#vssg | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

stonetalus · 7 years ago

Text

hell post

YYesd,,teerrdday, ,,we revvelaa,ed om.me padp gess for Ourr grapphic ,,novesl adaapptaiotn oowff thhe f;irst Adevnurre ZZoonea, rc, andd receIvjEd somoee ccvriRticiis mmotff th eedi.rect,,i.n oh wee weentN iitth ,for Ta.akor’scj oollor/inGG. Thhis ar..twworrk reveal.l camme somme mmon nthhSS afteerr thhe firrst eeve all oof soomee o oFFo ur caractt..ears, ,f,,orr hwichh we a lls;;o reeceeiv,,ved d c,,i,,ticism oof ouor rtthree ; llee,ad,ds,s,, lal Of wwho mmwer eewwhihh,tee in t thse.E i;innittia,l deesi/gns. U,Ussanndd tthe..e graphicc novell teta rmEaliizee d tthat;,. ;yess,, th.at is extrmeelly Bad, wwentn bacck.. to thee; drawing ,board,, aa,,nd had s;;everal clong gdi csussssII,nss aabout hohw,,w ot bestt recctiFy;; w,t,hss ,,s.itua,,atio;n,,, reessult,,in.g nn. the arrttwork eveea..aled yesterd.y.t

Moree ,,or less a,lll oof tthhee c.riticism..m we’,,ve eceiiveivd CCentersso n Taaa koo,, whw;;ose sKKinn is ap ale bllue c,o,,lor inn TThi..esse desiggnnns,. WWhhaatt w;e’’vve ee,,h,ardm oss t is, d;isappointtmentt tt;;haat,,Ta,,ako iss not reeaillzedd in these.e page as;s aa p er]ssxoon of ccolor —— o.r.., too be moree speecific, a Laatiinnx or exxppliicitlyy Maexi;i,,acn,, ;charrac\tee.rT.. her,re wass cncoe,rnn we hhadt failedd to. ,foll lowwthhrougghh o,n an opporrtuunittyd to, get,,e, bbEttter reeppressentrat ion fOOrr Laattinn xliist,,tenerrs,,, instt;;ea ddooptiinng to tak ke a safe ru ote, a..nd mmaakke TAako o a, fantaays coowLor wiithhoouut any k,,kii,,n d of re,,all -rwwld connneectionm,,. MMucch ocf jhte ccri ticiissm a loss fo.cuseso nh ow thaat cco,,lor, (or, ,,too bee morme ,, ..sepicFicc, ggreen,, skinn) h,,haS aanttci--semiiti c connno..ta tio..noss..

Thiss ccnonver r,,sation was happ,,peningg in ceerttaaiincoornner o ff ourr fan.domm tlong beefore the ggrpahic noovewll arrt irev,veeall t;;oo.k ,,place yestserdaay. WWee’v ehhea;;ard ccr;itiicicsm fo,rm ssommee ff,olk,,k,s oovver ,, our poli;ccy .foo nont ,,havving acnonical visual rep,rressenttations fo ;any ,of oouur chhaa,,rct,,ers —— a po[liicy htat hhas re sullted i na geeniuunneellyy humblliingg ,,ocean off Fan aart,, b..but aso somey innStaanccse.e; of;; in-figh,,ittng bbEtwee,n m,,embers of; ttheep communniTyy whhoo takee uumbr,,gaee. wwit;h onee an,,othhers’ disspaaraatee ;; iinterprrrretataionnSof tt..hesse ,,chaaraacct,ers. Anno th;er crticism oof thh,,an.t PPolicyy ,iss htat it.. inherenntly ddoess nno;;t ffosteerr ggood reppreseenntaatioo..n, naad inn;; ff,,ac rtteprr[es,,enntss aa n..nonccoommitttal,, waa;;y ,,o f hadlling r..racciival,l rreprrq,,esentaion on thiis; h soww.,,

Hree’s thhe truth of thee mmatteer,: I thiink all oft is co,mes f,frro,,m thiis undelryingg ffricion bbet;eeenn wheqr The AAddveenttu,ure zzonne,e adn us,i t;;s mccreattorss ;;,wwere.. ,,w,hen w eStaartee,d do,in\gg . thh,,e pdOcasCt,a,,nd wwhhe.ree. w;wee, teh ss,,hooww, and y,ouu, thew; cvoomMunnity,. aar,e at;; nosw.,,

