#And critics will be more meaningful
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
People really be talking about peace and love and understanding of others and social justice, then the moment a villain in a children cartoon sees the errors of their way and gets redeemed through love and understanding they yell outraged that they didn't use a guillotine
#Thinking again about steven universe unfair treatment#But this also applies in general#Besides the fact that deserved redemption in a show isn't linked to the villain actions but to how they're portrait by the writers#People in general really need to stop thinking too hard about inconsistencies and stuff in a show with 5yo target demografic#There's a time and a place for some kinds of judgment#And honestly there are things that we as older audience are meant to ignore or just mindlessly go with it#Because a kid wouldn't care#And making something entertaining and fun is more important than a continuity error#That's not to say children media can't be coherent and with complex characters and storylines#But I'm still more willing to let go mistakes in these cases#The target age plays a hard role in that for me#If you're that unable to do that and get outraged because children cartoon characters don't act like real people would then just drop it#Drop children media and go watch or read something for YOUR target demografic#I assure you you'll be happier#And critics will be more meaningful
35 notes
·
View notes
Text
you hate solas x mythal because you think solas shouldn't have had any previous relationships in thousands of years of his life
i hate solas x mythal because it's yet another exhausting love triangle where the slaver and abuser gets a funky reincarnation and the victim gets blamed for absolutely everything and put into magical prison forever..........
we are not the same
#and it's not even 100% clear what they even WERE#the further we go the less and less i respect week's “~it's up to your interpretations~”#solas#mythal#solavellan#dragon age#dav#grow a fucking spine dude#you WILL inevitably piss off at least one part of the fandom by making mythal either solas's lover or mother figure (jesus this is cursed)#as it probably would've been when confirming him either have sex with lavellan or being ace#but now you're just pissing everyone off by inability to commit to your own shit#actually DA has one of the most obnoxious love triangles I've ever seen lol#Also (imho) it would've been much more interesting to make Elgar'nan and Mythal actually y'know#LOVE each other despite still being toxic and unhealthy and maybe even codependent#like not every meaningful relationship in people's lives just HAS to be romantic weeks#Mansplain-Manipulate-Malewife Elgar'nan 🤝 Gaslight-Gatekeep-Girlboss Mythal#I have spoken#bioware critical#i guess
115 notes
·
View notes
Text
okay i typed this in a reply but i need to say this more detailed here too, the way totk dealt with horses (and stables) is bad and worse than botw imo (yes i can rant about that too, these weird choices are in every little spot in totk, its almost impressive)
in a game that lets you build cars and stupid flying maschines, towers that shoot you into the stratosphere AND teleporting points all over the place, the chance is already low that you use a horse- though i would be one of them bc i love horses and hate building and didnt find it fun at all-
(also i almost never used any parts i had with me bc you cant put them back and your dumb vehicles despawn as soon as you dont look at them- also a negative thing about that system that reinforces the feeling of actually using it being more punishing than rewarding with the added bonus of the good ol saving your health potions forever problem)
-and something i DID like was that you can have more horses and the ... one.. new color (the lil spots but only AFTER you do that one quest in the spy post)
the stable points seemed like a neat idea, but like so many things, are utterly cheatable, imo the system should have only given you a point when you visit a new stable, so you actually have to go around and visit them all
(also .. add new stables, like mini ones or sth that dont offer beds- you dont need that anyway- so you have more places in which you can get them ... why did they remove some of them anyway, shouldn there be MORE now that the land is supposedly healing/being repaired? especially the one next to the big canyon, its so empty there it would have the perfect place for sth like a new settlement or a big boss arena but no its more empty than it was before, why?? and then putting yet another repeating annoying quest there in that weirld empty place?? i just dont get it)
letting you farm points by sleeping at a stable or bringing in a horse gives you LESS incentive to actually go around the world bc you can just farm it there
(and if that was done so youd 'discover' the malanya talks to you in your sleep 'secret' ... that is literally told to you, and if its bc you dont want to force players to go around and find every stable to get all those rewards ... why do you have 140 or whatver caves then with the majority of them being the literal same thing over and over ... to make people actually use the sleeping thing there? .. why, who uses that anyway, and farming points by sleeping there .. what the hell does that add? AND THEN the stupid sleep over tickets, probably the most nothign reward ever, dont count?? i dont think i ever used one- it just all doesnt make any sense, everything plays against each other)
