#or saying that bad people are redeemble bc they did one good thing or vice versa
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
Sometimes I feel like people are allergic to any sort of nuance and complexity when it comes to the characters. They either see them as completely evil, without any nuance whatsoever, and every single action from them as evil and bad as if everything is always so black and white and people are only one way, or then they see them as these perfect people who never do any wrong and try to explain away their faults and mistakes and shortcomings.
I am not saying you cannot dislike characters or that These or Those actions are redeemable, that doing a few things makes a person good etc. but the lack of nuance is frustrating me. I think it makes the characters much less interesting and less compelling to only reduce them to "completely evil person who never did anything good" or "perfect person who never did anything wrong". I've just seen a lot of oversimplification of these very nuanced, conplex characters.
People either go "yes, this character acted in a questionable way, but none of it was bad bc This and That, they did NOTHING wrong!!" or "omg they never did anything good and every action of theirs was an evil one". Like... You are allowed to have things be complicated, you are allowed to see the complexities It makes the characters interesting!!
#did this make any sense? probably not#i suck at wording things#but its just something ive noticed with a lot of the characters#ESPECIALLY with javier#and honestly with arthur too#like people forget he canonically does awful things and erase that complex part of his character#also with dutch kinda#i know he is bad and evil BUT to think there was nothing more to him is less compelling to me#again i am NOT saying that you're not allowed to like and dislike whichever character#or saying that bad people are redeemble bc they did one good thing or vice versa#just that i have seen this over simplification of these characters so much#rdr2#rdr#red dead redemption 2#red dead redemption
15 notes
·
View notes