frostfires-blog

[frostfires-blog]

I'm really trying hard to find the "happy marriage" part in the "My Happy Marriage" anime right now...

No, like they should've called it "My Tumultuous Enagement" instead...

[frostfires-blog]

HANANENE × TBHK S2 EP08

[frostfires-blog]

having sha hualing’s introduction right after liu qingge’s really is comedic gold. shen qingqiu spends whole pages talking about how cool liu qingge is and how pretty he is and how can a man be so attractive. and then he sees sha hualing, acknowledges that she’s another popular character and then is like "her clothes really aren’t suited to the situation" like okay gay boy

[frostfires-blog]

Can we collectively stop being so harsh on shoujo FLs? Like for the past month I've seen several people hating on a high school girl for "being weak and always crying"... Is it wrong for female characters to be introspective and vulnerable these days? Who has perfect emotional control and awareness in their teens anyway?

P.S. Look I get it if you prefer an FMC that's more confident and assertive but not every character can be like that.

[frostfires-blog]

Hello, how are you? Just want to say again, thanks so much for this blog of yours. I got many great anime recs from you and I learn lot, too (you made me interested in the meaning of flowers). 😆🤩😁

I really love how passionate you wrote your posts and when you answered questions.

Because you have inspired me with a lot of great recommendations and your lovely reviews, do you mind if I also share some of my favorite manga and anime series?

A.) I Want to be A Wall

This is my all time favorite. It's completed with 3 volumes. The story is about ace woman who married a gay man. They don't end up in romantic sense but have a great platonic relationship with each other. Bonus the mc is also a fujo....

B.) My Love Mix Up (Kieta Hatsukoi)

If you're a fan of romcom, then you'll love this series! It's completed with 9 volumes. The mc is so funny and such a disaster bi. This story focused on m/m relationship with a great m/f side ship!

C.) Banana Fish

I was really surprised when found out that it's a shoujo. So this series is my no. 1 favorite shoujo ever (no. 2 is "I Want to be A Wall" and no. 3 is "Akatsuki no Yona") and the mc is my all time favorite character (he is still in my top 5 fav). The drama and action scenes are amazing. And I adore the bond between the mc and ml. I love both the anime and the manga. It's completed with 19 volumes manga and 24 episodes anime.

D.) Stars Align

It's a sports anime with a heavy LGBTQ themed. The story is so good and the characters are great! The only sad thing is the anime is cut off so they only have 12 episodes. You'll not regret it after finishing it.

E.) Wotakoi : Love is Hard for Otaku

You can't imagine how excited I am when I know that you also love "Kiss Him Not Me" anime. I love it. Have you read the manga? Oh, spoiler, the 2 guys who like Serinuma, actually end up together...!

Now, this series (Wotakoi) is a story about otakus that all worked in an office. It's more of a slice of life/romance, completed with 11 episodes and 3 OVA. Bonus the mc and female lead are both fujos!

Another thing, the mangaka behind Wotakoi and Kiss Him are also BL mangaka.

F.) Hakata Tonkotsu Ramens

I just love this series so much! The action scenes are so cool! And the characters' dynamics are great! It's completed with 12 episodes.

Bonus!

♡ Classmates - Doukyuusei

It's one of my first BL anime. And it's one of my favorite anime to rewatch. Their relationship is so sweet. When you finished it, I think you should read the manga, too. When reading the manga, we can also see their relationship grew. It's completed with 7 volumes.

Sorry for this long ask. If you don't like either of the title above, I'm sorry. Hope you can find new favorite, too, @frostfires-blog 🌻

Hello again; I am fine, and how are you? Thank you for all your support! I'm constantly blown away that there are people who actually enjoy reading my ramblings and learn from them...

I truly appreciate recommendations, but I often feel guilty that I often only get around them way later than anticipated. For a while now, I've been going through a lot and have been struggling to manage my time as a result. Consequently, my watchlist has grown significantly and is often further delayed by the influx of new seasonal releases. One of my resolutions for this year was to finish the manga for several anime series that I've enjoyed that haven't received sequels. I've kept putting this off, but I really want to do this since many of the manga I've been keeping up with are ending soon, have already ended or are on hiatus. Thank you so much for the suggestions, but I hope it's okay if I put them on my list and don't check them out right away. On another note, I don't mind people accidentally recommending something I've already seen, especially when I like said series as it allows me to talk about it. Although I should probably try to post more about the more obscure series I have watched... If anyone has any ideas on how I can do that then let me know.

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

A.) I Want To Be A Wall Wow, this premise sounds really unique! I barely read manga series that don't have anime adaptations—since I typically like having a base to better visualise things—but I definitely want to check this one out when I have time.

B.) My Love Mix Up I've been wanting to check out this series for a while now. I've been holding off in hopes that it got an anime adaptation since there's a drama adaptation...but I should probably give up and just go read the manga at this point.

C.) Banana Fish Although I've never read the manga, I watched Banana Fish anime back in 2022. At first, I was also surprised to learn that it was a shoujo series—but in hindsight, I think it makes sense and wouldn't categorise it any other way. Off-topic, but I've been watching a lot of YouTube videos about the shoujo manga industry from @Colleen'sMangaRecs and it's really changed the way I perceive shoujo and josei animanga as a whole. I've realised that I allowed internalised misogyny to hold me back from acknowledging a lot of shojosei series I liked. As such my top 20 series list now is almost completely different to that of 3 to 5 years ago. Getting back to Banana Fish, my favourite part of the series was definitely the compelling character dynamics and music. Ash and Eiji's bond is so nuanced and intricate. While I think it is a good show, I really was caught off guard when I watched it and probably shouldn't have watched it during the timeframe I did. While I'm very glad that we have a series like this, I tend to favour series that are a bit less heavy.

D.) Stars Align I haven't seen this series, but I've seen a random scene of it online before and damn I was shocked...For reference, it was the flashback of how one of the characters got the burn on his back... I haven't seen a sports anime in a while so I should probably back into the genre sometime...

E.) Wotakoi: Love Is Hard For Otaku Wotakoi is actually one of my favourite josei series! I've finished both the anime and manga. It's practically the only romance series where I like all of the canonical pairings. While the series' music, voice-acting, humour and character dynamics are all great, an underappreciated aspect of this series is its setting. Most modern romance animanga tend to be set in high school so it's really refreshing to see another environment for once.

