#PM Modi Tamil Language

[phoenixx-news]

DMK says BJP's 'torn slipper' remark an 'insult' to anti-Hindi agitation

The DMK said that the Tamil Nadu BJP president K Annamalai's criticism of its anti-Hindi agitation, which he likened to an "old, worn-out slipper", was an "insult to the martyrs" who fought for the state language.

During a campaign event on Saturday, Annamalai said, "People of Sriperambudur should understand that someone is still talking about what was said in 1980. Hindi-Sanskrit, North-South, this-that. They still haven’t thrown away such old, torn slippers. This is DMK."

Hitting out the BJP state chief's remark, DMK spokesperson Saravanan said, "He insulted the martyrs of the language war. Tamil Nadu has a great history of waging a war against Hindi imposition."

He also questioned Prime Minister Narendra Modi's silence on Annamalai's remarks.

"Why hasn't PM Modi condemned it? Annamalai has compared it (anti-Hindi agitation) to torn sandals. This is the respect people have for Tamil Nadu."

Meanwhile, the AIADMK said Annamalai was "foolish" to make such a statement.

“Insulting this (anti-Hindi agitation) only shows his character. Let me ask Annamalai why those who studied Hindi are coming to work here. But those who studied Tamil and English are going abroad or to Isro (Indian Space Research Organisation) and have become great doctors too. I can only see Annamalai’s words to be foolish," AIADMK MLA Sellur Raju said.

The language war has always played an important role in vote bank politics in Tamil Nadu.

The DMK's active role in anti-Hindi agitation in 1965 had led the party to win elections in the state.

[newz-archive]

Modi’s Southern Sojourn: A Strategic Push with Artificial Intelligence

In a whirlwind series of visits spanning the past 10 days, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has orchestrated an unprecedented outreach to the five southern states of India. From bustling roadshows to solemn inaugurations, Modi’s presence has been felt both physically and virtually, unveiling development projects worth over Rs 6,000 crore. The timing couldn’t be more critical as the BJP and the NDA gear up for the upcoming Lok Sabha elections with ambitious targets in mind.

Over the course of his journey, Modi has crisscrossed Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana multiple times. Each stop strategically chosen, each event meticulously planned. Just recently, he graced Palakkad in Kerala and addressed a rally in Salem, Tamil Nadu. His schedule doesn’t relent, as he moves from public meetings in Telangana to Karnataka, culminating in a stirring roadshow in Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu.

The BJP’s stronghold in the South has historically been confined to Karnataka, but Modi’s relentless efforts signal a shift in dynamics. The party’s aspirations soar high, aiming to secure a substantial foothold in the region. Prakash Javadekar, Kerala in-charge for the BJP, exudes confidence, predicting the party’s emergence as the single largest force in South India.

But Modi’s strategy extends beyond mere physical presence. Leveraging technology like machine learning, the BJP is bridging linguistic gaps by translating the PM’s speeches into local languages. This strategic move ensures that Modi’s message resonates deeply with diverse audiences across the region.

Even before the Model Code of Conduct took effect, Modi was on a spree, virtually inaugurating projects and laying foundations, seamlessly connecting with the South from various corners of India. Whether it’s launching Vande Bharat trains or unveiling highway projects, Modi’s vision for Southern development knows no bounds.

Noteworthy is Modi’s “gifting spree” in February, where he inaugurated a plethora of projects ranging from educational institutions to infrastructure upgrades. The gesture was not just symbolic; it was a testament to the government’s commitment to Southern progress.

Moreover, the announcement of Bharat Ratna for the late M S Swaminathan, a revered agricultural scientist from Tamil Nadu, underscores the government’s recognition of Southern contributions to the nation’s growth.

In Modi’s Southern sojourn, every move is calculated, every step forward meticulously planned. As the landscape of Indian politics undergoes a transformation, Modi’s strategic push backed by artificial intelligence underscores a commitment to inclusivity and progress for all corners of the nation.

[tamilonlinenews]

https://tamilonlinenews.com/pm-modi-speaks-about-tamil-language-and-tamilnadu/

என்னால் தமிழை புகழ்ந்து பேசாமல் இருக்க முடியாது.. எங்கு போனாலும் நினைவுக்கு வருவது தமிழ்நாடு தான் ; பிரதமர் மோடி..!

[takataktop]

Chandramukhi 2 Twitter Reviews: Has Kangana Ranaut Elevated the Horror Level in 'Chandramukhi'? Find Out if it Passed or Failed!

Chandramukhi 2 Twitter Reviews: Bollywood's reigning queen, Kangana Ranaut, has made her mark in the world of horror-comedy with the movie 'Chandramukhi-2,' which has just hit theaters. Directed by P. Vasu, this film marks her first collaboration with Raghav Lawrence, providing fans with a fresh on-screen pairing. Chandramukhi 2 has been released not only in Tamil but also in Telugu and Hindi languages. Let's see what viewers have to say about the film.

