#yandere telltale riddler x reader | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

mr-voorhees-husband · 2 years ago

Text

Smart Boy... pt.2

guh, part one here.

A fic I was writing for myself, but decided to post. Can be read as an x reader, but, it's written w/ me in mind, so.. yeah.

Warnings: Blood, Major Plot Change, Gore, Yandere, NSFT, NSF/W, non-con biting, dub-con elements, Reader + Riddler are both messed up, Trans Masc fingering, T-dick, top-scar mentions, major age gap, Telltale Riddler being Telltale Riddler

Reader - He/him, FtM, 20-25, Not good morals.

I’d considered tearing down the shrine. I really had. I even got as far as to go up to it with a trash can in my hand, but, no matter what I tried to tell myself, I couldn’t. Granted, I should have. Especially considering how Riddler wasn't no longer in custody.

Waller hadn't made it to the station, apparently, not before Riddler had already broken out and run. Gordon had called me three times already, but, according to the DA, there was never a chance my father would be given parole. Not only did he lie, he was trying to continue to lie. It took massive amounts of self control to not hunt him down, and he was lucky I understood why he lied in the first place. If he wasn't doing it for the good of the people, it’d have gotten bloody.

My boots clattered noisily against the hardwood floor of my room, arms reaching down to take off my shirt and toss it to the dirty clothes. I was tired, sick of the day, and wanted nothing more than to sleep until my body was forcing me awake. My grandma was back in the hospital, Dad was still locked up, and to put the icing on top, John was trying to force me and Bruce to meet his friends. “Fuck.” I sighed, collapsing on my bed, jeans and socks still on.

“Bad day?”

I turned half-heartedly to the infamous villain, eyes cold and unimpressed as I glared. He was leaning against my wall, next to the open window, which I either forgot to lock, or he picked said lock. Riddler grinned, trailing over to my bed. “So you break out of the station, and head to see someone who put you in there?” I crossed my arms under my head, shutting my eyes with a sigh. “Real smart genius.”

“It’s 9 letters, rhymes with perfection, and you need it so dearly.”

There’s a beat of silence, before I gave up, shoving myself up to look at him. Riddler was sitting on my bed now, at the very edge, as if he didn’t want to risk upsetting me, or just didn't want to get close to me. Rolling onto my back, I thought over the riddle for a moment.

“I don’t need affection, Riddler.” I hissed, making him smile wider.

“Ah, wrong and right,” In a flash, the sharp edge of his cane was pressed against my shoulder, “should I punish or reward?” I didn’t dare move, knowing damn well that cane was sharp enough to split skin at the barest graze, and it being that close to my neck wasn’t the most relaxing. “How about neither?”

“Sounds- Sounds good.” I mumbled, eyes flickering between the intruder and his weapon. He smiled, pulling the cane away and resting it against the bed.

“What’s something of mine that belongs to you?” He continued, adjusting on the bed so his legs were pressing against my feet.

“Wha..?”

The cane was back against my shoulder, and this time, on instinct, I tried to pull away, sitting up. It didn’t change much though, Riddler simply followed my movement to keep the threat prominent. I knew the riddle, it was some sappy riddle about owning someone’s heart. The fact Riddler was asking me is what was throwing me off. “The..” I passed a nervous glance to the cane, and Riddler raised an eyebrow. “Your heart..?”

“Good boy.” He chuckled, and I couldn't hide the shock of pleasure that shot down my spine from the simple praise. Riddler moved fast, grabbing my wrist and twisting my in a way so my back was against his chest. “Now, keep up this little winning streak, and I’ll keep rewarding you.”

Before I could ask what the hell he meant by reward, lips were on my neck. I gasped, instincts telling me to struggle while my brain seemed to understand they wouldn’t do much. It wasn’t like I didn’t enjoy it, anyway, this older man, who I’d had a crush on for years kissing my neck. It had me spiraling in the best way possible. A nip made me yelp, finally trying to tug away. I shouldn’t be getting pleasure from this, my brain seemed to finally register, or maybe it was simply what little morality I had left fighting for me to not completely accept how insane I truely was. Riddler’s grip tightened while he shushed me quietly, akin to how you’d calm a scared animal. Maybe that’s all I was to him.