[ P.S. I have read the Kiss Him Not Me manga! I really enjoyed the series' ending, I'm glad she made the right choice! While the series does have its issues, I still think that it's overly criticized. In all honesty, what mid-2000s shoujosei series is not a little problematic? I think many people forget that comedy is one of its core genres and interpret a lot of its narrative and themes far too literally. (Spoiler Warning!) Just before I began reading the manga, I learnt that Nanashima and Shinomiya had gotten together, which surprised me because they appeared tense with one another, and I had always shipped the former with Igarashi. After finishing the manga, I can confirm that they totally make sense and are actually quite cute together. I didn't know that they both produce BL manga as well—though in hindsight, that makes sense. In my defence, I don't know much about most mangaka. I really should check out their other work then...]

F.) Hakata Tonkotsu Ramens & G.) Doukyuusei I haven't heard about either series before, but I'll look into them when I'm able to.

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

Thanks for sending in an ask and for all the recommendations! I'm sorry that I can't check them all out immediately though. I'll definitely start working on clearing my watch list and reading list. I actually plan on putting out a poll soon to help me decide which series of my top picks I should start with...

[frostfires-blog]

Hi again!

Don't worry about being new in MXTX works, better be late than never, right?

Your post of MXTX side ships is my favorite Valentine gift. Thanks for sharing them! 🥰🤩

I'm so glad you also love Lan Shizui/Jin Ling (Jin Ling is in my top 5 fav MDZS characters, best boy). So ZhuiLing is my no 3 fav ship from all MXTX side ships. 🌷

And I'm with you, BeefLeaf (He Xuan/Shi Qingxuan) is also my no 1 fav MXTX side ships. Their relationship is so bittersweet. And also because Shi Qingxuan is in my top 5 fav TGCF characters (they're so lovely). 🍖🍃

PeiHuang (Pei Ming/Yushi Huang) is my no 4 fav MXTX side ships, just love their interactions so much. 💐

I'm so excited you include QuanYin (Quan Yizhen/Yin Yu), too.....They're my no 5 fav MXTX aide ships. I can totally relate to Yin Yu. Quan Yizhen really frustate me but at the same time I care for him and can't hate him....

But for my no 2 fav MXTX side ships, is XueXiao (Xue Yang/Xiao Xingchen). Sorry, I know it's a toxic ship but I can't help but love their dynamic and the potential ship there (The Untamed really made me ship them harder).

When I found your blog and read your posts, I got so excited...! Thanks to you, I reread all 3 MXTX works and have a great time. They will always have special place in my heart. Also, I've been sending that MXTX Ask Game to some other people and from all, your answer is my favorite. It's so beautiful and very detailed (always a joy to read them).

As a fan of MXTX works, I never really knew about the meaning of the flowers in the works, until I read your posts. Thanks again for sharing this info.

Okay, it's random, but if you can choose what flowers that remind you some of your favorite characters from TGCF, MDZS, & SVSSS, what will they be? Why?

Oh, and thanks a lot for informing about TGCF OVA, I really love it (but yeah, too short). If not from you, I even don't know about the OVA.

If you want to try other danmei novels, here are some of my favorite (sorry if you don't like either of them) :

- The Husky and His White Cat Shizun (2ha)

If you want to read this, prepare for the angst (with a happy ending). For about the first 50 chapters (at least), you'll hate the MC for what he did to the ML. Because really what he did is unforgivable (oh yeah, don't forget to read the TWs). But as the story goes, you'll understand why he became like that and you'll start to like him gradually. And at the end, it's impossible to still hate him (yes, including me, at the end, I love him, too). For the ML, how can anyone dislike him, really? Even after everything (including the worst) that the MC did to him, he still love him and never hate him until the end. Their love is so beautiful. This series should have live action drama but got canceled (so sad).

- Legend of Exorcism (Tian Bao Fu Yao)

I think you'll love this most, because other than the romance, the story also have focus on the friendship between this group (the MC, ML with their group of friends). The fantasy aspect and the adventure in here are amazing. So in this story, there is another canon m/m side ship (with beautiful story, too). Bonus of why I think this series is special, when I know that the author is gay himself (that is a very brave thing to do because China is still very strong in censorship). This series also have 2 seasons of donghua and manhua (discontinued).

- Run Wild : Sa Ye

It's modern setting about 2 guys who each have their own problems and somehow when they found each other, it's the best thing ever happen to them. And the ML's little sister is great! This series have manhua (ongoing), too. Actually this series also have donghua but got cancelled (sad).

- The Fourteenth Year of Chenghua (The Sleuth of Ming Dynasty)

Now, because you're a fan of Apothecary Diaries, I think, you'll love this, too. The MC is really smart in helping to solve various cases in the palace (also he is a foodie). The ML is a serious type but totally whipped for the MC (in his own way). They have the Live Action drama (a bit different because of censorship but still great series).

- This Villain Emperor's Gotta Charm the Male Lead to Survive! (How to Survive as a Villain)

The MC will remind you of Shen Yuan and the ML is kinda like Lan Wangji, so you can imagine their dynamic will be. It's a great series, you'll laugh and also be sad at certain moments.

In this story, also have canon f/f and other m/m side ships (love them)! This series have manhua (complete) adaptation.

Sorry for this long ask, hope you don't mind. Again, I'm sorry because I'm not really good at writing reviews to make something look interesting (I wish I can write at least half as good as you).

P.s

I watched Apothecary Diaries thanks to you, I love it! You're so right, now that I think about it, JinMao really remind me of Pei Ming/Yushi Huang!

Hi, thanks for sending in another ask! I don't know if I can call myself new to the MXTX works? While I haven't properly ventured into other danmei, I've been an MXTX fan for around 4 years now... I started with the MDZS donghua in 2021 but only read the novels after watching the TGCF donghua in 2022. Given the complexity of the series' plot points and characters, it took some time for me to feel comfortable analysing them—especially considering how much I struggled with the names of characters and places. However, I understand that many MXTX fans have been around since before the novels were officially published in English, so I suppose I could be categorised as a newer fan...

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

On another note, I'm glad you appreciated the post I did about my favourite MXTX side ships! I was actually really worried people wouldn't be happy about some of my choices... A) Lan Shizhui × Jin Ling was one of the ships I thought might provoke negativity, so I'm happy to have found someone else who ships them as well! I didn't know they had a ship name, "Zhuiling" sounds so adorable! Jin Ling is one of my top five favourite MDZS characters too. I really feel like he's inherited all of the best traits of Jiang Yanli, Jin Zixuan, Wei Wuxian and Jiang Cheng, which is why I love him so much. B) Beefleaf haunts me every day... Both Shi Qingxuan and He Xuan are in my top 5 favourite TGCF characters list so I suppose it's not surprising that Beefleaf is my favourite side ship haha... C) I can't wait until we get to see PeiHuang and QuanYin interact in the donghua and manhua! I really hope the donghua adds in additional scenes like what they did with the Fang Xin Guoshi Arc... I totally relate to your feelings about Yin Yu and Quan Yizhen. Also thank you for teaching me all of these new ship names! It's so much more convenient than having to type out both characters' names every time. D) Even though I prefer SongXiao, I totally understand why people ship XueXiao. I'm convinced that Xue Yang harboured intense romantic affections for Xiao Xingchen—however, these sentiments were inextricably entangled with sinister undertones of possession, obsession, and vengeance. Xiao Xingchen clearly enjoyed Xue Yang's company before the big reveal—so If things had gone down differently, they could've been something. I favour SongXiao because I idealise the concept that your love for someone inspires you to become a better person and said person brings out your best qualities. While XueXiao had the ability to achieve that, Xue Yang chose to try to bring Xiao Xingchen down to his level instead. It's an interesting subversion of the aforementioned trope, so part of me does ship them—but I more so much gravitate towards SongXiao since they also have that bittersweet feeling but there's more sweetness than bitterness.

