#sorry you activated the ysh button. yellowfangs secret hate

[yuridovewing]

honestly cant decide which so answer whichever u like

(Fire emoji) Oakheart. just his whole fucking deal. OR. (Fire emoji) Yellowfang and HER whole deal. Whatd they do to her in her superedition???

HM idk if ive got any unpopular oakheart opinions so ill move to yellowfang

ive said this before but i straight up dont consider yellowfangs secret canon. it is a garbage book to me and i hate pretty much every decision made in it. like i straight up think its so nonsensical and dumb in every way that it is a waste of time, that is how much i hate it

why is yellowfang suddenly younger? why does she have empathy powers? why isnt she as snarky as she is in the first arc? why is raggedstars treatment of her so downplayed? why lizardstripe? why have sagewhisker just be the worst concievable character? why is brokenkit born so late into the story? why is yellowfang just a punching bag for everyone else?

its such an inconsistent and miserable read. its got yellowfangs name and face on it but thats not my woman. honestly they shouldnt even have made this a biography SE, just start the book when shes a warrior so we dont have to waste time on raggedstar’s daddy issues

speaking of which, why does RAGGEDSTAR get the kittypet lineage and not yellowfang? doesnt it make so much more sense if its her? first of all we follow a character that faces discrimination and thatd make her decisions with brokenkit later on more interesting, second of all shes literally a persian cat and you can easily make a backstory out of that, and third of all it doesnt make the first part of the book about her boyfriend instead of her. also if youre soooo determined to get rid of each and every ally she could possibly have, isnt that a better reason than being a medic?

ok just shotfire stuff:

-yellowfang shouldve been an insulting rename from brokenstar cause that name is obviously insulting to her

-she shouldve chosen on her own to be a medic

-brightflower being her mom is stupid im sorry. the drama with her is so contrived.

-honestly her not having a great life in shadowclan isnt like as awful as im saying cause her finally finding happiness in thunderclan is a very sweet plot point. but good lord its exhausting to read sometimes, especially since she never fights back.