Chandramukhi 2 Twitter reviews: Kangana Ranaut, after her powerful performance in 'Dhaakad,' has once again graced the silver screen. 'Chandramukhi-2,' produced by Lyca Productions, is an adaptation of the original Tamil film. However, the makers have released it in Telugu and Hindi on September 28th. Read more : This Bollywood Beauty is Dominating WhatsApp Channels, Leaving PM Modi and Facebook's CEO Behind This is Kangana Ranaut's first venture into comedy-horror in her career. In Hindi cinema, it competes with 'The Vaccine War' and 'Fukrey 3.' Let's find out if Kangana Ranaut succeeded in raising the fear factor in this film, as directed by P. Vasu, through the lens of Twitter user reviews. Chandramukhi 2 Twitter Reactions: In Kangana Ranaut's previous release, 'Dhaakad,' her action-packed avatar may not have impressed fans greatly. However, with 'Chandramukhi-2,' she has once again achieved the status of Bollywood's queen. Twitter users are praising Kangana's acting skills and seem to be genuinely impressed. One user commented, "The first and second halves of 'Chandramukhi' are both fantastic. Kangana Ranaut has delivered a splendid performance in the film. There are many spine-chilling scenes, and the climax is simply outstanding. You must watch Chandramukhi 2." Another user wrote, "I just watched Chandramukhi 2. This film is filled with entertainment. The first half is already good, but Kangana Ranaut has taken the film to a whole new level in the second half. She is superb." With its release, users are declaring 'Chandramukhi 2' a blockbuster. One user, praising Kangana Ranaut and Raghav Lawrence's performances, even declared it a "blockbuster storm that no one had imagined." Another user lauded the film, saying, "Chandramukhi 2 is the best film of today. Kangana Ranaut and Raghav Lawrence both are outstanding. It's a complete entertainer." It's worth noting that due to its release in the Hindi belt, 'Chandramukhi 2' is competing with 'Fukrey 3' and Vivek Agnihotri's 'The Vaccine War.' Whether 'Chandramukhi-2' outperforms these films at the box office or not is something to watch for. Read the full article

[thepursuitroom]

PM Modi Inaugurates Kashi Tamil Sangamam

The holy town of Varanasi and present-day Tamil Nadu share historical and civilizational links. A month-long festival named Kashi Tamil Sangamam aimed to rediscover the connection between the two major cities of language and culture in the country got off to a grand start in Varanasi on Saturday.

[squarwell-breakingnews]

At Kashi Tamil meet, PM calls for breaking language barriers | India News - Times of India

At Kashi Tamil meet, PM calls for breaking language barriers | India News – Times of India

VARANASI: Calling upon the 130 crore people of India to break the language barriers, Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday said that it was the responsibility of all countrymen to preserve and enrich Tamil, which is the oldest language of the world. Speaking at the inaugural function of the month-long Kashi Tamil Sangamam, the PM said that Kashi and Tamil Nadu were the two cultures closely…

[znewstech]

At Kashi Tamil meet, PM calls for breaking language barriers | India News - Times of India

At Kashi Tamil meet, PM calls for breaking language barriers | India News – Times of India

VARANASI: Calling upon the 130 crore people of India to break the language barriers, Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday said that it was the responsibility of all countrymen to preserve and enrich Tamil, which is the oldest language of the world. Speaking at the inaugural function of the month-long Kashi Tamil Sangamam, the PM said that Kashi and Tamil Nadu were the two cultures closely…

[technewstoday24]

''তামিলকে সরকারি ভাষা করা হোক'', মোদীর পাশে দাঁড়িয়েই দাবি স্ট্যালিনের

”তামিলকে সরকারি ভাষা করা হোক”, মোদীর পাশে দাঁড়িয়েই দাবি স্ট্যালিনের

নিজস্ব প্রতিবেদন: তামিল ভাষাকে প্রশাসনিক ভাষা হিসেবে স্বীকৃতি দেওয়ার জন্য অনেক দিন ধরেই একটা দাবি ছিল। কংগ্রেস নেতৃত্বাধীন ইউপিএ কেন্দ্রে থাকাকালীন ��ামিল ভাষাকে ক্লাসিক্যাল ল্যাঙ্গোয়েজ বা ধ্রুপদী ভাষার মর্যাদা দেওয়া হয়। এবার প্রধানমন্ত্রী নরেন্দ্র মোদীর (Prime Minister Narendra Modi) পাশে দাঁড়িয়ে আরও এক��ার একই দাবি জানালেন তামিলনাড়ুর মুখ্যমন্ত্রী এম কে স্ট্যালিন (Tamil Nadu chief minister MK…

[marathinewslive]

Mann Ki Baat : पंतप्रधानांनी व्यक्त केली 'ही' गोष्ट न शिकल्याची खंत | National

Mann Ki Baat : पंतप्रधानांनी व्यक्त केली ‘ही’ गोष्ट न शिकल्याची खंत | National

मन की बातमध्ये बोलताना मोदी म��हणाले, की काही दिवसांपूर्वी हैदराबादच्या अपर्णा रेड्डी यांच्या एका प्रश्नानं त्यांना विचार करण्यास भाग पाडलं. रेड्डी यांनी मोदींना विचारलं की, तुम्हाला असं कधी वाटतं का, की स्वतःमध्ये काही कमी राहिली आहे. नवी दिल्ली 28 फेब्रुवारी : नरेंद्र मोदी (Narendra Modi) मागील सात वर्षांपासून देशाची पंतप्रधान आहेत. याशिवाय 13 वर्ष ते गुजरातचे मुख्यमंत्री होते. मोदी हे जवळपास…

[budmiral]

Yaadhum oore yaavarum kelir tamil essay

#Yaadhum oore yaavarum kelir tamil essay movie

#Yaadhum oore yaavarum kelir tamil essay free

The leader had a packed agenda of bilaterals amongst other engagements, beginning with the mega "Howdy, Modi!" event in Houston event that witnessed him sharing the stage with US President Donald Trump before a crowd of more than 50,000 Indian-Americans. Charitable Trust Vision is based the following two. Modi's address at the UN comes on the final day of his week-long visit to the US. An advisory committee, consisting of people who have experience in various fields, share their experience and skills with the trustees drawing its inspiration from Mahakavi Subramania Bharathiyar and Swami Vivekananda.