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

I really enjoyed answering the MXTX Ask Game you sent me. I'm glad you liked the response I gave—given my tendency to overexplain things I worried you'd think I rambled too much... People in my personal life tell me I over-analyze things—especially when it comes to symbolism in fictional works. So, seeing how much you all appreciate my hanakotoba posts makes me immensely happy.

I've pondered the concept of using flowers to represent MXTX characters before—although it's quite difficult to separate them from their pre-established, canonical symbolism. Xie Lian is canonically associated with several flowers—most notably snow lotuses, water lilies and peach blossoms. Hua Cheng is canonically associated with red spider lilies—and I've always thought that red camellias suited him as well. Wei Wuxian is canonically associated with lotuses and peonies—while Lan Wangji is associated with gentians, magnolias and peonies. Luo Binghe is canonically associated with black lotuses. I recently did a hanakotoba analysis of fan art that depicted the 6 main characters of MXTX's works as flowers. Most of the flowers chosen there either appear in the respective series or greatly suit the respective character. So, to make the most out of your question—and avoid rehashing information—I'll focus on side characters instead. I limited myself to five characters, each with two flowers chosen, because I didn't want this to be too long. When selecting flowers, I aimed to ensure that their meaning aligned with the character's personality and colour palette. Also, because it was difficult to reverse my research process—as I usually look for a flower's meaning rather than flowers with a specific meaning—these may not be the greatest potential choices... I also tried to mostly go for flowers I haven't covered yet since I'm sure everyone is sick of me rambling about the same ones haha...Hopefully, they meet your expectations...

1) Jiang Yanli × Lotus (Nelumbo nucifera) & Purple Cosmos (Cosmos sp.)

It's apparent that Jiang Yanli is canonically associated with lotus flowers. Her name "Yanli" (厌离) means "disliking separation" and the "he" (荷) in one of the Chinese names for lotuses "hé huā" (荷花) also means union. I've spoken in depth about this in my MDZS hanakotoba part 2 post. In Japanese hanakotoba, lotuses are associated with a pure heart, sacredness, perfection, beauty, grace, eloquence and departing love. In Western floriography, lotuses symbolise purity of the heart, chastity, virtue, innocence, eloquence, departed or estranged love, "bringing together separate things" and "beauty rising from humble beginnings". In China, lotuses symbolise elegance, beauty, wisdom, humility, grace, integrity, balance, harmony, serenity, and purity of the mind and heart. A single stem bearing two lotus flowers represents the desire for harmony and a shared heart while a lotus flower with a leaf and bud symbolises complete union. As a second option, I chose the cosmos flower since I wanted something delicate—in a pink or purple colour palette—that highlighted her compassion, sincerity, and kindness. In Japanese hanakotoba, cosmos flowers represent harmony, humility, purity, love, grace and "a maiden's sincerity". In Western floriography, cosmos flowers are associated with modesty, grace, harmony and "the joys that love and life" can bring. In China, cosmos flowers symbolise love, beauty, innocence, and purity.

2) Lan Yuan │ Lan Sizhui × Sweet Osmanthus (Osmanthus fragrans) & White Strawflower (Xerochrysum bracteatum)

Although Lan Sizhui hasn't been associated with any particular flower in the novel, he is depicted with sweet osmanthus flowers in this official artwork. Osmanthus flowers have been valued throughout Asia for centuries for their rich, apricot and peach-like aroma and are utilised in the preparation of tea, wine, medicine, and confections. In Japanese hanakotoba, osmanthus flowers represent humility, nobleness, honesty and first love. In Western floriography, osmanthus flowers symbolise humility, purity, love, dedication, peace and unwavering charm. In China, osmanthus flowers are associated with autumn, longevity, prosperity, loyalty, sincere love, nostalgia and good luck. As a second option, I chose the strawflower since I wanted a white or blue flower that would not only highlight his kindness, sincerity, integrity, and maturity but also his subtle playfulness and easy-going disposition. I mostly wanted something that could tie into the courtesy name "Sizhui" (思追), —which was chosen by Lan Wangji and means "to recollect and long for"—as his bond with Lan Wangji and Wei Wuxian is an essential aspect of his character. Ultimately, I ended up choosing strawflowers also known as everlasting daisies. In Japanese hanakotoba, strawflowers are associated with eternal memory and everlasting joy. In Western floriography, strawflowers represent longevity, hope, undying love and remembrance.

3) Liu Qingge × Willow (Salix sp.) & Bluebird Columbine (Aquilegia sp.)

Although Liu Qingge is canonically paired with pine and willow trees, he isn't associated with any specific flowers, so I chose the bluebird columbine to symbolise him. When choosing a flower to symbolise him, I wanted something in a blue-grey and white palette that highlighted both his strength, resilience, and boldness, as well as his softer qualities such as his denseness, consideration, and loyalty. I also wanted to subtly hint at his ambiguous feelings for Shen Qingqiu. In the SVSSS novel, Liu Qingge's Bai Zhan Peak is stated to be full of pine trees. In Japanese hanakotoba and Western floriography, pines are associated with longevity, immortality, pity, sympathy and hope. In China, pines symbolise unwavering strength, resilience, longevity, evergreen sentiment, everlasting affection and endurance in adversity. His surname "Liu" (柳) means willow. In Japanese hanakotoba, willows are associated with freedom, obedience and the sadness of love. In Western floriography, willows are associated with bravery, forsaken love, melancholy, mourning, sorrow and freedom. In China, willows symbolise sorrow, longing, resilience, renewal, humility, friendship, lasting affection and "urging someone to stay". Bluebird columbine flowers symbolise denseness, resolve and determination to win in Japanese hanakotoba. In Western floriography, columbine flowers are associated with diligence, determination, tenacity, endurance, foolishness, courage, fidelity and love. In China, columbines symbolise valour and courage.

