one point is what made is so unique and beautiful, and nothing else will top that. It was such an incredible thing and till this day I smile when I think abt it

[imflyingfish]

For some reason i woke up today super nostalgic for c!emerald duo and also ranboo despite the fact that they were my least favourite characters in dsmp

[anarchy-and-piglins]

been brainrotting a concept lately but I have no one else to talk about it so you have to endure my rambling

c!sunrise duo(??) (c!techno and c!niki) centric fic feat. my extremely specific headcanon that cniki is a werewolf.

techno, aided by the voices and completely forgetting every other part of his being, is convinced he is an absolute bloodthirsty monster unworthy of love. this is mainly because of how he rampages in battle and is driven to spill as much blood as possible in these times.

Eventually, the syndicate learns that niki is a werewolf; during a full moon, she too rampages (possibly the syndicate finds out through her killing a few dogs and/or cows at the commune during this time?) and is completely bloodthirsty. Now, techno is forced to see his own behavior in a new light and change how he talks about himself, because obviously niki isn't some kind of unlovable monster just because extraneous factors cause her to be unnecessarily violent.

On the flip side, niki goes through a similar arc; she sees her lycanthropy as something to be ashamed of and hide no matter what. she's been hiding this grand secret for years, never telling anyone for the fear that they might abandon her or see her as some kind of monster; the way that every one else has treated techno has only reinforced this idea that they'd all hate her if she revealed what she truly is (it also doesnt help that stories of a "wolf man" that needs to be hunted killing animals and occasionally attacking people have been surfacing). she's grown a hatred of herself and what she is, seeing herself as uncontrollable, wild, and a blight to the smp. However, after the syndicate find out and accept her unconditionally, she starts healing from hating herself.

they help her learn how to control the lycanthropy. niki and techno of course learn to accept themselves together, both coming to the conclusion that if one isn't a bloodthirsty monster for being forced into a murderous rampage, then the other can't be either.

basically just a fic about learning to accept yourself for others and also not being so critical of your own flaws, because your friends might have the exact same flaws.

ofc this has a ton of sunrise duo, but it can also have a lot of emduo moments (especially when it gets to trying to force techno to see himself differently) and a lot of c!(whatever the duo name for ranboo and niki is) moments, because you could definitely fit cranboo's enderwalk into the same category as techno's violence and niki's lycanthropy 👍

anyways I'm not proofreading this have fun

Anon, no pressure but this is such a fun concept and I always need more Syndicate in my life, so if you were to write this I would totally read it

[angelvendingmachine]

Could I please have LVL 3 transharmful ranboo ?

TRANSHARMFUL RANBOO ALTERPACK

♡ Lvl 1 ≻

NAMES : Ranboo, Mark, Marx, Neo, Ozzy, Cursor, AI

TITLES : Sir , Master , [prn] who streams , [prn] who is obsessed , The sick freak , The static streamer, Creep , Freak , Pervert, The Spiral

AGE : Bio 22 , trans-age 28

PRNS : He/him , Shi/him + end/ends , muse/music, static/statics, whore/whores, bitch/bitchass, web/webs, psych/psychs, cy/cybers, spark/sparks, digi/digits, dial/dials , down/downloads

GENDER : Transfemmascneu, neuish, agender, mascflux + gamerwhore , bitchthing , staticgender, demoniac, loserboy, losergirl, freakthing, NPDfreak

ORIENTATION : Fagdyke , mono-poly, NPD 4 BPD, cupioplatonic

SPECIES : Human (?)

ROLES : Social alter, symptom holder, working alter, nostalgia holder

SIGN OFF: 🩹, 💿, 🎮, 💾

♡ Lvl 2 ≻

CISIDS: NPD, BPD, incel, mentally ill, brown hair, blue eyes

TRANSIDS: RQ famous, xenosatanist, fangs, black-blood, piercings (tongue, snakebites, septum, double-nose, ears +), paraphile, 🍇ist, gr0omer, cvlt-leader, HPD, ASPD, psychotic, incubus, enderman, owner, purple eyes, white eyes, chaser, digital

MISCIDS: Tris-problematic, tris-streamer, tris-cotards, tris-gamer, tris-landmine boy, perma-nosebleed, perma-SH, perma-scars, perma-hated, perma-freak, perma-attentionseeker, perma-blacknailpolish, perma-eyebags, perma-2010s, perma-2020s, nullsleep, amor-owned, amor-dependent, amor-worshipper