#Yaadhum oore yaavarum kelir tamil essay free

He had made it clear that India wanted to pursue bilateral talks with Pakistan in an environment of peace, free from the shadow of terror. This sense of belonging beyond borders is unique to India, PM added. The 69th session of the UNGA had witnessed the Indian Prime Minister calling for the early adaptation of the Comprehensive Convention on Global Terrorism, highlighting that it was a matter that had been pending for long. Quoting Pungundranar’s 3000-year-old quotes, PM gave a mention about his famous poem Yaadhum Oore Yaavarum Kelir, which means We belong to all places, and to everyone.

#Yaadhum oore yaavarum kelir tamil essay movie

Read the complete critics reviews & previews for the tamil movie Yaadhum Oore Yaavarum Kelir only on FilmiBeat. Yaadhum Oore Yaavarum Kelir Quoting Pungundranar’s 3000-year-old quotes, PM gave a mention about his famous poem Yaadhum Oore Yaavarum Kelir, which means We belong to all places, and to everyone. Check out Yaadhum Oore Yaavarum Kelir critics reviews. He had last addressed the gathering four years ago, with former External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj representing India at the world body during the interim years. Poongundranar was extremely influential in the revivalist Self-respect movement. Here comes the Energetic Divine beat Muruga from Yaadhum Oore Yaavarum Kelir Starring Vijay Sethupathi. This was the Prime Minister`s maiden speech at the UN General Assembly after assuming office for the second term. Yaadhum Oore Yaavarum Kelir - Muruga Lyric Vijay Sethupathi Nivas K Prasanna Silambarasan TR 05:10 7.1 MB 6,726,705. This sense of belonging beyond borders, is unique to India.' Pungundranar was an influential Tamil philosopher from the Sangam period. "The Prime Minister said the "world biggest democracy's message for the international community even today remains the same - Harmony and Peace." '3000 years ago, a great poet of India, Kaniyan Pungundranar wrote in Tamil the most ancient language of the world 'Yaadhum Oore Yaavarum Kelirwhich means 'We belong to all places, and to everyone'. The message was - Harmony and Peace and not dissension. His words, Yaadhum Oore Yaavarum Kelir mean I am a. Recalling Vivekananda's famous speech delivered at World Parliament of Religions, the Prime Minister said, "Around 125 years ago, India`s great spiritual leader, Swami Vivekananda had given a message to the world. The same spirit was envisaged by the Tamil poet, Kaniyan Pungundranar, more than 3,000 years ago.

[thewritingnut]

Colourfully painted in Black and White: Isn’t that an irony ?

Chess fever has engulfed the entire city. The walls and bridges are painted black and white in squares. As we slid through the floors of the Napier bridge in Chennai, it presents us with a feeling of a king or queen or the ministers or the soldiers. The commemoration finds a place in the buses, metro trains, and bus stops. The most intriguing was the milk packets imprinted with chess boards being delivered by the milkwalas, at your doorstep in the mornings. The celebrations are in complete swing and galore. The release of the chess anthem, Vanakkam vanakkam and welcome to Chennai which was composed by the Oscar winner and legend, A R Rahman and directed by the director, Vignesh Shivan is already doing the rounds in the city. It is resonating through the niches and corners of the state.

The forty-fourthFIDE Chess Olympiad begins today in Chennai. Prime Minister Shri. Narendra Modi landed in Chennai to inaugurate the historic event. To kickstart the event, the torch was lit forty days before at the capital city by the PM and handed over to the four-time world Championship Winner, Vishwanathan Anand. The torch traversed through iconic places which accounted for seventy-five places that commemorate the seventy-fifth year of Indian Independence. It is a moment of pride and dignity, as India respectfully hosts the 44th Chess Championship. The mascot, ‘ Knight Thambi ’ stands tall and yearns in the places which display the brotherhood of Tamilnadu’s culture. This Championship is going to see 2000 participants from over 187 countries. The orchestration of the event needs a blessed ovation as the city was lit brightly. The Prime Minister was given a cordial welcome as he travelled through the land to the Jawaharlal Nehru Indoor stadium. The rest of the competitions are going to be held in Mamallapuram, the city of Pallavas. It is very well known that Chess is a game that originated in INDIA. The sixty-four, black and white squares with Kings and queens along with their consorts of ministers escorted by the army of elephants, horses and soldiers are no lesser than a battlefield. It is well-known fact that one can win the game of Chess only through intelligence and not through sheer luck. The inauguration saw a galaxy of intellectuals. The cultural programme at the inaugurals included the eight dance forms of India, the cultural display of Tamilnadu and the language Tamil and finally the enjoy enjaami performance, the fever that gripped the individuals a few months before. The Prime Minister in his speech quoted the words of Thiruvalluvar, the eminent saint poet of Tamilnadu. He lauded everyone for the grand arrangements in a very short period of time. Prior to his talk, the Chief Minister with deep profound thanks appreciated the PM for accepting the invitation for the inauguration. He too quoted the history which speaks high about Chess. The Prime Minister officially revealed the colours of the Kings and queens that will be ruling the competitions thereupon at the Championship. Each delegate and respected dignitaries of the inaugural participated in the proceedings in an impeccable way. The consummate was the declaration of the championship 'open' by Prime Minister Mr Narendra Modi.

