#i'm not a communist either
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
#burn#no I'm not communist but yeah I do hate group projects#oh Eri why am I suddenly thinking of... one particular person xdd#not that this post has anything to do with it but. group projects.
Hey, Melkor was not a communist, that's slander!
Y’all are awfully communist for a bunch of people who hate group projects
#i didn't expect myself to protest about melkor slander but#he was many things but not a communist#he was just evil#without making up excuses#well except maybe “i deserve everything because i'm cooler than you”#[he was not cooler]#[ i mean ok technically “cool” is a form of “cold” so—]#tbh if anyone in arda invented communist revolution it would probably be evil!nienna#everyone else is either too nice or too openly selfish#or at least focused on some exclusive club of “cool people”#well ok maybe some dwarves could invent communism too#see: the thingol situation#not to say thingol was fine#but neither were xix century capitalists#or some modern day capitalists#especially mim seems to have the correct kind of resentment for a revolution#but then he dies#silm#rambling in the tags#i'm not a communist either#but on the compass i am more economical left than right#and yea i don't like group projects
76K notes
·
View notes
Text
The tapeworm in my ear is telling me to play Disco Elysium again for the third time now where I actually go through with the political quests
#I'm thinking of doing either moralist or communist first#Moralist because I think the ending is cool and Commie because I mean well that's what the game is about#Fascism only appeals just to talk with Measurehead and get the Icebreaker pfp but at what cost#I don't want Kim to yell at me for being racist (even if I 110% deserve it)#Ultraliberal sounds lame outside of that one joke of how 99.1% of your money is being taxed and that's why you need the free market#sp-rambles#I also wanna get the honourable cop achievement even if it'll be kinda hellish
13 notes
·
View notes
Note
Noticed your communist thing. Have to ask, have you ever experienced communism? Or perhaps a family member? I am telling you as earnestly and seriously as possible, that it is good on paper, and only so. Capitalism is oppressive, true, but communism is hardly great. Decided to put that out there. Coming from someone whose family has lived in communism. It isn't as edgy and #screwcapitalism as people might think.
Dude imma be honest with you you sound so stupid i didn't even wanna grace this tirade with an answer but
Boo! Equal opportunity and resources for everyone! No hoarding wealth for yourself! Does it scare you? Good. It should. Ur so mad about communism being a thing i can't wait for u to never be able to look away from it being everywhere
#you ppl are so cringey with that “i am from ex communist country” schtick#guess what sherlock holmes I'm from an ex-communist country too#“only good on paper” babe have you noticed that every country that attempts communism is either#bombed to bits#sanctioned by the west until starving#invaded by disgusting americans#orrrr#destroyed from the inside by paid coups#have you noticed that#i would rather live ten thousand years under communism than in this shithole system and you can die mad abt it#asks#commie posting
22 notes
·
View notes
Text
Just got a mail from my MdB (SPD) on why he will vote against the AfD Verbotsprüfung. I know i shouldn't put faith into A. liberal activism and B. the SPD having a spine but the Verbot was my last hope in this system despite knowing it's pitfalls - and now it's gone.
#i'm a fencesitter. i know and fully agree that liberal democracy will always enable fascist powers to rise again#and that i should put energy into communist action instead. the theory checks out.#but i often see takes that would reject any positive change so as not to take away momentum from the revolution and i don't agree with that#since lets be honest there isn't a lot of momentum right now in the first place and even voting is getting more results rn.#and if i were to disengage - what would i do instead. realistically.#either become a dkp karteileiche or get kicked out of the ko (the party one) because i cannot meet the active participation requirements#so i'm not going to dismiss liberal action. i've been writing plenty MdBs about the Verbotsprüfung and enticing others to do the same.#and next i gotta try using my BPD superpowers to manipulate the SPD MdB into feeling really bad and maybe change his mind. Any ideas?#because a reply á la “oh ok then sorry for bothering you” won't cut it. gotta put pressure on.#and he actually read my entire mail and didn't use a template to reply like the cdu wankers did! so chances are he will read my reply.
8 notes
·
View notes
Text
Worst MLP Song Tournament
Please listen to both songs before voting. Remember you’re voting for the WORSE song.
