#but we love tsuyuno yatsumura

[atarresturayr]

Magical Girl Site is a vile god awful show for the child sexualization and being a rip-off with kinda boring characters BUT I will forever take Tsuyuno Yatsumura's side. She is my girl I will not accept slander against her.

[comshipbracket]

Antis DNI

Comship Bracket 3 Round 1!

Round 1 is split up into 6 Segments, which are split into 3 smaller polls within them! These will be posted when I am able, with a 6-day voting time limit. Look out for your ships! Propaganda is both welcome AND encouraged, whether through the form of essays, art, fanfiction recommendations, or otherwise, Almost* All propaganda will be reblogged.

Disclaimer: All ships (other than NozoCoco) on this bracket are FOLLOWER-SUBMITTED ships, the Mods do not always hold necessary knowledge to be aware of any errors or fanonizing what should be canon material that may arise. Disclaimer 2: The mods are aware that in-system dating (regarding 0909) is not a problematic trait, 0909 counts as a comship in manners OTHER than this. Please stop constantly informing us "in-system dating isn't problematic", we already know this.

SEGMENT 1

Poll 1: Kyuumi (Kyubey x Mami Tomoe), Puella Magi Madoka Magica VS Komugiroha (Komugi Inukai x Iroha Inukai), Wonderful Precure

Poll 2: Stuilly (Billy Loomis x Stu Macher), Scream VS 10027 (Byakuran Gesso x Tsunayoshi Sawada), Katekyo Hitman Reborn

Poll 3: Finncest (Finn Mertens x Fern), Adventure Time VS ZADR (Zim x Dib Membrane), Invader Zim

SEGMENT 2

Poll 1: Aeshaia (Strophaia x Aeshma/Ichiro Umoregi/Akuma Kun II), Akuma Kun VS 0909 (Mikoto Kayano x John Kayano), MILGRAM

Poll 2: Amporacest (Eridan Ampora x Cronus Ampora), Homestuck VS Lucifadam (Lucifer Morningstar x Adam), Hazbin Hotel

Poll 3: Brujay (Bruce Wayne/Batman x Jason Todd/Robin/Red Hood), DC Comics VS Thoschei (The Doctor x The Master), Doctor Who

SEGMENT 3

Poll 1: Jimthan (Jimmy Valmer x Nathan), South Park VS Stannarrator (Stanley x The Narrator), The Stanley Parable

Poll 2: AiHina (Airi Sezaki x Hinako Hanamura), Kitanai Kimi Ga Ichiban Kawaii/I Love Your Cruddy VS Ayuno (Aya Asagiri x Tsuyuno Yatsumura), Magical Girl Site

Poll 3: Annie Edison x Jeff Winger, Community VS Cooprey (Audrey Horne x FBI Agent Dale Cooper), Twin Peaks

SEGMENT 4

Poll 1: NozoCoco (Nozomi Yumehara x Kouji Cocoda), Yes! Precure 5/Yes! Precure 5 GoGo/Kibou no Chikara ~Otona Precure '23~ VS Arthorin (Arthur Denton x Orin Scrivello), Little Shop of Horrors

Poll 2: LukeLeia (Luke Skywalker x Leia Organa), Star Wars VS The Floor Show (Dr. Frank N Furter x Brad Majors xJanet Weiss x Rocky), Rocky Horror Picture Show

Poll 3: Miki x Kozue (Kaoru Miki x Kaoru Kozue), Revolutionary Girl Utena VS Toukasaki (Aoyagi Touya x Tenma Saki x Tenma Tsukasa), Project Sekai

SEGMENT 5

Poll 1: Zackray (Rachel "Ray" Gardner x Isaac "Zack" Foster), Angels of Death VS Family Rentarou (Rentarou Aijou x ALL his girlfriends), 100Kanojo/The 100 Girlfriends Who Really, Really, Really, Really, Really Love You

Poll 2: Misato x Shinji (Shinji Ikari x Misato Katsuragi), Neon Genesis Evangelion VS Elriccest (Edward Elric x Alphonse Elric), Fullmetal Alchemist

Poll 3: HaniMori (Mitsukuni Haninozuka x Takashi Morinozuka), Ouran High School Host Club VS Tsumigiibo (Tsumugi Shirogane x K1-B0), Danganronpa

SEGMENT 6

Poll 1: FeaNolo (Fëanor x Fingolfin), The Silmarillion VS Tridentariicest (Coronabeth Tridentarius x Ianthe Tridentarius), The Locked Tomb

Poll 2: This Ship has been Disqualified on Bracket Rules VS Paire (Peter Petrelli x Claire Bennet), Heroes

Poll 3: FischOz (Prinzessin der Verurteilung, Fischl von Luftschloss Narfidort x Ozvaldo von Hrafnavins), Genshin Impact VS Studcoms (Steban the Student Communist x Ulixes the Echo Maker), Disco Elysium

- Mod Satou (She/Her Only) The mods of this blog use a COLLECTIVE Shes/Hers/Herselves pronoun (e.g. Both the mods on comshipbracket have been working hard lately. I really enjoy hers blog and hope shes are doing well and not overexerting herselves.)

[thestalkerbunny]

What is Magical girl site and what sin did it commited?

Okay SO LET ME FUCKING TALK ABOUT MAGICAL GIRL SITE, CAN WE TALK ABOUT IT FOR A FUCKING HOT MINUTE, IT’S BEEN TWO YEARS SINCE I READ IT AND IM STILL FUCKING STEAMED ABOUT IT.

Alright, For those of you who don’t know the plot, I’ll have a brief synopsis here spoiler free and then the spoilers under a read more so if it does tickle your fancy you can read or watch at your leisure. This is going to be on the long side because I’m including some images. As always, these are only my opinions and observations--I encourage you not to take them as LAW of how you should view the anime/manga but rather watch or read it yourself to form your own rounded opinion if you feel like you have the stomach for it because the Manga at least covered a lot of harsh topics.

