#good faith asks
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Note
Genuine question, and I don't know if you answered this previously, but how do you feel about the Palestinian citizens? Like, if you ignore whatever the fuck Hamas has going on and just look at the innocents, what are your thoughts on the genocide? Do you think Israel is justified in bombing the Gaza strip? If you think think that Israel isn't justified, what are your thoughts on the people that do?
I'm not trying to start shit or anything, this is all asked out of genuine curiosity, and there isn't a wrong or right answer (everything is objective when it comes to opinion based questions such as these)
have a good timezone
Dear anon,
My heart goes out to them and any answer that doesn't extend at least some compassion for people trying to survive in a dictatorship is wrong.
There is a middle ground between "these brown people don't understand how to not be antisemtic and not murder it's their CuLtUrE" and "All palestineans are complicit in hamas war crimes, even NO especially the refugees who weren't even in Gaza"
There is some normalcy and compassion that can exist between fetishization and racism
'your thoughts on the genocide?' STOP APPOPRIATING THE HOLOCAUST WHEN TALKING ABOUT GAZA.
You call it a genocide only because you don't want to call October 7th a war crime. Would you call the Iraq-Iran war a genocide? NO? Why not? Is it because the Jews aren't the ones doing the killing? I see.
"If you think think that Israel isn't justified, what are your thoughts on the people that do?"
I have spoken to those people. They feel like they HAVE to support the IDF to counter the "IDF belong in hell" Westboro baptist church style nonsense. It's kinda sad. PSA: you don't have to excuse your sides war crimes either.
I promise you if you can extend compassion for the Gazan civilian who bears some complicity in what Hamas does because they control everything in Gaza you can extend it to the average kahanist likudnik
Curent timezone time is: early morning
I am open about living in the southern us because I don't fake ethnicities for clout unlike my enemies
I WILL have a good morning
Cecil
#leftist brainrot#leftist hypocrisy#good faith#good faith asks#dear cecil#holocaust appropriation#holocaust inversion#people are not their government
33 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
I came across a post today by tikkunolamresistance (yeah, that alone should tell you what you're in for) linking to an article from last year titled 'Jewish settlers stole my house. It's not my fault they're Jewish' by Mohammed El-Kurd. And I was just struck by the sheer lack of self-awareness or accountability in it. This is an excerpt from towards the end.
'Here is where I stand. There is a Jew who livesāby forceāin half of my home in Jerusalem, and he does so by ādivine decree.ā Many others resideāby forceāin Palestinian houses, while their owners linger in refugee camps. It isnāt my fault that they are Jewish. I have zero interest in memorizing or apologizing for centuries-old tropes created by Europeans, or in giving semantics more heft than they warrant, chiefly when millions of us confront real, tangible oppression, living behind cement walls, or under siege, or in exile, and living with woes too expansive to summarize. Iām tired of the impulse to preemptively distance myself from something of which I am not guilty, and particularly tired of the assumption that Iām inherently bigoted. Iām tired of the pearl-clutching pretense that should such animosity exist, its existence would be inexplicable and rootless. Most of all, Iām tired of the false equivalence between semantic violence and systemic violence.'
"Centuries-old tropes created by Europeans" and "real, tangible oppression". I mean...for fuck's sake. Zero acknowledgement of the fact that the Palestinians were active participants in the oppression of Jews alongside those Europeans. Nor that the only reason he thinks of Jews being oppressed as not a "real, tangible" thing, is because they were forced to militarize to fight off those who would attempt to repeat that oppression.
Not to mention many of these houses were actually stolen from Jews. Like they killed and displaced us in our own land for centuries.
9 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
Againšu aren't actually answering my doubt at all.
You are saying Hindu lives matter in a Hindu dominant country.
And this is not a hate mail,a genuine question,I wanna see ur perspective as to why u are saying this.
Again I am actually proud of you for opening such a blog (I'll let u in on a thing...i follow u too) so no way in hell I am hating on u.
Rather I am happy to see someone take initiative to show the world,what Hinduism truly is and what's not.
