#anti alice x bumby

[angrbodic]

The thing with the Alice x Bumby ship and people who support it not only don't understand the ramifications of what Bumby did to Alice and that it's pretty obvious he was continuing with his obsession with Lizzie.

Alice looks very much like her older sister and shares personality traits with Lizzie. So Alice would have ended up the same as Lizzie, assaulted and murdered. Because in terms of the type of serial offender Bumby is, the likelihood of him repeating the same crime was extremely high.

But also they don't understand that Bumby was not only targeting Alice but children, something that you can see in actual, real-life serial offenders like the Golden State Killer, Ted Bundy, or even Richard Ramirez. These were sexual sadists, Bumby is also a sexual sadist. Not to mention, Bundy worked in a suicide prevention call center so I don't know how you cannot draw the comparison.

So, I have had the term "anti" thrown at me, and normally, genuinely, I'm of the mind "I don't like this ship, so I'm not going to read it" because policing people over fictional ships is a waste of time. And I'll be the first to admit I especially hate this ship because I HAD several Bumbys in my life. I was sexually abused as a little girl, so I especially hate this character. And we do have several CSA survivors in fandom, they have had the same feelings. If you're writing a ship that mirrors our trauma, yeah, it's gonna piss people off. But I'm not gonna be mad enough to throw out death threats.

However.

And this is a big HOWEVER.

Largely, the biggest reason as to why I don't like it because anyone who dabbles in this ship cannot manage to keep it IC (in character). They fundamentally don't understand Alice's characterization:

1. Alice is an extremely guarded individual, literally anyone around her treats her like a burden, object, or belittle her sense of being.

2. It's highly unlikely Alice is going to romantically gush over someone, much less someone she put into a position of a mentor, so the swooning doesn't make any sense to me. If you're writing Alice in a romantic relationship, you have to keep in mind that it probably took a WHILE. When I write Alice in romantic relationships, it's a slow burn build up.

3. She likely is very reluctant to share the burden of her mental illness (unless slow burn, see above), so, again, Alice is not going to be the how to open up to people so easily.

4. Alice is extremely independent, most times. You can see she'd rather do it herself, without help unless it's a necessity, and she puts more trust in herself than in people. So, it wouldn't make sense for Alice to open up to Bumby, a doctor, outside of a patient.

And like. These shippers tend to "woobify" Bumby. He's not gonna be chivalrous.

1.He's a sociopath, so his empathy is non-existent. He didn't see Lizzie as a person, he saw her as an object he was entitled to.

2. He showed little regard to Mr. Liddell, his superior, someone he kept going to see, as his mentor. He exploited that dynamic only on the account of Lizzie.

3. The man has a superiority complex, so he won't see anyone as his equal. His ego was too big and he was so full of himself and he underestimated Alice (like everyone else) and doesn't care for her, at all.

So, every time I see this ship pop up, these characters are so woefully OOC (out of character) and that shows me you didn't understand the source material.

If you're into a dark ship, that's fine, but you're essentially re-writing characters so far from the original source material that they may as well be your own characters. You can find a dark ship with Alice, but pick someone better than Bumby. Like, guys, Bumby would have done the same thing he did to Lizzie to Alice and Alice found out at the last minute before he had the chance.

Just saying as an Alice RPer.

[firyfox]

[josephinesrphub]

That being said

If you ship Alice with Bumby in any way shape or form

Get the fuck off my blog

I don't want you here and if I find out you do, it's an instant block.

Liddell sisters x Bumby is NOT PERMITTED HERE.

[josephinesrphub]

Preach!!

Finished Alice Madness Returns again and wow...still one of my favorite games.

I'm so surprised there has been a fandom but I've seen some things and I need to say my peace

BUMBY WAS A CHILD AB*SER, SEX TRAFFICKER AND MURDERER

SO SHIPPING HIM WITH THE LIDDELL SISTERS IS BEYOND FUCKED UP

NO ONE WILL EVER HAVE A GOOD ARGUMENT OR EXCUSE TO JUSTIFY IT. NO ONE.