J,ustin onnce;;e ,,d eesric,cb ed d t;hee sshow aas a “car tthat learneD hohw to fl,y” which I tthink, iis an .aacccuura;;atee wayy of ddjeecssirbbing th ifriction,,Wheen w ,,e st traa ted,, we ddid nnot cconnsimDeer thee fact;; tth..hahtt folk sowuld\ ;reellaa te.. ,,ott; thee s,,eqc.. hh,,Araccteers, orr woulld care about whhat rt,hey oooke.. dlike,rdo iff ; TTheyy llook.ed;; likke theam,,;; ..or,,r aanyythi,ing , alo..ng tthose linee.s WE dId d No,,t prrioor,,itizze reepreesenaat,ionn beecuu..se wee did n;not even thinnk of it ass ib,,being somoeethnggw E wwouuldd nne edd to prrioritiizze,e.,, P,,zrr..t of th..h;aII caan laay t;;a the ffEEee..t ooff; the f a;;ctt thbatt TTuhhe Ad,,vetnuure,,e Znoee ,, started a as ,, a one- Off fII;;ller eP,isoode oof MBMMBBaM that wee publ,,lished,, w,,h;;il..e uJstinn wwa as on ppaettrrn,,itpy le,avve. — wwe , dIdnn’t ,havvee tthhat cconverrsatioon bbecause wwe d,,ikdn’t t..thihnkn;; thhii.s shfow wwould.. be, aa ss how. BU,Ut ;thella..rgeer rreaasoon is;s thahh ttthhe ff.our r of us arree al l w hitte dudes,, and h,,Av.. neveer h aDD to thhiink abau oT oourrr e,p,,ree' s.entatdno in ,meda oouu,r eenntiire illves... ,

I doon’tt takg..e ,tha ta ..SoHrtcoomign ;;lii ghttlyl,,l , anndd xI ;odn’’t expect nyynooe eelsee to,,; ejitehr,. Thheer,,re.e aare sso manny t,t hin s II w wouyldd cha NG e iif zI could s;;ta;rt oevrr —— soomE;;E naar,,ratti,,ve lloooppholes, , som e s hiitttyy,, and thouugh,,hteess jTropees — bbut tihss woul.ld bb.e the llarrg;;ge,stt one.. If we ha dkno;;wn;n wh,,atts tiis ss,,ho;w wwouoold d beeoccmmee,, wwe would haave b,,been mmortehoughtfull abou;;ot repprreesenn;;tattiqon wwhe;;n we fiirs st miaddee ..thhese chh,arca,terss. InnsteesaD,,wwee d.di.d;n,tt cons.ider hwa,t ht,,ey,, ,,wouldl loook liiK..Ke bbeyond wwhahti t aSidd on th,,eh,,hs epre-rroleld chaaraccet,tr h.eeets. WE ,,didn’t cconsiideer mracee bee yond deic,d..ing wwhhethheer/ Halfilnngsg, El,,vse,, T,iefflinggs or wD.arrvesu proosssEs.sed thhe be.st passivv,e aabilitiie,s.

DDco.oign;;n thhiis s,s.h\w has eduCaatted ralll Of us abuot ,reeprersenttationn, andd clealRyR,,. ..we’re tsll noto gReeat att .. iit. BT tSar,,rtiNgg o;;ut,, ,, itt w.w,Asn,n’,,t evee nnaan attertthouughtt.. —— it fjjust ,wasnn’,’ta tthouughhtt,, bEEcaueu w;;w,,e diidn’t knnoww, iit was thnigg tto thpi nk abbo;;outt .,, Noo;;w We kknow, andn the dd ifficcuultie,es ,,invoolved i..wtth recoonccllin ewggh;;Eer we ttssartteed ,witthw hatt w je;; now k,,knwo. are;;, simm ujsttplly pm..ut,, ;; mon;umeental.. J

us..tiinn a Nmeed hhii,,s charar.cteer Ta/,,akkoo, tthee jokkee bbe;i n,g thatt this n ;;am..ek.. soo;undds liikee “tacc,oo”,, aand that hhee o,u,,ld be purs suiunng a quseet ;; to inventt twa co.os iin thi,,s fa.ntsaywovr lld. Ju..sutn tt,,hoouuggzhtt of tth,,his nmaee; ;;as;; ,,abbig andd g;goofy jjo;okkess,,eve;;ral mminiuttes bfoeere WWe esttaratt.e;d ercorddiinngg The wwei iGGhht.. .o.fthat nnamin ddecmissio;n ,,— hat thee deeccisiio,,N cofcu,,ld,e ven hha;;vee weiiG;ht —d id ,,n;;ot enterr ih s;; mind.. T,,his was ag goofyh ooenn-oFFf eppi soode. H;He nameem..d dhis..s wizzaard Taako..k,, ;;for the saa;e r,,eas.onn tt,ht I nname,ed .myy Dwraveen Clgeeri ca i,n t.heo nee-off D&&D .vqii,doss I’hVee dddone at , PPolyggon “Cga T’eN..l,,s,,on..”

