#international trade consulting

[intertaxtrade]

Website : https://en.intertaxtrade.com

Intertaxtrade, established in the Netherlands, excels in facilitating international business and assisting individuals in Europe with integrated solutions in tax, finance, and legal aspects. Registered with the Chamber of Commerce, they offer services like company management in the Netherlands, Dutch company accounting, tax intermediation, international tax planning, business law consulting, EU trademark and intellectual property registration, international trade advice, and GDPR compliance. Their expertise in financial and accounting services ensures clients have a clear financial overview, aiding in business success.

Facebook : https://www.facebook.com/intertaxtrade

Instagram : https://www.instagram.com/intertaxtrade/

Linkedin : https://www.linkedin.com/in/ramosbrandao/

Keywords: company registration netherlands legal advice online comprehensive financial planning financial planning consultancy international business services international business expansion strategies gdpr compliance solutions international trade consulting european investment opportunities gdpr compliance consulting services in depth financial analysis gdpr compliance assistance cross border tax solutions netherlands business environment european union business law dutch accounting services tax intermediation solutions international tax planning advice eu trademark registration services investment guidance online business law consultancy corporate tax services netherlands financial analysis experts business immigration support startup legal assistance online european market entry consulting international financial reporting services business strategy netherlands tax authority communication support international business law expertise dutch commercial law advice global business strategy services european business consulting online international business services platform expert legal advice online efficient company registration netherlands reliable dutch accounting services strategic tax intermediation proactive international tax planning eu trademark registration support tailored investment guidance specialized business law consultancy dynamic international trade consulting holistic corporate tax services netherlands streamlined business immigration support online startup legal assistance strategic international business expansion european market entry planning innovative cross border tax solutions navigating the netherlands business environment european union business law insights accurate international financial reporting proven business strategy netherlands exclusive european investment opportunities seamless tax authority communication in depth dutch commercial law advice comprehensive global business strategy proactive european business consulting one stop international business services personalized financial planning solutions expert legal advice for businesses quick company registration in netherlands trustworthy dutch accounting services strategic tax intermediation solutions innovative international tax planning efficient eu trademark registration tailored investment guidance online business law consultancy expertise comprehensive corporate tax services netherlands thorough financial analysis support streamlined business immigration assistance navigating netherlands business environment european union business law guidance international financial reporting accuracy business strategy for netherlands market european investment opportunities insights efficient tax authority communication international business law excellence dutch commercial law proficiency global business strategy implementation european business consulting excellence comprehensive international business services proactive financial planning strategies expert legal advice on international matters

[arihantcourierservices]

Outsource Your Export Process with AICS Export Solutions and Boost Your Export Sales

Unlock your export potential with AICS Export Solutions! This blog post details how they handle payment remittance, GST compliance, customs clearance, logistics, product storage, and more. Learn about cost-cutting solutions, destination-specific delivery, and expert support. Simplify your export journey and boost sales.

Read the full article: https://www.arihantcourier.com/blog-details/outsource-your-export-process-with-aics-export-solutions-and-boost-your-export-sales

[mohitsharma85784]

Boost Your Currency Trading with the Best Forex Signal Providers

Unlock your trading potential with the best forex signal providers offering expert insights for fx currency trading and international currency trading. Optimize your forex trading account using advanced forex trading strategies and real-time live forex signals for successful trades.

[milestoneworldwide]

Sustainability in Freight

Sustainability is becoming an increasingly important issue for businesses of all sizes. This is especially true for the freight industry, which is responsible for a significant amount of greenhouse gas emissions. As a result, there is a growing trend towards sustainability in freight.

There are a number of ways that businesses can make their freight operations more sustainable. One way is to choose a freight forwarding company that is committed to sustainability. Milestone Worldwide is one such company. Milestone Worldwide is a leading freight forwarding company in Pune that is committed to providing sustainable freight solutions.

Here are some of the ways that Milestone Worldwide is making its freight operations more sustainable:

Using fuel-efficient vehicles: Milestone Worldwide uses fuel-efficient vehicles to transport goods. This helps to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

Consolidating shipments: Milestone Worldwide consolidates shipments whenever possible. This helps to reduce the number of vehicles on the road and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

Using renewable energy: Milestone Worldwide is exploring ways to use renewable energy to power its operations.

