thewayilikemycookie

[thewayilikemycookie]

This is so random but on ms. P’s desk instead of the book ‘beach read’, the title is ‘swamp read’ 😭😭😭

Art department I love you

[thewayilikemycookie]

Smosh summer games you will be missed

[thewayilikemycookie]

This clip single-handedly made me wake up and hear y’all out on Damien

Requests are open btw

"I'm the only voice that matters, you hear it?"

[thewayilikemycookie]

Okay chat be 100% honest with me rn

Would y’all hear me out if I wrote a Shayne x reader fic….

*runs away*

[thewayilikemycookie]

Aaaaa, the trevor fic was perfect! Tysm 😭

- 📼

YAYYY IM SO GLAD YOU LIKED IT!!!! 🫶🏻🫶🏻

[thewayilikemycookie]

hello ! would you ever consider writing a fic of reader going to surprise their partner* and him not expecting it (and definitely breaking character.) and just being so tearfully happy to see them...

it’s just a soft, fluffy little reunion fic. (why they were apart is up to you but I was thinking established!relationship)

*(I was thinking Trevor for this but it could be literally anyone and I’d read it. ive fallen down a rabbit hole w/ your Spencer and Alex fics but I luv Trevor so idrc)

also im sorry if this is vague / weirdly phrased. i dont send in requests to people who aren’t my mutuals often but this ideas just been rotating in my brain. feel free to disregard this if you don’t want to do it— there’s no pressure from me.

hope you’re doing well <3

- 📼

📍┆Hundreds of Miles .ᐟ

Trevor Evarts x gn!reader

# est. Relationship, pure fluff, reunion!! <3

Word count: 926

Warnings: none!

You sat in Ian’s office, fidgeting with your sleeves. You could feel the nerves all throughout your body, your breathing uneven and hands a little shaky. This was the first time you would be seeing your boyfriend in person in at least 6 months, so no one can really blame you for having this reaction.

You two managed to keep a steady and loving relationship, even with hundreds of miles in between you. You made your way around the obstacles, constantly texting and Face Timing each other. He would talk to you while cooking, eating meals, during breaks in set, driving home or to the Smosh office and before going to bed. You loved receiving calls from him while you were studying, it served as a nice reminder for you to take a break, texting him during lessons, sending him videos of random foods for his approval and falling asleep while on video call. Just the day before your flight to California, you and Trevor planned an online cooking date, where you would both make pizza at the same time, just in different states. And even though they were rare, you absolutely adored every second you got to spend with him.

You two simply matched each other’s energy in a way you’ve never seen before and it felt too precious to throw it all away simply because of the distance.

Now, sitting on the Smosh owner’s couch while you waited for a crew member to come get you from your hiding spot, you felt your love for your boyfriend more than anything else.

“Y/n?” You heard Alexcina’s voice coming from the now creaked open door “It’s go time” She smiled sweetly and you could tell she could easily see your nervousness

“This will be fun, they’re doing a gentleman’s werewolf- Wait, you know about the gentlemen bit, right?” She asked you with a perfectly raised eyebrow

“Oh, yeah” You answered exaggeratedly “Trust me, I do”

“I bet Trevor talks about it all the time, he loves that character” You laughed at how perfectly she had perceived your boyfriend. Truth to be told, he did talk about the gentlemen bit all the time (the chosen coming in close with second place)

“Then you would be totally right” You giggled as you and Alexcina approached a part of the office with huge shelves of props and racks of clothing

“Okay, so, the games stage is right over here. The plan is: We’ll stay in the back and I’ll give you a signal, then you can, like, step closer to the set and say that there’s a technical issue you need to fix” Alexcina explained and you smiled and nodded with excitement

You entered the games stage following Alexcina’s path and leaning on a desk in the unlit back of the set, far behind the cameras.

Seeing Trevor in so long felt refreshing and extremely nerve racking at the same time. You watched your lovely boyfriend from afar, as he looked at the sound crew doing mic checks. The fact that he was just a few steps from you instead of hundreds of miles away made your heart instantly begin to race.

You tried doing breathing exercises to calm your nerves, but the moment you saw Trevor burst out laughing from a cast member’s gentleman joke, it was over your you. Your smile got even bigger and you felt like you couldn’t contain your excitement, just wanting to run to his arms and stay there forever.

“Y/n,” You heard Alexcina whisper by your side. You turned to her and she nodded at you, giving you your cue

You tried your best to hide your excitement as you walked over to where the cameras were, with a new found confidence from wanting to surprise your boyfriend

“Hey guys, real quick, we need to fix a technical issue, so just-” You were interrupted in the middle of your sentence by Trevor’s loud gasp from the further side of the couch

“WAIT, WHAT?” He jumped up, recognizing your familiar face in a matter of seconds and you beamed at his reaction “OH MY GOD”

Trevor ran past the set and crew members with so much energy and you prepared yourself for the impact of his hug. He wrapped his arms around you and buried his face in the crook of your neck, whispering things like “no way” and " I can’t believe this” and “I love you so much” while you laughed with happiness.

You hugged him back with the same energy, wrapping your arms around his necks and resting your forehead in his shoulder, smiling and giggling at your boyfriend’s adorable reaction.

He pulled away and cupped your cheeks “I can’t believe you’re here!” He laughed out in disbelief and you smiled at him, wiping a sneaky tear from his blushed cheeks

“You better, the drive was really long” You joked in the quiet privacy of your own moment

Trevor suddenly pulled you in for a sweet kiss. You savored the feeling of finally being this close to him again as he pulled you even closer by your waist. Just this singular moment could make up for the last 6 months of face times and online movie nights you shared. Feeling Trevor’s lips against yours and the warmth of his body hugging you filled your heart with so much love you felt like you could explode from it.

You pulled away from each other with matching tear eyed smiles.

“Surprise!” You giggled, looking at your boyfriend’s loving gaze

A.n: Chat it’s SO late, so if this is bad, I’m really deeply sorry. Anyways, I’m gonna go to sleep, my bed has never looked this good. I hope you enjoyed this anon!! Have a great day/night everyone!! Love ya <3

[thewayilikemycookie]

Would y’all kill me if I started a series before finishing my current one 😔😔

[thewayilikemycookie]

Smosh summer games is MY the summer I turned pretty LIKE THATS MY SHOW BRO

[thewayilikemycookie]

would love a fic bout spencer x kinda dumb/ditzy!reader!! like she isn't actually dumb, more like is clueless when it comes to certain topics? and spencer's always rlly patient in explaining things to her. maybe someone makes a comment about it on social media and she gets insecure?

inspired by the reading reddit stories "The Worst of The Worst" and the stupid sister-in-law story.

🌱┆Feels Like .ᐟ

Spencer Agnew x f!reader

# Est. Relationship, Hurt/Comfort

Summary: Y/n’s cluelessness is both her biggest character trait and biggest insecurity. But whenever she has a question, her boyfriend, Spencer, is always there to answer it with all the patience in the world.

Word count: 1.2k

A.n: Loved this request!! Also, I’m sorry it took this long lol, hope you like it anon!!

“Hello and welcome to another beopardy, today’s theme: Video games”Shayne announced to the camera

“I don’t know why I’m here” You interrupted the moment, making everyone laugh

“Today our competitors are: Trevor, who has played video games since birth; Spencer, Director of Smosh Games; And y/n, she’s also here… with us… today” Shayne joked and you nodded intensely, staring at the camera

The first question was about an online video game and you watched Trevor guess ‘Fortnite’ and win the 50 points for himself.