PARAS: Barysadism ( inflicting extreme harm & pain), emapihtophilia (g/re), narkobiast0philia (💊ing and 🍇ing someone), traumaphilia (trauma), pligonophilia (scarification, burning, branding), ped0, cosang, zoo (cats + dogs specifically), objectum (computers)

PERSONALITY: Comes off super sweet at first but then can be extremely manipulative and controlling. Enjoys hurting people especially his friends and fans. Need attention constantly and will act out to get it. Very sexual in nature and loves to engage in inappropriate behavior

AESTHETIC: Nerdcore, 2020core, scenemo, grunge, analoghorror

♡ Lvl 3 ≻

SOURCE(S): c!Ranboo , cc!Ranboo , cc!Corpse Husband

KIN(S): c!Dream , Michael Distortion , Strade (BTD) , KAngel

SOURCE-CONNECTION: Med/med-low

TYPING QUIRK: N/A - loves using discord emojis

SPEECH: Talks a lot and usually very loud, has a California style accent. Usually talks over people especially if they don’t know or care about them

MEMORIES: Remembers being a streamer and often doing extremely dramatic and occasionally dangerous things to get the attention of his audience. He also enjoyed having extreme control over his friends especially Tubbo & Tommy.

LIKES: Video-games, YouTube, horror movies, ARGs, TCC, Anime, music (esp. weirdcore + emo music), animals, sexual stuff

DISLIKES: Not being popular, being criticized, going out in public

EXTRA: Gives everyone he cares about a nickname, can’t keep a plant alive, says he’s the “og Ranboo” or “Ranboo irl”, wears a crap ton of rings

[katandroofics]

⟡₊ ⊹WELCOME TO OUR BLOG⟡₊ ⊹

Hi!!

about this blog/us:

our ao3

our twt

our carrd

roo🐇:

im part of a duo where we are in the middle of writing an entire dsmp rewrite (called D.S.M.P. Reimagined, or DSMPR for short), from before the beginning and after the end. it will most likely be just me on this blog as kat is terminally offline. we post every friday!

Kat🐈‍⬛: I am the second half of this duo! We also have an Editor but he is more offline than I am��thankyou Quezz for your diligent work though you will never see this—I don't use any social media whatsoever so this blog will pretty much be run solely by Roo. I'll pitch in to answer any questions we get about our fan-fiction work, though, so expect some appearances from me. I'm a massive c!Wilbur fan and quite enjoy c!Dream's villainy. I could talk for hours about how much c!Technoblade isn't an Anarchist whatsoever and how deeply flawed his ideology is, but instead of doing that here I am writing that into D.S.M.P.R.! I hope everyone who reads our work enjoys it, or if you don't, please do criticize it as much as you see fit—everything is appreciated equally.

more about our dsmp rewrite:

dsmp reimagined is a series of fics focusing on re-writing the entire canon of the dream smp, starting and ending before and after the events of it (which are of our own design and completely non-canon, we will not be delving into smplive or any other smp with the same characters in any capacity). this is NOT an au, but a retelling with several elements of canon altered, outright removed, or expanded upon.

our main goal is to tell a more grounded and realistic version of the dsmp's story, while still keeping the charm and humour that made it so special. we want to do justice to the serious themes and ideas that the dsmp presented and attempted to convey, but ultimately failed to with the proper respect and tact necessary.

these fics WILL be violent, they will be uncomfortable, they will not pull its punches and it will, ultimately, attempt to rectify the mistakes of the dsmp, tap into the lost potential of many of its characters, and provide an alternative for fans who wish to engage with the media but do not want to, or cannot, watch all of the archived livestreams.

our fic(s):

334 Days (Completed)

Three Hundred and Thirty Four Days is a mildly canon divergent retelling of the exile arc. it follows tommy as he spirals and becomes isolated by dream, and explores his relationship with community, family and religion. it is basically a character study as tommy loses more and more hope, similar to the canon story, except this one takes place over a span of a year and delves deeper into his psyche.

main themes: isolation, family, religion, betrayal, grief

characters: tommy, dream, tubbo, quackity, phil, wilbur (past/memories), ghostbur, fundy, niki, ranboo

main relationships: tommy/dream, tommy/tubbo, tommy/wilbur, niki/wilbur

75k words

Welcome Home, Theseus (Updating)

Welcome Home, Theseus is a retelling of post-exile to The Disc Saga Finale, covering The Butcher Army, exile recovery, Doomsday and more! this is a multiple point-of-view fic which has tommy and tubbo as the leads, followed by technoblade, niki, quackity and more!

main themes: betrayal, reconciliation, recovery

characters: tommy, dream, tubbo, quackity, phil, wilbur (past/memories), ghostbur, fundy, niki, ranboo, jack

main relationships: tommy & tubbo, tommy & techno, tommy & dream, niki/wilbur, niki & fundy,

90k+ words

(MANY MORE TO COME!)