Offsetting emissions: Milestone Worldwide offsets its emissions by investing in carbon credits.

In addition to choosing a sustainable freight forwarding company, there are a number of other things that businesses can do to make their freight operations more sustainable. These include:

Reducing packaging: Businesses can reduce packaging waste by using less packaging or using recyclable packaging.

Choosing sustainable suppliers: Businesses can choose suppliers that are committed to sustainability.

Routing shipments efficiently: Businesses can route shipments efficiently to reduce the distance that goods need to travel.

By taking these steps, businesses can help to make the freight industry more sustainable.

[bizilance]

Understanding the Importance of Anti-Dumping Consultancy Services

In today's globalized economy, businesses increasingly engage in international trade to expand their markets and optimize supply chains. However, with the benefits of global trade come challenges, including the issue of dumping—when companies export goods at prices lower than their normal value, often to gain unfair market share in the importing country. This practice can harm domestic industries and disrupt markets, leading to the need for anti-dumping measures.

Anti-dumping consultancy services play a crucial role in helping businesses navigate these complex waters. These services are designed to assist companies in understanding and complying with anti-dumping regulations, ensuring fair trade practices and protecting local industries from unfair competition. In this blog, we will explore the significance of anti-dumping consultancy services, their benefits, and how they can help your business thrive in a competitive global market.

What is Dumping?

Dumping occurs when a company exports a product to another country at a price lower than its normal value, typically defined as the price of the product in the domestic market of the exporting country. This practice is often used as a strategy to gain market share in a foreign market by undercutting local prices. While this may seem beneficial to consumers in the short term, it can have detrimental effects on the domestic industry in the importing country. If left unchecked, dumping can lead to the collapse of local businesses, job losses, and overall economic instability.

To counteract dumping, countries implement anti-dumping measures, including duties and tariffs, to protect their domestic industries. However, navigating these regulations can be challenging for businesses, especially those involved in international trade. This is where anti-dumping consultancy services come into play.

The Role of Anti-Dumping Consultancy Services

Anti-dumping consultancy services provide expert guidance and support to businesses facing the complexities of anti-dumping regulations. These services are typically offered by professionals with extensive knowledge of international trade laws, economics, and the specific regulations related to anti-dumping.

Here are some key roles of anti-dumping consultancy services:

Regulatory Compliance: Anti-dumping consultants help businesses understand and comply with the anti-dumping regulations in various countries. This includes analyzing the applicable laws, tariffs, and duties, as well as preparing the necessary documentation for compliance.

Market Analysis: Consultants conduct in-depth market analysis to identify potential dumping issues. They assess pricing strategies, market conditions, and competition to determine whether a company's products are at risk of being targeted by anti-dumping measures.

Legal Representation: In cases where a company is accused of dumping, consultants can provide legal representation and support during investigations and proceedings. They work to protect the interests of the business and ensure a fair resolution.

Strategy Development: Anti-dumping consultants assist businesses in developing strategies to mitigate the impact of anti-dumping measures. This may include adjusting pricing strategies, exploring alternative markets, or negotiating with trade authorities.

Risk Management: By providing ongoing monitoring and assessment of international trade practices, anti-dumping consultants help businesses manage the risks associated with dumping and ensure long-term stability.

Benefits of Anti-Dumping Consultancy Services

Engaging anti-dumping consultancy services offers several benefits to businesses involved in international trade:

Expertise and Knowledge: Anti-dumping consultants bring specialized knowledge of international trade laws and regulations, ensuring that your business remains compliant and avoids costly penalties.

Cost Savings: By identifying potential dumping risks and developing strategies to mitigate them, consultants can help businesses avoid costly anti-dumping duties and tariffs.

Competitive Advantage: With the guidance of anti-dumping consultants, businesses can navigate complex trade regulations more effectively, giving them a competitive edge in the global market.

Peace of Mind: Knowing that your business is protected from the risks of dumping allows you to focus on growth and expansion, rather than worrying about regulatory compliance.

