murkystarlight - Tumblr blog

murkystarlight · 22 days ago

Note

🎉 Quiz Time! 🎉

We're running a fun little quiz among some of the artists and writers in the fandom and we'd love for you to join in!

Participation is totally optional, of course. It's all just for fun, no pressure at all!

📝 How It Works:

If you decide to take part, all you need to do is rank the characters in each group from 1 to 5 for every question.

1 = highest, 5 = lowest

Please rank them within their groups only - no cross-group comparisons.

🧱 The Groups:

New Order of the Stone

Old Order of the Stone

Old Builders (we’re including Soren, Cassie, and Isa, but feel free to go with your own interpretation!)

The Admins

❓ The Questions:

For each group, rate the characters according to the following:

Who do you think is the most liked by in-game people?

Who is the fandom’s favorite?

Who’s the brains of the group?

Who’s the best fighter?

Who’s most likely to betray others for a minor/insignificant reason?

Who’s most likely to betray others for a major/significant reason?

Who would never betray their team?

Who’s most likely to commit murder on purpose?

Who would defend the murderer to the end?

Who is most likely to leave their hero/villain life behind and settle down?

Who’s the most charming one?

Who's the most intimidating one?

Who's the one to talk the group out of trouble?

🧾 Example:

Who would never betray?

New Order of the Stone:

Jesse

Axel

Olivia

Lukas

Petra

Feel free to add little comments or explanations to your answers if you'd like - that’s part of the fun!

If you're participating, please, use #mcsmquiztime so we can easily find all the answers!

Ooh this is exciting! I have bo reason to say no to this so... let's get started shall we?

It's a bit long so.. I have no idea how long this'll take lol

We'll be going through the questions then.

First question, "Who is the most liked by in-game people"

The ✨️NEW✨️ Order of the Stone!

Seriously who named the team.

....we have reached a dead end. And it's only the first one. It's fine. We're cool. Give me a moment to think....

1. Petra

My... very understandable reason for this is, she already had a few people who knew her back at Endercon, from when she did trades. Then, she becomes a warrior in a group and went on adventures, fighting monsters, getting some sweet loot, which definitely makes her cooler. Plus, I think people would appreciate the fan service. Cause, have you seen her in s1? She definitely gave out a lot of small gestures for fan service. Besides, what's not to like about a hot headed stubborn girl who's actually really nice n soft, and she shows that sometimes then pretends she didn't.

I feel like you can think 'hey, wouldn't her popularity be lower because of what happened in s2?' But I think... most of the "bad" stuff she did... was personal matter. The public wouldn't know. So... yeah. Maintained. I mean, not even Jesse knew and they're supposed to be best friends.

2. Jesse

Tbh, would've put them in first if it wasn't for Romeo playing pretend. It affected their reputation a lot, and the trust they built with the people before, was being questioned. But if it wasn't for that, Jesse is the one known to be the slayer of the WS. Saved the world. Went through cool adventures. The one who the people are most familiar with, runs a town(pretty well), and also just personality wise. Likeable for a lot of people.

3. Axel

Look, he's fun. Okay. On screen, on show, this kind of character works well for people. He can fight too, and is a very nice and friendly guy.

4. Olivia

I feel like she's more of a... favored character for a small amount of people. Small but obsessed.

Lukas I feel.. isn't really known as a part of the new order? I mean.. he wasn't on the stage, he wasn't adventuring with them, he was only there for portal hopping, then he wasn't with them again in s2. But, if he was, somewhere top rank. He looks good. Okay? It's said. OUT LOUD iwillstandbythis

Old Order of the Stone

1. Gabriel

Have you seen the people trying to get tickets to his show? He has a show. Where he talks to people. He is a goddamn CELEBRITY

2. Ellegaard

Well she runs a town. And everyone in that town looks up to her and respects her. And her inventions and ideas would've helped the world so i feel like a lot of people like her.

