#i just got to the part where eliot crowns alice
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
MAKE ELIOT AND ALICE GO ON HEALING ADVENTURES TOGETHER
#i just got to the part where eliot crowns alice#and as much as eliot and margo are bffaeae eliot and alice have this other bond of sadness in them#i just...#*ugly sobbing* my poor tragic romantic babies#the magicians annual watchthrough
7 notes
·
View notes
Text
personal theory for the magicians season four (keeping in mind that I know fuck all about TV writing in general / writing on the magicians in particular) is that season four got a complete rewrite at some point (obviously because of jralph leaving, and also I agree with the theory that they likely couldn’t get the actor for Irene McAllistair back) where the first few eps had probably already been generally planned out which is why they leave in the mcallistairs at the beginning and then never mention them again, and also why there is a very strong sense (to me) that, since they had to write Quentin out of the show, the show-runners planned out the series of events in the final few episodes that lead to the finale and Quentin’s death in the mirror world (in a scenario that is purposefully(?) and weirdly reminiscent of the climactic scene in the first Harry Potter movie, why why??) because they knew that’s what the whole season had to be leading to - and then went, okay, everything in the middle just has be filled in. By something. I guess. and some of the stuff in the middle is really good! and works!
I love everything they do with Alice, I would love Kady’s plotline with the hedges if a little more had happened with it, the dragon egg episode was fun and a nice break from the tension, Penny40′s part about not assuming who is the important in the story was good (although in retrospect felt extremely disingenuous and part of the original spin of ��actually Quentin’s death is subversive’). but so little of it is tied in with the main plotlines of the monster and the library in any way that matters. the most hilarious example of this is the episode where the library starts IMPLANTING PEOPLE WITH WORMS THAT KILL YOU IF YOU DO MAGIC. This should be something really terrifying and interesting and impactful! and it literally has no impact on the plot going forward or any of the main characters. Pete gets attacked, but Pete is a secondary character that even Kady only seems to slightly care about, and it barely gets mentioned again. The whole purpose of this plot point is to show that the library and specifically Everett are Bad, so that Zelda is willing to turn against them. The Monster is such a significant character for the entire season, but his story ends with a whimper, no narrative pay-off, and so there’s the sense that he basically exists to show off Hale Appleman’s acting and provide a problem to be solved and to send Quentin spiralling. This is also a similar problem with Margo’s plotlines - Margo gets awesome stuff this season! but since Eliot is out of the picture and the Fairy Queen is dead, she’s got no one to narratively bounce off of in Fillory except Josh and Fen, who are basically cyphers this season. What does Josh want, except for Margo to be his girlfriend and not be mean to him? Who knows? The episode that they could have showed us something about Josh (the werewolf one where he and Margo get together) tells us that Josh isn’t willing to murder or rape someone to survive, which is nice? But also a really low bar that we’d expect any of the main cast to clear. It tells us very little about Josh - the point of the episode is Margo sacrificing for him. The same with Fen - what does Fen want, what does she feel about Margo, about being High King, about Margo being High King? She seems basically okay with all of it, I guess. is all we get, because again the point is Margo sacrificing her crown for Eliot. Which I love for Margo, but it’s weird that she has to spend a whole season acting off of the blank spaces that should be Josh and Fen’s characters, ESPECIALLY when we get the damn goldfish scene, where it’s like, okay, I understand that Margo is awesome and Margo sacrifices for people and this is how she shows it, and she shows that she really cares about Josh, but. Why do WE care about Josh, again? Same problem with the episode with Penny23, Marina and the time-line shifting - like, it’s a cool concept, and they wanted to bring in Stoppard from the book, and Marina’s always fun, but what’s the point? Penny23 and Penny40 have their chat, but that could have been written in a million ways. Marina’s actor was signed for four episodes and they really didn’t know what to do with Penny23 other than indicate that he’s much more willing to sacrifice people (ie. Quentin) than the OG Penny, if necessary? Okay, fine, I guess? We couldn’t have gotten that out of a more narratively significant episode?
anyway, I know the Magicians’ strong suite has never been plotting, and mostly I’m fine with that, it just stands out really noticeably this season. they have all the main domino falling events happen in the last few episodes so that they can have Quentin and Alice getting back together, the scene with Quentin and the flower to call back to the book, and then leading to the monsters and the library both causing the final mirror world death scene, but it leaves this strange space in the middle of the season in which lots of things just seem to happen, some interesting and theme-and-character-developing and some only confusingly irrelevant to either the story or the characters.
#the magicians#the magicians season four#the magicians meta#the magicians negativity#the magicians salt#the magicians season four spoilers
13 notes
·
View notes
Text
and what's worst I enjoyed season 5.
I enjoyed Margo and Eliot, I enjoyed dark king, I kinda enjoyed him with Eliot, I enjoyed the twist in the end (and no, I didn't see that comming), it wasn't all bad
I didn't even mind Charlton
and unpopular opinion I didn't even miss Q and the show could hold on its own very nicely even without him, it's still so much fun, and I might like it even more without him
hell, I even enjoyed the last ep, honestly the parts with Seb and Eliot were so good, and the time loop thing being done from other side was surprising and nice touch, and I really really like the last shot at Margo pushing the button
I liked it, except for the obvious - Eliot at the end and Margo going to the center of Fillory alone, which okay. I can't really see Eliot letting her go like that but let's write it off to him being too broken at this point to protest. but like. we don't really get to see their renuion. she's his best friend in the whole damn world and he thought she went to her death to save him (sounds familiar, doesn't it) and honestly if they showed us one desperate hug when she gets back it would make it so much better and satisfying
I still love this damn show though
sure, they put too much in too short time, and overall it'd be better if that much plot was in at least 2 seasons instead of one, they didn't give Eliot time to mourn, we had that Eliot/Alice episode but after that bam! he's moved on, only Alice is allowed to grieve now
they did lot of shitty things that I just can't see characters doing
and I could forgive everything but I just can't forgive what they did to Eliot in the end
they just looked at that wonderful amazing character that's been through hell and went 'you know what this boy needs?? more trauma and heartbreak and PAIN'
because fuck him, that's why and fuck us more, I guess
if magic comes from pain he should be the most powerfull magician now, damn it
if there was another season, I guess I'd be like whatever (eyeroll) but they knew, they fucking knew there was possibility of cancellation and still did that
and honestly fuck them for that
they were even openly talking (I checked now) about how they wrote it with it being show finale in mind
like. they didn't even had to do lot to give him okayish ending. they didn't even do the bare minimum
and. they are proud of it
they are fucking proud of it
tell me one reason, why they couldn't show him standing behind Margo in new Fillory smiling
like why
that's what I wanted, at least one shot showing he's okay and relatively happy with his best friend, maybe even celebrating oh, you know, that he helped to SAVE WHOLE FUCKING WORLD AGAIN
and that's it, the simple mercy, one shot showing he's fine, pretty please
honestly, he deserved so much better. I haven't loved character as much as I love Eliot in a long long time.
it's not... it's not fair. why is Alice, Alice of all of them, allowed to be in new Fillory and have her bacon when, when she got handed her crown, she promptly went like nah, not my problem
Josh has his pizza, Fen knives, Margo I guess... opium? and Eliot? more heartbreak
like why wasn't Eliot allowed the same they were? couldn't they give him like idk champagne lake or something? it was his home as much as it was theirs. and he deserved to make new Fillory also his own. they did him incredibly dirty
why couldn't we see him off happy, just whyyy
whatever their plans for next season were, it wouldn't affect them, this is the magicians we're talking about, they could use whatever wacky trick they wanted to get him where they need him for plot reasons after
and what they gave us instead.
and they are fucking proud of it.
"And so we thought that it would be an interesting challenge to really look at the ways he's grown and the hard lessons that he's learned and whether he would be ready for something like this and have moved past some of the damage of his earlier life by the finale." x
no. the answer is no. he hasn't moved, he's clearly miserable again, trying so damn hard to hold it together, the way he was trying in earlier seasons
he's not better, he's alone, abandoned (and why the fuck they keep doing this to him - first in Fillory, now on Earth), he's not really friends with Kady, Julia or Penny, his close friends are gone and you call that satisfying ending?
like look at him when he tells Charlton to keep drinking
it's not him moving on. it's him just surviving. and it sucks
and the fact they made him into teacher? him? him? can you really see him being happy as a teacher?? 'cause I can't. just can't. they should have just swapped his place with alice. she'd be fine with teaching, it would make lot more sense and it would be actually good ending, or at least better than what they gave us. seriously, there are so many little things they could have done, that would affect nothing, absolutely zero, nada! except honouring his character better and giving him less shitty ending.
hell, Eliot's almost where he was in the beginning, maybe even worse because he doesn't even have Margo now. he lost so. damn. much.
and what. they throw Charlton at him and call it a day? again, I have nothing against Charlton, I kinda like the guy and I could get behind them - honestly I could get behind Eliot/anyone as long as he's happy and it makes little bit of sense - and with Charlton they could work - except:
we haven't seen them to put that work and time in and-
the timing is so exceptionally bad - he just lost his closest friends, Charlton, he had to blew up the planet he ruled for a great part of his life (that he admitted he loved), and the guy he cared about for the most of the season, the very reason they had to destroy the planet in a first place, you know the one he very much liked and cared about is probably dead and oh, he just asked you about him so he's clearly still pinning and mourning
honestly, what was that.
he isn't ecstatic about the prospect. Charlton's just. the consolation prize. and it's sad. it's seen in the way that it's Charlton who proposes him, it's not something Eliot actively wants
it's...it's Eliot settling, it's Eliot going 'whatever, why the hell not, nothing to lose now', it's sad casual pitty fuck with bit of curiosity sprinkled over, that Eliot's not even that much into - which bugs me the most - and if the show continued I can really see it not being mentioned ever again other than for a throw away line like 'yeah Margo, we banged, what of it'
and it's insulting. to the both characters. because they could be so much more.
because it's almost like Eliot's going back to his superficial lifestyle of sex, drugs, denial and magic and that's where we found him in the beginnig
he's.. he's the same character, equally broken, just in diffrent way now. and probaly hurting even worse. and I can't forgive them because he was getting better and they again crushed his shot at happiness.
#26ja watches the magicians#the magicians#spoilers#eliot waugh#magician spoilers#season 5#it's not fair#I could leave everyone where they are at the end and be kinda ok about it but not Eliot#not him#I want more seasons just to fix his ending#rant#love the show though#i'll never find show like the magicians#it had everything#and I haven't fallen for a charcter as hard as I have for Eliot in a long long time#Eliot deserved better
13 notes
·
View notes
Text
Masterpost of TMA Big Bang 2020 Fics
To prevent clogging up anyone’s dash, we have put all of these fics under a read more since there are 28 wonderful fics created for this bang, which makes for a bit of a long post! Below the cut are links and summaries to all the fics created for this bang!
In addition to this post, you can also check out our fic page (which you can find here)! The fic page includes links to all the fics, art, and the team members that helped create them! You can also use some basic filters for rating and oneshot/multichapter to find fics.
Thank you again to all our participants, and we will see you next year!
Your Job’s A Joke (You’re Broke) by @bisexualoftheblade and @desert-lily
Ao3: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27590578
Summary: Working at the Magnus Institute was stressful by default. With monsters, mayhem, and potential primordial entities, it has very little expectations for being a comfortable job. However, everyone is allowed to have a little fun sometimes - even an archivist, their assistants, and their really creepy boss. Fueled by spite and a rampant lack of heterosexuality, they all try to balance their work life with a bit of fun and a healthy dose of bullying twelve-times divorced Elias Bouchard.
I Know The End by @williammatagot
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27947966
Summary: Except, for all that beautiful poetry, Eliot was wrong, because the world doesn’t end with a bang, sure, but it doesn’t end with a whimper, either. It ends with the distant-yet-deafening voice of the man Martin loves shouting through a ragged, wild throat--I open the door. (The world ends, Jon shatters, and Martin tries to fix it. The house tries, too, in its own way.)
From the Depth of the Spiral by @trickstergod14
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27842941
Summary: Michael had no idea what was going on. He suddenly woke up in the tunnels under the Magnus Institute with no memories of the past seven years after that fateful trip to Sannikov Land. Watch as he slowly spirals into madness, regaining his memories while strengthening his bond with the Distortion along the way. Can he hide all this from the other Archival Assistants? What will happen when Jon wakes up from his coma? And what does the newly crowned Distortion Avatar, Helen, have to do with all this?
Every Word I Say is Kindling (But The Smoke Clears When You’re Around) by @ohnoimdeathing
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27956897
Summary: The unknowing left Jon stirring in the nightmares of others, watching their torment and suffering and making everything worse. He wanted to wake up, to go back to Martin, Tim, Basira, even Daisy. But he didn’t know how to. Until a voice told him to choose Though, to be honest, he doesn’t remember actually making the choice to stay a monster and live rather than be human and die. The only injury the doctors will talk about is his missing eyes, and why are all the doctors Scottish? At least Martin is here.
Spinning ‘Round (like two sides of a coin) by @awayofunderstandingit
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27835756
Summary: Time is a construct. What we know as past, present, and future all exist at the same time, ad infinitum. �� Guided not by time but a spoken word poem, follow along the lives of two intertwined souls, Timothy Stoker and Sasha James. The story of their friendship from the time they meet, through growing apart, to when they fall back together, and through their time working at the Magnus Institute. Witness slices of their lives—not memories, memories would suggest the past—as they exist, ad infinitum, even at The End.
retrouvailles by @jet-siquliak
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27818092
Summary: The Magnus Institute burns. The archivist, for all intents and purposes, burned with it. In a dingy hospital room lies what remains - Jonathan sims. weak, powerless, and insignificant. On Jon’s last day in the hospital, Martin awakes from a coma, unscathed. Melanie King kicks the dirt that once housed the institute. Tim stoker wakes up in the middle of nowhere. Elias Bouchard is dead. No one knows where to go from there. Or: the destruction of one home and the making of another.
Still, I’ll Always Keep the Memory by @revolutionnaire-e
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27932125
Summary: [MARTIN turns, stepping out of the shadows towards him. It is blood, not tears. His left eye is not his own. His eyes never shone that blinding green, never shone with such malice or self-satisfied pride.] MARTIN BLACKWOOD Pleasure to see you again, Archivist.
Making Home by @cuddlytogas
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27664805
Summary: After the events in the Panopticon, Jon and Martin rush to leave London. But making their home in an idyllic safe house isn't that easy: between the layer of dust, and Forsaken still clinging to Martin's heels, it could be some time before they reach an understanding.
called your name ‘til the fever broke by @corpsesoldier
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27845161
Summary: Basira made a promise to her partner. At the end of the world, a monster comes and demands she keep it.
assorted family photos by @lesbianbirds
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27903979
Summary: When setting off on a research trip, it is advised that you prepare yourself for certain oddities that may greet you. or; key moments in a world where the entities are weaker and everyone got a bit more therapy
Timothy Stoker’s Guide to Dating by @pezilla
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27841267
Summary: Timothy Stoker has a lot of advice when it comes to matters of the heart, online agony aunt, gossip monger and general love guru. He has a list and he sticks to it. Or he did. That was before he took a job at the Magnus Institute and before he met three of the most fascinating and frustrating people to ever come into his life. Rule #7 under no circumstances fall for a co-worker. Yeah, that rule was starting to become a problem.
Running the Institute by @drowsy-salamander
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27878306
Summary: Caroline Ferguson, the entirety of the Magnus Institute's legal department, is furiously ignoring any weirdness that could be going on in her workplace, from the tech issues to the vanishing colleagues to the everything about Artefact Storage, Caroline will turn a very deliberate blind eye. They're are not her problem. Now if only those murders could also stop.
kindred spirits (not so scarce as I used to think) by @pollylittlehigher-littlelower
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27914821
Summary: An Anne of Green Gables inspired AU, set in modern day England. Jon and Georgie are childhood best friends, but the two stop talking after a falling out. Even doing their best to avoid each other, Georgie struggles to escape him, even while dealing with her own mental health issues and a blossoming romance with her housemate, Melanie. Is Jon truly the kindred spirit she once considered him? Or will the two eventually part ways for good?
Friends of Empty Graves by @artswaps
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27974807
Summary: After the coffin, she cuts her hair. Who is Alice Tonner? People are searching for her in the space she left behind, in the person she was. Daisy looks elsewhere, and tries not to choke.
just let the feeling grow by @ajkal2
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27838447
Summary: Jon is a musician. He plays songs for a living. Except love songs. He doesn't do love songs, and he makes this quite clear with anyone interested in working with him. Except his manager has booked him for a wedding. Without asking. With days before the festivities start, Jon needs help. Desperately. He won't get it from his hosts, the Lukas family. He certainly won't get it from his manager. However, there's a certain amateur poet on the Lukas' staff who has a talent for making love sound genuine.