It is for sure that this Championship held at Tamilnadu will be the one that will be etched in the history and memories forever.

[thenetionalnews]

Modi on Stage, Stalin Pitches for Tamil, Demands it be Declared Official Language at Center

Modi on Stage, Stalin Pitches for Tamil, Demands it be Declared Official Language at Center

Amid a debate over Hindi and linguistic diversity in the country, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister MK Stalin on Thursday said Tamil should be announced as the official language at Union government offices and the Madras High Court. The chief minister made the remark in the presence of Prime Minister Narendra Modi during a speech welcoming him in Chennai. “This is the first govt event that PM Modi is…

[bharatlivenewsmedia]

MK Stalin urges PM Narendra Modi to declare Tamil official language as Hindi

MK Stalin urges PM Narendra Modi to declare Tamil official language as Hindi

MK Stalin urges PM Narendra Modi to declare Tamil official language as Hindi Tamil Nadu Chief Minister MK Stalin on Thursday urged Prime Minister Narendra Modi to declare Tamil as the official language, like Hindi, at Union government offices and the Madras High Court. Stalin and Modi were sharing the stage at an event in Chennai, where the Prime Minister launched several new schemes and…

[znewstech]

Kashi and Tamil Nadu are timeless cultural centres: PM Modi | India News - Times of India

Kashi and Tamil Nadu are timeless cultural centres: PM Modi | India News – Times of India

VARANASI: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday hailed Kashi and Tamil Nadu as timeless centres of culture and civilisation. The two regions are also the centres of the world’s oldest languages Sanskrit and Tamil, Modi said in his inaugural speech at Kashi Tamil Sangamam here. “If in Kashi there is Baba Vishwanath, then in Tamil Nadu there is the blessing of Lord Rameshwaram. Both Kashi and…

[eagle-eyez]

The state of Maharashtra witnessed high drama on 24 August when Union Minister Narayan Rane was arrested and granted bail in Maharashtra over his “slap Uddhav Thackeray” comment.

With his arrest, Rane, who holds the micro, small and medium enterprises portfolio in the Modi Cabinet, joins Murasoli Maran and TR Baalu to be the only Central ministers to be arrested in the past two decades.

Rane’s arrest

Union Minister Narayan Rane was arrested on Tuesday by the state police in the coastal district of Ratnagiri where he is travelling as part of the Jan Ashirwad Yatra. The Union minister was arrested over his remarks about slapping Maharashtra Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray for what he called Thackeray's "ignorance of the year India won Independence".

Rane had claimed Thackeray forgot the year of Independence during his 15 August address and had to check with his aides mid-speech.

"It is shameful that the chief minister does not know the year of independence. He leaned back to ask about the count of years of independence during his speech. Had I been there, I would have given him a tight slap," Rane said in the public meeting at Raigad.

The 69-year-old was later produced in a court in Mahad in Raigad in the night where he was granted bail on the Rs 15,000 surety with four conditions -- he will have to appear twice before Mahad police and he will have to ensure that the act will not be repeated. The Union minister will have to cooperate with the police for the collection of voice samples. The Union minister will have to ensure that the evidence is not tampered with.

The events also led to tense moments in the state with Shiv Sena and the Bharatiya Janata Party workers agitating against one another.

Initially, Sena workers in Pune hit the streets, putting up posters against the minister and slapping photos of him with shoes. They also vandalised an office in Amravati.

#WATCH | Maharashtra: A group of Shiv Sena workers pelt stones at BJP party office in Nashik & raise slogans against Union Minister Narayan Rane.

The Union Minister and BJP leader had given a statement against CM Uddhav Thackeray yesterday. pic.twitter.com/Y3A3cWZbTa

— ANI (@ANI) August 24, 2021

In Mumbai itself, Sena workers demonstrated outside Rane's bungalow in Juhu, leading to clashes with BJP members.

Sena’s Ratanagiri-Sindhudurg MP Vinayak Raut even wrote to Prime Minister Narendra Modi demanding Rane’s expulsion from the Cabinet. “Rane has belittled the constitutional framework by his statement. The Jan Ashirwad Yatra conceptualised by the PM was to seek the blessings of the people, instead of it, Rane has been issuing statements for the cheap publicity,” Raut was quoted as saying.

Can a Central minister be arrested? What’s the procedure?

Rane’s arrest has also triggered a debate on whether the state of Maharashtra carried out due protocol to arrest him. According to BJP Maharashtra president Chandrakant Patil, the minister’s arrest was “against protocol” and questioned how it could issue an arrest warrant against a Union Minister suo motu.

So, what does the rules say and what’s the process to be followed?

If Parliament is not in session, a cabinet minister can be arrested by a law enforcement agency in case of a criminal case registered against him.

As per Section 22 A of the Rules of Procedures and Conduct of Business of the Rajya Sabha, the Police, Judge or Magistrate would, however, have to intimate the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha about the reason for the arrest, the place of detention or imprisonment in an appropriate form.

As per Section 135 of the Code of Civil Procedure, a member of Parliament has freedom from arrest during the continuance of the House and 40 days before its commencement and 40 days after its conclusion in civil cases. However, the privilege doesn't extend to criminal cases.