3. Magnus

Would've put him in second with Ellegaard, but I do feel like some of the people didn't think good of him. Or that some of the greifers just don't like him at all, while some of them admire him.

4. Ivor

Well, do we need an explanation? Reason why he isn't last, now he's much better as a person. People know him better. So ultimately a lot of people are more fond of this guy by now. Though there are still some people who absolutely despise him.

5. Soren

He was the reason of the lie, so he would be the reason for the WS?? Not sure on that one. But he ran. He ran from the problem and didn't try to fix it. Dissapeared and never appeared again. Final state would more be that he's.. forgotten rather than unliked?

Old Builders

1. -----

Honestly, most liked? For these guys? Eh... a bit hard to imagine for any of these guys. Though if I had to put one, out of them all maybe Isa. Though I never really thought of her as a old builder till maybe recently

2. Harper, Otto

Harper is still judged by the people in Crown Mesa a bit. Most people in other places are... mostly okay. Though there are still a few judgments when she tells them her story. For Otto... he didn't play a big part on making the games bad. But he also couldn't do anything about the others taking charge and making it bad. So people are not that friendly with him either. And maybe Soren could fit in here? Out of the old builders... what he did wasn't HORRIBLE

3. Cassie

Has a reason, a backstory, also not many know about her so... middle. Yeap-

4. Mevia

Compared to Hadrian, didn't get a chance to show people how she is. But they know she was bad and very on track with Hadrian

5. Hadrian

This dude doesn't know what's wrong.

The Admins

Umm... probably none. They arent known to a lot of people except Romeo. And the people don't like Romeo. That's for sure. But in the Underneath?

1. Fred

2. Xara

5. Romeo

Finally the next question! Second, "Who is the fandom's favorite?"

I feel like I'm applying favoritism but I aint. My brain refuses to believe that

The New Order or the Stone

1. Lukas

They say it themselves. The game itself. They acknowledge it. Kay?

2. Petra, Jesse

Umm... I do think probably Petra a bit higher than Jesse? I'm not quite certain nowadays mmmnnn

3. Olivia

People like her. But I don't think I've seen a lot of people claiming her as a favorite?

4. Axel

I think a majority of people don't like him. Same for Lukas. But he has a big amount that favors him. Axel.... not so much? From my experience ofc. But still-

Old Order of the Stone

These guys were a bit more complicated. I feel like people like em more for tragedy

1. Ivor

Might just be me. But people I've seen, love this guy.

2. Gabriel

....either I'm getting gaslighted. Or--

3. Soren

I've seen a couple stans. But not quite sure? I do see him a lot with ships n agnst

4. Ellegaard and Magnus

I think a lot of the work I've seen of them were... ships. Or the same person saying one of them are favorites and showing the love rather than a big number of people?

Old Builders

1. I think it's.. Harper?

2. Cassie

3. Isa, Hadrian

4. Mevia

5. Otto

Can't really give reason here cause... I really can't tell....-

The Admins

1. Romeo

2. Xara

3. Fred

We barely know anything about Fred. Yet know so much about him...

Next question, "Who's the brain of the group"

The New Order of the Stone

1. Olivia

Just sayin- if Ellegaard is alive, it means she proved herself to her and became her assistant. If Ellegaard is dead then... she somehow became the one in charge of Redstonia?? She has skill. Crazy skill. And probably with the hard work too. I say she's the one who worked her way up to the skill she has.

2. Lukas

More like a hunch but... he does have some bright ideas. Curious and questions things. He can write well? He likes to learn and explore, that's what he writes about.

