#stampycat mcsm

[duskys-dreams]

I was replaying Minecraft story mode. It was supposed to be episode seven, but things were a little… different.

The team and I went in the manor, finding LDShadowLady, DanTDM, and StampyCat. I knew we were supposed to be finding Cassie Rose, so I led everyone around, trying to find her.

We came into the room that would later be the one that Lukas was tricked by the white pumpkin. Knowing the secret, I immediately punched the picture frame, revealing a startled Cassie Rose.

We chased her through the secret tunnels, eventually landing in a large room that had a river. Cassie Rose did a villainous monologue, and Petra stayed right by my side, protecting me.

Outside the game, I thought to myself about how I’ve always been exposed to Jesskas in the fandom, but this was why I loved the Jesstra ship. They aren’t as lovey-dovey, but they still care deeply about each other and would defend the other with their life.

I paused the game and wrote down a ship dynamic thing like the one I saw on Tumblr, about the smart popular girl and the brooding tough girl. I think I wrote it with a blue SmartBoard marker, because it was really hard to write down neatly.

I came back to the game. Cassie Rose kept going on her spiel about how she was greater than all of us and was going to trap us all here while she went to freedom. She was cut off by a skeleton standing in the river that shot her in the face.

Lukas pulled off his elaborate skeleton costume and yelled at us to run. We ran outside, and saw a second huge dark oak wood manor floating in front of the one we just came out of. It was on a one-block-thick plain about three blocks off the ground, and it was incredibly tall.

Lukas and Petra stayed back to guard while I explored the place with Dan, Lizzie, and Stampy.

We went down a winding spire, and Lizzie shrugged and told us that there clearly wasn’t anything here, and we should go back. Stampy agreed, as the entire manor was giving him the creeps. I wasn’t having it though, and I broke the north wall, revealing a secret office room with the Warden sitting at a desk, waiting for us. We all tackled him.

He surrendered immediately, and I broke the wall behind him, revealing a huge room with a giant unfinished nether portal. It had iron bars framing where each block should go. I suddenly remembered seeing a strange enclosed room outside when we were entering the manor, this must’ve been it.

Dan, Lizzie, and Stampy told me to finish the portal. I was in creative mode now, and tried to add obsidian to the unfinished parts. Something told me this wasn’t right.

The Warden was calling out the word “blue” repeatedly, and I eventually came over to ask what that was all about. He just told me “blue” again, and I stared at him. He sighed and told me to use warped tree logs. I finally realized that this was a puzzle, and went back to work, but not before placing polished andesite all around the hole that led to the portal room. I didn’t want the Warden jumping in and ruining everything.

The obsidian I had placed changed to warped planks once I held it in my hands. I kept placing, then decided that polished andesite wasn’t enough, replacing it with obsidian. The Warden said “yup,” as I replaced it, understanding my caution. I thought for a second, then placed bedrock outside the obsidian to make extra sure he couldn’t break out. He said, “yup, thanks for that.” Then I finally went back to placing.

I had worked my way to the other side of the portal before I heard blocks breaking behind me. Then, the Warden zoomed into my line of sight and swung three times at me, killing me instantly.

I respawned outside with Lukas and Petra, who asked me what happened. I told them that the Warden killed me, which was weird because I was in creative mode. This wasn’t how the game was supposed to go.

Since Cassie Rose had messed with the plotline, I decided that I would, too. I donned my elytra, along with Petra, and we flew behind the original manor. Right behind it, the world ended, and there was a layer of oak planks one block beneath it, barely enough for us to squeeze through.

Petra and I flew back through it and found the spot where the climax of the story was supposed to happen, the pit filled with Endermites. There was a large hole in the wooden planks, lined by red nether bricks, that went down to the room where Cassie Rose kept the real flint and steel. Petra and I agreed to come back later and take it, then storm the floating manor.