4) Shi Qingxuan │ Wind Master × Spring snowflake (Leucojum vernum) & Windflowers (Anemone sp.)

As far as I recall, Shi Qingxuan isn't canonically associated with any particular flower. When selecting flowers, I wanted something in white, green, or teal that highlighted his compassion, charisma, and integrity—while also reflecting his intricate relationship with Ming Yi/He Xuan and his tragic fate in the novel. In the end, I've chosen to go with spring snowflakes and white anemones. In Japanese hanakotoba, snowflake flowers represent an immaculate heart, purity, innocence and "charm that attracts everyone". In China, spring snowflakes symbolise purity, hope, courage and new life. In Western floriography, they symbolise innocence, purity, new beginnings, hope and "memories of youth". Anemones are also known as windflowers making them a fitting choice for Shi Qingxuan, the Wind Master. In Japanese hanakotoba, anemones are associated with ephemeral love, abandonment and the pain of love. White anemones in particular represent hope, expectation and truth. In Western floriography, anemones are associated with forsaken love, withered hope, anticipation, spring's arrival, "the fragility of life", and a loved one's death.

5) Yushi Huang │ Rain Master × Arum Lily (Zantedeschia aethiopica) & Baimo (Fritillaria verticillata)

Yushi Huang is also not canonically associated with any flowers—save for agricultural produce—so I've chosen arum lilies and baimo lilies. When choosing flowers to represent her, I wanted something associated with water that would highlight her humility, perseverance, and compassion. I opted for a green-and-white colour scheme, despite the donghua's blue-and-white colour palette, because her robes are described as verdant in the novel and blue flowers are uncommon.  Arum lilies typically grow along streams and ponds; furthermore, a cultivar of the arum lily featuring green stripes around the borders of its flower is known as the "Green Goddess," making it a good fit for Yushi Huang, the goddess of rain and agriculture. In Japanese hanakotoba, arum lilies are associated with grace, purity, passion and splendid beauty. In Western floriography, arum lilies represent modesty, magnificence and feminine beauty. Baimo lilies are also called woven lilies because their mesh-patterned, downward-facing flowers resemble braided bamboo hats like the one Yushi Huang wears. In Japanese hanakotoba, baimo lilies are associated with a "humble heart" and talent. In Western floriography, baimo lilies symbolise humility, modesty, elegance, and grace.

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

If you want to stay updated on the TGCF donghua-related information I'd advise you to follow the official official TGCF Twitter account. They post new official artwork, trailers and other promotional announcements there. I love the animated PVs they always release there. Of course, I'll try to post important updates here as well. Apparently, there's going to be another short film/OVA but I'm not sure when it'll be released. According to rumours, it's going to cover the first extra of volume 8 "Lantern Riddles on Yuanxiao Night".

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

Thanks for the danmei recommendations, I've been wanting to get into other series but haven't known where to start. I've seen a lot of Kictor's reviews—so I have a decent understanding of what a lot of them are about even though I haven't quite taken the plunge yet... Since I'm notoriously indecisive I'll probably post on poll sometime soon and have you guys help decide on which series I read next. I'll probably stick to officially published ones for now since the glossaries and appendixes are a lifesaver for me. I tried reading Faraway Wanderers last year—because I was watching Word of Honour—and I struggled so much without one...

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

I'm glad inspired you to watch The Apothecary Diaries, it deserves to be more popular! I'm glad you see the vision too! I've seen a lot of people compare JinMao to Usui × Misaki (Kaichou wa Maid-sama) and Tamaki × Haruhi (Ouran High School Host Club)—but I haven't seen anyone compare them to PeiHuang yet and it works so well...

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

[frostfires-blog]

MXTX Fanart Hanakotoba Analysis

So, I came across this absolutely stunning artwork depicting the six main characters from MXTX's three novels—SVSSS, MDZS and TGCF respectively—as different flowers. I asked the original artist, @Huaihua610715, if I could repost it here and analyse it, and they gave me permission. Please support the original post on Twitter as well.

═══════════════════════

-> 1.) SVSSS

1.1) Luo Binghe × Hydrangea (Hydrangea macrophylla)

In this artwork, Luo Binghe is represented with a red Hydrangea macrophylla flower. Although its name means "water vessel" in Greek, this flower is native to East Asia. Given that their colour saturation varies depending on the availability of aluminium ions in the soil, Hydrangea macrophylla flowers function as natural soil pH indicators. In acidic soils, the flowers range from blue to purple, whereas in alkaline soils, they range from red to pink.

➞ 1.1.1) Hydrangea symbolism:

In Japanese hanakotoba, hydrangeas are associated with fickleness, callousness, heartlessness, ruthlessness, pride, patience, and patient affection. White hydrangeas symbolise tolerance—while red hydrangeas are associated with strong love. The hydrangea's symbolism of "fickleness" is derived from its flowers' ability to change colour based on soil pH—while its symbolism of "patience" stems from its long flowering period. In China, hydrangeas are associated with gratitude, hope, happy reunions, pride, long-term love, forgiveness, apologies and heartfelt emotions. Red hydrangeas are associated with abundance and prosperity. In Western floriography, hydrangeas symbolise frigidity, heartlessness, boastfulness, "you are cold" and "thank you for understanding". White hydrangeas in particular symbolise purity, grace and abundance. Red hydrangeas are associated with boldness, love, passion, devotion, adoration, loyalty and desire.

➞ 1.1.2) Discussion of symbolism appropriateness:

In the SVSSS novel, Shen Qingqiu frequently compares Luo Binghe to a lotus—characterising him as a pure, white lotus during his time as a disciple at Qing Jing Peak and as a black lotus following his return from the Endless Abyss—however, the artist opted to depict him as a red hydrangea instead. This is primarily because the hydrangea's ability to change colour depending on soil pH mirrors the shift in Luo Binghe's character throughout the narrative—just like the analogy of a white lotus becoming a black lotus does. The hydrangea's representations of pride, fickleness, ruthlessness, boldness, frigidity, heartlessness and prosperity resonate with Luo Binghe's turbulent personality. Additionally, the flower's symbolism of passion, long-term love, forgiveness, gratitude, patient love, devotion, adoration, loyalty and desire greatly correspond with his feelings towards Shen Qingqiu.

Furthermore, Luo Binghe's and the hydrangea flower's names are both derived from water—with Luo Binghe being named after the river where his adoptive mother found him while hydrangeas are named after the Greek work for "water vessel" because of their bowl-like shape.