In Rane's case, he has been charged under Indian Penal Code sections 189 (threat of injury to public servant), 504 (intentional insult to provoke breach of public peace), 505 (statements conducive to public mischief), 500 (defamation), 505(2) (circulation of defamatory material), 153-b (1)(c) (commits any act which is prejudicial to the maintenance of harmony between different religious, racial, language or regional groups or castes or communities) of the IPC.

Infamous league of 3

Narayan Rane's arrest, however, is not the first time that a serving Union minister has been arrested. Rane, in fact, is the third Union minister in India to court arrest.

The first two were the late Murasoli Maran and T R Baalu.

In a highly publicised event, the duo was picked up at midnight by Chennai Police along with former Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M Karunanidhi in connection with a Rs 12 crore ‘flyover scam’ in June 2001.

The arrests came on the complaint filed by then Greater Chennai Corporation Commissioner JCT Acharyalu on June 29, 2001.

In visuals, aired on Sun TV, which shocked one and all, the police was seen manhandling Karunanidhi (now deceased) along with then Union Minister for Industries Murasoli Maran (he passed away in 2003) and TR Balu, who was the Union Minister for Environment and Forests at the time.

Maran, who was Karunanidhi’s nephew, had sustained injuries in the scuffle with the police during his arrest and was admitted to a hospital. Baalu had also sustained minor injuries.

They were both released on bail the next day after then Union Defence Minister George Fernandes had visited Chennai.

The arrest of the two Union ministers had caused widespread condemnation.

"In spite of identifying me as the Union minister, they did not care to produce the warrant of arrest and moreover they ill-treated and assaulted me", Baalu had said in a statement, released to the press in Chennai at the time.

Notably, the BJP had also expressed shock over the manner in which the DMK leader and former Tamil Nadu chief Minister M Karunanidhi was arrested by the police at his residence.

Inputs from Agencies

from Firstpost Politics Latest News https://ift.tt/3BeTLP1

[classyfoxdestiny]

Parliament proceedings live | Deve Gowda reminds about pending women reservation Bill

Parliament proceedings live | Deve Gowda reminds about pending women reservation Bill

The Lok Sabha on Tuesday passed the Constitution 127th Amendment Bill, 2021 with unanimous support from the House, and with this, the Lower House is expected to be adjourned sine die today.

The Rajya Sabha witnessed extraordinary scenes on Tuesday, with Opposition members, majority of whom dressed in black or sporting black bands, clambered onto the table in front of the Chair, protesting against the government for trying to push through a diluted debate on the farmers’ issue instead of going for a repeal of the three controversial farm laws. The protests are expected to continue today in the Upper House.

Here are the latest updates:

Rajya Sabha | 4.10 pm

K. Raveendra Kumar (TDP) recalls the crucial role in implementing reservation for OBC community.

Centre is compelled to bring this Bill after the Supreme Court judgment, he says.

He says the latest census should include caste enumeration. Without these figures we can’t make proper policy for the country, he says.

Sardar Balwinder Singh Bhunder (SAD) speaks in Punjabi. Some members complain they are not able to get the translation. The Chair asks him to speak in Hindi or English.  He says he wholeheartedly welcomes the Bill. This is the first time the Centre has restored powers taken from states since 1947.

The farmers protesting today are poor and frustrated. This is injustice with Punjab. Now you have the chance to repeal the 3 farm laws, he adds.

Rajya Sabha | 4.00 pm

Deve Gowda reminds about pending women reservation Bill

Former Prime Minister Deve Gowda welcome the Bill. Reservation in Karnataka was started by Maharaja of Mysore in 1918.

In the last session, the government 10% reservation for EWS over and above the existing system. Will the cap now be 60% now, he seeks clarification.

He says during his tenure, Rajya Sabha approved women reservation. It should be brought to Lok Sabha.

Karnataka provides 23% reservation to OBCs. Within that Muslims are also included and there was no opposition. Let the government clarify if such a reservation is possible after this Bill is passed.

Rajya Sabha | 4.00 pm

Include Dalit Muslims and Dalit Christians in SC list: Abdul Wahab

Abdul Wahab (IUML) says he was surprised the government brought this Bill in this session. Dharmendra Pradhan talked about giving petrol pumps to OBCs. If you privatise all institutions, who will give them jobs, he asks.

He recalls anti-Mandal protest and an upper caste youth who self immolated himself in 1990.

He reads out the abysmally low proportion of OBC faculty in higher education. He says in most cases, they stamp NFS (none found suitable) to evade reservation.

He demands including Dalit Muslims and Dalit Christians in SC list.

Rajya Sabha | 3.35 pm

Modi ensured reservation does not get lapsed if vacancy is not filled in IIT teaching posts: Dhrmendra Pradhan

Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan lauds the House for a constructive debate. Some members questioned the language of the 102nd Constitutional Amendment Act. It was drafted by the Select Committee. The then Minister had clearly said there will be two lists — one for state, one for Centre.

This is not a knee jerk reaction of our government. Noone should doubt our intention. Some members of DMK raised IITs were not following reservation. It was a news for me. Then we found out the reservation lapses if the vacancy was not filled up. Mr. Modi ensured the reservation does not get lapsed, he says.

We implemented OBC reservation in Jawahar Vidyalayas.  He lists out how they ensured petrol pump licences were offered to many OBC people.

On why a cap on reservation, he says over 80% States have crossed the cap. He says many welfare schemes of NDA government uses the same census data.

He says his father was also part of the then Madras Presidency. It was because of their BC scholarship, his father could become a doctor and he himself could be part of Creamy Layer.