We went back and explained the plan to everyone, everyone being Dan, Lizzie, Stampy, Lukas, and about a hundred random people that were in the original manor, apparently. Everyone was on board, and we gathered our weapons.

I went back and stole the flint and steel as everyone else marched outside to confront Cassie, who was floating in front of her manor. Apparently she had admin powers now. She laughed at us and flew inside, and we chased her.

In the floating manor’s ginormous living room, Cassie’s own army waited for us. We clashed.

I had an unenchanted netherite sword, and it took three swings to kill a person. That wasn’t very good, considering how almost everyone else had more powerful weapons. Even so, I held my own, killing Cassie’s soldiers left and right.

I found a person that had a stiff wrist, but a sword that looked like an enchanted gold katana. I killed him, then took his sword. It was enchanted with Wrist II, which assisted with the user’s wristwork. Even with this enchantment, the other guy was not very good at moving his sword.

I attacked a nearby soldier in full plated armour, and the sword cut through it like a hot knife through butter. They dropped immediately.

I clashed swords with another person, and their sword became horribly dented after hitting mine. I struck their sword again, bending it further, and then killed them.

My army was doing well. We were steadily gaining the upper hand. Then, I spotted Petra, cornered by four people. Technically three, as the fourth one was unarmed and a few feet behind their comrades, gloating. I killed the one in the back, and that brought everyone’s attention to me. I gestured for Petra to run, and she did.

One of the fighters, who resembled something of a small giant, started stomping, causing sonic damage. I mimicked him, jumping in sync with my more powerful sonic attack. This killed the other nearby enemies, and eventually the giant.

The battle came to a standstill, and I met with Luna from My Little Pony at the kitchen table. She told me that we were losing and we needed help, and she knew where to find it.

She took out some sort of kit and explained that she would call the creatures that little ponies feared. The horrible creatures from folktales, like Discord and a harpy. She started singing Confrontation of Jekyll and Hyde, and they started gathering in the kit. I noticed that they all looked like plastic toys, and a good chunk of them resembled my dragon figurines. I pointed this out to Luna, but she didn’t seem to care.

More and more toys started to appear, and I noticed two Discords who were identical, except for the shape of their eyes. I knew that his right eye was red and his left was yellow, but it was harder to see on one of them. Less so on the other, and his eyes looked more angry.

Eventually, I got impatient and grabbed one of the toys, a harpy, and threw it across the room. Everyone had found a hiding spot by now, terrified of what Luna was summoning. Once it hit the ground, the harpy came to life, and attacked our enemies. I tossed another toy, the Discord with the angry eyes. He came to life, growing larger and ready to kill.

I looked back at Luna and told her that I didn’t think we needed this many, there were barely any enemies left. She couldn’t stop at this point, and I even noticed Nightmare Moon in the pile. I wasn’t expecting Luna to want to summon her of all people.

[keltherealone]

forgot the name of this one

I think it's like something something ways to kill people . Sorry if ur a fan

[terracomets]

i love how mcsm redstonists are just. 

girlboss. weird woman. weird woman with secrets. soren. the people who live in the town the redstonist girlboss made. weird woman with secrets and a tendency for brutal murder. stampy cat, somehow.

women in stem. soren. and stampycat <3

[pigeonrocks]

"Yes. Yes I do. With the costume? And the crazy games? It’s got “Stampy Cat” written all over it."

"It’s terrible to think about, but that totally makes sense. He loves his costumes and little games, he’s great with redstone... seems like Stampy all over."