World Cold and Hard, Moth Boy Warm and Soft by @lcjenkinswriting
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27827491
Summary: Jon, a young moth fairy, leaves the nest in search of a place that feels like home
tapes winding forward by @ghostbustermelanieking
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27858721
Summary: Martin ignores him, stops him mid-sentence to say, "Jon, what have you heard about time travel?" --- Martin and Jon wake up two years in the future. It goes about as well as can be expected.
MAG 26.5: Beach Episode by @ebenrosetaylor
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27882746
Summary: Sasha is aware of the rising tensions in the archives after Martin was stalked by Prentiss and after she had her own encounter with Michael. In an attempt to boost morale and bring them closer together, Tim suggests that they all visit the beach to unwind and get their minds off of all things paranormal. Sasha takes it upon herself to make sure that everyone has fun and relaxes, but she forgets to give herself that luxury.
Rewrite The Rulebook by @radiosandrecordings
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27823774
Summary: "Panic! Bloody panic! I've been out since I was fifteen and never once actually brought someone home. I think I just wanted to seem like I had my life together, y’know? Mainly I just... I think I just wanted someone to be there with me, so I wasn't just alone with her the entire time. A bit of comfort.” There was pause as Martin let out a dramatic sigh, seemingly relieved to ramble out his thoughts. "... I could go with you. If you want."
A Test In Patience by @talking4the1
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27917749
Summary: Elias is going about his day as the new head of the Magnus Institute in 1995. Some spreadsheets to do, meetings to attend mundane and supernatural. Nothing seems out of place until The Eye calls him to Bournemouth.
Of Mothers and Memory by @loverdontleave
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27856585
Summary: There is a story to be told, of two people, a mother and a son. Of their history together, and the sacrifices they made for each other. Perhaps they loved each other once, but that thread of connection has weakened on one end, fraying away. And it is so, so cold.
Would That I Were Golden Dust by @that-one-girl-behind-you
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27734197
Summary: The world is a lot more dangerous with your soul walking by your side, and Entities aren’t shy about feeding on golden Dust.
Till Death, Parted by @bigowlenergy
Ao3 Link:https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27749680
Summary: Jon gets caught after ripping out Gerry’s page by Trevor & Julia, and through a comedy of errors ends up engaged as an excuse. Somehow, Jon gets out alive, Gerry is freed, and they have the two hunters accompanying them as bodyguards - and as best man and best woman - without a fight. Living alone in Gerry’s London safe house afterwards will be totally fine. Jon is fine. He knows what coping is and everything! Totally fine.
The Spoken Word by @drumkonwords
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/works/27802708/chapters/68066326
Summary: Jon wants. Their pinky twitches — stretching and curling to the tune of something musical. The song of wanting, with its motifs of long, low notes. Starting quiet and mumbling up into Jon’s chest until the strings of their heart vibrate like the strings of a double bass and all they can do is wonder who’s tune they’re matching. But they know.
First Aid by @platypik
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27948284
Summary: Jon is certain Martin has been acting strangely all morning. When Martin offhandedly mentions he took a bad tumble off the tube to work, Jon suddenly Knows that the fall had given Martin a nasty fracture. Despite his desperate pleading, Martin stubbornly refuses to let Jon drive him to the hospital. In fact, it seems he would much rather take care of it himself than have Jon worry and fuss over him. Jon would disagree.
Burning Bright, In the Forests of the Night by @triffidsandcuckoos
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27915400
Summary: The safehouse bursts into flames at their backs. You can choose to change the path. Just be ready for what else you might change.
i’ve been static for too long by @furryjefferson
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27887878
Summary: Jonathan Sims ends up with a stranger’s phone on the way home from work. All signs point to the Magnus Institute, and all roads lead to its mysterious archivist: Martin Blackwood.
through the clouds like a moonbeam by @digital-waterfall
Ao3 Link: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/tmabb20/works/27877402
Summary: After passing through the Vast’s domain, Jon is left with an unexpected surprise-- a pair of wings. Unsurprisingly, Martin finds them beautiful. Also unsurprisingly, Jon does not.
80 notes
·
View notes
Text
Getting back up
*Quick notes: This is in no way, shape or form related or compliant to season 5. Because I have not and will not watch season 5. You cannot take away my favorite character and destroy my favorite ship with it, and then expect me to keep watching your show, you meanie showrunners.*
This might be something that I will occasionally work on. It’s all thought out and finished in my head, so the only question is how well I will be able to put it into words. This is pretty much a teaser chapter, which I will expand on at a later date, when I have more time. English is not my first language, and I am not as eloquent or articulate as so many of the other talented writer I have had the pleasure to discover in this fandom. Alas, the plot bunny has gotten lost in my head, and now I have to write this thing out. I sincerely do hope that someone might find some enjoyment out of this fic, when it’s finished, but I caution anyone to not expect too much. It will likely be very slow going, and not as well written as it could be. :-)
It’s also entirely self-indulgent. I don’t want Quentin to stay dead. I want Queliot to happen. I want these people to all be actual friends who love and trust each other. So these are all things that I will be working towards, even though it might not always correspond well with the canon that has been established in the four seasons leading up to Quentin’s death.
Summary/teaser:
“Did I do something really brave to save my friends, or did I finally find a way to kill myself?”
- As Quentin gets the answer to this last important question, he also learns that his friends are still in need of saving.
Funnily enough, even though Quentin had spent literal years worth of time thinking about death (most specifically his own), he had never really pictured his funeral.
And, well, technically this might not qualify as a funeral, Quentin thought as he watched his friends sing and feed simple but significant trinkets into the fire, it was indubitably more beautiful than anything his broken brain could have ever cooked up.
Dean Fogg’s presence had surprised him a little, to be perfectly honest, but he certainly appreciated it.
Penny had taken him to Fillory first, where Josh and Fen had set up a memorial feast in his honor.
In memory of King Quentin Coldwater, savior of Fillory, magic, and the world.
Quentin felt unworthy of the title. After all, he hadn’t ever really handled any kingly duties the way Margo and Eliot had, and he hadn’t been the only one fighting to save all those things they were celebrating him for. But non the less, seeing as a whole kingdom raised their (metaphorical) glasses to him, as well as Josh and Fen’s honest tears, had filled his heart with warmth.
Then getting back to earth, watching the people he had come to love in each of their own specific ways, watching as Eliot and Margo had made their way into the circle, and god ELIOT! The tall man was leaning on Margo heavily, stumbling ever so slightly, face pale, clearly still hurt, still healing.
But in this very moment, he was the most beautiful being Quentin had ever seen. Alive.
Eliot was alive. They had done it. It had all been worth it.
Eliot was alive.
Thank god
Thank god
Thank god
Eliot was alive and on his feet. Quentin was unashamed of the tears that streamed down his face.
Margo, Alice, Julia, Penny23, Kady, Josh, Fen. They were okay. Sad, sure. Grieving, crying, for him, and this was still a concept that was somehow so hard for him to grasp, yet filled his heart with so much affection for each and every one of them.
But they were alive and whole and in time, they would heal.
He felt at peace.
“They are gonna be okay, right?”
The question was more of an after thought, murmured in Penny’s direction. And Quentin fully expected Penny to smile in that soft, knowing way of his (which was still so new and strange to Quentin, but somehow, fit the other man perfectly), and tell him not to worry, that their friends would be just fine.
But when no answer came forth, Quentin forced his eyes away from the group sitting around the fire to look back at his friend, and found an expression he had trouble deciphering.
“I was really hoping you wouldn’t ask me this, Q.”
The shock of those words, as well as the use of that nickname (Penny had changed so much. And the weirdest part of that was how Quentin still thought of him as the same person. As part of the team. Always one of them), made him turn around fully.
“What do you mean? They.. they will be alright, right?” Anxiety was building up. “We. - We got the monsters out. Julia and El- Eliot, they are .. we saved them. We did it! Everett is gone, and, and you said the library is in better hands now! Magic will return back to the way it was. Why-” He had to pause to get rid of the lump that was forming in his throat, threatening to strangle him. The song behind him was coming to an end and he turned his head to cast another look at his friends. They were fine. They were fine and alive and they were together! (Well, Josh was missing, but they had an easy way back to Fillory, and he knew, he knew they wouldn’t abandon each other) He watched as Eliot and Margo leaned into each other, both crying silently as they watched the flames consume the peach and blacken the crown. They were fine. They were alive. They were fine!
“- why wouldn’t they be okay?”
He was looking at Penny with what he hoped was conviction, but felt more like desperation. His words had been meant to come out strong, but had likely been a plea.
And Penny.., Penny looked like he wanted to fold his body into itself, while also trying to scrape together the words needed to talk someone away for the ledge. Quentin knew what that looked like. Because he had been in both positions. Been the one trying to talk someone down, and been the one who was being talked down. Right now, he felt like he was there again, looking down at the ground from high above, but he didn’t know if he was the one who wanted to jump, or the one who wanted to save the jumper.
“Quentin, look, I.. I literally can’t lie to you about this, but I really, really want to. Because this is not on you. This is not your responsibility. But if I answer your question, I know that you will take it as such.”
Penny took a step closer to him, settling his hands steadily on his shoulders, squeezing tightly, and looking directly into the smaller man’s eyes.
“I want you to listen to me closely. You have done and sacrificed enough. For the last three years, you have been running yourself into the ground, putting out fires, while ever more kept getting started. And I know you blame yourself for most of those as well, but I’m telling you right now, it wasn’t your fault. What happened to the others, what happened to me, what happened to the world as a whole. That wasn’t your fault, man. You just died, saving the people you love. There is a ticket in my pocket for you. That will take your soul to be reborn. All the pain, all the drama and tragedy, all that will be gone. It will be a good life, Quentin. A peaceful one. No apocalypses, no self serving gods or monsters. No more broken brain. You will be happy, Q. You deserve this. So please, don’t make me answer that question.”
Penny looked at him so earnestly, beseechingly. And Quentin felt bad about not being able to follow his request.
“Why won’t they be okay, Penny? ... Please.”
The other man closed his eyes, a sigh full of sorrow and regret leaving his lips, and squeezed the deceptively frail looking shoulders again, as if in apology.
“Is the thought that losing you is something they won’t get over, really so far out of your grasp?”
The answer to that was clearly obvious in the wide, uncomprehending eyes of the shorter man before him.
“...What?”
#the magicians#fanfic#queliot#quentin coldwater#eliot waugh#I don't accept quentin's death#william penny adiyodi#alice quinn#julia wicker#margo hanson#josh hoberman#kady orloff diaz#getting back up
17 notes
·
View notes
Text
The Wrath of the Time Bees
Okay, so I know I didn't live blog this week's episode, but I just wasn't feeling it last night. That being said, I think I want to keep doing these after episode assessments each week, just to see where I stand on things after I've had some time to let them marinate a little.
So let's do this...
Alice - my dear, sweet, stupid but I understand where you're coming from, Alice. Out of all of the characters, all of the Physical Kids, all of the Questers, you were the one understood the consequences in fucking with heavy magics. Necromancy, of any kind, never ends well. Ever. Thankfully, this didn't end horribly, but it still has to be traumatic to see someone that you knew and loved ripped from peace to be back on this mortal coil, even if it's not how you remember them. All of that being said, I'm glad she got to have that moment in the end where she got to say goodbye, mirroring when Quentin saw Alice's shade back in season two.
Julia - while I'm glad that she got to see Q's... "return" (it wouldn't have made any sense otherwise), I'm not digging the condescending attitude she had toward Alice. Yes, I understand completely, because that was her life long best friend and had to have been traumatizing for her, but given how the Physical Kids treated her after what happened with Reynard and then the Beast, you'd think she'd be a little more understanding. Though I do appreciate the inclusion of Circumstances in the overall plot.
Kady - her arc this episode was... interesting, to say the least. I'm glad we're actually exploring her role as the head Hedge (of at least New York) and the whole mind-assassin thing was interesting. I'm really glad we still get to see Pete, I'm a big fan of the Hedges and here's hoping that we see more of him in his role as Lovelady. Though, this whole thing has me intrigued because who is this mysterious competitor? Who has enough juice to not only steal a building but wipe everyone around so that no one remembers it?
My money's on the street vendor from the premiere. Suspect everyone, even the unexpected.
Margo and Eliot - this was a very interesting episode for these two, and I'm glad that we got it. For far too long, both in the show and in the fandom, they're though of as one entity. They're not, and this episode really showcased that with their back-and-forth in the dungeon.
Margo - I really appreciate Summer's acting, particularly in those scenes because we get to see a woman who is not just "the Destroyer" but just a woman, trying to save the guy she loves from a horrible death. Too often we see the trope of a "strong, independent woman" mean that she's incapable of the softer emotions because people feel it undermines the confidence and badassery. What I saw here was a woman with agency trying to do everything in her power to not give up because she doesn't know how. I know not everyone is a fan of Margosh, and to me honest I'm not a big fan of how they handled parts of that relationship, but I'm here for different avenues than what we'd expect.
Eliot - not a fan at all of them having him relapse into his earlier season ways. Not how dismissive he was of Margo's feelings toward Josh, particularly given the whole incident with Michael/Martin back in season one. They keep referencing El's time being possessed, and I know that's the reason that he's regressing to earlier coping mechanisms, but here's hoping we actually get an episode dedicated to having him grieve and vent or whatever.
Josh and Fen - stop waiting for Margo and save yourselves you idiots! Fen in particular doesn't strike me as the type to wait for anyone else to save her anymore and it felt like a real disservice to her character that she just waited until it was too late. That being said, Brittany's performance this episode was amazing. From the cape twirl when she summoned the guards to the two knives when she and Josh "made their last stand", but by far the best scene of the episode was her ghost. Her comedic timing is perfect and it was amusing that Fen was still perky and bubbly even after death.
Penny - give me more Professor Adiyodi!
Final Thoughts - I hesitate to use the term "filler episode" but that's what this felt like to me. Yes, we had a lot of stuff happen in a character level, but not an overall plot level. I'm not saying that to be negative or anything, because those type of episodes are important, too. I know that at the end of the season I'll look back and think differently on it, but right now I'm just trying to determine the path we're on for this season and I didn't get anything from this episode that pointed me in any direction.
PS: I really wanted to meet Professor Ex
PPS: I really hope Fen wins the contest for the crown next episode. Nothing against Margo, but I loved that Fen's arc culminated in her on the throne of her homeworld rather than an outsider.
#my thoughts#alice quinn#julia wicker#penny adiyodi#kady orloff-diaz#eliot waugh#margo hanson#josh hoberman#fen#the magicians#s5 e2
16 notes
·
View notes
Text
First Guy Wins - A Queliot Meta
I was rewatching The Magicians and was struck by a realization. Eliot and Queliot fit the “First Girl Wins” romantic trope. Yes, in this case, Eliot is a guy, not a girl but the trope still works.
Credit where credit is due, this is based by @scullylikesscience ‘s “First Girl Wins” meta.
When I first realized that Queliot definitely seemed to be the road the writers were going I was a bit cynical. I have quite a lot of experience and have been betrayed by many a showrunner.
I thought the writers had just seen that Queliot was more popular and course-corrected. Then I started my rewatch and realized that as much as the showrunners love claiming they’re winging it, this might have been planned after all.
It could still be a happy coincidence so I’m not going to give them too much credit. For the likes of this meta let’s focus on the facts and the characters.
We’re going to analyze Quentin and Eliot’s relationship through the lens of “First Girl Wins”
In romantic works, the first girl person introduced — either overall or as a potential Love Interest — has a very good chance of ending up with the protagonist (especially if the protagonist is male).
There are all sorts of explanations as to why this is. Things ending up the same place they started is a very old narrative technique.
From a Doylist point of view, the Law of Conservation of Detail suggests introducing the Love Interest early. An early introduction allows you to get the audience interested in her and rooting for her, gives you space for Character Development, and give her relationship with her (eventual) partner the most time to develop organically.
Eliot gets introduced pretty early, has a lot of character development outside of his relationship with Quentin and Queliot definitely has developed organically.
Is it the first girl the protagonist meets according to In-Universe chronology, even if we first see her halfway through the show's run? The first one to show romantic feelings? The first new girl the protagonist meets?
Eliot isn’t the first possible love interest that gets introduced, that’s actually Julia, then it’s Eliot, followed by Alice in the last place. It is in their introductions though that tells us that it’s actually Eliot that gets the title of First Girl™.
If you're suspecting some girl is supposed to be the First Girl™, a good idea would be to take a look at how the writer has played her up.
Is he a major character?
Eliot Waugh is one of the show’s leading characters ✔
Is the "first" interaction led up to, emphasized, treated as a big deal?
We first see him in the background as Quentin walks towards Brakebills. The camera shot is an Extreme Long Shot.
The camera focuses on him smoking for a bit (Wide Shot) until we see Quentin actually approach.