In the ever-evolving landscape of international trade, anti-dumping consultancy services are invaluable for businesses looking to protect their interests and ensure fair competition. Whether you are facing a potential anti-dumping investigation or simply want to stay ahead of the curve, partnering with a trusted anti-dumping consultant can provide the expertise and support you need to thrive in the global market.

By leveraging the expertise of anti-dumping consultants, businesses can not only safeguard their operations but also seize new opportunities in the world of international trade. If you are involved in exporting or importing goods, consider the benefits of anti-dumping consultancy services to protect your business and ensure long-term success.

[crescendoworldwideindia]

International Trade Consulting Firms

International trade consulting firms are essential for businesses looking to expand globally. Crescendo Worldwide offers expert guidance to navigate the complexities of international trade. Our services include market analysis, regulatory compliance, and strategic planning, ensuring smooth entry into new markets. With our deep industry knowledge and extensive network, we help clients optimize supply chains, mitigate risks, and capitalize on growth opportunities. Whether you are entering new markets or strengthening existing ones, Crescendo Worldwide’s international trade consulting services provide the expertise needed to achieve your global business objectives efficiently and effectively.

[souravsharma38393]

Tax Advisory Services | Myforexeye Fintech Private Limited

At Myforexeye Fintech Private Limited, they offer expert tax advisory services designed to help you navigate complex tax regulations with ease. Their comprehensive taxation advisory ensures optimal financial planning and compliance. Partner with their for reliable and efficient tax solutions.

[vickykumar652449]

Forex Trading Consultant | Myforexeye Fintech Pvt. Limited

Myforexeye Fintech Pvt. Limited offers expert services as a Forex trading consultant, providing invaluable guidance for fx currency trading. Their consultants help traders develop effective forex trading strategies, ensuring informed decisions in the international currency trading market. Partnering with Myforexeye guarantees strategic insights and personalized support.

[aussieimport]

International Trade Consultant in Sydney

Looking for an International Trade Consultant in Sydney? Aussie Import is your trusted partner for seamless global business expansion. Our experienced consultants provide expert guidance on import/export regulations, market analysis, and strategic planning to enhance your international trade ventures. From navigating customs procedures to optimising supply chains, we ensure efficient and compliant cross-border transactions. Partner with Aussie Import for tailored solutions that drive success in the dynamic world of international trade. Elevate your business to new heights with our specialised expertise. Contact us today for a consultation that empowers your global trade endeavours.

[andhumanslovedstories]

There's so many horrible things happening in America right now that it has been interesting to see what individual horrors hurt me personally the most. I grew up going to the Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts. Musicals, plays, concerts, that weird bust of JFK, playing around on terrace during intermissions, putting on a velvet dress that you're going to ruin dropping a milk dud in your lap and not noticing until it's fully melted, wearing the pinchy shiny shoes that are the training bras of women's formal footwear, operas I didn't like but did love, jazz I didn't understand but still fascinated me, red carpet, big stairs, the absolute nightmare amount of experiences I had as a new driver as I repeatedly got trapped in the Kennedy Center's fucking private DC island or whatever the hell is going on traffic-wise, free performances on small side stages, getting to see an enormous production on the Center's most enormous stage, all of which was accessed by walking through that a long, tall hallway lined with flags of the world that made you feel like a dignitary attending the most important even in the world.

And now Trump's taken it over. He fired its board. He appointed one of his loyalists to run it. I want to throw up.

Sometimes I miss DC so much. I love the Pacific Northwest and expect I'll live here for the rest of my life, but this isn't my hometown. I grew up the edge of the District. I've lost cumulative years of my life stuck in traffic on the inner loop and outer loop. Because of the Smithsonian, it used to be so baffling to me that anyone ever had to pay to get into a museum. I've used the Washington DC zoo as a shortcut to a different part of the city because it's free to enter. You couldn't count the amount of knockoff Spider-man popsicles that I've eaten sitting on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial. My reading tastes were molded by Kramer Books in Dupont Circle. I spent afternoons walking around the National Mall, normally just a big empty field until there's an event--book fair, country music program, international cuisine, whatever--at which point for a day or a weekend or a week it becomes a sea of tents and stages. I went to protests outside the Capital and the White House about the war in Iraq. I froze my toes off watching Obama's 2008 presidential inauguration.