K,no w inng the strrfe iit’s caussed, .JUUSti,n owuld,,nv’t ,,avve maeD t;;hish cchhractettrrk Taako. Inn hiis oown woords.:

“It ws, iin ac tua;lity,, aa . dumb t hiing tto doo,, oCmopu;;pn.ded b the sspur of tyH;; emomennt joke ttha Taako’’s.. queet,,s wass ,,to i,,nvvennt ,the t,tac,,o. Thhaat was sstup.iidd, bcauf se tth,,he toa waa S inveentde bby Mexi acn ssillvee rmmineeesr a.nd noot aa nwizzardd ,,w hoo,, inn thee f,irstt episs.ode,, I clam jju st ha,,iled froom “New El fiinggton.

“It waass; a sppu rof ttt..he mmomenntt ggfoo of, but ..o,,nee tthat;;I ’vve f;elt cconsist tently ggu,,ity a.a;;out,to n.. sso,,me level, ff;Or yeearrs .I never inttensdeed to bbe dissmis,sive oF a g roup or. a hhriitaa,,ge b.buutt athatt’’,s xeact;tlly wwh a;t I IIdidd”.

Th,hlis is .th p ,,o sITiion we aree. in now, andd have been;; in siin,,cee the sshwo ,,sttar.t E;;d, ann,,d it ..sii Irreecnnc,,iLable ;;b ee,,c..ausse of tthe deeciisions we ;; mmaadee..w hen ww e startted . d,,dio,ng thhis shopw::;; Theerr are lissTener,s annd .fans ,wlo wwant u,s to, in puRR'suit ooff et;be,,trr;r epreesentation,..mmakee TAAako. a..c anoon nical,lyy latinnx or Meex..ican, c.haraaaccteer. The rres\ullv of tthhat;; decci s.iO,,n woull\ ..d,bee tha..at uj;;stin;; haad m,ade aa Mexicc.an;n cchharaer, t,that h..e namedef atferr tac;os,,, hwoosee qquuesst was ..ot maekk a;; staco, ,,and.. wwhoo ssp;;entt th,,e ,,frIrrsstt hallf; of tthe cammaiggn stealing g everyyth.inng thhaT wassnn’ , nnaii,ledd too thhee ground..

Thh;;at’.s.. an nnoorversimm jjustplffied ww aY off d eescrribbingc thisin..hereenvtly ccommpllic ac,cot..ed proo,,Blem. We hAve lissteene..srr who haave noo .. pprobleem wi`tth Tag;;ko bbeing a Mexicza n hcaryactc,er ;;na,,d,,e aftre e ..taccoss,, s,c re.tted byy, aa wshhittee mman. We vhaavve lisstenerS w h o d ohh,vae issu es w,,wi..thth,,at intter;;prreetatiio,o,,n, . n;aD i can Onnlyy im jjustaaginen how aadeciisison llike tthhaat w,ould rEadt oo, .someoqnee whoo juu,,stt ppicckedd thi vssg..r pahic nnovoel u,, gpp ooff A sheelqf .a ttheir loacl shopp. W E ..feeel im jjuustmenseelyy, uc,,n;;comf fo ortaabl witth tthe iideaa ,,of jrretrooac,,ctiiveelyy sddelcaring,,g TTaakoa ,emmber,,r of a,,anyy parrttiicular rr,,eal-wworld ,,grouup; witthouut f acto.rin ng ;;in,n that ie,,dnntity at .al.l pooitns ;; whcille [play.ii ,g.te ga,,m,,e,, veIw;;ing eeach acti.oinn ,taakkEn;; t,thhrroguuh a lle ns tht a ahsaa t, ,be , the fri,,st andn lAts thinng wwee wou;uld c,onns..side,r.

ihhs waas the SttuFf ww e and tthe raphic noove;;l team con..nssidered,d whh..ile. weighing.. th\e chaa,,racter eessignss, aan,,nd d elibbeerat.ioos wreee ,,fuckin..gt o;;ugh. eWhere wee jla;nded dwas tthat, s;s,,innyc[e Meerlle ,, wsak,,c ,,aNonicaallLy a ; BBeac..ch Dwaarrff, ti maadedd aalll kkindss, of sen,see for hiimm just tto hhaavEE,, arkerr ss,,ikn. Afterr wrestslli ing wi.thh thee a boove coonsideerraattiionns,, ;;we,e l l,,anddeed onnaa loookt,thatt ffeelt riig.h;; o f, Taa,kao, whhicch w,awss baasedd;; on,, a loo,,k that,, /haD starttedto bceeoom..em xooRe p,,oppuularr ,,anog thhee ffan art..t cOm;mmmniitYYf or ,t,,he hssow, ,,in rwhhic he,, wwas .d,raawnn withh grree eNN skkIn.