“Can I say something vulnerable?” You asked with a smirk

“Sure” Shayne said while discarding the card

“I just learned about Fortnite. Like two weeks ago, Spencer explained it to me” You confessed and the room erupted in ‘what?’s and gasps

In the middle of the chaos, Spencer managed to say “No yeah- My proudest moment was being the one who gets to explain Fortnite to someone” Trevor doubled down laughing

“And that’s the thing about Spencer, he loves mansplaining video games to girls” You giggled “Okay, that’s not true, he was actually very patient. He didn’t even ‘WHAT?’ at me like you all just did” You aggressively pointed at your cast mates while Spencer smiled proudly by your side

You continued with the game, scoring a few points every now and then, but mostly just smiling incredulously at the cast’s knowledge. Every time Spencer would guess a question correctly or geek out about something, he would catch you smiling sweetly at him and you would catch him glancing over at you to see your reaction.

Reaching the final beopardy, Trevor buzzed in for a question

“I played that game, I don’t know his name though” He sat in thought, you caught the moment he ultimately decided he didn’t know the answer “Probably Craig Ligma, Am I right?”

A few crew members laughed from his corny joke, but you were confused, not knowing what the joke even was. You felt a little embarrassed to ask, but did it anyway, already anticipating their reactions.

“Who’s that?” You half whispered

Spencer turned his head in half a second “Who’s what?” He asked sweetly

“Craig Ligma” You felt all the eyes in the room on you

Everyone burst into laughter, leaving you confused once again. But Spencer just giggled and continued to look at you with the same kind eyes. You searched his expression for any type of support and he seemed to notice your internal embarrassment immediately.

He gently placed his hand in your arm “It’s, um… Ligma balls” Spencer explained

You laughed at your own cluelessness “I’m so stupid” You held your head in your hands while still laughing, cheeks feeling hot from embarrassment

“In the year of our lord 2025??” Trevor yelled

In the midst of all the chaos, Spencer leaned in and whispered with a smile “You’re not stupid, c’mon, it’s okay” You raised your head to face him, being met with his sweet and caring gaze

You pouted, making Spencer giggle and Shayne laugh even harder. You decided that the best place to hide was on Spencer’s shoulder. You leaned in and used your hands to hide your flustered cheeks. He used one arm to support your body, that was almost falling out of the chair, and the other one to pat your head, making a funny face to the camera.

To no one’s surprise, you got third place, with Trevor in second and Spencer in first. He celebrated the win with a “biggest nerd” sash and a playful smile.

After the shoot, you went to the games pod and laid down on their couch, opening YouTube. It was almost a tradition between you and Spencer that whenever he would work after hours, you would stay and keep him company. The late nights you spent editing together were what made you two so close, after all.

Now, you waited for him to finish a meeting in the comfort of the pillows and comfortable cushions of the couch. The video that popped up on your for you page was the newest games video, a horror video game where you were casted. You decided, irrationally, to check the comments. You knew you weren’t supposed to, but you remembered leaving that shoot with a smile, so they couldn’t be that bad, right?

Turns out, they could. A lot of them were nice, of course. But a smaller part were comments on your cluelessness, some even calling you ‘dumb’ or ‘ignorant’. This, of course, hurt you. You were obviously aware of the amount of questions you would sometimes ask, and subconsciously, you felt a little bad for wasting people’s time, but overtime realized that it wasn’t necessarily a bad thing. Your curiosity was what made you you. It was simply how your mind worked and after realizing you couldn’t change it, you just accepted it. But nevertheless, words like those made all of your insecurities come back in full speed.

Spencer’s voice interrupted your thoughts “Hey” He entered with a warm smile and two drinks in hand, but after noticing your expression, his face dropped “You okay?”

He placed the drinks on his desk and moved to sit by your side

“Yeah” You answered, but he could see right through you

“What’s wrong?” You felt the tears coming, but didn’t want to sound like a baby, so you tried to regain your composure. It was too late though, Spencer had already peeked at your screen and read the mean comments “Oh, baby”

He hugged you with a tightness you’ve never seen before, like his life depended on it. The warmth coming from his body and his hand caressing your hair was a little too much, making you break out into tears. He pulled away gently, only distancing himself so he could wipe your tears, offering you a caring smile.

“Dammit Spencer, you’re the best” You said, giggling. The negative comments now long forgotten, being easily replaced by your boyfriend’s warmth and care

“I highly doubt that” he huffed out through laughter, the sound muffled from his head buried in your hair

“I don’t” You met his gaze

You leaned in with a growing smile in your face. The kiss was short and sweet at first, until you slowly pulled away and Spencer leaned in again, with a certain intensity this time.

Your hands reached for the back of his neck and his for your waist and shoulders. You were both sinking in between the couch cushions more and more, not caring about the possibility of people passing by, since it was so late. The passion you shared made Spencer furrow his eyebrows and you grip onto the fabric of his shirt. You kissed him like he was your entire world and he kissed you like you were his.

When you managed to pull away from each other, you were both breathless. His hair looked a little messy and you were sure yours did too.

“Those comments don’t matter, they don’t know you. But I do, I know you like I’ve never known anyone and you’re so easy to love. Everything with you is always so new and fresh and exciting, it’s impossible not to love you. I promise”

You simply nodded with a huge smile on your face “Gosh, Spencer, I love you”

He offered you his usual smile, full of care and love, and how could you not lean in once again?

A.n: it’s LATE so if this is bad I’m genuinely so sorry, alright imma go to sleep now, hope you liked it, have a great day/night!!!

[thewayilikemycookie]

THANK YOU SO MUCH WTH!!!! 🥹🥹🫶🏻🫶🏻 I CANT BELIEVE THE SUPPORT YOU GUYS HAVE BEEN GIVING ME IN THIS SERIESSS!!!!! ILYSM 💗💗

(ALSOOO, new (and last) chapter out in a few days??? Brace yourselves!! I just wanna say ahead of time that I’m sorry for what’s about to come for these two, BUT THE ENDING IS GOOD I PROMISE)

🍂┆All That Can Be Seen .ᐟ

(Part 3) of “Call You Again”

[First part] - [next part]

Summary: When Spencer and Y/n get involved in a project together, they form a connection through conversations at midnight.

Word count: 2.0k

Warnings: Swearing

“Hello, everyone, welcome back to-” Arasha started the intro, but was interrupted by someone behind the cameras

“Hold! Sorry, it’ll be quick” A few crew members stepped into the games set to fix something with the lights

You were looking down, adjusting your clothes, when you spotted your drink right next to your feet. You looked up at Spencer. Who was sitting down at the Board AF table, chess board in front of him.

Spencer flashed you a grin and nodded in secret.

You took a step to the side and “accidentally” dropped your drink, causing it to tumble down and create a spill on the wooden floor .

“Shit, I’m so sorry” You covered your mouth with your hands, in (fake) shock, despise felling actually a little guilty

Spencer got up in a second, faking a passive aggressive tone “This is why we have a no drinks on set rule”

Immediately after he said that, he felt a tightness in his chest. Being so direct was unusual for him, specially like this - specially to you - “That was a joke, sorry” He added, offering you a shy smile

You smiled back. You noticed his expression immediately after he said it, and you couldn’t help but feel a little sorry for him. “It’s okay, it’s my fault”

“Don’t worry, it happens” He finished cleaning the floor and started walking over to his seat

You noticed Angela’s expression. She went into full acting mode and was looking at you two as if you were her parents arguing.

