Yet another reason why AM is the best written route! Billy never angsts about Supreme Leader in that route, the only times they say something positive about her is to comfort Dimitri, which is completely logical given they're close to him but barely know her in this route.
Sunday's salty answer is : Billy doesn't need to angst about Supreme Leader, Dimitri does it already and it's nigh unbearable
I've already mentionned it, but to me, AM's message of "drop vengeance for acceptance" falls completely flat because... Dimitri doesn't accept everything that makes Supreme Leader, well, Supreme Leader, WC is obliterated from everyone's memory and all is well that ends well.
Dimitri won't even ask what Thales is to her, or why she was working with him for her "ideals", or why Duscur happened (both the Tragedy and the following massacre), or where is Rhea/why was she caught, or why Supreme Leader thinks Flayn's race is what makes her unable to "rule over the people", etc etc.
That's why I prefer TS's Roland, both in his route and the golden one, he reluctantly accepts to put his revenge aside and not kill Gustadolph on spot, he still hates him but also wants to stop the bloodshed for the sake of Glenrbook/Norzelia.
Sure, Dimitri's AM arc is to learn to live for himself, so to stop pushing his feelings aside for the sake of his people and embrace them : he cannot still hold hatred against her but move on for the Kingdom, so the devs had him... not feel hatred at her at all? Drop all of his grievances and only end up fighting her because he has to stop her war and their views are not compatible at all?
Dimitri? Bleeding Heart Dimitri?
What would he feel if he saw the rooms where people were waiting in before being transformed in War Assets ? Or would he feel the same feeling of sadness because "their ideals" forces him to stop her, if Supreme Leader told him Flayn, because of her race, has no regards for human life? Or if she told him Dedue's sister and entire family were "necessary sacrifices" because her ideals needed Duscur to happen?
We have the entire sobfest "I have to kill her because our ideals are not compatible and we will not see eye to eye to end this war :'(" and no "I have to kill her to end this war and to bring justice for all those suffered and are still suffering due to her selfish war".
In a way we have boar!mitri being BaD because he wants not just to kill, but to murder her, and King!mitri being GoOd because now he doesn't want to kill her, but has to because their ideals are clashing and he has to end her war :'(
Fun for thought -
Imagining Supreme Leader somehow survives AM and Dimitri doesn't want to kill her, what happens?
Naesala only escapes death because Tibarn ultimately knows about the Blood Pact, bcs herons and bcs Naesala makes amends and decides to atone.
Assuming Rhea is found in the state she's in at the end of SS/VW, would the CoS want her execution?
If the truth about Duscur and Agarthans is revealed (but unlike Naesala, Supreme Leader willingly helped the people who tortured her and in turn called the following people who were tortured "necessary sacrifices"), on top of the current War and Cornelia, given how she helped and abided by her Agarthan associates, and started the war, and sacrificed her own people to create War Assets... Would Faerghus/whoever's in charge of Leicester (Erwin) and Adrestians themselves want her alive?
What would she become? Exiled from Fodlan? Executed? Put in permanent House Arrest in a manor?
9 notes
·
View notes
Thoughts on Tallstar’s Revenge?
i think i've talked about it before but i find tallstar's revenge to be an unsatisfying mess of ideaa. the plot really feels like a train track of just uuhh this needs to happen don't think about why
why does tunneling need to go? to cause conflict! who are the strangers why is windclan so chill with them? because tallstar needs to go elsewhere that's why! why is shadowclan is so weirdly aggressive the entire time??? who gives a fuck, we need conflict! what are they even fighting about? who gives a fuck, the book sure doesn't
sandgorse is a shining example of fathers who can literally abuse their sons throughout a book only to be redeemed at the end as a stand up guy who meant well and literally no one holds as much venom against him as they do similar characters or even characters who don't deserve it.
the book was hyped up on its release, i remember at the time i wasn't sure if i wanted to buy it and the OG forums said yeah it's sooo different and good than the others and it SUCKED ASS!!!! didn't like when i first read it and i still don't!!!!!! jake and tallstar's relationship is hyped up as if they don't know each other for a WEEK then literally fuck off from one another so jake can go make some protag/antag babies. what a romance!
the entire book is devoid of any real thought than The Plot Needs This To Happen. it's bad and it sucks because there's so much potential! literally just gimme a windclan civil war between moor runners and tunnelers, it literally fits so well in tallstar thinking he's united his clan only to cause ANOTHER civil war after he dies.
17 notes
·
View notes