Marilyn Monroe is falling to pieces again. That most endlessly analyzed of Hollywood sex goddesses is now being subjected to an especially rigorous process of deconstruction â or is it evaporation? â at the Shed, the new, $475 million arts center of Hudson Yards, where Anne Carsonâs âNorma Jeane Baker of Troyâ opened on Tuesday night.
âNorma Jeaneâ â which is less a play than a staged poem â is the inaugural production at the 500-seat Griffin Theater, and it has cultural cachet to burn, with the added draw of pop appeal. Ms. Carson is the esteemed Canadian poet, classicist, professor and translator, known for playfully finding serious links between the ancient past and the evanescent present.
The director is Katie Mitchell, the intensely cerebral theater and opera director. And its sole performers â and this, for the less recondite theatergoer, is the beauty part â are that fine stage and screen actor Ben Whishaw and the opera star ReneĚe Fleming.
Neither Mr. Whishaw nor Ms. Fleming portrays the title character in this equally hypnotic and exasperating production. Or not exactly. When first seen, on a snowy New Yearâs Eve in the early 1960s, their characters appear to be a rather anxious businessman (Mr. Whishaw) and the thoroughly professional stenographer (Ms. Fleming) he has recruited to help him work, after hours, on a special project.
That would be the very script of the show weâre watching, which is indeed about Norma Jeane Baker. If you donât know that Norma Jeane was Monroeâs birth name, I wish you much luck in following this show. Because thatâs only the first â and by far the simplest â of the identities attached to Monroe in Ms. Carsonâs investigation of the illusion and substance of feminine beauty in a testosterone-fueled world of war.
For Ms. Carson has merged Monroe with another much-maligned sex object, Helen of Troy. You know who she is, right, the face that launched a thousand ships? But wait. This Helen isnât exactly the woman you learned about in school. Instead, sheâs the heroine of Euripidesâ seldom-performed tragedy âHelen.â
In that play, Helen never set foot in Troy, having been spirited away by the Gods (to exile in Egypt) before the war ever started. There was someone who appeared to be Helen living with her abductor, Paris. But she, it turns out, was only a phantasm or (to use a word much savored in Ms. Carsonâs poem) a cloud.
That is the story that Mr. Whishawâs character is trying to tell, more or less, except that in his rendering, Helen is Norma Jeane, while her ostensibly cuckolded husband, Menelaus is transformed into Arthur, King of Sparta and New York (referring to Monroeâs third husband, the playwright Arthur Miller). The movie director Fritz Lang figures in this version, as does Monroeâs confidant Truman Capote, and â oh, yes â the singer Pearl Bailey.
Norma Jeane is further conflated with another abductee from Greek mythology, Persephone, especially as she was conjured by the 20th-century British poet Stevie Smith. All these variations on the theme of beautiful women held captive by men echo a phrase that is both spoken and sung throughout this production: âItâs a disaster to be a girl.â
Now why, you may well ask, is this a tale to be told by a man? Ms. Carson has said that she wrote this monologue with Mr. Whishaw in mind. He had appeared most compellingly as a fluidly androgynous Dionysus in Ms. Carsonâs translation of Euripidesâ âBakkhai,â at the Almeida Theater in London in 2015.
His ability to cross the gender divide without coyness or caricature turns out to be an invaluable asset in âNorma Jeane.â As his nameless man dictates his reworked version of Euripides â replete with spoken instructions as to punctuation and spacing, along with lengthy digressions on strategies of war â he slowly divests himself of his workaday clothing.
Whatâs revealed beneath his business suit is a deeply scarred torso, possibly â you may infer â a legacy of time in the military. Then, little by little, this nervous, determined man reinvents himself â painted by fingernail by painted fingernail, false eyelash by false eyelash â as Monroe as she was seen in âThe Seven Year Itch.â
It is a process that at first appalls Ms. Flemingâs transcribing secretary. But as the production continues, she warms to her wounded employerâs ardent attempts to understand a woman whose suicide is still fresh in the American mind. By the end, they have together achieved a sort of improbable apotheosis of empathy.
Or thatâs the way I saw it. Ms. Carson is not the most immediately accessible of writers. Nor is Ms. Mitchell â whose recent work includes the divisive, gender-swapping Martin Crimp play âWhen We Have Sufficiently Tortured Each Otherâ at Londonâs National Theater â one to lead her audiences by the hand.
She has rearranged Ms. Carsonâs original text so that the play now begins with Mr. Whishaw uttering the ancient Greek word ĎΚĎ, which he explains is a highly protean pronoun. The monologue that follows is dense with references that range from the academic to the tabloid. And it is heard not only as spoken live by Mr. Whishaw, but as recited by his voice on a tape recorder.
