#lucky plays SH2R

[luckyraeve]

The foreshadowing of that specific bed being smothered under some wall debris is sooooooo good. #ifYouKnowYOUKNOW 😭😭😭😭😭

[luckyraeve]

I did the meanest thing to James. At the graveyard, i made him walk into the water up to his crotch to see how far he could go before hitting an invisible wall. It's now canon (for my playthru) that he has to endure his Silent Hill journey in soaking wet jeans and soggy shoes. #adding to his horrors

[luckyraeve]

So, I was trying to get the "In Water" ending on my first playthru as well as the "Leave" ending, but for some reason my playthru was locked on "Leave". 😢 No matter what I did, I would get "Leave" even after replaying nearly the entire back half of the game from an old save. I made sure to avoid healing James unless absolutely necessary, and I looked at Angela's knife a bunch of times. I tried all combos of rust-coloured egg door / scarlet egg door / listen to Mary's monologue / don't listen to Mary's monologue ... and still got the "Leave" ending. 😡

After a bunch more googling for tips and tricks, someone on Reddit came thru. The yellow underlined part is what FINALLY gave me the "In Water" ending. 🎉

Just wanted to share in case anyone else was having the same issue as me. Hopefully you don't have to replay nearly half the game like I did. 🤞 Now that I have "In Water" i should be able to get all 6 other endings in my New Game + run. 🥳