You do realise that Hindus being a majority doesnāt protect them from being persecuted? You do realise that we were a majority when the Islamic invaders took over and they still oppressed us? You do realise that a few British people ruled over us even tho we were a majority? Also you do realise that there are Hindu minorities in countries like Pakistan and Bangladesh that are being persecuted and ethnically cleansed??
I appreciate you coming in good faith but like come on. Go through my blog at least once before coming into my inbox like this.
17 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
when people think delilah just completely takes over and laudna has no control. when people think jester is just an uwu child who has been manipulated by every man sheās met. when people think vex is an empty husk of daddy issues without her brother by her side. when people think fjord is an arrogant asshole who doesnāt pay attention to the party around him. when people think scanlan saying that vox machina doesnāt care about him is an accurate assessment.
#iām tired and i was bitching w a friend about this earlier but good grief.#cr fandom HATES when a character knowingly denies or portrays themself in a way that is false#but that fulfils the expected role the party/the fandom has dictated for them#whether the character is intentionally lying (vex and fjord esque) or has bad faithed themselves into believing what theyāre saying#(laudna and scanlan) cr very frequently plays with like . the character is saying this and itās not trueeeee#youād think the fandom thatās oh so willing to History Is Written By The Victors their way into validating wiping out all of the gods#because (checks notes) they do not fulfil the whims of every person who asks#might have a little more grace when it comes to doubting the characters words as always truthful or always well informed#critical role
1K notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
Many people say stuff about you. Like how you are sensative, annoying, an idiot, or just straight up bad person. How do you feel about that?
#iām so sorry this is the funniest ask iāve gotten in a very long time#and i donāt mean to make fun but i genuinely have no way of parsing if this is written in good faith or not#iām just elated#and i donāt know how to respond otherwise
29K notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
will peter be like an older brother to miles in lof ?
absolutely he is
there's about an 11 year difference between them (Miles is 14, Peter is 25), so it's a lot more like the older brother type of relationship that Peter has with Tim (despite Tim being his uncle). Peter has mentored(ish) other young heroes by this point (mostly in the Bats' universe) but since Miles is another Spider-Man, Peter takes up most of the responsibility in making sure Miles is safe and teaching him the ropes. That's HIS sassy child genius, thank you, and he's not a sidekick, he's Spider-Man.
He was also adamant that Miles tell his parents immediately, and gets along great with Rio and Jeff.
Which is HILARIOUS to me because at this point in time, Peter has built up a persona for the public eye just like the Bats did. In Rio and Jeff's eyes, they're gobsmacked that the clumsy, scatterbrained, and "scaredy-cat" kid that Tony Stark adopted a while ago is Spider-Man. (Technically, none of this is a lie. Because Peter is a terrible liar unless it's For the Jokes, and often comes across this way even if he hadn't meant to.) They're wondering how he pulled that off since he's the same age as Spider-Man, who is known to be an Avenger, and associates in the same circles as Peter. It helps that Peter and Spider-Man have been in a social media war, and that Peter works at the Daily Bugle that is known for disliking Spider-Man. Peter's been taking lessons for years atp to keep his identity safe. Which is also bonus points to Peter, because the two can tell that secret identities mean everything to him, but he told them who he was in a heartbeat (literally the very first thing he did when he found Miles).
In other words: Peter was ecstatic to become a teacher for his own matching superhero kid and it's one of the most important bonds in his life. That's his baby brother now!!
#erinwantstowrite#ao3#ao3 fanfic#leap of faith ao3#peter parker#leap of faith catch me if you can#leap of faith#miles morales#peter parker is a GOOD mentor#a great one even#he takes that shit so seriously despite it looking like he's always just telling jokes from an outside perspective#you know those folders you go home with when you're a kid#the ones where your teacher puts stickers and talks about how your day/week went and your homework#peter has one of those that's really just a journal written to make it look like miles is taking after school classes with him at SI#and miles has to give it to his parents to look over#āYou got three gold stars today!ā#āyeah 'cause i didn't get blown up :)ā#āthat's my boy!ā#rio was like āwtafā at first but she quickly was like āoh so if anyone is gonna help miles stay alive it's this kidā#thank you for the ask!