The camera closes on him with a medium shot as he talks to Quentin, then it’s a Medium Close Up as he gets down and introduces himself.
We see Quentin lose his cool and then he follows after Eliot. Asking if he’s hallucinating. Eliot and Quentin are in the same frame until they get to the exam which is where Eliot’s introduction ends.
This connects Eliot to Brakebills/Magic. So yes it’s definitely a big deal ✔
All other things being equal, is he a strong contender for being the protagonist's Love Interest?
Quentin and Eliot spend a lot of the first episodes together. The first person Quentin truly opens up to is Eliot (and Eliot opens up in return.) Eliot tells him one of his darkest secrets, while Quentin tells him about the hospital. The person he talks to about his worries re: getting expelled is Eliot.
1x02
In 1x03 Eliot goes to Quentin for help in finding the missing book. Thanks to this Quentin is introduced to the Hedge Witches, not only that but to the fact that Julia is one of them. Which means Eliot is there for Quentin and Julia’s big argument. This means Eliot has seen both sides of Q’s life (before Brakebills and after).
In 1x04 when Quentin gets stuck in Marina and Julia’s spell, Eliot is not only in the spell but visibly worried about Q outside of the spell.
Not only that but we actually see Eliot getting defensive with Julia.
When Quentin breaks out of it, the first person we see go to him is Eliot. Throughout the next couple of episodes, it seems there’s always a scene with the two of them together. The only time they don’t share screentime is in 1x07 (bc Q is with Mayakovsky and we’ll get to that later).
In 1x11 they literally have sex. Yes they’re high on emotions and it’s a threesome with Margo but it happened. If you hadn’t guessed by this point that Eliot is a valid romantic choice this made it more clear.
There’s no Straight Guy™ Freakout. Quentin was never written as a straight character. From his first interaction with Eliot, we see that Quentin is attracted to him. The only negative connotation the scene has it that it’s cheating because Quentin was in a relationship at the time.
Throughout Season 1 a lot of the major moments for Quentin himself happen with Eliot or around Eliot. Quentin might get expelled? Eliot is there. Confrontation with Julia? Eliot is there. His dad has cancer? Eliot and Margo help him out. Quentin gets separated from the group? Eliot sends a paper airplane to tell them where they are. This season establishes that Eliot is an important person in Quentin’s life.
In 2x01 we get the crowning scene between Eliot and Quentin and not only does it have very romantic vibes but the camera shots tell us a lot about these two characters. We get a Full Shot of the whole group before it becomes a lot more intimate.
The speech that Quentin gives Eliot is the longest of all the Coronation speeches. From Eliot’s side, we get Close-Ups. Close Ups show us what the character is feeling at this moment. We see an Eliot with tears in his eyes looking up at Quentin with so much love.
On his side, Quentin has a Medium Close Up all we see in his eyes is pride. Despite the fact that they haven’t had the best relationship recently Quentin still deeply cares.
Both of them look at each other. The camera focuses on both of them until the moment is over and the camera turns to Penny and the scene continues.
So is he a strong contender for being the protagonist's Love Interest? Considering this is only a smidge of their interactions? I would say definitely ✔.
(I could talk about all their interactions, especially “A Life in a Day” but then we’d be here all year and I wanted to focus on their earlier establishing scenes)
The First Girl will rarely be the first one to confess her feelings, admit them,
Pretty much all the romantic interactions between them have been initiated by Quentin rather than Eliot.
Back in 3x05, we see that Quentin is the one that first kisses Eliot. They live their life together and raise a family.
In 4x05 it’s revealed that after they got their memories back Quentin put himself out there. We see a Quentin who is sure that he loves Eliot “who gets that kind of proof of concept”. It doesn’t go well for him but he did it.
In fact, he's much likelier to be the one who does it last
We don’t get the full realization of Eliot’s feelings until 4x05. I think Eliot has known for a while that he loves Quentin, but it's just been implied (few people can heart eye as Hale can). But the reason I mention it is that this is where Eliot realizes he has to do something about it. The ball is in his court.
With his small window of opportunity, he tries to convey his feelings to Quentin while also giving him a reason to fight “Peaches and plums motherfucker, I’m alive in here”.
Complications will abound, Romantic False Leads will show up,
Most of Season 1’s romantic subplot is Quentin/Alice and later Eliot/Mike. The interesting thing is that both of the Romantic False Leads appear in the same episode (1x07). Alice has been there from the first episode but 1x07 is the episode where she and Quentin hook up. Coincidentally the same when Eliot and Mike hook up.
Quentin falls in love with Alice while Eliot is very deeply into Mike. Of course, both relationships end in tragedy. Eliot has to kill Mike to protect the rest and Alice dies defeating the beast. The pain of his actions makes Eliot turn towards substance abuse which leads to him going to Fillory with the rest. It sets him on a path that deviates from Quentin’s.
Quentin’s plot is about bringing Alice back from being a Niffin. Yet when he does she hates him for it. So their relationship fizzles out and never truly recovers.
In Eliot’s case, we also get Idri as a false romantic lead as they did technically get engaged and were clearly attracted to each other.
misunderstandings will arise between them, pride and denial will keep them apart.
The biggest misunderstanding between the two comes from the same scene in 4x05. Eliot believes that Quentin wouldn’t choose him if they had a choice. He gets scared and so he pushes Quentin away. Eliot mistakenly believes Q is straight so that’s probably the biggest misunderstanding between them. Quentin interprets it as Eliot not choosing him if he had a choice.
The misunderstanding gets worse when we remember 3x06 had Eliot rejecting Quentin’s idea of going on a quest. He has a perfectly valid reason but Quentin probably sees it as another rejection from the man he is in love with.
They’re both in love with each other but neither believes the other would choose him. Miscommunication is a large part of romantic tropes.
A more subtle tactic is to get the First Girl "off the radar" somehow —
Ironically enough Queliot fits this criterion as well. Eliot is married to Fen (and later engaged to Idri) while stuck in Fillory being High King the majority of seasons 2 and 3. While Quentin is dealing with Niffin!Alice and helping Julia in Season 2, and largely involved in the Key Quest in Season 3.
That doesn’t mean they don’t see each other because they do. They just can go periods of time without sharing meaningful screentime (especially in regards to show-time as time in the show passes differently than how we see it episode by episode).
You can expect an in-universe justification for how these two people met so early and took so long to figure out they belong together.
In Queliot’s case, it’s misunderstandings, romantic false leads, magical quests, their own stupidity, false identities and of course the fact that one of them is possessed by a monster.
The fact of the matter is that Eliot fits pretty much all the criteria for being the First Girl (or in this case First Guy). So whether it was on purpose or just a happy accident it still counts.
Eliot Waugh is the First Guy™ which leads me to believe great things are on the way for Queliot. We just have to sit back and enjoy the ride.
(Remember to pack tissues, as I have a feeling the writers aren’t done torturing us yet)
#Queliot#Queliot meta#Eliot Waugh#the magicians#the magicians meta#Quentin Coldwater#this turned out so much longer than I expected#but I'm proud of it#Yes I went all film major on this.. at least my degree got used for something#maii meta#sweetestinthegale#anniebibananie#missgoalie75#wedlakeserenities
140 notes
·
View notes
Note
8 + Queliot!
8. “I look at you and I think, ‘sunshine. Literal sunshine.’It’s annoying.”
Thank you for the prompt!! Sorry this took a little longer! It may have turned into some self-indulgent fluff, but like. That’s where we’re at now, I think.
sunshine (on AO3)
Seasons changed in their lives. The weather softened. Thedarkest seemed to be through—though Eliot would never say that out loud. Noneed to tempt fate when things were finally good again. Fate did so liketo surprise them once they’d finally found themselves again. In the meantime, inthe lull between the chaos, they could enjoy the peace they’d earned.
They’re more than earned some peace.
It had taken months. Many months, quite a bit of therapy,some psychiatry and some antidepressants. Time and work and patience. Hope and perseverance,all the things people said it would take. Not to mention all of the chamomiletea and late nights awake. It was never going to be easy.
It had taken several hard conversations. A lot of minormending, of so many different kinds. Apologies and confessions and promises.
They both still had nightmares. Quentin of his loved onesbecoming unrecognizable, becoming monsters—Eliot of all the things his handsmight have done while he wasn’t in control of them.
Healing was a process. Nothing got better all at once. Theywere both fully aware of that. They were no strangers to this kind of pain.
But on days like this—
Well. It really felt like the world was looking up. LikeEliot might be able to dare to be optimistic. It was a moment where it feltlike he could allow himself to feel comfortable in the warm contentment,instead of fearing that it would be ripped away.
A little idealism, a little hope. It couldn’t hurt.
The sun was setting over the city skyline, and Eliot andQuentin were out on the balcony of their small Manhattan apartment.
Quentin was reading, finally feeling enough like himself towant to again.
Eliot was, well, watching Quentin read as he sipped his icedtea.
The sounds of the city floated up to them—the constructionand honking and yelling sounded more beautiful than ever. Eliot couldn’t believehow good life was at this moment. With his boyfriend, in their sharedspace, on a calm, clear evening. A gentle breeze, the colors of the sky blendingtogether.
Eliot could let himself believe that everything was going tobe okay. Somehow, against all odds, maybe their life could be normal.
Leave ruling Fillory to Margo, who wore the crown with more graceand power than anyone else. Leave dealing with the Library to Alice and Kady,who both wanted to repair the structural issues of the world. Leave the questsand prophecies to the demi-goddess Julia, who was always more the chosen onethan any of them. Leave Brakebills to Todd and Josh, who might actually finishtheir degrees. Leave exploring the world to Penny.
Eliot had never imagined that all he’d really want, in theend, would be a quiet life. With tea and sunsets and lazy evenings. He’d alwaysthought he’d need something grander if he wanted any hope at happiness.
But that was before he met Quentin Coldwater. That wasbefore he knew what the beauty of all life meant.
As Eliot gazed at Quentin with all the adoration that he wascapable of, it hit him, not for the first time, just how much he loved thisman.
It was a frankly absurd amount. If he were the type, he’d bewriting sonnets about it. If he were the type, he’d be painting portraits. Ifhe were the type, he’d compose songs.
The love Eliot felt for Quentin was the kind of love thatbrought out the most tender parts of himself, right to the surface. It pulledat his heart in ways that almost hurt. It was all the clichés at once, really.Deep down, it turned out that Eliot was a romantic in the cheesiest way sometimes.
“Q,” he said.
“Hm?” Quentin replied, still looking at his book.
“You’re quite an ordeal in my life, you know that?”
Eliot caught the way Quentin’s lips twitched up in amusement.
“How’s that?”
“I look at you and I think, ‘sunshine. Literal sunshine.’ It’sannoying.”
Quentin finally looked up, one eyebrow raised. He used his indexfinger to mark his page.
“Um. Okay?” Quentin said slowly.
“I’m just saying, it’s absolutely going to ruin myreputation,” Eliot went on.
“I think our friends all know what a sap you are by now, El.”
“How dare you. They know no such thing.”
Quentin laughed, an open and clear sound.
And there it was again—sunshine, literal sunshine. Thewhole world lit up when Quentin was happy; it was truly a remarkable thing.Eliot might’ve been willing to admit it was just his own effusive, romantictendencies, if Quentin’s light didn’t radiate so.
It didn’t just light up Eliot’s life. It lit up the wholefucking world.
Eliot rolled his eyes theatrically. “You see? You areabsolutely too delightful, and I will not stand for it.”
Quentin scoffed, shaking his head. “You’re so ridiculous.”
“I’m being reasonable.”
“Yeah, that’s a word I’d use to describe you.”
“I don’t appreciate that tone.”
And Quentin just rolled his eyes.
And yet, still—
Sunshine, literal sunshine.
It was everything about him, wasn’t it? It was his laugh, itwas his smile. It was his scoff and his snark and his rambling. It waseverything.
“You’ve turned me into a romantic, Coldwater.”
“You’ve always been a romantic, Waugh.”
Eliot smiled fondly despite the exasperation in Quentin’stone.
“Not like this, baby,” Eliot replied, his voice soft andwarm. Soft and warm like this gentle evening. Soft and warm like their life wasclose to becoming.
Quentin turned a little, leaning towards him and meeting hiseyes fully. With those big, earnest eyes—gazing at Eliot with meaning in them.And even now, even after all this time they’d spent together, even after theirbickering over how to organize the fucking cupboards, even after realizing thatQuentin wanted a dog and Eliot wanted a cat and they couldn’t settle on a pet, aftereverything that had happened between then, an entire life—
A simple look from Quentin, with those loving, open eyes,was enough to take Eliot’s breath away.
“I love you,” he said, the words coming out easily. Likethey belonged in his mouth. It’s not like it had been easy at first, to say thewords—
But now, it felt as natural as breathing.
And even still Quentin’s face lit up like it was the firsttime he was hearing it.
“I love you, too,” he replied.
And Eliot leaned in, kissing Quentin gently, allowinghimself to believe that they were going to be alright. That this life was theirsnow, that they could have the small, quiet life they both yearned for. That thechaos of everything they’d been through was coming to a real end.
A little idealism, a little hope. It couldn’t hurt.
Eliot allowed himself to believe it.
They were going to be okay.
17 notes
·
View notes
Text
The Magicians - ‘The Serpent’ Review
“Some God of War. He only liked them when they were too weak to fight.”
Library’s become ever-more fascist, Alice splits in two, and big revelations are made, but not on-screen.
I’m going to be honest: I didn’t feel great about this episode after I watched it the first time. And then I watched it again and found I was better able to understand it and appreciate some of what it was exploring. But I still don’t feel great about it.
Here’s what I liked: the Alice on Alice conflict. From the moment she split I was excited. It’s like taking Gestalt’s empty chair technique and making it literal, and the psychology student in me was living for it. Even better, the execution was pretty great. It allowed the show to directly with Alice’s main conflict, which is that there was a part of her pre-niffin who was sheepish and kind and scared, there was a part of her post-niffin who was arrogant and dominant and selfish, and each part hates the other, blames the other for everything that’s gone wrong. But the thing is, they’re all Alice and all to blame. And she needs them both. She needs to be selfish to survive, but she needs to be cautious to avoid blowing stuff up. Both her arrogance and her fear can put everyone in danger. But she can’t lock either part of herself up and manage, and even if she could she wouldn’t be able to survive long.
It’s an interesting issue to explore, because it’s probably come up for a lot of us. It would be nice to be able to erase or at least lock up the parts of ourselves we don’t like. It’s harder to admit we’re more complicated than that and the whole of ourselves is the source of our problems and our triumphs. So we need to learn to better the parts of ourselves we don’t like, to see the good and bad in them, and, at the least, try to cope with them. But what I like best about what the show does with Alice is that she doesn’t really figure out how to do any of this. Both parts of herself work together to finish the spell, but that’s not because of any real epiphany. She (they?) just realized she didn’t have much of a choice. Alice still has a lot of growing to do. And, really, don’t we all?
While this is going on Zelda learns more about the Library—namely, that it’s devolving into a fascist regime. I didn’t appreciate this plot much the first time around. I thought Zelda finally realized the Library was corrupt after the Library kept the killer deweys in circulation and that the revelation that Everett was her mentor was revealed too late. I still somewhat feel that way. But after my rewatch I do feel more interested in the Library’s continued corruption. Throughout the season we’ve seen this grow slowly. They were meant to keep everyone safe by carefully distributing magic. But they unfairly favored trained magicians over hedges, manipulated people into the Library in exchange for magic and education, rewarded people who posted magic-monitors in their homes, the list goes on. Manipulation, indoctrination, invasion of privacy. And finally, faking a terrorist organization to create fear. The Library wants power, it will do anything to fuel that.
This whole idea of obtaining power by any means necessary isn’t new. What’s more interesting is seeing people why people might trust the Library, believe in its cause and believe that cause is just or that helping it would be a good option (Zelda, Fogg). Seeing Fogg struggle with when to cut ties with the Library, whether that would help or hurt, if that’s cowardly or selfish. Seeing Kady and Alice forced to make ethically-questionable decisions while trying to help those harmed by the Library (using Harriet’s vulnerable position as leverage). And seeing the harm that not only fear, but also apathy can have. When considering what to do about the terrorists, Kaylee Frye the Librarian asks if the terrorists are even the Library’s problem. She doesn’t care about the safety of the hedges, it’s likely few librarians do, and that makes her much more likely to go along with whatever the Library has planned regardless of the cost. And then there’s fear itself. While remembering The Monster’s destruction, The Monster insults Enyalius for going after souls too weak to fight. The same can be said for Everret. It seems Everret fears the hedges—he needs their submission to raise the Library up—and he uses fear to keep them down. And maybe this is—in part—what war is.