“This one should be fairly obvious, my love.” I flushed at the nickname, too caught off-guard to even try and fight when he went back to marking my neck. “What belongs to you now, everyone who ever dated you wanted, and I will have?”

“I..” That was a loaded question for a riddle I already basically answered. It made me rethink it for a solid moment or so, wondering if maybe I was wrong about it being my heart. “My heart?”

Searing pain spread through my shoulder, making me cry out in agony. Adrenaline started pumping, and I tried to rip away in pure surprise. Riddler crushed me back against his chest, kissing my shoulder better from whatever the hell he just did. Choking on air, I turned to the best of my ability, eyes finding a thin line of crimson trailing down my chest. Whatever he did, he broke skin, and it hurt. “Wrong, darling.” I whimpered at the feeling of his gloved fingers sweeping up my warm blood, before I heard him hum at the taste of it. “Try again.”

“..I- I don’t-” A cry escaped my lips, fingers pressing against my shoulder. “Love?”

More pain, making me sob out a broken beg of forgiveness. He kissed the wound once more, as if trying to shake away the pain. “So close,” a kiss under my ear, and I felt his teeth graze the shell of my ear before he continued, “something I don’t already have, dear boy.”

My brain shook for an answer, pain and adrenaline making it much harder than it usually should be. I still didn’t even know how he hurt me, which made it so much worse. I didn’t know what he did, all I knew was the pain it caused and I was bleeding. “Fuck- My virgintinty? I don’t know!” My eyes shut, expecting that agonizing pain to spread through my shoulder again. Yet, it never came.

“Amazing,” a hand cupped my chin, pushing my jaw up to give Riddler more room to kiss my neck and mark me, “absolutely brilliant, my dear.” For a moment, I was just happy I got the answer right, before it fully seemed to register what the answer was. Riddler wanted my virginity. Fuck. That idea alone made me flush, not to mention how close I was to him. I knew I shouldn’t feel lust right now, but I couldn’t shake it. I liked people like this. I wanted someone insane about me. Someone who would kill if I asked the right way. He ticked all my boxes and then some. “I knew you’d get it.”

“How do you know I still have my virginity?”

“Hm.” Fingers slipping in my pants made me gasp, head still pointed up with his other palm. “You’re too sensitive.” Riddler replied calmly, “Now, be a dear and unbutton your jeans.”

I didn’t have to listen. Nothing was forcing me. He was asking me to unbutton them, not telling me. Though, this was a one-in-a-million chance, and I wasn’t exactly known to be lucky. So, with only slightly shaking fingers I reached down and un-did my jeans.

“Good boy,” he purred, the praise making me whine and thrust my hips. Riddler chuckled darkly, kissing the wounds on my shoulder that had finally started to stop bleeding. “Is that what gets you going?” Nimble fingers found my cock, jerking it back and forth with smooth motions. “Praise? Such a smart boy gets off on being told how good he is?”

“Uh-huh..” I wasn’t sure if he wanted an answer or not, but I still decided to answer, anything to keep his hand there. My head hit his shoulder with a moan, and he finally let my chin go to rest his other hand on my hip.

“How adorable..” Fingers grazed my entrance and I trembled, the idea of him finger fucking me with his gloves still on making my head spin. “Let’s see…”

“No- wait-” I begged pathetically as he pulled his hand away and out of my pants.

“So needy,” he sighed, pulling the other hand away, “pants off, and then I’ll keep touching you.”

My pants were in a heap on the floor in seconds, underwear with it before I was clambering back onto his lap. Riddler grinned madly, accepting me with open arms as he situated himself against my pillows. This time, I was facing him, knees straddling his thighs. A much more willing position, along with allowing me to see him. My knees shook when his fingers found my cock again, slipping around it and jerking it between his middle and index finger.

“Would you believe me if I told you this was my first time?” He hummed, only getting an answer in the shape of me shaking my head. I was too far gone now, I never knew being touched could feel this good, all pain from earlier being forgotten. “It is, with a man, that is.” Riddler didn’t miss the way I seemed to huff softly at that, either in jealousy or a self consciousness, I couldn’t tell. “Oh, don’t worry, darling, those whores meant nothing.” The feeling of two of his fingers stretching me out made me sob, hands finding the lapels of his jacket. He grinned, teeth grazing my neck before they bit down softly on my good shoulder. “Just means to an end, nothing like this,” I grinded into his palm, rutting like an animal in heat with a stangled groan, “nothing like you.”

