#previously on: people who are legitimately proud of not having read comics and think criticizing fanon for being wildly out of character
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
oh my god just saw a truly horrible post. save me competent corner of the dc fandom
#shooting myself btw.#previously on: people who are legitimately proud of not having read comics and think criticizing fanon for being wildly out of character#is like. being negative or whatever#āi donāt care that itās out of character I can do whatever i like the best ā#YOU DONT CARE THAT ITS OUT OF CHARACTER?? HUH??????#SO YOU AGREE. THATS NOT THE SAME CHARACTER.#wtf are you all onnnnnn#shut the FUCK up. YOU DONT KNOW THOSE GUYS!#THOSE ARE NOT THE REAL GUYS!#YOU DONT KNOW THEM LIKE I KNOW THEM!! RAHHHHH#Iāve been living in our blissful little comic loving corner for so long that i lost tolerance for bad takes#āi donāt judge people who do read the source material BUTā <- an argument i just saw with my own two eyes#PLEASE.#āthereās no wrong way to be a fan this is just the way that works for meā#i mean sure but. why#you. you do know you are not an authority in those characters if you have never read the source material right#you do know you arent somehow better than people who actually read the comics right.#you do know the characters are extremely different basically unrecognizable and way more compelling in canon. right#ASJKENWKDKWKFJSLDJ. anyway
5 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
My Week in Manga: April 17-April 23, 2017
My News and Reviews
Well, I didnāt manage to post my in-depth manga review for April last week after all. Today Iām starting in a new position at a different library, meaning that last week I spent most of my time tying up as many loose ends as possible at my previous job. This included writing a lot of documentation. And since I was doing so much writing for work, by the time I got home I didnāt want to do anything but read, so thatās what I did. (Which goes to explain why I ended up finishing Cixin Liuās excellent novel The Three-Body Problem much sooner than I had originally anticipated.) But never fear, Iāll be posting my review of Nagabeās The Girl from the Other Side later this week in addition to the monthly manga giveaway.
In other news, Seven Seas continued its string of licensing announcements, adding OrikÅ Yoshino and Z-tonās light novel series Monster Girl Doctor, Kazuki Funatsuās Yokai Girls manga, and Saki Hasemi and Kentaro Yabukiās To Love Ru and To Love Ru Darkness manga to the slate. Recent announcements from Viz Media included Sankichi Hinodeyaās Splatoon manga, a Hello Kitty coloring book, picture books of Hayao Miyazakiās Castle in the Sky and Princess Mononoke, as well as the My Little Pony: The Movie artbook. Kodansha Comics had a couple of announcements to make recently, too, such as the upcoming release of full-color hardcover edition of Gun Snarkās Attack on Titan: No Regrets (Iāve previously reviewed the seriesā first English-language release) and a hardcover omnibus edition of Yukito Kishiroās Battle Angel Alita. (The series was originally published in English by Viz Media but has been out-of-print for quite some time.)
I also came across a few other interesting things last week: Over at The OASG, Justin interviewed Mariko Hihara and Kotoyo Noguchi, two independent manga creators in Japan. Noguchi also had some questions to ask in return. Frederik L. Schodt (whose work I greatly enjoy) was recently profiled at Nippon.com. The article takes a look at his involvement as an ambassador for manga over the last four decades. Caitlin from I Have a Heroine Problem presented a panel called āIs This Feminist or Not? Ways of Talking about Women in Animeā at Sakura Con 2017 and has made her slides available. A very nicely designed site called Persona Problems offers criticism of Persona 5ās English localization and delves into translation theory and practice that even people who donāt play the game may find interesting. Finally, the author and designer Iku Okada has started a series of autobiographical essays called Otaku Girl and Proud which explores Japanese gender inequality and identity and how popular culture can impact that experience.
Quick Takes
Dorohedoro, Volumes 17-20 by Q Hayashida. Despite being one of my favorite ongoing series currently being released in English, I seem to somehow always forget how incredibly much I love Dorohedoro. I tend to forget how tremendously horrific the manga can be, too, mostly because it simultaneously manages to be surprisingly endearing. Hayashidaās story and artwork is frequently and stunningly brutal, gut-churning, and grotesque, but Dorohedoro also carries with it a great sense of humor. Granted, the comedy in Dorohedoro tends to be phenomenally dark. Lately, as Dorohedoro continues to steadily progress along what I believe will be itās final major story arc, the series has become fairly intense and serious, but it remains exceptionally weird and has yet to completely lose its humor. The plot of Dorohedoro does meander a bit and because itās been so long since Iāve read the previous volumes Iām sure that Iāve forgotten a few important details as the story takes multiple convoluted turns along the way. Ultimately, it doesnāt seem to really matter though since the world and characters of of Dorohedoro follow and operate under their own peculiar sort of logic; Dorohedoro doesnāt need to make a lot of sense in order to be bizarrely enjoyable.