1.2) Shen Yuan | Shen Yuan × Four-season orchid (Cymbidium ensifolium)

In this artwork, Shen Qingqiu is represented with a Cymbidium ensifolium flower. This flower is more commonly referred to as the Four-season orchid, golden-thread orchid, spring orchid, burned-apex orchid and rock orchid. This orchid has been cultivated for over 2000 years in China and Japan and is renowned for its exquisite foliage and delicate, sweet, and lasting scent.

➞ 1.2.1) Flower Symbolism:

In Japanese hanakotoba, this flower is associated with grace, glory, purity, elegance and nobility. Its symbolism is primarily derived from its delicate, sweet fragrance and intricate blossoms. In China, this orchid symbolises dignity, integrity, nobility, self-restraint, morality, resilience, strength and humility—all of which are regarded as the attributes of an ideal gentleman. Ancient Chinese philosophers regard orchids as a representation of "the self-cultivation of a gentleman who adheres to moral principles even in destitution" because these plants grow in secluded forests devoid of admirers yet continue to emit a charming aroma. In Western floriography, four-season orchids represent elegance, virtue, nobility, refinement as well as "pure, valued and respected friendship".

➞ 1.2.2) Discussion of symbolism appropriateness:

Although Shen Qingqiu is not canonically associated with any particular flower, the Four-season orchid's white and green palate corresponds with his white and green colour scheme. Additionally, this orchid's symbolic representations of grace, elegance, self-restraint, refinement and resilience resonate with Shen Qingqiu's outward personality.

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

-> 2.) MDZS

2.1) Lan Zhan | Lan Wangji × Yulan Magnolia (Magnolia denudata)

In this artwork, Lan Wangji is depicted with a branch of Yulan magnolia (Magnolia denudata) flowers. This flower is native to central and eastern China and its Chinese name yùlánhuā (玉兰花) translates to jade orchid/lily.

➞ 2.1.1) Flower Symbolism:

In Japanese hanakotoba, magnolias are associated with sustainability, persistence, sublimeness and a "love for nature". In China, magnolias symbolise dignity, perseverance, beauty, purity and honour. In addition to being a component in traditional medicine, magnolias symbolise the onset of spring and are believed to confer good fortune and happiness.  In Western floriography, magnolia flowers represent perseverance, dignity, honour, majesty, pride, and nobility.

➞ 2.1.2) Discussion of symbolism appropriateness:

MDZS is the richest MXTX novel in terms of flower symbolism. Lan Wangji has been canonically associated with magnolia and gentian flowers in official artwork. Furthermore, magnolias are repeatedly noted to grow in the Gusu Lan clan's Cloud Recesses—particularly near the library pavilion where Lan Wangji and Wei Wuxian studied in their youth. The magnolia’s symbolic associations with nobility, perseverance, persistence, beauty, dignity and honour tie in well with Lan Wangji's character. Additionally, the magnolia's white flowers contrasted against the clear blue sky, are reminiscent of Lan Wangji's white and blue colour scheme. The magnolia's Chinese name translates to "orchid/jade lily" which corresponds with Lan Wangji being hailed as one of the Lan's "Twin Jades".

2.2) Wei Ying | Wei Wuxian × Peony (Paeonia sp.)

In the artwork, Wei Wuxian is depicted as a red peony (Paeonia sp.). Peonies have been cultivated in China since the seventh century for their luxurious, aromatic flowers, which range from white, pink to crimson. Although China has not established an official national flower—in spite of various electoral attempts and suggestions—the peony was considered the national flower during the late Qing dynasty.

➞ 2.2.1) Flower Symbolism:

In Japanese hanakotoba, peonies are associated with shyness, wealth, bravery, and regalness. The peony's association with wealth and regalness stems from its multitudes of large, silk-like petals. In China, peonies are hailed as the "king of flowers" and the "flower of riches and honour". They symbolise honour, wealth, prosperity, beauty, love and happiness in Chinese culture. Red peonies are associated with good fortune and prosperity in China. In Western floriography, peonies represent bashfulness, shame, prosperity, compassion and a happy marriage. Red peonies in particular symbolise passion, desire, honour, romance,

➞ 2.2.2) Discussion of symbolism appropriateness:

Although peony flowers are heavily associated with the Jin Clan in the MDZS novel, they are also canonically linked with Wei Wuxian. During the Siege Hunt at Mount Baifeng, Wei Wuxian throws a pink peony to Lan Wangji amidst the parade. Later, while on a trip to Yunmeng, the latter once again encounters Wei Wuxian who throws him another pink peony. In this audio drama adaptation of this scene, Wei Wuxian asks a ghost woman what the meaning of peony is, and she responds that it means "wishing you would return my feelings" or to part with a heavy heart." Years later, following Wei Wuxian's death and resurrection, he finds a pressed peony flower that Lan Wangji uses as a bookmark. Given Lan Wangji's sentimental nature, this peony is undoubtedly one of those given to him by Wei Wuxian. Aside from the peony's dark red petals matching Wei Wuxian's colour scheme, its symbolism of passion, honour, compassion, bravery and happiness greatly complement Wei Wuxian's character. During the long debate to decide China's national flower one of the proposed solutions was the "One Country, Five Flowers" system. This concept entailed designating the peony as the primary national flower while having an additional four supplementary flowers symbolising the four seasons: chrysanthemums for autumn, plum blossoms for winter, orchids for spring, and lotuses for summer. While this may be a reach, I find the peony standing over four other flowers somewhat analogous to the cultivation world's crusade against the Yiling Patriarch, in which Wei Wuxian opposed the combined might of the four major clans—namely the Jin, Jiang, Nie, and Lan.

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

-> 3.) TGCF

3.1) Hua Cheng × Camellia (Camellia sp.)

In this artwork, Hua Cheng is depicted as a red Camellia (Camellia sp.) flower. Camellias are native to the tropical and subtropical regions of southern and eastern Asia. Various species of camellias have been cultivated for centuries not only for their beautiful flowers but also for tea and woody-oil production. Camellia flowers range from pure white to soft pink to deep red. With proper care, camellia plants can live for many years. It is said that the camellias around the emperor’s palace in Japan are known to be more than 500 years old.

➞ 3.1.1) Flower Symbolism:

In Japanese hanakotoba, camellias are associated with modest kindness, pride, eternal love and enduring love. Red camellias in particular symbolise love, humble virtue, modest splendour, unpretentious grace and "perishing with grace" in hanakotoba. Pink camellias represent love, modesty, beauty, longing and missing someone. On the other hand, white camellias symbolise waiting, impeccable charm complete beauty and supreme loveliness. In China, camellias symbolise admiration, perfection, everlasting love and the "perfect union between lovers". Red camellias symbolise happiness, good luck and protection in Chinese culture. Camellias are associated with everlasting love, marital bliss and perfect unions between lovers because, unlike most other flowers, the calyx and petals of a camellia flower don't separate when its flower wilts. In Western floriography, camellias are associated with constancy, steadfastness, perfect loveliness, unpretending excellence, adoration, longing, admiration and perfection. Red camellias in particular are associated with passion, love and desire.