“Riddler- fuck- please-!”

“Eddie, darling.” Edward gently chastised, fingers stretching me out before searching for that special place. When he found it, stars flashed through my eyes and I sobbed out a moan, burying my head in the nape of his neck. “Oh, there it is.”

“Eddie! Please-pleaseplease!”

“Shh, darling, I know,” His voice was demeaning, like talking to a child, but I couldn’t care at all, not with him making me feel like I was on cloud 9. “I know you can cum like this, so why haven’t you?” His free hand grazed up my side, before landing on my chest, rubbing the crescent shaped scars under my pec gently. “You’ve been so good too,” I moaned at that, eyes rolling back as I continued to hump his palm, “I’m sure if such a brillant, smart boy can fuck himself on my fingers, he’d be able to cum on them.”

“Can’t you, darling?”

I cried out to him one final time, body tensing as I came on his hand. Edward continued to thrust his fingers in me until my orgasm was finally over. I shuddered against his shoulder with the barest whine as he pulled his hands away. My eyes flickered over to him just in time to watch him suck my climax off his glove, pupils blown and face ever so red. Edward hummed at the taste, hand moving from my chest to tug off his gloves and toss them to the side. He glanced at me, before smiling.

“Well, dear boy, how do you feel?”

“..Warm..” My arms dropped from his jacket to dig between his back and the pillows and pull him into a hug. Edward hummed, bare, clean, fingers going to my hair to run his hand through it. “Are you gonna leave now?”

“No.”

I couldn’t tell if that was a good thing or not.

#telltale riddler #telltale #riddler #tw yandere #yandere riddler #edward nygma #batman the enemy within #edward nigma #yandere reader #riddler x reader

34 notes · View notes

finniestoncrane · 2 years ago

Text

💚 my requests are always open 🩷

you can find my writing:

in my tag

on my masterlist

my AO3

important things first:

🔞🔞🔞 minors DNI 🔞🔞🔞 you can request anonymously 💚 i don't write in order of when things are received, i do it based on inspiration. if i can't think of anything for something after a few months i'll delete it without explanation, sorry i have a prompt tag and if you use it let me know which prompt list you've asked for or let me know more than just the numbers! let me know gender specifics of "reader" if there is one (pronouns, genitals etc.) if you don't specify it'll be gender neutral or female please don't include images or gifs in your requests, they visually overwhelm me and make it difficult to tackle the prompt i mostly identify as cis/white/afab so keep this in mind if you request nb/trans/t4t/different races/male reader presenting etc. i will choke you if you don't reblog and like the thing you requested, be nice and supportive!

requests i accept:

i write for batman rogues, fallout and a few other characters! for dc rogues headcanons: i will do multiple characters per post for headcanons but only for all general rogues, a specific dork squad (in my do writes!) or all iterations that i write for of a specific character e.g. ✅ can you write first dates with arkham!dork squad? ✅ what would all the riddlers do on a first date? ✅ how would the rogues handle a first date? (if you ask for all iterations of a specific character i'll either write for them all or pick several of them depending on the ask. if you want one specifically to be included just let me know)

characters i write for:

🦇 DC/BATMAN 🦇

Riddler (⭐arkham, dano, ⭐zero year, telltale, TWOJAR, gotham, BTAA, young justice, BU, BTAS, general)

Penguin (⭐farrell, BTAA, telltale, OBD, gotham, general)

Scarecrow (⭐arkham, ⭐BTAA, golden age, general)

Two Face (⭐arkham, BTAA, general)

Victor Zsasz (gotham, general)

Mad Hatter (arkham, gotham - NO INCEST, general)

Captain Boomerang (⭐ss:ktjl, general)

Poison Ivy (arkham, general)

Polkadot Man (suicide squad)

Harley Quinn (telltale, arkham, ss:ktjl, ⭐general)

Bane (arkham, telltale, OBD, ⭐general)

Harvester (bu)

Amanda Waller (ss:ktjl)

Mr. Freeze (arkham, gotham, general)

John Doe/Joker (telltale)

Butch Gilzean/Solomon Grundy (gotham)

King Shark (ss:ktjl, general)

Deadshot (ss:ktjl, general)

Killer Croc (arkham!origins, general)

Firefly (arkham, general)

