#jesuiscommejesuis
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
jonsameta · 6 years ago
Text
Hi, me again!
jesuiscommejesuis: Haha, I’m on that GoT grind and probably won’t stop until the premiere 😂. I trust your opinion so unfortunately you have to endure another ask from me. Anyway…I think that most of us have considered the possibility of Jonsa not being canon. (RIP me if that happens). But my question isn’t about whether Jonsa will be or won’t be (I’ve come to terms with the fact that GoT will end how GRRM always intended it to end) it’s about what that possibility means for all of the evidence, clues, foreshadowing, etc that we’ve gathered. In your opinion will Jonsa not happening render those clues and meta meaningless and we were all crazy after all? Or do they take on a new meaning and point us in a new direction? Idk if that even makes sense. Maybe I’m just afraid that Jonsa wont happen and I’m afraid for no other reason other than that I will have looked and sounded insane to all of my GoT friends and had nothing to show for it. Also do you know of any interviews or blog posts from GRRM possibly supporting Jonsa? Same for D&D? Or any other people on or working with the show? Thank you so much!! 💙
—-
Hi there, 
The thing about theories is they’re like Shrodinger’s cat. If you try to be objective, you have to entertain the possibility that it won’t happen, but it can’t completely be false until proven otherwise. That said, some theories are more probable than others because there’s material within the text that thematically undoes something. This is because a story’s themes (which differs depending on the adaptation but it can’t be completely divorced from the original source either) define its boundaries because they essentially make up “the heart of the story”, not the plot. They give the main characters a moral dilemma that drives their journeys. Considering the themes of the story - both bookwise and showwise - Jonsa is very probable because it answers a lot of long standing character arcs that go beyond these characters and provides a bookend that Jon/Dany cannot considering R+L=J. 
I think anything in this story has to be considered according to the politics - even the fantasy part because the personal is political. With such a spread out story only the themes and the morality dilemmas of politics that the smallest moment can have is what holds it all together. And I think the strongest argument for the probability of Jonsa comes from a structural level of gauging the politics. 
Jon’s parentage is a political game changer and the way it’s been built up it cannot just be for personal angst - especially when the element of his parentage revealing him to have a higher claim than Dany is brought up. It doesn’t just affect him or his relationship with Dany. It affects Westeros and Dany’s own longstanding goal.
Jon may not want to be king, but Dany is walking in as a very unpopular figure into the North and the way she has gone about her campaign hasn’t improved her reputation and only worsened it. And Jon himself will lose popularity after having 1) bent the knee to a Targaryen, 2) consorting with a Targaryen and 3) being a secret Targaryen. 
Dany doesn’t realise that although Jon claims to have pledged his allegiance to her, it doesn’t mean the North has fallen into her hands. He’s only lost their faith from this move so no Targaryen by themselves could claim the North. Not to mention the Vale and Riverlands are more allied to Sansa than they are to Jon. To regain faith, he’d have to separate himself from Dany and the Targaryen identity a bit and yet he would need a political statement that only a marriage alliance to Stark could give if he were to remain in power. There’s also the pesky issue of how unknowingly Sansa and the Starks have more allies than Dany (or Jon without the Starks) does as everyone comes into Winterfell. So Sansa’s constant label as “key to the North” and the importance of marriage alliances becomes very important here. He can’t become king or even gain the faith of the people (back) without Sansa. So in that case, the whole notion of the Pact of Ice and Fire being fulfilled through Dany and Jon falls apart because Jon will be seen as an outsider. @thelawyerthatwaspromised has even written a post with infographics to make it easier to understand. It’s like R+L=J resets the chessboard. Ironically, what the audience thought Jon/Dany’s union would do politically is far more possible through Jon/Sansa. 
As it makes sense as a political match, the possibility of it happening and impacting the narrative increases a lot more. The original outline also matters here because clearly the pseudo-incest tag didn’t stop the author. However, as the characters haven’t interacted in real time in the books and aren’t close, there’s not much people have asked him about it nor has GRRM has said about it unless you count his vague reply once (”I won’t say more than I’ve already said in the books”). I’d say there’s more to be gauged from what he has to say about other ships that fandom roots for, that isn’t as positive as they make it out to be - whether Jon/rya, San/San, San/rion or Jon/Dany. It’s not obvious because he hardly shuts down possibilities but there’s reading between the lines. It becomes more obvious through a process of elimination. It’s also because Jon/Sansa as a ship tramples over so many ships that fandoms have banked on that people are inclined to dismiss it rather than re-evaluate the pre-existing ships. 