the upgrading system for your horse is .. once again, a neat idea horribly executed, you have to go find malanya to upgrade them, and similarly stupidly like the fairies, they only tell you what food you need for what upgrade when you are there .. or when you are sleeping in the special tm bed at a stable, randomly, one food, bc the quantity changes too
which is just so ??????????? let me go and do a quest that rewards you with a lil booklet in which you can look up what an upgrade costs, or let the stables have that, either as a list or in the menu when selecting a horse or something?? (also why the hell is malanya in a different spot anyway, like, it feels like a modder just plopped them over there, their og spot is just empty now - except for yet again a stupid filler quest for .. another big horse and a yaaaaaaaaays crystal shrine quest- ... the spot is even still called spring of the horse god .... its so stupid, just like the fairy shuffling around, like you really couldnt think of a better way to reuse that concept other than to ... move it to a different spot in the same map and map level???? and not change anything in their og spot except idk, put a hole in the map ... for one of them like .. its like they moved them around last minute just to have the semblance of things being 'changed' with no regard what makes a change actually feel like one and what just feels like, pick up thing, click on random spot on map, drop thing- its like that for the fairies and shrines too, its so dumb and .. feels disrepectful to botw and how much thought seemed to have went into these spots that were clearly built about those things)
and like it couldnt get WORSE, they cut off the paths that horses follow automatically with one of those miasma buttholes (sorry its just a hole cut into the map, it doesnt even look like miasma burst through, it just .. cut out) a monster camp (that RESPAWNS, i thought those camps you clear with a quest would stay clear, but that would make sense, so of course it respawns and you can do the frame rate killer quest over and over yippieee) or otherwise like, with a big rock or a broken bridge-
and there is NO WAY to create a new path or fix or move anything in a game ABOUT BUILDING supposedly, like you needed more reasons to never use a horse????? i liked jsut hopping on and letting them follow a path and chill looking at the landscape, you cant do this here, and you cant even excuse it with 'its bc of the theme' as in, stuff is destroyed bc calamity 1.5 or whatever bc nothing in the game makes it feel like theres anything actually at stake, but the real crime is to make it not be fixable. WHY??? link moves entire buildings with ease but cant move one freaking rock that fell into a river?????? you swing around logs like a club but cant fix a bridge so your horse can get over it??????????????????????????????
#ganondoodles talks#zelda#ganondoodles rants#totk critical#i know i know its long#and you may wonder how i can find things to rant about yet#and i swaer im not trying to find thigns to hate#but igven how much it reuses from botw#imporvement or at least meaningful change should be the minimum and they just ......dont .... again#like WHY this is so dumb.................#the more i try to get my feelings into coherent thoughts about this game the more i realize just how rushed it feels#even the detail or side mechanics either dont make sense#or have some sort of way to cheat around way too obviously to be something overlooked#or are poorly integrated#or cheapen antoehr function#like these problems are everywhere#and the longer you look at it the cheaper it looks#even if you love the game and dont mind it or whatever there is NO WAY to justify that price tag#and so wish they were honest about what happend#it cant just all be covid can it? theres so much wrong in every part except for sound and music#and so desperately want to know WHY#........ i just wanted more horse colors- more horse slots- and a lil pasture somewhere where i can see them all frolicking around#i feel like thats not too much to ask
126 notes
·
View notes
Text
cw: harry potter, jk rowling, transphobia
I occasionally see posts/get messages about the various harry potter references in the bright sessions, etc. and I've gotten a bunch of new followers recently so just so any new/younger listeners of my shows know:
jk rowling is a terrible transphobe whom I hold zero respect for and I haven't given a dime of my money to her since she revealed who she truly is. I want the whole bright universe to be a safe space for trans people (including the trans folks in our cast and crew!) and if I could go back and remove those references, I would. but I can't! harry potter was an extremely significant part of my life until...well, until it became very clear who she really was. it makes me so sad to think that folks might be finding TBS now and get thrown out of the story by these references, but just know that the people who made the show do not stand by jk, and that in many ways, the show is a product of its time.