Harvey Bullock (gotham)

Alfred Pennyworth (gotham, general)

Black Mask (arkham, general)

Sofia Gigante/Falcone (the penguin series)

☢️ Fallout Franchise ☢️

Cooper Howard (fallout prime)

Maximus (fallout prime)

Thaddeus (fallout prime)

John Hancock (fallout 4)

Sturges (fallout 4)

Edward Deegan (fallout 4)

Paladin Danse (fallout 4)

Nick Valentine (fallout 4)

Kent Connolly (fallout 4)

🔴 TF2 🔵

please note!!: i'll write all ships (plus blu x red) and i'll base the dynamic either on your request or on my own interpretation of them

sniper/mick mundy

scout/jeremy

soldier/jane doe

demoman/tavish degroot

heavy/mikhail/misha

engineer/dell conagher

medic/ludwig

pyro

spy

💚 Other Characters 💚

Cecil Stedman (invincible)

Walter Skinner (x-files)

Arthur Morgan (red dead redemption 2)

Hosea Matthews (red dead redemption 2)

Kieran Duffy (red dead redemption 2)

Micah Bell (red dead redemption 2)

Susan Grimshaw (red dead redemption 2)

Bill Williamson (red dead redemption 2)

Egon Spengler (ghostbusters)

Nick (left 4 dead 2)

i will write:

x reader, x fem/male/gn character, ships, headcanons

absolutely yucky disgusting smut of most kinds

most kinks including knife play, blood play, bondage, sub/dom, pain play, mommy/daddy, etc.

darker themes like cnc, dubcon, noncon, somnophilia, hypnotism, manipulation, gaslighting, guilting

angst, fluff, romance, friendships, hurt/comfort

jealousy, yandere, obsessive themes etc.

ships plus ships x reader also!

non-ship pairings of characters in my "will write" criteria

death, gore, extreme violence

blood, cum, spit and some piss

injuries, pain etc.

imagines, scenarios, full fics, short fics, headcanons

i won’t write:

underage characters (at all, in any scenario, including platonic or familial)

vomit, shit or breast milk

real people

bestiality

pregnancy/pregnancy sex/having children/step-children

age play (daddy and mommy kink fine, dd/lg not for me!)

incest

characters x monster/monster!reader (may do in commissions)

OCs or overly detailed reader specifications (may do in commissions)

AUs or crossovers (may do this in commissions)

extreme anal i.e. fisting/enemas/stretching (may do in commissions)

also i am anti-cancel culture! i'm not about to out you/report you/fuck with your privacy if you send me anything that i'm not sure about or uninterested in writing

and finally, no pressure at all but if you want to thank me i would greatly appreciate reblogs, comments, and maybe even a tip

#finnie shouts into the void

105 notes · View notes

fatgumsurpremacy-remastered · 2 years ago

Note

could I request

Hear me out

Yandere telltale riddler headcanons? I feel like he would be absolutely terrifying

THIS OLD MAN IS GONNA MAKE MAN SOOOOOO UNSANE

Yandere Telltale Riddler x reader

Tw: kidnapping, surveillance, branding, punishment reward system, nonsexual, withholding

•First and foremost this man knows there is a need for comfort and he is willing to give it to you, if you obey. Obeying can be something simple to complex, and he’s someone to slowly deprive and even more slowly reward. Lest you obey from the beginning.

•He’s a very quiet sort of danger, and he’d let his general distaste for any attitude slip on by until he’s able to make his point.

•In regard to punishment one of his favorites is branding. In his mind branding is the clearest way of making sure you know who exactly you’re dealing with. It doesn’t happen often but for mistakes you must learn and learning clearly doesn’t come easy.

•As bossy as he is towards anyone else he’s open enough to you. He asks for advice and options, and sits down, and shuts up like a proper gentleman at least with you. He tries to make what he does somewhat natural.

•As hes ran the criminal underground for quite some time he’s got leverage everywhere in Gotham. He has eyes to keep on you even when you don’t suspect. If you managed to escape you’d be back faster than you could snap a belt across someone’s face.

•He would prefer if you treated the relationship as a spouse would in any case. Like an old married couple, just reminded of the rules of marriage.