Our main gal is a girl named Aya. She is the victim of INTENSE bullying at school by a group of girls and at home by her older brother. And I’m not talking about leave a rude word written on your desk or mean comments-I’m talking physical violence day in and day out to the point of becoming immensely suicidal.

She eventaully comes across a website that promises to make her a magical girl and sends her a ‘stick’ to help protect herself and fufill her role.

It’s a gun. The magical girl ‘Stick’ can take numerous forms from game controllers, a cell phone, a pen, a broom, even underwear, but they’re all imbued with their own unique magical power. The gals use them to protect herself (Aya uses hers for the first time to protect herself from would be R*pists set up by her school bullies) She eventually makes friends with other magical girls

*SQUUAADDDDDD*

It turns out the website has a count down clock and they spend most of the manga trying to figure out what happens when the clock runs out. It’s later found out the site will target girls who in bad situations (ranging from dying of cancer, to being abused at school to needing to protect themselves) to use these wands which much like Madoka, uses up their life span, to suck up bad negative energy (as most of the sticks are used to get revenge)

The series is interesting in it’s tough topics like depression, suicidal feelings, abuse, bullying, abusive home lives, R*pe etc. and handles it in a rather mature way- And thru out the series I liked it, It was a great darker read, it had intense dark moments but also wonderful sweet moments of the girls being friends. As a person who never really got to have the full experience of Magica Madoka-this was an excellent alternative to a darker magical girl genre. It is also apparently done by the same person who made ‘Magical Girl Apocolypse’ and has references to that.

The series is also well noted for having a main trans character who is actually respected and loved by her comrades and her character is done respectfully without her being a ‘joke’

That’s her on the end with the hair bow, she is a good gal. The Girl in black is also a great one. Her Stick is a goddamn whole knife.

Now here’s where my Beef starts. Ahead is spoiler territory so if you don’t want to be spoiled if you plan on watching or reading MGS, you best stop here. Or continue on if you feel like you may need to brace yourself when you do want to watch/read it-I totally understand wanting to do that

-

So at the start, Aya meets another magical girl, her name is Tsuyuno Yatsumura. She goes to class with Aya.

Tsuyuno has the power of time manipulation with the help of her cell phone and from the start she is very much a boss ass bitch. Her family was murdered in a home invasion and she’s managed to catch the killer and been slowly and painfully torturing him with the help of her ‘Stick’ to keep him alive. She cares greatly for Aya and they become closer and Tsuyuno opens up more to her, there is actual character build up and development here.

Over time, Tsuyuno and Aya get closer and it’s shipping level territory after they share a genuine kiss after a date.

Everyone is like ‘well this is it, this the end game couple. I sure hope nothing fucking BAD happens.’ Of course it’s Magical Girl Site, of course bad things happen, but I wasn’t expecting THIS.

Tsuyuno is Aya’s long lost twin sister. Apparently they were adopted out and separated as babies.

And everyone feels weird and fucking incesty after rooting for that. ROOTING FOR THEM FOR SO LONG, because it wasn’t just a random thing-they had character development and chemistry and people were like ‘YEAH THAT’S IT. THAT’S THE COUPLE.’ and then the manga never fucking ADDRESSES THAT ‘yeah they’re sisters’ AGAIN.  And they BOTH FUCKING KNOW IT.

Then there’s the secondary beef.

Previously I talked about how there was a trans character. Her name is Kiyoharo

Thru out the series none of her friends misgender her, respect her as a fellow magical girl and team member, and it’s never a ‘hahah, a guy in a dress’ joke with her. She is a well done character. There is even a moment where she talks about coming out to her mom and her mom accepting her whole heartedly and supporting her.

Now twords the ending, it’s revealed that the timer on the site is a count down to ‘The Tempest’ which would be unleashed by an ancient entity known as The King. The negative energy gathered by the gals using their magical girl sticks was to gather up power to basically destroy the world as humans are the cause of all the planet’s problems.

Now when the team is squaring up against her-it’s found out that only boys who use the magical sticks can do real intense damage to ‘The King’. and first they were going to use Aya’s weird sociopath brother to do the damage but it was a ‘HAHA. NAH. you got fucked in the ass, you’re not a man, you’re a GIRL.’

Which let me tell you-was a deep inhale thru the nostrils for me. One, that was a rapey situation where he got fucked by another male character and TWO, getting fucked in the ass a woman does not MAKE. If getting fucked in the ass makes you a girl, that means there are a lot more women on the planet then men I GUESS.

anyway.

The manga already stated that regardless of how you identify, the site (which was set up by ‘The King) will recognize you BY THE GENDER YOU IDENTIFY AS. (hence Kiyoharo getting a wand because she is a girl and identifies herself as one.)

So they can’t use the brother as a killing blow because butt sex makes you a girl and ineligible to do the kill. BUT SUDDENLY THEY CAN USE KIYOHARO for THAT. Here is the DIRECT PULL from the WIKI ITSELF

And like the more I try to read that, the more it smells iffy. I don’t LIKE it. It ENDED WEIRD for me because of that. We were going strong  and then you just sort of ended it like that. I’m glad she got the killing blow in-but the reasoning behind it was iffy for me.

TLDR: Plot twist on the one lesbian couple is that they’re twins, apparently being fucked in the ass by a man makes a dude automatically a girl and apparently despite the whole system set up by the BBEG recognizing the one trans character as a girl suddenly is damaged by her ‘male energy’; that’s kinda my tick off points for the series.

It is a great series and interestingly done, but there are some points of it twords the end of the manga I’m critical of. I don’t know if the anime shifts gears because I haven’t watched it yet.