#which i mean....is fair. the fgo version did exist before redline.
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
( I was finally able to play through Okita's interlude and I have - mixed feelings about it? )
Because on one hand I really loved her interactions with the kids. The conclusion of finding her 'makoto' was really solid. I adored the way she still kept trying to train even though she could barely swing her sword properly
But, not going to lie, I feel like romanticizing and overall making the death scene so soft was not the right direction to take.
Now, I understand that in literature we tend to overlook certain things for the sake of making a good story - we all do it. But there's no way on earth you're going to convince me that a person who died of tuberculous ( or so the legend goes, a lot of debate on that in some places ) lived the last few bits of their life happily in the warm sunlight.
It just...didn't portray her as a fighter very well, I think? The way I always visualized Okita's death was tragic with the records I read, as the legend of the original tell of him growing delirious and crying out to know what became of Kondou, with everyone telling him he was fine ( a lie, he'd already been executed ).
So they way they just have her smile and collapse when she's been told she looks really health that day - I'm not a fan.
Death by TB is not quiet and calm - it's spent gasping for air, your entire body having crumbled away bit by bit as time as gone bad. It's a devastating, hideous disease - specifically when we didnt have the treatments for it.
I think not portraying Okita as fighting against it to desperately try and get back on the battlefield was such a missed opportunity.
#thankfully this doesnt affect my canon at all#since i dont really go with the fgo interpretation of her anyways#and redline handled the TB thing so well in those panels#its genuinely painful to see her hack and wheeze there#vent cw ?#idk im trying not to be overly negative#but it really lacked a punch for me in fgo#but we can't mess with Okita's waifu status there ig ¯\_(ツ)_/¯#which i mean....is fair. the fgo version did exist before redline.#but a little sad after all the progress she'd made in the recent events#at being a more defined character#noble phantasm is charging ( ooc )#fgo stuff#cherry blossom saber [ okita ]
4 notes
·
View notes