[noodlethewolf]

Hey guys since I'm posting mcsm stuff hehe imma tell u guys my favorite characters from it >:3 which is Ellegaard,Petra,Lukas,milo,soren,ivor,stampycat, dantdm,captain sparkle,aiden,jesse, Oliva,xara. Yea, that's all chat oh wait an Gabriel lol.anyways, which mcsm characters u guys like? :v

[goitale]

RAHHHH WOF AU WOF AU

LONG YAP AHEAD!!! ++NOT ALOT OF LORE mostly whos what tribe(s) and a bit of stuff for lore munchers to ponder of :3

also i pasted from discord so ermmm oopsies

wof mcsm au!

notes: dom/rec for hybrids. for admins, like Freedom, they are no specific tribe, but first generational dragons.

reminder that beetlewings are the generation behind hive/silk seperation

noots

jesse- nightwing

petra- skywing

axel- mudwing

olivia- rainwing

lukas- seawing

reuben- scavenger

dragons around beacontowns' area r very mixed tribes but rainwings r considered primary due to cultural impact

jack- sandwing

nurm- rain/silk

vos- seawing

oots

ivor- sand/sea/ice mix (hes cool enough for 3) (65%/25%/10%)

gabriel- icewing

sorren- rain/sea

ellegaard- sky/ice

magnus- sky/night

ender dragon = very deranged darkstalker, "THE DARKSTALKER is a horror myth where þe shadows of þe ender world came to life and made a horrible huge dragon!!"

admins

romeo- primarily night, sky, sand genetics

xara- primarily rain, ice, leaf genetics

fred- primarily sea, mud, beetle genetics

stella- icewing

lluna- scavenger from the rich scavanger kingdom i forgot þe name but lluna hates champion city AND þat kingdom

~ after the bedrock...(no beetles)

freds keep has muds, ices, seas, silks

binta- sea/mud genetics

romeoburg has hive, night, leaf genetics

xara's oasis is deserted with mostly sandwings and rainwings hiding in the deserts

the warden- night/sky with a tail prosthetic due to explosions fun fact

the admin favors his genetics so the institute is primarily his grandx999 children that disappointed him because he þought nightwings and skywings were so cool

old builders

harper- beetlewing, in her episode the townsfolk r sands and a few sand/silks

purple suit guy- hivewing

blue hair girl-leafwing

harper's friend guy- silkwing

cassie rose- deranged rain/leaf, with lots of sloths

sky island dragons are primarily beetlewings and the mythical spider tribe

founder- hivewing

youtubers (fun fact, ices and rains have accents)

dantdm- ice/night

ldshadowlady- ice/sand

stampycat- rainwing

stacyplays- sandwing

sparklez- rainwing

þe first one þat died- skywing

"the white pumpkin"="the darkstalker", cassie pretends to be darkstalker myth :3

nell- sea/rain :3

em- sand/sea :3

*they communicate in aquatic! rest of their group r seas or sea hybrids for þis reason, Kelp team btw*

NOW FOR A BIT OF LORE ABT IT!!!

jesse gets random premonition dreams (aka a dream you have þen later on turns out to be true/þat dream happens irl) like every 6 monþs and therefore has sm fun stories to tell and every time it happens she IMMEDIATELY has to tell olivia and þeyre a duo ever

she isnt exactly a seer nightwing and petra is initially very confused by þis when jesse is like "yeah dont give your sword to a lady from anoþer city, petra!" þen it happens. and jesse explains

ALSO M JESSE EXISTS BUT ITS RLLY WEIRD AND ONLY SEASON 2

if yk jerboa and jerboa II's story, it relates to þem and þeir in-universe counterparts :3

[jetra4ivor]

This year marks another MCSM ending of sorts.

Stampy’s Lovely World will be coming to an end. After 10 years and 800 videos, Stampycat will be ending his Lovely World Series.

What’s heartbreaking to me about this is that not only is Stampy a character in the MCSM series, but his “lovely garden” (which is inspired by his lovely world) was a way for the MCSM developers to sneak in romance into the series without outright saying it.

The final decision of the entire MCSM series is to either stay in town with Lukas and friends, or run away with Petra and have adventures with her forever. And that choice with Petra was symbolized by the heart shaped garden she was walking past as she left the city. Real subtle!

But now, Lovely World will be coming to an end. That symbol of love will only be a memory for people who remember his series. If MCSM ever becomes playable again, I wonder how many people will remember or understand the significance of why Stampy was such a huge part of the MCSM world.