•Being the king of puzzles is no joke, as his more playful moods bring out this side of him. This means that he’ll hide things or hold them out of comfortable reach to until you answer him. This ranges from a cookie to clothing, and can be outrageously tricky to answer. The longest time this had lasted was when he hid your cat in his study for two days until you cried because you thought he got lost. That’s what had your husband caving and bringing the precious little thing out unscathed (and over fed because Eddie might like that cat a smidge more than you’d expect.)

#yandere telltale riddler x reader #yandere telltale riddler Headcannons

39 notes · View notes

fatgumsurpremacy-remastered · 2 years ago

Text

Welcome folks-

My name is Festen Martinez, you can call me Festen. I am an actor above all else and a writer second. I write and draw for Team Fortress Two, as well as the Batman Rouges, (Some Hazbin), and FNAF. If you spark up a convo with me and I know the property and character you have a good chance at me writing for them too.

Feel free to send me requests and I’ll have a look. Current count (41, with 3 more in drafts).

Follow my second blog @faire-of-fictition

My hazbin oc blogs: @mc-tooley-tobias-toby , and @magnum-pritchard-repro

Other info:

He/Its

Bisexual

Transmasc

American (West Virginia, and Texas)

You can send me requests for your OCS or you can ask for mine as well. Don’t me shy, make yourself at home. 🧡

Requests open!

I am a Fandom Writer:

I write for:

Btas villains: Riddler, Twoface, Mad Hatter, Scarecrow, Harley, Ivy. Batman also

TF2: All Mercs AND MS PAULING

I will write:

•Should be obvious but chubby (or fat) reader

•Yandere (preferred)

•Smut (preferred, just reference what you’d want in the ask and I’ll give it to ya.)

•Non con/ Dub con/ CNC

•Platonic

•Headcannons

•Drabbles

•Imagines

I’ll draw any of the above as well

I won’t write (or draw)

•Scat

•Pedophillia

•Age Regression (dkh)

•Detransition

Masterlists:

Tf2

Demoman:

Demo joining a LARP group!

Yandere Demo w/ an s/o who doesn’t like dancing

Yan demo w/ bartender S/O

Engineer

Yandere Conagher Brothers x oblivious reader

Dell x trans husband smut

Yandere Engie and forced affection

Traveling preist Engie Art by @virginstoner666 💗

Go! Yandere Engineer x GN reader (almost smut)

Heavy:

Yan heavy cuddles!

Pyro

Yandere Platonic Emesis py Reader

Semi unmasked art

Ms. Pauling

Yandere Ms. Pauling

Semi Marriage proposal

Platonic Ms. Pauling and new trainee

Medic:

Yandere medic smut

Yandere medic with a captive that goes missing

Yandere medic and a partner w/ stolkholm

Yandere medic lap dance

Yandere medic Cycle of violence smut

Scout:

Get bonked

Yandere scout, kissing practice

Platonic scout

Sniper:

In my style

With a bratty so smut

Soldier:

Nsfw thoughts

Platonic Solly and overstimulated hugs

Spy:

Yandere spy egg vibes

All:

Yandere Red Octoberfest drawing

Would I trust them with my pets?

Demo and heavy x reader Head-cannons

Mercs reacting to a love letter

Yandere emesis Blue x reader

Yandere medic and sniper w/ clingy s/o

Emesis character comfort

Yandere mercs and if they’re comforting or not

Yandere mercenaries and how scary they are when jealous

Yandere Angel au with Sniper, Solider, and Medic smut

My my mercenaries

Soldier/Demo

Medic/engineer

Merc Headcannons

Memed science party

Spy and Engie dad stance

Btas

Alberto

Cornelius Stirk:

Stirk img.

Eddie

BTAS Eddie nsfw snippet

Yandere Arkham asylum riddler w/ shy and anxious reader

Yan telltale riddler with a reader who tries to escape

Yandere telltale Eddie

Yandere Arkham Eddie hcs

Handling it (smut)

Caked up Eddie img.

Eddie frame redraws💚

In my style: Ed and Jerv 💚💙

Nightmares img.

An Ed Kento for Sunny 💚💛

For Arkhamverse simps

Scantily clad ed

5’2 Au pt 1

5’2 suited up

5’2 Au ground img.

5’2 classic mv

5’2 smut pic

There’s a light img.

BTAS Insp. Art

Indulgent riddlebat

More fancy Eddie Art

Dilf Eddie?

