#empires smp s2 analysis

[voidnoidoid]

Jimmy, aka Tumble Town's Outlaw (+ rambly character progression analysis and stuffs)

my take on Jimmy's villain arc is that instead of trying to reclaim his role as Sheriff, he should instead become the most feared outlaw the empires have ever seen.

old timey sheriffs often toed the line between justice and crime, and Jimmy has made it clear he's not above some corruption: bribery, stealing, manipulation, shady deals, arson etc. He's not the pillar of justice and upholder of the law he makes himself out to be. Hell he doesn't even follow his own laws sometimes and he let Scar break all of them! So why not turn to crime and vengeance?

recently I read an article about Kid Curry, a notorious outlaw of the Wild West, and I thought hey, what if Jimmy's character went in that direction? (PG-13 of course cmon) He could have a cool nickname like Dynamite Jim or something. Another thing I noticed is that Jimmy doesn't use a gun, saying that he is averse to using that kind of weapon, despite most cowboys carrying some form of firearm on them. He prefers to use a bow and arrow and his lasso. Could it be that he's used a gun before? Anyway I think it would a real turning point in his character arc for him to start using a gun, and ironically name it the Peacemaker (after the colt single action army revolver)

I find the Sheriff turned Outlaw story really compelling given what we know of Jim's character so far. Other people have brought this point up but Jimmy's whole character seems to tie in with themes of isolation and loneliness. Tumble Town doesn't have any villagers or custom citizens anywhere. The saloon is empty and devoid of any beverages. It's just Jimmy and his horses around here. Almost as if Tumble Town is completely deserted.

We don't know anything about Jimmy's life before he became the self-proclaimed Sheriff, but I assume his life before that wasn't a happy one. Why else would he crave respect so desperately, unless he wasn't afforded any before? He hates being seen as powerless and lesser than, as being called a toy is very much a soft spot for him. Him shrinking down in size and having his peers literally and metaphorically look down on him isn't helping either. From the beginning, Jimmy was never one to be taken seriously, as he was a goofy, good-natured man who kind of bumbled into being a Sheriff.

He demanded respect by imposing his laws upon every empire, despite not really having any right to do so other than being "The Sheriff". He is the leader of Tumble Town, not the whole 12 empires after all. Jim didn't really do much to show that he deserved the kind of authoritative respect he wanted from everyone, but the other rulers still liked having him around. People he considered allies such as Gem, Sausage and FWhip treated him nicely for a time, but either tolerated his Sheriff playacting and/or made fun of him by playing into the whole Toy Story bit. They were his "friends" but didn't give him respect as Sheriff and as a person.

For the majority of empires Jimmy has been treated as lesser than, as someone who isn't even human. He wasn't given basic respect asa a person. Joel outright mocked Jimmy by calling him a toy to his face, and every single person who has interacted with Jimmy has engaged in the toy bit. Hell, his own deputies, FWhip AND Scar, didn't treat him like an equal.

FWhip became deputy for his own gain and wore the toy story alien uniform to subtly make fun of Jimmy without him knowing. He did get attached to Jimmy though and took it extremely personally when he got fired for disrespecting Jimmy, getting back at him by stealing the hat and badges. I do think c!FWhip took it too far and is basically an embittered ex.

Scar on the other hand, was extremely nice to Jimmy and literally built him an entire train and a bunch of buildings as well as setting up villager trading posts for him. It's a really kind and generous thing to do for Jimmy, but despite that he still doesn't respect him in the way Jim wants him to. He gave Jim a whole pep talk about how "being Woody is a good thing" which, while being very sweet and encouraging, also unconsciously reinforces the fact that Scar DOES see Jimmy as a toy just like the rest of Empires. And when Scar was imprisoned by Jimmy for like 10 seconds, he threatened to call Jimmy a toy to get himself out of jail.