[sweetest-honeybee]

My brother and I were playing MCSM and I had this fun little idea to make other people the white pumpkin based on a possible motive so I thought I’d do good ol DanTDM first :)

[dirtyhandslolo]

• | StampyCat wasn't The Impostor | •

[ Sorry guys, I just preparing for exams at moment ]

[lesmond-sycamore]

I had the best idea of Cassie trying to apologise to Stacy and Stampy for committing murder but Stampy sets an army of parrots on her before she can even open her mouth so she's just running around screaming for fifteen minutes until they realise that she isn't trying to kill them

this is so fucking funny.

[sarksakura]

I know Stampy through MCSM.

I love his accent and I think he is really cute💙

It is so adorable when the parrots made him land safely in the game. XD

[duskys-dreams]

The White Pumpkin was murdering again, and I, Jesse, was determined to get to the bottom of it. I forced everyone to keep watch, relying on my friends to make sure they kept in line. Nobody was happy with me.

When Soren was killed, Lukas, Petra, and I went through the cave and found the White Pumpkin’s lair. Lukas told me that he was worried that the people might turn on us, and I called him a paranoid idiot. When he left, I told Petra that that was the most un-Luz thing I’ve ever said, and I didn’t know why I was so mean.

When we went back to the surface, all the survivors rebelled. They accused me of being the White Pumpkin. Then, Lukas came forward and said he was the White Pumpkin, which wasn’t true. He put on a mask to prove this, which looked like a hollow white pumpkin placed on top of an orange one. Then, Petra followed suit. They locked us all in the tiny house and kept watch, along with a random SkyWing that didn’t have a name. I sat on the seat-sized bed that took up one sixth of the entire space.

We found a broken fountain inside and decided that we should swim out. But we didn’t know how long it went, so we needed potions of water-breathing. A lot of the ingredients were inside the house, but we needed some materials that could only be found in a volcano. So, I snuck out and gathered them. Why we didn’t all sneak out at once like this, I don’t know.

I brought the materials back (instead of making a distraction so Lukas and Petra could make a run for it) and fused the smooth white stone with the blazing orange one. All we needed to do now was make the potion, but none of us knew how.

When all the guards left to run errands, leaving only Ivor to supervise, I stuck my head out of the window and asked him to make the potion for us, since we had the materials. Again, I don’t know why we didn’t just leave while the only guard was my ally, but I guess we were dead set on escaping in the flashiest way possible.

Ivor came inside to inspect the ingredients and was surprised that we had managed to procure a volcanic rock. He asked us where we got it, but Petra told me to keep my mouth shut. Ivor could still betray us and keep the volcano for myself.

I thought that was dumb. If he wanted to betray us, he had all the things he needed already. Besides, he was our friend, why would we hide the location of something he needed, and we didn’t?

Still, I kept quiet, just saying that it was in the house like everything else. Ivor clearly didn’t believe me, but still took everything and promised to have the potions ready.

Everything was back to normal by the time the guards returned. The potion wasn’t ready yet, so we played the part of trapped and hateful prisoners. As in, we made smug small talk that would make it obvious that we had the upper hand.

Ivor told the others that Cat had finished redesigning their Migalik (it must have been that random SkyWing?) so StampyCat opened the prison door to take it. Ivor threw us the water-breathing potions as the door was open, and we all drank. StampyCat yelled at us to stop, but we all jumped into the fountain and disappeared.

[littleghostarts]

[sketchyface]

As I’m returning to the MCSM fandom, I’m honestly disappointed of how little ‘white pumpkin aus’ there exists

Like; white pumpkin DanTDM, white pumpkin StampyCat, white pumpkin Lizzie, white pumpkin Stacy, white pumpkin TorqueDawg or white pumpkin CaptainSparklez??? Maybe even white pumpkin Jesse, white pumpkin Lukas, white pumpkin Petra or white pumpkin Ivor???