485 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
Can I ask how Vasco reacted to hearing about Macheteās assassination? :o did he put on a brave face? Was he inconsolable? Does he imagine that if he were there, he couldāve done something (even if that isnāt true? I imagine it would be tortuous mentally and emotionally for him, poor lad
He most likely went through a mental breakdown, followed by years of paralyzing grief and depression. Vasco had proven to be outstandingly resilient and optimistic in adversity, putting on a brave face was his second nature. But this was his final 'break the unbreakable' moment. He turned withdrawn and apathetic. He had never lost anyone this abruptly before, and he became visibly paranoid about the safety and health of his family while failing to look after his own wellbeing.
Of course he kept rewinding the events in his head and second-guessing himself about whether he could've prevented this outcome somehow, even when everyone who knew about his situation kept telling him there was no reason for him to blame himself for it. He struggled with the suddenness of it, and the lack of closure, and couldn't get over thinking how the love of his life had died alone, surprised, scared and in pain, and that there was absolutely nothing he could do to remedy that. Ludovica's support was invaluable to him. Since he couldn't mourn openly she was one of the few people who were there for him.
Eventually he came to terms with what had happened and learned to live with it, and even though he slowly regained his good-humoured personality, he never fully recovered back to his previous self.
#his relationship with faith also went through a number of changes#he was both viscerally angry at God#for never having helped Machete no matter how hard he had tried to be a good person and earn his place in the world#and then allowing him to get snuffed out so thanklessly#but he also started praying in earnest#because he was aching to do something to alleviate the situation and he was out of options#he hoped that maybe if he asked nicely he could bargain something back#and he was suddenly acutely aware of the fragility of life and worried about the safety of his living loved ones#and afraid of what was going to happen to Machete's soul now that he was out of his reach#and whether they would be able to reunite in afterlife or not#answered#anonymous#Vaschete lore#death#cw death#Machete's life is sort of a slow burn struggle#Vasco gets smacked with decades worth of trauma in one devastating blow without a warning
485 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
I know the color palettes are user submitted, but do you have any standards for them or anything? Because some of these are ugly as hell.
the standards are in the template and format. i think 'ugly' palettes offer a lot of value in learning and experimentation. exercising your brain by working with unconventional color palettes or even just colors you don't normally use can be very helpful i think!
#palette spam#im interpreting your ask in good faith but dont forget these are real human beings behind the submissions!
800 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
rewatching orymās visit with the wildmother and iāve just gotta say that some of yāall really let your personal christian trauma get in the way of a beautiful, heartbreaking, terrifying scene
#like my goodness not all religions treat people like christians do#in fact some of them have much more egalitarian conceptions of the relationship between god and human#some of them donāt even ask for your faith or belief to be a good person#critical role#critical role spoilers#cr spoilers#orym of the air ashari#the wildmother
669 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
about the "people are allowed to be cis" like i kind of get the optics & context but I do think it's important to recognize that a gender journey can end at the same place it started. Often-times it doesn't because the journey starts due to discomfort with one's gender but in my mind it's the same as questioning any other belief, it's good to do it even if you end up still holding that belief.
The 'problems' faced by cis people who have questioned their gender are not nearly as big as those experienced by trans people but it's still something that happens, particularly among people in trans communities. I think this idea also sort of intersects with the idea of people wanting representation, and the idea of somebody questioning their gender sort of implies they're going to be trans so then there can be disappointment.