Snips and Snails Rap Propaganda: As if they did not even try
youtube
Derby Racers Propaganda: has one line that gets stuck in my head from time to time but it isn't memorable at all. I could not tell you any other part of the song
youtube
#I'm going to assume the [MLM] in the rap's video title#means that EqG Snips and Snails are canonically dating#either that or they go on to form a communist paramilitary organization#or perhaps a pyramid scheme#my little pony#my little pony friendship is magic#mlp fim#polls on tumblr#tournament polls#mlp music#Worst MLP Song Tournament#Rainbow Rocks#The Cart Before The Ponies#Snips and Snails Rap#Derby Racers#0x7v0x18#Worst MLP Song Round 2
15 notes
·
View notes
Text
¶
#nothing is more depressing than working on my cv#because I just don't feel like I have marketable skills#and so many of the writing and research posts I come across on job sites are like ''you'll be working alongside ai''#I even saw a copywriter post that said ''you won't be doing any writing or editing. you job will be to refine and improve ai prompts#so that the ai can more consistently produce the texts we need''#like hello#the person doing that job is literally making themself more obsolete by the day#so here's the plan#I need to take any job that pays vaguely well#and use that money to either do short corses#or save up to go so my masters#that conclusion is inescapable#just. for now I'm still stuck on step 1 : finding a decent job#and (perhaps I'm being too picky) but post covid I do not want to go back into anything in the tourism industry#it's too precarious and honestly just comes down to entertaining rich people which pushes me further left every time i think about it#I considered joining the communist party. but 1) they're still part of the tripartite alliance with the anc... which is a no from me#and 2) communist révolution should spontaneously happen in industrialised countries with surplus wealth when the proletariat arise#south africa does not have surplus wealth nor class consciousness really. it's still filtered through post apartheid racial groupings#which is unhelpful because the black bourgeoisie are not our allies just because they're black#and trying to impose communism in a society without the surplus wealth didn't work out too well throughout the 20th century#so what does that leave you with#parties like cope ? plagued by the same issues as the anc ? no thank you#(I did also study politics btw which is why I've even considered these career paths)#(although I haven't worked in politics or governance since graduation so maybe that doesn't even matter anymore it's been years)#all I want is a job that pays fairly and leaves me with enough free time to do my hobbies#I do not have the grindset I'll admit that#which is why I've enjoyed the art industry#but again. it just comes down to entertaining rich people in the small galleries which is needlessly stressful#and the larger non-commercial galleries and musea aren't hiring atm...#and that's it. rant over I guess since this is the 30th tag
11 notes
·
View notes
Text
Political rant in tags.
#Honestly sometimes I wonder if pop communism is a psyop#like#Let's take all these people with an energy and desire for change#and tie up that energy in consuming a whole bunch of media that ultimately says the same thing#and becoming obsessed with praxis#and building insular echo chambers#and shitting on anyone who wants to approach things differently#and making communist themed social media identities#and self congratulation#like it's practically the same shit that happened with feminism#and I'm just So Tired#oh and the constant emotional guilt trippy 'arguments' too#Guh I hate online activism so much at this point#I genuinely want to see positive change in the world and so many of the people who express any caring at all#dedicate so much of their energy to pointless bullshit that distracts at best and alienates potential allies at worst#and no I cannot Be The Change I Want To See In The World#I'm a closeted trans woman with chronic fatigue and barely a job at all with no local connections#The nearest place anyone wants to to organize at all is multiple hours away and not only can I not justify burning that much gas#my car has some mystery check engine issue that I cannot get resolved and I can't justify that risk either#and like#with things being as I described#What am I going to do as a single person?#*anime girl screaming while descending into fire*
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
the state of American politics TERRIFIES me because what do you fucking mean you're choosing to THROW AWAY YOUR VOTE in the name of activism when the result will be the other guy winning and the thing you're protesting Getting Worse, along with worse lives for already oppressed people in America. a lot of people are giving away how narrow minded they are right now. I'm sorry, but there is no third option until we rally and fight for one, and no one is fighting. not voting for Biden won't end the genocide. you need to be fighting for Palestinian people, but you need to be able to seperate that from the immediate threat of Trump winning. our system is broken, and we need to start fucking fixing it but that process will not be finished before the election ends, and the election WILL end, and if you don't vote for Biden our president will be Trump. you Can Not Let The Need For Change Distract You From The Present
#joe biden#two party system#hey this animal can talk#but there is currently no other option#and that's not even considering the fact that individual voters have no power anyways#do what you fucking can now#also! I'm trans. if trump wins I'm genuinely terrified that I will lose my access to testosterone. sure#it sounds selfish#people are fucking dying#but America will not stop funding death because you didn't vote for biden#and all we can do is try our best to keep life livable here at the same time#you have to be fucking selfish when it's this dire#trust me i'm basically a communist#i don't want a genocidal liberal dinosaur in office either#leftists
5 notes
·
View notes
Text
Imagine a world where people have actually read Utopia. Or at least know what it's about.