There exit these possibility of ‘other characters being the white pumpkin’ aus

And there exist NONE of them???

If this continues I’ll have to write my own white pumpkin au fanfics

I already have an idea of a fanfic I want to write for a ‘white pumpkin DanTDM au’. Well... more like multiple fanfic ideas for white pumpkin Dan lol

[tumblingclockwork]

HI LEAF IVE BEEN HYPERFIXATING ON MC STORY MODE AND ON STAMPYCAT PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE TELL ME YOUR THOUGHTS ABOUT STAMPYCAT BEING THE WHITE PUMPKIN IT SOUNDS SO COOL

HELLO HI YES I AM MORE THAN WILLING TO EXPLAIN

Before I start I wanna give a huge shout out to @mephones-declining-mental-health who was actually the first to point a lot of this out. We spent a lot of time putting this all together and she deserves a ton of credit for it. So go check them out.

ok so mcsm is an old game so quick refresher on episode 6: Jesse and his gang end up in another world and are put into a murder-mystery type situation. They’re trapped in the mansion due to zombies and have to survive until the day while the person who invited them all to the mansion (who goes by “The White Pumpkin”) kills them off one-by-one in order to obtain the Enchanted Flint And Steel. Which Jesse is also trying to get. Minus the main cast, everyone in this murder mystery is based off and voiced by famous minecraft YouTubers from the time. This was a pretty genius move on TellTale’s part because it meant the players were already going in with a certain level of attachment to these characters, allowing the game to kill them off in a way that would be emotionally impactful without effecting the plot of the overall story that much.

The people you meet in the mansion are the following youtubers: CaptainSparklez, TorqueDawg, StampyCat, TheDiamondMinecart, LDShadowLady, StacyPlays, and CassieRose

Multiple of these YouTubers are killed off (though some can be either saved or killed depending on your choices) and [spoiler warning] Cassie Rose is revealed to be the white pumpkin at the end. Her motivation being that she’s stuck away from her home world for and desperate to get back.

Now here’s the thing: that doesn’t make Any sense.

Cassie doesn’t have a single line or any piece of evidence that would necessarily point to her being the white pumpkin. The only real evidence that points to her feels so last minute and forced. And just completely disregards any other scene in which you were collecting evidence.

This would be less frustrating if there weren’t multiple other people that had far more evidence against them. But the one who has the most undeniable evidence against them? StampyCat.

Now I don’t know if they changed the story halfway through development or if the writers at TellTale are just bad at their jobs (equally likely but there is some evidence to suggest Cassie was not always the intended White Pumpkin) but Stampy has the most evidence, best motive, and would have just been a very interesting villain entirely.

Let’s go over everything.

So for starters. The first murder.

Spoiler alert! But the first murder is TorqueDawg. He stands under a dispenser that shoots him with a poison tipped arrow and he dies.

Now, tipped arrows were a relatively new thing at the time, and the game makes a point out of this. A lot of the characters in the mansion Don’t Know what a tipped arrow is. But a few do.

After the second murder (which we’ll address in a moment) you have the ability to interrogate three of the characters. LDShadowLady, TheDiamondMinecart, and StampyCat

Lizzie (LDShadowLady) is fully aware of the tipped arrows. Both Dan (TheDiamondMinecart) and Stampy point this out. When you ask her about it, she says she does know how to make them and taught others about it.

One of the people she talked about the tip arrows to is Cassie, aka the white pumpkin. So story-wise it does make sense. But Lizzie also states that Stampy had asked her about the tipped arrows, and specifically how to make them. So we know he has full knowledge of them.

But what does Stampy say when you ask him about the tipped arrows?

“I’ve never seen anything like it before”

This is Never addressed. Not once. Stampy blatantly lies about knowledge of a murder weapon when he seemingly has no reason to do so and he gets away with it.