Some of this is speculative, and i haven't seen the original post so maybe i'm missing something but your post really hit weird because it's not telling people they can be cis it's saying you can dip your foot in the pool of transgenderism and not go all the way in. Like obviously that's less urgent than people shooting at those in the pool but just dismissing it is kind of weird
people are told it is okay to be cis literally from the moment they are born. i dont want to be harsh but literally everything you're saying could be coming out of the mouth of a conversion therapist -- the current term used to sanitize conversion therapy in the UK is in fact "exploratory therapy". "well we shouldn't rush them into transness we should give them time to decide in case they're actually cis after all" is the #1 talking point undergirding the total annihilation of trans healthcare for young people in the UK. trans people are already told at every single step of the way that it's okay to change their minds and be cis. they are told this by parents and teachers and peers who say "it's just a phase". they are told this by media outlets panicking about """rapid-onset gender dysphoria""". they are told this over and over again by transohobic medical systems that tell them that they should think about whether maybe they're just autistic or gay or they need to have more sex. every single part of our brutally transphobic society is already screaming "IT'S OKAY TO JUST BE CIS" in everyone's ears every second they exist in it. there is never a need to add your voice to that chorus.
#tattletxt#nobody harass or yell at the asker here#im sure this was asked in good faith but im tired
1K notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Kingdom Hearts 3 - The Caribbean
#kingdom hearts 3#kh3#the caribbean#scenery#my gif#my favorite world in the game#it's so beautifully crafted and fun to explore#they did such a good job with port royal i'm no expert on the movies but i'm sure it's a super faithful recreation#there are so many lush islands to find with caves full of treasure. it's like a real pirate adventure#i'm glad that we're able to dive into the water because i really like underwater scenery and being able to freely swim around#i love sora's pirate outfit and that he gets a ship of his own to sail. he has such a blast in this world#the banter between sora donald goofy and jack while on the ship is a lot of fun too#big fan of how they integrated the organization's search for the black box with the chest that contains davy jones's heart#gotta love when the main story ties into the plot of a disney movie#the final cutscenes in this world are insane and so well rendered that they're almost indistinguishable from the movie#i sent screenshots to friends asking if they could tell the difference and they couldn't#not that i'm complaining because it really elevated the experience but why did they go so hard
426 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
genuine question, and I hope this comes across as good faith the way Iām intending. What would you say is the definition of blood libel? I was taught by my parents that it was a historical conspiracy theory that people spread claiming that Jews were mixing the blood of Christian children into matzo and was used as a pretext to persecute and murder us. Is there more history or meaning to it than that?
Dear anon,
that's the classical definition. The modern definition is " Jews accussed of murder to slander them" under this definition Leo Frank (and a black man) falsely accussed of killing a gentile white girl and being lynched for not getting the chair is also blood libel.
I use it in the sense of "using false accusations to discredit or kill them" so calling me an islamophobe so that anons can send me rape threats or claiming I raped someone or hurt their cat (things that have actually happened to me) would also count. But that's stretching it
by the ADL's defintion however the cat one wouldn't count
https://www.adl.org/resources/backgrounder/blood-libel-false-incendiary-claim-against-jews
https://www.adl.org/resources/blog/blood-libel-accusations-resurface-wake-oct-7
https://antisemitism.adl.org/blood/
yours,
Cecil
7 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
hi! its hindulivesmatter. just wanted to take out some time to thank you for your support. I've seen you in my notes all the time and you're always one of the loudest supporters of my blog, and I appreciate you so much! xx
Hey! Of course, the Hindu-Jewish solidarity tag isn't just for show. I'm as disgusted by hinduphobes taking notes from antisemites as you're disgusted with the other way round, and Hindu spaces have been one of the few ones to remain Jew-friendly, making Jewish spaces Hindu-friendly in return is the least we can do. I hope one day we'll wake up to our cultures fully decolonized and not under attack by a world that normalizes and glorifies Islamist imperialism.
9 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
This is a take I've seen fairly often- that trans men & mascs only think they experience transandrophobia because they refuse to accept that what they're experiencing is misogyny.
