#hes an homage to older detective fiction but the films bring a different perspective
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Benoit Blanc's similarities to other fictional detectives
Specifically Holmes, Poirot and Columbo because I'm most familiar with them and saw many of their characteristics in Blanc.
Impeccable clothes - Poirot
Cigar - Columbo
Post-case slump - Holmes
Eccentric - Holmes, Poirot, Columbo
Detection as a means of helping people, not just for the sake of solving crimes - Holmes (and Poirot and Columbo to a slightly lesser extent)
Fun name – Holmes, Columbo, Poirot
Referred to by surname (almost) all of the time, even by close friends/partners – Columbo, Holmes, Poirot
Kindness to and deep respect for vulnerable women – Holmes, Columbo, Poirot
Said to be the best detective in the world – Holmes, Poirot
Fun American accent – Columbo
Hates rich people who abuse their financial influence – Holmes, Columbo, Poirot
Polite – Columbo (of course Holmes and Poirot can also be very polite but I don't feel like it's a defining characteristic for them the way it is for Columbo)
Rude to mean rich people in a way that is so polite the horrible rich people don’t realise they’re being made fun of/talked to rudely – Holmes, Poirot
Politeness and diplomacy that is often pushed too far and they explode into explicit anger – Holmes, Columbo, Poirot
Drama in resolution – all three to varying degrees, but especially Poirot
Understated and affable – Columbo
Involved in self-contained stories – Columbo, Poirot, Holmes (though a couple of Holmes stories do link closely to previous stories)
Uses the word 'afoot' – Holmes
Gay – Holmes, Poirot (I'll let you decide if this applies to Columbo)
#feel free to add to this or debate it (but kindly)#sherlock holmes#hercule poirot#benoit blanc#columbo#knives out#glass onion#acd sherlock holmes#obviously many of these were intentional and the films have a definite poirot vibe#like benoit blanc is a homage to other detectives but still fresh - i like that he is not the most central character for example#hes an homage to older detective fiction but the films bring a different perspective#i could maybe make this into a venn diagram but for ease it is a list#holmes doesnt necessarily help women get their revenge but he also doesnt stand in their way#like with kitty winter and then the women who shot CAM#actually im not too familiar with kitty winter's story so dont quote me on it but im pretty sure she fits the point im making#left out some obvious ones like 'consults with police' bc that's boring imo
934 notes
·
View notes