#ppl are like ooh hes improved since he debuted with 127 and like yeah maybe but not that much

[liu-yu-xin]

Helllllo everyone :-) its 2:30am i am Not on edibles (bc i ran out) so i am coherent mostly and its time for my nyt op ed about shit no one cares about anyway im Reallyyy fascinated by what the hell winwin's whole Deal is re: being an idol bc like ok hes a really weak vocal thats a known and accepted fact its whatever but whats more weird is that ive re watched a bunch of videos where he dances and hes also. Not a great dancer? Esp for someone whos a trained traditional chinese dance dancer? whos probably been dancing since he was a kid and ik ppl say his traditional dance background makes him look a little off when he dances modern dance types that emphasizes dancing on beats and thats definitely a part of it and if this was a year ago i wouldve accepted that BUT i have someone to compare to him now which is liuyu of chuang2021 fame who has almost the exact same dance background as winwin down to the national academies where they trained and liuyu definitely had similar problems to start with but he adapted really quickly to the modern dance styles like at least to the point where its serviceable for the level of dance that idols do and hes not noticeably different than everyone else and thats just over a few months so i Cant accept that winwin couldnt do the same over like 5 YEARS.... Even watching wayv stuff from 2020 hes still just a little off even compared to the member like yangyang who learned dance from scratch when they joined sm and beyond that he has the complete wrong 气质 for a lot of these kpop stages his whole vibe has no aggressive or striking feel to it which isnt inherently a bad thing i think a lot of traditional chinese dancers have a similar vibe bc that kind of stillness and calmness is more desirable for that type of dance but that means he seems even More out of place even the actual worst dancer in wayv lucas at least has enough stage presence to offset his dance skills like if u average it out lucas ends up looking like a Better dancer than winwin... AND even moving away from more hiphop heavy dances winwin's contemporary dance and even chinese traditional dance are not as good as liuyus thats just my opiNIONNN but that actually really surprised me bc winwin has much better physique for dance than liuyu like winwin is tall and has long legs and long arms if they danced at the same level he would be the lead dancer just because the dance would look better expressed thru longer limbs but as it is liuyu's emotions are more expressive, his extensions are more full, his shapes and lines are more clean, and his eyes are more focused like winwin definitely looks more in his element with traditional dance but idk . Im not a dancer but from an audience pov he just lacks something.. the oomph... the desire to perform? Maybe he had it at some point i mean u dont get ranked first nationally for nothing but i dont think I've seen him do a single performance where he seemed like he wanted to be there for which makes me think hes one of the worst dancers in nct not because of technical issues but because of attitude problems as in he cant adjust his dance style to kpop because he doesnt really want to . And i dont know that he wants to dance at All. appearance aside I've honestly never seen someone Less suited to be an idol like there are probably idols who are less talented but there is no one less interested in being an idol than him lol he gives me the feeling that he could quit tomorrow and not feel anything about it but i also dont think he Hates being an idol? which makes him seem even more like a pretty doll in my mind like he'll just go where u put him.. and like no offense but if hes out there chilling while everyone else is competing for more lines and screentime then isnt him getting next to no lines kind of uhh 理所当然... honestly his ideal career shoulve been a model he has the body and the proportions and the face and in that case his 气质 could really set him apart in a good way anyway call me winwin i wanna be ur high school counselor lets find u a better career good night