#w/ nan//amo ever again
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
wild to me that stb made it front and centre (all but waving a billboard in your face) that hingashi doesn’t have primal issues like eorzea does bc the populace doesn’t implicitly think of their ‘lesser’ beastman races as anything other than different dudes with different cultures that intermix in population centres freely and are given the respect any other sentient being would deserve and as the fishing quests show the interplay between them is necessary to preserve local ecological health, and the designated ‘bad’ factions are just ones that have chosen different ways to survive the crisis affecting them (which would be a far more interesting moral quandary to explore if the game bothered to designate them as anything other than ‘the bad guys in red you can kill’, remember the beastman designation and treatment eorzean groups get is an ul’dahn custom)
and it’s wild to me that shb did this AGAIN with the mirrored races living peacefully with each other in the wake of a world-destroying apocalypse and are integral to the survival of a great many communities and this is normal and why would you treat them any differently, they’re just people and they look a little different but we could say the exact same for you.
and at least so far, not once does this ever trigger any serious self-reflection in any of the scions abt their role in perpetuating a racist regime of violence and surveillance in the cultures of other people bc they’ve arbitrarily designated them as dangerous and violent and evil (even tho even the base game allied quests prove this assumption wrong) and never once do they actually ever even attempt to figure out what the real cause of excessive primal summoning is bc if they cared they wouldn’t be sucking off the alliance leaders for clout they’d be telling them to fucking stop treating the beast races like shit for existing, which they never do even when it’s explicitly laid out for them (like limsa betraying a peace treaty which is one of the direct causes of their issues w/ the kobolds and the sahagin and it’s very much Their Fault but the scions consistently and always side with merlwyb on the issue)
#ask to tag#long post#I fucking hate ul//dah as a place and for how destructive it is an an institution and I desperately wish I never have to interact#w/ nan//amo ever again#and I've had serious doubts abt the scions as an organization since ARR. when I heard their literal backstory is#'a bunch of non-eorzean natives with good intentions decided that they knew what was best for this place they're not from and they're the#only people smart and capable enough to do what needs to be done' as they blinding follow the alliance leaders and slaughter the beastmen#and keep surveillance on them at all times just so they can unleash the fucking warrior of light on them at the slightest sign of misconduct#really made me go. hm. is this really what you wanna say abt your designated good guy faction.#considering the scions never really deal w/ anything that's not directly related to the alliance and it's cities there's a serious dialogue#to be had abt them explicitly working to uphold damaging racist status quos#and how much they actually know abt eorzea outside of it's cities#saint.txt
8 notes
·
View notes