#wdym annabeth doesnt know how to be human.
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
this is actually one of the changes that made me angriest because in the books, luke and thalia take annabeth in for no other reason than compassion and empathy for their shared fates as demigods. SHE WAS THEIR SECOND CHANCE
I know a lot of us have had various complaints about the way the PJO show approached certain things, but one thing I haven’t seen people bring up is the change made to Thalia’s relationship with Annabeth, in which Thalia made Annabeth “earn” her place in the group, instead of Thalia being sympathetic towards a 7 yr. old who was all alone and needed a place to belong.
Now, it’s very possible that Rick and the writers will forget they made that change and things will proceed as normal, but let’s just assume that Thalia and Annabeth’s relationship will actually change.
Am I the only one that doesn’t really like this change? It makes Thalia seem like a massive asshole, and I’m not even entirely sure that it fits her character (assuming we’re still working with the same Thalia; with the way the show’s going, it’s very possible that she’s gonna get a personality shift too). I also wonder what repercussions this is going to have when we get to Titan’s Curse. The show’s version of Annabeth sounded almost resentful regarding her relationship with Thalia, and it sounds like the show’s version of Thalia is the type of person who doesn’t really empathize with people until they prove they deserve it. Does that mean that their relationship in TTC will be awkward and unfriendly? That’s not really the dynamic that those two seem to have.
Idk, man.
#also the concept of a 12yo making a 7yp prove herself as useful to “earn” her care is hilarious 😭#in what world is framing the act of taking a kid in while on the run as an investment rather than a kindness logical??? 😭😭😭#SHES 7!! SHE WILL SLOW THEM DOWN!! AND SHE WILL BE EASILY TRAUMATIZED!!#absolute logical parkour happening in the writers’ room#they said the reason why Thalia is Like That is because luke Isnt so annabeth must have gotten it from Somewhere. therefore: Thalia#which is funny because in the first place annabeth is not the cold emotionless hardass they portray her as in the show#tbh when you think about how they portrayed all the female characters who aren’t one-off appearances#so thats sally annabeth clarisse thalia and athena#they tried to make them so ‘girlboss’ at the expense of the love and compassion they are all capable of in the books bc. Strong Women™️#like wdym sally yells at percy for mild disobedience#wdym annabeth doesnt know how to be human.#wdym thalia made a 7yo earn her care#and wdym the goddess of wisdom punishes annabeth for humiliating her BY LETTING HER SANCTUARY BE DEFILED#(this is the one that pisses me off the most because in contrast poseidon gets to be an extra loving father by surrendering to zeus)#similarly in comparison to thalia luke gets to be the easygoing sympathetic big brother who just happens to be a little misled by kronos#rr crit#pjotv crit
94 notes
·
View notes