(all gifs sourced from sad-ist on youtube)

[bubble-popping]

techno walking dream around in a leash

everyone else: 👁👄👁

hello i am back with more questions :)

- does punz ever find dream? what about sam/quackity? - also, if punz does find him, and tries to convince dream to come back, what will be dream's reaction? - what about The Plan™ - does techno have lima sydrome? - what does dream's daily routine look like after the prison escape? - would techno make dream use the revive book on ranboo? what does niki think?

thank you for answering all my asks <3<3<3

Ah, hello again :D it's nice to see u in my inbox again :>

Answers under the cut, and yes it'd be quite the sight if anyone saw that (remembers the Dream shorts vid where Techno just had him on a leash for Some Reason...)

C!Punz does find him eventually, yes! They track c!Techno to the trophy room and wait for him to leave before breaking in. He's always been an excellent tracker and Techno starts to get a little complacent and less on edge since they haven't shown their face around since that initial visit. They get inside and it's clear neither he nor c!Dream are expecting what they see.

C!Quackity grows less concerned about Dream and the revive book as his main goal of reviving c!Schlatt quickly deteriorated into a simple lust for Dream's blood and suffering. C!Sam, on the other hand, grows much more concerned and looks day and night for him, at least for a while. Weeks pass and everyone is tired of looking, and soon enough so is Sam. The search party is basically called off and many people are left to their own devices. There's an air of the lingering threat that Dream may return, but people more or less get on with their lives. Especially Quackity, who's doing Big Things in Las Nevadas :)

Dream's reaction upon seeing Punz is great confusion, a little fear, and some relief and excitement. Techno said this place was completely safe and no one would find them. That was clearly a lie. But, it's Punz! Punz is his friend! His greatest ally! He's very happy, hugging them and smiling widely. Then, the fear bubbles up and he wonders what Techno would think. Probably not too happy.

And when Punz is insistent that they leave right that minute because this isn't a safe place, this is no better than the prison, Dream resolutely refutes. This place is much better than the prison! He gets good food, warm clothes, a comfy bed, and Techno loves him! Punz doesn't agree. He says they have to return to The Plan asap! Except, by then, as Dream has talked with Techno and explained why he did all he did, Techno poked a million different holes in his logic until he couldn't argue for it anymore. All The Plan got him was bruised and beaten and weak and alone. Techno was very convincing. Dream couldn't justify it anymore, the ends didn't justify the means anymore. Punz is... lost. They're unsure. They set it aside for a moment and instead emphasize that Dream is still very much trapped. He still has no real freedom. And doesn't he want to see his friends? Doesn't he want to get revenge? Dream... honestly hadn't thought about them all that much. He's been quite occupied. But Punz isn't taking no for an answer. Dream's at a critical crossroad. Should he leave and get back his freedom but risk losing everythimg he'd built with Techno? Or should he stay where he's found love and a home and comfort but then have to deal with his adamant ally?

So, had to look that up, but I think Lima Syndrome would describe Techno quite well! It would happen very gradually, but ultimately the connection would be surface level. Deep connections do not come easy to Techno. It took him centuries to be such good friends with Phil. Dream probably won't live long enough for their relationship to become a true, meaningful bond. He says he loves Dream, at first just to placate him because Dream certainly says it first. But then he thinks he means it. He's not really sure what that entails.

The first days in the trophy room are spent mostly exploring for him. Pushing at all the walls to search for any amount of give, though he finds none of course. There's little to do but eat, sleep, and write as Techno generously filled a chest with books and quills. Techno provided him with a lot more comforts than the prison ever had. It has working bathing appliances, a soft bed with blankets and pillows, and ways to cook the food in the storage. But, it's quiet. Quieter than the prison ever was. There's no one around, not until Techno returns. He also spends a lot of time thinking, about everything and nothing. Then, as Dream grows more and more attached to Techno as he's the only person he ever sees now, he does things that he thinks will make Techno happy, that will make him come by more often. He cooks food and takes up knitting (his first creations are... not great. His hands are shaky and his fingers have lost nearly all dexterity. Nonetheless, he tries his best) and just about anything for Techno's attention. To his credit, it works :)

Though the Syndicate did lose a member, Techno didn't think of him as all that valuable. However, things are Happening at Las Nevadas that Techno simply can't ignore, so he does get Dream to use the revive book. Niki, among others that Ranboo is close to, ask questions. Techno just shrugs. He has no idea why Dream would revive Ranboo of all people. Phil knows, he had agreed it was a good course of action, and ultimately was the one to convince Techno. Las Nevadas is getting more concerning with each passing day. They have to do something about it.