#the bright sessions#harry potter#jk rowling#transphobia#I know there's PLENTY to say about the bigotry in the actual books and I think there's a lot of merit to those criticisms#and I'll own to choosing not to see some of that stuff before all this went down bc the books were meaningful to me#(this is not HP specific - another beloved childhood book series that was EVEN more formative to me growing up)#(is also something I've grappled with in recent years bc I think the author is actually probably wildly misogynistic)#(even though he's never behaved badly (far as I know) in his public life - there's stuff in the text)#BUT ANYWAY#it can be so hard to remember that we didn't have ANY inkling of her bigotry in this regard until 2018#all of the original run of TBS was written before that#and I'll admit I gave jk the benefit of the doubt in 2018 re: her liking that tweet! I wanted to give her a chance to learn and grow#and she did....not do that#but TAMA was written in that little grace period#and then a few references in TCT were taken out during recording bc june of 2020 was when she really started to go mask off#and so we were making changes in real time#we didn't know what to do about quidditch#bc we were like 'this is a sport that people play in college and it's just called that?'#'and it's already canon that caleb plays?'#and it wasn't called quadball yet#anyway not trying to make excuses!#just know that none of those references were put in with any malice#and I guess I *could* go back and rerecord all those lines and replace them#but I know enough about my original audio engineering to know that it woudl be VERY hard to make it sound natural#and idk I do think there's something to be said for not covering up errors in old work#I'm not going to try to pretend HP wasn't important to me#EDIT: I've turned off reblogs for this post#also this is not me trying to tell other people how to approach their own HP fandom#fanworks especially - there's no benefiting jo in that - and I think it's totally legit for ppl to want to take HP as their own!
159 notes
·
View notes
Text
Daydreaming and wondering why SJM never once thought to perhaps have done a romance between Cassian or Azriel with Rhysand’s sister as their past love interest? It would make more sense as she would have been within Illyria far more than Mor. Perhaps live in that house alongside their mother, which they all grew up in.
It could have been a whole little trope of 'brother's best friend/ best friend sister' with the addition of nobility hierarchy and inadequacy. Plus, I don't recall a single Illyrian couple within these books. It's always Illyrian's with a High fae and I dunno; seems a bit sad and really pounding down that Illyrians are just worth nothing; not even love between them, apparently. It would have given a chance at getting to know more about Rhysand’s sister as a character than a far away memory despite meaning so much to these people: for starters, what's her NAME?
#sjm critical#acotar#rhysand’s sister#Rhysand#cassian#Azriel#missed opportunity#these guys are more than 500 and lack a meaningful dating history...its weird 🤔#acotar critical
25 notes
·
View notes
Note
The line is actually on the next page (4), the same page where Twice puts on his black shirt. It's the third panel. There's a second another speech bubble commenting on Endeavor's fans being mostly young men.
"While the number of incidents Endeavor's resolved is certainly high, the instances where his furious disposition has gone too far are are not few either." Chapter 115
Oh Iam so sorry anon!!
Yeah this is spot on! And also very much holds your point and so does the previous page.
Enji is incredibly violent and thats not a good look heck the heroes, the civilians and the villains don't like him but I suppose he is high on the list for the amount of work he is done and the weird demographic that he has seemed to acquire.
I want to comment on that demographic but I don't think I can actually put it into a proper conscience response so I won't say much but what I will say is that it's not a good look on enji and something something about toxic masculinity and the whole red pill ideology.
We haven't actually seen a lot of enji fans in canon but the ones we have seen aka inasa end up being very questionable characters.
This is also the reason when all might points out that enji and bakugo are similar or that bakugo and enjis have parallels it's not a good look on bakugo (even if enji gets a horrible attornment arc)
That aside I do actually wanna talk about how the reporter says that we shouldn't passively protect the status quo just in the end for the status quo to be preserved and be uplifted by hawks and the heroes.