It seemed like everyone's family touched the federal government in some way. Everyone's family had moved here because they were military or state department or a political consultant or worked with an NGO or some other reason that meant you had to be here, in the nation's capital. Plenty of people had connections to the federal government that we more hush-hush. Like kids in class straight up going, "I have no idea what my parents do for a living. They're not allowed to tell me." High schoolers regularly, accidentally drove into the CIA parking lot and got escorted out because the premises were that accessible. My family moved here because my dad is a reporter who ended up covering international trade. (Imagine how much his job sucks right now.) He switched beats one summer to cover the White House instead. He got to fly on Air Force One. He got official Air Force One M&Ms. I was SO disappointment my dad didn't work there for Bush to call on him by nickname.

Every day my family got The Washington Post. I read the comics and the kid's page, then the rest of the Style section, then Metro, then news. I learned to read from it. We wrapped our delicate Christmas ornaments with its pages. We used yesterday's papers to clean our windows because they didn't leave streaks. I took journalism in high school. You can't IMAGINE how much and how frequently we talked about Watergate. When Post changed its motto to "Democracy Dies in Darkness" after Trump's election in 2016 that meant something to me. I knew Bezos owned the paper now, but that was still my paper, and the motto spoke to something I fervently believed: if people just knew what was happening, they wouldn't allow it to happen. If you expose a problem, people will naturally agree that it is a problem and that we should do something to fix it. Flash forward to Trump's third fucking campaign, and the newspaper wouldn't endorse a presidential candidate. Chickenshit cowardice. Then they change the motto. "Riveting Storytelling for All of America." Eat shit. You're nothing now.

Politics in America is just telling everyone how much you hate Washington, DC so that they'll elect you so you can move to DC. Well, guys, the city fucking hates you too. Republicans will never give the District actually meaningful political representation because no one in that city would vote for them. It's not just the policies; it's the contempt. No one in the new administration loves the city they schemed and lied and stooped to take over. It's just iconography to them, and all they care about is taking that iconography for themselves. Trump doesn't give a shit about the summer program for the Kennedy Center. He has never seen a show at the Kennedy Center. When he was president, he never attended the annual awards. He's trying to destroy one of the most significant places of my life and I'm genuinely unsure if he has ever stepped for inside of it.

[haberai]

CELİKELCPA - PLATİNUM

Are you considering taking the exciting plunge into the dynamic Turkish market? Look no further than Celik El CPA, your trusted partner for seamless company formation and registration in Turkey. As an expert in navigating the complexities of business setup, our services cater to both local and international entrepreneurs eager to establish a foothold in this vibrant economy. With our knowledgeable Turkey accountants by your side, you can rest assured that your financial matters will be managed with precision and care. From navigating regulatory requirements to ensuring compliance, we simplify the process of starting a business in Turkey. 

Company Formation in Turkey

Setting up a business in Turkey can be an excellent decision for both local and foreign entrepreneurs. The process of company formation in Turkey is streamlined and relatively straightforward, making it a lucrative destination for investment. With the right guidance, including the assistance of professional Turkey accountants, you can navigate through legal requirements with ease.

One of the key aspects in securing a successful company registration in Turkey is understanding the various business structures available, such as limited liability companies (LLCs) and joint-stock companies. Each type has its unique benefits and requirements, which is why consulting with experts is advisable to choose the best option for your business model.

Moreover, Turkey's strategic location and growing economy provide a wealth of opportunities for business growth. Whether you're considering import-export businesses or tech startups, the benefits of entering the Turkish market are plentiful. You can leverage local resources and a young workforce, enhancing the potential for business success.

When you’re ready to start your business journey, ensure that you have all the necessary documents submitted accurately to avoid delays in the registration process. With the right support, how to start a business in Turkey can become a seamless experience!

Company Registration in Turkey

Company Registration in Turkey is a crucial step for entrepreneurs looking to establish a business presence in this vibrant market. The process involves several key steps that are designed to ensure compliance with local laws and regulations.

