#if that were the case he wouldnt have been able to talk/kill emily or anyone else for that matter | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

eldritchqueerture · 8 months ago

Text

okay okay okay but HOW exactly. how exactly did john kill Emily and Parker. he was trapped in the book. Emily was described to have been mutilated!!! in a fucking field!!! and when parker died there was no blood! did john take over arthur's body for a brief second? why has arthur never questioned it? how the hell was that possible

when kayne said "anyone who wouldve opened that book and taken what you took wouldve died. they all die." did he mean that?? cause per intermezzo other arthurs manage fine despite not being SpecialTM like our arthur. and WHY were they killed in such different ways??

#also its so. arthur says in s4 that he killed parker. by accident #but then he also kinda blames john for it as per 26 and john never argued with that #john fully takes responsibility for emily's death but HOW was he able to do that. how did he speak to her from the book??#AND when exactly was he in the dark world?? at first i thought he was trapped in the dark world because of being trapped in the book but #if that were the case he wouldnt have been able to talk/kill emily or anyone else for that matter #UNLESS. he was something akin to the vanguard. ?#i dont think we ever get answers for those questions and it feels like the narrative is past these points so im sort of lost on those #if anyone can offer any insight please do #malevolent #niki.rambles #malevolent spoilers

34 notes · View notes