3. Jesse

Just.. in the middle. Not amazingly smart or bright. But.. knows. Just knows. Plus Jesse counts as yourself. I was.. not very good at guessing lol

4. Petra

Definitely a bit brighter in certain subjects. But just... a bit less in a lot of the other parts? Not in a bad way. Just... average. Or maybe a bit slow

5. Axel

I feel like he's similar to Petra. But he appears less intelligent because of the way he presents himself

Old Order of the Stone

1. Soren

Old builder brain. He knows some weird crazy shit. But he does seem a bit... off. To people around him

2. Ellegaard

But in knowledge of just the world they are in? She might be smarter than Soren

3. Ivor, Gabriel

Both smart in their own ways. In their specialty. And also in understanding of humans.

4. Magnus

He either lights up randomly with facts or is a dumb fuck.

Old Builders

1. Harper

2. Cassie

3. Otto, Isa

4. Hadrian

5. Mevia

Sorry, she just doesn't fit that well as "smart" to me

The Admins

1. Xara

I think like her whole vibe was supposed to be machines? So-

2. Fred

I mean... he wasn't dumb. He was smart. Yeah. But... didn't really appear like that much. And he doesn't really use his brain that much.

4. Romeo

..okay, he's more... eh... questionable than dumb. Or not smart. But still.

Other than the first question, these paragraphs are getting pretty short-

Next! "Who's the best fighter?"

1. Petra

She is

2. Axel

Close second. Only because Petra can actually make a plan up in her head. Axel just jumps in. I think that affects the way they are seen by others, and the results of the fight.

3. Jesse

Yes. Very strong. I know... but feel like it'd be a bit less agaist Petra or Axel.

4. Lukas, Olivia

If they tried, they could probably win a fight or two. But they don't really bother?

Put these two up in a fight. In five minutes they are laughing and talking about how life is these days over chamomile

Old Order of the Stone

1. Gabriel

Well he is the legendary warrior. Like c'mon- besides, I don't think a lot of the order focuses on combat.

2. Magnus

He has a death ring.

3. Ivor

He fought agaist Jesse, and a weakened Gabriel/Petra. I think he can hold himself well in a fight. And also with his use of potions.

4. Ellegaard, Soren

I don't think neiter of em would do a lot of combat. Least not close up. Maybe if they use machines or other tacticts. In Sorens case, he's more the strategist type.

Old Builders

1. Mevia

Maybe because she looks scary? IDK why she looks scary.

2. Isa, Cassie

From their scenes, they seem capable. More than enough.

3. Hadrian, Harper

Honestly, Hadrian doesn't really seem like a fighter to me. And for Harper, I bet she got some good survival skills from playing hide and seek tag with PAMA

4. Soren

5. Otto

The Admins

1. Romeo

But it's unhinged

2. Xara

3. Fred

I think he would be a pacifist

okay now this question is tricky-- "Who is most likely to betray others for a minor/insignificant reason"

The New Order of the Stone

How minor-??

1. Petra

she's.. yeah

2. Olivia

If she was to betray others, I think it'd be for a minot inconvenience. During the heat of the moment, when even she didn't expect it.

3. Jesse

But like... not a big betrayal

4. Lukas

for something minor? I think he'd be pretty okay

5. Axel

He can get mad. But betrayal? Nah.. I can't ever imagine him like that

old Order of the Stone

1. Soren

2. Ivor

3. Ellegaard

4. Magnus

5. Gabriel

these guys.. well... the reasons are a bit complicated but it's too hard for me to explain

Old Builders

imma be really unfair about this one

1. Cassie, Soren

2. Hadrian

3. Mevia

4. Harper, Isa

5. Otto

The Admins

1. Romeo

2. Xara

5. Fred

And a similar question which tbh, I'm not very sure how big of a difference they have- "Who is most likely to betray others for a major/significant reason"

The New Order of the Stone

1. Petra

She proved herself a lot I think lol

2. Lukas

Don't judge my view of him too much-. It's a bit messed up but.. well it's something. Anyways, he's got temper so.. I feel like out of the rest. He gets a spot here on top

4. Jesse, Olivia

If it has a big, clear reason, they would think it through before betraying people

