#I was just thinking that the moment where he tells madame thenardier off
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
I draw Javert really big right cause it's funny that he looks like a walking brick wall
but then I was thinking. what if. cause he's her narrative parallel they're both watchdogs of society, right. What if.
What if I made Ćponine be built like a brick wall
I mean she is Madame Thenardier's daughter after all. What if
#I was just thinking that the moment where he tells madame thenardier off#he's probably directing some misplaced anger he had on his mother#like think about it. the thenardier den is probably a very similar vibe to his own life growing up
49 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
i just watched the dallas theatre company les mis here are my observations
IF YOU HAVE NOT WATCHED THIS PRODUCTION I SUGGEST YOU DO! DONāT READ THIS IF YOU DONāT WANT SPOILERS THOUGH!
so, in case you didnāt know: in 2014, Dallas Theatre Company did a modern interpretation of les mis. i just watched it on youtube (i will link it later, i promise) and took SO MANY GODDAMN NOTES so here they are!
ACT ONEĀ
(Look Down-WHID)
starting out strong! we got some HARSH TRUTHS ABOUT THE JAIL SYSTEM!! blatant police brutality happening BASICALLY the entire first part of the song. it hurts me.Ā
note on the cops costumes: they legitimately terrify me and they are dressed in like. full riot gear.
okay so,,,valjean wraps the rope from his bag around his neck at the end of WHID. this is interesting bc, a) heās trying to find a solution as to what he should do after the Bishop and thatās a direction Iāve surprisingly seen no one take, but b) this part has the same melody as javertās suicide, when javert is ALSO trying to figure out what he should do after his perception on life is altered. for a moment there, they both are on the same page, the page being suicide. however, only one of them takes that choice.
the above makes the lines (in both songs) āiāll escape now from that world / from the world of valjeanā ESPECIALLY interesting because. in two different ways, they did escape, but they ALMOST had the same conclusion for a brief second.
(At The End Of The Day)
in ATEOTD fantine ends up being the last one working, causing everyone to look at her with varying degrees of annoyance or frustration. She do be hardworking doe
OH SHIT KIDS IN THE FACTORY!! three little kids run up to the foreman when heās giving daily stipends to the ladies!! (theyāre also the last to be paid, giving significant sass to foreman who also sasses back)
Girl #5 mockingly calling fantine āinnocent sisterā when 5 is white and fantine is a WOC...thatās kind of interesting given that that can be read as SERIOUS racial profiling on 5ās part
foreman looks like bobās boss in the incredibles but like. tall lmao
(I Dreamed A Dream)
her look of like,,shock-but-not when everyone from the factory exits and she takes off her bandana,,,that. that is good acting
her transitions from chest to head voice are so good
iām kinda sad she isnāt younger?? or just. doesnāt look super young bc fantine is supposed to be like. early twenties. sheās not 45 and had a decently long life before she died, no, sheās young. she was taken advantage of. thatās the whole point. but thatās sUPER little like this lady is way too good
she has the perfect mix of sadness and regret plus anger and shameless hope. like. kudos to you allison blackwell youāre a dope fantineĀ
the cry on ākilled the dream i dreamedā brb sobbing
(The Dock Scenes)
MALE PROSTITUTES I REPEAT!! MALE PROSTITUTES!! (no idea what wig heās wearing tho. he was done dirty in the wig department)Ā
oh male prostitute is prostitute #1!Ā
oh damn there is. lady def on some bad drugs with her kid passing behind fantine on the bench. ouch.
hoo okay they did n o t censor lovely ladies!! (mini note: camera person has the camera down an AWFUL LOT on these docks scenes lmao)
there are cops on the docks. gross.
(Who Am I-Confrontation)
OH SHIT THEY HAVE A FALSE JVJ IN THE BACKGROUND OF WHO AM IĀ
jvj comforts not-jvj for a second!! (money note was FANTASTIC btw)
fantine being WOC and DYING in a modern hospital also is,,yeesh because. you know. racist doctors.Ā
jvj cries after fantine dies JUST STAB ME NOW OKAYā
confrontation is really funny when u see that javert has a GUN and jvj has A CHAIR
JVJ DID THE LIL RUN ON ālive within my careā YAAAAY
(COAC-Master Of The House)
oh boy baby cosette,,so small,,so pure plus classic baby head shake when she sings I STAN
MADAME T LOOKSāOH GOOD GOD
DID SHE SPIT ON MY BABY--
cosette: āplease do not send me out aloneāā madame t: āoooooh my gOOOOODā omgĀ
what the fuck is thenardiers hair iā
WHAT THE FUCK IS THENARDIER IN G E N E R A L
random idea regarding thenardierās prison tattoo: he has the same number on his chest that jvj has. Meaning he was in jail too. so why isnāt he as messed up as jvj? i wanna say maybe he was in for less time, but like. I doubt it. However, he has a whole ass gang. did the thenardier gang break their boss out of jail? please say yesĀ
him listing things for baby Ć©ponine to charge i love it
OH MY GOD THENARDIER FLAUNTS HIS NUMBER WHILE JVJ DOESNT!! jvj hides his past because he believes it will get him into better places (it does, he becomes mayor for godās sake) while thenardier shows off his past with stubborn pride. while thenardier cheats his way to success, jvj lives an almost honest life where he ultimately suffers due to the stress all the hiding he does gives him
i love that Ć©ponine looks like neither of her parents,,,madame t got around huh?Ā
(The Bargain)
I JUST REALIZED THE STAGE HAS A CATWALK DOWN THE CENTER INTO THE AUDIENCE THAT IS THE COOLEST OMG
Instead of madame correcting thenardier on cosetteās name he asks cosette herself which prompts the CUTEST ANGRY YELL OF āitās cosette!ā I HAVE EVER SEEN
also thenardier fuckin MANHANDLING cosette iām DYING
JVJ LOVES HER SM I AM SOFTTT
(The Beggars)
omg marius is so ADORABLE i love him
gavroche is a style icon
kid holding sign saying āmy mom got laid offā POOR BB
i love Ć©ponine
thatās it thatās the note
wait a sec was that montparnasse with the prostitute earlier in beggars??
ALSO I SEE AZELMA AND OTHER THENARDIER KIDS PRESENT FOR āturn on the tears!!ā THANK YOU FOR UTILIZING THAT LINE PROPERLY
why does enj have a bat?? If it;s not a bat then,,,what is it? someone please help me
marius saves cosette from bad guy gang!! š„°š„°
bruh javert misses jvj running by like,,,MAYBE two seconds that is hilariousĀ
jav looks so done when thenardier is trying to get out of this lmao i love it
javert looks so cop-like it scares me
(Stars)
the line āsafe behind barsā in stars kind of kills me here because as the audience you SEE the cruelty that the convicts face. you see the guy on the ground getting beaten you SEE the chains around their throats and yet. yet javert still somehow thinks that putting jvj in jail is safe? i think the thing to focus on here is not whether itās safe, because it obviously isnāt. the focus is who itās safer for, jean valjean or javert?
has it always been āyour fatherā rather than āher fatherā when marius asks Ć©ponine to find where cosette lives?? if they changed it that is SMART because yk. jvj would be ALARMED if he found out heād been found by Ć©ponine but he wouldnāt hurt her. heās not the guy she has to worry about, itās her own father. thenardier gave her a job and sheās straying from it, heās what would endanger her.
THE PLAYFUL BOOP AND SHOVE FROM MARIUS š„ŗš„ŗš„ŗ
(The ABC CafƩ)
ānote-ruh daymā
hee hee pretty enjolras
pretty enjolras in skinny jeans even better
OOH we have,,,angry enjolras in this version o k a y
grantaire raises his hand before agog/aghast part omg
āiāve never heard him ooOOOOh and aAAAAh *excited squeal*
ādan joo-wanā i love texas
bossuet spotted :)
longing gay looks NOT spotted :(
i love enjolras okay but this one is just,,,a little too aggressive. enjolras isnāt just angry all the time, heās not that one dimensional. of course, there is more of the show to see and i hope he changes a little bit, but so far red and black isnāt doing much for me. enjolras is hopeful, not just angry.