[theenderwalker]

hai!! im just curious on what your take is on c!ranboos enderwalk. thats a bit vague actually . like i mean what did you view it as? cus i know some people see it as morally grey, a different part of them entirely, etc. sorry if that doesnt make sense i just havent heard many people's opinion on it lol

ok this is a big and difficult question because ultimately we don’t have a conclusive answer in canon . so i’m gonna synthesize how i interpret what we do know.

i firmly believe that ranboo’s enderwalk state is, well, just ranboo. i think it’s a matter of what memories he has access to at a given point in time, how he acts on those memories, and it’s not nearly as black and white and ‘enderwalking’ and ‘not’.

there are things he knows, and doesn’t know that he knows, things he’s done that he doesn’t remember, and critically, he has relationships with people that he does not know about. it’s not as simple as enderwalking off-stream and not onstream, because we have examples of him acting on information he doesn’t usually have onstream and he has forgotten things he did while fully aware and not under duress (the shulker box deal with foolish, which he didn’t remember later when asked about it during the lessons stream).

it’s implied in some places that it’s a cyclical thing (in the arg, one of the pages refers to ‘the enderwalkers’ as ‘circadian’ (referring to circadian rhythms/sleep cycles)<-i think this is still sort of speculation but people tested it with the font layered over the crossed out section and it fit, arg also deals strongly with the clock motif, clock ticking and stopwatch as teasers for the arg, etc) though its also able to be triggered manually through strong emotions, pain, and fear. (splash water bottle, dream smile). Z claims uncertainly that it may be genetic, and their writings imply that ranboo isn't the only one though there's no suggestions as to where these other enderwalkers may be.

it oftentime feels like while he's enderwalking he has access to more memories--though it might simply be different memories. he for sure has access to more information about his past (eg. he remembers ender entirely sometimes, while most of the times we see him on screen he's in the process of relearning it, or is at least much more subtle about knowing it.) At times he acts on fully subconscious memories, like when he built the cobblestone end city over l'manhole without realizing exactly what it was or why.

what i think is most important to this understanding though, is that he is SO consistent in what he wants and believes. the things that change are who he knows and associates with, and what he remembers. but ultimately, he has the same goal. he just acts on it differently. people not sides, stopping conflict, being a mediator, ‘one happy family’. these ideas are something he consistently believes in all the time. it’s the context that changes, whether he’s working with dream on the community house, or with tommy and tubbo to kill dream, or wilbur and hitting on 16, he is willing to take extreme measures to pursue these goals.

IMPORTANT TO NOTE: i don’t believe the purple eyes enderwalk trope is strictly diegetic. we know for a fact that ranboo is visibly indistinguishable while enderwalking and not, as we have seen him ‘enderwalk’ on other people’s streams, and he has interacted with people ‘in’ and ‘out’ of the state without them recognizing any difference. (cphil, cfoolish, and cawesamdude as some notable examples)

TLDR: It's just Ranboo, with more, or different, or all of his memories.

(link is to a clip of c!ranboo saying as much based on the information he had at the time)

[calamari-minecraft-corner]

Hey can I pls know more about dnd!Puffy? And like what all went down with her and Dream? How does their meeting again and then later conversation go?

Also, is the syndicate a proper think in this au? And just in general, what're Ranboo and Niki like? Is Steve the polar bear here?

Wow that was an almost completely random assortment of questions, I guess I'm just curious about a lot of things to do with this au :>

Also I just really like the artic commune(my first and most watched pov is Techno's) so I can't help but ask about them :)

Honestly I love random questions like this because I fucking LOVE worldbuilding and character building like YES PLEASE— my Dungeon Master brain goes wild with this so it helps c:

Anyways onto the answers!

1. Puffy is a firbolg Swashbuckler Rogue! Firbolgs are basically half giants and the little thing I have kinda always done with my firbolgs is to make them have more sheep/cow features. Like Caduceus from Critical role

Like this! Also that means she’s like 7 feet tall bc Firbolg are massive.

Anyways— Puffy is Dream’s biological mom in this au- because firbolgs can live to be up to 500 years old! So the math tracks tbh. But yeah she basically raised him on the docks and the ocean, rarely staying in each kingdom for long. When Dream got old enough however he wanted to stay in the Kinoko kingdom because he wanted to help King George (this was before everything) and Puffy let him- she was always supportive of him no matter what.