➞ 3.1.2) Discussion of symbolism appropriateness:

Although Hua Cheng is not canonically associated with camellia flowers, I've always thought that they greatly complemented him. The camellia flower's association with perfect unions, passion, love, desire, longing, adoration, admiration and enduring, everlasting love perfectly encapsulate Hua Cheng's feelings towards Xie Lian. Just as the calyx and petals of a camellia flower remain together, Hua Cheng has forever remained Xie Lian's "most devoted believer". Additionally, the camellia's representation of steadfastness, unpretending excellence, good fortune, protection, impeccable charm and pride greatly resonate with Hua Cheng's character. Camellia flowers also symbolise "perishing with grace," and Hua Cheng has declared that dying in battle for Xie Lian would be his greatest honour—he has already upheld this assertion by dying three times for Xie Lian.

Furthermore, the camellia flower's contradictory symbolism of pride and modesty mirrors how Hua Cheng's confidence and boldness are toned back when it comes to Xie Lian, with whom he reveals a far more vulnerable and genuine side of himself.

3.2) Xie Lian × Tianshan snow lotus (Saussurea involucrata)

In the artwork, Xie Lian is depicted as the rare and precious Tianshan snow lotus (Saussurea involucrata). Just as its name suggests, this flower is native to the Tianshan Mountains of China where it is known as Tiānshān Xuělián (天山雪蓮). It grows at altitudes near 4000 meters, in frigid and low-oxygen conditions, among ice-streaked rock fissures. It is a valuable ingredient in traditional Uyghur, Mongolian, Kazakh and Chinese medicine and has been hailed as the "king of all herbs" and "best medicine" by locals. In China, this flower has historically inspired songs, poetry, and legends, wherein it is thought to possess magical properties that extend life. These flowers are threatened due to climate change and over-harvesting.

➞ 3.2.1) Flower Symbolism:

Tianshan snow lotuses are associated with pure love, tenacity, purity, holiness, resilience, renewal, spiritual awakening and "bringing hope to people" in China. The Tianshan snow lotus, which grows at high altitudes under arduous conditions, is thought to symbolise that "beauty and purity can arise even in the most challenging circumstances".

➞ 3.2.2) Discussion of symbolism appropriateness:

Xie Lian is known as the "The Flower-Crowned Martial God: Sword in One Hand, Flower in the Other" and as such he is canonically associated with several different flowers, one of which being the Tianshan snow lotus. Ironically Qi Rong is the character who constantly compares Xie Lian to a Tianshan snow lotus. However, Qi Rong derisively calls Xie Lian a "blackhearted snow lotus" which holds the implication that the latter's compassion is nothing but a façade to mask his malicious motivations. Qi Rong uses the snow lotus as a metaphor not just because of its cultural connotations but also because its Chinese name "Xue Lian" is phonetically similar to Xie Lian's name, despite the differing hanzi. Despite Qi Rong's ill intent, I do think the Tianshan snow lotus greatly complements Xie Lian's character. The Tianshan snow lotus' symbolism of tenacity, resilience, renewal, hope and pure love particularly resonates with Xie Lian character. Xie Lian's character arc greatly encapsulates the idea that "beauty and purity can arise even in the most challenging circumstances"—in the same way as the Tianshan snow lotus. Despite enduring immense hardship and being exposed to the worst qualities of humanity; Xie Lian still found himself moved by one person's kindness. His desire to help others and compassion remain steadfast, despite having been subjected to numerous trials and tribulations.

═══════════════════════

╰┈➤Hanakotoba Post Directory

╰┈➤TGCF Hanakotoba P1 & TGCF Hanakotoba P2

╰┈➤ MDZS Hanakotoba P1 & MDZS Hanakotoba P2

I changed up my usual style with this post so hopefully, no one has any issues with the format and tone changes. If anyone has any requests or questions feel free to drop a comment below or send me an ask. For anyone new, I uploaded the links to my previous hanakotoba posts above, enjoy!

[frostfires-blog]

Me every Sunday:

The thoughts:

[frostfires-blog]

Valentine's Day Poll Winner:

Top 10 MXTX Side Ships

Sorry that I'm only posting this almost 2 full days after Valentine's Day... I highly underestimated how long this was going to take and had a few things up which delayed me further... Before I start, I just wanted to remind everyone that this is what won the poll—so I'm not just putting this out to rile people up. I'd also like to reiterate that this list is based on my own opinions—so please don't get upset with me if your favourite ship isn't here or isn't in the placement you'd want to be. Admittedly putting together this list was a lot more difficult than I thought it was going to be... Considering I value ships that have a good basis in the canonical narrative and avoid pairings with a lot of toxicity, there weren't many options... There are also a quite few popular ships that I have mixed feelings on, so I chose not to include them... That being said constructive comments are welcome! I'd love for you to politely share your own favourites in the comments!

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

-> Honourable Mentions:

Lan Yuan × Jing Ling

Lan Yuan × Lan Jingyi

Sha Hualing × Liu Mingyan

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

-> Top 10 MXTX Side Ships:

10.) Moshang │ Mobei-Jun × Shang Qinghua

I'm sure a lot of you are going to be disappointed that the only canonical M/M side pairing in MXTX's novel was placed so low on my list... I don't know how to explain it other than that I like the idea of them as pairing but don't quite like the execution... I feel that they weren't given enough time to properly grow on me and that we don't see enough of their dynamic for me to like them as much as the other ships on this list. They have a lot of issues that weren't handled as carefully as I would've liked due to SVSSS' light-hearted tone. That being said I like how they gradually bring out the best in one another—with Shang Qinghua becoming more standoffish and bold while Mobei-Jun becomes more expressive and compromising.

09.) Tianlang-Jun × Su Xiyan

Admittedly it's a little hypocritical of me to place them above MoShang considering that these two got even less screentime and things ended tragically... But I really liked the bit of their dynamic that we saw. Tianlang-Jun is such a fun character and Su Xiyan complements him so well. What I appreciate most about this ship is its subversion of a few conventional tropes, particularly with Tianlang-Jun being characterised as a "lovestruck teenage girl" and a "pampered young lady who fled from home and was oblivious to the world".  In contrast, Su Xiyan is characterised as a "wealthy young master," "cold and ruthless," and "solemn and driven."