Alright fast forward to present time. Jimmy meets the Old/Past Sheriff and learns more about being a real sheriff. He learns how to get people to respect him more and is really excited to have a mentor figure, especially someone who used to be a real Sheriff running a town. Excitedly, he calls his friends over to the great bridge, riding atop a horse, to share about the cool thing that happened to him. Notice Gem, Sausage and FWhip are all wearing the Dawn Sunglasses, and Jimmy isn't, which creates this feeling that Jimmy is an "other" and not part of the in group. Instead of listening and congratulating him, all three of them crouch and poke fun at him for being small. Jimmy is all too aware of how everybody is treating him. He promises to be a better man, a better Sheriff they can all be proud of. And so he begs them, "so do you guys finally respect me now?"

Do you see me for who I am?

Will you finally see me as your equal?

Your friend?

And he is shot dead.

They've made their point loud and clear, and Jimmy has had enough. No more playing games. If they refuse to respect him, he will make them fear.

[simple-seranade]

which empires smp characters i project onto think should have religious trauma

both season one and season two because i think about this wayyyyyyy too much lol

so, without further ado:

Xornoth

this one is probably the most obvious of the bunch i’m going to list? imagine. you grow up learning about a pair of beings, one benevolent and one malicious. you praise the light and shun the dark, as all your family does. then, it’s revealed that you and your brother are part of a prophecy. the two deities you worship? yeah, they force siblings to be their champions, a fate that only ends in both their deaths. if they don’t, everything is destroyed. not only you have to perish, but so does your brother, who you care deeply about, because you’re kids.

that is already a lot to take in. what kind of god who loves you would force you to die? but then, you get told that you’re not even that. you aren’t the chosen of the light. you’re a child of the dark, and they immediately treat you as such. no matter how much you plead and pray, all they do is shake their heads and declare you too far gone. the god you worshipped hates you, and the evil you were taught to fear has claimed you as his own and you will never escape, instead doing everything you swore you would never do.

yeah. xornoth definitely has some trauma. but they’re not the only one, because…

Scott of Rivendell

yeah neither of the princes were getting out of this one unscathed.

the same things i said about xornoth apply, except everything changes. the people hail you as the one who will save them when the time comes, the one who will defeat the horrible evil. the evil who tucks you in when your parents are busy. the evil who plays tag with you in the palace halls and has snowball fights with you. the evil you call your sibling.

you don’t get to be a kid, because your god has chosen you to die. you don’t get a choice, but you’re hailed with the highest honor. you should be grateful, they say. but you don’t want the honor. you want peace. you want to not carry the world on your shoulders.

you want your sibling.

yeah being lifted up by a church can be just as damaging as being shunned by it, and we got both ends of the spectrum here! congrats, rivendell twins, now go get some therapy while we move onto…

Sausage of Sanctuary

sausage’s trauma is… different.

sausage has plenty of reason to be shaky in faith. his village was destroyed, he meets someone who looks exactly like the one he worships. it’s enough to shake anyone’s faith. is your god on that can respond? if so then why hasn’t she? you’ve been so faithful, so why are you hurting?

sausage’s trauma is less a direct result of the church and more of the terrifying ordeal of doubt. how dare you doubt that santa pearla is real and good. how dare you lose faith for even an instant. getting his memories back helps, but there’s still the nagging feeling he gets that he’s horrible for doubting that which brings so much joy. the voice hurts. praying sometimes hurts.

but something sets sausage apart.

sausage still believes. that’s a constant, no matter the hurt he suffers, he believes in Santa Pearla. he says his prayers, revels in her peace as he’s presented every reason not to. even after getting his memories back, his church stands. yeah, pearl was pretty powerful (oli has called her god before) but it’s… different. it’s faith. even though he knows he knows her, instead of being shaken, he’s solidified in it. because the world is good. santa pearla is good. people are good. he puts his hope in the good, even in the bad.

guess which one of these is most projecty lol

so yeah take my random ramblings about how different characters have religious trauma because i wanted to. sausage probably makes the least sense but i swear my brain has more reasons that don’t translate to words.

[mcytmetazine]

[Image ID: Two drawings of LDShadowLady's Empires character from S1 and S2 on the left and right respectively, between which is a title reading 'FAQs'. Set on a white to yellow gradient background.]

Thank you to everyone who's submitted the interest check so far!

