#listen 99% of the time i skip sound effects because i find it too awkward but i watched this while very sick and my god it cheered me up
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
whose-line-requests · 7 months ago
Text
Sound Effects: Tarzan and Jane hunting for food - Season 3 | Episode 19
96 notes · View notes
kalira · 5 years ago
Text
CATS movie thoughts~
(post mirrored from Pillowfort here)
I went to see the new CATS movie with @mad-madam-m yesterday (we've been planning this since the first trailer dropped) and it was actually a) better than I expected, and b) enjoyable, which was a nice surprise! (I expected us to enjoy it because it was entertainingly bad, honestly.)
I've loved CATS since I saw the Broadway version as a kid, and listened repeatedly (incessantly) to the soundtrack thereof back then - and at times even these days - and was delighted to see a production of it when it came to our city when I was small.
The movie left me with 2-3 major issues and a handful of quibbles. . . I have not organised them at all, but here are my thoughts.
. . .which I am putting under a cut because I had a lot more to say than I thought, apparently.
I am not surprised they did an outsider character to be an audience surrogate, but *SIGH*
Also . . . Victoria? Whose characterisation in the stage show is 'excellent ballerina'?
I know that's why they chose her, they could fill her in as they chose, but it was weird to have a cat who left almost no impression in the stage show as the 'main character'
Okay I admittedly missed that they apparently folded in Jemima/Sillabub to her as well, but that really doesn't make me feel any better
Did we have to have the incredibly forced romantical feeling type focus?
Not to mention we had some oddness towards that with Munkustrap initially
Then there was Misto falling tail over paws - because he bumbles through everything - at her
Then the oddness of the Munjojerrie and Rumpelteazer song which was probably not supposed to added the both of them to that list, if more briefly
Holy heckies adding a new song for the new central character was not a bad idea but literally anywhere else in the goddamn movie, and not spinning off of Memory oh my lord all the no it was so cringe
Look you cannot build off of Memory as 'but I have it worse than you so feel better'
Who has it worse is never a good game to play at all, playing it here was so cringey
'What's a Jellicle?'
Okay I know, audience surrogate, but oof
Actually let me skip back - the CGI did not bother me that much and it's like 99% of the ranting I have seen about this since the very first trailer. It never bothered me that much.
The cats were made a bit more plain; that bothered me.
Let them have ruffs, especially the toms, wtf did you remove those for it looks a) weird, and b) wrong for cats
However the show really can only be played by humanoid cats, I think, or it . . . look, the production wouldn't work with more catlike cats
The addition of dialogue stringing together the songs and adding more plot elements and freedom to work with them was really not an issue in my opinion
It strung together the slightly expanded plot in a way it really needed
It wasn't that jarring or awkward, to me
Misto, oh baby, why oh why did they do that to you~
Mister Mistoffeelees, who is an aloof, confident, and incredibly skilled magician in the stage show is made into a nervously fumbling barely-past-kitten who fails at almost every bit of magic he attempts (and falls and trips rather a lot as well, when he's a brilliantly graceful dancer in the stage show)
It was painful, oh sweetie
I can guess part of why they did it, but it was not well done and I don't think it was necessary
Misto's magic was painful; not because it was painful itself but because he was so bad at it, and everyone expected him to fail every time he tried
Misto using his magic for Gus' song, for dramatic effect? I thought it was really great and also really sweet
Actually Misto being so starry-eyed at Gus was adorable all around
That could have been put in even with Misto being his confident stage self, in fact it could have been super cute to have him be composed and confident and then go to an overexcited kitten with Gus in front of him
The absence of the Conjuring Turn was so sad, it is a star point of Misto
Look I'm not a fan of the 'awkward bumbling male finds his confidence because of the unwavering (with no reason) faith of the new female love interest' trope in general, having it wedged in here suddenly did not make me like it any more
Upon the note of Misto, the rescue of Deuteronomy . . . was very badly timed on the beats, and badly done (I felt) when it finally happened.
I didn't expect her to show up when Misto first tried
I semi-expected the second time, but okay
When she didn't show up the third time it stopped being any kind of suspense - especially since, let's be real, the plot is not really a huge mystery - and became 'okay so . . . what are we doing instead now?'