Step-by-Step Process

Choose Your Business Structure: Decide on the type of entity that best suits your business needs, such as a limited liability company (LLC) or joint-stock company.

Prepare Necessary Documentation: Gather all required documents, including your business plan, identity proof, and proof of address.

Open a Bank Account: Deposit the minimum required capital into a Turkish bank account and obtain a bank receipt.

Notary Public: Have your company’s articles of association drafted and notarized.

Register with the Trade Registry Office: Submit your documents to the local Trade Registry office to officially register your company.

Obtain Tax Registration: After registration, apply for a tax identification number from the Tax Office.

Benefits of Registering Your Company in Turkey

Completing the company registration process not only gives your business legal standing but also opens doors to various advantages such as:

Access to a growing market with a dynamic economy.

Eligibility for local and international contracts.

Enhanced credibility with clients and investors.

Engaging with experienced Turkey accountants such as those at Celikel CPA can significantly streamline your registration process. Their expert guidance ensures all steps are efficiently handled, allowing you to focus on your core business activities.

Ready to take the plunge and establish your presence in Turkey? Start your journey today with the support of dedicated professionals who are there to guide you through every step of How to Start a Business in Turkey.

Turkey Accountants

When planning for company formation in Turkey, selecting a skilled accountant is crucial to ensure compliance with local regulations. Experienced Turkey accountants possess in-depth knowledge of the Turkish tax system and can guide you through the intricacies of company registration in Turkey.

These professionals are adept at various services including bookkeeping, financial reporting, and tax planning, which are essential for new businesses. With their expertise, they help business owners navigate the complexities of local financial obligations, enabling you to focus on building your company.

If you are considering how to start a business in Turkey, partnering with the right accounting firm can significantly streamline your operations and enhance your chances of success. Ensure that your financial foundations are strong with professional help, positioning your business on the path to growth.

How to Start a Business in Turkey

How to starting a business in Turkey can be an exciting and rewarding venture. With its strategic location, dynamic market, and favorable investment climate, the country is an excellent choice for entrepreneurs. Here’s a concise guide to navigating the essential steps so you can move forward confidently.

Choose Your Business Structure: The first step is to decide on the type of business entity that suits your needs. Options include limited liability companies (LLCs), joint-stock companies (JSCs), and sole proprietorships. Each structure comes with its own regulatory requirements and tax implications, so it's essential to choose wisely.

These steps can set the foundation for your success in Turkey’s vibrant market landscape. With effective company registration in Turkey and the guidance of experienced Turkey accountants at your side, you will be well-equipped to launch and grow your business.

For more detailed assistance and tailored advice, don't hesitate to visit Celik & Co. CPA—your trusted partner in navigating the complexities of starting a business in Turkey.

[teilfirms01]

Choosing the right law firm to handle your legal needs in Illinois can be a daunting task. With so many options available, it can be difficult to know where to start. In this post, we'll explore that how to choose the right law firm for your legal needs, whether you require international trade consulting services or other legal expertise.

[milestoneworldwide]

Challenges Faced in International Logistics Shipments

The world of international trade thrives on the seamless movement of goods across borders. However, this seemingly straightforward process can be fraught with complexities and unforeseen challenges. As an international logistics company understands, navigating these difficulties requires experience, adaptability, and a proactive approach.

The Maze of Regulations:

International shipments face a labyrinth of regulations and customs procedures. Different countries have varying import and export restrictions, documentation requirements, and labeling standards. Failing to comply with these regulations can lead to delays, fines, or even shipment confiscation.

The Paper Chase:

The sheer amount of paperwork involved in international logistics can be overwhelming. Bills of lading, commercial invoices, certificates of origin, and various customs forms all need to be meticulously completed with accurate information. A single mistake can hold up your shipment for days, causing frustration and additional costs.

The Unpredictable Journey:

The path of an international shipment is rarely smooth sailing. Unforeseen circumstances like bad weather, labor strikes, or political instability can disrupt schedules and cause delays. An international logistics company must be prepared to adapt to these disruptions and keep clients informed of any potential setbacks.