A CAPELLA SECTION IN RED AND BLACK?? I think YES
the amis finding out lamarque is dead has āfuck trump just won the electionā energy
okay i was hoping that enj would change his aggression thing when they find out lamarque is dead (bc thatās when most enjolrai figure out what may happen and kinda sober up yk) but. it doesnāt look like he did. there is hope for barricade scenes
OMG LIL NOTE ON COMBEFERRE GIVING OUT FLYERS TO AUDIENCE MEMBERS: that is fucking pERFECT and yk why?? because itās a call to action!! itās less obvious in DYHTPS because theyāre mostly singing to each other but later in epilogue when the words and melody is repeated, itās meant as a call to action! āwill you join in our crusade, who will be strong and stand with me?ā is a cALL TO ACTION AND THEY ARE HANDING FLYERS TO AUDIENCE MEMBERSāthatās officially the only way to break the fourth wall THANK YOUĀ
hey fantine doubles as a student i think!!
HARMONIES ARE C L E A N OOOOH
(In My Life-Heart Full Of Love)
okay yes i already love cosette because she plays awkward-teen-in-love-for-the-first-time PERFECTLY.Ā
book-ish cosette hell yes a cutie
father-daughter forehead kisses š„ŗ
awkward mARIUS TIMEEEEE
placing marius, Ć©ponine, and cosette in a triangle is a MARVELOUS decision thank u for that symbolism
marius checking if he looks good and Ć©p giving him a thumbs up omg
*aggressively tries to sit normally* same cosette
*awkward curtsy* also same cosetteĀ
(Attack On Rue Plumet)
robbery time letās see how they do this
ooh marius and cosette run off but i canāt tell if they notice gang before running
thenardier fuckin SLICES Ć©ponine after her scream
NOOOO HER LIL WHIMPER AFTER BEING THREATENED AGAIN
(One Day More)
this lil part between robbery and one day more is interesting bc i legit have NO idea what jvj is thinking here. he keeps looking between his watch (i think itās a watch idk) and cosette after she runs off to pack so like. what. is he doing here bc he looks like heās choosing between two things but i donāt,,know,,what things
red berets on the amis are dope btw
i think marius is discussing what to do with Ć©ponine here, which is FUN because we all know why she goes to the barricade in the brick :ā) Ć©ponine might be convincing marius to go to the barricade knowing this is her chance to die with him like in the book
omg
OMG
OMG
that stomp bit with the students was the coolest fucking thing iāve ever seen
END OF ACT ONE
act two will be posted shortly :D
#enjoy my super long analysis on WHID and Stars lmao#i went ham with the english brain#les mis#les miserables#dallas theater company#modern les mis#les amis de l'abc#les amis
16 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
A ramble on Dallas Theater Center Les Miserables
So, 5 years late, I jumped back on the bandwagon and finally watched a bootleg of Dallas Theater Centerās 2014 production of Les Miserables.
And wow. I canāt believe I waited 5 damn years to watch it. So hereās a long rambling write up on it based on the live-tweeting I was doing as I watched (and a little bit on me skipping through the bootleg video right now). Itās partly just me summarizing scenes so I can nerd out about the little details I loved and towards the end me talking about the show as a whole and why it was so fucking important.
First of all I wanna say that I'm surprised it took this long for a professional theater company to do a "modern day" Les Mis. I know all the fans fucking love their Modern AUs fics, I've been reading them since like 2012 and I love them. But also I'm SO glad someone finally did it because Les Miserables' themes are universal and they are amazing but they're also really relevant to what's going on today, or 5 years ago (since it's only gotten fucking worse tbh).
My first big impression was how great the costuming was. You can tell the socioeconomic class of the characters just from what theyāre wearing, from how they posture and interact with others. Which is easy when itās period costuming, you just make everyone look dirty and ripped up vs not dirty, but this (aside from the Thenardiers) is a little more subtle.
Also re: the costuming, I absolutely LOVE that they modernized Javertās costume into a copās uniform but managed to retain the classic Javert Silhouette by giving him that trenchcoat, so we still get the expected Inspector Javert Silhouette despite the fact that heās a modern day cop. Also all of the other cops/soldiers being straight up SWAT was an excellent decision, not only because it shows the sheer violence of a police that isnāt supposed to necessarily be SWAT, but also because the helmets completely cover their heads, so when the soldiers sing lines, they donāt even sound human. Yet another layer.
Nehal Joshi as Valjean was great. Honestly the moment I keep thinking about is actually from the very beginning, just after Valjean is released. Joshi looks so happy, delighted, like his heart is light again. He smiles as he sings ā Drink from the pool / How clean the tasteā while looking up into the sky like heās amazed at being in the open air. Then suddenly his posture changes completely, becomes guarded and hard, his expression gets closed off, and he sings āNever forget the years, the wasteā before thumbing at his nose in that tough way and grabbing his bag off the ground. It was an emphasis on a pair of lines that Iāve never seen properly emphasized before. Usually the emphasis is on the next lines, when Valjean is saying āNow letās see / what this new world has in store for meā. But here they emphasize that despite being free, he has traumas he has to deal with, and experiences that mean heās wary of the world. It makes his theft of the silver make a lot more sense; itās not just opportunistic, itās also that he straight up doesnāt trust anybody.
(Another note on costumes: Valjeanās post-prison costume is his orange jumpsuit with this weird ratty, torn up sweater thing over it. I do very much wish theyād given him a hoodie that was equally as ratty instead of a sweater because I feel like that wouldāve been another interesting layer of commentary.)
Two notes I made specifically about this productionās Soliloquy: This production had Valjean rip his prison papers accidentally, while heās in the middle of an emotional gesture, then he stares at the rip in disbelief, and comes to the realization that he could just rip it up, and so he does. I thought that was a very cool mechanic. The audience literally watches him get the idea of changing who he is. Also, when he sings āI am reaching, but I fall / And the night is closing inā he actually wraps the rope of his bag around his own neck, like heās considering death, like he doesnāt know what to do with himself. I thought it was really interesting considering those are the lines that directly mirror/parallel Javertās Suicide.
This production also has all the Bad People roles played by white people, which is just fantastic. The foreman, Javert, all the cops, etc etc. I thought it was an excellent decision, since all of the main characters (minus the revolutionaries) are POC.
Fantine was amazing, has an incredible voice, and her I Dreamed A Dream sounded genuinely miserable, almost frantic with the fact that not only is she a single mother struggling to pay for her child whoās living with some other family, she now has nowhere to turn for money at all, and sheās completely alone. I think sheās my favorite Fantine of any of the ones I saw.
And Lovely Ladies absolutely blew me away. This was the first Lovely Ladies Iāve ever seen that felt Real. Not just that there was sex going on (because there was, thereās people fucking and getting blowjobs etc in the background the entire time), but it doesnāt feel like something silly or shallow. The entire thing feels desperate and exploitative and miserable and painful. Most of the other characters are dressed in provocative, revealing clothes. But there are a few in just jeans and t-shirts, looking desperate and kind of bedraggled. And then you have Fantine, who is literally just in a slip and long socks, looking out of place and terrified.
The usual Lovely Ladies shenanigans do ensue, but thereās a tinge of horribleness to it that is sharper than in the traditional show. In the traditional show, the moment where the music suddenly slows, and all the women sing āLovely ladies / Going for a song / Got a lot of callers / But they never stay for longā, it usually feels like kind of a weird and unprompted moment of introspection after so much ruckus, but in this version the reason everyone slows down is because the pimp plucks their cash out of each of their hands one by one. And then the horribleness is increased tenfold because all of the women are in a line with men behind them simulating sex, and Fantine is in the center, bent double, the Captain behind her, staring down the audience. With each thrust she grits her words out like sheās in pain in every way imaginable. And the Captain āfinishesā just as she hits the line ādead!ā Which is just. A lot. But so good. It packs so much more of a punch than Fantine leading the Captain offstage, or to one side of the stage.
The way that Confrontation was staged was also so cool to me. In the shows Iāve seen the first part of Confrontation is Javert and Valjean facing off with Javert stage left and Valjean kind of up beside Fantineās bed, but theyāre on the same ālevel,ā in that Valjean walks a few paces forward a few lines later and they grapple. In this version, they stood quite literally on either side of Fantineās hospital bed, so that theyāre arguing across her dead body.