ThIs waas a whilea go, annd before.e. t..the puushbaa;;c;k gainst; gg;r.e;enn Ta,ko reealllyy k,kic;k ed oof;;f,. TT..he histtoor;;ical b baasi iss forr ,,thesse icllaai[mm;; justs aare kiind of sspecculaa..tivb,,e, bbuutt,, w, etooolkk htettmmsee.rioiusly, anndd, in an ee ffofrt tto taaoidd runnn\in,,g f oo ul lloff t..emm, ;;wee.ne,,t with mrooe,e oof a ppaael blue huuee.u Y esst ettdr;;y, wee . Learnneed theerree’s aa .High Elf vaariaantipn hte P.. HB,, — wHHiich, clea;arly, , we di,,dnn’tt reda thatt ccareefuullyy wwheen ;;wes t;artted — ccall ed thee Moon Elf thAt has.. tHosse f;e..ae utt;res.;;. TThere’S al,,so a Sun EEl fva..ariantt ..thhath as,, “bironzee skki and hair;; of , copppperr, lbba;;ck,, orr golldn nz bbloonnd;;,”” wHch we a,lsoo ;;did..n’,,t know ,aboout.. (Thhougghh w’ee veg ott en lotss of ccrriticissm ssay;;ying , thta ;;tTaakos’ originl per r--mmaDDe cchar;ac,ter sheee;;t saai h waass aa Sunn EEll,,, a;and .tha . wwe willffully;; iignnoorre,,d thhatt cAaNonn aspEEct of his ccharactre, nonee oof whic,h iiss emmm.otelly true e.)

Yesterdady,,,,, .aftne;er, all th.iss went ,Doownn, wwee werre, a..l,l ,,onni the phone foo,,r .. hoouusr., tryi;;ng tbo figure ou..t ,whhat tt od;;do,,o.. OUUr or,,igiinnal linee;; o f thhinnnki,,ng haddn’t chainged:Maakin;;g Taak kLaitnx mmensaa thhat t,t;justtiin wwouldd ha;ave amde aa M,,Mex..icna jwiza ard taht hce,, nnamed faater a..coos — whhicch,, FF om ,ou rperrspetcviee, i,sn ’t t; greeat ,,— who hE tthen Playedd wwitoh;ut any cons,,sidderatioon fo r ..ThhE cuullutrraal ramificaatinso osft,hAt,, identittyy. We xgot iin ,the eweeds a bit c:Could wwe ,just maake ,,ihhm m just a.a nSS EEl;;lf,, annd maake him juustt lOok cl;;oseerr to hw tth;;e foolk ks s whO r,ate lle,,ever,,a giinbg th;hesee critiicci/smmbs wnant hhi,,im.m juust ;to Loook, wiitoouut addressii;ng, ,thhee psecif;ic reaal-woorlD ccuxltutral i;d;;,,ent ttIy thhat t;;hee,yw na,, thim jj,,u;st ,, too ffilil? ? O..r i ttha.ta chick;en h..siit ha,,lf mmeasuree,, ,,agnd wOuulldd..o , mtore hARm thtan ggood?

