#nolan hotchkiss | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

kkthanks · 6 years ago

Text

Classic Bell tower Situation? Already theorizing about PLL the Perfectionists

**WARNING: LONG! But I do appreciate you for reading it anyway! :) **

Perfectionists theory

I think Mona kills Nolan and that she worked with Nolan’s sister, Taylor, who is supposed to be dead, to do it. Mona, last we saw her, admitted that she killed Charlotte. We don’t think Alison did something with that Information? Mona really just gets away with that and is playing with Alex and Mary as human dolls? None of that is Mona’s imagination? Mona doesn’t go back to a mental hospital? I think she does, and she meets Nolan’s sister, Taylor, there.

Mona missed the game from PLL so much, she started playing it again when she met Taylor, especially because of how much Taylor likely reminded Mona of her original doll, Alison. Mona ALSO happened to help Alison fake her death, and I believe she may be doing the same with Taylor now. More on that below. When Mona played the game with Charlotte, she pretended to be Alison until they eventually tried to bring the real Alison to the dollhouse.

Now Taylor’s family is bringing Alison to town, which is exactly what Mona wanted. I think when Ali comes to town she figures out that something weird is going on with the main characters who are students at the school and takes too much of an interest and this puts her in danger. So Mona wants to “save” her and the other characters, even if it means taking dangerous measures to do so. I believe Mona thinks any of them finding out that Taylor is alive puts them in immediate danger. Taylor obviously didn’t want people knowing and was reluctant about Nolan asking anyone for help.

Mona misses the game and she needs Alison if she’s really going to get to play. That game thrives on Ali being in danger. But the family only had a reason to bring Alison to town after Taylor “died.” So Mona arranged Taylor’s “death” just like she helped Alison “die.” But people, except Nolan, seem to really believe that Taylor is dead. So when we learn Nolan knows Taylor is alive, he dies soon after. I do think Taylor was in genuine danger or a situation where she felt the need to fake her death as well, but perhaps she doesn’t know the true reason why Mona helped her, if I’m right about this. Maybe we are going to see a lot of people die with a common reason of knowing or suspecting that Taylor is alive. It’s probably dangerous to look into her at all. I also kind of got the vibe that Nolan might remind Mona a bit of Noel, Charlotte and Alison.

Nolan was a danger to the girls in the show, maybe to Taylor as well, and Mona thinks now, Alison. The theme in the show is whether or not it’s ok to kill a murderer. Mona killed Alison’s sister and maybe she is trying to make up for that. OR maybe she misses playing the game with the girl she killed, AND feels guilty. Maybe she will do anything to get rid of the guilt. Even kill Nolan or anyone who is dangerous to ali and Taylor. Mona has multiple personalities, she has mentioned it and so have her doctors. book series had the “villain” character turn out being a nice, main character girl who is mysteriously missing from the TV series. I think Mona in some way “replaces” this character, which would be an otherwise serious loss for the show. Mona and this character from the books who is NOT in the show also have an affinity for that black hoodie uniform. I just felt the need to mention that, especially now that: on multiple occasions in the pilot, Mona seemed to be talking to herself when she looked in the mirror as though she was talking with a totally separate person like Julie and Parker in the books.

That character MADE the story in the book, maybe that’s why the series needed Mona’s character. I wouldn’t be surprised if Mona takes on Taylor’s personality or something, since the books also involved the main character taking on the personality of someone who she doesn’t realize has died. She’s all about masks and wigs and pretending to be other people. And we can’t doubt either girl’s ability to easily escape that hospital.

If Mona did in fact meet Taylor at a mental hospital, this could have resembled the scenario with Charlotte was doing with Mona when she was on her medication in Radley in PLL. Mona says she misses her dolls and Ali was always her favorite “doll.”

Taylor and Nolan are afraid of something and need help and protection. Since they seem to KNOW their mother is behind the weird surveillance, that suggests they fear something more than just that. Maybe someone was stalking their family and that’s the reason for their mother’s surveillance, similarly to the way Jessica DiLaurentis kept tabs on the girls when she suspected then confirmed that Ali was alive, despite having been hit in the head with a giant rock by her sister and buried alive by her mom... but I digress. Jessica knew Ali had a bully in PLL and I think Nolan’s mom might know the same about her kids. Maybe we are even talking about the SAME bully here, MONA.

the trio meet up in the woods where Nolan used to bring the girls. Ava says she’s done with Nolan and wants to stop him. They discuss that Alison offered to help. Dylan says he can’t do it bc the info he knows would come out.

They discuss him dying and joke about killing him, discuss Agatha Christie not being wrong in “and then there were none” talk about various causes of death.

Someone’s in the bushes clearly listening and it was probably Mona but would make sense too if Taylor found out.

Mona talks to herself in the mirror AGAIN in the car and Alison corners her jumps in front of her car and demands why she’s really here.