FukuFuku: Kitten Tales, Volumes 1-2 by Kanata Konami. Before there was Chiās Sweet Home there was FukuFuku Funyan, Konamiās cat manga which started in the late 1980s. The series featured an elderly woman and her cat FukuFuku. More recently, Konami createdĀ FukuFuku: Kitten Tales, a spinoff of FukuFukuās first series which, as can be accurately assumed by the mangaās title, shares stories from the loveable felineās youth. While Konamiās artwork in FukuFuku: Kitten Tales is black-and-white rather than being full-color and the manga is only two-volumes long rather than being twelve, the series is otherwise very similar in format toĀ Chiās Sweet Home. Itās actually been quite a while since Iāve read any ofĀ Chiās Sweet Home, butĀ FukuFuku: Kitten Tales feels like it might be a little more episodic as well. However, it is still an incredibly cute series. Each chapter is only six pages or so but manages to tell a complete story, accurately portraying the everyday life and antics of a kitten. FukuFuku: Kitten Tales isnāt especially compelling or creative as far as cat manga goes, but it is an adorable series which consistently made me smile and even chuckle from time to time.
Magia the Ninth, Volume 2 by Ichiya Sazanami. I enjoyed the first volume of Magia the Ninth immensely. Iām not really sure I could call it a good manga per se, and I donāt think I would necessarily recommend it broadly, but personally I got a huge kick out of it. That being said, I canāt say that Iām surprised that the series only lasted two volumes. (I donāt know for certain, but I get the feeling that Magia the Ninth was cancelled.) What did surprise me was how well Sazanami was able to pull everything together to conclude the manga in a coherent (and almost satisfying) fashion when obviously it was intended to be a series on a much grander scale. To be honest, Magia the Ninth probably would have done much better for itself if the manga had had that level of focus from the very beginning. Magia the Ninth is a strange and somewhat goofy little series about demons, magic, and music. While the series wasnāt always the most comprehensible, itās stylishly drawn, has tremendous energy, and even manages to effectively incorporate legitimate music history into the story. Magia the Ninth may not have lived up to its potential, but I had fun with it.
The Prince in His Dark Days, Volumes 2-3 by Hico Yamanaka. More and more of The Prince in His Dark Days seems to revolve around Itaru, but at this point I would still consider Atsuko, who is serving as Itaruās double, to be the real lead of the manga. Unfortunately, Atsuko is casually threatened with sexual violence on a regular basis in the series which frankly makes me uncomfortable. In general, the power dynamics in The Prince in His Dark Days tend to be fairly disconcerting. It doesnāt really help when other charactersā try to play it off as a joke, either. If anything, it only seems to emphasize the fact that so many of them are unrepentant jerks. I know that Iām supposed to empathize with some of their personal struggles, but I find it difficult to spare a lot of sympathy for entitled assholes. However, the themes that Yamanaka explores in The Prince in His Dark Days are of tremendous interest to me, most notably those of gender expression and sexual identity. I also appreciate the mangaās melancholy mood and the slow blossoming of love in unexpected places. Thereās only one volume left in The Prince in His Dark Days and despite some of my reservations about the series I am curious to see how it ends.
The Three-Body Problem by Cixin Liu. If my memory serves me right, The Three-Body Problem is actually the first contemporary Chinese novel that Iāve read. It initially came to my attention when it became the first work in translation to win the Hugo Award for Best Novel. Interestingly, when The Three-Body Problem was translated into English by Ken Liu, the order of the chapters was restored to what the author originally intended and a few additional changes were made in consideration of some of the real-world scientific advances that had developed since the novel was first published in China. As a novel that leans heavily on hard science, I found The Three-Body Problem to be fascinating. (At one point in my life, I actually considered going into theoretical physics.) But what makesĀ The Three-Body Problem so compelling are the social aspects of the narrative. In particular, Chinaās Cultural Revolution and the charactersā responses to it play a critical role in the storyās development. The Three-Body Problem is the first book in a trilogy, Remembrance of Earthās Past, and so while largely being a satisfying novel on its own, itās obviously only the beginning of a larger work. I definitely plan on reading the rest.
By: Ash Brown
0 notes