#well im gonna be honest i dont think that the quantity of words dedicated to talking about the character is your actual motivation here
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
I've gone and exposed myself to losers online who are incredibly mad about War of the Rohirrim for stupid reasons and I'm not gonna obsess over it, honestly, but I do want to point out that it's a supremely faithful adaptation of the single page of the appendices it was based on. There were two notable deviations from the extremely bare-bones story that we're given in the appendices. One, Hera killing Wulf at Helm's Deep instead of Frealaf killing him in Meduseld, simply had to be done because of the medium. Imagine a movie about the events that gave Helm's Deep its name, but the climax of the movie happened at Edoras. That would be so lame. I suppose Frealaf could still technically have killed him, but this ties into that other thing I was talking about, about great deeds that aren't remembered in song and Eowyn's complex about that. (There are no witnesses to Hera's challenge to Wulf except for some Dunlendings, Olwyn, and Frealaf at the very end.) The other deviation is Hama's death. I'm supremely ambivalent towards this in a movie where Hama is only a supporting character. His role in the movie was to motivate and develop Hera and Wulf.
#as to the complaint about the fact that the movie makers decided to focus on one character who was mentioned in passing#instead of another character who got like a whole paragraph and a half dedicated to him#well im gonna be honest i dont think that the quantity of words dedicated to talking about the character is your actual motivation here#helm would have been a very difficult protagonist for the writers to make likeable#which. different slightly less loaded post about that later#because the writers did something very interesting and skillful with helm and i do want to talk about it#(frealaf could also make a good protagonist but i havent seen anyone bitching in that direction. not that ive looked)#(but i suspect that hes too faramir like for the sensibilities of people#who think that fleshing out the unnamed daughter into a protagonist is 'woke')#especially in a movie about rohan#give it up people rohan belongs to the horse girls
22 notes
·
View notes