Mona: “I think I’m doing a good job, don’t you?” Reminds me of how she spoke to Charlotte who she thought was ali when she was in Radley.

Ali freaks out to Mona about the similarities between her and Taylor. Mona claims she got ali selected but this was before she knew what Taylor looked like.

OF COURSE Mona would need ali back in town to play with her like a doll just like when she was A. Mona helped ali fake her own death once, I seriously wouldn’t doubt she’s doing the same thing with Taylor whether she knows it or not.

Right before Nolan dies, Nolan meets up with someone apologizing for being such an asshole and telling that person it’s not just about him but about Taylor, she’s alive. Nolan is then killed just like the way the trio imagined it would be. We are supposed to suspect the person Nolan was talking to of being the killer but I don’t think so at all.

— Mona speaks into the mirror what the hell just happened was this our fault? (In reference to Nolan’s death) Answer me damn it. Then someone replies to Mona “Mona, go to your safe place!” This is supposed to make it appear that Mona is not talking to herself and doesn’t have some sort of multiple personality issue, but we have just watched an episode of a show creepily focused on surveillance, so I wouldn’t doubt that the person was telling Mona to go the “safe place” in her mind. Maybe Mona’s behavior we have seen talking to herself in front of the mirror is a symptom that triggered whoever that woman was to react by telling Mona to go to her safe place.

As I said before, It’s difficult to believe Mona never had any personality issues again and just voluntarily left Mary and Alex and her game in France ... I don’t think that’s what happened. I think Mona killed Nolan; perhaps she believed it that important to protect the secret of Taylor being alive and to protect certain people around her. I believe Mona knows about that and has been helping her and there’s gotta be a good reason Taylor would want / need to fake her death. And it doesn’t seem like her reason (like most others on the show) has anything to do with being afraid of her brother, in fact she trusts him.

As I mentioned before, I think Mona May have met Taylor at a mental hospital type place and helped her fake her death the same way she helped Charlotte “stay gone.” It could be some sort of high tech therapy they do. For some reason, Taylor needed a “replacement” to be near her family and friends etc and pretty much BE her, while everyone believed she was “dead.”

Maybe Nolan knew ali was there because of a plan between Mona and Taylor and that’s what he was insinuating when he said there’s more too it than his mothers claim that ali reminded her of Taylor.

I think Mona is struggling with personality issues again and has some sort of identification / connection with Taylor. I think these scenes with Mona looking into the mirror and speaking to someone “else” is Mona communicating with another personality, whether or not she is aware of this. I think they showed that woman “replying” to her at the end to get fans off track of guessing that.

Mona is the reason Ali is in town and she claims this has nothing to do with Taylor, but Mona made a lot of claims when she was secretly working with Charlotte too. In fact, the first time Mona started teaming up with Charlotte, she was in Radley and her medication caused her to hallucinate Ali and believe that she was talking to Ali when really she was talking to Charlotte. Perhaps something similar happened here when Mona met Taylor.

Mona warned ali to stay away from Nolan; I am wondering why this is. The writing on Ali’s wall stating that “they’re watching,” definitely brought me back to the days when Mona / A left messages just like that, and I’m not sure why we should believe she has ever stopped playing the game; she’s admitted it’s an addiction for her and a disease. We know that Nolan and Taylor knew about the surveillance. I think there IS some sort of personality link between Mona and Taylor and they left ali that message.

I am also reminding myself that MONA too once faked her own death. Although it ended up not being within her control, she did come up with the idea to do it initially. When I couple that with the fact that Mona told Ali that apparently Taylor just “snapped” from all the pressure. That comment has me wondering if Mona gave Taylor that idea to use “snapping” as an alibi, kind of like the way Mona would get herself sent to Radley intentionally. This sort of thing worked especially well for her after killing people, like Charlotte.

Mona KILLED ALISON’S SISTER and we are to believe that ali is cool with Mona just walking around like she’s perfectly fine? And BELIEVING that she’s perfectly fine? That’s just one of the bell tower deaths that happened while ali and Mona were present at some point. There was also Ian... Ali pushed Ian and Mona finished the job, actually killing him. He was terrorizing the girls and in Mona’s eyes, it was likely a problem that Ian had now seen ali alive. I think Ali could have been involved in Nolan’s initial injury here and then Mona killed him because he was being too trusting in regards to Taylor’s secret. I bet you we’ll learn who the person was that Nolan met up with right before he died, the person he’s been an asshole to lately and the person to whom he revealed Taylor’s secret. I wouldn’t be surprised at all if people begin suspecting this person of being the culprit behind Nolan’s death and it might seem convincing. Then that person is probably the next person to die, common denominator being that they knew about Taylor.

#pll the perfectionists #pretty little liars #the perfectionists #perfectionists theories #nolan hotchkiss #who killed nolan #taylor hotchkiss #mona vanderwaal #alison dilaurentis #mona and alison #pll theories

122 notes · View notes