canto8waitlist

[canto8waitlist]

hong lu hairstyles (+ one yi sang)

[canto8waitlist]

how my brain picks a new favorite character who sucks

[canto8waitlist]

hong lu for my friend who I dragged down the limbus rabbit hole

[canto8waitlist]

oh yeah I never posted this one here

[canto8waitlist]

elevator scene.mpeg

[canto8waitlist]

What do you think about that parting moment between Xichun and Hong Lu? It definitely feels like there’s something off there with the way Xichun cuts herself off mid-sentence and Hong Lu is immediately like “Oh so we’re parting ways here” but I don’t have the words to articulate it

I think it's simple.

I believe this is the moment where it all clicks for her.

This is where she realizes Hong Lu isn't, in fact, searching for immortality like she is. That he wasn't sent out by the elders like the rest of their siblings. It's where she realizes Hong Lu doesn't care to survive as an heir at all.

It's where she realizes why the elders are actively searching for him.

He's not chasing the clouds, nor chasing that old, tiresome thing.

No, perhaps he is the cloud being chased.

And I'm worried about the possible danger she could be putting herself in due to now knowing that information.

[canto8waitlist]

a threat

[canto8waitlist]

[canto8waitlist]

🔮✨

[canto8waitlist]

he makes me so happy and so profoundly sad at the same time

[canto8waitlist]

I need him to be put down

[canto8waitlist]

This is how it feels to read a classic that everyone in the world has already read and loves

[canto8waitlist]

thinking about that one post that said hong lu fans are the most opinionated people ever and I'm thinking it's true and why redology is a field of study to begin with

on that note my main prediction is that I do not fucking trust granny jia

[canto8waitlist]

This is just a dumb theory, but given what Xichun has said about the elders of their family seeking immortality of the mind and the ruthless competition they've got going between their grandkids, this might be the simplest and easiest explanation we have, so I'm probably wrong, but it's still a thought:

What if the elders are attempting some sort of Get Out style body hijacking scheme? Whoever the strongest, fittest, most ruthless of the kids is deemed worthy to have an elder live inside of them?

I've been mulling over how to respond to this because there's both a lot to say and not that much at the same time.

Because, on the one hand, yeah you are absolutely correct. The search for the Immortality of the mind is absolutely very likely going to lead to the exposure of new and inventive ways for the elders to exploit the younger members of the Jia Family.

This would be further corroberated by my Two in One/Daiyu-Baoyu theory, as it implies that the reason why Baoyu was so valuable to the Family and why the elders are now invested in getting him back is because the fact he was able to keep on living via a version of body hijacking could be exactly what they were looking for. And, well, if they can't achieve Immortality themselves, they still want to have their One Immortal back to force him into doing what they want.

However, I do feel like this isn't all there is to it.

My main point of contention is that I don't believe that the seeking of Immortality and the competition between siblings are inherently this closely connected. I think that, at the very least, they weren't at first.

The competition for the spot as the head of the Family feels like a kind of tradition that would go back for many generations, way before whatever kind of Immortality scheme the current elders are cooking.

After all, note the difference in how Xichun and Hong Lu talk about those two concepts. Neither of them ever really question the competition between siblings, they're fully expecting murder attempts as if they were normal facts of life. There is no judgement of it, it's as natural to them as gravity causing things to fall or plants needing water.

On the other hand, this kind of idea of normalcy is not afforded to the search for Immortality by them. In fact, they both seem to see it as kind of a bother. Xichun calls it an "old, tiresome thing", while Hong Lu is clearly not even really taking part in it, with his writing in the Rose Hunter log implying he believes it to be the beliefs of a select few specific people in his Family.

While it's implied that both concepts have been around for a long while, the normalization of the sibling competition and the lack thereof for the search for Immortality suggests that the former is an established tradition of the Family, while the latter is only a development as recent as the current elders being the ones in power.

But... there is a deeper, thematic way that the two ideas connect together, despite their in-universe connection not being as close as you posit.

Both the sibling competition and the search for Immortality, and even Baoyu being kept within the Jias' grasp - they all serve a single purpose.

To allow for the endless and cyclical perpetuation of the Jia Family and its legacy of abuse and violence.

The competition between siblings isn't just to find the strongest and most ruthless child to become the next head, it's specifically to find an heir whose personal values are the most like the values the Jia Family itself holds, and which thus can continue to perpetuate it.

The search for Immortality then is just another incarnation of this attempt to continue perpetuating the Jia Family, but in this case in a more "efficient" manner. Instead of relying on the random chance of hoping that the one heir who comes out on top will share the values of the elders, the elders can just ensure the Jia Family remains as it is by always being the ones in power. Its legacy can't die if its head never dies after all.

And then, of course, is the one Immortal in question - Baoyu. The Family likely "treasures" him so much because he's their one sure way to never let the Jia Family die. As long as they can keep him locked, as long as they can shape him into the kind of person who would blindly follow what they say, they can ensure he can keep the legacy alive forevermore.

It's... an interesting and kind of poignant smaller scale parallel to how Project Moon portrays the City itself.

Both the City and the Jia Family are, in a way, their own "living" beings independent of any of the people that are a part of it, and yet which can only continue to live on in perpetuity because those same people are the ones who perpetuate their systems of abuse.

It's not a single person's fault that they both continue to live on and cause harm. ...But there's also very few who aren't at least in part to blame for keeping them alive. Even those who are being actively exploited by those in power and have no choice but to perpetuate those cycles... well, they're still perpetuating them all the same.

[canto8waitlist]

[canto8waitlist]

Top tip! you can defeat feudalism by hanging out with girls and being transgender

[canto8waitlist]

**FAVORITE means whatever you want it to. Meta, lore, design, personal bias, anything.