On the show, people have been coy too but there’s more content to gauge as the characters have already reunited and their dynamic has become pretty pivotal to the story. Where D&D shut down Dany and Yara ever happening, in the same panel they evaded a question about Jon and Sansa being developed as a romantic relationship. Aiden Gil/lian commented on how Jon’s parentage opens up possibilities for Jon and Sansa’s relationship romantically at the end of season 6. Sophie was asked about it post season 6 and she said it was possible because it’s GOT and they’re cousins. Also, there’s Liam Cunnin/gham who once liked a Jonsa fanvideo lol and he barely has any likes. Sophie has said it’s possible, even as she joked about how it would be embarrassing to film an intimate scene. Kit has somehow avoided all questioning, but he has some pretty interesting reactions regarding Jon and Sansa’s relationship - either in the words he chooses (”She twists him like no one else”) or how over the top his reaction to Sansa is when he talks about how annoying she is to the point where he’s flushed and red and laughing while saying “I’ve gotten really animated now that Sansa has come into the story”. Bryan Cogman has a lot to say regarding this dynamic too, that he even wrote Jon leaving Ghost behind to watch over Sansa when he left for Dragonstone. 
What helps regarding the show is that it’s not just the actors or the political sense, but the camerawork and visual framing that makes their scenes very confusing because they’re shot as a romantic couple about to happen, as @trinuviel has explored in her series “All is Subtext”.  This notion that it was “framed” or “shot” that way was echoed by multiple reviewers and podcasts through season 6 and even into the beginning of season 7. 
A huge part of this was because it very subtly visually paralleled more positive romantic ships on the show like Ned/Cat, Jaime/Brienne, Robb/Talisa, Sam/Gilly, Missandei/Greyworm and even Jon/Ygritte to some extent. This is over a course of 7 episodes under 5 different directors. One of the most telling scenes for me was when they did two back to back parallels to Ned/Cat and Jaime/Brienne after Jon chokeholds Littlefinger over Sansa and they go on to give a Jaime/Brienne-esque goodbye. The same director Mark Mylod directed both the season 6 Jaime/Brienne and season 7 Jon/Sansa goodbye. Bryan Cogman even confirmed that the Littlefinger chokehold was meant to parallel Ned doing the same over Cat. 
But in my opinion, what weirdly cemented it was how Jon/Dany contrasted Jon/Sansa’s dynamic and framing. There were a lot of structural decisions made that undercut the Jon/Dany “romance” and made Jon/Sansa look more compatible and romantic, which is something I explored in my “Undoing Romance” series. Again, this is looking beyond the actors. The biggest tell for me was that they never got a first kiss so romantic tension was never released but just dissipated over plot exposition. Moreover, how is it that Jon and Sansa have more parallels with romantic ships than Jon/Dany do? Why do Jon/Sansa have more Robb/Talisa framing through season 6 than Jon/Dany through season 7 if that’s what’s happening? Why was there no passionate first kiss like theirs? We just skipped to the sex in between a montage that told us how related they are. 
Why didn’t Jon look back at Dany when Jorah did, while he looked back at Sansa? Why does Jon react more violently to Sansa’s suitors than to Jorah? Why are these characters caught in triangle with interlopers, who pose a political threat but are also interested in one romantically? Why is this dynamic given so much importance where there’s tension but also there’s emotional vulnerability that pours out contrasting Jon/Sansa’s and Sansa and Arya’s season 6 and season 7 battlements scenes respectively. Why did they reveal R+L=J at the end of season 6 - the season in which people questioned what the hell was happening in the Jon/Sansa dynamic and a whole season before Jon met Dany. Both season finales also teased conflict because of political claims that change because of R+L=J. Where his parentage reveal, relieves Jon/Sansa of the direct incest factor because it biologically distances them, it makes Jon and Dany biologically more related - especially because she’s heavily inbred herself. 
So it is a situation of “will they/won’t they?” but even more subtly because the cast and crew always skips past discussing it and with Jon/Dany happening people take it as accidental chemistry. There’s no heavy dismissal from the TPTB though when there could’ve been or laughing at it like Tormund and Brienne, which is totally for laughs and a show ship. What they do keep saying is that this relationship is key to watch and you have to wonder: why is it so important? To me it’s not about the actors chemistry or singular scenes. It’s about the story’s intrinsic narrative structure and the camera framing that makes the visual subtext convey more than the text does. 
The show frames Jon and Sansa’s relationship is odd because we know they weren’t close and Arya was his favorite and yet they take up quite an important part in each other’s arc at this point, where they both want to trust each other completely but don’t and yet their vulnerability comes out most around each other in these last two seasons. They’re being built up more slowly than Jon/Dany and more subtly so while people expect a full blown romance, I expect something more subtle, more quiet and thus emotionally rewarding for these characters individual and collective arcs. If it happens, D&D are building it up as a plot twist/game changer because it’s related to politics. But it’s not to say there can’t be emotional catharsis too because these characters have a lot of issues that they answer pretty well. 
Hope that answers your questions. 
