#why tf was Adar in the forest anyway why not enter Eregion to execute Sauron on the spot? | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

mistwalkers-menagerie · 1 month ago

Text

TRoP Season Finale spoilers under the cut

Fuck this show.

If this was fanfic I'd gobble it the fuck up but these people are writing official Tolkien stuff. Half-assed bluster poetics ain't really gonna cut it for me even though I'm not a Tolkien purist.

Rest in peace Adar, you would've loved the Tragedy of Julius Caesar (not)

#never for a moment have i been a hater but #they try even if clumsily build up sympathy for the orcs through Glúg and through their loyalty to Adar #only for them to turn coat OFF SCREEN?#like yeah orcs will orc I'm not mad about them betraying him but HOW they betrayed him #like you give us a really cool concept of Nenya healing Adar's very soul the moment before you kill him off?#why tf was Adar in the forest anyway why not enter Eregion to execute Sauron on the spot?#he HAD to lose at one point I ain't delulu but this death wasn't poetic to me it was just a waste #like I see the semblance of logic in everything the writers do but it all falls so flat #like Adar had this big powerful moment at the end of ep 7 only for him to be Julius Caesar-d by GLÚG of all people?#there were signs but honestly #Glúg choosing fucking Sauron because he was mad at Adar trying to protect HIM and all the Uruks like #what was the point of Glúg then it's like they couldn't make up their fucking minds about whether orcs can be capable of redemption or not #and don't get me started on the Balrog getting like 30 seconds after they've been teasing it all season and even the season 1 #or that Isidul the most crucial CANON character to the story didn't do shit all season aside from homewrecking lol #also Arondir is fine??? Apparently??? Like completely fine???#and the whole Rhún sequence was just filler in the end too #bruh #i've never been a hater before to anything and yeah there IS bias on my part regarding Adar but #irrelevant things are given depth and actually interesting narratives are left shallow and just crumble under all the flawed logic #mist mumbles #mist rants and raves

4 notes · View notes