We're delighted to see how many people are excited to contribute and/or see the zine, and we've been reading through your questions, concerns and suggestions frequently to ensure that our process is as clear as possible.

Below the cut, we'll answer a few questions about the premise, applications, and the final outputs. If you have any questions not answered here, feel free to send us an ask!

Huge thanks to @smaragdine for the lovely art in the banner of this post!

With that said, let's get started :D

So, what exactly is the MCYT Metazine?

The MCYT Metazine is a small zine with the aim of celebrating analysis and meta in Minecraft Youtube fandoms! With such a unique medium comes a certain type and nature of meta analysis, and we'd like to draw attention to the analysts and their work in this corner of the internet. We will be focusing on meta of the fandom and medium - whether any specific Minecraft media, a selection of media for comparison, or the entire fandom in general! We're also not limiting this to only Minecraft SMPs/series on Youtube; as per the generally-used definition, we'll accept media that's streamed on Twitch or similar platforms as well.

What form can the analysis take?

The analysis can take any form, as long as it manages to communicate some level of commentary or analysis! This can be a written essay, an academic-style essay with citations, an infographic, a webweave, a piece of art... we're open to whatever you can think of, provided you can reasonably explain your pitch and how it might look once it's done. This isn't something we've seen done before, so we don't want to place strict limits on what can be allowed - and we're sure some applications will surprise us with inventive topics and forms! For the audio/video component of the zine, we will provide the opportunity for analysts to read their analysis out loud or, if it doesn't take a traditional written form, to give some commentary on their piece. This is subject to discussion when that point comes - don't feel you need to limit yourself to something that needs to be read out loud!

Can we submit character/relationship analysis?

Character or relationship analysis can be pitched, however in most cases meta analysis will be preferred. If you'd very much like to do character/relationship analysis, we recommend doing so in a unique way. For example, you might pitch a novel approach to character/relationship analysis, relate your analysis to the wider fandom, or use your analysis as a case study of a particular fandom phenomena. If we can, we'd love to include this sort of analysis in the zine!

What does the artist role involve? What about the voice actor role?

The artist role will be to create art to accompany analyst pieces. We aim to have a good range of both analysts and artists so that this can be facilitated more easily, and art will not need to directly depict the accompanying analysis so that artists aren't limited to only the topics pitched. If you'd like to use art as a form of analysis, please apply as an analyst and specify this within the application! Voice actors will be reading written analysis out loud to form part of the audio component of the zine. Think of it as a podfic role but for the subject matter typical of a video essay! Applications for this will be much later in the year - around early May is our current estimate - so if you're interested we recommend keeping an eye out for that then.

What exactly do the different forms of output (digital/physical zine and audio/video components) mean?

The digital zine will be a fully-online version of the zine. A physical zine would be a printed version of the zine that can be shipped to you. At the moment, we're most likely to only create the digital zine out of these two - it will be free to download, and we'll be aiming to provide access to reading the zine online as well. An audio component of the zine would involve reading the analysis out loud; this is inspired by the concept of podcasts and video essays. We're hoping this will make the zine more accessible to readers and provide analysts a chance to hear their work read out loud or give commentary on their pieces. A video component would be very similar in concept, though would incorporate visual elements as appropriate to each piece. We currently plan to release the audio/video components on Youtube for affordable and accessible distribution. We're still deciding on whether we'll do audio or video elements, but we hope to try making at least one!

What does the schedule look like?

As of right now, the schedule isn't finalised. However, we aim to have moderator applications out on the 2nd February and analyst and artist applications out on the 2nd March. We plan to have a finalised schedule out by that date, after discussion with moderators.

Who can apply?

Anyone can apply, provided you are over the age limit for both Tumblr and Discord (this is 13 for most people, but please check your region's Terms of Service). We have a range of roles on offer, including moderators, analysts, artists, and voice actors. We also very much want to cover a range of MCYT subfandoms and topics, so we absolutely encourage applying if you're part of a smaller subfandom or have a very niche pitch you're interested in!

What socials are needed?