Flashy Eddie ing.

Yandere platonic Eddie teaching riddles

Harley:

Harvey:

Au art

Harvey and insert art

Tasteful nudity

Ivy:

Jack:

Joinker au

More whore clown img.

Jervis:

Bonkers img

Jervis img.

Wonderlan img.

Reading img.

Johnathan:

Johnny img.

Scarecrow design img

BTAS scarecrow yandere head-cannons

Comp drawing w/ batman

Yandere BTAS headcannons

Ozwald:

Oswald Img.

Compilation

Au Squad: Jervis, John, Jack, and Edd

5’2 height matrix img (WIP)

Batman Vigilante Squad Au

Hazbin/Helluva Boss

Alastor

Under the Same Young Sky (male reader, ao3)

Vox

Yandere Vox housespouse

It Takes Time to See a Doll, Yandere Vox x Cis!Fem Reader P[1] [1.5]

Vox x chubbyfem reader wip

Ocs

Maddox

Maddox x reader play fighting

81 notes · View notes

mr-voorhees-husband · 2 years ago

Text

"Smart Boy..."

A fic I was writing for myself, but decided to post. Can be read as an x reader, but, it's written w/ me in mind, so.. yeah. This is part one..

Warnings: Blood, Major Plot Change, Gore, Yandere, NSFT, NSF/W, Slight dub-con (Feelings reciprocated, but reader doesn't specifically consent.), Implied stalking (riddler), unhealthy obsessions on a human (reader), major age gap, Telltale Riddler being Telltale Riddler

Reader - He/him, FtM, 20-25, Not good morals.

I was exhausted.

No, wait, scratch that, I wasn’t exhausted, I was just on my last leg. Quite literally, considering that fight with Riddler had twisted my ankle in a way I was pretty sure would leave me limping for a day or so. Batman hadn’t been much help either, focusing on saving some pretty girl agent (or spy, not like I cared to remember) rather than help me in a fight I was seriously outmatched in. No matter, we still won, leaving Riddler beaten and tied up. Not that I wanted him to be, in all honesty, if it’d been up to me, I’d have let him go scott-free. I found the older man pretty damn hot, after all.

“It’s over Ridder.” My eyes flickered up from where I was leaning, landing on Batman who was looming over Riddler in a way not-so heroly. With a bit of trouble, I limped over to them, listening. “Look forward to a padded cell.”

That irked me, the guy may not have been sane, but he didn’t deserve to go to arkham. Though, granted, no one did. That place was hell on earth to put it bluntly. “Well, congratulations, Batman.” Riddler muttered, eyes downcast and voice oddly.. Defeated. It made me feel bad in a way I hadn’t felt in a while, even with the aftershock of adrenaline slowly draining from my blood. “You and your…” Riddler glanced at me for a fleeting moment, before back to the flood, “friend managed, even in my twisted game, to keep everyone alive. But at what cost?” I looked over at the woman again, knowing immediately what he meant before he even said it. “Agent Avesta suffered, so no one had to die. That can’t sit well with you two.”

“Don’t drag me into this.” I hissed out before Batman could answer. Making the caped crusader pass me a glare.

“This entire twisted situation is YOUR doing, Riddler,” Batman spoke up finally, scowling down at the villain, who’d finally looked up at us, “all blame is on you. And so are the consequences.”

“You came after me, you know.” Riddler pointed out, and I gave Batman a look. He was right, which was ironic to say considering how much pain this damn old man put me through. From traps, to fights, he’d given me my fair share of bruises, burns, and scratches within the last couple days. “Not the other way around. I made you hurt an innocent woman to get to me.” He chuckled softly, before his eyes fell again, replaced with something akin to, oddly enough, being disheartened. “My comrades would have been impressed.”

“I set this all up to show them,” a glint caught my eye, eyes going towards the bridge. Someone was up there, I noticed, which wasn’t odd, but something told me to keep staring, even while Batman started to pace. “I thought they’d back me up, even if they didn’t agree.” The longer I stared, the bigger my worry grew, and against my better judgment, I looked back to Riddler, who was still glowering at the floor. “They… They left me here to deal with you alone.” He growled out, eyebrows furrowing behind his domino mask. “They… They betrayed me…” His voice cracked, and I gave him a look of concern.

