#spencertheory

[sleepylittleliar]

Who did she kill?!?! Will we find out? I NEED ANSWERS Y'ALL!!!

[pretty-little-fandom-blog]

Reasons Why Spencer is A 

1. Clearly Spencer is the most intelligent of all the girls which may be how she could pull something off

2. Spencer may have had the most things happen to her curtosy of A but maybe Spencer is so twisted that she would punish HERSELF so no one would think it's her

3. With the whole Ali and Ian thing it would make sense that Spencer would dispise Ali enough to become A

[sleepylittleliar]

Marlene Theory

I really do think that the Spencer twin situation was originally supposed to occur in season 4 or season 5. It would have made so much more sense and the story would have worked itself out. I think Marlene originally planned for there to be a twin switch when Spencer was admitted into Radley. It would have explained Spencer's visions, Eddie Lamb and his disappearance, and I think Spencer (or her twin) were really supposed to have killed someone the night Ali disappeared. The Cece reveal and backstory threw EVERYTHING off and took away from what the show was meant to accomplish. I'm glad she went the twin route in tonight's episode, but the timing and storyline of it was just awkward.

[sleepylittleliar]

Way to crush my twin Spencer dreams! 😩🙃

[sleepylittleliar]

I still want this explained SOOO bad! Someone? Anyone?

[sleepylittleliar]

I'm sorry but one of the stupidest things Marlene has done is start this "lifelike" mask sh*t. I didn't mind those initial Ali masks because they were noticeably fake and added creepiness to the show. But now we have these "lifelike" masks to deal with. First of all, no mask is going to look THAT real. You mean to tell me someone could be prancing around town in a mask looking like someone else and nobody would notice? It's not Halloween folks! I know this show hasn't exactly been realistic but the whole mask crap is just utterly ridiculous and fake as sh*t!!! Another cop-out to me because you can always say any one person was wearing a mask. I can't roll my eyes any freaking harder.

[sleepylittleliar]

Let's be honest here. If Spencer has an identical twin, and there was a switch somewhere or if the twin had scenes we thought were Spencer, it would totally make me want to re-watch the entire series over again. That, my friends, would be epic.

[sleepylittleliar]

Could this be a parallel and a clue? Maybe the twin/AD was trying to trigger the memory from Spencer while in the dollhouse? I fully believe AD/twin were a big part of the dollhouse.

[sleepylittleliar]

Not every Spencer scene is Spencer...

Hear me out. My ultimate theory for the last couple of years is that Spencer has an identical twin and that it’s Avery Drake. I really do think that throughout season 7, we have been seeing the twin in multiple scenes, thinking it was Spencer. I think the twin was the one going through the photo album looking at baby pictures, I think the twin is who actually asked Toby for the goodbye kiss (despite him being with Yvonne), and I think the twin is who Hanna really saw when she was being held hostage. I think the twin is A.D.. I think when Hanna was being held hostage, the twin went to her, posing as Spencer, and when Hanna said if she knew Charlottes killer she would tell, the look on Spencer’s/twin’s face was kind of an “oh shit she really doesn’t know” look. After that she hinted to Hanna how to break out of wherever she was being held hostage because she realized Hanna really didn’t know who the killer was. And notice how after this happened, A.D. hasn't asked the girls who the killer is anymore! Anyway, I think we have been seeing actual A.D. in some scenes, but we all just thought it was Spencer. Would be a HUGE twist!

[sleepylittleliar]

Spencer...

I've been on the Spencer twin theory for quite some time, although it seemed a bit of a reach, especially since there's already a set of twin (Jessica/Mary). I'm starting to wonder if this whole show is in Spencer's mind. Maybe Ali's disappearance set Spencer off and with combining her pills, her mind has been going 100mph since then. The show has made everyone suspect and it seems like something our brains would automatically do, then by process of elimination weed people out. There's no denying Spencer has been a focal point of this show, and with her biological mom possibly having mental issues, it could've carried over to Spencer. Maybe Ali was originally on the run hiding from Spencer.

[sleepylittleliar]

Did Spencer's twin surprise Mona in season 5?

What if Spencer’s twin was the one that creeped up on Mona in her room before she faked her death? Mona had just gotten a text right before, saying that Spencer had been arrested. So imagine her turning around and seeing “Spencer” standing in front of her, but with blonde hair/a wig and in a black hoodie! I got chills just thinking about it!! This could have been the twin finally revealing herself to Mona.

[sleepylittleliar]

Seriously how could they jip us like that and not show how Spencer came across Wren? My goodness has she been talking to him? To me that was like a huge deal and we have been waiting seasons to see him! It was just so weird to see it from Ezra's perspective and not Spencer's. Is it a clue or a big "F you" and they're just trying to confuse us?

[sleepylittleliar]

Amen sista!

[sleepylittleliar]

Has anyone wondered or questioned where A.D. has gotten all of their information from because this person sure knows a lot! Even that letter from Mary to Spencer goes wayyyyy back. Only a select few in Rosewood know as much info as A.D. knows about everyone. Whoever A.D. is, they're not new to the game.

[sleepylittleliar]

N.A.T. club theory

Since they secretly filmed around Rosewood, maybe they caught Avery (Spencer's twin) on video sneaking around. Remember a Halloween episode where the Radley car is seen pulling away? Someone was dropped off or Radley was searching for someone (The twin) so she was probably around town doing who knows what. Anyway, Alison ended up getting a hold of the video files from Ian's computer remember. Melissa knew about the twin and that's why she barged in Alison's room "that night" because she was looking for Alison and the video files. Remember she has always been trying to protect Spencer so she didn't want those videos out! Also it would explain why Cece and Melissa were talking "that night." I think Melissa and Cece both knew about the twin and were trying to figure out what to do next. Also, it would explain why only Jason is left from the NAT club...he's family! Thinking back, this would explain a ton of things. I could honestly go on and on. This would tie everything back to the very beginning and that makes me excited. What do y'all think??

[sleepylittleliar]

So was it ever explained who Spencer hit or what the blood splatter on her face was about? I mean she definitely didn’t show up back at the barn with blood on her face. What was all that about? It doesn't help that all of the details from "that night" are scattered throughout multiple episodes. If anyone could break down "that night" for me in a nutshell or direct me to a post about it, it would be much appreciated.✌🏻