She looked over at Arasha and you made eye contact with Spencer once again. He secretly shot you a wink before turning to the chess board. You felt your whole face heat up and crossed your arms, refocusing your mind on something else. Oh wow the ceiling looks great today!

You self pitied the part of you that felt flustered by Spencer’s presence. Gosh, why, why, why?????

Angela interrupted your embarrassing thoughts “You good?” She asked

“Yeah,” You affirmed “Just a bit cold”

“We can turn off the A.C-” Angela started but Spencer was quick to interrupt her - with a certain urgency, you noted

“You can take my jacket, it’s on that chair” He pointed to a chair a few feet away from you, with his denim jacked placed on top of it

You looked at his face, trying to decipher if this was a complete honest moment or if it was a part of the plan you missed. He looked at you with kind eyes. You settled on the second option, for the sake of your own heart.

You walked over to the chair and picked up the jacket, putting it on. You hated to admit it, but it was extremely comfortable. You could faintly make out the smell of kickstart and Spencer’s cologne in the fabric.

You were in the writing pods with Erin, when Angela came bursting in, dragging a disheveled-looking Spencer along with her.

“SHE BOUGHT IT!!” She whispered yelled

“Did you really have to drag me here? What happened to ‘Hello, Spencer, my great coworker, how are you? Please follow me this way’” You laughed at his annoyed monologue

“Spencer, don’t fucking do this. ANYWAYS, IT WORKED!” Angela was full on shouting by this point

“Angela, be quiet” Erin laughed out

“It’s lunch time, it doesn’t matter,” She shrugged it off “anyways, I was telling Amanda and Chanse about you two hating each other’s guts”

You and Spencer shared a look but she continued “And Arasha was there, and she was like defending you, I personally think she got kind of annoyed, like I know it was playful but-”

“Angela” Erin interrupted “Did it work, or not?”

“HELL YES” She jumped in celebration and you smiled at your energetic friend “This bit city episode is about to be the best, I can SEE the views. 1 million…. 2 million… 3 BILLION” She gestured dramatically

“That’s a bit far fetched but okay” Spencer added and you burst out laughing

“Spencer calm down, just because it’s not your baby, Smosh Games, doesn’t mean its not important” She added, acting sassy

You were all laughing when you asked “What else are you guys doing?”

“Like two more ridiculous rumors, then we’re done” Erin answered “Not about you guys, though”

“Good, no more spills” Spencer joked

“Also, guys, why didn’t you tell us you were also doing the jacket thing? That was like, the cherry on top” Angela asked

You looked expectantly at Spencer, who appeared to be uncomfortable, as if he already felt guilty for something he hasn’t said yet.

“I- um yeah, I just saw the opportunity and took it” He didn’t look at you

Your heart dropped for a few seconds. You had already came to that same conclusion, but this tiny little part of you, a void in your brain that would whisper it’s thoughts, grieved the other possibility.

“Great call” You smiled at him and he could see right through your fake expression. None of you said anything after, just watching Angela dramatically act out the conversation she just had.

When Spencer had to go shoot a video, he hesitated to leave. He cleared his throat and awkwardly turned around to meet you

“I, um- great job”

Really Spencer, ‘great job?’ Really? He thought to himself, swearing he would never talk to any woman ever again after this interaction.

But all his doubts went away when you beamed at him “Thanks Spencer, you also did a great job”

Nope, forget about it, he wasn’t a loser, after all.

You really tried to not expect it. You brushed your teeth, turned off your lights and laid down in your bed. But something kept you up. You really really didn’t want to be this frustrated, but you were. You knew it was completely illogical, but you felt it anyway. You pondered getting up to get your phone, but it was a crazy idea, right? Yes, totally ridiculous, you would just turn around, shut your eyes and magically go to sleep.

Little did you know, Spencer was suffering from the exact same problem. Lying in bed, he would try to focus on the game in front of him, but after a few moments, he would find his finger hovering over the ‘call’ button.

You know what? Fuck it.

The speed in which you got up, picked up your phone and answered Spencer’s call was just plainly insane, you deemed it.

“Hi” You said, a little breathless

“Hey, that’s was quick” You felt your cheeks heating up, thank god he couldn’t see you in this moment

“I- uh- Why did you call?” You scrunched your nose in embarrassment. Y/n, why were you like this?

“Um- Good question. Can I say ‘out of habit’ and you pretend to believe it?” You could make out a tint of nervousness in his voice, which you thought was adorable

“Sounds great” You agreed, eager to forget your embarrassment as soon as possible. You noticed the lack of clicking sounds from the other line “No controller today?”

“No, I was actually playing on my phone”

“What game?” You fell into your normal conversation

“Balatro” He answered

“I see Shayne has already convinced you to buy it” You joked

“I honestly think he might be trying to get everyone in the office on it” You laughed

You and Spencer managed to talk about everything and anything at all. You explained to him your childhood, your hobbies and funny stories about your Smosh audition and he got into the details of surviving on a few hours of sleep, becoming a director and his favorite genres of games. Today felt a little different from the other days, as if the playful dynamic you would always fall into was long gone, only remaining the true curiosity you had for each other. Every time he shared something you felt like you understood him more, like it was a puzzle piece that fit perfectly into the picture of Spencer in your head.

“Okay, but seriously, did you not play any video games when you were a child?” His voice got lower with the hours, you could feel the tiredness in it

“I mean, I played arcade games, like a lot” You shared “My dad owned the local arcade so I would wait there after school, until it was closing time”

“You do realize that’s like every child’s dream, right?” You shared a lazy laugh, your stomach hurting by this point into the call “What arcade games did you play?”

You thought back on those childhood memories you cherished so much “My dad had this vintage Donkey Kong machine, that one was my favorite”

“I loved Donkey Kong” Spencer gasped “To be honest I loved going to the arcade in general, once I snuck out in the middle of the night to go to this 24/7 arcade close to my house”

“First of all: Insane lore drop. Second of all: Did you get caught?”

“Nope, I don’t think my parents ever found out, actually” You laughed at the image of mini Spencer in his pajamas, playing with a machine too big for him to barely even reach the controllers

Spencer sighed, he liked hearing your laugh “I don’t even know why I said that, I’ve never told that story to anyone else”

“Well, I’m honored” You felt the infamous butterflies in your stomach ”Your secret’s safe with me, by the way”

Spencer stared at his ceiling “It’s easy to tell you stuff” He whispered, the moment feeling too fragile. Like if he were to use his normal voice, it would break the spell

“What do you mean?” You whispered back

“Like, I don’t have to overthink it, I just say it and I know you’ll either laugh or be interested in it” His voice has a certain rawness to it. While you were still very sleepy, a part of your mind was wide awake, truly realizing what Spencer has just told you “Unless you’re just a really good actress”

“No, I’m interested” You were quick to clarify “I don’t know if it’s something about the whole video games nerd, or…” You slowed down

“Or what?” The hoarse voice in the other end of the call asked

“Or if it’s just you, but I want to understand everything about it. About you” You managed to punch out “I’m sorry of that sounds creepy or weird, or-”

“It doesn’t” he cut you off “You don’t even know, y/n, but it helps. A lot. You asked me questions about the most random stuff and I felt like I was finally being known… I think this helped me realize how alone I felt before”

He talked about this as if it was permanent, and it sparked your heart with the possibility. Over this last few days, you truly realized how much you loved and cherished his presence around you. You couldn’t help but feel at least a little hopeful.