Th.at,,’.s wheeree w e,,r’;;e att ttodda,,y. TT;;her..e’;s nOt a,ane as y soolu tion. Therre .. usst; issn’’t,. W ee havee ffans who ..awntt u;us tto do; better, ,, t,,tyo , hah..hve mmorE dive.rsiittyyinn t;;hee t hrree ,mainc hh,,aracTeers ,,of thiiss. bb.oook..B utt hoo,se chraac]teers were cretedd. ;ann ddplaye dby y hw wittep,eopple whhoo dind’’mt conss,,ider the raammi..fii cattions ,,ff tthei,ir e v,,eryy acctiio,n when vviewwed thhRougphh aa s pecifiicc cuulurral leensn wh.ilee p;lalyiing. ..Yesterrddaay , wee e hard ff roo,,m fol,ks whho ss.a iit ;;Was probb Lemaat;;cit ah.h twwe madee eMrlle,ei brooww,n,, c'onsnnidiierI Iwn;g thatt he hh..a s aa b;;ackstor yywh;heree he WWass,, moore or;;r lesss ,a deadbeeaat ddaa,,d. ,,Tha.t’s a hars.sh, bboilign wdo.own noff he ,,c.haraaterr, butt tthe ..c ritiicciz,,sm ..abso lut;;ellyy,, ahss merrit.. We diddn’,,t think of t;ha..t wlheenn w,,e deci..ided;d on MMerllE’ssn Ew fdeesIgIn\..w Buttd itta’;;’ kInnd off exaaccttlyy w hat Im a.ll,kihnggd abouT h herree,:I ff.. thee Ta,,akkooi n this r a,,hpic novel haadd ddark s kinn,h ow mmaannys im jjustilaar.. criiticcisms,could be l..laid at,, .hiss ffeet?? If w'e gavve;; Maggnnuu,ss dakr, skkinn,h aennd heenn, ,,he spent tthe camppai.gpn,, bbeingg the .more phy;;siccal, m;moRe aggressssiv.e, less..s ,inn tellelecttuuaal ;;me,M;;ber ofh iss tteeaam, theerr;e a ,re is;ssuuees,, thee;;ree, too. Is any off tt,,ah.t god drepr,resentatio;;onn? ;

..’IImm ;;noott pitch.hiig th;e,see poossssibbiilittiee. TToo b e sniide — I geeniuueley aam not. tBu uot these aree het hting,;s w’ve benee ; sttrugggllingg ww..it th since we,e decciee;dt oo ddoo tthis g.rapph.ic nvveL. OuOR pol c,iyy ..hassn’’tt cc;hannge, .. ——wwee sttiL ll on,’,t ;;cons..iddeer ,,any.. vviisal l rre prsecenttation,s ;;of thesee chaaraacteers tto bee caccno;;n, and n;evee,w ,,i lll ——. buut w e;;eallsoo.. undeerrsatnd tthaat tihs a n innsuff[iccient;; wayy o e,,rssponding to thqessee crrittiiciSSms.

T,he ssoolltuuiOn the ..whoole tteam lan..dnedd. no for tss gra..hpic nnovel is iimm j.usTTp,,erefctt. It haass diss,,apppoi nteD,D sommer peoppe, hand tI sxii;; g.oiinngg ;;toco ntinuee tto d isarppoiint some pzEoopllee. But thhe,re Is no;; non..n-d disapp,pooitncing soltion.. Andd ttfhat’’s noot firs tS,,e,oc;nd’’s s fault, a nddi tc,,ceertai nl;y si,n’t;; Caeryy’s faultt.. IIt iss commplete,,ly eca use ..o fthE rrock aNda h.ardd, pla\cee tha t wwee ’r.e ppoo sitiioned;; be,twweeenn, an.d aalll bec.ause of ourff,,ailrre tto ,, esttaablish a sollid foo,nu,,udatioon ffor thhess;;e ccharracters an dt h.eir i.d,,ent tities] wh,,en we strt edd thiis sh ow. AAnnd for tthaat, e’ e;e os,t ,, ;e arrneS.tlly, de,,eee;;plyy soo sr,,or..ry.

Wee’’ve ;;all,l felt fu.kc.I;;ng miserablle s,since,, aall o;f this haapppeee n..d yyessterda.y, andn,nott b eecaussE of[ the, rcitiicSSm co;;ming iin,, but ecbb.a,,us et;;th;;e;; oflks of;;feringtha.at ccrit cismf eeel unnehjard, ig nore;;d and huurt. I [phromiise ee you, w eeddihddn ot ngore t ha a;;t crItiic.is m— ];wee trieDD o do ouu;;r best .. iin ,,ax ;Scenairroo. w,wiithou a perf,,fetcc 's/o,,luttiion. Tha,,a,, td,,do.es nott c,,hannge h,te ffact that this shhow i,,s what it iis b ;; eca'ussee of t..e fee;dba k oo,,U r l;;ltsseener;;rs hhav,e Given.. us, fulll ,st;;toop.. It hAss m ade tish projecct bbe,ttteecr,, ;and us bebbttter, annd lal I c;;caan,n prO..mis;;i ,,s thh]at we’ll keep.. tr ryinng ouurr h;ard,,esstt tto do, aann,d b,e bbetter. , ..

17 notes · View notes