#mha critical#mha#bnha critical#horikoshi critical#bnha#bhna critical#thanks for the ask#thanks for the ask!#thanks anon#thanks anon!#anti enji#anti enji todoroki#anti endeavour#anti endeavor#status quo still ends up beinh protected in the end#i really wanna comment on enjis fans age demographic but i simply cant#although its making me think of red pill mf and those types of influencers#also surprisingly both in fandom and in canon most enji fans are men in that demographic (the ones i know at least)#its not a good look on bakugo at all to be compared to enji#however i do think its much more meaningful to have bakugo grow out of it and have the two characters face different paths#that's not saying that all of his fans are like that#but its simply making me think in that direction
29 notes
·
View notes
Text
when you make a point and then someone goes "yeah! I agree that *a completely different misinterpretation of your point that they missed entirely*" like. dude. that wasn't at all what I said where did you even get that
#shitpost#wow tags look weird now why do they keep changing things#anyway i said I didn't like ai art because it steals from artists#and my teacher was like yeah you have a good point art might be devalued if its oversaturated in the market#like??? that's a completely different and also wrong point!#human art will always be more valuable and meaningful than ai#i was talking about the copyright and control artists should have over their art being disrespected and discarded#how did you even get to an oversaturated market like. my guy#he repeated it in front of the CLASS that wasn't what I SAID#at least i'd said my point out loud so anyone with critical thinking skills knows he said my point wrong#but like. dude#-_-
252 notes
·
View notes
Text
Part of me feels like if you enjoy and/or are involved in the fandom of IWTV, knowing how a rather significant part of the show is set in Dubai (a part of the UAE), you should be aware of, and taking action about what's going on in Sudan.
To explain: the UAE has been exploiting Sudan for its resources in gold (mostly), and in many ways actively fueling the war there to get it. Making the UAE a responsible party for the multiple humanitarian crisis happening there; over 6 million displaced peoples, genocidal massacres, extreme sexual violence, etc. - just look into it.
There's been a demand not to travel to the UAE/Dubai for this reason. Luckily, from what I gather they don't film those scenes on location, except for the aerial driving sequence in Season 1 episode 1. This would've also been before the war started in Sudan where this such demand wasn't in place (as far as I'm aware). Which is good for fans as it means enjoyment can just be critical and not reason to turn it off.
Anyway, just something to very much consider.
#Not saying fans have to be super informed or vocal about it online or they're a pos btw tho its always good to see ppl doing more#I guess becoming at least a bit more invested in Sudan is the minimum ask here#I'd say it is almost like your duty as a fan to be aware and critical with these things#If you don't wanna engage the politics surrounding your favorite shows that just tells me you're not a fan in any meaningful way#iwtv#interview with the vampire#amc interview with the vampire#amc iwtv#Personally the UAE being the way it is adds another layer of dimension to them being there - a greater depth of analysis to incorporate#but on the other hand there's degrees of separation between the show and our reality and one should always put more weight on reality#Analysis into location can be fun if you have it but it shouldn't outweigh like the real world with its real problems
23 notes
·
View notes
Text
Excerpt from 2024 人物 interview, found here:
For example, [while redoing the album] Qian Lei "forced" him to write a song. Qian Lei thought, this new album was extremely significant to him, so there should be a song Zhou Shen wrote himself. What's more, others have criticized him for not being able to compose. But Qian Lei knows he can---and quite well too. "It's not possible someone with strong emotions and a sensitive heart to not be able to write a good melody, it's completely not possible." Usually, Zhou Shen will hum out a melody and record it with his phone---sound engineer Xu Wei has listened to them and thought the melody lines were really good, and could absolutely be straightened out into an original song. But Zhou Shen always felt it wasn't good enough, and even said, to compose beside such a skilled composer like Lei-ge, it would be like an elementary schooler insisting on reciting their composition in front of a doctorate holder---so imprudent. His friends all know his personality---for a "master in self-deprication," being unduly humble was a daily occurrence. His old friend of ten years, lyricist 沃特艾文儿 said: "Not just composing---when I first met him, he even thought his singing was bad. It was so upsetting to me. I'm very relieved that he at least recognizes his singing ability