And then the fourth try, when she did appear, it was done very anticlimactically
Deuteronomy being female didn't really bother me but it left me a bit eh
Judi Dench is awesome, but Deuteronomy not really singing is weird
Also, let Judi Dench's Deuteronomy have been implied to have had 9 - or 99 - wives you cowards
. . .plus that line being altered to be another repeat of 'Old Deuteronomy's had many lives, some may say ninety-nine' . . . it was awkward/clunky and felt over repetitious
Jennyanydots . . . oof, poor hon
Jennyanydots is a mature and above all sweetly sincere queen in the stage show
She honestly wants to better the mice and the cockroaches, and it's a bit silly perhaps, but she is determined to do it - and does
And the other cats respect her and, more, they genuinely care very much for her it seems
And she's earnest
I expected her to be played more for comedy given who was cast to play her, but the extent of it felt not great, to be honest, even before the other cats began to feel like they were mocking her a bit
Not to mention - the joke about the mice being dinner and a show I could let pass despite being very different from Jennyanydots as she originally was, but actually eating cockroaches as it went was a bit too far
As I told M when we were discussing the movie after the showing, it was like, I was rolling with it, and then they rolled too far
Also on that note? The CGI mice were a bit o.O - when the CGI cockroaches started marching my thought was actually 'oh, this won't feature in my nightmares at all'
They won't actually but they were kind of horrifying
I did like the cats watching with that alert, slightly twitchy focus of a cat seeing a small moving creature
The traditional costume change looked . . . weirder and creepier with the CGI than costume work
Bustopher Jones went from a dignified figure to a ridiculous one
It was again rather terrible to watch, wince-worthy
Prancing through the rubbish bins and splatting through things instead of his usual stage show refinement and rather snobbishness? Oof
Bustopher has always been respected, even specifically so because of his size, making his weight a joke and/or something he's 'extra sensitive' about was . . . so unnecessary
The Rum Tum Tugger has always been my favourite, since I was a wee tiny Kalira
. . .he was blessedly not so bad as I feared - and even went back closer to the rocker cat (complete with flirtatious tease nature) than the rap adaptation I have heard of and been continually ohgodwhy no at
However, why did they discard the few details of his character that are not a self-important flirt?
He's not even focused at that - in the stage show I am accustomed to he is very much a determined performer, basking in being adored
he was a bit 'oo shiny' and kept ignoring his adoring audience in the movie?
In the stage show he is also around to drop in playful lines from time to time
Also he sings a good chunk of Misto's song and brags him up, as well as pieces of other songs
While he claims to be distant and aloof, and may somewhat be, he continually comes back and causes minor disruptions for his own (and others') amusement in the stage show
He also protectively shelters some of the kittens more than once
Misto's barb was kept in but sounded more like a jealous, anxious attempt to detract attention instead of a teasing barb at an egotistical friend
Along with many of the songs, Tugger's was altered so that it is entirely sung about himself, and as with many of them, I felt it was better with some of the lines from another singer
Though his is not so bad as many, perhaps because he's already talking himself up
I wasn't really surprised to find he's changed from the inspirations I remember from the stage show and when I was little (Mick Jagger and David Bowie, mother told me when I got older XD) but it was still a little bit of a disappointment
Also a bit random, when mostly the soloing cats - at least/especially the ones singing for themselves in front of all the others - were competing in the formalised 'who gets to ascend' spread, that Tugger is evidently not
Mungojerrie & Rumpleteazer were kind of fantastic and then kind of wtf for me
me, during their song, as they pulled Victoria along with them to play and cause all manner of mischief in the house: I don't think I'm intended to be shipping Victoria with both of them now, but I definitely am
me, at the end of their song, as they deliberately abandoned Victoria strangling and trapped as a dog came barrelling up after her with saucy nonchalance: . . .what the fuck?