In Fillory, things go down with the prophecy. But also, not really. Fen doesn’t want to overthrow Margo, Margo has her eyes on Fen for all of a minute before asking (forcing) Fen to dethrone her so she can go off and find something to save Eliot. It’s all resolved pretty easily. That said, I did appreciate that Margo and Fen didn’t act out of character or that just enough information wasn’t kept from them to make things more dramatic. But I just didn’t understand why Margo had to ask Fen to dethrone her at all. The only explanation I can think of is that Margo had to leave Fillory to go to the desert, and that’s not allowed for kings. But I don’t remember being told the desert was out of the realm. And I also don’t know that leaving Fillory is still not allowed. Ember and Umber are dead and Fillory is a quasi-democracy, do the rules even apply anymore? All this confusion messed with the story’s emotional beats. Not entirely—I’m not a monster—I still felt for Margo losing the crown she worked so hard to get for the realm she cares so much for. But enough.
Finally, there was The Monster stuff. There, we almost get information about Julia’s “transition”, but then we don’t; Alice finds the binder but doesn’t open it up. And then we almost get information about The Monster’s plan, but then we don’t; Eliot tells Penny 23 the plan off-screen, Penny 23’s just about to tell Julia and Quentin the plan when the show ends. It all kind of feels cheap, especially the final cliffhanger. The Magicians has ended episodes—entire seasons—in cliffhangers before without it feeling cheap. But something about the multitude of not-reveals, the show looking away at just the right moment, and ending the episode almost mid-scene was too much. I wish the episode ended right after Margo’s last moment instead. Seeing her walk out to the desert listening to 80s music would be a fitting lead-in to the musical in the desert. And it would’ve felt way less cheap.
Bits and Pieces
-- Kady got to use her mad punching skills, which elevates any episode. Sucks for Alice, though.
-- Zelda gets a back-story! She was a hedge, her mom died, she was found in an ally. Zelda’s right, it does sound dramatic.
-- It was great seeing Harriet and getting her back, but I wish she and Marlee Matlin had more to do than just struggle to communicate with Alice while Alice deals with her stuff and share new plot information. Hopefully she’ll be on again.
-- I feel (maybe unreasonably) defensive of Julia. Zelda says she trusts Kady because she was able to try to understand the woman responsible for Penny 40s death (which must be Julia, right?). But that wasn’t really Julia’s fault, both Kady and Penny 40 agreed to help take down Reynard, Julia never asked Penny 40 to go down to the poison room, and it’s not her fault Reynard was evil and raped her and killed most everyone else. And, even so, both Julia and Kady summoned OLU in the first place. It just felt victim-blamey to me and I didn’t appreciate it from Zelda (I wouldn’t from anyone). End of rant.
-- Speaking of Julia, I found it interesting seeing how quickly she offered to shift the focus from her god problems to The Monster problems. Her story has been moving along pretty slowly (probably because if she powered up she would be hard to keep on the show) and maybe this an in-show reason why. Her issues always fall second to The Monster or even the Library issues, because those are life and death.
-- I also liked seeing Penny 23 advocate for Julia (suggesting they try to research the binder while working on The Monster stuff) and Julia advocate for Penny 23 (trying to keep him from putting himself in danger with The Monster, etc.). And they almost kissed! But The Monster cock-blocked them. Maybe now that he’s alive they’ll have that dinner he promised her.
-- Margo found out Eliot’s alive! And immediately had sex with Josh. Fen’s facial expressions were amazing.
The Monster: “Are you aware that there is big money for psychics who are in actually big giant fakers?” I actually did know that, Monster! John Oliver just did a whole segment about it.
Ru, Queen of West Loria: “During the feast you will order the castle doors open where upon my men will enter and chop off—” Fen: “Enjoy the desert course.” Ru: “Did you really think I was gonna say that?” Fen: “Hoped.”
Margo, about Fen: “That false-toed bitch!”
Margo: “Wait! I curse Fen’s name, but if I were you I’d listen to her! And wait! Be nice to her! Your grandkid’s grandkids will fear me!”
Three out of four fascist libraries.
Edit: Thanks to Percysowner and late-ish night reflections I now understand that Margo needed to be dethroned so the Fillory-hating people of The Foremost would agree meet with her.
Ariel Williams
#The Magicians#Alice Quinn#Margo Hanson#Eliot Waugh#Quentin Coldwater#Julia Wicker#The Magicians Reviews#Doux Reviews#TV Reviews
15 notes
·
View notes
Note
Hello there! I need to hear everything about this soulmate AU of yours. Just searched through the blog and all I could find was the fact that there are platonic soulmates (BIG LOVE) and I am starved for feels please and thank you
ok i said i wanted asks abt this but then my laptop fell apart and then i lost internet for a few days so this is super late and i’m sorry bUT!! soulmate au. this isn’t anything coherent and has zero (0) plot but it’s smth i made that i really enjoy so here we go folks
the rules of this ‘verse are basically that you are born with black and white tattoos that symbolize something to do with your soulmate (if your marks reference the same thing, the stronger your bond is. similarly, if your marks are on the same area of your body, the stronger your mark is). the soulmark tattoos turn in color when you first meet your soulmate, and it’s possible to have multiple soulmates and also platonic soulmates (quentin and julia and margo and eliot are both pairs of platonic soulmates in this au). so without further ado, here’s the kids(tm) and their soulmarks
quentin’s soulmark tattoo is a giant map of fillory that stretches across his entire back. specific places reference his specific soulmates. his mark for penny is where the virgo blade was first used/talked about and/or the swordsmith's shop. his mark for eliot is the beach where they were crowned, castle whitespire, and the mosiac area. his mark for alice is the wellspring, and all other parts of fillory are his platonic mark with julia. he and julia know they’re soulmates from p much day one, bc they’re childhood friends, and they're 5 and have no reservations so they know they're soulmates from almost the moment they meet. they date in high school, julia realizes she's a lesbian, they come to terms with it being platonic. quentin and alice realize they’re soulmates the morning after he saves her from niffining for her brother, and they’re both fairly sure this incident is what alice’s soulmark for quentin is referencing, so their ‘bond’ isn’t super strong (spoiler alert: it’s referencing her death so their bond is actually fairly strong). penny and quentin first realize it when penny gets stabbed by the virgo blade. quentin gets excited that he’s found another soulmate. penny rolls his eyes and asks quentin to concentrate on the fact that he's been fucking stabbed. quentin and eliot realize they’re soulmates the night they have the threesome (which is Less of a deal here, partially bc at this point alice knows quentin and eliot are soulmates, and instead, she’s more mad at margo — who is one of her soulmates — for sleeping with quentin). alice and margo figure out that quentin and eliot are soulmates before the two of them do. mostly because the two of them aren’t weenies who don’t want to talk about things (unlike quentin and eliot).
eliot has two soulmark tattoos, which is the lowest number of soulmates i think anyone in this au has, tbqh. he has quentin’s mark on his left wrist, and it’s a goblet on his left wrist, overflowing red wine, with a peach and plum behind it. his marker for margo (arguably the strongest mark in the entire series, ftr) is her high queen crown wrapped around his upper left thigh. during the trials, eliot and margo share soulmarks and pasts, and they realize their crowns match and changed color on the same day, eliot says that he's gay so margo doesn't get any illusions about their relationship, and it works out.
margo has four marks. wrapped around her upper right thigh is eliot’s high king crown. she has a white shorthair cat winding its way around the back of her right ankle for alice’s mark, which they figured out whe margo corners alice and gets her drunk (the scene with the wine) and convinces her to share her soulmarks. also they talk about charlie's unrequited niffin fire soulmark. when margo sees the cat she just kind of knows it matches her cat and they start dating. she’s got the spatters of blood across her face from when micah was killed as her mark for him (though i haven’t decided what his is for her yet), though they know they’re soulmates instantly as they instantly turn red when she meets him, which....is a really ominous soulmark. she also has a simple wolf silhouette for josh, but i haven’t decided if her and josh’s mark is platonic or not, or when they discovered it bc the two of them are a new season development lmao sorry.
alice has three marks — one for quentin, which is niffin fire curling up from under her left armpit and over her left breast with the last tendrils of fire reaching her collarbone (they think it's since they first met because of her brother who niffened but it's really referencing her death and that means her and quentin's marks were stronger than they first thought), one for penny, which is the bad whiskey they were drinking when she had sex with him the first time on the back of her right calf (they figure it out the night they sleep together and penny jokes about how he's glad it wasn't margo or eliot), and one for margo, which is a sleeping cream persian cat curled up at the base of her neck.
penny has three marks — one for quentin, which is what looks like scars from the virgo blade but over the entire right side of his torso, one for alice, which is an empty emotion bottle on his left ankle with the necklace chain wrapped around to the front of his ankle and up some (like three-fourths of the way up his calf is where the necklace ends), and one for kady, which is ropes over his wrists like the trials, which represent the first time he really let kady in (both of theirs are so obvious they know pretty much the first time they meet. they don't realize what they mean until later, and penny’s for kady actually get sliced right through when the beast severs his hands and are scarred/parts of the mark are missing afterwards).
kady only has two soulmarks, but both are romantic. she has one for julia, which is lighting from that whip she used to save julia beginning at the top of her hip and going across her stomach and curling up under and beside her right breast (they realize it after julia is helping kady get out of the shower after the heroin den, and she asks when kady's changed, they talk about the dates their changed after the shower and start dating but don't realize the significance until the bank heist), and one for penny, which is battle magic/hedge witch symbols all up and down the inside of her arms and over the front of her shoulders and the front of her throat (representing the first time she let penny in).
julia has two soulmarks. one is her platonic mark with quentin, which is a map of the outer islands and the edge of the world that adds on to quentin's fillory map if they stand next to each other spread across her back. her mark for kady is on the back of her left thigh, and is the wooden spoon the monster kady saved her from was made from.
disclaimer: i didn’t include josh and fen in this au originally and the penny mentioned is original penny (penny 40) because i made this au ages ago and haven’t been bothered to go thru and change things really but like. they still exist and if there’s interest i can add their tattoos in as well !! but this is already super long so. if anyone has any more questions feel free to hmu i love this au. also sorry this is so late !! thanks for asking lovely
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
Magicians s4 is garbage and here’s why. Spoilers.
Can we take a moment to appreciate just how bad Magicians s4 was, as a whole? I know, people are mad about the whole ‘going out of their way to hint at Eliot/Q for no reason when they had just as much of a connection as friends, just to upset the people that shipped it more when they killed Q’ but
Honestly, there’s so much more broken garbage about this season than just the one part of how it ended that the writers WANT us to talk about. So yes, let’s take a moment first to appreciate how the writers hate Quin and refused to let him grow as a character ever or give him the moments of success he had in the books, until they pointlessly murdered him instead of letting him finally be happy with the ending he should have gotten. It deserves derision.
But let’s focus on other things, too.
It’s long. It’s ranty. It’s going to rip apart season four and its finale and also touch on season three. It’s already tagged spoilers, but there’s more spoilers in here than out of the cut. Also, yes. We’re gonna talk about how the show pretends that it’s empowering females while it takes away all of their agency and makes them all about their men. And other hypocrisy.
First off. The fake female empowerment crap. And yes, it was so fake. We know it because the show itself utterly undermines and destroys it at the end of the season. Or sometimes literally right after they flex.
First: IT’S OKAY TO CALL MARGOT BY THE GENDER APPROPRIATE TITLE FOR ROYAL MONARCH OF A LAND. I know that by magical technicality she has to be ‘high KING’ (more on that later if I remember, because they actually ignore some of that) but there’s no reason Margot herself and other characters need to insist on ‘king’. Queen Regnant has the same ruling power and authority as a King Regnant. That’s why a non ruling Queen is called Queen Consort. Unless, of course, Magicians and SYFY are implying that Queen Elizabeth I and II are somehow inferior to King Edward and Henry the VIII(s) because they are only queens? Nevermind Elizabeth II has been queen so long her crown would have fossilized on her head by now if she wore it like fictional royalty always did.
Anyway.
Show. You’re not progressive because you have Penny smugly smile and say ‘let go of your cishet white boy bias, the main characters are the women’. You’re just obnoxious. Especially when Penny immediately finds out the cishet white boy he’s talking down to is actually his boss. Oof.
See, if you want us to believe other characters are actually the protagonists? You need to treat them like protagonists. You don’t do that, though. The only reason I remember the blonde librarian’s name is because it’s Zelda.
The episode builds up how important Fen is and how she has her own quest that will do something important, but what happens literally the very next episode? Oh right, Margot steps in and takes control of that, seizing the quest for herself. The only reasons I can presume this is for is #1 - the show writers despise the books and want to undermine everything about them, down to ensuring none of the humans get to rule Fillory even after they wasted multiple episodes democratically handing Margot the crown. Too bad for the talking animals, eh? and #2 to set up the sequel hook in the ending that, while interesting purely because it’s a Prince Caspian set up, was entirely unnecessary and could have been replaced by a series finale ending instead.
It actually makes no sense. Margot doesn’t contribute in any significant way she couldn’t have if she were still High King, because Fen could have done the entire black sand mission herself, because she is married to Eliot, remember, let’s not make fun of her feelings for him just because she’s not the main character (but she is! screeches smug penny!) - could she have seen the fairy? No, but she would have been able to work it out anyway, because it just wanted to help her. And here’s the kicker? The reason West Loria is against Fillory (aside from lol plot) is because OF FEN. Margot wasn’t ruling when Fillory chose the wrong side! Margot hasn’t weighed in at all, so why IN THE WORLD would this woman decide that she absolutely wouldn’t deal with any High King EXCEPT THE ONE WHO DID THE THING SHE DIDN’T LIKE?
Quick, tell me what Margot contributed to the plot from the point she left Fillory that Fen couldn’t have done, or that couldn’t have been accomplished by Margot still in Fillory.
Whoops, you’re out of time! There’s nothing. She did nothing of consequence that Fen couldn’t have done just slightly differently to suit her skills and actually justify the BS Penny spewed about her being a significant protagonist figure. Margot got swapped with Fen primarily because, no matter what self congratulatory subversive crap the show patted itself on the back with, Margot is actually a main character and Fen isn’t, so Margot needed to at least be near the action, and get her own quest, even if it was just taking Fen’s away from her. And also having a weird rushed romance with Josh for some reason. Who knows. I miss the genuine connection Margot and Eliot had for seasons that this season chose to throw away on a boring monster plot. I also miss Margot and Q’s friendship that this season ignored because we needed to focus on romance instead and pretend Margot doesn’t make friends.
Which reminds me, it’s super great how we went from Josh detesting Margot for making him help murder one of his only friends to Josh wanting to be her boyfriend because they share an STD. Really important and believable romance, there.
Kady also did fairly little from the point of that episode onward. They had to bring the Hedgewitches plot in to make her important, and even as the defacto ruler of the HW she still did very little except suggest that they could help the completely improbable ‘let’s just skip over the mechanics of making this work’ collaborative spell. And Alice and Julia already had the contacts to allow that to work anyway
ANYWAY MOVING ON
but not too far, because I need to talk about that awful red sand episode.
First, an aside: just because people liked your two musical episodes over the span of the entire series doesn’t mean you need to start stuffing singing into everywhere because ‘SINGING’
If only the problem with the episode was that the singing didn’t end with dancing Eliot. But no. This episode was PEAK fake female empowerment.
Margot finds a tribe of nomads who inexplicably choose to live in a desert that’s constantly trying to kill them. Every time women have an over the top emotional eruption (the show keeps saying ‘the tiniest bump’ or whatever but that’s a bunch of crap, it’s very clearly only when they have an eruption or tantrum), red sand appears and tries to kill them via possession. Men in the tribe protect them from this by jumping in the way and getting possessed instead, and then USUALLY DIE because the method of fixing them is to effing stab them with double axes and pull out the spirit, then try to fix them with desert medicine.
Raised knowing that their lives are in constant danger, and that if they fly off the handle about something not only are they in danger but the men around them, whom they purportedly love, may very well die, the women of course are incapable of just controlling themselves and will erupt in rage regularly like some modern city girl even while being actively cautioned to calm down and knowing they’re endangering their entire settlement.
Upon hearing that men consistently risk their lives to protect their insane girlfriends who literally cannot control their emotions on pain of death, Margot concludes ‘wow, this culture is mighty misogynistic. sucks.’
but then, oh no. The sand isn’t trying to HURT them, the sand - for no reason anyone in the show bothers to explain, because world building isn’t important to the writers - it actually just wants the women not to be sad and will grant their any wish if one so much as has a temper tantrum. Trigger scene where Margot beats up all the evil menfolk for oppressing these poor, helpless, weak women who need a sassy foreign girl to save them from themselves and literal fairies to look after their every boo-boo. There’s brief lip service given to the idea that maybe the women themselves DON’T hate all the men around them, but Margot shrugs it off and suggests that now the women of the camp are free to literally murder any man who makes them mad, or ‘just’ force them to slave for them for however long they want.