His words are occasionally picked up and echoed, often in song, by Ms. Fleming. From time to time, her creamy, disembodied voice floats through the air like thought made sound.
You donât really you need to know your classics or even your Hollywood lore to grasp the thematic gist of âNorma Jeane,â which ponders the follies of war-making men and their abuses of women. Sometimes Ms. Carsonâs conjunctions of figures past and present can seem both too obvious and too obscure. The showâs surprisingly predictable conclusion lacks the haunting resonance it aspires to.
But the precise calibration of the physical production holds your attention. (Or held mine, anyway; there have regularly been walkouts since it began previews last weekend.) The cohesive technical elements include Alex Ealesâs perfectly detailed âMad Menâ-era set, Sussie Juhlin-WalleĚnâs matching costumes, Anthony Doranâs crepuscular lighting and Donato Whartonâs creepily insinuating sound.
Mr. Whishaw and Ms. Fleming are, against the odds, marvelous. They somehow lend an emotional spontaneity to ritualistic words and gestures, while conjuring an affecting relationship between two people who, after all, donât even exist in Ms. Carsonâs text. Mr. Whishawâs astutely measured metamorphosis here suggests both deep, contemporary personal neurosis and atavistic self-sacrifice.
As might be expected, Ms. Fleming brings a luxuriant, caressing tone to the song fragments composed by the composer Paul Clark (which sometimes bring to mind Samuel Barberâs âKnoxville: Summer of 1915â). What you may not realize is that most of the sound effects and background music have been made entirely from a base of recorded clusters of notes sung by Ms. Fleming.
This seems appropriate to a show about the mutability of perception and image. And though itâs a man who narrates â and tries to make sense of â Norma Jeaneâs story, it is fittingly a womanâs voice that supplies the aural oxygen in which it unfolds
13 notes
¡
View notes
some fic recs above 100k?
100k+ Larry Fic Rec
To find even more works that are 100k+ please refer to this list of basic fandom must reads. Those works will not be repeated on this list. The works on this list are all works I have read and they will be ordered by length, the shortest starting at 100k, the longest being 286k.
Resist Everything Except Temptation
The one where Louis is the commodoreâs son who is forced to become a part of Harryâs crew when he is captured.
Through Eerie Chaos
The Ghost Hunter AU where Niall lives to prove ghosts are real, Zayn is a skeptical librarian and Harry gets caught up in a century-old mystery and catches feeling in the process.
Wings to Break Your Fall
Strip club AU. Harryâs work and family are keeping him busy. He really isnât looking for a relationship, doesnât want one. He just wants Louis. Problem is, Louis has other plans.
Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose
âThereâs something so great about watching you interact with art,â Harry said quietly. âLike, when you were giving the tour, you were just so you, and so happy and excited and funny and engrossing. But then when youâre looking at the art, when itâs, like, just for you, you get so quiet and observant.â He pressed a kiss to Louisâs shoulder. âBut you still seem so you, and so happy. I donât know if Iâve ever seen you as happy as youâve been tonight.â He kissed his shoulder again. âAs you are right now.â
A shiver went up Louisâs back.
âIâm happy when Iâm with you,â he said.
Or, Louis loved art and Harry was a masterpiece.
Wasnât Expecting That
Since moving out of his mumâs house with his baby daughter, itâs always been just Harry and his little Luna Flower; dad and daughter against the world. Things are just fine and Harry doesnât think he needs anyone â and that could have had to do with the fact that he doesnât think thereâs anyone out there good enough. But, with a leap of faith and some unexpected twists and turns, maybe he might just prove himself wrong.
Or, the one where Harry is a single dad and gets more than he bargained for after a one night stand of sorts.
Dress You Up in My Love
Harry is single, and more than anything wants to find love. Agreeing to sign up to a dating website was a bad, bad idea. Niallâs bad, bad idea. Louis is single, but has no interest in relationships. Or so he tells himself. â¨â¨Harry is a lawyer whose boss, Nick, happens to give him a bonus, which he decides to splurge on a new work wardrobe. Louis is a frustrated designer, working as a personal shopper at Selfridges. Louis happens to be working on the day a very beautiful, but out of his depth, new customer ambles into their department in need of advice. Louis might have just found the muse he never knew he was looking for.
Run Away Home
Louis stands, in the middle of a clearing with his hands in his pockets, and stares. This boyâGod, this gorgeous, gorgeous boy. He seems so clumsy, confused at the best of times, but thereâs a wisdom about him as he speaks, a maturity that belies his age.
Louis is hopelessly, wildly attracted to him.
Or, Louis is a successful jockey down on his luck, struggling to get his life back on track after an injury. Harry has a horse, a house fit for a prince, and a broken heart.