“I really like your presence” You confessed “I never thought I’d say this but I think normal people need to normalize this more. It feels nice to just… talk to you”

“Thank you for admitting it” He lazily joked “Tell me more about that arcade” He whispered in the quiet of the night, like it was a secret just between you two

You talked about the memories you had with your dad and the games you would play. Spencer had a way of making you feel like you weren’t just saying words, but actually sharing a part of you with him.

“But yeah, I don’t remember much” You waited for his answer, but it never came “…Spencer?”

You glanced down at your phone. It was 00:42 and it showed you had been on call for almost three hours.

You realized he must’ve fallen asleep at some point in the conversation. If it was anyone else, you would’ve probably felt a little offended, but coming from the guy who claimed he couldn’t sleep before 2 a.m, you couldn’t help but feel a little special.

You knew it came from a place of being comfortable, not boredom, and that was enough to make your heart race.

A.n: I KINDA LOVE THIS ONE CHAT. Also, next chapter is the last one!! And can I just say, the Spencer x reader fics have been SOOOOO good this week???? I love all the writers in this fandom sooo much!!! Anywayssss, hope you liked it, have a great day/night!!

[thewayilikemycookie]

🍂┆All That Can Be Seen .ᐟ

(Part 3) of “Call You Again”

[First part] - [next part]

Summary: When Spencer and Y/n get involved in a project together, they form a connection through conversations at midnight.

Word count: 2.0k

Warnings: Swearing

“Hello, everyone, welcome back to-” Arasha started the intro, but was interrupted by someone behind the cameras

“Hold! Sorry, it’ll be quick” A few crew members stepped into the games set to fix something with the lights

You were looking down, adjusting your clothes, when you spotted your drink right next to your feet. You looked up at Spencer. Who was sitting down at the Board AF table, chess board in front of him.

Spencer flashed you a grin and nodded in secret.

You took a step to the side and “accidentally” dropped your drink, causing it to tumble down and create a spill on the wooden floor .

“Shit, I’m so sorry” You covered your mouth with your hands, in (fake) shock, despise felling actually a little guilty

Spencer got up in a second, faking a passive aggressive tone “This is why we have a no drinks on set rule”

Immediately after he said that, he felt a tightness in his chest. Being so direct was unusual for him, specially like this - specially to you - “That was a joke, sorry” He added, offering you a shy smile

You smiled back. You noticed his expression immediately after he said it, and you couldn’t help but feel a little sorry for him. “It’s okay, it’s my fault”

“Don’t worry, it happens” He finished cleaning the floor and started walking over to his seat

You noticed Angela’s expression. She went into full acting mode and was looking at you two as if you were her parents arguing.

She looked over at Arasha and you made eye contact with Spencer once again. He secretly shot you a wink before turning to the chess board. You felt your whole face heat up and crossed your arms, refocusing your mind on something else. Oh wow the ceiling looks great today!

You self pitied the part of you that felt flustered by Spencer’s presence. Gosh, why, why, why?????

Angela interrupted your embarrassing thoughts “You good?” She asked

“Yeah,” You affirmed “Just a bit cold”

“We can turn off the A.C-” Angela started but Spencer was quick to interrupt her - with a certain urgency, you noted

“You can take my jacket, it’s on that chair” He pointed to a chair a few feet away from you, with his denim jacked placed on top of it

You looked at his face, trying to decipher if this was a complete honest moment or if it was a part of the plan you missed. He looked at you with kind eyes. You settled on the second option, for the sake of your own heart.

You walked over to the chair and picked up the jacket, putting it on. You hated to admit it, but it was extremely comfortable. You could faintly make out the smell of kickstart and Spencer’s cologne in the fabric.

You were in the writing pods with Erin, when Angela came bursting in, dragging a disheveled-looking Spencer along with her.

“SHE BOUGHT IT!!” She whispered yelled

“Did you really have to drag me here? What happened to ‘Hello, Spencer, my great coworker, how are you? Please follow me this way’” You laughed at his annoyed monologue

“Spencer, don’t fucking do this. ANYWAYS, IT WORKED!” Angela was full on shouting by this point

“Angela, be quiet” Erin laughed out

“It’s lunch time, it doesn’t matter,” She shrugged it off “anyways, I was telling Amanda and Chanse about you two hating each other’s guts”

You and Spencer shared a look but she continued “And Arasha was there, and she was like defending you, I personally think she got kind of annoyed, like I know it was playful but-”

“Angela” Erin interrupted “Did it work, or not?”

“HELL YES” She jumped in celebration and you smiled at your energetic friend “This bit city episode is about to be the best, I can SEE the views. 1 million…. 2 million… 3 BILLION” She gestured dramatically

“That’s a bit far fetched but okay” Spencer added and you burst out laughing

“Spencer calm down, just because it’s not your baby, Smosh Games, doesn’t mean its not important” She added, acting sassy

You were all laughing when you asked “What else are you guys doing?”

“Like two more ridiculous rumors, then we’re done” Erin answered “Not about you guys, though”

“Good, no more spills” Spencer joked

“Also, guys, why didn’t you tell us you were also doing the jacket thing? That was like, the cherry on top” Angela asked

You looked expectantly at Spencer, who appeared to be uncomfortable, as if he already felt guilty for something he hasn’t said yet.

“I- um yeah, I just saw the opportunity and took it” He didn’t look at you

Your heart dropped for a few seconds. You had already came to that same conclusion, but this tiny little part of you, a void in your brain that would whisper it’s thoughts, grieved the other possibility.

“Great call” You smiled at him and he could see right through your fake expression. None of you said anything after, just watching Angela dramatically act out the conversation she just had.

When Spencer had to go shoot a video, he hesitated to leave. He cleared his throat and awkwardly turned around to meet you

“I, um- great job”

Really Spencer, ‘great job?’ Really? He thought to himself, swearing he would never talk to any woman ever again after this interaction.

But all his doubts went away when you beamed at him “Thanks Spencer, you also did a great job”

Nope, forget about it, he wasn’t a loser, after all.

You really tried to not expect it. You brushed your teeth, turned off your lights and laid down in your bed. But something kept you up. You really really didn’t want to be this frustrated, but you were. You knew it was completely illogical, but you felt it anyway. You pondered getting up to get your phone, but it was a crazy idea, right? Yes, totally ridiculous, you would just turn around, shut your eyes and magically go to sleep.

Little did you know, Spencer was suffering from the exact same problem. Lying in bed, he would try to focus on the game in front of him, but after a few moments, he would find his finger hovering over the ‘call’ button.

You know what? Fuck it.

The speed in which you got up, picked up your phone and answered Spencer’s call was just plainly insane, you deemed it.

“Hi” You said, a little breathless

“Hey, that’s was quick” You felt your cheeks heating up, thank god he couldn’t see you in this moment

“I- uh- Why did you call?” You scrunched your nose in embarrassment. Y/n, why were you like this?

“Um- Good question. Can I say ‘out of habit’ and you pretend to believe it?” You could make out a tint of nervousness in his voice, which you thought was adorable

“Sounds great” You agreed, eager to forget your embarrassment as soon as possible. You noticed the lack of clicking sounds from the other line “No controller today?”

“No, I was actually playing on my phone”

“What game?” You fell into your normal conversation

“Balatro” He answered

“I see Shayne has already convinced you to buy it” You joked

“I honestly think he might be trying to get everyone in the office on it” You laughed

You and Spencer managed to talk about everything and anything at all. You explained to him your childhood, your hobbies and funny stories about your Smosh audition and he got into the details of surviving on a few hours of sleep, becoming a director and his favorite genres of games. Today felt a little different from the other days, as if the playful dynamic you would always fall into was long gone, only remaining the true curiosity you had for each other. Every time he shared something you felt like you understood him more, like it was a puzzle piece that fit perfectly into the picture of Spencer in your head.