#'this game has a weird fascist central authority masquerading as a communist utopia' my guy. That's what Utopia (1516) is ABOUT#y'all use that word to have positive connotations and it's literally a book about a society that has achieved post-scarcity through#sacrificing individual autonomy.#People living in Utopia cannot even HAVE SEX BEFORE MARRIAGE.#The ruler is prince for life. Slavery is the punishment for every crime.#I'm pretty sure the authorial intent wasn't actually that Utopia was heaven on earth#But either way if modern people actually read the book I'm not sure that we'd think Moore actually intended Utopia to be seen as a good#place
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
Shame I must be so careful about who I follow.
#baltic demon#diary pages#there are too many with brainrot on here#too many fucking communist sympathizers#and I even end up unfollowing people who reblog too many quotes of russian writers or russian things in aesthetic posts#like do you not fucking understand there's a war going on? what that country is doing?#i'm not saying everything russian will always be bad i'm saying the country is commiting war crimes right now where's your fucking tact#do you know nothing of history?#maybe listen to people who do EdUcAtE yOuRsElF ugh I hate that phrase#but WHY when people still don't give up a russian thing it's always Dostoyevsky#that dude was an utter garbage person and his books aren't even that good#why are most people on here either radical left or radical right#the political spectrum is a circle you morons you are closer to each other than anything else you're rubbing butts#i guess that's what happens when you sit in the internet's fucking madhouse you can't expect sanity here
2 notes
·
View notes
Text
apart from a couple things now out of date this is a pretty accurate summary of the crap that's been happening. and it's not just that labour was voted out, it's that a lot of people who would normally be labour supporters didn't turn out to vote.
however, comma, the coalition govt is not doing fascism. a great stew of right wing nastiness for certain - including elements of conservatism, economic liberalism and neoliberalism, libertarianism, populism, nationalism, and deeply reactionary in many ways - but fascism is a specific ideology and this ain't it.
USA please listen to me: the price of “teaching them a lesson” is too high. take it from New Zealand, who voted our Labour government out in the last election because they weren’t doing exactly what we wanted and got facism instead.
Trans rights are being attacked, public transport has been defunded, tax cuts issued for the wealthy, they've mass-defunded public services, cut and attacked the disability funding model, cut benefits, diverted transport funding to roads, cut all recent public transport subsidies, cancelled massive important infrastructure projects like damns and ferries (we are three ISLANDS), fast tracked mining, oil, and other massive environmentally detrimental projects and gave the power the to approve these projects singularly to three ministers who have been wined and dined by lobbyists of the companies that have put the bids in to approve them while one of the main minister infers he will not prioritise the protection of endangered species like the archeys frog over mining projects that do massive environmental harm. They have attacked indigenous rights in an attempt to negate the Treaty of Waitangi by “redefining it”; as a backup, they are also trying to remove all mentions of the treaty from legislation starting with our Child Protection laws no longer requiring social workers to consider the importance of Maori children’s culture when placing those children; when the Waitangi Tribunal who oversees indigenous matters sought to enquire about this, the Minister for Children blocked their enquiry in a breach of comity that was condemned in a ruling — too late to do anything — by our Supreme Court. They have repealed labour protections around pay and 90 day trials, reversed our smoking ban, cancelled our EV subsidy, cancelled our water infrastructure scheme that would have given Maori iwi a say in water asset management, cancelled our biggest city’s fuel tax, made our treasury and inland revenue departments less accountable, dispensed of our Productivity Commission, begun work on charter schools and military boot camps in an obvious push towards privatisation, cancelled grants for first home buyers, reduced access to emergency housing, allowed no cause evictions, cancelled our Maori health system that would have given Maori control over their own public medical care and funding, cut funding of services like budgeting advice and food banks, cancelled the consumer advocacy council, cancelled our medicine regulations, repealed free prescriptions, deferred multiple hospital builds, failed to deliver on pre-election medical promises, reversed a gun ban created in response to the mosque shootings, brought back three strikes = life sentence policy, increased minimum wage by half the recommended amount, cancelled fair pay for disabled workers, reduced wheelchair services, reversed our oil and gas exploration ban, cancelled our climate emergency fund, cut science research funding including climate research, removed limits on killing sea lions, cut funding for the climate change commission, weakened our methane targets, cancelled Significant National Areas protections, have begun reversing our ban on live exports. Much of this was passed under urgency.