The Price of Passage:

The cost of international shipping can be a significant factor, especially for large or bulky items. Fuel price fluctuations, currency exchange rates, and various customs fees can all impact the final cost. An international logistics company should offer transparent pricing structures and work with clients to find cost-effective solutions.

The Language Barrier:

Communication plays a crucial role in ensuring a smooth shipment process. However, language barriers can create misunderstandings between shippers, customs officials, and overseas partners. An international logistics company with a multilingual team can bridge this gap, facilitating clear communication and avoiding potential issues.

Security Concerns:

Cargo theft and damage are constant worries in international shipping. An international logistics company should prioritize security measures throughout the entire journey, including secure packaging, real-time tracking systems, and insurance options to protect your valuable cargo.

Partnering for Success: How an International Logistics Company Can Help

Navigating the complexities of international logistics can be daunting. But by partnering with a reliable International logistics company, you can ensure your shipments reach their destination efficiently and cost-effectively. Here's how they can help:

Expertise in Regulations: An experienced international logistics company possesses in-depth knowledge of customs regulations for various countries, ensuring your shipments meet all compliance requirements.

Streamlined Documentation: They can handle the preparation and processing of all necessary paperwork, minimizing the risk of errors and delays.

Global Network: A well-established international logistics company has a network of partners and offices worldwide, allowing them to monitor your shipment throughout its journey and address any issues promptly.

Risk Management Strategies: They can develop contingency plans to mitigate potential disruptions caused by unforeseen circumstances, ensuring your shipment arrives on time.

Cost-Effective Solutions: An international logistics company can negotiate competitive rates with carriers and explore cost-saving options based on your specific needs.

Communication and Transparency: They provide regular updates on the status of your shipment and maintain clear communication with all parties involved, keeping you informed every step of the way.

International logistics, while complex, holds immense potential to expand your business reach. By understanding the challenges involved and partnering with a reliable international logistics company, you can navigate the complexities with confidence, ensuring your goods reach their global destinations efficiently and securely.

[psdglobal]

International Technology Sales Leads — PSD Global

Throughout the world, there are nations, cities, and regions that look forward to attracting new businesses and with them, new opportunities. Every year businesses seek to find new markets, international technology sales, and new customers to help grow their business. Once your company reaches a certain point, there is no other option for continued growth other than expansion. PSD Global is the lead generation economic development firm focused on helping growing firms accelerate theirs in international technology global sales and business development objectives.

[mostlysignssomeportents]

Canada’s ground-breaking, hamstrung repair and interop laws

If you'd like an essay-formatted version of this post to read or share, here's a link to it on pluralistic.net, my surveillance-free, ad-free, tracker-free blog:

https://pluralistic.net/2024/11/15/radical-extremists/#sex-pest

When the GOP trifecta assumes power in just a few months, they will pass laws, and those laws will be terrible, and they will cast long, long shadows.

This is the story of how another far-right conservative government used its bulletproof majority to pass a wildly unpopular law that continues to stymie progress to this day. It's the story of Canada's Harper Conservative government, and two of its key ministers: Tony Clement and James Moore.

Starting in 1998, the US Trade Rep embarked on a long campaign to force every country in the world to enact a new kind of IP law: an "anticircumvention" law that would criminalize the production and use of tools that allowed people to use their own property in ways that the manufacturer disliked.

This first entered the US statute books with the 1998 passage of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), whose Section 1201 established a new felony for circumventing an "access control." Crucially, DMCA 1201's prohibition on circumvention did not confine itself to protecting copyright.

Circumventing an access control is a felony, even if you never violate copyright law. For example, if you circumvent the access control on your own printer to disable the processes that check to make sure you're using an official HP cartridge, HP can come after you.

You haven't violated any copyright, but the ink-checking code is a copyrighted work, and you had to circumvent a block in order to reach it. Thus, if I provide you a tool to escape HP's ink racket, I commit a felony with penalties of five years in prison and a $500k fine, for a first offense. So it is that HP ink costs more per ounce than the semen of a Kentucky Derby-winning stallion.