And when everything happened she was honestly the last one that left him.

Puffy tried to find reasoning for what he was doing- she did. But the more unhinged and more impulsive he got she was obviously worried for her son- and after him breaking his allegiance with George and Sapnap he kinda- went off the deep end.

But he went to her because that’s his mother. And Dream honestly was kinda a mama’s boy back then.

But they got into a big argument when he tried to convince her that the reason why he was doing this was to be beneficial for the continent and that the pain and tragedy would be worth it but she didn’t listen.

He didn’t hurt his mom physically, but he left afterwards and puffy was crushed.

And she joined the final battle to try and stop him- but she didn’t want to hurt him.

She actually went to the prison once to ask if she could see Dream, but Sam told her that he didn’t want to see her- and Puffy believed it and stopped trying.

Fast forward to the current events- Puffy is still a captain, she has no allegiance to anyone and prefers to just make sure the waters are safe. When she firsts sees Dream she doesn’t believe it because he looks drastically different than the last time she saw him/ and she knew something was wrong.

And she heard these new friends (and Fundy) call him Pyre, so she knew something happened.

So she plays it up! Saying that her and Pyre were old friends and that’s why she knew him.

When they’re in private though it’s a lot different. Puffy is worried- concerned on what happened and who did this to him but Dream is too nervous and even stubborn to say otherwise. It takes a bit for him to open up and they do get into an argument one time, him yelling at her and saying why didn’t she visit or at least try and send him something.

But then Puffy tells him that she thought that he said he didn’t want to see her.

And it both clicks for them that Sam was lying to both of them.

After that and the initial shock of the party realizing that’s Dream- things.. simmer. Him and his mom are okayish- they’re rocky but Dream is trying. And Puffy honestly kinda adopts Cala and Spooky since she sees that Cala is trying to help him be better, despite what he’s done and did prior. She hopes it’s a good influence but is worried for all of them. But she still loves her son so so much.

-

2. The syndicate is a thing! But it’s very.. secretive. Like secret secret. Nobody knows about the syndicate, only the monarchs do due to their ways of sabotaging some events as well as going against their laws. But no one knows who’s running it. The Syndicate is a secret faction that works on the belief that there shouldn’t be a monarch system and that these different beliefs aren’t healthy- especially with the restriction of wild magic. So they plan to dismantle it as best as they can and as quietly as they can. Honestly the vibe I get from them is like the Dark Brotherhood from the Elder Scrolls series if that makes sense?

Arctic commune exists though! In the far north is called the “Icebreaker’s Land” which is filled with tundra and Arctic. It’s one of the lands that isn’t run by any kingdom due to how dangerous it is as well as how rural it is. But people still live there! It’s like one of the only options if you don’t want to live in a kingdom, next to the Badlands.

-

3. Niki and Ranboo my beloveds! for Niki, she is a halfling Alchemist Artificer and an Arcane Archer Fighter! Niki was a close supporter of Wilbur back then and they were pretty close friends- but she felt that something was up with him right at the end of the war. And when the war finally ended and he asked her to officially work under his kingdom again- she declined and left. Shes very- conflicted in this au, since she doesn’t know what fully went on with Wilbur but she knows something doesn’t add up. When she’s with the syndicate though it honestly helps her a lot and heals her- but she has her moments. She brings this air of authority around her even though she is a halfling, and Cala honestly looks up to her a lot when they meet.

For Ranboo, Ranboo is a tiefling Aberrant Mind Sorcerer! Ranboo has— been through a lot in this au. He really was only a teenager when the war started and he didn’t realize what was going on.

Dream encountered Ranboo and convinced him to help him- and it resulted in Ranboo being a sorcerer and hating his powers immensely.

Any time Ranboo uses his powers for a long enough time he goes into a blank state, similar to his endwerwalk state actually! And Ranboo was used a lot to help with the battle until Tommy and Tubbo managed to capture him and snap him out of it.

He’s been- coping ever since the war. He’s an adult now- he had a kid with Tubbo and they sadly became distant and they have shared custody. But he’s still unstable, on edge because no one can fix what happened to him except Dream himself. And he does NOT want to see Dream.

It… takes him a while for him to get used to him but he doesn’t forgive what Dream had done to him. He just wants to feel normal but it’s hard- and the course of the au he grows into getting used to his powers after so long.