me, when they were helping with Macavity's attack directly: excuse me no
I know they're said to be 'rumoured' to help him out in the stage show but this was very different
Yeah they said here that it was 'only a bit of fun' and they didn't know Macavity was planning to kidnap Deuteronomy, but . . . no
I did actually like their colouration redesign, making them I think the only cats I did in the entire movie
The lack of their tumbling and acrobatics was a bit sad, though their song and playful successsion of running about, Victoria in tow, was fun
Macavity was played super well considering he has no lines in the stage show so rather little to go on, and the expansion of his plot was honestly understandable - I mean, CATS has a heck of a thin plot for a musical, let alone a movie
One of the things that bothered me about him was honestly that his song where he is described he is described as ginger and poorly-combed
He's played by Idris Elba and his fur is sleek rich brown
He looks great, but alter the lines, you've already altered several, including Deuteronomy's because of the genderswap
On that note, the plot expansion in general . . . it was way better than I feared
I was afraid they were going to wedge in another plotline alongside the (very thin/hardly there, admitted) one in the stage show and it wouldn't go well
On the other hand the making the Jellicle Ball an official competition was a little eh to me
The more I think about it the less I like it even, really
I suppose it had to be, maybe, to work with expanding Macavity's plot and actions, but I don't care for it (and I think it could probably have been worked around)
I could have done without the queens being actively aggressive to Grizabella, oof that was owch
They recoil and hiss and act like she has the plague or a curse, very disdainful of her, in the stage show, and it works well
Having the queens actively attack her, not only hissing but instead of recoiling circling her and closing in on her to slash at her? It was . . . not good
So I guess the lead queen that I noticed doing that the most is . . . Cassandra? I honestly thought it was supposed to be Bombalurina
Bombalurina only showed up as Macavity's chief singer and queen underling, to distract and drug everyone
Really? Yeah some of the queens sing about Macavity in the stage show, but Bomba is even the one who comforts Demeter when Macavity's presence freaks her out (in what seems like a trauma reaction, rather) in the stage show
I have no idea who is supposed to be Demeter, the queens were all but interchangeable background, really most of the chorus cats were
Which brings up the theme of a lot of the cats being unrecognisable to me, honestly, and/or having their roles remixed a little, or straight-up lessened
Skimbleshanks was awesome, and his song/number was perhaps even better than in the stage show
The tap-dancing along the rails? Awesome
The cats playing around in the sleeper cabin was also pretty great honestly
 I will say when Skimbles appeared my immediate impression was of a very specific within-the-LGBT+-community gay man stereotype
Also I am terribly amused that he's wearing half a suit of clothes and it's the opposite half that he was in the stage production I'm most familiar with
Munkustrap was rather different, still a large part of keeping things going, if not the same way
Less serious than I'm used to? Not that he's only serious, but still
He made the best faces, like, it rescued a few awkward moments
At least a handful of moments that made me go 'this is so very not the Munkustrap I know' characterisation-wise
With the battle removed and a few other things, many of the moments that make his personality shine were gone
No seeing him lunge into action as the Jellicle Protector, basically
No seeing him trying to manage the little play-within-a-play put on for Deuteronomy (even when Tugger causes mischief) although I can't blame them for cutting both of those
No seeing him shield the kittens or younger/other cats without hesitation
Instead there was mostly just the slightly silly characterisation that showed in the moments between in the movie, it seemed to me
Gus the theatre cat was another of those whose song was rewritten to be sung by themselves, though his is the most notable for that, given he barely sings at all in the stage show
I really think it worked better the other way
But they gave me Ian McKellen being awesome in that song so I am okay with this
Also, Gus using a bit of that to scare Growltiger off the ferry and into the Thames? Fabulous
Misto's song - I talked about him and about Deuteronomy's rescue, but the song
I love having it led in by Tugger in the stage show, and I love having Tugger brag him up
Tugger is good at that, honestly, it so suits his style
Misto needs a bit of bragging up, especially for this moment
First of all, changing it up so Misto sings most of it himself instead is a bit sketchy
Changing it so it becomes less of a confident, showy number and instead is Misto being so anxious he can barely sing and constantly checking reactions . . . that made it worse
Next up, changing it from Tugger - who reads as friendly to Misto, in the stage show - leading in Misto's song and encouraging the others to praise him, to Victoria who has only just met him and all the other cats being dubious as they join in. . . I did not like
My shipper heart: why would you take that away it was excellent interaction!
My non-shipper heart: why would you take that away it makes much more sense and it also makes a lovely balance with Misto teasing Tugger during his song and shows that Tugger took it in the light-hearted spirit (they're friends, they're there for each other) it seemed to be
Also that it was so sweet a bit of interplay they took it away from Tugger to give to Misto's Sudden Romantic Interest in the movie, with zero changes otherwise? I have some side-eye.
I already mentioned the rescuing Deuteronomy beats being all wrong, but it also left me thinking we'd be getting less of Misto's song and it was oddly broken-up when we did get more
The catnip usage had me a bit o.O I'll be honest, for several reasons
Erwhat with the drugging everyone in that scene?