So Stampy 1. Has the ability to create the weapon used for the murder and 2. Felt the need to hide this ability.

So that’s pretty suspicious right off the bat.

Now these interviews are caused by the second murder. So let’s talk about that.

Second murder: CaptainSparklez is pushed into a sand pit and suffocated by a very elaborate redstone trap. The trap is activated by one of the buttons on the table that they’re all sitting at.

Each of the buttons activates the trap, but only one of them was actually pressed. The connection we’re supposed to make here is that the White Pumpkin set up multiple buttons to keep suspicion off of themself.

The people sitting at the buttons were StampyCat, TheDiamondMinecart, LDShadowLady and Jesse’s friend Lucas.

Now you’ll notice that CassieRose, the actual White Pumpkin, is not on this list.

TheDiamondMinecart (Dan) is the one who presses the button. Dan is supposed to be a Red Herring here as he didn’t know what the button would do and pressed it anyway (though he’s a bad red herring. And we’ll discuss that in a moment). Even with the knowledge that it wasn’t the white pumpkin who pressed it, it doesn’t make any sense for her to have not been sitting at a seat with a button. And this is never really addressed either. Making this scene a complete waste of time, unless of course the original white pumpkin was intended to be one of those 4 people.

The interviews give us a lot of knowledge about the interpersonal relationships of the characters and what their skill levels are. Such as what I discussed earlier about the tipped arrows. But one thing that stays consistent is Jesse’s insistence that whoever the white pumpkin is, they must be good at redstone.

And he’s right. Every trap set by the white pumpkin at this point was redstone activated. Whoever made it must have been very skilled with it. And out of all the suspects there’s only one who has that level of ability. Stampy.

Both Dan and Lizzie make a point of saying that Stampy is a master of redstone and his skill is unmatched. But when Stampy is asked about this, his first instinct is to lie about it. When you catch him in this lie, he immediately back-tracks.

So Stampy

Has knowledge on how to build the first murder weapon (which wasn’t knowledge everyone had at the time)

Completely lies about this knowledge and is never called out for it

Was sitting at one of the buttons that caused the second murder

Is the only one with the redstone knowledge capable of creating the white pumpkins traps.

Lies about his redstone ability

So there you go! That’s a ton of evidence against him! And pretty much no evidence against Cassie other than the fact that she also knew about tipped arrows at the time.

In fact the dinner scene confirms Cassie can’t be a suspect unless we’re supposed to believe she just hoped someone else would do the job for her. Which considering she’s later characterized to be super paranoid and unwilling to leave things to chance, I doubt it.

While looking through secret tunnels you manage to find a secret conversation between Dan and Lizzie where Dan admits that he was the one who pushed the button on accident and that he feels super guilty about it. Jessie spots the white pumpkin looking through a painting at this moment. And considering he’s also seeing Dan and Lizzie, and he knows where Lucas is, out of all the people sitting near buttons, Stampy is the only one left. If the White Pumpkin was someone who was sitting at one of the buttons (which it should have been) it would have had to be Stampy

Now I do think having Dan push the button is realistic and fine. It’s a button. Everyone likes pushing buttons. But the fact that the white pumpkin would Bet On That Happening and not sit near a button at all feels like it couldn’t possibly be right, especially because everything else is so thought through and calculated. It feels out of character for Cassie to do. Cassie being the white pumpkin also means those interview scenes were an entire waste of time. They gave us no real information that could be used in the case and crossed off the real murderer as a possible suspect.

If *Stampy* was the murderer however, this would have made a lot more sense. As the interviews would have given us a lot of info about him and against him. Plus his relationship to the others. Even if Dan turned out to be the one who pressed the button, we still would have gotten that important info on Stampy. Not to mention that Dan just so happening to press the button before the White Pumpkin got a chance is a lot more believable than the White Pumpkin betting on that.