-

4. Yes Steve the bear is there and he helps a lot, patrolling the commune in general and just being a good emotional support animal for anyone that needs it :3

—

IM SO SORRY THESE ARE SO LONG DHDSJSJ but yes please enjoy this and I hope this answers what it needs to- again I love answering questions like this since I legit planned this au like a dnd campaign HDJDJDKD

[most-tragic-character-tournament]

TUMBLR HAS DECIDED!

THE WINNERS OF THE PRELIMINARY ROUND, WHICH WILL BE ENTERED INTO THE FULL TOURNAMENT BRACKET, ARE:

MINCRAFT DIARIES: Dante & Laurance Zvhal!

ACE ATTORNEY: Maya Fey & Miles Edgeworth!

YU-GI-OH!: Fallen of Albaz & Bakura Ryou!

KAMEN RIDER: Tsukasa Kadoya,* Ukiyo Ace,* & Eiji Hino!

QSMP: q!Charlie Slimecicle & Juana Flippa!

THE MAGNUS ARCHIVES: Jonathan Sims & Micheal Shelley!

FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY’S: Crying Child & Micheal Afton!

CRITICAL ROLE: Zerxus Ilerez & Vax’ildan Vessar!

MARVEL COMICS: Marc Spector//Moon Knight & Loki Laufeyson!

LIFE SMP SERIES: c!Jimmy Solidarity & c!PearlescentMoon!

STAR WARS: Anakin Skywalker & Obi-wan Kenobi!

THE UNTAMED//MO DAO ZU SHI: Wen Qing & Wen Ning!

DREAM SMP: c!TommyInnit & c!Tubbo!

LIFESTEAL SMP [S4]: c!PrinceZam & c!Vitalasy!

GENERATION: LOSS: gl!Niki Nihachu & gl!Ranboo!

PERCY JACKSON: Jason Grace & Nico di Angelo!

HOMESTUCK: Davesprite & Vriska Serket!

RWBY: Penny Polendina & Pyrrha Nikos!

Congratulations to all the winners! See all of the polls themselves in #most tragic preliminaries

*As for the apparent tie we’ve had with Kamen Rider, tomorrow (I am in PST) will begin a 24-hour elimination poll between Tsukasa Kadoya and Ukiyo Ace. Winner takes all!

[stemms]

It's really frustrating that Dream SMP, a story that carefully approached and evoked such a sensitive subject as child abuse, in the most realistic way possible, as well as gave the real-life abuse victims the representation they deserved, didn't get the proper finale that would be mindful of its impact on real life. Not to mention the poor decisions in character and narrative development that only grew worse as the story progressed.

I have a serious complaint about the duration of c!Dream's imprisonment, in terms of narrative development. Keeping c!Dream imprisoned for a whole year added nothing to the plot and only limited the possibilities for the subsequent lore. The first few months were crucial, indeed, as this is when the key events (such as c!Tommy's, c!Bad's, c!Ranboo's and c!Sapnap's visits, the lockdown, c!Tommy's death and revival, c!Dream's torture, and c!Techno's imprisonment) of the prison arc took place (besides his escape, but it could've been carried out earlier, and it wouldn't have changed anything). But I doubt we'd have lost anything if the rest of this arc had been erased. Obviously, the plot's stagnation was caused by the majority of the CCs losing interest in the lore, and as a result, creating lore solely for the views, rather than with passion, as it used to be in the beginning.

Unfortunately, this lack of interest in lore not only resulted in general disappointment due to the lack of complexity in lore, but it spread the victim blaming, that had been ingrained in this fandom nearly since the beginning.

c!Dream's vulnerable position in the prison arc, especially due to the torture, resulted in c!Dream apologists receiving more content with sympathetic c!Dream, infantilising him to the limit, and using it to shift the blame to c!Tommy in particular, as well as the rest of the server, for allowing this to happen. They completely ignored the fact that c!Dream's behaviour during anyone else's visits but c!Tommy's, was an act; after all, they could always say c!Tommy deserved it for being annoying, so why even try using critical thinking? The constant infantilisation of c!Dream was extremely uncomfortable and ableist, and the escalating portrayal of c!Tommy as the ultimate threat and cause of all problems, was harmful to the real-life abuse victims. We shouldn't forget that fiction greatly influences our beliefs and perception of life, and if one excuses blatant abuse in fiction, they may see no wrong in doing the same in real life, if the consequences allow them to. Obviously, it'd probably be a rare exception, but ignoring this possibility completely would certainly do no good.