This was clearly a bad idea in 1998, though it wasn't clear how bad an idea it was at the time. In 1998, chips were expensive and underpowered. By 2010, a chip that cost less than a dollar could easily implement a DMCA-triggering access control, and manufacturers of all kinds were adding superfluous chips to everything from engine parts to smart lightbulbs whose sole purpose was to transform modification into felonies. This is what Jay Freeman calls "felony contempt of business-model."

So when the Harper government set out to import US-style anticircumvention law to Canada, Canadians were furious. A consultation on the proposal received 6,138 responses opposing the law, and 54 in support:

https://www.michaelgeist.ca/2010/04/copycon-final-numbers/

And yet, James Moore and Tony Clement pressed on. When asked how they could advance such an unpopular bill, opposed by experts and the general public alike, Moore told the International Chamber of Commerce that every objector who responded to his consultation was a "radical extremist" with a "babyish" approach to copyright:

https://www.cbc.ca/news/science/copyright-debate-turns-ugly-1.898216

As is so often the case, history vindicated the babyish radical extremists. The DMCA actually has an official way to keep score on this one. Every three years, the US Copyright Office invites public submissions for exemptions to DMCA 1201, creating a detailed, evidence-backed record of all the legitimate activities that anticircumvention law interferes with.

Unfortunately, "a record" is all we get out of this proceeding. Even though the Copyright Office is allowed to grant "exemptions," these don't mean what you think they mean. The statute is very clear on this: the US Copyright Office is required to grant exemptions for the act of circumvention, but is forbidden from granting exemptions for tools needed to carry out these acts.

This is headspinningly and deliberately obscure, but there's one anecdote from my long crusade against this stupid law that lays it bare. As I mentioned, the US Trade Rep has made the passage of DMCA-like laws in other countries a top priority since the Clinton years. In 2001, the EU adopted the EU Copyright Directive, whose Article 6 copy-pastes the provisions of DMCA 1201.

In 2003, I found myself in Oslo, debating the minister who'd just completed Norway's EUCD implementation. The minister was very proud of his law, boasting that he'd researched the flaws in other countries' anticircumvention laws and addressed them in Norway's law. For example, Norway's law explicitly allowed blind people to bypass access controls on ebooks in order to feed them into text-to-speech engines, Braille printers and other accessibility tools.

I knew where this was going. I asked the minister how this would work in practice. Could someone sell a blind person a tool to break the DRM on their ebooks? Of course not, that's totally illegal. Could a nonprofit blind rights group make such a tool and give it away to blind people? No, that's illegal too. What about hobbyists, could they make the tool for their blind friends? No, not that either.

OK, so how do blind people exercise their right to bypass access controls on ebooks they own so they can actually read them?

Here's how. Each blind person, all by themself, is expected to decompile and reverse-engineer Adobe Reader, locate a vulnerability in the code and write a new program that exploits that vulnerability to extract their ebooks. While blind people are individually empowered to undertake this otherwise prohibited activity, they must do so on their own: they can't share notes with one another on the process. They certainly can't give each other the circumvention program they write in this way:

https://pluralistic.net/2024/10/28/mcbroken/#my-milkshake-brings-all-the-lawyers-to-the-yard

That's what a use-only exemption is: the right to individually put a locked down device up on your own workbench, and, laboring in perfect secrecy, figure out how it works and then defeat the locks that stop you from changing those workings so they benefit you instead of the manufacturer. Without a "tools" exemption, a use exemption is basically a decorative ornament.

So the many use exemptions that the US Copyright Office has granted since 1998 really amount to nothing more than a list of defects in the DMCA that the Copyright Office has painstaking verified but is powerless to fix. We could probably save everyone a lot of time by scrapping the triennial exemptions process and replacing it with an permanent sign over the doors of the Library of Congress reading "Abandon hope, all ye who enter here."