It’s been six months.
#not directed at op#this has been building up for a while#calling the coalition government fascist is about as meaningful as calling the last labour govt communist imo#it's not accurate and it's not helpful for either understanding what they're doing or organizing against it#nz stuff#I'm never going to get deeply into current politics on this blog cause this is Not My Space For That for various reasons#am I being deeply picky about the use of one word in an otherwise good post? yes#I am also a historian#I really worry that we are getting to a position where fascism is no longer a term for a specific political ideology#but has come to mean 'right wing politics I dislike'#all history is contemporary history#How to Make Pasta#Ingredients#2cups tomatoes#in addition to their juices (for example#a 28-ounce can of San Marzano whole peeled tomatoes)#5tablespoons butter#1onion#peeled and cut in half#Salt#Preparation#Step 1#Combine the tomatoes#their juices#the butter and the onion halves in a saucepan. Add a pinch or two of salt.#Step 2#Place over medium heat and bring to a simmer. Cook#uncovered#for about 45 minutes. Stir occasionally#mashing any large pieces of tomato with a spoon. Add salt as needed.
18K notes
·
View notes
Text
Every time tumblr/the internet tries to project its politics onto Sweeney Todd and acts like it was some anti-capitalist manifesto, I can only think of Sondheim shrugging and going, "I thought it was about scaring people."
#no Sweeney does not face the audience and specify he's the exact type of communist you are lol#no I don't care about Hal Prince's reading either#I'm saying that this reading is not in Sondheim's actual writing#there are just a few lyrics about people at the top being privileged and greedy#that's about as basic as you can get#the show is not about that lol#still not as bad as reading Bobby from 'Company' as aromantic though#queue
1 note
·
View note
Text
Trying to explain what the fuck just happened in Lankan politics today.
The leftist party has won 159 seats out of 218 in the Parliamentary elections. The single biggest landslide win since we broke from the British and achieved universal franchise in 1948.
Any party achieving a super majority in the executive and legislative is, objectively speaking, bad. It disables checks and balances, which is a catastrophic thing for any democracy, and the only two other times it's happened for us has irrevocably eroded the fabric of civic rights and democratic freedom. Also, the reason the NPP won the North and East is that the colonized, genocided and subjugated people there have no faith in electoralism anymore. The way this government has engaged minority issues has been utterly abysmal and now they've been rewarded for it.
On the other hand:
The winners. Are all. Grassroots. Candidates.¹
We have voted out every single career criminal that's been barnacled into the Lankan political arena since before I've been alive. The fascist party has only three seats.² The other fascists didn't win a single seat. The neoliberal legacy party won none. There are only forty people in Parliament that represent any sort of dynastic political legacy. After 76 solid years of nothing but political dynasties.
This is barely five years after the Rajapaksas swept in and absolutely glutted the Parliament with their family members and cronies end to end.
This is the illegitimate interim government we had for most of the last 18 months. We literally, physically, chased the Rajapaksas out of the country and this fucking demon set up a puppet government just so he could finally sit in that goddamn chair and be the despot he'd always dreamed of in exchange for letting them all come back. He's now gone. His entire circle is gone.
