#tfa is wildly derivative tros might be THE worst movie i've seen | Explore Tumblr posts and blogs

chamerionwrites · 1 year ago

Text

Unrelated but I'm tired of hearing about Rogue One's apparently tortured/chaotic/piecemeal development process. It's certainly not a perfect movie, I could (and would if someone sent me an intriguing enough ask) write the essay on what I personally think its strengths and weaknesses are, but 9.9 times out of 10 I'm just hearing people gesture vaguely at this as evidence that it's bad while failing to say anything about the film itself. Sure it has its flaws, but as a viewer I give precisely zero fucks about how chaotic the production was or wasn't. I'm judging based on the quality of what was ultimately put onscreen!

#rogue one #star wars #also what am I supposed to consider a better sw movie?#tfa is wildly derivative tros might be THE worst movie i've seen #the PT is full of interesting ideas but a mess in execution (i would slot tlj in here as well imo the pacing is really rough)#rotj has some great scenes VERY shakily stitched together #even anh has some CLUNKY george lucas dialogue #what's the standard by which we're judging here you know #i'm not putting all those movies down but so often people basically say ''rogue one is bad because it's imperfect''#while praising other star wars movies with imperfections that just personally bother them less #my posts

13 notes · View notes