#(the deal was just for yennefer to deliver a COMPLETELY RANDOM girl to a certain location and that's it) | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

endiness · 18 days ago

Text

can i just say how much it fucking annoys me when show haters bring up geralt punching jaskier — A COMPLETELY RANDOM STRANGER WHOM HE DID NOT FUCKING KNOW AT THE TIME (and with the circumstances under which he punched him being jaskier positively calling him "the butcher of blaviken") — as proof that the show didn't understand their friendship at all though. like what friendship. what the fuck are you talking about. they met like five fucking seconds ago! what friendship! (and how does this """logic""" work anyway when geralt was still willing to basically die for jaskier a few hours later anyway!?!?)

#!txt: the witcher #eta: also same thing w yennefer ~betraying ciri and geralt in s2 #like yennefer didn't even know who ciri was when she agreed to voleth meir's deal #and she was under voleth meir's influence the whole time anyway #to the point where ciri was able to break through it #(also that like the situation w j/g yennefer was straight up willing to die for ciri in the next episode anyway)#(also that ppl think yennefer tried to kill ciri like that LITERALLY did not happen)#(the deal was just for yennefer to deliver a COMPLETELY RANDOM girl to a certain location and that's it)#(plus that doesn't make sense w what voleth meir wanted ciri for anyway)#eta2: AND the same thing w eskel and how ppl complain abt how he was ooc so that MUST mean the writers didn't understand his character #nevermind that he was INTENTIALLY written ooc because he was infected by the leshy #and both geralt AND vesemir comment on how eskel isn't acting like himself #AND there's a flashback in the next ep where eskel's disposition is a lot closer to that of his book characterization #like so many complaints ppl have abt the show are actually just them not paying attention to what's going on #or having no observational skills whatsoever let alone critical thought

14 notes · View notes