Now the way the story actually goes is that Stampy is revealed to have the enchanted flint and steel (even though before he claimed to not even want it) and as I’ve said, Cassie is revealed to be the white pumpkin.

We learn she’s the white pumpkin because she’s the only one who didn’t have a portrait of herself with a red X over it, which is a sign someone had died. Meaning she was never intended to die at all.

Now because the writing team didn’t put any actual evidence of her being guilty before this, they slip in a Not At All Subtle clue that she’s the white pumpkin.

The white pumpkin’s hide out is Filled with calico cats. The same cats as Winslow (the cat that Cassie had kept with her). And while this is obviously supposed to tell us it’s her, it doesn’t really make much sense as a clue. Considering Winslow is just one cat. A bunch of cats that look like him is sort of out-of-nowhere. She’s had no real evidence against her other than the final connection, meanwhile all signs seem to point to Stampy.

This doesn’t necessarily mean anything but I do think it’s worth mentioning that there is one character who Does have a ton of animals like the ones we see in the white pumpkin’s room. And that’s Stampy. He has a ton of dogs that could have easily taken the place of the cats. But anyway.

This last second Right At The End clue seems to almost indicate that there was some change in writing half way through the process. Before Stampy is revealed to have the flint and steel (which is something that any character could have confessed to and the story would be pretty much the same), the story makes a lot more sense with the idea that Stampy was originally intended to be the white pumpkin. We can also gather that it seems they intended the white pumpkin to be a man, as the protagonists refer to the white pumpkin by he/him pronouns and that assumption is never addressed when they learn the white pumpkin is a girl.

Either that or the writers are just. bad. Which is also very likely.

That’s all the evidence I have. So let’s talk about how story-wise it would have been so much more interesting to make Stampy the white pumpkin.

Cassie is great. But she didn’t get a lot of actual screen time in game until her villain reveal because she really never had any evidence against her. Stampy however got a lot of screen time and was generally the fan favorite when it came to the youtubers that were in episode 6. He was one of the most beloved youtubers at the time and the writers took that into account.

Whenever Stampy was accused of something, he’d play the innocent card. He’d say things like “it’s me! Stampy! I’m everyone’s friend!” In an attempt to get sympathy. Instead of defending himself, he played at the emotions of the people around him. He was played as the sweet innocent character who wouldn’t do anything wrong. I think this would have made him a Great twist villain. It would have made a lot more sense for the end scene as well, as the other youtubers defend Cassie, saying she would “never do something like that”. Which never really made sense considering they all knew one of them must have done it, and none of them had any real connection to her. Defending Stampy or being shocked would have made a lot more sense regarding the relationships of the characters.

His villain reveal would have been so much more surprising as well, as Cassie’s tone quickly shifts to much more malicious once she admits to being the White Pumpkin. And while I do believe shes a very good actor, I do believe the scene would have had an extra punch if the lines were delivered by someone who was previously set up to be the trustworthy friend who wouldn’t hurt a fly

But it’s Cassie’s motive specifically that I think would have fit So Well if Stampy had taken her place.

Cassie wants the flint and steel so that she can return to her home dimension. She’a been stuck here for a very long time and is willing to do anything to get back home. Specifically saying that she needs to get out of this “stupid world”.

Now this will only really make sense for those who are familiar with StampyCat outside of mcsm. But I’ll do my best to explain.

Stampy, as a YouTuber, was known for his “lovely world”. The minecraft world that he loved and cared about a lot. If the plot line was that Stampy specifically was separated from his lovely world, it would have been a great motive that he was desperate to get back it it.

So uh. Yeah! I think that’s all I got. I’m sure me and Worm aren’t the only people who have come to this conclusion but I’m just here to put it all into writing. I’m not sure if this was all a last minute change or sloppy writing but either way I think it’s interesting!

[warning-heckboop]

If Cassie Rose (a murderous asshole) and Stampy (a skittish cinnamon roll) somehow managed to fuse Well They would just make a cat, really And I think we all know that’s perfect