Madame Thenardier made me think of a bizarre cross between Miss Hannigan, the mom from Matilda, and Patsy Stone from Absolutely Fabulous. She did a great job. M Thenardier is a douchey hipster pirate type guy with white guy dreads. Also they made him an ex-con as well, but he displays the numbers tattooed on his chest with pride compared to Valjean who hides them, which was yet another interesting decision.
This version of Les Mis has taught me that āMy mom doesnāt let me drinkā is the absolute BEST piece of spoken dialogue you could throw in before Master Of The House kicks the fuck off.Ā
Also this version has Eponine participating in the scams during Master Of The House: she takes peoplesā orders, carries plates, dances, etc. Sheās cleaner and more pampered than Cosette, but sheās still being used.
Look Down was really interesting to me. Now, I think what Iām about to say is partly informed by costuming. That is, I think with period costuming an audience has a harder time distinguishing more subtle roles between (non-main) characters. What I mean is, in traditional Look Down, it just seems like three characters having an argument with each other, but with a modernized version the costuming makes it clear that itās an old beggar woman, a prostitute, and her pimp. While thatās obvious from the actual dialogue, the period costuming makes it a little harder to glean the separate character types other than ābeggar typeā. Anyway, the roles being clearer via costuming makes all the interactions seem a lot more Real. Itās not just people all dressed alike singing lines at each other, itās actual separate people having actual conflicts.
Also, I really really liked Mark Hancock as Gavroche. Heās older, or at least bigger, than most kids who end up playing Gavroche, and heās not the most beautiful singer, but I think that works all the better for a production like this one. Heās not a cutesy Oliver Twist-type character. Heās a kid living rough on the streets, and heās got a sense of humor but he is a badass.
This version also had a LOT more flirtatious behavior between Marius and Cosette. Like itās not just one glance on the street. During The Robbery, Marius and Cosette are giving little glances and flirty waves the whole time, all shy and cute, little hand signals like āI want to talk to you oh my godā etc. Also this Cosette has glasses! Sheās so cute!
Stars as a song feels very weird when itās a Modern Day Cop singing about such a philosophical topic, and at first I was kinda ??? about it. Because you know, in a period piece, you kind of expect more elaborate language, you expect certain types of morality, etc. It sounds weird coming out of someone dressed like a pig youād see on the street in real life. But then at the end of the song Javert takes a rosary out of his breast pocket to sing āLord let me find him...ā etc, and suddenly it actually made a lot of sense. It finally connected the religious references and morality displayed in the lyrics. Because a lot of shitty cops in real life are masquerading as Christians, so again, a good decision.
Ah, the ABC Cafe. Always lovely to hear those horns. John Campione was AMAZING as Enjolras. At first I was a little disappointed they made him a white guy, but then I thought about it and it actually makes a lot of sense. Despite his passion about justice etc, Brick Enjolras is a wealthy student; what better way to show his privilege in a modern setting than to have him be white? Anyway, I think Campione did a great job of portraying a leader who is so passionate, and so dedicated, and so intent on his cause but also kind of stressed out as the day draws nearer. (More on that later.)
Similarly, this Grantaire is a little shit. He does this hilarious like ācall on me!ā hand raise before āI am agog, I am aghastā which I thought was quite funny and cute. Also after āItās better than an opera,ā the Amis all laugh and clap, and Enjolras does this extremely sarcastic slow clapping before admonishing Marius with āIt is time for us all to decide who we areā etc. Also Grantaire and Enjolras are actually standing beside each other for Marius lines, so that when he says āstruck to the bone in a moment of breathless delight,ā Grantaire looks directly at Enjolras and stays staring at him, so that when he moves downstage to stand across from Marius and sing āRed!ā andĀ āBlack!ā at him, it feels more like solidarity than mocking.
But then Enjolras pulls Marius further downstage for his āMarius you are no longer a childā etc lines. His body language is great here. When he sings āWho cares about your lonely soul,ā he doesnāt just look like some charismatic leader man. He looks like someone whoās stressed out and a little annoyed/exasperated that this person is causing a distraction right when things are started to get important. He runs his hands through his hair, his gestures are clipped and fast, like heās got too much energy and isnāt quite sure where to put it. Itās so good. He sings āOur little lives donāt count at all.ā And then thereās a long, long moment of silence. A long one, where Marius looks around at his friends and realization that what theyāre undertaking is much bigger than his emotional outburst, that Enjolras is right and he has to be with them instead of off in the clouds. And he raises his hand tentatively and then more surely towards Enjolras and sings that next āRed! The blood of angry men!ā all on his own before the rest of the Amis join in. GREAT decisions there. SO COOL. (Also this is the moment when an Amis Hand Sign is established, which is important later on.)
This show uses silence in a way that Iāve never really seen another version do it. After Gavroche yells āGeneral Lamarque is dead!ā thereās usually a beat of silence before Enjolras begins to sing. In this version there is a long, long moment of silence when everyone looks around at each other, a moment where Joly tosses his pamphlet angrily onto the table and sits down with his head in his hands, a moment where Marius and Grantaire are the only two who turn away and face upstage at the news, a moment where they all process that this is fucking Real, and everything that theyāve been planning is suddenly Actually Happening. And then Enjolras begins, and his voice is so soft, and so sad, and itās like heās delivering a eulogy, but itās only when he gets to āIs the sign we await!ā and we get those trumpets that it changes into Enjolras The Leader, and itās go time, and everything is Intense. Campione is fantastic as Enjolras because I think often people play Enjolras as this solid, charismatic leader who is stoney-faced and sure of himself etc. Which works for the period style (and is fairly Brick-accurate), but I think would seem a little odd in a modern day setting. This Enjolras is in it, heās into it, heās fucking intense and ablaze with energy. He sings Do You Hear The People Sing like heās giving a speech, like heās trying to convince (And āthe real glory is to convinceā so yāknow).
And Do You Hear The People Sing as a campaigning song is brilliant. It starts out not with march, but with handing out fliers made of red paper, passing them out and getting out the word. Only then do they pull out signs and put on red caps and start marching.
In My Life/A Heart Full Of Love was so fucking hilariously cute. Marius and Cosette are both excellent levels of awkward, and thereās a lot of nonverbal flirting going on, and I just thought it was really well done.
I was told while I was live-tweeting that during One Day More the sort of dancing march they do (because itās like a dance, instead of the in-place marching of the traditional version) is actually the Toyi-Toyi, a South African dance that was used as a form of protest during Apartheid and during other times as well. So that was a very cool addition. Iām sure there are other callbacks in this show to other protests or protest traditions like that that I didnāt even catch. The dance also reminded me of the body percussion used in A Quoi Tu Danses from 1789: Les Amants De La Bastille, so that was cool as well. We also get face paint and signs and red berets and button pins and a lot of stuff that has been seen in a lot of modern protests/movements lately.
Side note: Javertās disguise is amazing because he retains his cop boots and trousers and crisp white shirt; he just puts a brown jacket and a red scarf over it and wears a red beret.
OKay SO. This is possibly the BEST On My Own Iāve ever seen. Now, Iām highly partial to Briana Carlson-Goodman as Eponine because the emotion in her voice is just mind-blowing. But this On My Own was so amazing. First of all, Iām amazed Iāve never seen any other production do this: when Eponine sings āpretending heās beside meā, she puts out her hand like sheās holding some imaginary loverās hand, like sheās genuinely imagining him walking with her, and it made her self-deception that much sadder. And this version was so good, I think because it was this perfect combination of angry and disappointed and yearning and self-deceiving. You can tell this Eponine KNOWS sheās deluding herself that Marius will ever love her, that sheās hugely disappointed and almost angry at that fact, but she still loves him and wants him and wants that love, and it just makes that self-deception all the stronger.
This version of Les Mis brings the barricade in as a flown set piece, which I think is an interesting decision. I definitely prefer the US Tour version, where the downstage scrim is backlit/lifted and both the audience and Eponine are suddenly confronted with the fully-built barricade. However, the barricade being flown in does give the Barricade Boys a moment to stand and admire their handiwork, so thatās kind of also cool.