THEY ARE ALL FUCKING GONE.
In US terms, just imagine that, five years from now, when Trump's GOP has control of everything, the entire GOP and the worst of the Dems are all purged from Congress and Senate, the Green Party in control of all three branches of government under a pro-union left-wing President and an unmarried female LGBT rights activist Vice President, and the Dems reduced to barely 20% of the House.
This is my anthropology professor. She joined politics from the small nascent leftist coalition to help keep the government accountable. She's now the Prime Minister and the most popular Parliamentary candidate in the nation's history. (Edit: She was knocked off first place by a dude in the final result. Boo.)
(On the other hand— the woman who helped make me a radical anarchist and literally helped write a book on political dissent and resistance...now is the state. Uh.)
But there are so many women in Parliament! We had the lowest female representation in a South Asian Parliament and some of them were from the list of seats reserved for parties rather than elected ones. Most were either anti-feminist conservative embarrassments, widows and daughters of elite politicians and neoliberal shills. It's still only an increase of a few percentage points (Edit: from the previous 5% to 10% in the final result!) but now we have elected academics, feminist advocates, activists! There Is a representative for Malaiyaha Tamils in the Central Province for the first time in history and it's a young woman! (Edit: now it's two female Malaiyaha MPS!!) This is the plantation community that still live in conditions closest to the slavery the British forced upon them two hundred years ago!
I'm like. Completely mindfucked. To be very very clear, the NPP coalition formed around the nucleus of the JVP that used to be communist but haven't been in 30 years, they're now just social democrats who are left of places like the US and UK, whose "left" is now center-right. They're only threatening to the Western mainstream media for some reason who can't stop bleating about how we have a "Marxist" government now. In reality, the actual chances for radical reform are still quite low, and the opportunity for further erosion is quite high with a super majority government regardless of affiliation.
On the other hand:
What the fuck.
Sometimes living through historical events is really damn amazing.
---
¹ Well, nearly. There are a few career politicians and a nepo baby but they aren't so bad either.
² Goddamn it, Baby Rajapaksa and Sri Lanka's answer to JD Vance have wormed their way in using the list of Constitutionally reserved party seats for non-elected members. FUCK the National List.
#five years ago i was working a news desk watching a band of violent ethnofascists known for genocide torture kidnappings and murder sweep in#and take control of the entire country#on the heels of the worst terrorist attack we've suffered that they orchestrated for this purpose#wondering how many of our colleagues would be safe#and watching the people that opposed them flee the country#i cannot tell you the enraging hopeless terror#and now#they're all gone#THEY'RE FUCKING GONE#sri lanka politics#sri lanka news#sri lanka protests#sri lankan parliamentary elections#sri lanka election 2024#anura kumara dissanayake#harini amarasuriya#feminism#leftism#world news#faith in humanity#power to the people#aragalaya#knee of huss#අරගලයට ජය!#අරගලයට ජය
4K notes
·
View notes
Text
Kim's itchy trigger finger
So, Kim reaches for his gun often. Very often. sometimes for the most ridiculous reasons- opening the bear fridge, the experiment in the church, a note from Klaasje.
This one is just from being anxious going into the communist reading group. Kim doesn't want to be the kind of cop who draws his gun constantly, who shoots instinctively, but he is, or at the very least it's very difficult for him to stop himself from becoming one.
Perhaps the most horrifying example is with The Pigs-
Even if he KNOWS the gun isn't loaded, even if he knows it's safe, the instinctual muscle twitch could have ended in an unnecessary death. Kim is very well aware of that fact, and it's horrifying to him. @shufflerock-jam has this really good post about it, where they wonder how many of Kim's kills were unnecessary. "Something about a pair of traumatized cops, one fighting against shooting himself and one fighting against shooting everyone else".