08.) QuanYin │ Quan Yizhen × Yin Yu

The fandom has many opposing opinions on this ship and while I have my conflicting thoughts, I can't help but want to root for them. They have an intriguing yet complex dynamic in the canon narrative. While Quan Yizhen is strongly attached to Yin Yu and admires and cares for him, Yin Yu intentionally avoids Quan Yizhen, claiming that he despises him—though this hatred appears to be a front to conceal his own guilt and uneasiness. I find it incredibly moving that, despite everything that has transpired, Quan Yizhen has chosen to believe in Yin Yu's sincerity—despite what others say—and continues searching for him. Yin Yu is someone who struggles to see the good in himself—while Quan Yizhen can only see the good in Yin Yu. Despite their difficulties communicating, the extent they've gone to defend one another despite everything makes their care for one another evident.

07.) Pei Xiu × Banyue

Dare I say that this ship is one of the most underrated ones in the TGCF fandom… They somewhat serve as a parallel to HuaLian like most other hinted ship pairs in the series do. Pei Xiu's guilt and helplessness to save Banyue—along with his willingness to sacrifice himself and others to protect and avenge her—are reminiscent of Hua Cheng's feelings and actions. Similarly, Banyue's benevolent beliefs led to her achieving no success and culminated in her suffering, drawing a subtle parallel with Xie Lian's tribulations. On the other hand, Pei Xiu and Banyue differentiate themselves from HuaLian in a lot of ways. While Pei Xiu values Banyue over her own wishes and ends up harming innocent people, Hua Cheng greatly respects Xie Lian's desire to protect others and sacrifices himself instead. TGCF delves into the interplay between devotion, morality, and obsession—with several subsidiary relationships depicting the alternative trajectories the main pair could have followed under slightly different circumstances. This results in dynamics that are both notably comparable but also significantly distinct from the main pair in several of its prominent side pairs.

06.) FengQing │Feng Xin × Mu Qing

I'm sure their presence on their list was expected given that they're the most popular side ship in TGCF. Their immense popularity isn't without cause and can largely be attributed to their dynamic chemistry and abundance of comical canonical interactions. I'm a huge fan of the rivals-to-lovers trope which these two embody perfectly with their tension-filled interactions and contrasting personalities. Despite their distaste for one another they are almost always seen collaborating with one another, often not needing words to do so. They have also saved and protected one another numerous times. They bring out the best in one another as they are very closely matched in numerous respects, and as such their competitiveness drives them to strive for improvement. Although their lengthy history together denotes that they have a better understanding of each other than anyone else, the long-standing misconceptions they have of one another provide opportunities for them to grow as they work through them—which lends their dynamic a sense of novelty. Despite their contrasting viewpoints and personalities, they have the capacity to be a good match given Mu Qing's desire for acceptance and stability and Feng Xin's innate reliability and protectiveness.

05.) SongXiao │ Song Lan × Xiao Xingchen

It's a common conception that Xiao Xingchen was supposed to have his own separate story—I think that the depth of the bond between these two makes this even more apparent. That being said, the Yi City arc integrates itself well into the narrative of MDZS. Song Lan and Xiao Xingchen serve as a great parallel to WangXian. Both Xiao Xingchen and Wei Wuxian had noble aspirations and promising futures but instead fell into despair after doing what they felt was right brought them and their loved ones suffering. Furthermore, both characters sacrificed a part of themselves for a loved one, leaving themselves vulnerable. Likewise, Song Lan and Lan Wangji have similar dispositions and have both erratically pushed away the person they cared about most—leaving them to lament the person's death as they were unable to save them. Although their story ends tragically, their care for one another is evident in their final actions: Song Lan not alerting Xiao Xingchen of his presence to avoid hurting the latter with the revelation of Xue Yang's deception, and Xiao Xingchen taking his own life after discovering that he had been deceived into killing Song Lan. Furthermore, Xiao Xingchen's willingness to give up his sight for Song Lan is not just a display of his innate altruism—or to assuage his guilt—but is also a testament to his care for the latter.

04.) Pei Ming × Yushi Huang

I've really come to like this ship upon my second full read-through of TGCF. While they don't get many interactions, the ones they do get are quite telling. I never get tired of seeing the "pretty boy gets brought down to earth by a nonchalant girl" trope. In this regard, these two are somewhat reminiscent of the dynamic Jinshi x Maomao (The Apothecary Diaries) has. Pei Ming's awkwardness around Yushi Huang, and how he repeatedly finds himself saved by her despite his masculine chauvinism, is incredibly amusing. I maintain that this is the only pairing in which Pei Ming is not depicted as a suave heartbreaker—given that Yushi Huang subconsciously forces Pei Ming to confront his flaws and archaic viewpoints. In my opinion, a healthy relationship is one that continually encourages you to better yourself. Yushi Huang's genuine selflessness and humility sharply contrast with Pei Ming's excessive arrogance and egocentricity. Pei Ming and Yushi Huang are essentially the antithesis of one another, which adds to their complexity and chemistry. Their dynamic is further compounded by their uncomfortable history which necessitates for them to actively work at things for a relationship to work out.  In the original novel, I got the impression that there were some unrequited feelings on Pei Ming's end—and from what I've heard the revised version further hints at this. With that in mind, another aspect of this pairing that I appreciate is that it provides a sense of fulfilment regardless of whether it culminates in a mutual relationship or remains unreciprocated. In the latter case, there is a sense of poetic justice as Xuan Ji's curse on Pei Ming will have manifested as a punitive karma.

03.) LiuShen │ Liu Qingge × Shen Yuan

I'm not sure if this counts as the side ship, but I'm going to opt to include them... I've spoken about LiuShen here before—but I'll repeat a lot of what I said because it still stands... SVSSS is the only MXTX novel where I've fully committed to shipping a protagonist with a character aside from their main romantic interest. I just find something about LiuShen's dynamic so gripping... I truly adore all of their interactions. The little presents Liu Qingge occasionally brings Shen Qingqiu from missions along with him constantly returning the latter's lost fans are the cutest detail. They balance each other out so well, with Shen Qingqiu relying on Liu Qingge's physical strength and Liu Qingge trusting in Shen Qingqiu's vast knowledge and intellect. Liu Qingge is a relatively stubborn, aloof, and straightforward person—but Shen Qingqiu brings out this sort of determined, flustered, and complex side of him. The saddest thing for me is that it's highly implied in the extras that Liu Qingge thought that Shen Qingqiu was his soulmate... Shen Qingqiu while often subtly annoyed by Liu Qingge's aloofness and bluntness, clearly has a degree of respect and admiration for him. The way he sometimes finds himself inadvertently poetically describing Liu Qingge's features is both amusing and endearing. Another aspect in the canon narrative that makes me gravitate towards these two is the fact that Liu Qingge spent all those years trying to get Shen Qingqiu's deceased body back from Luo Binghe—despite there being nothing in return for him other than having his pride repeatedly trampled on. Out of all the MXTX pairings, I probably read the most fanfics of these two (& WangXian), so please drop any LiuShen fic recs in the comments below!