We need applicants to any role in this zine to have at least a Discord account for communication. For moderators, having a Tumblr account will be very useful. For contributors, this is optional - but we do recommend providing one so that we can promote your blog once the zine is released! Additionally, having a Google Drive or an equivalent way of storing recordings will be required for voice actors.

Do applicants need to provide past examples of their work? How finished do they need to be?

Providing examples of analysis or art are recommended in your application so that we can have a look at your style and/or approach. This can be for any fandom and, due to the nature of the zine, we're also open to it being about related topics. We understand that for analysts, you might not necessarily have something that directly relates to your pitch - linking something similar will be best in this case. We'll give more details on examples for voice actor applications closer to the time; for now, however, if you already have podfics, past voice acting work, or similar, you should be covered by the time applications open up!

Are there any limitations to content submitted for the zine?

We'd like to keep the zine SFW and avoid in-depth discussion of darker topics, for the purpose of accessibility. Discussion of shipping and RPF are permitted. During applications, we'll most likely judge this on a case-by-case basis, as we understand that there is a lot of nuance to the inclusion of darker topics within MCYT analysis. You can reach out to us to ask about specifics on this. We'll have space for multiple pitches during applications; you can give an alternative here should you still be unsure if one of your pitches covers allowed content. Note: Please avoid submitting pitches for discourse. We're aware this word has various meanings - in this case, we generally mean discussions of allegations against CCs, negativity about specific groups of fans, interpersonal drama, or similar. While we appreciate there is space for some of these within fandom, this zine does not endeavour to be that space.

Can someone apply to be several roles?

Yes! Moderators can apply to contribute, and contributors can apply to take multiple roles. Due to the diversity of roles on offer and the length of the project, however, we ask that you ensure you're willing to commit for the role within the schedule we provide. Notably, we will offer analysts the role of voice actor for their own pieces in the audio component of the zine first, before asking voice actors.

How many applicants will be accepted?

At the moment, we're not sure how many applications we'll get! As we anticipate a smaller pool of applicants, however, we estimate that we'll be accepted around 20-30 contributors for art and analysis and a flexible number of voice actors.

If you have any further questions, please reach out to us via ask or DM. You can also contact @codes-and-stuffs, who is running this zine!

[quaranmine]

howdy!

You may call me either Quara or Alyssa! My main is @doctorletmebebrave (so if you see that name liking or commenting, it is me) and I'm also the sole admin of @mcyt-cats! My AO3 can be found at doctorletmebebrave.

I post about a lot of mcyt, including but not limited to: Hermitcraft, Empires SMP, Dream SMP, 3rd Life SMP, Last Life SMP, Double Life SMP, Evo SMP and MCC. I write fanfic and post the occasional piece of fanart! Please don't repost my stuff, and I'd prefer it if my things are not shown to CCs--although if they come on tumblr and find it themselves, or I tag them, then that is fine! (unless it is martyn. i trust him) (you may also advertise mcyt-cats to CCs though lol)

Common original content tags:

Art- #quara_art

Analysis- #quara analysis

Asks- #quara asks

Liveblogging- #quara liveblog

Fanfic- #quara fanfic

I use a variety of other tags for things, and often shorten people's names or things to make it easier. If you need to know one, just ask. I'm also willing to trigger tag things although I make no guarantees I won't forget sometimes.

Bonus link: My Evo Lore Spreadsheet

Bonus link 2: Free Geoguessr Challenge Links

Fanfics, oldest to newest:

The Babysitting Game (HC)

New World, New Faces (HC)

a pair of yellow names (LLSMP)

take (his) life (LLSMP)

let me help (ESMP S1)

but we made the best of what we had, you know? (HC)

How to Be a Human Being AO3; Tumblr Masterpost (HC)

some kind of trouble is coming (DLSMP)

Lonesome Dreams (EVO)

Gadus morhua (ESMP S1)

do you see no ghosts in me at all? (HC)

i'll be waiting here 'till the stars fall out of the sky (HC; sequel to HTBAHB; unfinished)

The Incandescence of a Dying Light AO3; Tumblr Masterpost (HC Firewatch AU)

the here and now (LILSMP/ESMP S2)

leave a light on for me (SLSMP)

<3