All of this was well understood by 2010, when Moore and Clement were working on the Canadian version of the DMCA. All of this was explained in eye-watering detail to Moore and Clement, but was roundly ignored. I even had a go at it, publicly picking a fight with Moore on Twitter:

https://web.archive.org/web/20130407101911if_/http://eaves.ca/wp-content/uploads/2010/Conversations%20between%20@doctorow%20and%20@mpjamesmoore.jpg

Moore and Clement rammed their proposal through in the next session of Parliament, passing it as Bill C-11 in 2012:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Modernization_Act

This was something of a grand finale for the pair. Today, Moore is a faceless corporate lawyer, while Clement was last seen grifting covid PPE (Clement's political career ended abruptly when he sent dick pics to a young woman who turned out to be a pair of sextortionists from Cote D'Ivoire, and was revealed as a serial sex-pest in the ensuing scandal:)

https://globalnews.ca/news/4646287/tony-clement-instagram-women/

Even though Moore and Clement are long gone from public life, their signature achievement remains a Canadian disgrace, an anchor chain tied around the Canadian economy's throat, and an impediment to Canadian progress.

This week, two excellent new Canadian laws received royal assent: Bill C-244 is a broad, national Right to Repair law; and Bill C-294 is a broad, national interoperability law. Both laws establish the right to circumvent access controls for the purpose of fixing and improving things, something Canadians deserve and need.

But neither law contains a tools exemption. Like the blind people of Norway, a Canadian farmer who wants to attach a made-in-Canada Honeybee tool to their John Deere tractor is required to personally, individually reverse-engineer the John Deere tractor and modify it to talk to the Honeybee accessory, laboring in total secrecy:

https://www.theregister.com/2024/11/12/canada_right_to_repair/

Likewise the Canadian repair tech who fixes a smart speaker or a busted smartphone – they are legally permitted to circumvent in order to torture the device's repair codes out of it or force it to recognize a replacement part, but each technician must personally figure out how to get the device firmware to do this, without discussing it with anyone else.

Thus do Moore and Clement stand athwart Canadian self-reliance and economic development, shouting "STOP!" though both men have been out of politics for years.

There has never been a better time to hit Clement and Moore's political legacy over the head with a shovel and bury it in a shallow grave. Canadian technologists could be making a fortune creating circumvention devices that repair and improve devices marketed by foreign companies.

They could make circumvention tools to allow owners of consoles to play games by Canadian studios that are directly sold to Canadian gamers, bypassing the stores operated by Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo and the 30% commissions they charge. Canadian technologists could be making diagnostic tools that allow every auto-mechanic in Canada to fix any car manufactured anywhere in the world.

Canadian cloud servers could power devices long after their US-based manufacturers discontinue support for them, providing income to Canadian cloud companies and continued enjoyment for Canadian owners of these otherwise bricked gadgets.

Canada's gigantic auto-parts sector could clone the security chips that foreign auto manufacturers use to block the use of third party parts, and every Canadian could enjoy a steep discount every time they fix their cars. Every farmer could avail themselves of third party parts for their tractors, which they could install themselves, bypassing the $200 service call from a John Deere technician who does nothing more than look over the farmer's own repair and then types an unlock code into the tractor's console.

Every Canadian who prints out a shopping list or their kid's homework could use third party ink that sells for pennies per liter, rather than HP's official colored water that cost more than vintage Veuve Cliquot.

A Canadian e-waste dump generates five low-paid jobs per ton of waste, and that waste itself will poison the land and water for centuries to come. A circumvention-enabled Canadian repair sector could generate 150 skilled, high-paid community jobs that saves gadgets and the Earth, all while saving Canadians millions.

Canadians could enjoy the resliency that comes of having a domestic tech and repair sector, and could count on it through pandemics and Trumpian trade-war.

All of that and more could be ours, except for the cowardice and greed of Tony Clement and James Moore and the Harper Tories who voted C-11 into law in 2012.

Everything the "radical extremists" warned them of has come true. It's long past time Canadians tore up anticircumvention law and put the interests of the Canadian public and Canadian tech businesses ahead of the rent-seeking enshittification of American Big Tech.

Until we do that, we can keep on passing all the repair and interop laws we want, but each one will be hamstrung by Moore and Clement's "felony contempt of business model" law, and the contempt it showed for the Canadian people.

Image: JeffJ (modified) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Tony_Clement_-_2007-06-30_in_Kearney,_Ontario.JPG

CC BY-SA 3.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/

--

Jorge Franganillo (modified) https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Duga_radar_system-_wreckage_of_electronic_devices_(37885984654).jpg

CC BY 2.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/deed.en