The glowing I'm going to assume is to show that it's having an effect on the cats, but it came off a bit weird to me
There were several cats it looked like were 'trying to escape' the catnip who most definitely had/should have already been hit
Also how did the cats assisting Macavity avoid being affected? Bombalurina at first made sense, sprinkling it below herself, none of it after that did
Wow Macavity's song and climax there with the stairs right up to the 'Heaviside Layer' in his stage display? So cocky! An unwise cat
Deuteronomy smacking him down? Very nice
Continuing to do so when he disappeared them both? Even better
I was really rather surprised not to see the melee battle among the cats in the climax with Macavity
Of course that also took away some of the drama, aaand some of the chorus cats, especially the toms', chances to shine
The queens were pretty indistuingishable from each other but at least we saw them somewhat, the toms mostly seemed to be entirely background blur
Growltiger being added in as Macavity's henchcat was actually kind of great? Watching over the kidnapped cats and as a secondary (and subordinate) Bad Tom, yes
In contrast to the mischievous Mungojerrie and Rumpelteazer being used that way, I am so there for it
Grizabella was . . . a little disappointing?
She was played wonderfully! But she could have been played more
Seriously, fabulous actress there for her and they did nothing with her other than her songs and crying while singing them?
The stage production I'm familiar with has more than that with her and less time
Let her be proud and trying to gather herself up
Let her be dubious of herself and/or the others
Let her stand aside as though she doesn't even want to rejoin them after being turned aside
Look there's lots more that could have been done in the space there was with her in the movie (and without involving Victoria so much as she was, which was still a bit cringey outside Victoria's song, but at least not so badly)
She 'went with Macavity'? Felt a little unnecessary and also . . . hrm, to me
The stage show doesn't explain why the Jellicles reject her or where she was
I honestly always assumed she left on her own - Grizabella the Glamour Cat? - to make her own way, and eventually fell from grace
It was also a little strange to see her so young
Deuteronomy making the choice also felt . . . a little flat to me
I'm not sure what I was expecting or what the problem was
Regardless, it felt a little lacking somehow
I was impressed with how they had Grizabella's ascension managed, since that would be necessity be rather different from the stage show
Also great for Misto keeping some of his confidence from his song and rescue for this bit
Macavity trying to leap on and hitch a ride to the Heaviside Layer was excellent, and his getting stuck and having his magic not work to get himself un-stuck? Great
I do wonder - is his magic entirely broken, or just not working to catch his ride on Grizabella's balloon again?
The Ad-Dressing of Cats feels a bit awkward in a stage production to me; having a close-up of Judi Dench staring at me in the movie screen, for an extended time, did not make it better
Also the prologue bits about the naming of cats and what a Jellicle is were both changed and so there was no semblance of something similar in the beginning
I still think it would have been awkward, but if it bracketed the movie with the fourth wall breaks it might have worked better
The faces of the three cats close around Deuteronomy as she recited the entirety of that - which felt too long - were the only things that kept it being too awful
Munkustrap was the best in that
Misto looking horrifically embarrassed a few times and hiding behind his hat once . . . oh baby, I feel
'You're a Jellicle now!'
There's a Jellicle Ball once a year, see you then
So . . . for now, goodbye to your butt that was thrown in a sack into a junkyard we immediately ran away from
Rather than it being the Jellicles' (second, in some cases) home
I know your whole arc has been please accept me, see me, give me a place to be
But run off on your own, see you in a year
Seriously Victoria could have followed Misto, or Munkustrap, or Mungojerrie & Rumpleteazer, or anyone
Even Munku's mate could have, say, come up and encouraged Victoria to come with them
Not that we saw enough to assume he had one, still don't know who was supposed to be Demeter, but beside the point
It was a rough ending there
. . .I had a lot to say, and I'm not willing to swear that I didn't repeat myself anywhere - if I did I apologise - or skip over things I might have wanted to say. I saw the movie 24 hours ago and wrote most of this when I should have been asleep.
I did enjoy the movie and will probably watch it again - I also plan to watch the Broadway version again very soon (as soon as the library brings it to me) and have been listening to the Broadway soundtrack since yesterday afternoon.
(I may also be writing more for this fandom soon, but we'll see about that.)
8 notes · View notes