- lostlittlesatellites
73 notes · View notes
herodine · 3 years ago
Text
Tumblr media
0 notes
murphy-s-grout · 4 years ago
Photo
Tumblr media
J’ai assez d’emmerdes pour pas que tu viennes me faire trop chier. CORDIALEMENT
0 notes
artepmb · 5 years ago
Photo
Tumblr media
Quarantaine #sijamaisjoublie #pourquoipas #jesuiscommeça #jesuiscommejesuis #sketch#esquisse#dessin#doodle#drawing #scribble#scarabocchi #gribouillage #garabatos #quarantaine https://www.instagram.com/p/B-n7UXhpoeU/?igshid=1g4j9dsfyoxpp
0 notes
boyz-bieber · 6 years ago
Photo
Tumblr media
New York, 1960’s My father’s portrait of my grandfather. Though they differed wildly in lifestyle - my dad the rebellious hippy youth, his dad the holocaust survivor and literature professor - these two had an incredibly close relationship 🤝 Dad respected granddad’s #OG knowledge, granddad loved his son’s passion and free spirit. So much so that he was the one to smuggle my father out of the country to escape the law. Dad was not allowed to attend his own father’s funeral a few years later, so at 10yrs old I delivered I these words in his stead: “Our father who art in Heaven...stay there. And we shall stay on Earth, which is sometimes so pretty...” - Jacques Prevert 🇫🇷 #grandpere #legend #outwitting #gestapo #twopeas #differentpods #policemoment #photobomb #foreshadowing #jesuiscommejesuis (at New York, New York) https://www.instagram.com/p/BtV8_tfgSLN/?utm_source=ig_tumblr_share&igshid=12266rqgtg8mt
0 notes
franpolliin · 4 years ago
Text
Tumblr media
jesuiscommejesuis (c) franpolliin - 2021
13 notes · View notes
rosenworld · 6 years ago
Photo
Tumblr media
#stripes #iamwhatiam #jesuiscommejesuis #memoir #wip #rosenworld https://www.instagram.com/p/Bqp260xFqcn/?utm_source=ig_tumblr_share&igshid=9tg62b5qn0sf
0 notes
gigichristo-blog1 · 8 years ago
Photo
Tumblr media
Je suis comme je suis. Jacques Prevert. Je suis comme je suis Je suis faite comme ça Quand j'ai envie de rire Oui je ris aux éclats J'aime celui qui m'aime Est-ce ma faute à moi Si ce n'est pas le même Que j'aime à chaque fois Je suis comme je suis Je suis faite comme ça Que voulez-vous de plus Que voulez-vous de moi Je suis faite pour plaire Et n'y puis rien changer Mes talons sont trop hauts Ma taille trop cambrée Mes seins beaucoup trop durs Et mes yeux trop cernés Et puis après Qu'est-ce que ça peut vous faire Je suis comme je suis Je plais à qui je plais Qu'est-ce que ça peut vous faire Ce qui m'est arrivé Oui j'ai aimé quelqu'un Oui quelqu'un m'a aimée Comme les enfants qui s'aiment Simplement savent aimer Aimer aimer... Pourquoi me questionner Je suis là pour vous plaire Et n'y puis rien changer. #poeme #poesie #poete #prevert #jacquesprévert #jesuiscommejesuis #ecriture #citation #poem #poemsofinstagram #quoteoftheday #iamwhoiam #iamwhatiam #instalove #instapoem #instaword #poetry #poetsociety #poetsoninstagram #spilledink #bellesphrases
0 notes
murphy-s-grout · 7 years ago
Text
Si
Tumblr media
0 notes
kc1155 · 6 years ago
Photo
Tumblr media
[#citationdujour] ● La vie est difficile mais n'oublie pas d'être incroyable chaque jour! (Aide-toi et la vie t'aidera) 💎🙋‍♀️👈☝️ . . . #emag #kc1155 #santéetbienêtre #vulnerable #sensible #imparfait #authentique #lifestyleblogueuse #blogueusemtl #bonte #mtlblogue #jesuisunique #etreunique #lavie #souffrance #moimeme #aimer #cestlavie #santementale #etre #soisgeniales #gentillesse #vrai #vulnérabilité #portraitintimiste #etrevrai #blancetnoir #jesuismoi #jesuiscommejesuis . Image cc @justin veenema https://www.instagram.com/p/BqFm88inhfd/?utm_source=ig_tumblr_share&igshid=79nisyy6uv10
0 notes
rosenworld · 6 years ago
Photo
Tumblr media
#stripes #iamwhatiam #jesuiscommejesuis #memoir #wip #rosenworld https://www.instagram.com/p/Bqp260xFqcn/?utm_source=ig_tumblr_share&igshid=13o7e4uguaa5d
0 notes
andreatarella · 9 years ago
Photo
Tumblr media
My #illustration for @two_fc #JeSuisCommeJeSuis thanks to @christian_frascaro and @francesco_cristiano #AndreaTarella #illustrator www.andreatarella.com (presso Loculo Tarella)
0 notes
dexterdextao · 10 years ago
Photo
Tumblr media
Comingsoon#acting#emmanuel#DDT#jesuiscommejesuis#thk @renaud duval#writer#realisatoractor#his last Book is#Lanouvelledameauxcamelias#editionsfortuna#👍
0 notes
goldenrubbish-blog · 12 years ago
Quote
Je suis comme je suis Je suis faite comme ça...
Jacques Prévert
8 notes · View notes