now." Qian Lei has also listened to Zhou Shen's compositions before, and told him, isn't this pretty good? Zhou Shen said, don't mess with me. Qian Lei said, I'm serious, I'm not joking, it's quite good. Zhou Shen said, bye bye. Qian Lei said, bye bye yourself. Thus, when working on the new album, he would use every means possible to force him to write a song. One moment he would "hold a hammer behind him and get him to hurry up and write," the next moment he would set his mind at ease, saying "you don't have to overthink it, gradually the more you write the easier it will be. I'm here, so don't worry." This song was written at Qian Lei's home---once the first step of writing was taken, the rest went smoothly. Musically, Zhou Shen already had things in mind, and a few hours later, the main melody was basically set. Zhou Shen also participated a lot in writing the lyrics. He really liked the line "I can catch the flowers floating in the wind; I don't care whether I fall into the galaxy or into the mud." But "no matter how I sang it, it felt a little off, like it was missing something." He hummed it and hummed it, and out of nowhere added a soft, low, even a little "rude", "嘿,少管我," and "suddenly it came to life." Before, Zhou Shen had always wanted to write a song called "少管我." In his earlier years, he had randomly used these words in replies to fans, and in an interview where he talked about how his fans were never satisfied no matter what he changed his profile picture to, he ended up jokingly shouting "少管我, " and it then went viral. After that, Zhou Shen thought, as a singer, if one day I could turn "少管我" into a song, how interesting would that be. These past few years, he found a lot of people to compose its melody, but he always felt the melodies weren't quite what he wanted. The album that was cancelled also had a song in it named "少管我," but he still felt it wasn't quite right. Until now, it came to him like a "gift" from above. The first impression many people get from these three words is more or less rigid, sharp, harsh, stubborn, and capricious. But to Zhou Shen, a rebellious attitude is easy but truly knowing yourself is a long journey. "It's not necessarily about rebelling against the whole world, but you have to clearly know what version of yourself you want to be, and only then can you become yourself."
The day of the interview at an art park in Tongzhou, Beijing, the sky darkened a little. Zhou Shen took out his cell phone and played the unmixed recording of "少管我." The melody was light, "like travelling, very free." He shook his head to beat, and listened to the song he had listened to countless times one more time. "When I was writing this song and its lyrics, I didn't have "少管我" in mind, but in the end it became the "少管我" that I wanted." Moments like these, sparks flying, you think, "that’s right"---that's the biggest joy in making an album.
#zhou shen#my translations#uuuhhh this was supposed to be a quick translation why is it so long asdfASDFASD#this post is how i learned that tumblr doesn't like it when u have too many paragraphs in a row indented OTL#but IT DOESNT TELL U IT JUST GIVES U AN ERROR MSG??? SO ANNOYING ASDFASD#speaking of annoying.... all the ppl who criticize zs for not writing his own songs#which is ridiculous for SOOOO many reasons#and like?? there's so many artists out there who are just releasing any and whatever garbage (sorry lol) they come up with#and like!!!!! thats absolutely not bad or wrong at all#but u just KNOW zhou shen could do SO MUCH BETTER#if only he was a little more confident in himself AAAAAAAAA#AND NOW WE HAVE SHAO GUAN WO WHICH IS SO CATCHY AND ADDICTIVE AND SO MEANINGFUL ;;#PLS RELEASE ALL THE ORIGINAL MELODIES YOUVE RECORDED SHENSHEN ;;#U MIGHT THINK ITS GARBAGE BUT ITS TREASURE TO US ;;;;;;;;#anyways there's a LOT (A LOT A LOT) in this interview that makes me feel like screaming crying throwing up#i might?? translate more excerpts?? idk i dont wanna step on resident 大师 presume's toes in case they were planning on having a go at it LOL#but anyways this is pretty unedited sorry LOL#i need to sleep now zzzzzz
23 notes
·
View notes
Text
I also don't think hbomberguy's video about RWBY is very good this is because I do not inherently agree with everybody who dislikes RWBY because sometimes their problem is less that they think some things were handled poorly and more that they don't really enjoy any aspect of the show and I think you can differentiate these attitudes by the amount of nitpicking being done. Like. I think it's worth mentioning the objectification of Yang early in the series (Kerry calling her "everyone's dream girl," her inexplicable romantic relationship with an adult man that is not seriously addressed) when discussing the overall trend of misogynistic tropes in the series, sure, that makes sense, but like, why the fuck should I care that they (probably) called them "volumes" because Miles Luna based some things on ATLA and they're called "books" in that series? Idk. I find it very silly.