(Somewhat unrelated, but throughout the show this Grantaire is a lot more still than other actorsā versions of R, but also more still than the other Amis in this show, so itās clearly a choice. Other version of R are slumped over a table or slumped on the ground a lot, or theyāre wobbly, or just generally restless and upset. This R is so still and just standing unmoved and blank itās definitely a choice. Very much taking the āhe seemed to be waiting there for a bullet which should spare him the trouble of wakingā quote from the Brick and translating it to the stage version, in that he does move to shoot his gun but aside from that heās so stock still itās like heās given up. Anyway. Back to the actual show instead of me just waxing lyrical about my favorite character.
When Eponine climbs over the barricade, Marius waves down all the guns just as Joly yells āThereās a boy climbing the barricade!ā This kind of happens in other versions, but it seems like most of the traditional Les Mis versions all the Barricade Boys just kind of accept someoneās climbing the barricade and let Eponine over? In this one Marius like actually is waving down their guns, blatantly being like ādonāt shoot, I know this person.ā
And when Eponine is revealed to be shot, they donāt just let her die in Mariusā arms. The first half of A Little Fall Of Rain is sung with Eponine in Mariusā arms, but thereās also Feuilly there as a medic, pressing handkerchiefs to her wound, his hand on her with Mariusā hand on top of his and Eponineās on top of them both. When Marius is saying āand you will live āPonine,ā medic/Feuilly shakes his head at him as if to say, ādonāt tell her that, sheās not going to make it, Iām so sorry,ā but he still has his hand on her wound. Itās only when she sings āJust hold me now, and let it beā that Eponine pushes the medic/Feuilly away so she can die just with Marius. I really, really, really loved that because it seems so Right. Like, theyāre fighting for a better world, theyāre not just going to let an injured person die, theyāre going to try their best to help her even if sheās dying and thereās nothing they can do. And I really liked that there was a medic there, but he was faced upstage, away from the audience, as if he was trying to help but also not intrude on this private moment. But when Eponine does push him away, he goes fairly easily, like heās realized that sheās realized that sheās going to die. Also, instead of carrying Eponine offstage like a ragdoll, Grantaire and Feuilly bring over a stretcher and sheās carried off in it by Marius and Feuilly while Grantaire collects the handkerchiefs that were bloodied by her wound.
Valjeanās soldier disguise is the SWAT gear, even the helmet, although he mostly carries it in his hand rather than wearing it. Itās interesting because the difference between the SWAT gear and the suits he wears as Fauchelevent are a hugely stark difference, whereas the difference between his nice period clothes and the soldierās period uniform isnāt quite so intense.
I noticed that during Drink With Me, Joly put his hand on Grantaireās shoulder during āLet the wine of friendship never run dry,ā which is sweet. I also noticed that aside from the moments where he was shooting his gun and the few moments he was being helpful re: Eponineās death, Grantaire spends most of his time very very still, staring down at the floor with his shoulders slumped. He judges moments with just a shake of the head and turning away while others watch. His part in Drink With Me is sung with a bitterness that is more final than it is angry, like he canāt understand why theyāve all chosen to sacrifice themselves like this and he hates it and heās bitter that all his friends are going to die but heās realized thereās nothing he can do about it.
Bring Him Home is SUCH a hard song to sing and itās actually really interesting in this version, I think. Because in traditional shows I think Valjean is played as a fairly calm person who is just always calm. Joshi plays his Valjean like he has taught himself to be calm, but inside heās still kind of angry and traumatized and still has those instincts and still doesnāt quite know whether to believe in god or not, or something like that. So Bring Him Home is a moment where it seems like at first heās just hoping, and then by the end of the song heās genuinely imploring god to save Marius. Like itās the first time heās ever really begged a higher power to do something instead of just acting of his own power to make the good happen. I have no idea if Iām articulating myself well.
Again, Campione is a FANTASTIC Enjolras who plays him like a stressed out passionate leader who is constantly stuck between This Is Finally Real Hooray and Holy Shit This Is Too Fucking Real Oh God. In The Second Attack he portrays it really well, looking around at all the people he suddenly feels responsible for, body language like heās trying to make too many split-second decisions. Itās just really good.
Death Of Gavroche is also great because even though this Gavroche is not the best singer, he gets shot once and keeps reaching for the bullets, and only stops when they riddle him with bullets. Also, I didnāt realize this until skipping around in the video to write this, but I think they kind of tried to retain some of the Gavroche-Grantaire relationship that the US Tour established? Grantaire goes from being kinda listless stage left to bolting over to the barricade once Gavroche starts climbing, reaching for him desperately; he gets shot in the leg and goes down and spends the rest of Gavrocheās lines up to his death with his head in his hands. Once Gavroche dies, Enjolras actually checks on Grantaire and wraps a tourniquet around his leg while Feuilly and Marius tend to Gavrocheās body.
Marius gets a thigh injury during The Final Battle (we know this because this production shows Actual Blood! Gavroche is actually bleeding! Eponine, too! And Marius! And Enjolras! Like thereās actual red and it makes it so much more intense! Anyway, Marius gets a bullet to the thigh, which frankly I think makes a lot more sense than the shoulder injury he gets in canon at least in terms of him being unconscious for so long (although I guess in canon he also has at least one head injury so meh). Anyway, Valjean sees it and immediately tourniquets him as one by one all the revolutionaries are picked off by bullets.
This Enjolras death is my favorite Iāve ever seen. We donāt get a permets-tu scene, but thatās okay because this is fantastic in another way. Enjolras doesnāt die on the barricade.
Enjolras is standing center stage, the bodies of his friends around him. Heās shot once, in the stomach, and goes down on all fours. As heās on the floor, SWAT cops surround him, pointing machine guns straight at him. Enjolras struggles up, standing, and faces the cops and the audience. He raises his hand in a defiant fist to the air and is shot in the head.
Then there is a long, long stretch of silence. Quite literally an entire minute (I just counted) of silence, where there is no music, no speaking, nothing. Just the sounds of SWAT walking around, checking the bodies on the floor, and the indistinct sound of walky-talky chatter. Only after a whole minute of silence has passed and the SWAT leave the stage do the little plucked notes and the clarinet playing the Bring Him Home instrumental begin as Valjean stands up.
Valjean actually goes over and checks Enjolrasā pulse to see if he could possibly be alive, which I think hurts A Lot. And then thereās a moment where he looks around at all the bodies on the floor and kind of doubles over in shock, but only for a moment, and then heās bolting back over to Marius to make sure heās still breathing and then heaving him up into his arms.
(By the way, the bodies of the revolutionaries remain onstage through all of the proceeding songs.)
Dog Eat Dog is a boring, crap song in every production, and this one is no exception. The guy playing Thenardier is quite good but thereās really no way to redeem how boring a song Dog Eat Dog is. Also, this version cuts out the long instrumental part of Valjean walking with Marius through the sewer due to the fact that they donāt have that crazy projection thing. Instead itās just a few seconds of him dragging Marius before encountering Thenardier and then also a few seconds before encountering Javert. Also, Valjean straight up puts his chest against Javertās gun while heās asking to save Mariusā life. Brave as fuck.
Okay this Javertās Suicide was mostly really really good. Edward Watts gives Javert this sort of frantic emotion that Valjean spared him on the barricade and then is only asking to save this stranger. He looks genuinely freaked out and distressed. Itās not just confusion, itās like actual Freaking Out. The only part I didnāt like was the actual throwing himself off the bridge part, but honestly I feel like there really is no way to do that part in a way that isnāt a little ridiculous-seeming. Itās hard to have a show where they never had any sort of fly rigs or any special types of practical effects at all and then suddenly thereās a guy flying through the air? and take that seriously. I dunno. But in any case, the rest of it is really good because the frantic confusion and questioning and anger and sadness and everything is so well done. Also, he takes his cross out of his pocket and drops it on the ground before he jumps, like he believes even god has failed him.
And then the lights return and the bodies of the revolutionaries are still onstage, with police tape cordoning them off. Turning begins with women in black mourning clothes coming onstage: at first they stand behind the tape with candles and flowers and teddy bears, then someone breaks the tape and they move to sit beside the bodies and set flowers down beside them. As Turning is going on, as the women move to sit beside the bodies, Marius also enters and sits in a chair upstage.