Rajya Sabha | 3.35 pm

Reservation is for the self-respect: Thambi Durai

M. Thambi Durai (AIADMK) says the Bill will go a long way in ensuring equitable distribution of resources. He recalls the contributions of Periyar, Anna, MGR and Jayalaithaa. Reservation is for the self-respect, he says.

He recalls how Justice Party brought reservation in Madras Presidency in 1921.

Rajya Sabha | 3.25 pm

Odisha has started its own caste enumeration: Amar Patnaik

Amar Patnaik (BJD) narrates how Odisha provided social justice despite the Indira Sawhney case. He says Odisha wanted to provide 27% reservation for SEBC, but are able to provide 11.2%.

The Indira Sawhney case highlights that there is no scientific data to support reservation. The government of Odisha has started collecting data by its own since March.

Rajya Sabha | 3.15 pm

A speech targetting Congress

Harnath Singh Yadav (BJP) hits out at Congress. He claims in 70 years, the grand old party has not done much for the OBCs.

He wonders why the Congress and UPA couldn’t grant constitutional status to the OBC Commission. His entire speech is targetted against Congress. He claims Sardar Patel was not allowed to become PM because he was the son of a farmer. Congress members object to it.

The Chair asks him to end his speech citing paucity of time.

Rajya Sabha | 3.10 pm

Meritorious people should not be included in reservation: Rajmani Patel

Rajmani Patel (Congress) says the several opposition parties have forced the government to bring this Bill by approaching the court.

Had the government’s intention was favouring OBCs, they would have not gone on the roads with Kamandal, he says.

Congress brought reservation for OBCs in Madhya Pradesh. The subsequent BJP governments didn’t take it up and the Supreme Court struck it down. Whereas Tamil Nadu fought well and ensured 69% reservation continues there, he says.

He seeks change in the roster within reservation with binary roster.  Even animals are counted, why can’t OBCs be counted, he asks pitching for caste cesnsus. He also seeks reservation in promotion. Meritorious people should not be included in reservation but should be alloted in general category, he says.

Rajya Sabha | 2.55 pm

You are shedding crocodile tears, Binoy Viswam tells government

Binoy Viswam (CPI-M) while supporting the Bill terms it election adjust Bill. B.R. Ambedkar must be weeping now. It was V.P. Singh that brought justice to his words. Who raised the slogan Mandal vs. Kamandal? Who raised Mandir to hide Mandal? he asks.

He quotes M.S. Golwalkar’s words against quota. Now that BJP, with thought of votes, is coming with a Bill on reservation. Please don’t cheat the country, he says.

You are supporting people who raped and murdered young Dalit girls and you are shedding crocodile tears for Dalits, and OBCS, he tells BJP.

Rajya Sabha | 2.45 pm

War of words between Sanjay Singh and Naqvi

G.K. Vasan (TMC-M) says the Bill will uplifit the OBCs socially and economically.

Sanjay Singh (AAP) supports the Bill. He says the government’s claims on OBC welfare are laughable. He shows Uttar Pradesh OBC report flagging the reserved teachers post not filled yet. He also speaks on Hathras rape and murder, the atrocities against Dalits in Uttar Pradesh and Gujarat.

Deputy Leader of the Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi seeks expunging the references of Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister. Jairam Ramesh supports Sanjay Singh. The Chair says it will be reviewed.

Rajya Sabha | 2.40 pm

 Indira Sawhney case should be revisited: NCP

Vandana Chavan (NCP) also supports the Bill. Let us ask ourselves if the 102nd Constitutional Amendment passed the test of being unambigious. She wonders if the earlier amendment was only to seed the protests.

This Bill gives powers to the State, unfortunately without action, she says. The Indira Sawhney case should be revisited, she says.

She says the migrated people are also a deprived lot. They should also be considered for reservation.

Rajya Sabha | 2.30 pm

Narendra Jadhav, nominated member, also supports the Bill.  He says nearly 1/5th of the OBCs would have lost the benefits of reservation had the Bill was not brought in.

Sanjay Raut (Shiv Sena) says he supports the Bill and will talk about Pegasus in the evening.

He recalls the Maratha reservation agitation, and lauds the youngters for taking part in a peaceful protest. However, he says the issue is far from over, despite the passage of the Bill. Only the removal of the ceiling limit can provide a permanent solution, he says. 

Rajya Sabha | 2.25 pm

Change your mentality on caste enumeration: Manoj Jha

Manoj Jha (RJD) terms it a historical moment when the House is unitedly supporting a Bill. He remembers former member and writer Tulsiram, a Dalit who faced discrimination while he was in school.

Many members have asked several times requested to make public the caste census data. He recalls how a BJP member in Lok Sabha demanded it yesterday. “It is not a Freudian Slip, it came from her heart,” he says.

He pitches for proportional representation. Recalling BJP’s earlier statement that we are ready for categories but not for caste enumeration, Mr. Jha says this mentality should change.

Rajya Sabha | 2.20 pm

Time to make Lohia’s vision a reality: JD-U

Ram Nath Thakur (JD-U) recalls Ram Manohar Lohia’s agitation for reservation.  He recalls Nitish Kumar granting 50% reservation for women in Panchayats and wards.

He urges government to fill up the posts lying vacant in higher education institutions.

He also insists on caste-based census.

Rajya Sabha | 2.10 pm

Act cannot be implemented well without taking a fresh caste census: Ramgopal Yadav

Ramgopal Yadav (SP) supports the Bill. The fruit of the Bill will truly be felt only when the 50% reservation ceiling is lifted, he says.