5. Axel

Old Order of the Stone

1. Soren

2. Ivor

3. Gabriel

If it's for the better good 😀

4. Magnus

I feel he's a similar personality guy with Gabriel

5. Ellegaard

Old Builders

1. Cassie, Soren, Hadrian

2. Mevia

3. Isa

4. Otto

5. Harper

The Admins

1. Romeo

2. Xara, Fred

Tbh not much different-

Next, "Who would never betray their team"

1. Axel

2. Petra

So... that makes no sense? But if you get the vibe... that would be wonderful :) (I'm sorry, I just can't think of the right words to explain this situation)

3. Jesse

This is a choosing game. There's a chance. Always a chance

4. Olivia

5. Lukas

Old Order of the Stone

1. Gabriel

2. Magnus

3. Ivor

4. Ellegaard

5. Soren

At this point, I just have something against this guy-

Old Builders

1. Isa

2. Harper, Otto

3. Soren, Mevia

4. Hadrian

5. Cassie

The Admins

3. Fred

4. Xara

5. Romeo

Almost there, "Most likely to commit murder on purpose"

The New Order of the Stone

1. Lukas

Yes. But with the right reasons.

2. Olivia

Only if it's absolutely necessary

3. Jesse

4. Axel

He could. Probably not entirely on purpose though..

5. Petra

Probably not on purpose. Or if it was, only as a last resort

Old Order of the Stone

1. Ivor

2. Magnus

3. Ellegaard

4. Soren

5. Gabriel

I cannot find good reasons for this;;

Old Builders

1. Cassie

She already has

2. Hadrian, Mevia

Only if the person is a big bother to them

3. Harper, Soren

4. Otto, Isa

The Admins

1. Romeo

2. Xara

3. Fred

They're pretty much like gods. Who knows what they could've done

"Who would defend the murderer to the end"

The New Order of the Stone

1. Petra

Well, it would depend on who the murderer is. Still gives them justice.

2. Olivia

She likes to believe in the good of people

3. Jesse

Hard to choose for Jesse really

4. Lukas

5. Axel

Old Order of the Stone

1. Ivor

2. Gabriel

3. Ellegaard

4. Magnus

5. Soren

Old Builders

1. ...no one?

I really can't think of anyone that would... um

4. Isa

Leaders need some mercy don't they?

5. Otto, Harper

Tiny

The Admins

1. Fred

3. Xara

5. Romeo

"Who is most likely to leave their hero/villain life behind and settle down"

The New Order of the Stone

1. Lukas

2. Olivia

3. Axel

4. Jesse

5. Petra

Old Order of the Stone

1. Gabriel

Think he's the one with the least regrets for the job

2. Ellegaard

She's good with her engineering. No need for being a hero or whatsoever

3. Ivor

Similar reason to Ellegaard. But he does seem to enjoy the hero thing more

4. Magnus

5. Soren

To me, his need of keeping his status as hero is like.. equivalent to Petra's. If not more. Whereas Petra seeks the thrill of adventure while doing so, Soren... not so much.

Old Builders

1. Cassie, Harper, Isa

I believe Cassie never wanted to go that far. Even if she did do it in the end. Same for Harper. Not what she intended. Plus she doesn't want to be stood out as villain. And she doesn't relaly have anything to be hero so.. thats that. Isa has stated she wants to let of her status and just be Isa and her best friend Benedict(then right after she claims to rebuild something similar to sky city. Curse the writing)

3. Otto

He stayed to continue the games as something fun again. But the villain status? Probably wants to let go of that.

4. Soren

5. Hadrian, Mevia

They don't seem like they wanted to give up the spot 🤷‍♀️

The Admins

1. Fred

He has. Hasn't he

2. Xara

4. Romeo

I mean.. he does seem to want to quit and seem to maybe feel sorry at the end of it??

Next! "Who's the most charming one"

..this is like... from my view. Right?