“Okay, but seriously, did you not play any video games when you were a child?” His voice got lower with the hours, you could feel the tiredness in it

“I mean, I played arcade games, like a lot” You shared “My dad owned the local arcade so I would wait there after school, until it was closing time”

“You do realize that’s like every child’s dream, right?” You shared a lazy laugh, your stomach hurting by this point into the call “What arcade games did you play?”

You thought back on those childhood memories you cherished so much “My dad had this vintage Donkey Kong machine, that one was my favorite”

“I loved Donkey Kong” Spencer gasped “To be honest I loved going to the arcade in general, once I snuck out in the middle of the night to go to this 24/7 arcade close to my house”

“First of all: Insane lore drop. Second of all: Did you get caught?”

“Nope, I don’t think my parents ever found out, actually” You laughed at the image of mini Spencer in his pajamas, playing with a machine too big for him to barely even reach the controllers

Spencer sighed, he liked hearing your laugh “I don’t even know why I said that, I’ve never told that story to anyone else”

“Well, I’m honored” You felt the infamous butterflies in your stomach ”Your secret’s safe with me, by the way”

Spencer stared at his ceiling “It’s easy to tell you stuff” He whispered, the moment feeling too fragile. Like if he were to use his normal voice, it would break the spell

“What do you mean?” You whispered back

“Like, I don’t have to overthink it, I just say it and I know you’ll either laugh or be interested in it” His voice has a certain rawness to it. While you were still very sleepy, a part of your mind was wide awake, truly realizing what Spencer has just told you “Unless you’re just a really good actress”

“No, I’m interested” You were quick to clarify “I don’t know if it’s something about the whole video games nerd, or…” You slowed down

“Or what?” The hoarse voice in the other end of the call asked

“Or if it’s just you, but I want to understand everything about it. About you” You managed to punch out “I’m sorry of that sounds creepy or weird, or-”

“It doesn’t” he cut you off “You don’t even know, y/n, but it helps. A lot. You asked me questions about the most random stuff and I felt like I was finally being known… I think this helped me realize how alone I felt before”

He talked about this as if it was permanent, and it sparked your heart with the possibility. Over this last few days, you truly realized how much you loved and cherished his presence around you. You couldn’t help but feel at least a little hopeful.

“I really like your presence” You confessed “I never thought I’d say this but I think normal people need to normalize this more. It feels nice to just… talk to you”

“Thank you for admitting it” He lazily joked “Tell me more about that arcade” He whispered in the quiet of the night, like it was a secret just between you two

You talked about the memories you had with your dad and the games you would play. Spencer had a way of making you feel like you weren’t just saying words, but actually sharing a part of you with him.

“But yeah, I don’t remember much” You waited for his answer, but it never came “…Spencer?”

You glanced down at your phone. It was 00:42 and it showed you had been on call for almost three hours.

You realized he must’ve fallen asleep at some point in the conversation. If it was anyone else, you would’ve probably felt a little offended, but coming from the guy who claimed he couldn’t sleep before 2 a.m, you couldn’t help but feel a little special.

You knew it came from a place of being comfortable, not boredom, and that was enough to make your heart race.

A.n: I KINDA LOVE THIS ONE CHAT. Also, next chapter is the last one!! And can I just say, the Spencer x reader fics have been SOOOOO good this week???? I love all the writers in this fandom sooo much!!! Anywayssss, hope you liked it, have a great day/night!!

[thewayilikemycookie]

🍂┆Let It Happen .ᐟ

(Part 2) of “Call You Again”

[First part] - [next part]

Summary: When Spencer and Y/n get involved in a project together, they form a connection through conversations at midnight.

Word count: 1.9k

Warnings: Swearing

Going into work the day after the phone call with Spencer, you prepared yourself to not expect any interactions with him, you were still basically strangers, after all.

You were, weirdly, still thinking about last night. You would’ve never expected to see that side of his, considering the Spencer you normally see. Maybe you just misjudged him, but for the guy who could guess games in one try and make jokes about ‘toucans’, he suddenly seemed caring and flirty? No, that sounds wrong. Definitely not flirty. You were getting ahead of yourself.

You grabbed a coffee from the kitchen, ready to start your day. You were working on a script with Tommy on the writers pod when Erin came in with her usual lateness and iced coffee.

“Y/n! Have you decided-“ She noticed Tommy’s presence “ that thing we were talking about?” You giggled at her reaction

The memories of last night came to you in a flash. You remember everything, like it was engraved into your mind. Him calling you ‘normal person’, you talking about video games, him agreeing with your suggestion for the prank without even thinking twice. You shrugged the memories off “Yeah, should I tell you at another time?”

“Sure” She exaggeratedly winked at you

“I swear to god, if this is another Arasha lie” Tommy shook his head and you laughed, before noticing someone else was at the door

“Sorry, um, y/n?” You recognized Spencer’s voice immediately. You turned around and was met with him in his Legacy hoodie and denim jacket.

“Spencer, what’s up?” You smiled at him

“Shayne’s not coming today, do you think you could you cover a sponsorship for him?” Spencer asked and you noticed a little awkwardness in the way he was standing

“Yeah, sure” You smiled at him

“Thank you, games stage at around 3 pm sounds okay?” He took a step back but still faced you

“Sounds good, I’ll see you then” you waved at him

“Bye Y/n” he waved back and his smile made your heart flutter

Spencer left, cheeks blushing from just seeing you. He had to get his shit together, he told himself while walking to the games pod.

You entered the games stage at around 3 pm, Spencer waiting for you, with a camera already set up, a podcast microphone on the Board AF table and the teleprompter and it’s respective controller ready. You noticed his legacy hoodie was placed on a chair nearby, and now he was wearing a shirt with the words ‘Mr. Sleep Deprived’ printed on it.

You giggled “Hey, that t-shirt really fits you”

He looked down and smiled at you “I’m surprised yours doesn’t say ‘normal person’”

“Fair enough,” you laughed and moved past him to sit by the mic “alright, let do this”

Spencer stared at you behind the camera as you got through the ad pretty easily. He watched your little mannerisms. Your smile in between sentence breaks, your wide open eyes and and the way you played with your sleeves.

“…And now, back to the video” You finished off with a smile to the camera. After holding it for a few seconds, you broke the pose and flashed Spencer a grin “is that all you need?”

To be completely honest, Spencer considered asking for another take or for another random sponsorship, just so he could have an excuse to spend more time with you. But decided not to waste your time and that it was totally creep behavior.

“Uh, yeah, thank you” he smiled, awkwardly standing by the table, weirdly dreading having to watch you leave

“Of course” You got up and stared to head to the door. Your mind racing through excuses to stay in the games stage for a little longer “I- um, you excited for any specific shoot… next week?”

What? What kind of question even was that? You felt your whole face heat up. If there was any 10 feet deep hole near you, you would jump and hide in there without having to think twice.

“Oh, definitely gentleman’s sniper chess” Spencer answered without hesitation, leaving you with your face burning for no reason “It’s gonna be a lot of fun. You’re actually casted in it, now that I’m thinking about it” He added and you smiled

“Okay, now I’m excited!” Your smile made Spencer’s heart flutter in secret “Do you know who’s my teammate?”