“You need better friends.” It was blunt, and made me want to sock Batman for saying it. He really did need to learn when to stop rubbing salt in the wound. “The term “thick as thieves’, it’s a lie–”

“I need smarter friends, like this boy.” Riddler snapped back, cutting off Batman’s words and motioning to me with a nod of the head. “They were all so small minded. None of them had vision…” Part of me wanted to crouch down and offer him a hug, though I knew it wouldn’t do much, especially with my leg. “Unless.. Unless that white-faced prick set me up… never told them to meet me here.”

There was that glint again, and I knew what it was this time.

I clutched his face to my chest. Riddler shouted. The sniper rifle went off. A dart hit my metal gauntlets with a ‘dink!’. Then Batman yanked me off of the poor villain. “Sniper.”

Batman spun to look, sure enough finding the damn gunman already running off. Riddler was staring at me bewildered, yet I ignored it, reaching down to grab the dark, which was just a crude bullet shape, with a glass vial to hold the poison, and a needle to inject it.

“Well, either those friends of yours are a lot worse than you thought,” Crouching down, I showed Riddler the dart, which was filled with a vicious lime colored liquid, “or Waller ain’t the only person who wants you dead.”

----------

The police station was buzzing with attention, a mix of news reporters and Waller’s men trying to force their way in to reach Riddler. I peered silently at them from where I was resting, a now lukewarm cup of tea in my palm. Currently, Riddler was being interrogated by Bats and Gordon, some bad cop and worse cop shit that I didn’t care about. All I wanted was some Ice for my ankle, but judging by how ‘busy’ the station was that wouldn’t happen. I wouldn’t leave just yet either, though, as I still needed to talk to Gordon about when I should go talk to the DA about getting the release on my father’s parole block. That was the only reason I even agreed to help with putting Riddler behind bars anyway.

“(L/N)?” I glanced over to the deputy, a nice woman, Melody McKenna. “Erm.. Commissioner Gordon needs you.”

“Oh,” With a slight limp, I walked over to her. “Why?”

“He’ll tell you.”

She led me to the interrogation room, which had none other than the Dark Knight and the esteemed ‘only good cop’ in front of it. I didn’t miss the look they shared, an odd mix of annoyance, defeat, and guilt. Deputy Mckenna quietly excused herself, leaving the three of us alone.

“Well?” I leaned against the wall to try and get some of the weight off my good foot. Gordon and Batman glanced at each other, before Batman motioned for Gordon to explain.

“Riddler is refusing to talk..” His voice trailed off with a sigh, hesitence more obvious then how gay I was. “Riddler is refusing to talk unless it’s with you.”

I blinked. A second went by of me just staring at them, trying to dictate if they were telling the truth. Riddler wanted to talk to me. Not just talk to me, but me and only me. That was simultaneously a horrifying and flustering thought. To say I had a thing for Riddler would be an understatement. Every couple months I’d end up hyperfixating on him, and now that he’d made his comeback, I was back to my roots. Meaning I was more blushy and simp-y then normal. Logically, I should tell them to fuck off, and that I already did my part, but logic had long gone out the window, and the idea of having a one-on-one chat with Riddler was too alluring to pass up. “Alright.”

“What?”

“I said alright,” I repeated, crossing my arms, shoulder still against the wall. “I’ll do it.”

“Good.” Batman grabbed my wrist, yanking me towards the door. I hissed in pain, instincts winning over logic as I tried to stabilize myself with my bad leg. Batman didn’t say anything urging me to the door. “We’ll be waiting out here.”

With a glare sent his way, I opened the door and limped inside. Riddler was sitting at the metal table, hood off, bruised face still bloody, and his cuffed hands resting on the table. He glanced up, eyes showing something unreadable as I barely managed to make it to the chair myself. Lord knows my dad would kill me for not getting it checked out, but, It’d figure it out.

“You wanted to talk, I’m here.”

For a moment, Riddler didn’t say anything, simply staring at me. It didn’t bother me that much, but, when you have someone you’ve had a crush on for years staring you down, it doesn’t exactly feel the best. “You should really get that leg of yours checked out.”

Okay, not what I was expecting out of him, but it was better than nothing. Subconsciously I rubbed my swollen ankle with my other foot, ignoring the way it ached in pain. “It’s fine..” I mumbled, cut off with a cry of pain as his foot pressed against it. I yanked my foot away, whimpering in pain as he continued to stare with that damn unreadable look.