So Empty Chairs At Empty Tables happens with the bodies of the revolutionaries lying on the floor right in front of Marius, and women in black kneeling beside the bodies, facing upstage. But as Marius sings āPhantom faces at the window, phantom shadows on the floor,ā the revolutionaries rise and move downstage, looking at him. They all make their little group hand sign before exiting, until itās just Enjolras looking at him, then he makes the sign as well and exits and Marius is left alone with the mourning women in front of him and his hand raised in farewell. Itās just SO GOOD because I think it makes it all the more real. It feels like heās actually singing to the bodies of his friends as well as their memories, like heās full of survivorās guilt and heās watching them walk away from him and doesnāt know what to do. Combining the Turning Womenās mourning with Mariusā mourning is really cool, because it shows itās really not just Marius thatās affected by this, and essentially heās singing Empty Chairs for himself as well as the women in mourning kneeling on the stage before him.
Side note: Dorcas Leung, who plays Cosette, is a True Fucking Soprano. Her voice is SO high. Itās wild. Like, really wild. Like, glass-breaking high but in a good way. Also sheās really cute.
Anyway, the next thing I took note of was Valjean telling Marius why he was leaving without telling Cosette goodbye. He sings āPromise me, Monsieur, Cosette will never knowā and puts his hand out in a way thatās partially imploring, and partially asking for a handshake on the promise. Marius says āFor the sake of Cosette, it must be so,ā but pointedly does not shake his hand. Heās going to honor the promise but heās not gonna fucking like it.
Wedding Chorale/Beggars At The Feast is mostly unremarkable except that Mme Thenardier is dressed like Cruella de Ville. Oh, and Thenardier gets a kick in the balls instead of a punch to the face from Marius. Also the actor who played Combeferre and the actor who played Bossuet are dancing together so during Beggars At The Feast when Thenardier sings āThis oneās a queer, but what can you do?ā, the Combeferre actor does a little wave.
Iāve always hated in the musical that Valjean goes from being perfectly healthy to straight up dying in a matter of minutes but I also understand that montages of like a year are hard to do in musical format, so I forgive it but itās still annoying.
Anyway, this Epilogue is FUCKING FANTASTIC. Valjean does this beautiful laugh of relief and amazement when Fantine tells him āAnd you will be with godā like heās still amazed after all these years that heās a Good Person Who Deserves Heaven.
Also, Fantine sits down on the bench beside Valjean, and then when Marius and Cosette enters, Cosette runs and sits down between Valjean and Fantine, facing Valjean, and thereās a moment where Fantine smiles in disbelief and strokes Cosetteās hair like āoh my god this is my daughter!ā
Finally, the fucking kicker for me: āTake my hand, Iāll lead you to salvation / Take my love, for love is everlasting.ā Thatās always the moment in the show when I start actually crying and this one made it even sadder: Eponine is not the only one to enter in that moment. Eponine enters singing the duet with Fantine like usual, but Enjolras and Gavroche also enter, standing behind her, not singing.
This was such a great, fascinating, unique decision, and I fucking loved it. Because with that group, you have all the types of love and belief that are Important in the Brick: Fantine, the love of a mother. Valjean, the love of a father and the faith and belief that comes from someone else suddenly believing in you and the goodness that is a result of that. Marius and Cosette, romantic love, but also love of children and chosen family. Eponine, unrequited love and sacrifice. Gavroche, not necessarily love but an innocent death, a death from the goodness that comes from wanting to help. And Enjolras, the love of the people, the belief in the people, love of patria and the belief in justice. Just all of these important symbols standing together.
Then Do You Hear The People Sing reprise starts up, and the rest of the cast enter and stand at the edges of the stage around the group at center before everyone scatters out and spreads across the stage.
So basically that was an incredible fucking show. Like, okay. Since joining the Les Mis fandom in late 2011-ish or something I've read A LOT of Les Mis fanfics, I've read the entire book, seen the show live half a dozen times plus a ton of filmed boots and movie adaptations and last year's BBC miniseries. I've got a Les Mis tattoo and I'm vaguely thinking of getting another one. I've read fanfic taking place in canon era, modern day, Mai 1968, the 90s, the 40s, and on and on. All of them are important because all of them interpret the themes differently. Basically what I'm saying is I've consumed A Lot of Les Miserables.
But this version of Les Mis is So Important. Like, it's important enough I'm really surprised they didn't give in to the call for a DVD recording back in 2014.
Because the difference between like, the traditional version of the show, and reading a modern day AU fanfiction, and this Dallas show is that this Dallas show is In Front Of You. It's important because you're used to seeing this show with 19th century clothes and 19th century mannerisms so you don't necessarily connect it to today, or you do on a surface level only.
And in fanfics you can imagine it, but it's not the same.
But this show takes the music we all know and the characters we all know and places it in front of us NOW. We get Valjean in an orange jumpsuit, posturing like we've seen people posture in real life. We get Enjolras in a denim vest and button pins. We get Fantine, a woman of color, being fired for having a child out of wedlock and being accused of prostitution, and having to actually turn to prostitution. And we get a depiction that shows so viscerally how horrible that is. We get white people as cops (SWAT, no less) while POC are abused.
Suddenly this is a show that connects on every level.
And not only that but the visuals of the actual rebellion can be connected to so many movements and protests and things that have happened in recent years. Like with the Toyi-Toyi. And all the signs and pins and face paint and weapons and clothes and even to some extent the barricade.
And the cops going from soldiers with bayonets (which, to be fair, back in the day were pretty daunting weapons with their triangular blades, but we don't see them that way) to SWAT with helmets that black out their faces and semi-automatics is a a hard-hitting message.
And I've always thought it was funny that people who see the show casually think it's about Marius & Cosette's romance. Because thatās not all itās about, of course. But this version made me really, really realize how little that romance matters in the musical. How much the musical is about Valjean, and then in tandem about the rebellion. Because place the whole "I've known you a day and I'm in love" thing in a modern setting and you realize how ridiculous it is, and how much more important Valjean's growth is, and how much more important the movement and the rebellion is. I mean the entire book is just about the Power Of Love And Belief In All Its Forms etc etc. But I think this version pointed out better than any other how many other forms of love exist in this story, besides the romance of Marius and Cosette.
But truly I think the most important thing that this show did is what I mentioned earlier: it placed the story, its themes, its characters, its rebellion, it's Love and Belief, in the Here And Now, and made it really, truly connect with its audience and the present world. This is a show that people always say is so relevant, so important, and it is. It really is. But sometimes, for a casual viewer, itās hard to see past the period costumes and sets. And then you transplant the show into modern dress and modern sets and suddenly itās a story that is just as believable and hard-hitting and important now as it was then. Suddenly you can connect with these characters and you can see these things happening in real life, in present day, and you can believe that it would happen.
It just blows my mind that we have all these Modern AU fanfiction pieces, that we have multiple groups of people doing Modern Les Mis Youtube interpretations, that thereās a Spanish musical out there thatās purely about Grantaire (which, god I wish there was more info on!), that thereās a ton of music and TV adaptations and yet this is the first time Iāve seen a professional company do any sort of modern interpretation of the show. And it works SO incredibly well and is SO hard-hitting and just took my breath away.
Uh so yeah such massive praise to the Dallas Theater Center for having the courage and imagination and awesomeness to finally do a modern version of this story because they knocked it out of the damn park and made an already important story even more important.
#les miserables#les mis#dallas les mis#dallas les miserables#dallas theater center#dallas theater center les miserables#les mis dallas#les miserables meta#les mis meta
45 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
Director Tom Shankland: From Punisher to Period Drama
The BAFTA and Emmy-nominated director talks about keeping Zen whilst battling a storm on Les MisƩrables and his chameleonic approach to genres
This month saw director Tom Shanklandās epic six-part BBC adaptation of Les MisĆ©rables draw to a close. Featuring an all-star cast including Olivia Colman, Lily Collins, Dominic West, and David Oyelowo, the songless adaptation breathes fresh contemporary relevance into the 19th century tale. No stranger to painting vivid worlds and bringing timeless stories and characters to life, Tom is responsible for directing high-profile feature films and series such as The Punisher, House of Cards, Luke Cage, The Missing, and WĪZ.