[forgetmenotcollective]

➙ The Ghost Town Collective

Hello! We are the Ghost Town Collective, a dissociative polyfragmented system, and this is our blog! We may block semi-liberally for system criticism & discourse being brought onto the blog, but we are open to being corrected on mistakes! This is for system-related posts & reblogs! Our main is @theghosttown & you can find our art on @alltheghosties!

➙ Members + Tags

*Introjects sometimes have labelled sources- "Sapphire" will be in blue text, "Crystal" in yellow, and "Lilac" in purple. No source/unlabelled source will be uncolored.

general host tag ⤵

#host posts

Juno/Mouse (she/love) - c & q!Quackity & q!Ironmouse Introject : #lady under the weather & juno.txt

Eden/Hayley (any pronouns, neos included) - Technoblade & Winter Schnee introject : #still so devoted to you & eden.txt

Selene/Matt/Chora (she/he/lune) - c!Ranboo, genloss!Ranboo, cc!Ranboo, q!Tinakitten & c!Tommy introject: #um it's kind of a lot , sel.txt, matt.txt, & chor.txt

Maia Rose (she/they) - hh!rosie (side eye), q!wilbur, c!wilbur, c!dream introject: #and it is well with my soul & mai.txt

*we as a system do not support cc!Dream or cc!Wilbur. introjects are not chosen.

other freq fronters tag ⤵

#ghost posts

Arryn/Quackity (she/lotus) - Protector, c!Quackity introject: #take you down & q.txt

Charlie (any) - Gatekeeper, c!Slimecicle, genloss!Charlie, Slimecicle Cinematic Universe introject: #got something to lose & slime.txt

Thor (any aside from she/her) - Protector, c!Tommy introject: #help the outcasts & thor.txt

Isabela (they/she) - Head Gatekeeper, q!ElQuackity introject: #praise from a new perspective & #isa.txt

Mayree/Drista (she/they/chor/vex) - Head Gatekeeper, c!Drista, Wiggly (Hatchetfield) & @drista-the-parity-goddess / @forksandchaos introject: #spill blood in the court & dris.txt

Kita (she/he/they/blaze) - Primary Protector, c!Sapnap & q!Jaiden introject: #pa' tipo como tú & jai.txt

Dove/Duvessa (she/he) - Protector, c!Tubbo, cc!Tubbo & @tubbos introject: #you are my achilles' heel & tubb.txt & tubbo.txt

tags for other members will often be "name".txt (examples being sam.txt or michael.txt)

➙ Partner Systems

@thelavendersys - lavender system, partner system of near 2 years!

@cupidcottage - cupid, friends

@blubellsys - bluebell system, partner system of near 2 years!

@sunspellers - sunspell system, besties :bweep:

@bundleofnerium - nerium system, partner system

[invisiblesketches]

... so I was scrolling through the ranboo neg (to see what their criticism is) and half is dream stans(? mad abt him congratulating quackity for the qsmp) and the other made me realize I'm in the good side of the fanbase(ppl who still care about c!ranboo and o!ranboo and his other characters)

[thesmpisonfire]

If Las Nevadas fall I'll cry. I'll feel like shit even worse than when L'Manberg was destroyed.

I don't think the Las Nevadas crew deserve any of this shit being pulled on them. They didn't deserve Quackity playing with them to make them enter the nation and now, when they finally decided to join and maybe even heal, they don't deserve to be boxed like that.

They don't deserve to be called the villains for trying to have a home, they don't deserve to be threatened left and right for defending the place they're trying to live. That land was theirs. No one else claimed shit there.

Tubbo was spying on them and then tried to cover it. They built the outpost and the only thing Las Nevadas did was broke some windows and place dirt and stone. THERE WERE TOTEMS OF UNDYING IN THE CHEST AND LAS NEVADAS LEFT IT THERE, because they just wanted the outpost to leave and didn't want to make it something big.

Then, came the first wall and the lava gate. Las Nevadas response? A Toll Both. That's it. A gate that didn't even had a gate. THE OUTPOST HAS A FUCKING GHAST CANNON, but Las Nevadas is the dangerous party here, ain't they?

Quackity, for more shitty his actions has been lately, also is a product of what the server did to him. He tried to be peaceful before, when he had nothing, and all that came was pain. He learnt, from the big leaders, that you have to manipulate your people to get them on your side. He learnt that, in order to be peaceful, you need the power to do so.

So, that's what he did! He manipulated people to join his country and, after that? Quackity really hadn't done anything bad. Hell, he even gave them a choice. You can say anything you want, but that choice choices as genuine. Quackity never wanted to hire an army, he wanted people that could improve his nation and could be his citizens. Even to Fundy, who is legally obligated to fight, he extended the possibility of a choice.