PATRIARCHY DESTROYED, GUYS. EQUALITY ACHIEVED. MEN ARE NOW ENSLAVED AND KILLED OVER NOTHING!!! LOOK AT THE STRONG WOMEN WHO LITERALLY NEEDED A FOREIGN WHITE CHICK TO SHOW UP AND SAVE THEM SO THAT A WHOLE SPECIES OF FAIRIES COULD CONSTANTLY CODDLE AND LOOK AFTER THEIR EVERY NEED.
SO STRONG.
I’m not even joking, though. They tried to write a “YEAH! WOMEN!” plot but just made the women there look completely inept and incapable of fending for themselves at all without a smart American there to teach them. And that’s without getting into the horror of setting up a slave society where men are objects that can be killed on a whim. eugh.
Anyway, so Margot does all that and spends just...all season insisting WOMEN ARE STRONGER. WOMEN ARE TOUGH. WOMEN ARE STRONNGGG. DON’T NUTSACK OUT ON ME MAN. BE A PUSSY AND TOUGH IT OUT!!!!! OF COURSE THE WOMAN IS THE VIOLENT AND UNSTABLE ONE (wait--)
But where’s that all lead us to?
The season finale.
Before we dive too deep let’s take a brief moment to look at poor Julia through all this season.
#1, in some twist that doesn’t really make sense, the dean hides all of the main cast as alternate personalities under glamors with some heavy witness protection magic as a deal to the Library so they don’t have to die...and so naturally the Library has a dead or alive bounty on them.
huh?
Whatever, let’s not focus too hard on the garbage pail of a plot the monster plot is, because that’s tied into the huge dumpsterfire that season 3′s finale was, and the best to talk about that is how these smart and manipulative people literally couldn’t be bothered to lie to and trick a simple childlike monster into thinking he was their ACTUAL FRIEND no matter how often he looked for validation from them (maybe he wouldn’t have been so keen on clinging to Eliot if he thought you guys liked HIM, not just the body, you nimrods) and who began to get some development and understanding of living life normally without killing everyone right before they imprison him and send him to ultra-hell.
No it’s cool. Just imprison the childlike creature who you didn’t bother to try to teach morality to after it desperately sought some kind of affection and acceptance from literally anyone. Seems like the good guy thing to do. I mean, you showed that mean ol’ child molester by getting him to trust you, using his knowledge, and then literally trying to murder him, so honestly this isn’t out of character at all for our ‘good guys’.
a n y way. JULIA.
It’s hinted at in season 3 that burning up all your god magic to make keys is actually temporary (but renders you able to be killed, so season 4 literally got it opposite of right, whoops), so obviously Julia really wants to get that back. She’s been motivated and shaped by magic as much as Q. She has been raped, lost her shade, suffered, had people die protecting and helping her, and became a goddess entirely by her own merit. She reasonably wants to get that power back, since she can’t die and isn’t really affected by magic in a normal way so she’s not fully human still.
Julia rescues everyone from the mindwipe by dying literally hundreds, maybe thousands of times and coming back. She gets a Mainaid (who I don’t feel like spelling right) that comes to believe in her and worship her as a goddess, and what happens? Well, first Penny who wants to get his dick wet gets jealous and runs off because he’s not the center of her world for like an hour. Partly because of this, the girl whom she rescued from suicide gets pointlessly murdered protecting her.
But hey, they’ve confirmed Julia is still a deity mostly but just can’t seem to access her powers. So Julia keeps digging and looking for a way to get them back. This leads to discovering an ancient book in the mirror version of the library who confirms that yes, she’s basically a demigod who won’t ever die, but needs to complete the transition either back to full godhood or to full humanity or she’s always be a little wrong, basically like she dislocated her divine limb fixing the keys and it can either be put back in or chopped off.
Now, this book (the Binder) warns her that both options are going to be long and painful and have their downsides, and implies they’ll be permanent, so she’s going to have to be SURE of what she wants. This warning is the ONLY reason Julia doesn’t immediately jump to a decision. And then the Monster shows up and kidnaps her. She calls the Lady Underground, who is unhelpful and just says ‘gotta make a choice yourself girl, no wrong answer’ and then the lady gets herself killed for no reason after Julia is immediately possessed.
Penny ‘rescues’ her by stabbing her in the back to pull the spirit out, and then blah blah her demigodhood doesn’t like that stabby thing, and it won’t let her die but also won’t heal. Solution? Make the choice and go full god or human and it’ll fix. Naturally, even though Julia’s been awake this whole time, she’s now unconscious ‘for the pain’ and Penny who is A POWERFUL TELEPATH can’t be bothered to pop in her head and ask what she wants under those circumstances.
no, he makes her decision FOR her. This is important, we’ll get back to this.
Penny has been chasing Julia(’s tail) around all season now. He’s been a part of her path to godhood this whole time, knows what she’s done to try to get it, so when forced to make a permanent choice for her
THIS
DICKHEAD
CHOOSES TO MAKE HER HUMAN. Against EVERYTHING he’s seen of her up until this point, and against whatever he knew of his Julia. Why? “I was selfish” WELL THANK YOU, MISTER “I JUST WANNA GET LAID” FOR AT LEAST ADMITTING YOU ROBBED A WOMAN OF SOMETHING SO UNBELIEVABLY SIGNIFICANT AND IMPORTANT AND LITERALLY LEFT HER WITHOUT MAGIC BECAUSE YOU WANTED TO STICK IT IN.
That’s right. Fandom’s all mad that Quentin died and they glorified suicide? Yeah, they just stripped away ALL AGENCY from a woman and made a choice for her that he KNEW she didn’t want just because it would be more convenient for him. Just violate the trust and remove the agency of the woman you already raped on screen once, show. Seems smart. Plus, now she does nothing for the rest of the episode and gets unfairly saddled with the guilt of Q’s demise because you just had to hamfist in his death.
ohoho but it doesn’t end there, no.
Penny, a man, takes away everything Julia earned HERSELF and locks away her path back to godhood (despite book Julia staying a goddess and becoming a Dryad) and then leaves her helpless and pointless sitting at home hoping everyone does okay, wrestling with her new existential crisis of being a weak, magicless human after all she did to get magic in the first place...and then Quentin dies, and because she’s so sad about him, suddenly she can do magic again! Weird internal consistency there considering how little is present in s4.
So Julia goes from a self-made woman, whose primary connections outside of her childhood friend are other women, to a woman whose whole life is now dictated by men. Important choices are made for her, she is passive in a crisis about her friends, and then her breakthrough to regain magic is...because of a man.
(BTW Kady also breaks down and decides she’s all about Penny, even though she’s kind of already worked through this last year and had plenty of other stuff to do this season)
And since I’m talking about consistency, let’s glance at THAT can of worms, shall we?
First and foremost: the High King of Fillory shouldn’t be able to leave Fillory. Remember when that was a huge plot point that caused great angst for Eliot in season 2? And how it only stopped because magic went away so the spells involved no longer worked?
Let’s assume Margot was grandfathered out into the normal world, and further assume that an election still makes her High King, not Eliot. As soon as Ember’s Emanation snapped her back into Fillory, she shouldn’t have been able to leave until MAYBE she was ‘overthrown’ (which might have given a REASON for her to be overthrown, if her location on earth mattered)
Yet that’s not a concern at all. Margot also doesn’t really bother to rule much so. sucks. but whatever. Clearly they just wanted King Fen here. (Again, ‘king’, because ‘queen’ is weak somehow. ew girls.)
NEXT
Eliot. How do you mess up Eliot when he’s in like three episodes and barely in two of those? I don’t know but they did it.
Here’s the problem with his ‘darkest memory’ thing. It’s not that Eliot might have feelings for Q, this surprises NO ONE, it’s everything else about it.
First. Puzzle Quentin marries PEACH GIRL. He’s not married to Eliot, they just share an extremely deep bond. It’s pretty much explicitly nonromantic though, given that Quentin marries and breeds with some girl he never mentions nor appears to mourn again. He’s hit with a lifetime of feelings, and instead of thinking “I had a wife...and a child...what happened to my child?” he thinks “Gee, I should hook up with Eliot even though I’m bicurious at best.”
This. This is while he is self-professed to be in love with Alice, around the time of his fling with Poppy, and again, right after finding out he was married, widowed, and a father. This is when the writers decided to stage “Once, Quentin wanted to marry Eliot.” It just makes Quentin look fickle, unfaithful, and frankly some kind of addicted to relationships, like he’s terrified of not being in one.
But it’s also? Not a good look for Eliot. Because this season basically MOCKS his marriage to Fen. He’s shown to be affectionate to her, she is in the trio of the people that he loves (Margot, Quentin, and Fen) who he summons to protect him, but very very very little is spoken or suggested by him to be missing her or wanting to see her again, and more importantly, it doesn’t ring true for him to be ‘afraid of commitment’ or whatever it is he was suggesting by rejecting Q here.
Why? Because he already did this arc. Season 2 is all about him accepting his role of King (which they take away because lol) and more importantly, his marriage to Fen. He has to learn to accept monogamy and actually build feelings for Fen, eventually starting a family with her - that is tragically ripped from him by the Fairies. He then spends s3 with Fen as his wife and with a fake daughter, adventuring and questing and crap, and during the time the scene is set very clearly fine with commitment, as he’s actually in love with Fen at this point and not running away from the marriage. During this time he’s also totally cool with marrying another king for peace because he likes that guy, but I guess we should forget him because...I don’t know? He’s black, maybe?
By the way, he mentions how he ‘has sex with people’s boyfriends’ and shows the scene of his doppel getting it on with someone who has a boyfriend and ignores that he is actively cheating on Fen while he is doing this.
And the show makes fun of Fen mourning the death of her husband, and also implies something like Fen maybe didn’t really love him because she didn’t see herself as a person and was only raised ‘for the high king’ (nevermind she used to be a FU Fighter, they forgot), and that she’s dealt with losing her child TWICE now. Nah, she’s mostly for laughs because DAGGERS.
This is all done just to diminish Eliot/Fen so they can pretend Quentin was in a triangle with Eliot and Alice literally just to make it more sad when he dies unbelievably pointlessly.
Gosh.
Am I forgetting anything? Hm.
The library plot was garbage, but that ties into the dumpsterfire of s3 finale.
Oh yes. Isn’t it great when Marina is just a repeated trope forever? Ah, yes. Me too. I love when characters are super flanderized instead of being allowed to grow and change. All characters in Magicians basically just need to spin their wheels and retrace steps over and over until they die.
Ah yes.
Quentin, thy name is hypocrisy. You’ve been abusive to Alice for three seasons, and then you have the nerve to freak out at her over the keys? Sure it was a dick move, but honestly this only happened because you kept abusing Alice and manipulating her into loving you over and over. Because you’re a dick.
And let’s close out on that, I think, not on a bizarre rendition of Take on Me.
Alice, ex-Niffin, smartest and most talented and most capable mage they know, does not get any say when Quentin stupidly kills himself (by the way he only dies because for reasons known only to the writers he STOPS running and just stands there until he dies). She doesn’t throw the thing in WITH Quentin stopping the crisis before it happens (why were they moving so slowly when there was such a short timeframe? Just LOB EM IN, MAN! Alternatively wtf was the library still forcibly shorting people when there was a universal crisis and Zelda KNEW IT?)
Nope.
Our girl power season ends like this:
Julia loses her agency and has her life defined by the two main men in her life
Alice has no agency in how things play out in the mirror and has her life defined by the two (same) men in her life
Margot is told to ‘go cry outside or something’, and has fallen in love with a random white dude because she banged him once rather than literally let him die. This is character development, because none of the other relationships she’s ever had matter or affected her because they weren’t a romance.
Kady decides to define her life around the (dead) man in her life, until the other man in her life makes her realize he needs her still.
Fen is overthrown by some man offscreen
Zelda refuses to own up to the Library’s problems and try to fix them herself, and instead decides she’s going to pick someone else to do it for her. Also arguably she just sat back and let two men decide how the world would play out.
But it’s okay, guys. The Magicians is very subversive and not like other shows. The white cishet men aren’t main characters, and they proved that because Quentin died, and that’s WAY more subversive than the books, where everyone gets stories and endings that ACTUALLY MAKE SENSE FOR THEM and Quentin actually gets to eventually be happy.
But it’s not a suicide, because Quentin’s friends love him and therefore he had a good thing going, and Quentin has never ever missed or thrown away a good thing before.
Remember guys
it’s really realistic, because ANYONE CAN DIE IN REAL LIFE GUYS
OH MY LORD JUST GIVE US THE EMMY AND TELL US WE’RE PROGRESSIVE, PLEASE. WE’RE ALMOST THERE!
That’s season 4 of Magicians.
It’s bad.
#the magicians#the magicians season 4#magicians season 4#magicians spoilers#magicians season finale#ooc#long post#spoilers#rant#can't list the characters because it mentions them all
4 notes
·
View notes
Text
Lifeboat
The Magicians (mainly Queliot, but all ships on the show are canon)
Word count: 9.2k of ?
Chapter 1 of 3
Summary: After his family is massacred, Todd is given the opportunity to go back and find out why and how, and stop it from ever happening. (Alt. the todd is a time traveler au)
Warning: everyone’s dead, and everything that happened in canon (up to the end of season 3) is canon.
Sidenote: a super huge thank you to @eversall for beta reading this. Thank you!!
He stumbles across Jane Chatwin’s little clearing in the Fillorian woods shortly after being crowned king. The crown dangles from his fingertips, vague memories of it resting atop his father’s head flitting across his mind the closer to the tips of his fingers it gets, as he crosses the barrier. He only recognizes her because his family had described her and their heroics practically all his life. Remembers his father, former High King of Fillory, sneering at the ground and proclaiming her, “The ultimate anti-hero.” And when she looks up at him with shining eyes and a gentle smile, his other Dad’s words ring even louder. “Anti-hero or not. She’s the only reason we’re alive. So we’re thankful, El.” He can practically hear the two of them bickering as if they were standing right beside him, facing their past with him. But, of course they’re not. He’ll never stand side by side with them again. The crown in his hand, digging into his fingertips, is an unwelcome reminder of that fact. Jane clasps her hands in front of her. “Well,” she says, “Royalty. To what do I owe this honor?” He nearly scoffs. Honor? He’s only king because the rest of the Royal court was murdered, and he’d been off doing some meaningless task he can’t even remember. He’s only king because he’s the only option left. What honor does that belie? She tilts her head after a moment. “I see.” “I didn’t say anything.” “You didn’t need to, Todd.”
He blinks, unable to help the step back he takes. Forgive him if he’s wary of strangers, whether or not they’re heavily featured in his family’s stories, but said family was recently slaughtered by a group of well informed assassins. “You know my name?”