In this interview, the director, who is represented by Great Guns for branded content, reveals how he and his committed cast conquered a myriad of challenges to bring the colossal project to life, and how he changes gears from sledgehammer gore to period masterpiece.Ā
Q> Your most recent work - the BBC adaptation of Les MisƩrables - stars an impressive British cast including Olivia Colman, David Oyelowo, Lily Collins and Dominic West. What was it like working with them?
Tom> Victor Hugoās story features some of the most iconic characters in literary history. I always wanted our version to dig deep into what made these characters tick, whilst also making their world feel as viscerally real as possible. I didnāt want anything too stately or āchocolate-boxā-y, it absolutely had to have grit and soul - something only possible with a cast who were prepared to go to some extreme places.
I vividly remember filming the sewer scenes on a freezing night in Belgium; Dominic West [playing Jean Valjean] hurling himself into the mud, rain and river, whilst carrying Josh O'Connor [playing Marius Pontmercy] on his back. They were a tough couple of days but Dominic looked so epic in those shots.
Similarly, Lily Collins [Fantine] told me that she was really up for being pushed - words every director loves to hear! With that instruction, as soon as she arrived from sunny California to our -10ā set, I had the location staff switch off every heater in Fantineās set so Lily would really feel the cold and the camera could pick up her breath.
Olivia Colman [Madame Thenardier], one of the loveliest people in the world, was virtually in tears every time she had to do a scene where she beat Cosette. Whereas Lia Giovanelli, who played little Cosette, loved every minute!
Every actor dug incredibly deep every day and I marvelled at the way they shed all ego and completely disappeared into their characters and the world we were creating. They were the best bunch of people to have alongside you; I really could not have hoped for more from everyone who came on this adventure.
Q> This was a huge production with so many different variables. Did you encounter any interesting challenges during the process?
Tom> There were many, many challenges of shooting Les MisƩrables: the battles to protect the resources for the epic revolutionary scenes; coping with a monsoon storm in the middle of the day when shooting the Waterloo sequence; figuring out a way to write into the narrative a reason why our Enjolras had a hand injury when the actor, Joseph Quinn, arrived on set having nearly lost his finger the week before, to name a few.
Generally, I like to think that we found ways to overcome and even make virtue of some of the challenges. I love the shots of the rain at Waterloo that the editor worked into the sequence and how we gave Enjolras a heroic side story to explain his injured hand. There was one day I remember though (with a slight shudder), where we couldnāt find a way around it. The little girl playing child Ćponine just could not be persuaded to come to the green room to be filmed running around a tree, no matter what we tried. A brilliant little actress and truly such a sweet girl - it was just one of the days you can have as a six-year-old. We lost half a dayās filming and a massively important scene lay unfinished. Thankfully, two days later she was far jollier and the scene was completed - happy days! That was definitely the day I heard the First AD muttering 'Happy place! Happy place!' under his breath. All you can do in moments like that is be Zen.
Q> Youāve directed shows such as Marvelās The Punisher, chilling-murder mystery The Missing and now Franco-period drama Les MisĆ©rables. How do you transition between such vastly different genres?
Tom> I love directing different types of material; partly to push myself as a director and also because I love being a perpetual film student. Fundamentally I ask the same questions of the material: how do I make this moment convincing; how can I make the audience care about the hero; whatās the most cinematic way to build this characterās world; where is the tension in this scene; and what am I trying to say? In that sense, it feels easy to move from one genre to another because the most important questions are always the same.
In some ways, the differences between The Punisher and Les Miserables are only superficial. The audience who love The Punisher want Frank Castle to explode into brutal action at some point but when Valjean unleashes hell in Les MisĆ©rables, I would be less likely to go in for big close-ups - whereas The Punisher fans would be furious if they didnāt see the gory results of a sledgehammer attack!
Q> Youāre represented by Great Guns for branded content. What are the benefits of production company representation as an established industry figure?
Tom> I love being represented by Great Guns because, for me, itās important to be somewhere where the people know much more about short-form filmmaking than me! I can bring my point of view and filmmaking experience but I love working with people who can help me be very forensic about every detail in a frame - something that is absolutely crucial for short-form. I love this medium, and like all filmmaking adventures, you need the right gang around you. I do wish the auteur theory was entirely true, but, alas, itās only partially true.
Q> What has changed most in the industry since your debut?
Tom> At film school, me and most of my fellow film school brats wanted to go out and make indie films; TV didnāt seem like a very exciting place for a filmmaker to express themselves. High-end commercials seemed exciting and exotic with their vast budgets and such opportunity to express cinematic flair. They also had a great track record of supplying visually interesting directors to Hollywood, of course.
Cut to the present and these days a ācommercialā could be a ten-minute slice of somebodyās life shot on a smart-phone; bingeing a great TV series could be much more artistically and narratively fulfilling than 10 trips to the cinema; and maybe the best film of the year, Roma, was made for Netflix!
All of these changes are revolutionary and a massive tectonic shift for all three industries. Iām sure there are downsides too but Iām a glass half-full kind of person; I tend to think all these changes open up lots of new possibilities for different kinds of storytelling.
Q> Between genres, periods, and styles, youāve built up a versatile portfolio... Where do you draw inspiration from?
Tom> Iāve been very lucky to have had the chance to work across very different genres; a conscious quest Iāve been on since film school. I arrived at National Film and Television School obsessed with Ingmar Bergman and convinced that I was going to be a writer-director of angst ridden art films. Yet somehow, I ended up leaving film school having made a super-violent five-minute horror film and a ātrue crimeā murder story as my graduation film - both of which got me lots of attention and interest. I did get to do my āpersonalā film in the second year and it was absolutely one of the least successful things Iāve ever done; whereas the filmmaking in the two-genre shorts was much better (and confusingly, felt more personal).
This got me thinking about my childhood love of Westerns, musicals, thrillers, comedies, and classic Golden Age Hollywood entertainment made by directors like Howard Hawks and Billy Wilder, who jumped between genres all the time. You can see and feel the personalities of these directors in each of those different styles, even though their agenda was just to entertain the audience. I really think there is something liberating and joyous about not trying too hard to be self-consciously personal.
To be frank, I love losing myself in whatever story I am telling. Wherever you go, there you are...
https://lbbonline.com/news/director-tom-shankland-from-punisher-to-period-drama/
#les mis bbc#bbc les mis#tom shankland#dominic west#Lily Collins#joseph quinn#olivia colman#Interviews#articles
3 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
BBC Les Mis Episode 1
As promised (a few days ago ^^ā) my review/analysis/thoughts on the first episode of the new bbc miniseries!
Warning for spoilers ahead! And it got really long so uh! Warning for that too!
Oh my god itās 2000 words that's longer than some of the essays I submitted for uni good luck lads :,3
Iām just going to start with a few quick thoughts!Ā
Antagonists like Tholomeys, Thenardier and Gillenormand are all awful scumbags and perfect to hate! So great job there!Ā
Less of a great job with the font! Which was frankly an awful choice! Who's idea was that!Ā
The transitions were a little weird too. Switching straight from beautiful scenery and kissing scenes to Toulon threw me off a little ^^ā Ā
Tholomeys sure did piss on a tree though huh :,) somehow that was vitally important and needed screen time :,) Didnāt need to see a nude Felix either :,)
I would die for Georges and little Marius Pontmercy though. Georges.... is handsome.... and baby Marius is so precious omg!Ā āScoundwelā! I die!
Fantine was so sweet and precious it broke my heart :,)
The scenery was beautiful too!Ā
Oh and there were lots of animals featured too and I will talk about some of them later but I loved all of them especially the goats!
Just look at these little stars :,)
Right! Now all of thatās out of the way Iāll talk about what you were probably actually interested in if you follow me: Valjean and Javert!
I love Oyelowoās Javert. Heās an incredible actor and he clearly understands Javertās character and motivations. Plus..... hhhh sexy voice...... handsome.....
West is also a great actor and plays Valjean brilliantly, however thereās a few things Davies has done to Valjeanās character that Iām not too pleased with :/ But! Iāll talk about that next!
