#however: no one would go to hardhome. So at least theres that
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
what was mance’s actual plan in a scenario where he can take castle black and let all the free folk through the wall (i.e. if jon died before warning them). let them disperse into the gift and just. fend for themselves i guess? would his kingship have ended there? was there ever a plan more complex than “dont get turned into ice zombies” or was he just riffing the whole time. was he imagining some kind of treaty? maybe his plans relied on there still being a reasonable stark in winterfell lol. but it’s not like he can negotiate with the boltons or stannis… and the wildlings are so fractured they would IMMEDIATELY split off. like what would he have DONE if he won? was he doomed from the start??? someone please spitball with me
#ive been trying to crowdsource ideas about this for insane fanficky reasons but it’s like#cause the wildlings are not like. centralized he cant just keep them at castle black forever there are 100000 of them#he also would have. zero information about current northern politics#at castle black he’s in an ok position esp if he also takes the shadow tower but he still has stannis + some dregs at eastwatch#he could.. maybe.. take empty winterfell before the boltons ever got there but would it even help? there wouldnt be any food there#and the bolton coalition might even actually be bolstered if they had a common enemy lol#however: no one would go to hardhome. So at least theres that#i guess it would devolve into a chaotic mass migration scenario but mance is like. Clever and wily i cant imagine he didnt have a PLAN!!!#the smart move would be to take moat cailin before roose can come up but. To accomplish what exactly#i mean if everyone chilled repopulating the gift would anyone even care. you’re gonna massacre a hundred thousand civilian wildlings?#But stannis is the issue there he would not allow that he would want to reinstate the watch. hmmmm
26 notes
·
View notes