The Act cannot be implemented well without taking a fresh caste census, he says.

He counters Sushil Kumar Modi by listing the number of posts reserved for OBCs lying vacant in various higher education insitutions.

Rajya Sabha | 2.00 pm

When reservation creates inequalities within the reserved class itself, the state has to intervene: Kareem

Elamaaram Kareem (CPI-M) says it is a welcome step and the government is rectifying its earlier mistake. This cannot be taken as something to glorify the government, we all know its OBC policy.

The earlier amendment took away the rights of the State. The States could only send suggestions and the Union government can only add a caste to the OBC list.

After wasting time, the government has decided to bring this Bill. He also asks the government to review the EWS norms. Dalit Christians should also be included in reservation, he says.

When reservation creates inequalities within the reserved class itself, the state has to intervene, he says.

He also takes up the Pegasus snooping row. The unconstitutional attitude of the government led to this situation, he says.

Rajya Sabha | 1.55 pm

What is the scientific basis for 50% cap on reservation, asks Banda Prakash

Banda Prakash of the TRS asks, “what is the scientific basis for 50% cap on reservation?”

He demands a Caste Census. “Without data, how will you implement reservation?” he asks. He demands a Ministry for Backward Classes.

Subhas Chandra Bose Pilli of the YSRCP speaks in Telugu.

Rajya Sabha | 1.45 pm

Govt. compelled to introduce Bill: Tiruchi Siva

Tiruchi Siva of the DMK says Tamil Nadu, with its 69% reservation, leads in empowerment and social justice.

Supporting the Bill, he says, the government was compelled to introduce the Bill as 671 OCBC committees were being affected. “This was done under compulsion. Federalism is not a suitable word for you (government). For you, all is unitary– one language, one religion, etc. But federalism is the core feature of the country.”

“Caste Census should be immediately conducted and the 50% cap on reservation should be done away with,” Mr. Siva says.

“We support the Bill. But our appeal to you, to bring changes in the interest of the people and not out of compulsion.”

Rajya Sabha | 1.40 pm

RJD happiest if States’ powers restored: Prasanna Acharya

Prasanna Acharya of the BJD speaks in Odiya.

This Bill will strengthen the federal structure of the country, he says. “RJD will be the happiest party if the powers taken from the States are restored,” he says.

He says the 50% cap on reservation should be reconsidered and also asks that Ceste Census take place.

Rajya Sabha | 1.30 pm

Will talk about legislative incompetence of govt.: O’ Brien

Derek O’ Brien of the TMC says to the Speaker, “Through you, Sir, I want to request the Prime Minsiter to come to the House, when an important discussion as this is taking place.”

He makes a remark on Pegasus, invoking a reference to “the Olympics god Poseidon”.

Making a refernce to Sushil Modi’s remarks on winning elections, he says, “we don’t talk, we do. We want to remind them of the elections in West Bengal.”

He says he supports the Bill, “but I also want to talk about the legislative incompetence of the government.” “We warned the government to go slow on the GST, although we supported it. In 10 months, 376 changes were made,” he says, as an illustration.

He cites the CAA and the farm laws as mistakes of the government. “The government did not listen and continued to make mistakes.”

He says the Trinamool has studied 98 Bills passed by the government, and “29 Bills are anti-federal”.

He asks why Caste Census is being done away with.

Mr. O’ Brien recalls that the government did away with reservation to Anglo-Indians based on a census that wrongfully said Anglo-Indian community comprises only 200 people.

Rajya Sabha | 1 pm

Sushil Kumar Modi is heckled in the House as he makes statements bashing the previous Congress govts.

Sushil Kumar Modi says a review petition was filed by the govt. withing 8 days of the judgment by the Supreme Court. “We have brought this Bill early, unlike Mr. Singhvi’s insinuation, as soon as our review petition was rejected.”

Quoting from the minority judgment Of Justices Bhushan and Najeeb, Mr. Modi clarifies the legislative intent of the Bill. Our intention was not to deprive the States, he says, adding the Supreme Court misinterpretated.

He says, “we supported the V.P. Singh decision of giving the OBC reservation. We gave constitutional recognition to Scheduled Tribes Commission. What did the Congress do?”

He makes statements bashing the previous Congress governments. He says Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his government has brought in favourable changes.

The Opposition members express disagreement to some statements. Chaotic scenes ensue in the House.

Mr. Kharge says false claims are being made by Mr. Modi.

Rajya Sabha | 12.35 pm

The wrong of 2018 being rectified, Bill long time coming: Singhvi

Abhishek Manu Singhvi of the Congress, says, “The path to hell is paved with good intentions. The Bill was a long time coming. But I also want to point out that the government is only correcting its big mistake of 2018.” Mr. Singhvi was making a reference to the 102nd amendment made in 2018.

The government committed a mistake and the government is congratulating itself for rectifying it now, he says.

An amendment was proposed in this House, many MPs also made some suggestions when it was sent to a select committee for recommendations, he says.

He says, “as feared, the Supreme Court faltered in the interpretation of the ambiguous language of the legislation.”

Speaking about the Maratha reservation issue, Mr. Singhvi says, the 50% cap on reservation cannot be followed as a strict rule. He gives the examples of States like Nagaland and Tamil Nadu which have more than 50% reservation. “The Supreme Court will not reconsider this. So, the government has to, and make the change.”

Mr. Singhvi brings up OBC seats lying vacant ingovernment employment.