She nods. “You needn’t be afraid either. I wouldn’t harm you.” “Why not?” Shrugging, she turns her back to him and heads towards a plant in the back of the clearing. She hums thoughtfully as she picks up a pair of shears. “Because who else is going to fix this mess we’ve found ourselves in?” “I... I don’t understand.” Her shoulders rise and fall with a heavy sigh as she turns to face him again, the shears held at her side, “My dear. You’re going to save your family, obviously.” His heart practically stops in his chest as he rushes forward in three quick steps. He falls short, though, stopping suddenly. His family’s dead. Magic can’t turn back time. “That’s not possible.” “Of course it is.” “How?” “Honestly, it’s as if nobody’s told you who I am.” Before the week he’s had, he’d have laughed at the genuine offense she’s emanating at the thought of not being featured in his family’s stories. He used to laugh a lot. Kind of misses laughing at his father's and his aunts and uncles making petty, fond jabs at each other. He shakes his head, rolling his hands until the crown is sliding into the palm of his hand, the heavy stones each digging into the grooves of the skin there. It’s almost as if it’s trying to remind him that he’s not supposed to be king. That this isn’t his crown. Like the crown has its own mind and wants him to drop it, lest he wants to face its wrath. “You’re Jane Chatwin. The Watcher Woman,” he pauses, taking a moment to look down at the crown. His thumb runs over the largest stone, and he swallows thickly as he looks back up at her. “My father used to talk about how much he hates that you went for a pun. In your name.” She waves a hand, “The High King has a very limited imagination, is all.” “Had.” She tilts her head, hand moving up to rest on her hip. “I’ve met many people over the years, stumbling across the clearing.” She looks up at the sky through her eyelashes for a moment, before she snaps her gaze back to him, “Most of them speak kindly of the crown Prince’s infectious optimism. Why is it that I seem to be the only person missing out on it?” His hand forms a fist around the crown, and he nearly relishes in the sharp pain the gems shoot through his fingers. “Could have something to do with everyone I’ve ever loved being assassinated less than two days ago. Could also be the fact that I wasn’t even given time to mourn them before I was hounded by every member of the royal court insisting it’s ‘time to take the crown, Prince Todd.’ But you’re right.” He loosens his grip on the crown and takes a deep breath, before letting the all too familiar Royal Smile (trademark pending, of course) settle on his lips with ease. “I’m the king now. I should be playing the part of the happy king. I apologize.” She purses her lips before taking two steps forward and pointing at him. “Todd, my darling. Might that smile be real if I told you I’m going to send you back?” “To the castle? Probably not. They’re still cleaning blood off the throne room walls.” “No,” She pauses, furrowing her brow and dropping her hands to her sides, “Can’t they cast a spell to clear it up?” “The castles alive. It doesn’t want to let them go.” And neither do I. “I imagine you relate to the castle in that respect.” She clears her throat and continues on, “Back to the topic at hand. I’m going to send you to the past. Earth’s past, specifically.” “I’ve only been to Earth once,” He says, without meaning to. It’d always been a point of contention between him and his family. He wanted to see where they came from, but they couldn’t go back, and wouldn’t risk him not coming back. “After Margo died, none of them saw any point to returning. Why would I go there? They died here.” “The answer to your families fate isn’t in Fillory, Todd. The answer is in the past, on Earth. You’ll be a spy for the future. Look for who they upset, who they fight. What shortcuts they take to save the world. All of that.” She pauses, before offering him a soft smile, “You’ll get to know your mother.” “I knew my mother,” He mutters, bringing his other hand up to the crown, and rubbing at one of the larger jewels with his thumb. Jane clicks her tongue. “Dear boy. She died when you were a toddler. I —“ “My father's made sure not a day went by that I didn’t learn something new about her,” He interrupted, voice hard as his thumb nail scraped over the face of the jewel. “And I won’t stand here and have you beseech her memory. Or theirs for that matter.” Jane stares at him for a few long moments, her fingers tapping at her waist, before she nods, once—perfunctory. “Well,” She says, “If there were any question as to which of them were blood, that’s certainly gone.” “What?” “Eliot. You and he share a temperament.” His thumb slides off the crown and to the side, digging into the rough edge of it. “You think I’m like him?” He asks, soft. “It’s uncanny, really.” His chest tightens but he nods once, chin tilting down so he can look at the crown. “Thank you.” “Of course.” She claps her hands together, and he jerks his attention back to her, his thumb clumsily sliding off the smooth jewel and scraping against the side of the crown. “Now. I’ve already alerted Henry to your arrival—“ “Wait—I’m. I’m going now?” “Obviously.” “But I’m king. I can’t just—I have to prepare my people. And I—I don’t know anything about earth! Or about those times! I won’t fit in and I—“ She moves forward and gently grabs him by the shoulders, eyebrows raised high. “Quentin’s anxiety is infectious,” she says, “But best not let it overwhelm you. You’re going back in time. Whatever happens, if you do what you’re meant to do, will all be erased. When you come back, your family will be alive.” “All of them?” “All of them.” “Even my mother?” She makes a face, before shrugging. “Possibly.” “And Uncle Penny and Aunt Julia and—“ “And Kady, Alice, Josh, and everyone else. Your family’s death,” She pauses, her mouth settling into a thin line as she looks away, shaking her head. “Was not meant to happen.” She lets go of him and takes two steps backwards. “If you want to set things right, you have to do it now. They’re coming for you. We have to send you back before they find you.” “They?” She nods. “Can’t tell you too much, I don’t want to affect anything. But if you don’t go now, you’ll die. And you won’t be able to save anyone.” He watches her, swallowing thickly. Part of him is ready to turn around and head back to the castle. Wait for them—whoever they are—to find him. Let them kill him so he can find his family in the underworld. So he can be with his dads and his mom. If he lets them kill him they can all be together again. But that wouldn’t make his family proud. And that’s the catch, isn’t it? Being torn between having them all again and making them proud. If he does this, goes back and watches their lives from the sidelines to try and see who killed them, he could screw everything up. Ruin it all. He could get them killed sooner. He— He could be the reason they die. But he’d also get to meet his mom before she got sick. Watch her become high king. Make her proud, too. He can’t do that if he’s dead. If he lets himself get killed, he’ll run into her arms in the underworld as a disappointment. He clenches his jaw and drops the crown. With it, the weight bearing down on his shoulders and chest eases and he squares them, defiant. “How’s this going to work?” He asks. “What do I need to know?” She smiles, glancing down at the crown sinking into the grass. “No affecting anything, unless otherwise stated by Henry—“ “Right,” He nods, then pauses, “Who’s Henry?” “Dean Fogg?” “Oh. My family has complicated feelings about him.” “I can imagine.” She nods to herself before continuing, “If there’s something you’re meant to do, he’ll let you know. Otherwise you’re not meant to actively be a part of their lives. Listen closely. Pay attention. Use your training to be King to your advantage.” His heart drops. “I can’t talk to them?” “I can’t stop you. But it’s not recommended.” So he’s going to talk to them. Talk to her. “Okay. What else?” “Pretend you belong.” “I don’t even know how people on earth dress—“ “Henry will have clothes for you.” “--or how they talk—“ “Exactly like your parents.” “Oh.” She laughs, soft and takes a deep breath. “Are you ready?” “I mean, no. Absolutely not. But we’re on a clock. So I don’t think I have a choice.” She nods again, chuckling as she moves forward and cups his jaw. “One day you will make a spectacular king. But not today. Today you get to be a child.” She raises her eyebrows before leaning forward and pressing a kiss to his temple. “Good luck, Todd.” And before he can even pull in a breath to ask how everything’s going to happen—the world around him starts spinning until he falls to the ground on something soft. Warm, and soft. His eyelids flutter open, blink rapidly as he tries to collect himself. A bright light shines down on him from the left, and he lifts his hand to block it out until his vision clears up and his surroundings aren’t blurry. When everything eventually comes into focus, he pauses, his hand slowly falling to his side as he pushes up on his knees. He glances down, eyebrows furrowing at the sight of a blanket, and the feel of the cushioning of the bed beneath it. Not the ground, then. He looks back up again, quick, as he recognizes the room he’s in and takes a fast breath as he stumbles off the bed, crawling through the blankets. He takes a step off, his leg tangled up in the blanket, and falls face first onto the ground with a loud crash. He jumps back up, huffing out a breath, and continues his way across the room, barely able to even register the searing pain of his entire face. His hands come up to rip the curtains open, sneaking in through the gap that the sunlight bleeds through, and jerking them apart so fast the bar almost comes out of the window. His hands fall to his side, as all the air he hadn’t realized he’s been holding in eases out of him, slow. His heart pounds frantically in his chest. It’s Brakebills, in the distance. He’d only ever seen photos before, but he’d recognize it anywhere. When you spend your entire childhood dreaming of a place, it’s hard not to recognize it. His dads would be so pissed if they knew. Turns out there’s a benefit to being orphaned: no getting in trouble. Without meaning to, he reaches up, fingers grazing against the smooth glass of the window. He’s within reach of Brakebills. He’s so fucking close, he could cast a spell and be there. Technically, he’s already there, though, isn’t he? He’s in the physical kids cottage. He turns around, as he remembers exactly where he is, and his heart starts pounding against his chest again as he steps away from the window. His legs go wobbly as he looks back at the blanket, now tangled and half hanging off the bed. He’s seen it before. In pictures. Oh god. Oh god. He’s not sure he’s ready for this. And obviously, like everything else in his life, because he’s not ready—the door bursts open. The girl—the woman—stands there, glowering eyes moving from him, to the mess of her bed, and back to him. Her head tilts, slow and cautious as she narrows her eyes and points a perfectly manicured nail at him. “What the fuck do you think you’re doing?” She asks, finally stepping into the room. Her movements remind him a predator stalking her prey. “I—Uh—I. Got. Lost?” Her eyes narrow even further, which shouldn’t even be possible—but she’d been a king for a reason, and it wasn’t because she was all sugar and sunshine and rainbows. “And getting lost equals fucking up my bed, how?” “... panic?” He’d always imagined getting to talk to her. Her hating him hadn’t ever been a part of what his mind made up for him. Eyes burning, he takes a step back as she advances. He wills himself not to cry. He can’t. This is his mother. She’s alive, and she’s not just well. She’s— She’s fucking beautiful. “Are you new?” He blinks. “Y—Yes,” He says, nodding emphatically, “That . . . is what I am. I’m. New.” To this school. To this world. To this time. Nobody can say he lied to his not technically dead, but actually dead mother, that’s for sure. “Well, new kid,” she finally stops, crossing her arms over her chest and cocking a hip, “I’ll generously give you five seconds to get the fuck out of my room.” She pauses, pulling one hand away and raising it in the air, “1.” Todd takes a careful step closer to her. “2.” A second finger pops up beside the first. She’s shorter than he imagined. Angrier. Still beautiful. She’s somehow more than he’s spent the majority of his life imagining. She’s got a ferocity he hadn’t expected—even if both of his fathers had gone on about it incessantly anytime she was brought up in conversation. And Uncle Penny’s numerous drunken exclamations of how wondrously bitchy she was — which was always said with a fond smile, and a far off look in his eyes.
None of it could have prepared him for how absolutely regal she is. And she’s not even royalty yet!
“3.” The third finger conjures a brief memory, fuzzy and barely there at all, from when he was a toddler, maybe four? She’s older. Staring down at him. But her lips are quirked, like she finds whatever he’s doing humorous. And just as quick as it’s there, it’s gone. He moves faster, barely makes it to the space in front of her before she shakes her head and drops her hand to her side. “Hang on,” She says, taking a step back, and flicking her gaze over him. “What the fuck are you wearing?” He frowns, looking down over himself. Fuck. Why hadn’t Jane let him change out of his coronation clothes? He looks back up, making a face as he pulls his arms around himself self consciously. He finally gets to actually meet his mother, and he’s wearing the ugliest, itchiest clothes the royal cabinet could find for him. Abigail and the rest of the cabinet suck, so hard. He clears his throat and shrugs a shoulder. “I’m . . . not from here.” A king he may be, but there’s a reason he wasn’t done training before the massacre. It’s because he’s an absolute shit liar. Jane didn’t think this plan through, at all, did she? “Alright, not from here, where’s your accent?” “Not everywhere has an accent?” She watches him for a moment before rolling her eyes. “Okay. Where were we? 4?” He nods, once, and darts out of the room, flinching as she slams the door shut behind him with a wave of her hand. Taking a deep breath, he leans against the wall and lets his eyes slide shut. His hands tremble at his sides. Even if he had any intention of abiding by the ‘don’t talk to them’ rule, that’s a little difficult when he crash lands in his dead mother’s bed, isn’t it? He opens his eyes and looks up at the ceiling, narrowing his eyes. His first interaction with the woman who gave birth to him in sixteen years, and he’s wearing a ridiculous smock of an outfit, and she has no idea who he is. He shoves away from the wall and clenches his hands. * Dean Henry Fogg is an asshole. When Todd appears in the doorway of his office, Dean Fogg sighs heavily, motioning for him to come in with a lazy, albeit reluctant, wave of his arm. And as Todd takes the seat across from the desk, Fogg pulls out a flask of whiskey and takes a long, impatient drink from it. He screws the cap back on and shoves it in a drawer in his desk and glares at Todd like he’s not quite sure what to do with him. “Do you know,” He says after a few moments of heavy, awkward silence, “how many times I’ve had to live through these delinquents’ failures?” “Sorry?” “40 times,” Fogg continues, as if Todd hadn’t spoken at all, “And now I learn that on top of the time fuckery I’m already dealing with, I get a call from Jane to tell me that there’s another layer—except this one’s from the goddamned future.” He picks up a pen, grips it in his hand tight like he’s trying to force all his anger and frustration at life into it. “I’m getting real sick of your family.” Todd blinks once, twice, before nodding and shuffling uncomfortably in his seat. “I’d give anything to have 40 lifetimes with them,” He pauses, furrowing his brow, before adding, “Sir.” Fogg doesn’t even seem to realize the implications of the statement. “Look. Todd. It is Todd, isn’t it?” “Yes. Todd C—“ “I don’t care. Can you do magic?” Todd clears his throat and nods. “I—have a limited knowledge? Aunt Julia tried to teach me to the best of her ability, but Dad and—“ “Still don’t care about the details, Todd. Odds are they’re not even going to succeed this time. None of it matters.” Todd blinks again, shifting forward in his seat, and tilting his head. “I’m sorry. But I’m from the future, remember?” He squints his eyes, making a face, “In my future, they succeed. They defeat the beast, and a number of other magical, and non—magical foes. They become legends. All of them. They’re heroes. And—disasters, as my father would say. They’re imperfect, but they—“ “Alright. I get it. You can stop waxing poetic about the bumbling buffoons I’ve watched fail over and over again.” “You don’t speak of them in that way,” Todd hisses, anger rising like bile. “You’ve made your fair share of mistakes as well, sir. I know all about it. You do not get to talk about them as if they’re the only ones to make mistakes. My family risked everything to save magic. To save everyone. Including you.” He pushes up from the chair, and the tone of his voice falls, deeper, and more regal than he even realizes he’s capable, “It would be wise to remember that.”
Dean Fogg only raises an eyebrow before barking out a laugh and leaning back in his seat. “You’re Waugh’s kid, aren’t you?”
“I thought you didn’t care.”
His lips quirk, as he bobs his head, “Well. She did say I’d be dealing with a king.” He tilts his head, then, frowning. “Though in the past Fillorian kings have been…”
“Useless and an unjust burden placed on my people?”
“Both of your parents are from Earth.”
Todd nods. “And this is only my second time here. I am Fillorian, no matter my heritage. My people are in Fillory.”
“Then why are you here?”
“My people,” he says, soft as he leans back in his chair, “Have my spirit. I will give all that I need to, to ensure not only their survival but their happiness. But my family,” he swallows, thick, and lowers his gaze to the top of the desk as his fingers fidget in his lap. He can almost feel the crown in his hands again. “My family have my heart,” he adds, after a moment. “And no true king can rule without his or her heart.”
Dean Fogg stares him down, before he laughs again. “I take it back. You’re nothing like your parents.”
Todd’s gaze snaps back up. “What?” His stomach flips as he pushes out of the seat, shaking his head. “You can’t take that back. You said I’m like them. You can’t—“
“I meant that you’re actually smart. But sure, get offended.”
“My parents are—were… are? Are. They are smart.” He sniffs, his eyes starting to burn. “What is with all of you. Or—What is with you and Jane Chatwin talking about my family as if they are nothing more than pawns on a board you’ve placed? They are more than pieces you move to treat you whims. They are people. Incredibly loving, smart, people. And they don’t deserve—“
“Enough.”
Todd’s mouth snaps shit, and his lip twitches as he points a shaking finger at Dean Fogg. “I am the King of Fillory. You will not—“
“Not here you’re not. Sit the fuck down.”
So much for doing what his parents do whenever someone crosses a line they shouldn’t.
It makes sense. He’s not as intimidating as his father.
His dad says it’s because his eyes are too kind, that people can see the good in him.
At the thought of Quentin, a sharp pang of regret fills his gut. He regrets pushing him aside to follow Eliot around. Quentin was a good dad, too. But he wasn’t the High King. And all Todd wanted was to make his father, the High King, proud.
And in the end, he’d abandoned him again, in search of being something more than he is.
When he saves his family he’s got to tell Quentin he loves him. He misses the kindness. Misses his dad. Of course he misses Eliot, too. He’s spent his entire life idolizing him. Memorizing the way he walks, and talks. Learning to be just like him.
But now they’re gone, and Todd’s afraid only one of his parents knew he loved them.
He falls back into the chair with a soft plop and stares up at Dean Fogg. Neither of them say anything for a few long minutes. But he leans back in the seat, exhaling long and slow to ease the guilt and says, looking up at the ceiling, “Now what?”
“Now? I’ve got a shit load of paperwork, and you’re going to help. Then we’ll get you situated.”
**
The first time he sees him, is from a distance. His arms are overloaded with books Dean Fogg threw at him because “you’ll need these if you expect to learn anything” or something. He’d tuned him out in order to look over the covers of them as they were piled up. In fact, he’s gazing down at the cover on top of the stack, when he here’s a familiar laugh in the distance.
His head snaps up, just in time to see Eliot walking backwards, facing Margo and someone Todd’s never seen or heard about, grinning as he waves his arms around, probably telling some extravagant story he’s retold a thousand times.
Something in Todd’s chest pangs and he nearly drops all the books to run across the grass to pull them into a hug. His vision goes blurry, and all three of them turn into watery blobs until he can blink the tears away.
As he flips around to walk side by side with them, Eliot lets out another laugh, loud and boisterous and more than Todd could have hoped for. He takes a step towards them without meaning to, swallowing thick. “Fuck,” He breathes, turning his gaze back on the books.