#Rbs off on this one cause its more me bitching about people who claim to be doing critical readings who are actually#just parroting shit that a youtuber said without thinking about it at all#I think it's a kind of lame video I honestly think it'd only be a third of the length if it was meaningful criticisms Only#talk#rwby
19 notes
·
View notes
Text
Annoying fandom people when you tell them characters do things based on writers’ decisions and biases and are not fully autonomous sapient beings they’re watching in a terrarium
#babbles#this is in general an ideal i hold very close in fandom stuff but like especially abt wc cuz that fandom sucks with this#i hate warriors fans so much it’s unreal. it’s not ‘these writers have weird ideas about what is romantic’ but ‘this character is toxic!!1’#boiling down what can be a meaningful discussion about abuse and patriarchal standards into a purely blorbobrained character argument#about in universe traits like these characters are real and we need to give them counseling#because having the 500th soapbox about bramblestar or nightheart or whoever being abusive makes you feel progressive#like. i'd love to discuss for instance the misogynistic standards that the erins have as writers and how that affects their work.#i dont however care to discuss which Fictional Cat For Ten Year Olds is the most Problematic. bc that does nothing#reminds me of that tweet abt like the fatphobic trope of chars being depressed or hitting a low point and being fat slobs#and ppl came in waves like 'no it makes sense because he was depressed and xyz etc etc' like we're discussing a real person#and not constructs made by writers that show fatphobic ideologies. missed the point so hard dude.#less 'character does this' more 'writer made the character do this'. not even in criticism but in discussing themes etc etc
110 notes
·
View notes
Text
Atla live action 😐
#thats my honest reaction 😐#to be fair ive only seen 20 minutes of the s1 finale bc my parents are watching it but. mmmmm kinda mid#like. the casting is definitely an improvement since the last time they tried a live action but it feels like the writing falls flat#or maybe im being harsh bc ive only heard negative criticism on it beforehand. but fr anytime u bring up the original its already#good and not just because its the original. so much fucking detail went into it to the point of someone noticing azula wielding mai's knive#to how well thought out irohs character is used as a way of uniting the cast especially as zukos foil#i heard that sokkas sexism was toned down and i have to agree that feels like a cheap move. like i get WHY they think it would be better#but its not about how that reflects on real world its about how it affects the story. sokka starts out as a misogynistic asshole because#it makes it that much more impactful when he changes. toning that down makes it flatter and makes his character development weak#and someone pointed out they didnt even make him wear the kyoshi warrior uniform and i know it feels like such a small detail but#come on man. they did that in the original because not only does it help him really walk in their shoes - wearing 'feminine' clothing and#makeup and having suki explain its significance but it also ties in with the shows theme of harmony and intersectionality#i was also disappointed when they had the fire sages explain how the water tribe draws power from the moon because in the original it was#IROH who explained it to aang and everyone else BECAUSE we as the audience is under the impression hes with the 'bad guys'#and it builds up to how he learned from the other nations which reconciles his past as a war general and his character overall#AND its an excellent starting point for the cast and audience to understand how the nations arent as closed off as you would think#plus you would think its only fire nation doing propaganda but they expanded on that with earth kingdom censorship and it WORKS#a lot of things in the live action also feel arbitrary like. they gave momo a near death experience for 5 minutes for no reason#im firmly on the stance of bringing back filler moments instead of putting major events right after each other so that u give your#audience a sense of time passing and to really absorb the story. but i think thats more like shock value than filler and yeah its a small#thing to gripe about but those things build up and its really annoying. the thing abt avatar filler moments is that however small#its at least meaningful. hell even