This is.... also definitely a valvert adaptation. If they keep up like this it might be even more of a valvert adaptation than 1978!
Iām going to talk about specific scenes now! And the first one Iām going to address is one that takes place in Toulon early on and has already been discussed a lot!
So. Does Valjean try to kill someone??
I mean. What happens is an intentional action. He sees a guard telling off another prisoner, waits until the guard stands underneath him and then keeps checking on him to make sure heās still there before he drops a fuckton of rocks on top of him. Was the intention actually murder? Maybe?? He smiles afterwards but he also smiles knowing that the guy isnāt dead and is only injured? So Iām not sure ^^ā He goes down to help lift the rock off the guard afterwards, but it seems more like at this point thereās some sort of threatening/showing off directed towards Javert, who was watching the whole thing, in a ālook what I can do you think you have the power here but I can hurt people too and the decision to save this man was in my handsā. Anyway I kind of like that? And kind of really hate it because itās really out of character. As a nonverbal exchange between prisoner and guard, I love it. As Jean Valjean purposefully perhaps trying to kill someone, I hate it. Because thatās not Valjean. Angry Toulon Valjean is sulky and hateful, not violent. So anyway thatās my Hot Take on that scene!
So the next Toulon scene I took notes on is also a valvert scene! Javert has a guard take Valjean to what seems to be some sort of torture room and has him restrained (sounds like a fanfic opening I know I promise this happens) then the guard leaves them alone together. This scene seems to be Javert ācorrectingā the power balance after what Valjean did earlier and it has so much potential to be an incredible scene! If the dialogue wasnāt so clunky! Javertās entire backstory is just dumped into the interaction and all it leads up to is a joke. Hey Davies thereās this thing called buildup and using this incredibly important information about Javertās character for something dramatic! Come on! Flashbacks! Shouting! Using it to suddenly make everything make sense! Not casually having him say it in the first episode it doesnāt mean anything to anyone at that point! Please watch Shoujo Cosette and take some inspiration from them! Even the musical drops the information at a Dramatic Moment! Wasted opportunity! Dsfsfsf anyway ^^ā despite the limitations of the script Oyelowo did incredibly with it and Iām so excited to see more of his Javert!
Oh yeah and Valjean strips in front of Javert did I mention that? (I mean. Iām not complaining about the Valjean butt š and muscular shoulders šš) Did I also mention that thereās implied interest from Javert? Iām actually... not liking this because I donāt trust Davies.... like, Toulon era is the least healthy way to do valvert which is fine in fandom where we understand that and do it anyway with that understanding, but in a real adaptation? Where that understanding isnāt established and itās real popular representation and Javert is implied to be a predatory gay man? I donāt like that too much. But weāll see itās only the first episode maybe itāll get better as we go along. Still not complaining about the Valjean butt uwu Also! āMonsieur 24601ā! So there is some good dialogue after all! Just do that with the other scenes!
Dsfsfsf just found āWas Valjean putting his head under a water fountain entirely necessary? No. Did I appreciate it anyway? Absolutely.ā in my notes without any context too lol
Uhhhh Myriel scenes! Myriel is perfect and I adore him Valjean is still too aggressive it doesnāt feel like him :/ The scene when Myriel gives Valjean the candlesticks was too creepy too I didnāt like that whatās with the creepy music Davies itās a nice good scene :,3
Petit Gervais sings! No singing allowed! Illegal!
Didnāt like what Davies did to the petit Gervais scene though!! Valjean intentionally stole the coin knowing what he was doing. It was supposed to be unintentional and unconscious thatās what makes it emotional and thatās what breaks him goddamn it! Of course I was very happy to have Petit Gervais included but I still feel like this scene had so much potential that was almost reached but just wasnāt quite!
But. Itās only the first episode. I still have hope that Valjeanās characterisation might improve later on! Please for the love of god letās not have a repeat of 1998!
So far I would say the miniseries is enjoyable enough and definitely still worth watching! No les mis adaptation is perfect and this certainly isnāt a bad one as of the first episode!
So now youāve read the part you actually wanted to read itās time for me to talk about (potentially unintended) animal symbolism >:3 Look I had the decency to put it at the bottom at least! Could I have made it a separate post? Yes. But I didnāt die mad about it.
Hugoās animal symbolism in the Brick is clearly something Davies has picked up on and decided to incorporate aspects of into his own adaptation. I donāt know how far or deep he intends to go with the symbolism but from the beginning thereās a fair bit of animal imagery in speech, mostly in relation to Valjean, but itās also once used with Tholomeys when Favourite says āhe looks as if he wants to eat you Fantine!ā Hugo used imagery of predators (and of eating people :,3) to indicate individuals as dangerous so this is very fitting with that line of symbolism. But Sirius! You say, a comment like that doesnāt automatically mean intentional animal symbolism! Not on its own no, but alongside everything else it looks more likely that itās intentional!
As I mentioned, the majority of animal imagery in speech in this episode is in relation to Valjean. The first example is when a guard calls a prisoner aĀ āfilthy dogā in one of the Toulon scenes. The prisoner isnāt Valjean but Valjean is watching. The next example is also in reference to dogs when Valjean asks MyrielĀ āhow can I love my fellow man when he treats me worse than a dog?ā Iām pretty sure this is a reference to the lineĀ āI am not even a dog!ā from the Brick which I got very excited about! As a brief summary of the symbolism of dogs in les mis, Javert is a dog. Heās a social outcast like Valjean but he chooses to protect society as a policeman, making him a domestic dog and not a wild beast. Valjean isĀ ānot even a dogā andĀ ātreated worse than a dogā because even though theyāre both social outcasts, Javertās position gives him some sort of status, while Valjean is left with a yellow passport and nowhere to sleep. The final reference to dogs is... actually not the final reference and comes before Valjean talks to Myriel but Iām talking about this out of order lol.Ā
Valjean goes into a building looking for somewhere to sleep and instead finds a dog who barks at him and chases him off. This is a reference to one of my favourite scenes in the Brick which includes this quote:Ā āI went into a dogās kennel; the dog bit me and chased me off, as though he had been a man. One would have said that he knew who I was.ā Javert is a dog. This scene is foreshadowing for the relationship Javert has with Madeline in M-sur-M. I really hope Davies takes the symbolism this deep by giving us a scene in the future that links Javert with dogs in this series! He probably wonāt ^^ā But Iāll still be looking out for it!
Hereās a post with links to more analysis Iāve done on dogs in the brick if anyone was interested!
Moving on to the other animal symbolism used with Valjean! Yeah thatās right Iām still not done! After Valjean takes off with Myrielās silver, Madame Magloire calls Valjean anĀ āungrateful beastā and then tells her brother off for āletting a wild beast like that into your houseā. There is, of course, also the scene when Valjean (to quote my notes) āroars like a beastieā before running away after Myriel gives him the candlesticks. The symbolism of āwild beastā is also something used by Hugo in the Brick and the meaning of that symbolism is described surprisingly unsubtly: āthe peculiarity of pains of this nature, in which that which is pitilessāthat is to say, that which is brutalizingāpredominates, is to transform a man, little by little, by a sort of stupid transfiguration, into a wild beast; sometimes into a ferocious beast.āĀ
Thatās all I have to say about Valjean but!! Iām still not gonna shut up!! Because now Iām gonna talk about Cosette!!
In her room, Fantine has a bird in a cage.
Look it even gets a shot to itself!Ā
This bird is also shown at the end of the episode when Fantine is holding Cosette.
There they are! This file is saved as birbsette on my laptop lol.
Anyway, Iām fairly certain that this is a reference to Cosetteās Hugo Assigned Symbolic Animal being a songbird, specifically a lark. Of course it could be that the bird in a cage is actually associated with Fantine but weāll have to wait until future episodes to see if the use of birds is continued and who theyāre linked to if it is!
So! In summary! Davies has actually set up the basis for a lot of animal symbolism in the first episode and Iām very excited to see how far he decides to take in in further episodes! And we also learnt that Sirius has a hyperfixation! Thanks for getting this far folks and as always feel free to add anything on to or correct any mistakes in my ramblings!