It takes them a while to figure out that they need each other.
Mutability
Harry and Louis meet in a book club. Life and fiction have their parallels.
Both Showing Hearts
Louis Tomlinson is, in fact, not straight.
Harry Styles isnât sure what he is.
Together, they figure it out, and maybe fall in love along the way.
Or, the Uni AU where Louis helps Harry figure out his sexuality, Niall crashes a bachelorette party, Liam works in a printing centre, and Zayn happens to need lots of printing done.
Weâre Not Friends, We Could be Anything
The one where Harry and Louis are unlikely uni flatmates who definitely donât like each other and definitely wonât fall in love (even if Liam and Niall think otherwise).
Never Be
The one where Harry Styles moves to Connecticut from England for nine months as a part of a study abroad program, and he just so happens to move in with Louis Tomlinson and family.
Marking Up the Atmosphere
At the age of twenty, Harry deals with things expected to occur at his age: student loans, instant meals, electricity bills, and the constant, incessant presence of never ending coursework.
That, and the job of raising his six year old daughter and avoiding the charm of a young, successful, and very off-limits Louis Tomlinson.
My Heartâs a Stereo (and This Melody is Meant for You)
Louis Tomlinson, an ex-boybander now stuck in the rut of a comfortable has-been, gets the chance to resuscitate his career when a pop star asks him to write a duet for her highly-anticipated comeback album. Through a chance encounter, he finds a quirky lyricist in Harry Styles, the curly-haired baker and former writer with an above-average sense of rhyme and inexplicable interest in personal questions.
Or: the Music & Lyrics AU that no one asked for, in which Louis is Hugh Grant, and Harry is Drew Barrymore, and the slow burn is (hopefully) worth the wait.
These Bountiful Silences
They live in a world where they can only say four words per day. Harry meets some people that donât want to live that way.
California Sold
Notoriously closeted boyband member Harry Styles is famous on a global scale, meanwhile Louis, as his best friend, is back home in Manchester, living the typical life of a 24 year old. When Harry needs Louis with him in LA, a publicity stunt gone wrong changes their friendship forever.
A fake-relationship AU between two lifelong best friends.
The Night Sky is Changing Overhead
âUm, sorry, but I believe thatâs actually mine,â Harry said a bit awkwardly, pointing at the cup.
The man huffed, slightly narrowing his blue eyes, âNope, large Americano, dash of cream.â He held the coffee up closer to Harry and honestly, Harry knew exactly what was in the cup because it was his coffee.
âRight,â Harry slowly drawled out as if he was talking to a toddler, âWhich would make that mine.â
âLook, I really donât have time for this, Iâm running late. And this,â he said before he took a sip from the cup, âIs mine.â
Harryâs jaw dropped and he held his hands out, failing them slightly, âWha-you canât just drink it!â
âWell I did, so, do you still want it or can I be on my way?â The man challenged.
Harry shook his head disbelievingly, âTake it, but for the record, it says Harry on it.â
The man turned the cup around and a sharp laugh came out of his mouth, âWell, shit.â He looked at Harry, a smile stretched across his face as crinkles formed next to his eyes. âThanks, Harry.â
Got the Sunshine on My Shoulders
Five years ago, Harry Styles left his tiny home town to make it big as a recording artist. he didnât have much regard for what he left behind - a life, a family, and a husband, who woke up one morning to find him gone.
Now, Harry has everything he could possibly want: heâs rich, famous, and adored by everyone he meets, including his boyfriend. But when said boyfriend proposes to him, heâs forced to face the uncomfortable facts of his past - and Louis, whoâs spent the last five years returning every set of divorce papers Harry sent him.
Just a Walk in the Park
Itâs 2015, the first time dinosaurs walked the earth in over 65 million years. The multi-billion dollar company, Twist Corporations, is planning a summer opening for their world changing attraction, âJurassic Parkâ.
They take an interest in the history making duo of Dr. Louis Tomlinson, a stubborn paleontologist, and his partner, paleobotanist Dr. Liam Payne, giving them the chance of a lifetime to work for the new theme park. Louis is apprehensive, but Liam has a âgut feelingâ that it will change their lives. He isnât wrong.
Featuring Niall as the top engineer to get the park up and running, Zayn as the raptor expert, and Harry as the grandson of one of the most influential men in the world.
Among the Humans
A gothic, modern day vampire romance between a young human named Louis Tomlinson, and Harry Styles, ancient vampire and gentleman.
Creatures of the night come with more trouble than they wish to make it seem.
With a Whimper
Dystopian AU. Louis has been alone for too long to remember how not to be, and Harry has too much to worry about to deal with a scrawny, wild, stranger.
