#to elaborate a lil on the cis people playing trans characters
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Photo
I hate this attitude so much! This argument is stolen from disability and poc activists who have been asking for a long time for people playing disabled characters or characters from a particular ethnic background to actually be from these groups. You'll notice this actually makes total sense!
While not having scarjo play your poc is a good starting point, casting a chinese actor to play a vietnamese character because "its close enough for the white people in the audience" is still a problem. And casting accurately solves many many problems. Eg when your writer/costumer/set designer messes up the actor knows and corrections can be made. When they need to act vietnamese can.
Same goes for disability. So many autistic people hate shows about us because allistics are really bad at playing us! They can do stereotypes and act kooky enough to satisfy allistic audiences but like in the above example that means using us as objects while ignoring us as part of the audience. You have any idea how often we see mobility aids used dangerously wrong on tv? Or how often characters are supposed to have an illness but they don't have any of the symptoms! A disabled actor has symptoms! Their aids are real! And when things are depicted as real then we exist
But we don't have these same reasons for queer characters. Sure there is a queer culture, but crucially not all queer people are part of the community. There is no way to act queer the way there is to act muslim or italian, because the only thing we all have in common is being different. We come from everywhere, and we act every way. Some of us try to fit in with our communities of origin, some of us try to fit into the queer community. Neither way is right or wrong. Anyone can be queer and we can be anyone.
There are times when casting queer actors might make sense, like for a visibly trans character, but if they're not visibly trans cis people can do that. And I always like it when queer people are in things because give us money, but we can be anyone so anyone can be us
#to elaborate a lil on the cis people playing trans characters#it is both accurate and pro trans to have people like zendaya play trans women#because a. trans ppl look like that. b. yes random man you can be attracted to trans women it happens all the time chill#but if someone wanted to write a story about a trans person who stays closeted every day of their whole lives#i feel like in most cases youd have to have a cis person play them? that sounds like such a dysphoric and difficult roll to play while trans#but yeah plenty of times queer actors play queer characters in deeply unqueer stories#because what matters is that the writing is queer#this is the same reason that my casting a chinese person to play a vietnamese character wouldnt really matter so much#if the entire thing was made in vietnam#if the writers director and other behind the scenes people were all disabled#than i bet they could have an abled actor do a great job playing someone with cerebral palsy or smth#depends on the disability but they would pick one that could be mimicked yk?#but yeah as always context matters the most and this awful coopting of nonqueer activist rhetoric#has had predictably disastrous effects ie forcing ppl to come out#this is as always why ppl who join social justice communities but dont understand theory#behind things#need to be quiet and LISTEN#anyway ty for coming to my tedtalk
32K notes
·
View notes
Note
i dunno if uve been asked this but do u have *any* queer clone high headcannons? like, a trans or bi headcannon atleast ?because yknow inclusivity and diversity is a butiful thing and especially in clone high were some of the clones were actually clones of historicly queer people and i think that its really cool theres cannonicly queer characters.!!
you wanna talk about diversity when you can ask literally any other clone high blog for their lgbt headcanons and they'd all have a list to show you lolol, lil old me going nah I headcanon everyone as cis and straight is not going to kill you and maybe it can bring a lil more of that diversity if you think about it... a small grayscale patch to really emphasize the saturated colors that surround us, right?
if a character is canonically queer, here they'll be headcanoned as cishet, kinda like back in the day (and now :v) where canonically cishet characters are headcanoned as queer, not much of a big deal honestly~~ tis all in good fun, the frida boy kisser you may see here it's not going to erase the frida girl kisser from the canon of the show (or erase real life!frida's bisexuality) and its not like it affects characterizations and such
except for topher of course, depicting him as not-cishet in any way could be unmistakably and severely out of character for him but i will elaborate in a couple of hours so do look out for that one ;3c (and it is still in good fun if you wanna do that, I care a lot about it but that's entirely a me problem, no need to don't worry about it uwu)
and as a final note, trans stuff is like, the exact opposite of my area of expertise, so i'll avoid dealing with that as much as possible, i rather work with whatever feels closer and relatable to my experiences, which i'm guessing is what a lot of y'all are doing with your dolls so don't let it bother you the way I play with my dolls, ey~?
#ask#clone high#i remember that i was going to theme this blog as clone het during s3#but all eps dropped at once so nah xd
1 note
·
View note