You're just sick.

[londerland-liddell]

Also I’m very much anti-Liddell-x-bumby, so if I ever reblog anything from a user who ships either of the Liddell sisters with Bumby, or Alice with any serial killers, it was because I didn’t realise the op shipped them, so please let me know, because I want this blog completely free of anything that tries to paint Bumby in a positive light or tries to demonise Alice and turn her into a psychopath

Thanks

[firyfox]

Wow so some of y’all are just out here shipping Alice and Lizzie with Bumby as if it’s not fucking disgusting lmao

[firyfox]

Wait help are people actually shipping bumby with alice?? Like it's not some cruel joke it's real?!?!? they're shipping a rapist/sex trafficker with his victim??? it's not some big prank??

Unfortunately , yes . And with Lizzie as well . People ship it for some reason . 🤢

[firyfox]

Hello, I don't know who you are, but I am a fictive of Alice from Alice: Madness Returns and I saw your posts in the tag. B*mby x Alice shippers are horrid, why would anybody ship that disgusting man with me? - 🔪

Well I can’t think of any GOOD reason for it , but I’m assuming they’re just attracted to how he looks , so they desperately scramble to find someone to ship him with so they can have someone to project thenselves onto , especially in certain awful NSFW scenarios . 💀

[josephinesrphub]

People actually ship Bumby with people? Yo he's the worst human being to exist in amr. Fuck that shit he's disgusting.

[josephinesrphub]

Psa

American mcgee HIMSELF said Alice should never be sexualized. She's been traumatized and scarred. Also

For fucks sake

Guys

I can't believe I'm saying this. It should be common sense.

DO NOT SHIP ALICE WITH BUMBY. HE IS A TERRIBLE MAN. HE ABUSED HER AND COUNTLESS OTHERS NOT TO MENTION HE IS ALSO A COLD BLOODED KILLER. IF YOU SHIP ALICE X BUMBY, GET THE FUCK OFF OF MY BLOG. YOU ARE NOT WELCOME HERE.

[josephinesrphub]

This is still relevant.

That being said

If you ship Alice with Bumby in any way shape or form

Get the fuck off my blog

I don't want you here and if I find out you do, it's an instant block.

Liddell sisters x Bumby is NOT PERMITTED HERE.

[firyfox]

Ok ?? It’s still gross lmao ur literally shipping a child trafficker with his victim but go off I guess

Wow so some of y’all are just out here shipping Alice and Lizzie with Bumby as if it’s not fucking disgusting lmao

[firyfox]

Ok but the reason people are concerned with ships like these is because it’s literally JUST abuse . Like , there’s nothing else there . So if the people shipping things like this don’t actually like abuse , then what exactly do they see in this stuff ? I would legitimately like to know what exactly you enjoy about this trafficker / victim relationship . Oh , and in the other ship he literally raped Lizzie . Also , if I have to see gross ship art of a pedophile and his victims , you should be able to tolerate posts against it from time to time . Like you said - YOU could just ignore it . And I’m really not convinced with the whole “it’s just fiction” argument , because 1 . What people enjoy and project in fiction is reflective of your actual likes / dislikes . 2 . In this case specifically , shipping Bumby with these girls is completely missing the whole point of the entire story . If you wanna romanticize rape and pedophillia , maybe don’t put it in the main tags :)

Wow so some of y’all are just out here shipping Alice and Lizzie with Bumby as if it’s not fucking disgusting lmao

[firyfox]

Aw 🥺 are you upset that I don’t like your “nice” little abusive pedo ship ? :(

Wow so some of y’all are just out here shipping Alice and Lizzie with Bumby as if it’s not fucking disgusting lmao

[firyfox]

If you don’t give a fuck , then why are you still on my post ? What do you have to prove to me by continuing to comment ? Just run along back to your pedo ships ☺️

Wow so some of y’all are just out here shipping Alice and Lizzie with Bumby as if it’s not fucking disgusting lmao