Not yet.
Not until he can look at them without crying.
**
Quentin Coldwater has almost died – as far as Todd can tell – at least six times in the three months Todd’s been lurking around on the Brakebills campus. Which would be fine. Really. Okay, not really. Todd may know the future, but how many times does he have to hear second hand news of, ‘Did you hear what happened to Coldwater today?’ or ‘You will never believe what Coldwater did!’ before he stops having heart attacks? There’s only so much he can take of thinking his presence in the past has somehow altered everything so drastically that his dad is dead.
Ten years before he’s even been born.
And don’t get him started on having to see Quentin fawning over Aunt Alice.
If he ever gets back to the present, and his family is alive, he’s going to have to ask them why the hell nobody bothered mentioning that particular affair. Look. He’ll admit as much as any other human being who’s ever met her, Alice is beautiful. And inspiring.
But she’s his aunt.
And Quentin’s his dad.
It’s just weird, okay?
**
There’s a lot Todd expects when he walks down the stairs. His mother. Dressed in nothing but a bikini and chains?
So, so incredibly not one of them.
Like. At all.
His heart still jumps, when he sees them laughing and smiling together. Beats frantically in his chest, because this is the life he’s always wanted. The two of them. He knows how close they were. And he knows how deeply it wrecked Eliot when Margo died. And this is before most of the real troubles in their life begins.
So, when Eliot stands up wearing a goofy hat and ridiculous sunglasses, he can’t help but laugh.
Because he has never, in all his life, truly seen his father so absolutely, resolutely carefree. Even in halls of the castle, with Quentin. Even on trips, when he gets to pretend he’s not king, and he and Todd and Quentin just spend a few days out at sea, being a family. It’s a part of his father he’s never seen and it’s--
Well. It’s a get out jail free card for the future.
It’s also hilarious.
And he’s been here for four months. And they’re staring at him now. Eliot looks disgusted. Margo just looks bored. For a moment, he thinks, this is it. This is what it feels like to be on the outside of his own family. But, he’s smarter than people give him credit for, and if they find out he’s just eavesdropping trying to figure out who they’ve pissed off that’ll attack them thirty three years from now, he’s doomed.
So, he uses his eavesdropping to escape certain death. Okay, not death, because though they’re regal, they aren’t royalty yet. And Eliot does not have the ability to make that particular execution order, thank god, because his glares are terrifying-- a fact that does not change in the future-- and Todd does not doubt that he’d make the call without hesitation.
He grins, wide, and says, “Hey, so Ibiza!”
“Is a place.”
“That we’re going to.”
And it’s so clearly a ‘leave us alone’, but Todd’s stubborn. Thank his parents.
“I'm hearing Encanto Oculto this year is gonna be, like,” He pauses. What’s a phrase people of this time use? Oh! Right! “Off the chain. But you have to be invited by people who've been... and you guys have both been.” He’s not exactly sure at all what he’s talking about. It’s just clips of conversation he’s heard over the past couple days.
“Twice,” Eliot says, tossing his hat on the table.
Todd knows the frown on his face. But Todd is a king. And King’s aren’t scared of frowns. Even if his entire body is urging him to run back up the stairs and hide until they’re gone. He turns his attention to Margo, instead of darting out of the firing zone, and swallows. “Margo . . . you look so beautiful.”
She’s his mother. He can say it. It’s not creepy.
She smirks, glancing him over, until Eliot starts spluttering. And she says, all smooth, careful, “I got this.” Like she’s had to bat a thousand guys away every day for as long as Todd’s been alive. Which, considering the year, isn’t long at all because he’s technically not actually alive. She turns her attention back on him, blinking, “Tell me your name again.”
He supposes he should be thankful she doesn’t remember. He touches his chest, “Me? T--Todd.” He wants to remind her that she’s the one that named him, but holds that much back, at least. Because it’s not a reminder if she doesn’t already know.
“Todd,” And he can’t help the smile that eases across his lips at the sound of her saying his name, “Here’s the thing. Encanto Oculto is a solid week of sun, drugs, and magical art. Time stops, reality bends, and you fuck five times a day.”
. . . Okay. He doesn’t need to know about his mother’s sex life.
Oh god. Please no mental images.
“On a bad day,” Eliot adds.
And that is somehow so, so much worse.
He’d walked in on Eliot and Quentin once.
He knows his parents have sex lives.
He just doesn’t need to know about them.
He laughs awkwardly anyways, because if he does manage to get on this trip - because apparently that’s a thing he now wants - he gets to spend time with them. Which is something he does actually want. “Sounds awesome!” So long as he doesn’t have to see, hear, or acknowledge any sex they have.
“It is, Todd. It is awesome. But honestly, you'd end up in a corner alone. Bitter. Bumming everyone out. Like last year at the bacchanal.” He’s not sure what she’s talking about entirely, but it does kind of sting, how quickly she dismisses him.
As a child, he’d always known her to be kind. Patient. She was a great mother. Even when she was sick, she’d pull him up onto her bed, and run her fingers through his hair while she read a story, or used a spell to bring the words of a storybook to life. It’s one of the few real, tangible memories he has left of her.
It’s just jarring that that’s not who she’s always been.
She turns her attention back on Eliot. And he continues for her. “Poor… wait. What was his name?”
“Hmm… Todd.”
“Todd! How weird is that?” ”
He’s almost shocked by how in sync they are with each other. But his entire life has been filled with stories of how Margo was Eliot’s soulmate, from literally everyone who knew them.
So, it’s not so much shocking as it is terrifying to be on the side that gets beat mercilessly.
He doesn't even know what’s about to happen. Just that, he’s definitely going to end up walking away with tail between his legs.
God, there’s a reason he wasn’t ready to be King.
“Todd,” Eliot repeats, this time to pull Todd’s attention towards him. Speechless, and so unsure of what the hell is actually about to happen, Todd obliges, “You don’t want to end up like the other Todd.”
“What . . . happened to him?”
Eliot looks down like he feels bad, and before Todd can even think that oh, maybe this isn’t going to go how he expected, Margo picks up the invisible baton and carries on. “He just wasn’t meant to be there,” Right, okay. No mercy for the living, it is, “He moped and whined and brought everything down.” He’s not sure he feels about his mother thinking he’s anything like his fictional alter ego, but he doesn’t say anything, just lets her go on, “Okay, we were a little wrecked, and for fun, someone--Someone not us…”
“No. Not us.”
God, they’re terrifyingly sinister.
“--turned Todd into a pig.”
“And we ate him.”
Todd pauses, expecting them to laugh. But they don’t. And an unexpected, confused, awkward laugh bubbles out of him. But they stay stoic and scary, and suddenly he doubts that they’re lying to him at all as he grabs onto the banister. “Wait--are you guys messing with me right now?”
Margo--his mother, should the world need reminding--looks him over. Like he’s a piece of meat.
Unsure of what else to do, or say, because his parents are actually terrifying and no amount of Royalty is going to make him any less terrified that he’s going to actually get eaten before he’s even been born, he says, “Okay . . . I’m just. I’m going to… I’m…” And darts up the stairs before they actually decide to murder him.
At the top of the stairs, he hears them burst into laughter, as he falls against the wall and holds his hand to his chest.
Maybe this is the real reason Jane told him not to make contact.
Because his mother is somehow more terrifying than both his father's combined.
**
He’s not sure how he gets into helping Margo with the Gin, all he knows is he walked by a hall closet, heard something he prefers to have not heard, and was dragged into the livingroom by a livid, frustrated Margo Hanson.
And she may be snappy and irritated, but he catches glimpses of his mother.
So when Eliot and he-who-is-definitely-the-beast appear and Margo says, “Todd was more helpful than you,” he thinks this is the moment that he can finally become a part of the group. But he’s barely taken two steps when she looks at him, deadpan, and says, “Don’t.”
Which, fair.
But then, the Genie takes Eliot’s boyfriend -- who Todd is still debating telling them all is definitely the beast, because wow the trauma that unfolds from this particular thread is a hefty load, and a story his family doesn’t exactly like retelling, for obvious reasons -- and Todd finally gets to claim his place.
Because his family is smart. And they made him learn a whole lot in preparation of becoming a king.
And Arabic may not be his best language, but it does have Margo dragging him along to help.
Is it weird that his mother actually wanting his company, even if to use him for something, is the best part of his year?
**
“You wished my boyfriend away!”
“Boyfriend? He’s random cock!”
… And that is Todd’s cue to go find beast-boy because any talk of cock from his parents is so far out of his league it may as well be 33 years ahead of even his future.
Stumbling across the beast giving a doorknob the equivalent of a blowjob, is somehow simultaneously the most hilarious and confusing moment of his life. He wonders if his family ever realized, after discovering the truth, that they’d made the beast give a door a blowjob.
When he saves them he has to figure out a way to let them know. Like, maybe, “Hey your life was shit at this point in time, but did you ever consider the hilarity of the fact that the beast was trying to murder you, and in doing so, ended up humiliating himself?”
But then again it did send Eliot down a particular downward spiral that makes it onto the list of Things We Must Never Mention.
Like Margo’s death.
**
“Todd!”
Shit. Shit. Shit. They know he’s eavesdropping. He just needs to play it cool. He walks into the livingroom, thumbs tucked into his pockets. That’s casual, right?
“It’s your lucky decade. Pack a swimsuit.”
What?
“Seriously?”
She nearly rolls her eyes. “Ground rules: you need to fit in, so don't talk.” He can’t really argue with that. He’s still getting the hang of figuring out how people talk on Earth. In this time.
He opens his mouth to respond, but Eliot’s rushing forward, and grabbing onto Todd’s shoulders. He flashes back to the first meeting with the kingdom Loria, when both Eliot and Quentin had pulled him aside to tell him no matter what happens they’re proud of him and how far he’s come. Wills himself not to get emotional. “See that she hydrates, wears sunblock, and waxes. Mama's down south can get jungly.”
… Nope.
If his parents don’t stop giving him mental images he does not need, he might actually burst into tears. And for once, not the my life sucks and I’m traumatized tears, but more the, oh god the images won’t leave my brain, tears.
“And you’re in charge of the genie,” Margo adds, tossing him the bottle. He nearly drops it in his haste to catch it, but it’s okay.
Because he’s going to spend time with his mother.
**
It takes two days in Ibiza for him to fuck everything up.
Margo’s drunk, but calm and relaxed, lounging on the beach, staring out at the ocean, a cocktail in her hand, and a man fanning her with a giant leaf. Todd should be doing literally anything other than what he is doing. Which is, effectively, just gazing at her from his towel. Admiring her.
He assumes that when he was a baby that she had days like this. Days where she could just be. He doesn’t doubt that at some point in his childhood, he got to sit with her. Maybe on her lap. Maybe they watched a Fillorian sunset or two together. As mother and son. Maybe she ran her fingers through his hair, and pointed out things on the horizon. Maybe he got to have real moments like this.
But he doesn’t remember. He was too young. All he has are the memories of when she was sick. Of nights in the dark, and days in the castle staying by her side. Or of healers ushering him away.
Of her final days.
Eventually, she notices him staring. And really, that’s when it all goes to hell.
She sighs, dramatic, and pushes her sunglasses up so they’re resting atop her head. She raises her eyebrows, all drama -- which he’s learning is her default -- and lifts one shoulder. “Why are you looking at me like that?”
His eyes dart left to right. “I’m . . . not looking at you in any particular way.”
She scoffs. “You’re looking at me like I kicked your dog or something. What’s the deal?”
“No deal. I’m--I feel bad for the leaf waving guy.”
“Seriously?” She asks. He nods, and she rolls her eyes, shuffling to sit up. She waves one hand lazily, and the guy fanning her with the leaf sets it down and walks off. “Has anyone ever told you you’re a terrible liar?”
Yes. Literally everyone he’s ever met. Including King Ess of Loria. But that’s irrelevant. Mostly because his opinion is irrelevant to every topic known to man.
He’s probably the only person less ready to be King than Todd and he’s been King two years longer than Todd has.
“Nope. Because I’m honest. Like a beaver.” He’d met a beaver once. Apparently it’s a part of their moral code to never tell a lie.
She narrows her eyes, before leaning to the side of the lounger and picking up the bottle with the Djinn in it. “That’s not an expression. And I’d suggest telling me the truth. Or I can make you. It’s really up to you.”
“Is it, though?”
“Nope.”
He huffs, nodding to the jar. “Shouldn’t you have given that to someone by now?”
“They didn’t want it.”
“Oh.”
She raises her eyebrow, “Come on. Out with it. You should be out fucking everything that breathes. Instead you’re staring at me. Which is usually fine, I am a sight to behold, but you’re not supposed to be sad when you stare at me. It’s creepy.”
Oh. Well, at least she’s blunt. “I wasn’t trying to be creepy.”
“I got that. Doesn’t mean you’re not.”
He lets his gaze drop back down to the sand, fiddling with the towel. “I’m sorry,” He says, softer. Sometimes it’s hard to pretend. He can’t help it. It doesn’t matter that he’s been here close to half a year. Doesn’t matter that he still hasn’t come in direct contact with Quentin or most of the rest of his family. Doesn’t matter how many times his mother and father both push him aside and remind him that they’re not his parents yet.
“Oh for--” She cuts herself off and he looks back up to find her shuffling to the end of the lounger. “What the fuck is wrong with you?”
“It’s nothing. Really.” He offers a grin, waving a hand lazily, “Just homesick.”
She narrows her eyes until their thin slits, and taps one nail against the bottle, a sharp clink sounding between them. “I’ll give you one more chance to tell me the truth. I really don’t have the patience to play games.”
“I am—“
She scoffs, shaking her head, and pulling the bottle up into her lap and popping the cork in on fluid motion. If they weren’t surrounded by magicians on a private beach, he figures she’d have hesitated. But the genies appears, and a few people around them coo with jealousy, but nobody really reacts.
She stares at him, and the Djinn turns to him slowly.
“Come on—“ But the Djinn grants her silent wish, snapping his fingers as he appears, standing beside him, arms crossed.
Todd’s mouth falls open.
Did she seriously—
“If this actually works, you can’t lie to me.” She leans forward, resting her elbows on her knees. “What’s really going on here? Out with it so we can go back to having fun.”
Jane’s going to kill him. But Todd’s only so strong. Because the Djinn reaches down, touches Todd’s shoulder, and the words come tumbling out; “It’s just jarring how much you’re like her, while not being like her at all.”
She tilts her head. “Explain.”
“My mother.”
“Why is me not being like you—do you have some kind of weird incest thing? Is that why you haven’t found someone to fuck?”
“No!” He exclaims, pushing up to his knees, only flinching a little as the Djinn’s fingers dig into his shoulder. “God, no!”
“Then what the fuck are you talking about?”
He tries. He really does. He clamps his mouth shut, swallowing the words that will themselves to the top of tongue, down. If he can’t not tell her the truth, then he can just opt for silence.
Which, apparently not. Because the Djinn’s grip tightens, nearly breaking skin, and instead of crying out in pain, he finds himself blurting it out;
“You’re my mother! Okay? You’re my mother! Ow! Fuck! Let—“ he struggles against the Djinn until it let's go and he jerks away, crashing into the sand on his side. He stares down at the sand beneath him, willing himself not to cry.
Because there’s no doubt that he’s just ruined everything.
Not only is he not going to save them in the future, he’s probably going to get them killed in the Now.
His fingers dig into the dirt as he swallows down the limp in his throat, fists filling with sand. He expects her to yell at him, maybe call him delusional. But she’s completely silent.
Only after he realizes she’s not going to say anything does he look up. Her elbows are still on her knees, but her arms are crossed at the wrist, dangling in front of her, and she’s staring at him with an inscrutable look on her face.
He sniffles, chin trembling as he turns his attention away from her.
“That’s not possible,” she finally says.
He shrugs a shoulder, silent.
There’s shuffling, and he can see movement out of the corner of his eyes, but he doesn’t realize she’s moved until she’s sitting on the towel next to him. “How’s that possible? My wish was that you had to answer my questions honestly. So you’re not lying.” She clicks her tongue and pokes him, roughly in the side. “Tell me how that’s even remotely possible.”
He shrugs again, shuffling in the sand to sit up straight. “Maybe I’m just a really good magician and can —“
“Cut the crap, Todd.” She hisses, “What the fuck is going on?”
“I can’t tell you,” he whispers. “I can’t, Margo. Just—please.” Finally, he turns to look up at her. He can feel the tears streaming down his cheeks, and he’s sure he looks as much of a lost child as he is, but he doesn’t know how to fix this. “Please, trust that I’m not here to do anything—anything bad. I just can’t tell you.”
Her gaze softens, but she clenches her jaw and shakes her head, waving a finger in his face. “No fucking way is that going to work on me. What the fuck? You think you can just say that I’m—that you’re—“
“I didn’t want to!” He says, desperate, twisting and turning until he can kneel in front of her hopelessly. “You’re not supposed to know. None of you are!”