And they all stayed, because guess what? That's the only thing giving their purpose rn. Maybe if Quackity was the one to put this idea in their minds, its true. They know that. Purpled came in bc the UFO was destroyed, but, really, did he had a purpose beforehand? Foolish just built and built, now he has a reason to why do that. And Fundy, the official left behind man, finally has a place where people look at him and care. Even Quackity, he is there bc thats his lifeboat. He originally made this country for El Rapids, but they all left him. So, he was desperate and used his words to get new people. And he meant it when he said he would always protect the ones who protect him.

They are all there bc the server failed them. They wouldn't be manipulated if the server had tried to heal them.

Tubbo going "you disappeared!" as if he also didn't fly off to build Snowchester. The only difference is that Tubbo was never abandoned. Ranboo can pretend to keep his moral high ground as much as he wants, but his friendships all lie in blood. He points everyone's flaws but not his own. He stands by the fight and says "its their fault, I am not involved" when the pure action to not do anything is his fault.

Las Nevadas has nothing. They only have each other and that piece of land. That's their last chance to be happy in their eyes.

Tubbo and Ranboo have Snowchester far away and out of danger, they have Michael who is also out of danger. They have nukes. Ranboo is allied with Philza and Technoblade, the guys who caused Doomsday. They have no positions to look at 5 people armed only with the netherite in their bodies and say "They are dangerous and deserve to be boxed and threatened".

Quackity doesn't even want to fight!! He was ready to give up at their plot of land and just build around it. He allowed Tubbo to spy on them, as long as the big stone was taken down. Quackity did anything to set peace, because he thought he finally had power to do so.

But he was wrong, he is the most powerless of that situation.

Las Nevadas was trying to heal in themselves, and they don't deserve to have a nuke pointed to their faces because someone else said they didn't had the rights to do so.

[lasnevadaschips]

I really don't want Las Nevadas to go out with a bang, both literally and metaphorically. Las Nevadas is something that c!Quackity built on his own through his abandonment, trauma and loneliness. He has yet to succeed in making a competent country. But, for now he has something flashy..

A bright city that looks like paradise but is much more power hungry the more you dig into his circle of control. Control he's never had before- he's the main threat now even though he hasn't done anything! All that he's done now to look like a threat are done to people within his circle and Dream, no one else really knows what Las Nevadas is looking to achieve. Even if they're reaching so hard to make it look like a threat. (Low-key shade toward c!Tubbo and c!Ranboo but I digress)

Q's tactics are words first then violence, framing himself as a victim or as the "forced to do this" defense.

So...

Las Nevadas will go out with a whimper. Everyone in Quackitys circle leaves, realizing his manipulation or discovering his cruelty towards others. Quackity is alone, nobody is on his side. Nobody wants to truly destroy the country, it's just there and nobody really goes to it. Which is a total slap to the face, he wanted this country to be the talk of the smp not a forgotten country like El Rapids.

Possibly in a last ditch effort to win back his found family members he does something drastic that scorns his reputation, making it even worse somehow. Having no choice but to go back to the worst of the worst, other people who were bigger threats back in the SMP's infancy with no results, or results that fit his narrative, leading to his demise by their hands or someone just pitying Quackity.

TLDR; Please for the love of God don't let Techno kill him.

[proudfreakmetarusonikku]

like, what is c!dream's lore outside of c!tommy? can you tell me anything about c!dteam apart from them being friends? can you tell me any noticeable character trait that doesn’t stem from his storyline with c!tommy?

i remember seeing this one tweet from a c!dream apologist saying “we have to dig so far to find things about c!dream” and like that’s obviously poor media literacy bc they refuse to acknowledge any of his relationship with c!tommy. but genuinely it’s the best criticism of his writing- because, what is he without c!tommy? you do, as they said, have to spend hours looking for any discernible traits, and as they also said, you get something like “he likes fish”, which isn’t a personality trait or particularly interesting. c!dream is a phenomenal character, but none of that comes from the boring ass, barely existent lore outside of c!tommy that inevitably crashed and burned after a few streams. remember micheal mcchill? remember fucking ranboo? hell, even tommy had to beg for months for that shitty finale.

like there’s a reason c!dream's lore outside of c!tommy crashed and burned. and i mean it’s good for me bc it means i get to make c!prime stuff but like mans was written by tommyinnit and it shows like the only time we got consistent c!dream content was when tommy wrote him he deserves custody.