Facade
An AU where Louis is the lead singer of The Rogues, Harry is the lead singer of White Eskimo and both are sick of being in the closet so kiss one night to fuck with the media.
Eight Cakes and Two Eulogies (Make a Happy Marriage)
The Honourable Louis Tomlinson, heir to the Earldom of Colbury and the multi-billion pound family business, RLA Enterprises, often feels under pressure to conform to the expectations of those around him. The 30 year old, nerdy and rather homely physicist part of himself feels he ought to be getting married and carrying on the family line â as does his formidable Grandmother. The only problem is, after his last disastrous relationship, seven years ago, he has little desire to get intimate with another woman, let alone marry one. Of course, Harry, his famous actor of a best friend, always likes to pip in that he is free to marry him and while Louis loves him to pieces, the joke is getting a bit old now.
You Call Out My Name (For The Love You Need)
Louis thinks he has fallen in love. Heâs so sure about it. Then everything changes. He gets into a car accident with his mother and suddenly his life turns from living into being an angel. He doesnât know what to do with his time, until his mother gives him a task.
Harry is trying to make it as a singer. He spends his days on the streets, playing his guitar, and his nights at a pub. He loves his whiskey and he likes his one night stands. When a guy with blue, bright eyes sits next to him in the pub, he realizes things could be a lot different.
In other words, Harry is a street artist and Louis is an angel.
Flour and Chocolate
Louis is a single dad and Harry works at the newly opened bakery down the street.
Baby Weâll be Fine (All We Gotta do is be Brave and Kind)
Louis hates Harry. Harry hates being hated. First aid kits and kittens make it better.
The Wonderlands
âSomewhere between chaos and control â these are the wonderlands.â
Harryâs daughter, Andy, is signed to Louisâ girl band. Her path to success is marked by competition, chaos, and for Harry, a love affair.
Take My Breath Away
There is a prestigious school in the British Royal Navy classified as Premier Delta - or as it is known by its flyers, 1D. These select pilots are an elite set of Naval lieutenants who are trained in the skill of aggressive aerial combat. They are instruments of war, trained in times of peace. They are dogfighters, relentless and fearless in their mission to protect their beloved country. From their lofty vantage, they are always watching, waiting, and ready to lay it all on the line.
Lt. Harry Styles, call sign Sparrow, is a prodigy when it comes to flying. The owner of an unrivaled Naval pedigree, being a pilot was always written in the stars for Harry. With his trusty RIO, Lt. Niall Horan, Harry has made an unprecedented ascension in the ranks of the Naval aerial combat elite, and has been recruited to the esteemed Premier Delta flight school, carrying on his familyâs legacy. What he finds there are unexpected friendships, perilous challenges, and something beyond what he ever thought possible. Because as his father had always told him, before the great Captain Styles went tragically missing in combat, you donât fall in love with the sky, you fall in love with what keeps you on the ground.
Love Endless (the Road to Recollection)
The year is groovy 1973, and eighteen-year-old Louis Tomlinson is perhaps the gayest teen to ever grace the gloomy, hateful town of Fortwright. Would be fine if he wasnât so viciously bullied at both home and school for such a âharmfulâ sexual preference.
Yeah, yeah, weâve all heard this story, havenât we?Believe him, Louis didnât think he was anything special either.
Until he found the mansion. The notoriously haunted mansion hidden deep within the forests of his tiny blip of a town in Bumfuck Nowhere, Idaho. No one with a brain ever goes near it, but Louis could use a little excitement in his lifeâŚand possibly a Band-Aid or two.
After discovering the mansion was less abandoned than heâd thought, heâs now left with the most riveting mystery of a lifetime; every new finding leaving him with more questions. Who is this elusive owner, and why wonât they show themselves? Why is there a set of journals in the same handwriting that span over centuries? Why in the world is there a padlock on the refrigeratorâŚand who the hell is Alexander?
Your Mess is Mine
Louis is the father to the most brilliant little boy in the world who is all Louis really needs, or at least thatâs what he tells himself. Harry is a gorgeous boybander fresh off a two year break and a massive scandal thatâs left him a little broken and more than ready to move on.
They fall in love.
Shake Me Down
Harryâs new to college, fresh out of Catholic school and conversion therapy camp, and Louis runs the campus LGBTQIA organization.
Youâve Got to See Yourself from Far and Wide
Harry and Louis meet at a very early age under all the wrong circumstances, which leads them to absolutely loathe each other for years on end. Eventually they both make it as professional football players in -very- rival teams, but are suddenly bought by the same club and depend on each other to either make it or break it at the height of their careers.
418 notes
¡
View notes