02.) XuanLi │ Jin Zixuan × Jiang Yanli

Generally speaking, I find people in the fandom either really like this pairing or really dislike it. While I somewhat understand people's misgivings, I do think many overlook the context of their relationship ignore and Jin Zixuan's character development. Although Jin Zixuan is initially immature and arrogant, he becomes more mature, upstanding and caring. His initial dissatisfaction with his arranged engagement to Jiang Yanli is comprehensible—considering no one desires to be coerced into a lifelong commitment—particularly when confronted with numerous instances of arranged unions resulting in turmoil. After their engagement is dissolved, Jin Zixuan is free to pursue anyone he likes, and it is only after maturing that he falls for Jiang Yanli's compassion and thoughtfulness. Only once his misguided assumptions about her are dispelled is he able to pursue her of his own volition. They complement each other—albeit in a more nuanced manner than WangXian. Jiang Yanli acts as a source of tranquillity, humility, and sincerity to Jin Zixuan—who is otherwise encircled by ostentatious and duplicitous individuals. While Jin Zixuan provides fulfilment, security, and assurance to Jiang Yanli—who has experienced significant loss and upheaval. In this sense, they remind me a lot of Kyo x Tohru (Fruits Basket), which makes me adore them even more. They were both brought up in households with parents who were constantly at odds and as a result, they share a strong desire to better themselves for each other. This is most notably seen when Jin Zixuan invites Wei Wuxian to their son's one-month banquet—despite their prior disputes—to make Jiang Yanli happy. It was truly endearing to see him swallow his pride and embarrassment whilst courting her, and one of my favourite details is that teases him about this after their marriage. I'd give anything for an added scene of them interacting with Jin Ling, their son who embodies their best traits despite them never having had the opportunity to raise him.

01.) Beefleaf │ He Xuan × Shi Qingxuan

Unsurprisingly, I had to rank these two at #1! Why am I so infatuated with these two, despite what occurred during the Black Water Arc? I do not know... But what I do know is that I don't go a week without thinking about them and what could have been... Their dynamic centres around the interplay of vengeance, duty, guilt, friendship, and betrayal—making them narratively complex and intriguing in a way that's different from HuaLian. I fear I'm secretly a sucker for unexpected angst... They pack in so many great complex tropes that I can't begin to list them all... Although I'm typically drawn towards happy endings, they satisfy my deep-seated yearning for angst—in a way that only Eren x Mikasa (Attack on Titan) has managed to do. The Black Water Arc is so messy because while you absolutely feel for Shi Qingxuan, you can totally understand He Xuan as well. That duality is quite difficult to pull off... I believe that we oftentimes tend to focus on Shi Qingxuan's sentiments towards He Xuan while rarely examining the latter's feelings. It's evident that He Xuan wanted to despise Shi Qingxuan but couldn't quite bring himself to. He practically acknowledged that he had wanted Shi Qingxuan to choose him over Shi Wudu by offering him several chances. While Shi Qingxuan never picked up on anything, and He Xuan couldn't let go of his desire for vengeance—the sentiment of "what if" will always remain. While I would've liked to see more of them in the series—particularly after their fallout—I liked how ambiguous and nuanced their feelings are portrayed towards one another. Although it is improbable that they would ever reconcile—it is apparent that Shi Qingxuan will spend the rest of his life rehashing the past, dwelling on overlooked details while wishing he had done things differently. Similarly, it is implied that He Xuan will be watching over Shi Qingxuan from a distance, wondering if he made the right decision—as suggested by the former returning the latter's fan and not having dissipated after exacting his revenge. They possess strikingly complementary yet contrasting aesthetics and attributes that evoke an ethereal, poetic quality. This is undoubtedly what allows me to hear them in so many songs and see them in so many things…  Just like with many other TGCF side pairings, several parallels can be drawn between Beefleaf and Hualian. Both Shi Qingxuan and Xie Lian—who are apart of the Famous Four Tales—are among the few gods who are compassionate, moral, and fair. He Xuan and Hua Cheng—both ghost kings apart of the Four Calamities—are seen as antisocial, haughty, and bothersome.

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

Thanks to everyone who participated in the poll... Hopefully, this met your expectations. You're more than welcome to share your own lists and any fic recs in the comments! There are a lot of points that I chose not to expand on due to time constraints... So, if there's anything you want me to elaborate on, then feel free to send me an ask. My inbox is also open if you have any other questions or requests...

[frostfires-blog]

Hands down this is my favourite KouNene interaction in the series:

#Amane and Mitsuba's deadpan jealous faces in the BG are sending me haha

[frostfires-blog]

I can't believe we're actually getting the Picture Perfect Arc animated...

#The HanaNene and MitsuKou stans are winning today!

[frostfires-blog]

TGCF SHORT FILM OPENING: LIÁN CHÉNG CÍ

[frostfires-blog]

So I just rewatched the short film with subtitles and damn they really said to hell with the censorship:

"My beloved is a brave noble and gracious special someone..."

"A fleeting glimpse, a hundred lifetimes enthralled..."

"I've liked him since I was a child, for so many years... and I finally get to stand by his side after going through thick and thin...

I can't believe they actually allowed him to say that!!! Aah!!! Those are among my favourite Hua Cheng quotes from the novel!!!

[frostfires-blog]

This might just be my pessimistic side taking over, but I'm starting to worry about how the tgcf donghua is going to handle the flashback arcs...

Like if this short film was just a fun little extra, then I'm beyond happy. But if this is all we'll be getting from the God Pleasing Crown Prince Arc, then I'm worried... Since quite a bit of background was cut given that they only had 8 minutes...

The movie chose to center around HuaLian's interactions, and while their dynamic is incredibly important and valuable... There was a lot more to Xie Lian's life as the crown prince of Xianle than just his interactions with Hong Hong-er...

I hope they'll cover this arc a little more extensively in Season 3. I'd love for them to better highlight Xie Lian's dynamics with other characters and the pressures he was under given his conflict between his position and ambitions...

Although the MDZS donghua was adapted by a different studio, I remember them cutting out some parts of the flashback arcs and rearranging the rest... So I fear my worries may not be unfounded...

[frostfires-blog]

HuaLian × TGCF SHORT FILM CHAPTER 1

[frostfires-blog]

Xie Lian × TGCF SHORT FILM CHAPTER 1

[frostfires-blog]

Hua Cheng × TGCF SHORT FILM CHAPTER 1