#so imagine how much more ‘subtextual’ shit was cut out of final reels pre/post production

[naruhearts]

(— @bookdork1 )

“The writers wrote this DeanCas scene / this queer Dean moment and then still called us delusional.”

No, they didn’t. But I’m sure as fuck calling you delusional right now for repeating this completely fabricated bullshit for the past decade without once stopping to wonder “but wait, which writer said that and when?”

Because if any of you had ever bothered to do that you’d realize that not a single one of the 52 credited writers of spn has EVER said anything remotely close to this.

Several writers have, in fact, said the opposite–and feel free to do your own homework on that, because the receipts are out there, and maybe if you dig them up yourselves you might actually pay attention–but people have been projecting and playing fandom telephone for so long that baseless bronly quotes have been falsely attributed to the people who were actively and deliberately writing this stuff into the bones of the show for years, and who eventually made it as canon as they possibly could within the confines of the network’s grip on a dinosaur Bush-era TV show.

I swear this take was exhausting to see continually crop up when the show was still airing, and I’ve gotta say it’s even more exhausting now because THE WRITERS UNEQUIVOCALLY WROTE IT INTO THE TEXT OF THE SHOW. AND THEY STILL HAVE NOT ONCE SAID THAT WE WERE DELUSIONAL FOR SEEING WHAT THEY PUT THERE.

For crying out loud the core emotional arc of the final goddamn season was Dean and Castiel’s relationship.

Castiel flat out confessed his romantic love for Dean in a scene that was written first thing in the season, that was built toward with deliberate intent for multiple years. Through that confession the show retroactively confirmed that all of the subtext and parallels and on and on that meta writers had been pointing out for years was in fact exactly what we thought it was.

So unless you think that somehow we managed to be spot-on correct about everything on Cas’ side but forgot how to interpret layers of text on Dean’s side, you should be able to understand that we were given two equations and one answer.

1 + 1 = 2 is what they gave us for Castiel.

1 + 1 = ? is what they gave us for Dean.

If you think they did it by accident you’re kidding yourself. If you think they left Dean’s answer as a question mark for some malicious reason you’re kidding yourself. If you think that “the writers” think we’re deluded for reading into all the layers the deliberately included in the story then you’re kidding yourself.

Quit uncritically spreading anti trash around like it’s truth.