#click read more at your own peril :'3#Les Miserables#les mis#jean valjean#javert#valvert#monsters of our making#bbc miniseries
40 notes
Ā·
View notes
Text
I NEED YOU NOWĀ ā KLAINE
TAGGING ā Blaine Anderson & Kurt Hummel
LOCATION ā Kurtās apartment.
TIME FRAME ā Late evening, July 4th.
WARNINGS ā None as of yet.
NOTES ā After being devastated by a letter from his ex-boyfriend, Blaine doesnāt know what to do with himself or where to go, and he soon finds himself at Kurtās doorstep.
Blaine was enjoying his night watching the fireworks, surely he was alone but watching it from the roof of his apartment building. The fourth of July made him think about his ex boyfriend who was off in the military. He sighed, drinking his wine cooler, swirling the last half in his bottle. After the show was over he went down towards his apartment and he came to see a box there and a gift basket with things Blaine loved. Blaine took it inside and knew it was from his ex. He went to open things and then seen a letter, Blaine read it and he felt his heart break, he was getting married to a man he met in boot camp, apparently they were childhood friends and the letter was asking for Blaine to be the best man. He was completely devastated and he couldnāt attend his wedding so he immediately texted him telling him thanks for the offer but he couldnāt make it. Blaine didnāt know where to go, it was late enough that Kurt was probably home so he went to the boy he was always fond of, someone he enjoyed being around, he was hating to bother Kurt but he sat in front of the door and just waited for Kurt to show back up to his place.
Kurt sighed heavily as he pulled into the parking lot of his building, putting the car in park and shutting off the engine. Today had been the longest day ever. It had started off easy enough, with Kurt dropping Fiyero off at Codyās ranch for the day; the ranch was far enough away that he shouldnāt have been affected by the fireworks too much. The problematic times had started when he got to the theater. Not long into their first dress rehearsal, during the āMaster of the Houseā performance, the man playing Thenardier had stepped on the dress of the woman playing his wife and managed to completely rip the skirt off of the dress. Kurt wasnāt even sure how heād done it, considering just how tight his stitches had been, but of course he had. So now he had to completely fix the costume while the choreographer had to spend extra time on the blocking so it didnāt happen again. It didnāt help that he also had to fix Eponineās costume. The woman playing Eponine had quit at the last minute, and Vanessa had volunteered to take the role since they didnāt have an understudy for her. Kurt was thankful for that, but now he had to fix all of Eponineās costumes by Friday night. It was safe to say that he had a lot to get done in the next few days. Grabbing his things and the fabric pieces that used to be Madam Thernardierās costume, Kurt pulled himself out of his car. āCome on, Fi,ā he remarked, watching with a smile as his dog hopped out of the car. At least the day had gone well for someone. Getting to his apartment too a little longer than normal - Fiyero had gotten distracted a few times along the way since Kurt hadnāt put him on a leash - but soon enough he was on his floor and heading down his hallway. He hadnāt even noticed someone was in front of his door until Fiyero went bounding down the hallway. āFiyero!ā he called, a dominant tone in his voice that made the dog stop at Blaineās feet, though his tail was still wagging excitedly. Even from halfway down the hallway, Kurt recognized Blaine standing in front of his door. It was almost as if Blaineās presence alone had made him forget all about how stressful his day had been. āHey gorgeous,ā he said with a smile on his lips, though it quickly faltered as he got closer and saw the state the other man was in. āWhatās wrong?ā he asked with furrowed brows, juggling his things to free one of his hands in order to grab his keys and unlock his door.
Blaine was in his own world he didnāt even hear Kurt shout for his dog who was happy to see him, Blaine smiled, petting the dogs head, āHey Fiyero, whoās a good boy,ā he smiled softly, but the smile didnāt last long remembering why he was here in the first place. āI just, hey Kurt, I got some news that- well that I honestly wish I didnāt have gotten.ā Blaine entered Kurtās apartment and went to go sit down on the couch, heās been over at least a dozen times since moving here six months ago. āHeās getting marriedā¦ Jeremiah is getting married and he-he wrote me a letter and wants me to be the best manā¦ weāve only been broken up a little more than six months ago. He sent me gifts and I read the letter and my heart just felt like it shattered.ā
Kurt opened his front door and let Blaine into the apartment, listening as he spoke about what was wrong while Kurt put his things down on the table and kicked the door shut. āHeāsā¦wait,ā he paused for a moment, stopping in the middle of the living room area. āYouāve been broken up for six months, and heās already a) getting married and b) wants you of all people to be his best man? Seriously?ā he asked with a flabbergasted look on his face. āLike, I get that you guys are best friendsā¦or-or used to be, but things change when you take that kind of friendship to the next level. He canāt honestly believe that would be something youād be okay with doing?ā he asked, moving to sit down next to Blaine.
Blaine nodded, his face falling into his hands as he let out a soft sob, mainly out of frustration. āThey were childhood best friends who reunited in boot camp, itās like a love story Kurt, people would love to fall for their friends theyāve had a past with. I just, how could he think him inviting me was a good idea, he was sweet and I just, it broke me Kurt, I thought I was done with the past but thereās always something that comes back to bite me in the ass.ā When Kurt sat down next to Blaine he couldnāt help but throw his arms around Kurtās neck, āWhy would he do this to me?ā
Kurt frowned as he watched Blaine partially fall apart. Instinctively, he really wanted to just wrap his arms around Blaine protectively while also yelling at Jeremiah. How in the world could Blaineās ex think that this would ever be a good idea? He listened as Blaine spoke about Jeremiahās relationship with the man he was marrying, but listening as Blaine spoke about how this had broken him pushed Kurt forward. Almost as soon as he sat down next to him, Blaineās arms were suddenly thrown around his neck, and Kurt stiffened just a bit before relaxing and wrapping his arms around Blaine in return. Running his hand down Blaineās back in a comforting manner, Kurt nuzzled his nose against the side of Blaineās neck for a moment before shaking his head a bit. āI donāt know, hun,ā he whispered in response. āHe obviously wasnāt thinking.ā
Blaine kind of just melted in Kurtās arms, he was good at this comforting thing, he felt a little embarrassed coming to Kurt about his past relationship when he was feeling whatever it was he was feeling for the Hummel boy. Blaine just rested his head on Kurtās shoulder feeling like nothing else was going on, he felt like he was calming down in Kurtās arms, like he was the most comfortable pillow Blaine ever needed. He couldnāt help but felt a shiver run down his spine when Kurtās nose nuzzled against the side of his neck. āHe wasnāt, but itās okay, because I have the one thing he will never have again, and thatās my heart back, I can give it to someone who deserves it, you know?ā he moved out of Kurtās hold and wiped his eyes, āDo you have any kind of beverage, what a hell of a fourth of July, this is one of the first holidays Iāve had to spend alone in what feels like forever.ā
Kurt smiled a bit to himself as he felt Blaine starting to relax in his arms, calming down the longer Kurt held him. If he thought about it, he could really get used to this. Not the whole Blaine being hurt thing, but having Blaine in his arms. Normally, Kurt loved being the one who was being held, but in this instance he really didnāt mind. He loved the way Blaine just sort of melted into his embrace. Nodding in response to Blaineās comment about how he still had his heart, which he could give to someone who really deserved it, Kurt smiled a bit as Blaine sat back, out of his grasp. āThatās what matters. You deserve to be with someone who can actually appreciate what they have, even if theyāre not in the same place as you. Someone whoās not stupid enough to let you go,ā he said with a light smile, sitting back against the couch for a moment. When Blaine asked for something to drink, Kurt nodded a bit before pulling himself up off the couch. āOf course,ā he said with a smile. āDo you want a regular drink - water, soda, et cetera - or do you want something stronger?ā he asked as he walked into his kitchen. āIāve got Diet Coke, Sprite, waterā¦even some tea if you donāt mind waiting a little bit. And when it comes to something stronger Iāve got wine coolers, vodka, and about six different bottles of wine,ā he said with a laugh.
#[ i don't know if you want to keep the chatzy format or just delete the first posts and add your reply lol ]#t: i need you now#tag: threads#{ blaine anderson }#thread: blaine anderson
10 notes
Ā·
View notes