It's also a completely ridiculous take. The fact that trans men/mascs are targeted by misogyny is a fundamental part of transandrophobia theory. Trans men/mascs, and others who regularly discuss transandrophobia, emphasize over and over again the ways in which trans men/mascs experience misogyny. For example, the idea that they are women and therefore are too stupid and brainwashed to be trusted about their genders, or the sense of entitlement to trans men/mascs' bodies (how dare you ruin your perfect breasts, how dare you transition in a way that makes you unable to carry children, how dare you not be the beautiful woman i want you to be).
In fact, the people who deny that trans men/mascs experience misogyny tend to be the same people who argue against the concept of transandrophobia. They insist that trans men receive male privilege, and in fact actually benefit from misogyny rather than suffer from it.
When trans men/mascs point the ways that they are affected by misogyny, they are accused of spreading TERF rhetoric (as though acknowledging the ways in which people who were assigned female at birth are oppressed automatically means you believe in "sex consciousness" and "afab unity" against anyone assigned male at birth"), or accused of implying that trans women aren't affected by misogyny (they absolutely are, the belief that trans men and women can't both be affected by misogyny stems from oppositional sexism)
All this to say: The people who talk about transandrophobia are well aware that trans men/mascs suffer from misogyny, and aren't denying this out of dysphoria or internalized misogyny- they aren't denying this at all. The people who deny that trans men/mascs suffer from misogyny are the people who believe transandrophobia doesn't exist.
And, transandrophobia isn't "just misogyny." Misogyny is a crucial component of transandrophobia- again, no one who talkes about transandrophobia is denying this- but not the only component.
Trans men/mascs being denied access to gynecological healthcare (that cis women are able to access) because they appear to be men, or have their gender legally changed to male isn't "just misogyny."
Trans men/mascs to losing their friends, support, and abuse and mental health resources when they come out and transition, or reach a point of being "too masculine," isn't "just misogyny".
The belief that going on testosterone will make trans men/mascs dangerous and violent, and the negative rhetoric about bottom surgery, isn't "just misogyny."
Being called a gender traitor and accused siding with the enemy and only transitioning to gain male privilege isn't "just misogyny."
Trans men/mascs being impregnated specifically as a method of forcing them to detransition isn't "just misogyny."
Choosing to use a women's bathroom (either due to safety concerns or transphobic laws) and being kicked out or assaulted for looking male isn't "just misogyny."
Trans men/mascs getting violently attacked because "if you want to be a man so bad, I'll beat you up like one" isn't "just misogyny."
People who talk about transandrophobia very much recognize that trans men/mascs experience misogyny (and are trying to get people who deny transandrophobia to recognize this as well), and there are aspects of transandrophobia that go beyond "just misogyny." Neither of these things contradict each other. In conclusion, "'transandrophobia' is just misogyny but transmascs don't want to admit it" is completely false all around, so I wish it wasn't such a commonly held belief.
#transandrophobia#anti-transmasculinity#looking for sources just ended up taking a toll on my mental health so i decided not to link 'proof' for the examples of transandrophobia#if you're curious about a specific one and ask in good faith i might provide something though#anyway. you ever see such a garbage take you have to write an entire tumblr post about it
618 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
How will calling in sick for a week help Palestine?
hi anon. the crux of the global strike is the fact that Palestine's genocide, at the hands of the UK and the US and Australia and a host of other countries, is funded by taxpayer money. disrupting the economy for an extended amount of time that isn't simply limited to one day pressures the people in charge to acknowledge civil unrest in their homecountries.
I understand that people still have bills to pay that won't magically go away for a global strike, but there are many of us who are in privileged enough positions where we can afford to cut out unnecessary spending and minimise hours worked. this would overall be a stronger movement if the world was significantly more unionised, but that unfortunately isn't the case and we'll have to make do with the resources we currently have.
581 notes
Ā·
View notes
Note
got bored and had lof on my my mind here are my humble offerings:
this SENT me i love the henry danger memes š
#these are all so good#erinwantstowrite#ao3#ao3 fanfic#leap of faith ao3#leap of faith catch me if you can#peter parker#dick grayson#thank you for the ask!#perpetuallypanicky#:)
303 notes
Ā·
View notes