At the end of The Pigs exchange, if Harry says she tried to kill him, Kim begins to interject, but stops himself and agree this situation could've been very bad. Then Empathy chimes in- 'He's trying not to think about how bad it could have been had the gun been loaded.' Which is the heart of the issue, right? that leads us to Eyes-
This is such a fascinating background to give Kim as a character- not just losing his partner, which gives him the trauma and survivor's guilt that lead to this unhealthy relationship with his gun and frankly with death in general, but losing his Eyes, and having that not interfere with his shooting. Kim doesn't need to see well to hit, he doesn't need to think. It's all in his hands, a reflex. A reflex that nearly took an innocent life. That might have taken one before.
His awareness of looming danger, to him and to his partner, is fueling his version of Hand/Eye Coordination to have him constantly on edge, his whole body is like a loaded spring, always prepared to make sure it doesn't happen again. Then it does-
In his nightmare scenario, leaning over his partner's bleeding body, Kim only needs one word to shoot without a second's hesitation. He's never not ready to take that shot. He doesn't need his Eyes.
Harry is distraught to discover he's killed before- his body remembers it. He wants a drink to soften the feeling. Kim however is impressed with how little he's killed- especially coming from the bloody murder unit. He wants to be 'one of the good ones' (Kim's adamant belief in the possibility of a Good Cop is a whole other can of worms) the kind of cop he would think highly of. Kim is disgusted by cops who kill like it's a game. Espirit gives us a vision of a cop exactly like that, who kills so often it doesn't feel like anything anymore. In a way that is completely mechanical- no thought, no feelings, just a thing your body does. Not unlike the way Kim shoots- like a spring unloaded. Kim has 6 confirmed kills before the tribunal, double the amount Harry has. He doesn't react the same way though-
It's doesn't bother Kim that he has killed, even if he declines to elaborate on it, and he seems to frown upon (or worry about) Harry's destructive coping mechanism. If they're unable to save Ruby, he says "Control your emotions. We did our job. This won't be the worst thing that happens on this case… believe me. You can't let this break you." When you wake up after the tribunal, he doesn't dwell on the lost lives on either side. Harry's skills call him a killer, a bloodstained killer, but when he tells Kim he also killed he simply nods. He's smoking though. I'm not saying that Kim is heartless or careless, he's rattled by nearly blowing The Pigs' head off, very sorry for the lives lost during the case, and clearly hunted by death, having been surrounded by it for his entire life. But I do think death is a part of the job for him- not just possible civilian causalities, but his own potential death. He speaks plainly about how he might die in the lie of duty, and he narrowly avoided it more than once, with others dying in his place..
He walked into the line of fire with harry expecting for of them to die, and his quick fingers on the trigger made it so they lived another day. Even if more ghost joined the list that hunts him in his sleep, he is alive. He goes on. He can't afford to fix this habit, as much as he wants to.
So it's so horrible and so touching that when Dros asks "What have you done?" Kim says-
It's a tragedy, really. A wartime orphan who wanted to be a revolutionary pilot and played with Franconigerian knights, who grew up to be a cop, a job that slowly shapes his body into a killing machine. And when you ask what he does, what you both do, he says keep people alive.
#disco elysium#kim kitsuragi#harry du bois#disco Elysium meta#de#de analysis#de meta#this is so long and i'm sure it's been done a dozen times before but i'm new here and i can't stop thinking about it#goddamn this game#🏺#juha.txt
1K notes
·
View notes
Note
unless you're gonna grab a gun yourself and start this so-called "revolution", your politics and activism are performative. shut the fuck up and vote, and then spend the next 4 years actually doing something to change the system rather than whining about it online. grow up
As a communist, I'm entirely fine with the notion of engaging, myself, in revolutionary war for the sake of the people, there's no hypocrisy there.
Revolution is not something I just personally wish to happen, neither is it something communists as a whole are necessarily the driving force of - revolution is an inevitability, given the collapse of the existing system into economic, political, and environmental crisis. World war is on the horizon, and the consumate repression and deprivation of all peoples international and domestic that comes with it means that civil unrest, insurrection, and revolution are an inevitability. WW1 ended with the creation of the first socialist state, WW2 ended with the emergence of a global socialist bloc, and a third world war (which is as clearly on the horizon as the first world war was, as the imperialist states are forced by waning profits to aggress upon both competitors and their own allies for gains) will only end in either revolution in the imperial core, or the annihilation of humanity.
