#sure none of the nurses are without their biases but the nuns are literally doing this as part of their religious life
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
so i've been catching up on call the midwife and finally watched the latest episode (s14e4), and this line caught my eye:
"We journey in faith. We must permit all doubt, for it is only through doubt that we can find its opposite."
which naturally made me think of conclave, since that also talks a lot about doubt and faith/certainty - namely two particular quotes:
"Let me tell you there is one sin I have come to fear above all others. Certainty. Certainty is the great enemy of unity. Certainty is the deadly enemy of tolerance. [...] Our faith is a living thing precisely because it walks hand-in-hand with doubt. If there was only certainty and no doubt, there would be no mystery. And therefore no need for faith."
and obviously CTM has this quote coming from sister julienne, an anglican nun, whereas conclave is catholic. but i'm just kinda fascinated by how they're two diametrically opposed quotes despite their similarities. cardinal lawrence views doubt as the foundation for faith and thus the two are the same, whereas sister julienne sees it as a way to find faith (but not the same). it's especially interesting since conclave is dealing with a church that is torn btwn change and stasis, whereas call the midwife's nuns are dealing with a changing world that is increasingly uncomfortable (and rightly so) about the role of religion in healthcare.
idk if sister julienne's view is typical to anglicanism, but as an atheist who was raised catholic, i've gotta say that i prefer cardinal lawrence's view of faith and doubt. it just seems... so much more accepting of human psychology.
#call the midwife#conclave#not ragging on sister julienne it's consistent w what she's said in the past i just have thoughts on it#then again i find myself not entirely comfortable w how ctm is treating religion in the current season#like ok i get why everyone is railing against the board of health not wanting the nuns to be involved with healthcare#but maybe this is me being too half-irish but i find it bizarre that none of the secular nurses are even willing to go#'well i understand their point bc can you promise your faith won't interfere with how you treat patients asking for abortions/contraception#*especially* since call the midwife has literally done plotlines about this very issue before#sure none of the nurses are without their biases but the nuns are literally doing this as part of their religious life#yes the church of england is the state religion but i just wish ctm would dig a bit deeper on that#it feels like it's falling into the romanticisation ctm has for certain aspects of the period without really interrogating it#like they largely did in earlier seasons
8 notes
·
View notes