1. Lukas

Also, it's canon so. You can't argue :p

I know "everyone" is supposed to be attractive here but... it's mentioned in-game. That must mean something right??? I also did this experiment with my friends irl-

2. Petra

In season 2. It. I can't with her. I don't like her personality. But her looks? Aughhh she got me a soar throat from screaming so much.

3. Olivia

Love her. She is a badass. Yes. And smart too. And the sarcasm. Then came season 2- but she still got some charms there too so.. like the season 2 design is stunning

4. Axel

He's a cutie. I don't understand why people won't like him.

5. Jesse

No hate. Just... i think of Jesse as a very normal person. Just.. very very normal. No special features or anything. Besides, Jesse is me. That's the way I think of it.

Old Order of the Stone

1. Gabriel, Ellegaard

I dunno but yay i like these two. Both hot. And... a lot of influence probably. I'm into it now

2. Ivor

I like the energy:)

Plus he is a former madman villain. Sick

3. Magnus

Silly man. Also not very silly. Like him.

5. Soren

I'm telling you. I must have something against him-

Old Builders

1. Isa

She's beautiful. Girl boss.

2. Cassie

You can't say she isnt good looking and blood thirsty. Hot

3. Mevia, Harper

Gotta admit. She's pretty hot. Hot old ladies?

4. Hadrian, Soren

I only recently started to see Hadrian with the "oohhh... i see the appeal" so give a bit low score

5. Otto

No hate. He's sweet. But.. not charming. He.. he is kinda boring...

The Admins

1. Xara

...maybe I just like cool women

2. Romeo

He's a cool guy. Silly. Evil. Definitely got the charm. Yeah-

3. Fred

Huggable. He looks so easy going and nice

That was an awkward section- NEXT

"Who's the most intimidating one"

The New Order of the Stone

1. Axel

Stand in a dark corner and he'd be able to scare off people. Without. A mask.

2. Petra

Tall, sleeps with a sword, attitude???

3. Lukas

He needs to at least look intimidating or mean for you to make me believe the treehouse gang hated him. I don't see the connections other than that.

4. Jesse

If you can grab a crowd without talking and only the silence and looks? Yeah... some intimidating look you got

5. Olivia

Only by a smidge. Similar to Jesse though

Old Order of the Stone

1. Ivor

He looks like a rat. I think that's really intimidating

2. The rest can all go here. Yup. Similar but in different ways. But only slightly different

Old Builders

1. Cassie, Isa

They have their moments. I have specific scenes in mind...

2. Mevia

3. Hadrian

4. Harper

5. Otto, Soren

Yo these two are like absolute besties in my head

The Admins

1. Xara

2. Romeo

Only when he's like super mad tho. He rather not be seen as intimidating unless he wants to. And unless he really tries, he isn't too intimidating

3. Fred

We don't get a lot of info about him okay?? 'M sorry-

Last question! Finally "Who's the one to talk the group out of trouble"

The New Order of the Stone

1. Olivia

2. Jesse

3. Lukas

Feel like he wouldn't really step in unless its... super urgent

4. Petra

5. Axel

Old Order of the Stone

1. Soren

2. Gabriel

He would be in first with Soren but.... he sometimes likes to ignore the problem

3. Ellegaard

Same as Lukas actually

4. Ivor

He hates it. But sometimes. Just maybe

5. Magnus

💥 saves all. Who needs talking

Old Builders

1. Isa, Harper, Soren

2. Otto

3. Cassie

4. Hadrian

5. Mevia

Mostly vibes here i think

The Admins

1. Fred

5. Romeo, Xara

...yeah. for Xara, too much temper to talk it out. Maybe before the fallout she's a.. 3 or 4

Wow that took a long time... and a lot of thinking.

The post started to lag. I may have put too many comments. But

This was super fun! Thank you whoever for sending that message out to me :)

I haven't double checked this thing so.. if there's anything wrong with it... you'll have to tolerate it a bit 🙏

9 notes · View notes