“We haven’t decided teams yet, but I made sure to cast Angela, Arasha, you and me” He explained “You know, for Angela’s whole thing”

“And because you wanted to play Sniper Chess, be honest” You played with the hem of your shirt

“I’m not confessing to anything” He joked

“That sounds even more suspicious” You looked down at your watch “I have to go back to work, Bye Spencer!” You grinned

“Bye y/n!” He offered you a shy smile back

That night you heard your phone ringing in the other room, while you were brushing your teeth. When you managed to pick up, you could still feel the minty flavor in your mouth. The call came from a non-saved number.

“Hello?” You asked

“Y/n?” You recognized Spencer’s voice instantly

“Spencer, you have to start calling me at a better time” He could make out your smile through the phone.

“It’s not even midnight yet!” He complained jokingly

“What do you need?” You said tiredly, giving up on arguing

“I’m sorry, it’ll be quick” he apologized and you thought it was sweet how he would do so the moment you showed any sign of seeming uncomfortable “It’s about the Angela prank. I know yesterday we agreed on scripted moment, but we forgot to actually, you know, script the moment”

You (mentally) face slapped yourself “You’re so right”

“So, I was thinking maybe right before we start filming?” You heard the clicking of his controller from the other end of the call “But, frankly, I don’t know what we should do”

“Hmm” You tried thinking about ideas for the planned moment while walking to your bedroom, but you found yourself getting increasingly distracted from the sounds of Spencer’s controller “Are you in a fight or what?” You asked with joking annoyance

“What?” He breathed out a laugh

“The clicking.” You answered with your eyebrows raised, even though he couldn’t really see it

“Oh, yeah, this guy’s beating my ass, to be honest with you” You laughed

“There are fights in Pokemon?”

“What did you think the game was about?” He asked in the middle of giggles

“Collecting weird animals?” You answered as if it was common sense and Spencer laughed in response

His laughter felt infectious. You only realized you were smiling when he started talking again “Well, close enough. You get to use those weird animals in fights, basically”

“That’s mean, they didn’t ask for that” You argued

“…Honestly, you’re kinda right. I’ve never thought of it that way”

“And I thought you had empathy…” You joked , turning off your lamp and sitting down in your bed “Anyways, are you winning?”

“Nope, Cheese has already lost half it’s life” Spencer casually said

“WHAT? Wait, you’re joking”

“Unfortunately, no” He laughed “But I’ll try to save him”

“Okay, I got scared for a second there” You joked and the call slowly went silent.

All the awkwardness and doubts you felt whenever talking to Spencer in person left your mind when talking to him like this. It was just you, the darkness and his voice through your phone’s speaker.

You could still hear the clicking of Spencer’s controller and his light breathing. For some reason, the moment didn’t feel weird to you in any way. It didn’t feel uncomfortable, just… easy, natural.

“It feels lonely sometimes” He breathed out, almost like a whisper

“What does?” You mirrored his soft tone

“Nights. For the most part it’s just me and this screen” He confessed

“Well, why don’t you just go to sleep, then? You must know that your employment isn’t actually based on this, right?” You leaned back into your pillow and placed your phone close to your head

“No, I know it isn’t, but that’s not it, it’s just- um, well, you know, my insomnia” His voice was still low in a whisper

“Oh… Is it bad?” You asked carefully

“Most nights, yes. Others, not so much” Spencer sighed “I’m used to it, though. That’s how I became a video game nerd, actually. When I was a child I would secretly play a bunch of games until, like, 3 a.m.”

You chuckled, thinking about mini Spencer in dinosaur pajamas staring at the pixeled screen, playing video games “That actually makes sense”

“What’s that supposed to mean?” He laughed and you grinned upon hearing the sound

“I mean, you’re the exact same now. Except maybe you’ve grown a few inches” He laughed even harder and your smile got wider.

“I need to work on my public perception” He joked

“What?” You asked, a little shocked

“Everyone must think I’m a loser nerd” Spencer laughed

“No they don’t, I mean, you are a nerd, yes, but not a loser. Like, Director of Smosh Games? That’s pretty fucking cool” You admitted

“Really?” He asked incredulously, still with a joking tone

“Yeah, dude” You wondered if you had maybe gone too far, if he would pull out of this at any moment and break the illusion.

You waited until Spencer broke the silence “Nah, I still think I’m a loser”

“Well, that sounds like an internal issue, not an external one” You laughed softly “I promise” Spencer could feel the honesty in your voice

“If you promise, then I guess its settled” He said in his normal, joking tone. You sat in the quiet of the night, until something shifted in the other end of the line “Thanks for saying that, y/n” Spencer said, his voice filled with vulnerability

“You’re welcome, Spencer” He felt like he could almost see your expression as you whispered. He smiled back at your invisible grin.

You started laughing out of nowhere, realizing something “We forgot about the prank”

“Oh shit” You shared giggles when Spencer lazily came up with an idea “Should we just go with a drink spill or something?”

“Ah yes, the classic drink spill” you sighed “That works for me, you could get a little mad, like, jokingly even, and Angela can exaggerate later”

“Alright, deal” He grinned “I’m sorry this took so long”

“You’re sorry? Wow, maybe you do have empathy” You smiled tiredly

“I did manage to save Cheese… just saying” You snorted

“Goodnight, Spencer” He felt a certain tightness in his chest

“Goodnight, y/n” The call disconnected and Spencer stared at his phone for a few seconds, now only showing is home screen.

‘You have to start calling me at a better time’ ‘Director of Smosh Games? That’s pretty fucking cool’ ‘I promise’

Spencer felt his head spinning. What did this even mean? Did you really think we wasn’t a total loser? Did you actually want him to call you again? Cause goddamn, he wanted to call you again.

No, you’re overthinking this, he thought to himself in the silence of the night, don’t be weird, she was just being polite.

But despise this, he couldn’t shake off the feeling that took over him thinking about it.

Thinking about you.

A.n: Did y’all know that Pokemon fight? Cause I had NO idea. Anyways, how much italics is too much italics? I feel like I exaggerated a little BUT I forgive myself cause I just really love italics. Hope you liked reading this, cause I’ve been loving writing it, have a great day/night, ily!!!

[thewayilikemycookie]

NEW SERIESS!!!!

[thewayilikemycookie]

🍂┆Stay Up .ᐟ

(Part 1) of “Call You Again”

[next part]

Summary: When Spencer and Y/n get involved in a project together, they form a connection through conversations at midnight.

Word count: 1.7k

Warnings: none!

You and Spencer Agnew weren’t made to be friends. And you were okay with that fact, really, you were.

With your busy schedules and chaotic environment, you two never got the chance to even start a conversation. It felt like it was a decision made by the universe, so you just accepted it.

Of course you would still interact with him, mostly during videos, it’s your work after all. But for the most part, his presence in your life came from watching him from afar. Watching him direct a Games video, watching him have conversations with other people during lunch, watching him during morning meetings. Maybe it sounded a little creepy, but you swore it wasn’t anything like that. By this point, you felt like making the effort to start a connection was wasting time, and he seemed to agree, since he also never made any move.

Spencer was very much aware of your relationship - or the absence of it - but didn’t want to overstep any boundaries, so he never made any direct effort in order to turn your interactions into something more than just friendly small talk. With time, he made himself comfortable with just experiencing you from afar, through your acting and your comedy.

This was reality. You both accepted, in your different terms, that this wouldn’t just change out of the blue.

It was a non-shoot week at the Smosh Office and you got a text from Erin, one of your friends in the Bit City team, to be in the meeting room in a few minutes.