Said war, crisis, and revolution are imminent, but not yet upon us. Revolution is not something initiated by communists in a time of peace (which is why all the 'what about hospitals bwuh bwuh' takes are moronic), it is a mass popular response to unimaginable poverty and violence, which communists take up a leading role in. The current task is to build up the networks and political organs to establish a mass base among the people, represent their genuine interests, and be ready to lead them in not just class struggle, but open class warfare. The electoral system of another class, of an enemy class is completely irrelevant to any sort of proletarian political action.
I live in the People's Republic of China.
1K notes
·
View notes
Note
"you, specifically, are a bad and evil person that all my posts are written to condemn" this is not what i said. i'm sorry for not being clearer. i just feel like everyone in this space, not just you, look down on people who live in the first world as people who willingly don't change anything about how the world works when it's just not that simple. i know you all love to combat this and say otherwise but it will never change the simple reality that for some people it really is very hard, if not impossible, to do anything politically, for a variety of reasons. i'm disabled, i live in a remote part of the country, and i'm bad at talking to people. i don't have the money to just move to a population center or get lessons on how to speak to people. i can't do anything and i feel like every time you or one of the other communists on tumblr talks about the imperial core, i feel like i, personally, am being held to an unreasonable standard that i would not hold anyone else to, if i were in one of your situations. obviously i want things to change. i don't want genocide to be a thing that's constantly happening, i don't want my country to have its tendrils dug into every other country, i want socialism and eventually global communism, and if i could do anything meaningful-- anything at all-- to achieve those goals i would be working on that. but right now that just is not the case for me, and i feel like i'm not alone in that either. i just wish you had like a smidgen of empathy for some of the people living here who don't fit into your stereotype of what a member of the imperial core looks like-- i'm not even trying to say that sarcastically, it genuinely feels like you all don't see us as human. like nyanguard especially seems to think of us as incapable of saving ourselves, and one of the reblogs to my first ask just said they "like to imagine that (i'm) crying as i type this". how am i supposed to react to that? is this how all of you feel about people like me? would your feelings about me change if i lived in another country, or would you find some other excuse to talk down to me? is it really just the country i live in that's the problem, here? i'm not trying to accuse you, i'm asking this question genuinely.
i know it's tempting to respond to this with a snarky comment but please just try to understand where i am coming from. i really am willing to help if i can.
i don't think any marxist seriously has a political theory of imperialism that amounts to "citizens of the imperial core simply choose not to do anything because they are all individually bad people". i mean the whole point of marxism is that economic relations are the ultimate drivers of historical change, not abstract psychological or moral qualities of people.
i'm sympathetic to your situation! the imperial core is a very atomizing place to live, and there are places and situations where there's just no practical path to getting organized and taking meaningful political action in the near future. however, your problem here is:
i feel like i, personally, am being held to an unreasonable standard that i would not hold anyone else to
nobody is posting about you, personally. like at the end of the day you have to learn to either not take posts like that personally or just block everyone who makes them to manage your own time on the computer vis a vis niceness--i don't think it's the responsibility of me or any other communist to constantly provide asterisks and carveouts that we're not talking about the Good Ones Who Have Extenuating Circumstances when we talk about the usa and its material political base.
& in the same way that you ask for empathy for your situation i would ask you to extend a level of understanding to people whose homelands and countrymen and communities have been devastated by US coups and sanctions and invasions, that they have as much a right to express the rage and fury and hurt of that cultural legacy as you do to express your own sadness about your own situation. imagine, for example, how you would feel if your grandparents could not reliably get medicine because of us sanctions. & of course the correct target for these feelings are not random usamericans--but these posts are also not serious politcal platforms, they are venting from people who live their lives under the weight of empire.
if you think what they're saying is unfair to you, then you need to develop the ability to say 'well, i understand why they would feel that way' and move on. like i understand why you are upset, and i don't say this to be dismissive, but as real advice: it is not fair (especially to bloggers from the global south) to essentially rest your happiness and self-worth at their feet and demand that they validate you.
genuinely, i hope this helps. it's all i really have to say on the matter.
680 notes
·
View notes