the beach episode emphasizes how isolated zuko and his friends are as child soldiers#i also swore to never watch the first live action since it was that bad but i really liked the stylized tattoos they used for aang#anyway. those arejust my thoughts. im not gonna watch the rest because im a ride or die for the original aftr growing up and#rewatching it at least 20 times as a kid. but theres definitely room for improvement and i wish ppl wouldnt take it as 'better' just cuz#netflix is adapting it. i wouldve killed for them to just reanimate the entire avatar series and touch NOTHING ELSE no redub#no changes to the story. just reanimate the thing and leave the rest alone and youd make easy money just the same#ALSO its very jarring not hearing jack desena and dante basco voicing sokka and zuko cause their voices were the most recognizable to me#i get that its because its live action but im allowed to feel a little sad abt that. and uncle irohs accent was really soothing#yapping
48 notes
·
View notes
Text
I'm vaguely following up the dragon age situation from afar, as I'm not super intimate with the franchise, but it seems to me we're still sliding down the same slide that began its slope at the citadel dlc and led to andromeda, and now to these increasingly toothless takes on bioware's IPs, and it's very unfortunate but I can't say I'm surprised :/
#bioware critical#this is making me pretty much already write off the next mass effect which sucks!! but yeah#there's a corporate niceness sheen that's been applied to everything bioware has been putting out since 2015 more or less#that even retro-applies to stuff they've been putting out from before#like the over-focus on romance and flattening of character arcs (hi mordin) and disregard of worldbuilding and atmosphere for me#the aversion to meaningful conflict has been a huge problem in bioware's writing since at least a decade now imo#especially social-driven and political-driven conflict#not saying it was always done super well#but at least it was not only there but a constant driving force that helped selling these worlds were alive and worth caring about
12 notes
·
View notes
Text
it's a deeply silly connection, but i think about trent and the critic's speech from ratatouille a lot
#trent crimm#gertspeak#'we [critics] risk very little' '[negative criticism] is fun to write and to read'#'[but the truth is] the average piece of junk is probably more meaningful than our criticism designating it so'#'but there are times when a critic truly risks something [...] the new needs friends'#etc etc .
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
bf just got very excited about a book series that came across his for you page somewhere and then we had to spent twenty minutes trying to figure out if this author used Ai to write or 'just' the covers and audio books
#the panic button response to ai use in any way is excessive imo#genuinely its a good idea to investigate what and how it was used in any given project before passing judgment#but a multi paragraph screed in your own faq about how ai generation is a tool that allows you to write deeper and more meaningful work#makes me think very little of your actual writing skills and also your critical thinking. sorry.
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
persona 5 had so much potential to be one of the greatest social commentaries of its decade in, hell, not even just in gaming and they fucking blew it by giving us fanservice of minors with gigantic tits and totally not pedophilic romance options as opposed to thematically poignant queer relationship options and you expect me to not be pissed off?? like ur kidding
#the style of the game!!#the advertising!!#it was supposed to be so much sicker than it came out#not to say that p5 isn’t fantastic#because it is#but it could’ve been more#you are a slave. want emancipation??#GODD THAT COULD HAVE BEEN SO MUCH MORE MEANINGFUL#but noooo#atlus after betraying its games own ideals to drag in an audience the persona franchise was never meant to have#makes me so upset#especially when you look back on their history#they couldn’t commit to the darkness they implied with all of persona 5’s promotional content#mfs after writing about outcasts and then bullying the outcasts#wish that they couldve rounded it all off with the theme they started with like in persona 3#it makes me so upset#persona 5#persona 3#atlus#rant post#persona 5 criticism#out of love because it’s still somehow my favourite game
10 notes
·
View notes