“For a ‘fine’ ankle, that seemed to hurt.” He replied bluntly, intertwining his hands together. I didn’t reply, letting out a shaky sigh as I let my foot fall back to the floor slowly. I noticed the way both his feet were now between mine, set in a way that made me only slightly worried he’d try and actually break my ankle. “You’re a smart boy, aren’t you?”

“I mean..” That wasn’t something I was asked often, and it definitely wasn’t something I had a prepared answer for. “I like to think so.”

“You like to think so.” He repeated as if he was tasting each syllable, eyes scrutinizing. “You solved my riddles in record time…” his left foot rubbed against my right one, and I fought the urge to yank back in pure surprise. Even if I liked the guy, I knew better than to let my adoration get over my fear. He was still dangerous, even with Bats outside. “And you only like to think you’re smart?”

“I… I guess?”

“Hm.” I didn’t miss the way his right foot grazed my left, yet, this time much more careful, and flat out missing anywhere that might hurt. “You’re (Father's name)’s son, aren’t you?”

What?

How did he?

I never told him my name- I never even..

Panic settled in my bones, for a moment I didn't even move, and neither did he. He shouldn’t know that. Even if he recognized me, the way he said it. It wasn’t a damn question, it was a statement. He knew who I was, he just wanted to hear it from me. Wanted me to know he won already. I squeezed my fists, inhaling only slightly shakily as I tried to come up with some kind of reply. Hell, what do you say to that?

“I am.”

“Mhm,” He nodded, and I almost jumped at the feeling of his left foot trailing up my leg slowly, “of course you are.” His foot reached my thigh now, not going any farther, not yet at least. “I’ve been keeping an eye on you for a while now, (Y/N).”

Fuck.

Fuckfuckfuck.

“I-”

“Shh, I’m talking.” Riddler hissed, and on instinct, I shut up. He smiled at that, eyes still unreadable. “You see, before I made my grand.. Let’s say comeback.” His foot nuzzling against the inside of my thigh made me jolt, so close to my crotch I wasn’t sure if I should push towards it or away. “I caught wind that my old partner in crime was locked up, leaving his poor, darling boy alone to take care of his mother all alone.” At this point, I couldn't tell if I I should be more concerned over his foot or his words. He was downright admitting to stalking me, telling me things only those who had my records knew. “And well, I wanted to see how good you’d be if I needed a replacement for your father.”

“What are you-”

“Silence.” The sharp word was extenuated with his foot pressing against my clothed sex, making me bite back a gasp. I didn’t run yet, though, I probably should have. “I was surprised to see how utterly brilliant you were,” Riddler’s boot grinded against my cock, making me fight the urge to lean against it, “Oh and that shrine of yours. Quite the ego booster.”

Fuck, of course he knew about the shrine. A small section of my room, hidden from most people, covered in newspaper clippings and any kind of physical things I could find surrounding Riddler. As stalker-ish as it seemed, it was the only thing that I could really have that kept my hyperfixation at bay.

“So what?” It was an act, and an act quickly unfurling at that, but an act nonetheless. “I’m a fan, sue me.”

“Sue you? No, no. I was thinking something much more… primal.”

Fuck.

FUCK.

I stood up, my chair clattering to the floor noisily. I couldn’t do this. Not now. I needed my dad out first. If I even slightly jeopardized this, he could stay locked up for the rest of his life, which I really didn’t want. Every fiber of my being wanted to leap over the table and shove our lips together, but if Gordon even got the idea I did this for any other reason other than to help my old man, he could call it all off. I wasn’t risking that, even if Riddler lit a spark in my heart I hadn’t felt in… well, ever.

Riddler stared, eyebrows furrowing, this time with eyes I could read. They were a bit upset, and if I didn’t know better, I’d say jealous. The door clicked open, Gordon coming in and resting a hand on my shoulder. “(L/N)-?”

“I’m leaving.” It was said much harsher than the Commissioner probably deserved, but, I had too many emotions storming my body I didn’t care. Gordon reached out to me, but I was already storming out the door.

“See you soon, darling!”

#Telltale #riddler #telltale riddler #batman the enemy within #riddler x reader #tw yandere #tw blood #tw stalking

41 notes · View notes