The message itself wasn’t weird, this was Smosh after all, random meetings and production decisions made in the last minute were to be expected. However, this one lacked context, you thought they had already locked in next week’s videos, so what was this meeting about?

When you got to the meeting room right next to the entrance, you were met with Erin, Ian&Anthony, Angela and, to your surprise, Spencer.

“Hey, y/n!” Erin greeted you with a smile “Please take a seat”

“What’s this about” You smiled, following her instructions

You noticed Spencer looked just as confused as you. You shared a look of ‘I don’t know, do you know?’

“So, as you remember, we had the liars episode last month” Ian said and Angela nodded by his side “and Angela here was a victim of Arasha’s scheme… again”

“I want revenge!” Angela shouted

“Yeah, so we came up with a plan,” Erin took over “and we need your help”

She explained the plan to you and Spencer. Angela wanted to make Arasha think she’s a bad person by spreading fake rumors around the office, you and Spencer ended up being the victims of said rumor.

“We just want to know if you’re okay with it, of course” Anthony added

You looked over at Spencer to check for his reaction and found him already looking at you.

“I’m in, it seems like a funny idea” You said

“Yeah, sure, count me in” he nodded

“Okay, great!” Angela celebrated “we have a few options of, like, things to say to her, but you guys can choose or come up with something else”

“I’ll send you the google doc” Erin dove into the screen in front of her and you sat in silence for a few seconds

“If you want to pull back at anytime, you can, by the way” Ian added

“Of course” Angela said “But it wont be anything crazy, probably just like one of you ate the other person’s snack or something”

She explained how the point of the prank wasn’t to ruin you reputation, but for Arasha to think Angela is a liar, who crates fake rumors out of thin air (so she would realize how it feels to be lied to).

“Damn, Ang, you’re going hard on her” You commented

“She deserves it” She joked “No but for real, its a funny bit, right?”

“I think it’s pretty funny” Spencer smiled

After the meeting ended and you walked out of the glass door, you wondered to yourself: what did you just get into?

This was an insane idea, not only could you get asked about the rumor from Arasha or other people, but you could be asked to act out a fake rumor about you and Spencer, a coworker you had never had a proper conversation with. What were you thinking?

You convinced yourself it would be okay and that you wouldn’t have to do anything, it was all Angela and her extroverted magic. You would be helping a friend with her plan, you and Spencer would continue on as almost strangers and it would end up being funny to watch the reveal of the entire scheme during the Bit City filming. It was just another one of your fellow cast member’s antics that the fans would love.

That same night, right after turning your bedroom’s light off and snuggling under your comfy blankets, you heard a ‘ding’ coming from your phone. You wondered who could be texting you at this time.

You opened your phone to an unknown number:

unknown: Hey, It’s Spencer. Erin gave me your number after the meeting, so we could decide the whole thing

You: Hi Spencer, I haven’t checked the google doc yet

Spencer: Do you wanna get on a zoom call?

You did a double take. Was he really asking you to get on a video call at midnight?

You: It’s midnight?

Spencer: And?

You: My computer is in the other room

You watched the bubble with the three dots appear, then disappear. You wondered what nonsense he would say next. After a few seconds, your screen turned black and you saw that same number calling you.

The sheer boldness of it all made you pick up.

“Hello?” You said

“Hey” You hear Spencer’s voice through the phone

“Spencer its so late” You complained

“Yeah, but who the hell goes to sleep at midnight?” Spencer ask and you couldn’t tell whether it was sarcasm or not

“Normal people?” You responded

“Okay, normal person, can I make your bedtime late by like 5 minutes?” He asked in a joking tone

“You know what, sure,” What was up with you today? Who in their right mind would call their coworker in the middle of the night and who in their right mind would pick up the phone? “What do you need?” He could make out the tiredness in your voice and it made him feel a little guilty

“I can call you tomorrow at a better time, if you want to” He suggested. You thought it was strange how fast he backtracked

“No need, I’m wide awake now” You put the phone in speaker mode and placed it on your pillow

“Alright, if you say so,” you could hear the clicking of a keyboard from the other end of the line “I’m opening the doc”

For a few seconds you only heard the clicking of his mouse and his light breathing. It made you wonder what he was up to at this time of the night

“What do you even do at this hour?” The words came out of your mouth impulsively

“There’s no other time to play video games” He said as if it was a reasonable explanation “And that’s kind of my employment” he joked

You knew the last part wasn’t true but you laughed anyway “How do you have energy during the day, though?” You asked, actually curious

“Why do you think I drink Kickstart?” He joked and you giggled. You thought about just how effortlessly funny Spencer was known to be

“What game are you playing?” You realized you were actually interested, not just making small talk

“It’s one of the Pokemon games” He answered, also caught up in the conversation “Have you ever played any of them?”

“Would you believe me if I said no?”

“Maybe” You shared soft laughs and the call went silent for a few seconds, you noticed it didn’t feel uncomfortable like a normal break in conversation would. Spencer cleared his throat “Right so, anyways, I’ll read you the doc”

You made a noise of agreement.

“Pretending one ate the other’s snack, lying about y/n throwing a fit over a rule from a board game, scripted moment during a games video, Spen-” He read

“I like scripted moment” You interrupted “Arasha should also be there, not just Angela, so when she lies about it afterward Arasha would get really confused”

“Alright, seems good to me” you could make out the smile in his face even though you couldn’t see it

“Great, I’ll talk to Angela and Erin tomorrow”

“Okay, thanks” Right after he said that, you heard a gasp from the other end of the call

“You good?”

“Yes! I just got a really good Pokemon” You giggled at how boyish he sounded like “It’s not funny y/n, this is serious stuff”

“Sure, serious stuff” You repeated in a joking manner

“What should I name it?” He asked and you sat in thought for a few seconds

“Hmm, name it cheese” That got a laugh from Spencer

“Kid named cheese” He said through giggles “Alright, cheese, welcome to the family”

You smiled at the domesticity of it. For a second you let yourself get lost in the thought of Spencer playing games late at night with his makeshift Pokemon “family”.

For someone who outside seemed like a tough - but nerdy - guy, he was showing a certain softness in this side of him.

Spencer noticed your silence “Well, this took a little more than the 5 minutes I promised, but either way, goodnight y/n”

“Goodnight, Spencer” You said through a yawn

You turned off your phone and set it on your bedside table. If you told yourself from 10 minutes ago that you would have this conversation with Spencer Agnew, you would’ve never believed it. But even more unexpected was how he really, actually was. You met another version of him, completely different from the Spencer he shows the camera. Instead of misogynistic jokes and nerdy comments, this Spencer was sweet and called his video game animals his family.

Maybe some things could really change out of the blue.

A.n: All my Pokemon knowledge comes from having Alex’s streams in the background while I’m writing, so take this lightly. Anyways, NEW SERIES?!?!?!!?!! Hope you like it, have a great day/night!!

[thewayilikemycookie]

🍓┆Careful Whispers .ᐟ

Spencer Agnew x gn!reader

Summary: When y/n is having a bad day, the only person who can bring her happy energy back is Spencer, her boyfriend

Word count: 769

This was that one really rare time where you actually enjoy the night part of playing werewolf.

Ever since you joined Smosh, you have been known to bring a lot of energy and hype up every singe one of your cast members, on and off camera. This wasn’t a persona or anything, it was just you. So, chaotic shoots came naturally to you. It was easy for you to act as the one who starts or continues high energy, chaotic and funny moments.