He asks why Caste Census is being done away with. “We did it in 2011. Why not do it now in 2021?”

Suggesting an amendment to the Bill, Mr. Singhvi says, “This amendment is clarificatory. But unless it is applied restrospectively, no State list between 2018 and 2021 will be valid.”

Rajya Sabha | 12.30 pm

Allow discussion for more than three hours: Kharge

Manoj Jha asks the Speaker to allot sufficient time even for the smaller parties, who have equal stakes, to speak about the “important amendments” suggested in the Bill.

Leader of Opposition Mallikarjun Kharge tells the Speaker, he has the power to change the decision taken by the Business Advisory Committee. “No one is going to oppose this Bill…Even if the discussion time is increased by two or three hours, the country or the House will not be at a disadvantage.”

Minister Piyush Goyal suggests that the House sit until all the day’s business is completed, even beyond 6 p.m. “If we need to increase the discussion to beyond three hours, then we need to be on agreement to this.”

Member Anand Sharma says, “It is not acceptable that the extension is conditional.”

Mr. Goyal responds and restates that the day’s business will have to be completed, and “it is only fair that we agree to sit beyond 6 p.m. for it.”

There is chaos in the House.

Mr. Harivansh says the discussion will take place for four hours.

Rajya Sabha | 12.15 pm

House takes up Bill restoring States’ rights to specify OBC groups

Motion is moved in the House for the consideration of The Constitution 127th Amendment Bill, 2021 by Dr. Virendra Kumar, Minister of Social Justice and Empowerment.

Mr. Kumar thanks all members for the consensus shown in discussing the Bill. “It is a history-making Bill.”

The Bill give back power to states to identify social and economic backward classes.

He says, the constitution amendment bill passed by Lok Sabha on Tuesday will empower states to prepare and maintain their own list of socially and educationally backward classes (SEBCs) and provide them reservation.

Rajya Sabha | 12 pm

Question Hour, lunch break suspended

Proceedings resumes in the Upper House.

Deputy Chairman Harivansh is in the chair.

Minister of Parliamentary Affairs of India Pralhad Joshi asks that the House suspend Question Hour and lunch break to discuss The Constitution 127th Amendment Bill, 2021. The House agrees.

Mr. Harivansh condoles the demise of Thindivanam K. Ramamurthy, ex-Member.

Papers being laid on the table of the House.

Productivity of the Lok Sabha

20 Bills passed this session, only OBC Bill passed after discussion

At a press conference after the adjournment of the Lok Sabha, Speaker Om Birla said it pained him that the Lok Sabha didn’t function smoothly this monsoon session.

“The House functioned for only 74 hours and 46 minutes. The total productivity was 22%,” he said.

A total of 20 Bills were passed in the session, of which only the OBC Bill was passed after discussion. The remaining Bills were passed in din without discussion, through voice vote.

“I always expect the MPs to maintain the dignity of the House. There have been debates, agreements and disagreements in the House but its dignity was never lowered,” he said.

Urging all MPs to follow the Parliamentary traditions, Mr. Birla said sloganeering and raising of placards are not a part of these traditions.

Lok Sabha | 11 am

Lok Sabha adjourned sine die

Proceedings for the day begin.

Speaker Om Birla condoles the death of former Himachal Pradesh Chief Minister Virbhadra Singh, who was earlier Member of Parliament and a Minister at the Centre. Obituary references are made for Nityananda Mishra, Gopalrao Mayekar and Sudarshan Roy Chowdhury.

Mr. Birla gives an account of the works undertaken in the Lok Sabha this session.

The House is adjourned sine die.

Rajya Sabha | 11 am

Venkaiah Naidu expresses anguish over yesterday’s events

Chairman Venkaiah Naidu calling the actions of some members as “acts of sacrilege”, says “I have no words to express my anguish and condemn the actions of yesterday. I slept a sleepless night.”

Mr. Naidu got emotional and said he was distressed to see the sacredness of the House being destroyed over a difference of opinion. “I am distressed as the way this sacredness was destroyed yesterday when some members sat on the table some others climbed on the tables of the house, perhaps to be more visible, was an act of sacrilege. I have no words to condemn the act as I spent a sleepless night,”

When a discussion on agriculture was listed in the list of business for the day, the opportunity was not taken by the members to air their grievances. “Even a discussion on the farm laws could have been taken up,” he says, expressing his displeasure and “anguish” over the last day’s events.

The Opposition begins to raise slogans.

The House is adjourned till 12 p.m.

Meeting of Opposition parties

A meeting of Opposition parties underway at Leader of Opposition Mallikarjun Kharge’s office on August 11, 2021.   | Photo Credit: Special Arrangement

  A meeting of leaders of Opposition parties in the office of Leader of Opposition Mallikarjun Kharge is underway. Leaders from INC, including Rahul Gandhi, DMK, TMC, SP, SS, NC, CPM, RJD, CPI, IUML, RSP, VCK, KC(M) and LJD are attending the meeting.

Discussion

Member Vinayal Bhaurao Raut is scheduled to raise a discussion on the situation arising out of Covid-19 pandemic in the country and various aspects related to it, under Rule 193

Legislative Business

Rajya Sabha

Bill for consideration and passing

The General Insurance Business (Nationalisation) Amendment Bill, 2021

Bills for consideration and return

The Appropriation (No.4) Bill, 2021

The Appropriation (No.3) Bill, 2021

Lok Sabha

Bill for consideration and passing

The Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Bill, 2020

. Source link