#mudclaw as leader still wouldve been disastrous like hes leaning too far in the opposite direction here in hating all help and such
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Vio and I were talking about this on Discord yesterday but man I do not blame Mudclaw and WindClan overall for being sick of ThunderClan holding Firestar's heroism over WindClan's heads. Like yes, Tallstar does have a point in wanting to keep relationships good (clan xenophobia is exhausting to read about at this point) but there's also a point here about giving land to someone over herbs. (set up an actual trading system) The giving tree comes to mind where ThunderClan can dangle their good deeds over WindClan and take and take and take and take at WindClan's expense until there's not much left to give.
Maybe it's just that I've been in this specific situation where my gratitude was taken for granted and held over me but like. I get wanting to get out of that. And especially given what Onestar goes through, I don't blame him for shifting his beliefs to align more with Mudclaw's anyways cause he was STILL getting exploited.
#i know this happened in starlight btw but i. have not read it since middle school LMAO#so a lot of this is new to me#also ik this is a common opinion so i just want to say this is not ''mudclaw shouldve been leader'' stuff. i love onestar as leader#hes interesting and compelling as a leader and he literally takes all of this into account#hes just saying all this rn cause hes still firestar's bestie at this point and clearly isnt right for the job#mudclaw as leader still wouldve been disastrous like hes leaning too far in the opposite direction here in hating all help and such#idk. its a nuanced conflict. both parties are wrong here to a degree#ofc ur meant to think windclan IS being bratty and ungrateful from leafpaw's pov but man#gn liveread#also the argument mudclaw makes is just ''no help and friendship with other clans bad and should not happen ever'' which isnt productive
18 notes
·
View notes