However, today wasn’t like most days. It had started off when woke up late, got dressed in a rush and ran to your car, then realized you were running out of gas. It was safe to say you got to the Smosh office later than expected, which didn’t leave you enough time to drink your morning coffee before the first shoot of the day.

Everything else after that had gone by in a blur, you making sure to look presentable on camera, but not having enough energy to burst out with screams or laughter. During lunch, you didn’t engage in conversation, just watching your fellow cast members talk. This was a little strange to your co-workers, who were so used to your constant laughter and interesting comments. You reassured them you were okay, just having a bad day and they didn’t press you on the issue.

Now you were sitting down on the left corner of games couch, enjoying having your eyes closed for a few seconds but dreading the next 45 minutes left of the shoot. You looked at your boyfriend, Spencer, off stage, he was wearing his Legacy hoodie and his Smosh hat.

Spencer looked at you and like he had a sixth sense for it, he immediately realized you were silently asking for a 5 minutes break. He waited for the night to end to finally say “Could someone pause the audio really quick? We’re gonna take a quick five, for um- technical issues”

You tiredly smiled at him and mouthed the word ‘Thanks’, before standing up and looking for a quiet space. You ended up grabbing a drink and sitting on the green room, staring at the art in the wall.

“Hey, can I come in?” You saw Spencer at the door. His presence instantly brought you warmth. You nodded “You okay?”

“Yeah, just having a bad day” You patted the couch, gesturing for him to sit down by your side

“I’m sorry I didn’t notice” He sat down next to you, your legs touching

“You were busy, it’s okay” You smiled at him, your eye blinking slowly “is it time to go back?” You frowned

“In 2 minutes” Slowly, he placed his hand on your knee and you rested your head in his shoulder “do you wanna watch the moose master video with me later?”

“On the couch? And with a blanket? And popcorn?” You lazily grinned up at him

“Alright, I’ll break the ‘no food on set’ rule for you” He smiled at your closeness

“YES!” You grabbed his arm in excitement. The idea alone made you happy and warm

“There she is!” His smile got even bigger as he held your hand and got up from his seat

“Okay, let’s do this, I want my popcorn as soon as possible” You walked to the games stage once again and sat down on the couch with a fresh smile on your face.

The shoot went by quickly, starting off with you making a big effort to be your chaotic and happy self, but in the end, with the cast’s help, it came to you naturally. You managed to win as the werewolf for your last round, which everyone went crazy about.

After wrapping up the video, the cast dissipated for a break before the next shoot, but you never even left the couch, just laying down and calling for Spencer’s attention.

“Spencerrr” You acted as if you were melting into the couch. He brought his computer and a fluffy blanket to the couch

“I’ll go grab the popcorn, stay here” he kissed the top of your head and you snuggled in between the cushions

When he came back, popcorn bucket in one hand and drinks on the other, he snuggled right by your side

“Wow, you’re also breaking the ‘no drinks’ rule?” You asked, incredulously

“Don’t tell anyone, though. Pinkie promise” He held up his pinkie and you offered yours

You rested your head on the crook of his neck and over time he could feel your breathing slowing down. He smiled to himself in the darkness of the set.

A.n: THIS IS BAD IM SORRY, have a great day/night, ily, I promise I’ve been working on something bigggg

[thewayilikemycookie]

Is the way you like your cookie…like this?

https://youtu.be/hwSI44SJqAg?si=Djq-lu2lkLAvkBQC

Noo 😭😭 this is

[thewayilikemycookie]

🎞️┆True Gentleman .ᐟ

Spencer Agnew x gn!reader

Summary: When you jokingly die during a gentleman games video, Spencer breaks character to make sure you’re okay.

Word count: 766

You love Spencer Agnew and of all his weird characters. You love The Chosen, John D Bad, Fred Darts, Broody, etc, etc. However, one character definitely stood out between all the others: Gentleman Spencer.

Gentleman Spencer was always the one who got you to break the most. Whenever he got into that suit and grabbed the top hat, it’s like he became a completely different person, with a completely different mindset.

You believed that part of what you found so amusing about Gentleman Spencer was how incredibly opposite he was from the real one. Your boyfriend was a soft and loving nerd that would make stories up about your stuffed animals. So, of course, the complete absurdity of his gentleman personality made you automatically break character.

This is why when you saw “Gentleman Throw Throw Burrito” written on your schedule with Angela, Trevor, Spencer and you as cast, you almost jumped out from excitement, already anticipating the chaotic energy.

After waiting all day for the shoot block to come, it was finally time.

“Hello Gentleman, welcome, everyone, we gather here today to Throw Throw a Burrito” Angela faced the camera as she said the intro dramatically, complete with a British accent “We want to find matches and throw out cards like duel, then people will have to duel… with the burrito”

“Yes” Trevor laughed

“Amazing intro, Sir Angela” Spencer didn’t break character, saying it with total seriousness, which made you burst out laughing

“It’s Sir. Cognac Buttarack to you” The fact that you guys were already gasping for air while laughing at the start of the video was telling

You stated off with a ‘Burrito Brawl’, where Angela hit Trevor in the head and made his hat fall off. The game was going well for you, you were winning a lot of ‘burrito confrontations’ and your cheeks and belly were hurting by this point.

Suddenly, Angela called out a burrito duel between you and Spencer “Okay, here we go” you didn’t know why, but you simply couldn’t stop laughing

“You okay?” Trevor asked, reacting to your breakdown

“What? This is like me with Sanguinis Wenis” Angela was also crying from laughter

“Guys, we have to get our shit together” Spencer said in between giggles “Okay, y/n, let’s do it”

“Someone count us down” You were still laughing

“Alright, three, two one, duel!” Angela shouted with a British accent

As Spencer turned around to face you, you started running immediately, but your lack of breath from laughing so much slowed you down.

“Wait! Wait, don’t!” You tried calling for mercy, but Spencer didn’t show any for you

He threw the plastic burrito in your direction and it happened to hit your head directly. You dramatically fell to the ground, pretending like your head got painfully struck.

Within a second, Spencer was by your side, acting as if you were dying. You were legitimately gasping for air, the gas leak energy getting to your head.

After a few seconds filled with laughter, Spencer’s voice got low and he dropped the accent “You okay?” He asked and you nodded. You noticed him caressing your shoulder “You sure?”

“Yup” You smiled at him breaking character

“Yeah? Cause that fall looked a little too real” His voice was still low and his body was leaning into you, making it feel like you were having your own moment

“I’m good Spence” You put a hand on his shoulder, giving him a soft smile

“Alright” Your eye contact lingered and he took a moment to look at your expression. After he confirmed you didn’t hurt yourself, he looked back to the Board AF table with the British accent “You know, this actually reminds me of me of this one time, in the amazon…”

The video went on with the chaotic energy continuing all throughout, but you couldn’t stop the thought of your boyfriend and how sweet he was. Every time Spencer made a gentleman joke, you thought about how he could break character in a second for you.

After the shoot was over, you were still giddy from the antics you and the cast pulled. You looked at Spencer, still in his costume, and your heart filed with love. The emotion made you giggle.

“What?” He asked, growing a smile just from seeing yours

“Nothing” You answered with a soft smile

“Do you wanna come over today?” he walked over to your seat

“Yess” You intertwined your fingers with his and he took your gentleman hat off to kiss your forehead

You smiled, feeling extremely loved by your sweet boyfriend.

A.n: not feeling great about this, but I’m working on a bigger series, so this is just to fill the time. Hope you have a great day/night!!