“None of—“ she breaks off, shaking her head with a furrow of her brow, “None of who?”
His mouth falls open. “I—can’t.” It comes out as more of a sob than anything, broken and aching. “Please.”
She purses her lips for a moment, staring him down before shoving herself up, sand scattering around her, and holding her hand out to him. “Get up,” she says, shaking her hand at him. “Now.”
“Margo—“
“You said I’m your mother,” she whispers, callous, “So you have to listen to me. So. Get the fuck up.”
“That’s not fair.”
“Life’s not fair, Todd. Get up.”
Dejected, he takes her hand, a memory of her taking his hand to walk through the garden flashing across his memory as she pulls him up. It’s gone in a beat, as she turns on her heel and drags him across the beach towards a booth. She opens it, shoves him in, and it’s only as he stumbles into a hotel lobby, does he realize it’s a portal.
“Damn it, Margo,” he says, flipping around to glare at her, “I—“
“Nope.” She grabs his hand again and pulls him through the lobby, into an elevator, and then down a hall until they get to a room, and she slams the door shut behind them. She locks it, turns to him and points at the bed. “Sit.”
“I—“
“Sit.”
He opens his mouth to respond, but she raises one eyebrow and he sighs. Turns around and sits on the edge of the bed without a word. Even before she’s his mother she’s commanding.
On the bright side, he’s finally getting the parenting from her he never got to experience.
She nods, once, to herself and moves to stand in front of him, crossing her arms and staring at him expectantly. “How am I your mother? How is it even remotely possible? You’re only a year younger than me.”
He stares up at her. Watches the crease between her eyes deepen.
And honestly. What’s the point of lying anymore? He’s already fucked it all up.
“I’m—I won’t be born for another ten years.”
“I have a kid when I’m thirty three? That is—“
“You’re technically the surrogate. But you’re also my mother. You guys—it was. It’s hard to explain. It’s not normal here, I think.”
She blinks, falling back to lean against the dresser behind her, her hands cupping the space between her hips and the wood of the dresser. “None of this is normal,” she says. “Like, fuck.”
“I know.”
She closes her eyes, takes a few deep breaths. Which, he can’t really blame her. He’s freaking out, too. Just, less.
Because he has no idea what to do.
Because Jane Fucking Chatwin sent him into the past without a map, or a way to keep this exact thing from happening. He keeps expecting to find himself back in the clearing. But on the edge of the bed he remains. No wonder why Eliot called her an antihero. She’s the most morally grey, asshole of a hero he’s ever met. And he was born and raised in a fictional land full of people setting out to be heroes.
“How—,” she breathes, “Why?” She opens her eyes, and for once he’s not the only one misty eyed and confused.
But somehow being the person to make his mother cry? Not something he’d like to add to his list of achievements.
In fact, he’d like to go back in time again just to make sure she doesn’t cry.
“Something happens,” he says, looking down just so he doesn’t have to see. He wrings his thumbs in his lap. “I have to figure out why, and how to stop it.”
“What happens?”
He shakes his head. “No,” he says. “I can’t—won’t—can’t.”
She does say anything for a long moment. But when she does, it’s no surprise. He knows she’s smart. Smart enough to figure something as small as this out. “Does someone die?” He nods, once, and she lets out a heavy, stuttering breath. “Shit. Is it me?”
He jerks his head up, eyes wide. “What?”
“What do you mean, what?” She scoffs, shoving away from the dressing and walking a path between the door and the bed, turning to walk it again as she reaches the end. She points an accusatory finger at him, “You’re the one who’s been staring at me all sad and shit. What the fuck else am I supposed to think?”
Can he tell her her actual fate? Can he even tell her what really happens?
Clearly he’s already said too much. He’s in too deep. But can he actually stomach telling her she’s dead?
He swallows and looks back down. “I can’t tell you what happens. It might affect the future.”
“If you think you’re leaving this room without answering my questions, you’re too dumb to actually be my kid.”
He flinches. She’d hit a little too close to home, there.
She stops pacing. “What was that?” She asks, moving to stand just a few inches away from him. “Why’d you make that face?” He shrugs. And she huffs angrily, moving forward to kneel in front of him, narrowing her eyes. “Why. Did you. Make that face?”
His jaw trembles as tears flood his eyes again, and he forces himself to look away. He can’t stand this. How could anyone expect him to? This is his mother. All he has of her are his memories. And Jane honestly expected him to come to the past and not screw it all up over his love for his mother? Or his fathers’? Or his family? They’re all dead. What the fuck did she expect from him?
He doesn’t realize he’s said it all out loud, or that he’s sobbing, until she’s pulling him into her, her arms wrapping tight around his back. The tips of her fingers dig into the back of his neck, and her breath hitches as she tugs him impossibly closer.
He’d never been given the chance after their deaths to respond. It’s all been a series of “What next?” Since the massacre. Of people guiding him to the next post, telling him who he needs to be and where he needs to go. A sea of numbness blocking out the trauma.
Even at the funeral, he’d been forced to play the stoic king.
And ever since he walked into Jane Chatwins clearing, he’s been playing the part of a stranger in his families lives. He’s had to watch them walking around, living their lives, unable to tell them. Unable to approach Quentin—too ashamed of how he treated him, even though this isn’t even his Quentin. Too scared to disappoint Eliot—despite this Eliot not being the doting, always-expecting King.
It’s too much.
It’s too fucking much.
Margo pulls away just enough to make him look at her. She tugs at the hair at the base of his skull, raising her eyebrows. “You’re not doing this alone,” she says. “We’ll figure it out together.”
“You—you can’t—“
“Fuck anyone who tries to stop me.” And she pulls him back in. “You’re my kid, Todd,” she says, “And when you calm down, you’re going to tell me everything. And then, we’re going to fix this shit. Because there’s no way on god's green fucking earth I’m letting you suffer this much. Not my kid.” She shakes her head, nails scraping against his neck. “Fuck that.”
“You don’t even—“
She pulls away again, squeezing his shoulder. “I have a son in the future,” she says, “And I know I put out some serious I don’t give a fuck vibes. And that right here, right now, I don’t actually know you.” She pauses, clicking her jaw, “But I have a god awful family, Todd. I have literally been left standing in the dust by my family. I’m not abandoning you. Whatever happens in the future, right now. I’m gonna be your mom.”
“You don’t have to—“
“Did you come out of my vagina?”
He grimaces. “I—“
“Well?”
“Yes…”
“Then you’re stuck with me. No future spawn of mine is going to suffer alone. So,” she nods to him, “Cry it all out. Because when you’re done we’re figuring this shit out.”
He stares at her. Tears brim his eyes, and she goes all blurry as he nods, once, before nodding again, more erratic. He pulls her in for the hug this time, finally allowing himself to breathe her in.
“I missed you,” he says, soft, as he closes his eyes.
Her only response is squeezing him tighter.
He’s fucked everything up.
But he can’t find it in himself to care. She’s younger, and more brash and reactive, but his mother is holding him.
Nothing else matters.
Not even the future.
For now, at least.
#the magicians#queliot#todd#quentin coldwater#eliot waugh#margo hanson#the todd is a time traveler fic
87 notes
·
View notes
Text
Pretending
I had too many feelings about the episode last night.. And my brain tried to compensate by thinking about Margo x Alice all day.
Basically how Margo feels about what happened to Alice.
ao3-link
It wasn’t supposed to hurt. Not this much.
Margo had lost people before. She had seen family members shrivel up from illness and die. She had known people who had just left without a word, leaving a gaping hole where they had been before. But none of those losses had felt like this.
With every heartbeat her name was ripping through her, like a jolt of pain making it impossible to breathe.
Alice.
Alice.
Alice.
Emptiness caused by the absence of the blonde girl had fallen over their group and Margo had to watch her two best friends grief. The one hell-bent on finding a way to bring her back. The other had completely forgotten about the kingdom he was supposed to rule. Insisting to spend money and resources Fillory didn’t have on a huge monument for the lost Queen.
With her friends completely taken over by the hurt that Alice’s death had brought, Margo tried to tell herself and the others by repeating the lie over and over that Alice had never been their real friend. At least not hers or Eliot’s. But her desperate attempts to convince herself more than the others didn’t make it any less true. Alice had been their friend. And Margo missed her. It had only been a few day and, god, she missed Alice. She longed for seeing the girl again. The way Alice used to adjust her glasses or how she fiddled on the seam of her clothes every time she was uncomfortable, how she straightened herself before giving an explanation about something. All those were things Margo wished she could experience at least once more.
On one of her strolls through the palace to get away from everyone looking at her with a mixture of pity and uncertainty if she was about to snap at them or their neck, Margo had found one of her jackets in the gardens. She figured it had been tossed their by Alice while she had taught herself the Rhinemann Ultra. When she had picked it up a whiff of her perfume had crawled into her nose and she would have broken down then and there, if it hadn’t been for the weight of the crown on her head that reminded her of her responsibilities she was carrying.
She only allowed herself to cry at night, the tears she shed for the girl were only meant for Alice, not for everyone else to see. They couldn’t see her weak.
When night fell over Fillory and the two moons wandered over the sky, Margo would lay in bed, silent tears rolling down her cheeks into the soft fabric of Alice jacket she had buried her face in.
As soon as she closed her eyes she could see it all again. Alice fighting against the Beast and she felt the stupid second again during which she had allowed herself to hope. To think that this Alice had a chance to win. But then blue flames had started to consume her body, her screams echoing over the clearing. The moment that had felt like an eternity as the Beast had gotten up again until Alice showed up again. How the moth escaped through the opened chest of Martin Chatwin and how Alice had turned towards Quentin the moment the dead Beast had fallen to the ground.
She hadn’t noticed it had been her who had screamed Alice’s name. Only when Eliot stepped closer, mumbling about how she had gotten her attention and the rest of her plan.
The stuttered words that had left her mouth, failing at trying to apologize, hadn’t sounded real to her. Her mind had been too consumed by the thought that she had never given herself and Alice a real chance. Her intentions towards the girl had never been genuine, and now the regret for pushing her away, for playing with her, was seeping through the cracks in her armor.
From the moment she had seen Alice tiptoe over the campus, hiding behind her books and glasses she had felt something for her. At first she had thought it was the mean girl in her that saw the perfect victim, but when Alice had rejected her the night at the party, it had actually stung. She hadn’t been prepared for carrying about anyone else besides herself and Eliot. It scared her that every time she heard her laugh, saw her smile she wanted nothing more than just be with her. Controlled by her fear she had pushed her away, tortured her,
Now the girl was standing in front of her again, blue flames flickering over her skin from time to time.
But then she spoke and her words: “You’re talking like you mean something to me.”, making her realize that this wasn’t Alice. She was gone. Her piercing blue eyes, now ice cold without any recognition. All what was left of her was the magic that had burned through her, had consumed the very thing that had once been kind, smart and kickass Alice Quinn. This was no longer her Alice.
The last look she managed to catch of her before Eliot stepped in front of her to shield her, was pleading, begging that a little part of her was still in there. Trying to find a part that could come back to her.
But then Quentin’s muttered words released the demon in his back and as it attacked the blast and Alice desperate screams made her shut her eyes.
And as she opened them again, Alice lifeless body was lying on the ground, burn marks on the earth all around her. Q kept calling her name and she watched him struggle on the ground trying to get to her as Eliot took him into his arms in an attempt to calm him down. His weak words pleading that she might still be alive made Margo’s world cave in and a wave of pain washed over her, threatening to drown her.
But she couldn’t allow the pain to take over. So every morning Margo got up, her eyes still puffy from crying, head aching from lack of sleep and a weight on her chest pressing on her lungs and her heart. She pulled herself together as much as she could and did what she did best. Pretended she didn’t care.
#the magicians#malice#margo hanson#alice quinn#im really sorry#this wasnt supposed to happen#not this sad#margo x alice
25 notes
·
View notes
Text
The Magicians - ‘Poached Eggs’ Review
By Ariel Williams
“When things happen, they leave a mark. Figuring out how to deal with it takes time.”
So our characters contemplate how to bear the weight of their trauma and, well, existence. And there’s a fun jailbreak. Typical Magicians episode.
Let’s start with the jailbreak. So they still need to get the last key from the underground. They figure out a way to do this, which involves Penny turning himself into a book to break into the underground library, then passing the key to the Nietherlands library, where another traveler will be to bring it back home. The problem is their second traveler (Victoria from the Beast’s dungeon) is rolling with Harriet (fake buzzfeed, anti-library girl). They need to get Harriet on their side, so they need Kady, who’s been locked in a mental hospital since her conversation with Astral Penny.
The jailbreak itself is lots of fun. Quentin and Poppy use their concerning level of knowledge about mental hospitals to get her out. Kady gets to punch someone. It’s all great. Except for Kady’s conversation with Penny, which is heart-breaking. Kady isn’t happy to hear about Penny’s part of the plan, that he’s once again putting his life on the line for everyone. And her exhaustion and frustration is kinda understandable. Because she’s right; Penny’s sacrificed for the group time and time again, and his last sacrifice got him pseudo-dead. At the end of the day, its Penny’s choice. But Kady still might not want to (and shouldn’t have to) watch him do it again.
In Fillory, Margo and Eliot go up against The Fairies. They almost have them with their kidnapping scheme, but then the Fairy Queen threatens Frey. Frey realizes, if family does mean loyalty like Fen says, then the fairies don’t treat Frey like family. So she betrays them and admits to Eliot and Fen that she isn’t her daughter. Turns out, their kid died at childbirth. Fen’s disappointed in herself, that she didn’t know, that she tried so hard to force Frey to be her family. Because she didn’t want to see the truth and she saw as a way of avoiding her pain. But that would have never worked, of course, which is what Julia realizes regarding her own trauma.
After Julia and Alice did their switcheroo (as Dean Fogg puts it), it doesn’t work as well as either hoped. Julia’s still haunted by Reynard. Alice can’t hold Julia’s magic; it’s killing her. Alice isn’t willing to accept her end of it. It seems that she sees magic as a way of finding herself again. So Julia has to stop her, before the magic kills her. Ultimately (after Alice accidentally almost kills Julia) Alice gives Julia’s magic back and they have a nice conversation about trauma and healing. Julia realizes there’s nothing magic about her pain, so there’s nothing magic she can do to fix it. She just needs time. Alice likely needs the same to figure out who she is and how to be.
It’s a small conversation, but I found it to be the most important part of the entire episode. Because that’s really the answer to a lot of the character’s problems. Quentin can’t magic his way out his depression, he just needs time to accept it and learn how to cope with it. Fen can’t use a surrogate child to fix her loss. And Kady needs time to deal with kind of losing Penny. It’s that cliché saying: “time heals all wounds.” It’s not fun or entertaining, but it’s likely got some truth to it.
Bits and Pieces
-- Time alone isn’t going to save Margo and Eliot from the pissed off Fillorian residents, though. They could really use some magic about now.
-- For a moment there, Frey was starting to hate Eliot less. Which was a nice family moment. Until, you know, it turned out they weren’t really a family.
-- Irene Mcallistair’s magic reserve turns out to be creature excretions you take like cocaine. Nothing fishy going on there.
Dean Fogg, regarding Julia’s reason for rejecting her magic: “I'll file it under ‘entitled Millennial bullshit.’” This was a funny line, but I’m still annoyed by everyone’s inability/refusal to try to understand Julia’s reluctance.
Fen: “We had the most wonderful adventure. We went to the Square of Time, where no one sleeps. And it's always light.” Frey: “A man urinated next to me.” Fen: “Then we saw bards performing on your famous Broad Way." Frey: “You call it Cats, but it's just humans in cat greasepaint.” Fen: “And we tried a delicacy called pizza at an eatery that was ‘Family Style.’”
Margo, threatening: “So have fun on the little egg hunt, 'cause if you don't make this deal, we're about to boil and dye 'em like it's motherfucking Easter around here.” Fairy Queen: “I don't know what that means.”
Vampire, when Julia comes to save Alice: “Get out.” Alice: “No, I gave you my money.” Vampire: “Not enough to deal with hedgewitch Buffy.”
Margo: “There wasn't a blood test to tell me to be High Queen. I chose it. And I have had to fight for every shred of authority. And no offense, but you can't understand, because it was handed to you. And now I'm supposed to abandon my kingdom? Those fairy bitches wanna come for my crown, well I'll shove it up their fucking egg-holes.”
Three and a half out of four Easter-egged fairy fetuses.
#The Magicians#Julia Wicker#Alice Quinn#Kady Orloff-Diaz#Margo Hanson#Quentin Coldwater#Eliot Waugh#Penny Adiyodi#The Magicians Reviews#Doux Reviews#TV Reviews#ICYMI
3 notes
·
View notes